Towing vessel Chad Pregracke crashes into rail-bridge

2020 ж. 4 Там.
61 595 Рет қаралды

On February 27, 2019, about 0704 local time, the towing vessel Chad Pregracke, pushing 30 loaded grain barges down the Mississippi River, was coming out of a bend and lining up to pass under two adjacent bridges in Vicksburg, Mississippi, when the tow set toward the left descending bank and into a pier supporting the Old Highway 80 Bridge. The tow broke apart, one barge sank, and three barges were damaged. The vessel’s nine crewmembers remained on board and began gathering barges. No pollution or injuries were reported. Total damage to the barges was estimated at $800,000.
The 173-foot-long Chad Pregracke was a twin-propeller towing vessel that was powered by two diesel engines that produced a combined 10,000 horsepower. The vessel was fitted with two sets of flanking rudders and two sets of Becker (flap) rudders. The vessel was built in 2016 and operated by Marquette Transportation Company, LLC.
The Mississippi River current at Vicksburg was 4-5 miles per hour (mph), and the river gage was 48 feet and rising (flood stage was 43 feet). The Lower Mississippi River near mile 435 was under an extreme high-water safety advisory from the US Coast Guard Captain of the Port due to “hazardous conditions associated with strong currents, severe out drafts, [and] missing/off- station aids to navigation and diving buoys.” The Coast Guard considers extreme high water to be a rising depth of water measuring at least 40 feet.
The Vicksburg bridges included the Old Highway 80 Bridge, which opened in 1930 as a highway and railroad crossing and still serves as a railway bridge, and the Interstate 20 bridge, which opened in 1973 and was built with piers spaced to match the adjacent and upriver Old Highway 80 Bridge piers. The bridges were located 1.1 miles downstream from a 121° bend in the river. In addition to the cross-currents associated with such a large change in direction of the river, the current from the Yazoo river converged in the bend.
On February 6, 2019, the Lower Mississippi River Committee (LOMRC) activated watchstanders in the Vicksburg Information Center (VIC) to “provide mariners with the most current information related to river conditions affecting transit through the Vicksburg Bridges.” The VIC personnel also were responsible for granting permission for tows to transit under the bridges. VIC personnel verified that each tow met the guidelines for transiting the bridges after discussing the transit with wheelhouse personnel. To receive permission to transit under the bridges, wheelhouse personnel of southbound tows were required to confirm that they were comfortable with their tow configuration and the river state; the tow met the horsepower per barge and max tow size requirements; and all red-flag barges (barges carrying hazardous materials) in mixed tows were placed in inboard strings and not a lead loaded barge in any string.
The Coast Guard also issued a Notice to Mariners on February 6, recommending only daylight operations for southbound tows wider than 110 feet passing under the Vicksburg bridges. On February 25, two days before the accident, the Coast Guard issued another notice, reducing the maximum number of loaded barges from 36 to 30.

Пікірлер
  • (continued from video description) On the morning of February 27, the Chad Pregracke, with 9 crewmembers (including a captain and pilot), was en route to Baton Rouge, Louisiana, pushing 30 loaded grain barges, six across by five long. The tow measured 210 feet wide and 1,173 feet long. The pilot on board had joined the vessel only two days before the transit in Pemiscot Township, Missouri. The owner specifically assigned the pilot to the vessel because he had experience transiting through Vicksburg in high-water conditions. In preparation to pass underneath the Vicksburg bridges, the pilot and the VIC watchstander spoke at 0230 to confirm that the Chad Pregracke tow complied with the high-water measures adopted by the industry to mitigate the risk of southbound transits through the bridges. The pilot confirmed that he was comfortable with the tow configuration and that the tow averaged 333 horsepower per barge, which met the Coast Guard’s 280-horsepower-per-barge minimum guideline to transit. Later, at 0400, the pilot held up the tow on the left descending bank, waiting for daylight as called for by the voluntary guidelines, before passing through the Vicksburg bridges. Before getting under way at 0634, the Chad Pregracke pilot discussed the transit with the port captain from Marquette Transportation. The Vicksburg gage read just under 48 feet. The Chad Pregracke captain, who did not have high-water experience in Vicksburg, was also in the wheelhouse because his regular watch was from 0600-1200. The pilot stated that he would normally flank the bend above the Vicksburg bridges, but he decided to steer the bend based on experiencing little set from the current when he steered through the Brown’s Point bend at mile 444, just a few hours earlier, at 0320. As the tow moved through the bend, the pilot had about a mile to line up the tow with the bridge. The pilot, anticipating a set to port, steered for pier 4 on the right side of the span, in order to line up to transit the 800-foot width between piers 3 and 4. The pilot stated that as the tow moved downriver, the current set the tow to the left side of the river despite his efforts to head towards the right side of the span. The pilot told investigators that he experienced the set to the left earlier and harder than he anticipated. The tow, moving at 11.5 knots, was set down onto pier 3 at a 10° angle to the pier. The tow contacted the bridge between the third and fourth barges from the head of the tow on the port side, and the tow broke apart. Four barges were damaged. The CC 95507B sank immediately, and the LTD 405’s bow was submerged. Two other barges were damaged but remained afloat. The Coast Guard closed the river to traffic. By 1450, the crew of the Chad Pregracke, with the help of other towing vessels, had retrieved the remaining barges, and, on March 1 at 1300, the crew had rebuilt the tow with the undamaged barges and continued the southbound transit. A total of 26 towboats and 354 barges were delayed until the morning of March 1, when the Coast Guard re-opened the area for vessel traffic.

    @WhatYouHaventSeen@WhatYouHaventSeen3 жыл бұрын
    • Hey great channel, I love your stuff I slowed down the playback speed and paused to read the report. The pilot had 2 choices to make the bend - flanking, which means he puts the engines in reverse and point the stern to the right bank while the current pushes the left side of the bow to the right, kinda like pinning the end and swinging the front. Then repeats this maneuver in small bursts as he crabs the string around the bend and lining up. The other is steering the bend, which is exactly as it sounds, right engine reverse, right rudder, but with the pivot point of the entire string being only 1/3 ahead of the stern, the remaing 2/3 of the string was too much for the tug to overcome the current. The thing is the river was 5 feet above flood stage, but this is a very experienced pilot who was frequently hired by companies for high water passage. He said he had steered this bridge the week before but the water wasn't yet above flood stage. Whether or not he made the right choice, the conditions were in extremis and a safe transit was a risk either way. Do the shippers hold up 2 or 3 days until the level drops a bit? I don't know, but when I was a deckhand on tugs towing oil out of NYC the words often heard around the fleet when conditions were not conducive to safe passage were The schedule is more flexible than the bow

      @tommypetraglia4688@tommypetraglia46883 жыл бұрын
    • I can’t imagine being in the wheelhouse at the time🤯😭🤬

      @loadblock4995@loadblock4995 Жыл бұрын
  • As a bridge engineer, I'm gratified that the bridge won. They're supposed to be designed to.

    @jjohnston94@jjohnston943 жыл бұрын
    • If it didn’t, that train would’ve had a bad day

      @alexmartin0824@alexmartin08243 жыл бұрын
    • I'm guessing the high water submerged the fender system.

      @gusbailey68@gusbailey683 жыл бұрын
    • @@gusbailey68 I doubt it even has a fender system. The bridge was opened in 1930. You'd be surprised how much we didn't know only that recently (I mean, look how California still loses bridges in every big earthquake. You'd think they'd have it figured out by now). Plus, it would be the worst blunder a bridge engineer could commit to built the fender to an elevation that would allow it to be submerged. I've never designed a fender (there's no navigable waterways where I live), but if I were going to, I'd be sure to set its top to at least the "WSE200" - the water surface elevation you'd get from a storm so big you would expect to see it only once every 200 years. Finally, there's no mention of a fender system in any of the documents.

      @jjohnston94@jjohnston943 жыл бұрын
    • @@alexmartin0824 The tug would have had an even worse day 😂

      @Carter-dv4hz@Carter-dv4hz3 жыл бұрын
    • Not only did it win, but it won $800k USD of fixups!

      @AlecArmbruster@AlecArmbruster3 жыл бұрын
  • The Vicksburg bridge has eaten many barges over the years, I've had many close calls with it myself. I usually flank unless the water is low and the Yazoo isn't running, it's just safer. It'll definitely get your attention fast!!!

    @gatorfdx@gatorfdx7 ай бұрын
  • I'll bet the flathead catfish get pretty big in that area.

    @deuteronimus750@deuteronimus7503 жыл бұрын
    • Plot Twist: it was carrying coal

      @TheWizardGamez@TheWizardGamez3 жыл бұрын
    • @@TheWizardGamez barges with cover tops don’t carry coal. Mostly grain, so I’m willing to bet them cats got some good eating

      @stricklinatorr@stricklinatorr3 жыл бұрын
    • I’ve heard stories of divers going down and seeing catfish as big as them. No natural predators when they get that big. Just humans I guess.

      @milesaway3699@milesaway36992 жыл бұрын
  • I slowed down the playback speed and paused to read the report. The pilot had 2 choices to make the bend - flanking, which means he puts the engines in reverse and point the stern to the right bank while the current pushes the left side of the bow to the right, kinda like pinning the end and swinging the front. Then repeats this maneuver in small bursts as he crabs the string around the bend and lining up. The other is steering the bend, which is exactly as it sounds, right engine reverse, right rudder, but with the pivot point of the entire string being only 1/3 ahead of the stern, the remaing 2/3 of the string was too much for the tug to overcome the current. The thing is the river was 5 feet above flood stage, but this is a very experienced pilot who was frequently hired by companies for high water passage. He said he had steered this bridge the week before but the water wasn't yet above flood stage. Whether or not he made the right choice, the conditions were in extremis and a safe transit was a risk either way. Do the shippers hold up 2 or 3 days until the level drops a bit? I don't know, but when I was a deckhand on tugs towing oil out of NYC the words often heard around the fleet when conditions were not conducive to safe passage were The schedule is more flexible than the bow

    @tommypetraglia4688@tommypetraglia46883 жыл бұрын
    • "The schedule is more flexible than the bow." Ocean going warship sailor here, but 'Charlie Copy' on that message. Same applies to us, schedules can be flexible ... hulls aren't. Regards and respects.

      @robertf3479@robertf34793 жыл бұрын
    • Probably needed to do the first and lining up with pier four coming out of the bend.

      @shyman9023@shyman90232 жыл бұрын
    • Bottom line is he did not have enough boat I've been on the Savannah repeat experience Pilots had he pulled right the current would have took the back of that thing and flipped it to the left he would flank the bridge from looking at the GPS he didn't have enough room between the bend and the bridge for those current conditions

      @okiedoke6373@okiedoke63732 ай бұрын
  • pilot conclusively silencing the "you couldnt hit the broadside of a barn!" naysayers.

    @thurin84@thurin843 жыл бұрын
  • Once they hit the bridge and all those barges scattered.. the Benny Hill music (Yackity Sax) started playing in my head. I can see all these damn barges trying to make a run for it.

    @gxlbiscuit@gxlbiscuit3 жыл бұрын
  • Incredible what those tugs Captan’s have to navigate.

    @TeachAManToAngle@TeachAManToAngle3 жыл бұрын
  • Nuts! It's like driving on ice.

    @GunNtonic@GunNtonic3 жыл бұрын
  • Interesting to learn Marquette has named one of their tows after Chad Pregracke. He’s from my area and I’ve met him a few times. Don’t think he’s even 40yrs old yet. Has done remarkable work in cleaning up rivers and waterways.

    @ChristopherBix@ChristopherBix2 жыл бұрын
  • It's apparent that the mighty Missippi river has a little more power than a boat.

    @rh1507@rh15072 жыл бұрын
    • Every day.

      @DJVIIIMan@DJVIIIMan2 жыл бұрын
  • "would you believe by THAT much!"

    @thurin84@thurin843 жыл бұрын
  • at least we get to see a nice KCS Manifest passing as well as destruction..lol

    @Island_Line_Rail_Productions@Island_Line_Rail_Productions3 жыл бұрын
  • The Chad Pregracke, Vs the Virgin Bridge.

    @blackhawks81H@blackhawks81H3 жыл бұрын
    • I came here specifically for this comment

      @craigbikes8831@craigbikes88313 жыл бұрын
  • I wonder if the engineers on that train felt anything from that impact. I doubt they felt much, but I wonder if it was perceptible at all.

    @44R0Ndin@44R0Ndin3 жыл бұрын
  • Everybody gets a drug test!

    @justsmallstuff4994@justsmallstuff49943 жыл бұрын
  • So with the current, was it mandatory to have two bargers? Don't know just asking!

    @Mike7478F@Mike7478F3 жыл бұрын
  • Wow $800,000 worth of damage

    @jamielancaster01@jamielancaster013 жыл бұрын
    • Actually not that bad, considering a single A-frame barge that lifts the sunk barges runs around 100k a day.

      @bradgt5130@bradgt51302 жыл бұрын
  • When conditions are that extreme, they should be required to have assist tugs, but I’m sure corporate greed and lobbying keeps that from happening. Notice that not transiting the bridge at night is VOLUNTARY! It should be mandatory! Knowing the river traffic. I’m surprised that the engineers didn’t configure a bridge with a much larger span - unless of course this is an older bridge that didn’t anticipate this type of river transport.

    @scottwinter9370@scottwinter93702 жыл бұрын
  • Currents are so unpredictable .

    @anthonynewbreast1917@anthonynewbreast19172 жыл бұрын
  • That was one bad day for that tow pilot.

    @mpgarr@mpgarr2 жыл бұрын
  • Damn he smoked it good. I am glad I was not on there for that

    @brianladyman6426@brianladyman64262 жыл бұрын
  • Chad Pendraki (SP?) - isn't that the name of the Riverkeeper guy?

    @seemoretoys5944@seemoretoys59443 жыл бұрын
  • Pretty scary, especially since the bridges had a train crossing and plenty of road traffic. I'm not an expert, but one would think he would be set-up much farther to the right to compensate for the swift water. Yeah, I'm pretty happy the bridge "won" too.

    @wallochdm1@wallochdm13 жыл бұрын
    • I slowed down the playback speed and paused to read the report. The pilot had 2 choices to make the bend - flanking, which means he puts the engines in reverse and point the stern to the right bank while the current pushes the left side of the bow to the right, kinda like pinning the end and swinging the front. Then repeats this maneuver in small bursts as he crabs the string around the bend and lining up. The other is steering the bend, which is exactly as it sounds, right engine reverse, right rudder, but with the pivot point of the entire string being only 1/3 ahead of the stern, the remaing 2/3 of the string was too much for the tug to overcome the current. The thing is the river was 5 feet above flood stage, but this is a very experienced pilot who was frequently hired by companies for high water passage. He said he had steered this bridge the week before but the water wasn't yet above flood stage. Whether or not he made the right choice, the conditions were in extremis and a safe transit was a risk either way. Do the shippers hold up 2 or 3 days until the level drops a bit? I don't know, but when I was a deckhand on tugs towing oil out of NYC the words often heard around the fleet when conditions were not conducive to safe passage were The schedule is more flexible than the bow

      @tommypetraglia4688@tommypetraglia46883 жыл бұрын
  • You're fired!

    @147258GS@147258GS3 жыл бұрын
  • What’s the link to the PTZ camera?

    @greyghostproductions0938@greyghostproductions09382 жыл бұрын
  • Blame the idiots that put a bridge right below a bend.

    @rafeone9808@rafeone98082 жыл бұрын
    • There is more freight crossing the bridges than going down the river.

      @tomfuelery2905@tomfuelery2905 Жыл бұрын
    • Эти идиоты похоже везде мосты строят в самых неудобных местах !

      @ksv-river-men@ksv-river-men Жыл бұрын
    • @@tomfuelery2905 Hell no it's not. You have this backwards by far.

      @eddieroberts3402@eddieroberts3402 Жыл бұрын
  • The current looked a lot faster than 4 to 5 knots.

    @rael5469@rael5469 Жыл бұрын
  • Wow!

    @charade993@charade9933 жыл бұрын
  • so even river chads are chads.....

    @thurin84@thurin843 жыл бұрын
  • It seems to be quite a tough task to maneuver these "ships" through river bends. I am from Europe and we dont have river transport ships this big. At least I never saw something like this one. I would have failed right after the first curve in New Orleans/ Bayou :D

    @immermitderruhe@immermitderruhe3 жыл бұрын
    • Vicksburg , the town that’s in has been home for me for 25 years.. I’ve also worked on the towboats and gone under that bridge many times.. The current comes off of a point way above the bridges and pushes down and into that left descending bank… The captain fucked up by tryna drive through instead of flank . Look up “flanking Vicksburg bridges southbound explained” and there’s a video a captain made explaining what that means

      @MississippiKid96@MississippiKid962 жыл бұрын
    • Опасно первые 10 лет ! Потом привыкаешь !

      @ksv-river-men@ksv-river-men Жыл бұрын
    • @@MississippiKid96 капитан нормально зашёл в поворот на переднем ходу , течением состав снесло уже на прямом участке ! Если бы заходин на заднем ходу , всё равно навалило бы на мост !

      @ksv-river-men@ksv-river-men Жыл бұрын
  • No big deal....so the current made the tow veer off course, it can happen. A miscalculation not recoverable at that stage.

    @mervynsands3501@mervynsands35013 жыл бұрын
    • You work on the river?

      @jonathanwatson1243@jonathanwatson12432 жыл бұрын
  • They should rewrite the title "crashes into rail-bridge" into "scrapes bridge piling". Regardless how good a tug captain is, river currents and winds can easily put you where you don't want to be. Over sensationalized!

    @dbfcrell8300@dbfcrell83002 жыл бұрын
  • Marquette?

    @gregorythompson2251@gregorythompson22512 жыл бұрын
  • Didn't something similar happen some years ago? I remember seeing a documentary about a barge destroying a railroad bridge and a passenger train falling into the water.

    @peterdekker8545@peterdekker85453 жыл бұрын
    • That was in Louisiana IIRC. Barges hit a bridge and then an Amtrak train ended up going into the bayou at like 3AM with many casualties.

      @driftlesstroutdude7100@driftlesstroutdude71003 жыл бұрын
    • @@driftlesstroutdude7100 Many thanks for the info!

      @peterdekker8545@peterdekker85453 жыл бұрын
    • Big Bayou Canot

      @firstlast8902@firstlast89023 жыл бұрын
    • @@driftlesstroutdude7100 If you're talking about the Sunset Limited you got it all right except it was in Alabama. Just up the Mobile River from Mobile in Big Bayou Canot as First Last said. 47 train passengers and crew died. I've been by the spot a few times on the river and it always creeped me out.

      @John-tx1wk@John-tx1wk3 жыл бұрын
    • Boat wasnt even in the river channel.

      @dentonsbackyardshow1013@dentonsbackyardshow10133 жыл бұрын
  • Looks like he was never lined up for the bridge at any time before. Thus wasn’t able to recover at any point.

    @Ray-cv6kg@Ray-cv6kg3 жыл бұрын
  • Impossible to read the small printing.

    @ridethetrain9326@ridethetrain93263 жыл бұрын
    • thats why they zoom in..

      @SpanishArmadaProd@SpanishArmadaProd2 жыл бұрын
  • of course it was Marquette lol

    @boatmann1002@boatmann10022 жыл бұрын
  • Anybody know the program used for the simulation?

    @youdoyouplayer8529@youdoyouplayer85292 жыл бұрын
    • That was rose point, isn’t a simulation but the navigation tool we use.

      @bradgt5130@bradgt51302 жыл бұрын
  • Where did those people come from?! Does someone ride on every barge??

    @drnogueiras8783@drnogueiras87833 жыл бұрын
    • No ma’am. We ride on the boat, eat sleep and live on the boat. Every person (except call watch) works 6 hours on and 6 hours off for this particular company. 28 days on 14 home. This is a common occurrence unfortunately.

      @stricklinatorr@stricklinatorr3 жыл бұрын
  • While I train was on the bridge too! Yikes.

    @Studio23Media@Studio23Media3 жыл бұрын
    • Good thing that bridges have been designed to handle such impacts for a very very long time. If I had to make an uneducated and unfounded guess, I'd say that that lesson was learned and mastered back in Ancient Roman times, when they were building the viaducts.

      @44R0Ndin@44R0Ndin3 жыл бұрын
  • Marquette Transportation. I use to work for them in 2010. They be getting high as shit out there 😂

    @mthertruckerg@mthertruckerg11 ай бұрын
    • Marquette is not the wave

      @user-le8uw9yo8e@user-le8uw9yo8e5 ай бұрын
  • That was my first boat I road with

    @user-le8uw9yo8e@user-le8uw9yo8e5 ай бұрын
  • Oh look a marquette transportation, boat hit a bridge...imagine that....

    @challenger70fan@challenger70fan2 ай бұрын
  • That'll buff right out

    @mrtraumaboyy4098@mrtraumaboyy40983 жыл бұрын
    • Nobody: Will it fit in my Honda? Hold my beer Am I a joke to you? Asking for a friend Everybody gangsta End this man’s whole career He protecc, he attacc … Sexual/genitalia innuendo Scatological/potty joke Question of quantity answered yes Plot twist Left/entered the chat Gaming reference Dislikes are from I’m a simple man Last time I was this early Legend has it That’ll buff right out Punch line below read more

      @onemoremisfit@onemoremisfit3 жыл бұрын
  • Someone having a bad day?

    @thomasstecyk792@thomasstecyk7923 жыл бұрын
  • Can happen to anybody. Don’t take a chance in them conditions

    @chrissimmonds4898@chrissimmonds4898 Жыл бұрын
  • Of course it was a Marquette boat

    @silentdragon9734@silentdragon97342 жыл бұрын
  • All the parade of documentation ,etc. will make no difference, The pilot is screwed!!

    @robertjwilliams3532@robertjwilliams35323 жыл бұрын
    • Встань на место пилота ! А потом уже коментируй ! Диванный эксперт !

      @ksv-river-men@ksv-river-men Жыл бұрын
    • Curious - If you could read my English statement, then why did you not respond in English. I have no idea what you have posted. Sorry..

      @robertjwilliams3532@robertjwilliams3532 Жыл бұрын
  • GREAT STORY FEATURING THE TRIALS AND TRIBULATIONS OF SKILLED RIVER PILOTS. MAN CAN NEVER OUTWIT MOTHER NAURE

    @kingtut8381@kingtut8381 Жыл бұрын
  • rookie mistake!

    @paxmule@paxmule3 жыл бұрын
    • Absolutely not! I've been a pilot for 40 years and the Vicksburg bridge still gets my undivided attention every time. It'll make even the best pilot look bad on any given day.

      @gatorfdx@gatorfdx7 ай бұрын
  • Was it the Chad ?!? .... it might be the Chad ?

    @duncandmcgrath6290@duncandmcgrath62903 жыл бұрын
  • Thats not so chad... chad

    @TheWizardGamez@TheWizardGamez3 жыл бұрын
  • Oof

    @BeersNBullshit@BeersNBullshit3 жыл бұрын
  • 0:47

    @aggabus@aggabusАй бұрын
  • Haters

    @ostapbendervan7874@ostapbendervan78743 жыл бұрын
    • Trumps fault

      @danaharrison6016@danaharrison60162 жыл бұрын
KZhead