'What Does Victory Look Like For Ukraine?': Schmitt Has Tense Exchange With Austin Over Ukraine

2024 ж. 11 Сәу.
157 158 Рет қаралды

At Tuesday's Senate Armed Services Committee hearing, Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO) questioned Defense Sec. Lloyd Austin about Ukraine aid.
Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:
account.forbes.com/membership...
Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: fb.com/forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: / forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: / forbes
More From Forbes: forbes.com

Пікірлер
  • If NATO has an open door policy, why was Russia not allowed to join in 2000?

    @calanmacleod3948@calanmacleod3948Ай бұрын
    • Bingo.

      @johannuys7914@johannuys7914Ай бұрын
    • Must be trust from both sides

      @user-le8sn3xn2i@user-le8sn3xn2iАй бұрын
    • @@user-le8sn3xn2i no, America needs an enemy for the MIC.

      @calanmacleod3948@calanmacleod3948Ай бұрын
    • they didn't want russia intact and strong, they wanted to split it into hundred pieces with the help of the oligarchs and then plunder it.

      @Corsa15DT@Corsa15DTАй бұрын
    • Because in this case, NATO's raison d'être would disappear, the alliance would lose the enemy that NATO was created to oppose.

      @johnlenin830@johnlenin830Ай бұрын
  • ukraine a democratic country? did I hear it right?

    @sunilsilva8204@sunilsilva8204Ай бұрын
    • Of course, didn't you know that? Only in a democracy do they impose fines for using your mother tongue.

      @johnlenin830@johnlenin830Ай бұрын
    • Secondo lui...

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
    • Of Course it is a democracy, only in democracies you wage war for economic benefits, only in democracies you make up rules that benefit the richest, only in democracies...

      @Karimom810@Karimom810Ай бұрын
    • "Democrazia " americana = espansione del imperialismo =sottomettere i paesi, dettando le loro regole, cioè, "non devi fare quello che faccio io,ma devi fare solo che ti dico io" =invadere,guerre, in paesi, per derubare e saccheggiare le loro risorse naturale, energetice, petrolio, gas, etc. = distruggere l'economia di un paese,qualsiasi, che usa di superargli, oppure di equalizzatore loro,economicamente, =sostenere i a paesi alleati loro, nella stessa politica menzionata sopra

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
    • 😂😅🤡

      @dennyone3931@dennyone3931Ай бұрын
  • (The)Exit strategy is defined. Same as in Saigon and Kabul.

    @organicgardener1112@organicgardener111223 күн бұрын
    • Lịch sử đã chứng minh . Họ tháo chạy khỏi Sài Gòn và kabul chà đạp lên nhau khi mọi chuyện vỡ lỡ. Người Mỹ thực sự hèn nhát . Hoi chỉ dám bắt nạt người yếu hơn hoặc là kích động hàng xóm đánh nhau và họ là người được hưởng lợi. Họ nhân dân đủ điều nhưng chắc chắn là họ không chết vì súng đạn mà họ tạo ra . 1 ngày nào đó tôi không ngạc nhiên khi họ bị đánh bom hạt nhân .

      @hjajhahh2100@hjajhahh21007 күн бұрын
  • Russia will never allow a US military base in Crimea with nuclear weapons. This is the reason for the war 😣😏😣

    @evo4543@evo4543Ай бұрын
    • Yep. And they keep pushing this nato crap onto ukraine. I just don't understand it......

      @crazycat1232@crazycat1232Ай бұрын
    • Reason for the war is Russia expansionism.

      @mesquick@mesquickАй бұрын
    • There is no need to make Us bases for nuclear weapons. They can fly from US to Russia in 20 minutes

      @batmanyk@batmanyk26 күн бұрын
    • Reason is that russia want this land.

      @dociekania@dociekania23 күн бұрын
    • @@curio78 No it hasn't. Not a student of history are you? So why you replicate russsia propraganda online?

      @mesquick@mesquick23 күн бұрын
  • It's embarrassing. He was asked a simple question and couldn't answer it.

    @globalfunseeker6733@globalfunseeker6733Ай бұрын
    • Sono state fate piu domande.....e...lui....balbetattava sempre......sappiamo tutti il fatto che una persona, allorquando gli se fa una domanda ed essa comincia a balbettare nel dare la risposta....MENTE...è una persona BUGIARDA,..balbetta perché non sa quello che dire....

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
    • @@lorycotiga4231 Lei solleva un punto molto interessante e valido. Ma il suo balbettio può essere interpretato come un'ammissione di colpa, un'ammissione che nulla sta andando come previsto e che stanno perdendo. Deve dire la sua coscienza, la verità.

      @globalfunseeker6733@globalfunseeker6733Ай бұрын
    • ​@@globalfunseeker6733appunto, si,...conoscela verità ma non la vuole ammettere...apertamente

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
    • Because the real answer would be “we want to transform USA into a weapons manufacturer client state to win the next elections”. Not to mention gas exporting companies.

      @unai_asecas9070@unai_asecas9070Ай бұрын
    • Probably not up to him to answer that question

      @Triadii@TriadiiАй бұрын
  • Ukraine is finished and they are talking about Ukraine win.

    @rajibullah9072@rajibullah9072Ай бұрын
    • Follia pura

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
    • Yeah, has being finished for over more than 2 years and ever lasting.

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • @@sherion80 Ukraine is dead living on benefits

      @moviechannel7515@moviechannel7515Ай бұрын
    • ​@sherion80 u are funny my man 😂

      @roshanwadasinghe7294@roshanwadasinghe7294Ай бұрын
    • ​@@sherion80lol, US took 10 years to lose Vietnam, and 2 years means nothing

      @johnwi-l_l-iamsf3763@johnwi-l_l-iamsf3763Ай бұрын
  • For years Russia said they didn’t want NATO expanded to their borders through Ukraine. Why didn’t we hear that and reach an agreement rather than just trying to ram it down their throats? This conflict has been insane from the start by poisoning relations between the two biggest nuclear powers and risking WW3.

    @domino20@domino20Ай бұрын
    • Since when russia decides who enters NATO?

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • @@sherion80since the country that wants to join NATO would mean a direct threat to Russia’s borders

      @UncleJay101@UncleJay101Ай бұрын
    • @@UncleJay101 Never thought why countries bordering Russia tend to join NATO? Who is threatening whom?

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • @@sherion80 for many reasons. Mostly political, some see it as a precursor for joining the EU, or being able to reduce their own defence costs. But you will probably tell me Russia wants to invade all of them, because some people genuinely believe that Do you have an answer for why America is happy to let all these countries join NATO, at apparently a great cost to them? Able to answer that one?

      @UncleJay101@UncleJay101Ай бұрын
    • @@UncleJay101 USA is free to leave and isolate themselves from the world. That's what trumpists want. However, then other countries are ready to take control and replace you.

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
  • As a citizen of America I don’t want anymore of my tax dollars going to Ukraine while America is in debt. How bout that?!?!

    @RobertSmith-lw2bx@RobertSmith-lw2bxАй бұрын
    • "my", Ivan? You pretending to be an American again.

      @accountcreatedforrussiantrolls@accountcreatedforrussiantrollsАй бұрын
    • @@accountcreatedforrussiantrollsAre you saying EVERY SINGLE American citizen supports Ukraine??

      @nextentrepreneur9288@nextentrepreneur9288Ай бұрын
    • ​@nextentrepreneur9288 are you saying every Russian citizen supports putin or are they scared to speak against him and forcefully been sent to the meat grinder

      @jayhaugabook7393@jayhaugabook7393Ай бұрын
    • ​​@@nextentrepreneur9288Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦 God bless America 🇺🇸 Free Russia 🇷🇺

      @jayhaugabook7393@jayhaugabook7393Ай бұрын
    • @@jayhaugabook7393 I won’t comment on your question as it’s clearly not relevant. What I’ll say is that I do support Ukraine and hope that the aid bill passes so they can defend themselves. However, I don’t think that it’s appropriate to harass, intimidate and call “Russian bots/agent” anybody who voices opposition for legitimate reasons. This has to stop. That’s not democracy.

      @nextentrepreneur9288@nextentrepreneur9288Ай бұрын
  • Austin is a clown like Zele

    @elizabethhagman1984@elizabethhagman1984Ай бұрын
    • Clowns stick together!

      @illayreich8373@illayreich8373Ай бұрын
    • He has shares in the armaments companies

      @karlospalacio6368@karlospalacio6368Күн бұрын
  • How could you expect Millie to Define Victory he's never won anything

    @Whitecat76@Whitecat76Ай бұрын
    • And who are you, Ivan?

      @accountcreatedforrussiantrolls@accountcreatedforrussiantrollsАй бұрын
    • Well, I’m a retired combat veteran who fought for this nation in a different useless war (Iraq) and I agree with “Ivan”.

      @rodeocowboy@rodeocowboyАй бұрын
    • @@rodeocowboy you can agree or you want you didn't win s*** we haven't won a war since World War II and I'm not even sure we won that

      @Whitecat76@Whitecat76Ай бұрын
    • @@accountcreatedforrussiantrolls I'll tell you what I'm not a fake patch General with a whole bunch of awards painted all over my chest when I never want anything

      @Whitecat76@Whitecat76Ай бұрын
    • @@accountcreatedforrussiantrolls Here, i have a photo of you - 🐑

      @tomic369@tomic369Ай бұрын
  • American veteran writer Noctis Draven - "Ukraine and the West are extremely concerned about Russia's reaction to the Moscow massacre. The truth is that Russia treats Ukraine with caution. Russia has 100 times more power than it used against Ukraine. Russia has so far considered the situation in Ukraine as pest control. Moreover, the pest was Zelensky belonging to the West and his Nazi army. When dealing with pests, you don't burn down the whole house, you expel the pests. The West is concerned that Russia will not be able to hold back for long if there is an escalation like the Moscow massacre. It won't take Russia two years to destroy Ukraine. If she wanted to, then in two weeks Ukraine would have turned into a history lesson for Eastern European children. It would be a crater in the ground."

    @user-ok2mn4bw7u@user-ok2mn4bw7uАй бұрын
    • Thats' pure bs.

      @dinismantas7265@dinismantas7265Ай бұрын
    • What absolute crap. Simply refer to what Putin said was going to be the outcome. Take over all of Ukraine in four weeks without losing a single Russian. Got that wrong, didn't he. Lots of young Russian lives lost.

      @user-le8sn3xn2i@user-le8sn3xn2iАй бұрын
    • I agree bs

      @user-le8sn3xn2i@user-le8sn3xn2iАй бұрын
    • Remember, Russia said it would take four weeks with no lives lost. Young lives lost, and Russian inferstruture now being attacked????

      @user-le8sn3xn2i@user-le8sn3xn2iАй бұрын
    • Well said. Except it wouldnt even take 2 weeks.

      @imgr5143@imgr5143Ай бұрын
  • when a politician uses the phrase "I assure you this request is not dishonest." You know for a fact it is dishonest.

    @superfly3438@superfly3438Ай бұрын
    • No, this Representative was just taking a cheap shot for the purpose of getting some air time and stirring up a public that does not understand how budgets are on the hill (i.e. you).

      @stephengiunta1564@stephengiunta1564Ай бұрын
    • I assure you they will pass the biggest mess you've ever seen over to Trump.

      @toplarry@toplarryАй бұрын
    • @@stephengiunta1564 you’re right about the grandstanding while he’ll vote for another funding of the proxy war come September. This is yet another failure by the government, and it is further impoverishing us Americans by increasing our debt which is expected to hit 54 Trillion in 10 years. With BRICS expansion & de-dollarization by the so-called multipolar world, the US will go bankrupt.

      @YouTube_Enjoyerlol@YouTube_Enjoyerlol24 күн бұрын
  • We have a saying in Russia about someone who is clearly uncomfortable for his lies or misdeeds “he is twisting and turning like a devil on a frying pan”, and that fits Lloyd Austin))

    @ennuiennui7@ennuiennui7Ай бұрын
    • In russia we also say Mind your own busines occupant.

      @SkyhighStarlight@SkyhighStarlightАй бұрын
    • @@SkyhighStarlight exactly, mind NATO business elsewhere, not in Ukraine, and peace will return

      @ennuiennui7@ennuiennui7Ай бұрын
    • NATO is the real occupant here, they have no business in Ukraine. There was peace in the land before they decided to wedge in where they do not belong@@SkyhighStarlight

      @ennuiennui7@ennuiennui7Ай бұрын
    • @@ennuiennui7 Russia should go home. They lost enough of people. Ukraine is poor so it is nothing to steal other than land.

      @SkyhighStarlight@SkyhighStarlightАй бұрын
    • @@ennuiennui7 Nato doesnt kill anyone for 3000000 rubles a year. Ukraine is a country not a casino with striptease. Putin should quit drinking and gambling. He can lose not only money and soldiers but his own life.

      @SkyhighStarlight@SkyhighStarlightАй бұрын
  • Austin has no answers to these questions. Simple

    @Sunark@SunarkАй бұрын
  • What you don't understand, the money laundry must keep running. 10% for the Big Guy.

    @badhombre4942@badhombre4942Ай бұрын
    • Defense contractors--- who donate to politicians --- are making boocko bucks off of this war. The more money the Defense contractors get, the more they'll donate to the politicians to keep them in office. That's what this is about.

      @prometheusrex1@prometheusrex1Ай бұрын
    • Stupid to think it's about money laundering.

      @drewh1071@drewh1071Ай бұрын
    • @@drewh1071 Over a billion dollars to Ukraine cannot be accounted for...smart ass.

      @badhombre4942@badhombre4942Ай бұрын
    • @@drewh1071 you must be drunk

      @tianagarcia251@tianagarcia251Ай бұрын
    • @@badhombre4942it’s actually over a 100 billion that is unaccounted for Spike with a congressman.

      @davidross3404@davidross3404Ай бұрын
  • Total waste of money on a war that can’t be won .

    @simonschulz415@simonschulz415Ай бұрын
  • Hey Austin why don't u go fight in Ukraine 🫤

    @user-ei8pt7hc9u@user-ei8pt7hc9uАй бұрын
    • Austin is way too young to fight for Ukraine. Take a look at the veterans the Ukrainians are shovelling on to the frontlines these days.

      @duncansmith7562@duncansmith7562Ай бұрын
    • Wow asking an old decorated general who fought wars for America is very classy. Btw why doesn’t Putin fight in Ukraine numnuts… sound like a bot go me “user”

      @LIV-FREE-VET@LIV-FREE-VETАй бұрын
    • @@LIV-FREE-VET Putin doesn't need to fight. Russia is winning! At what point does it sink in, numnuts, that the West underestimated Russia? what convinces you that another 61 billion dollars will achieve what 91 billion failed to achieve?

      @duncansmith7562@duncansmith7562Ай бұрын
    • @@duncansmith7562 ☝️ You should… “Never argue with stupid people, they will drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience.” - Mark Twain 🤷‍♂️

      @neko1533@neko1533Ай бұрын
  • our own house is on fire and we are sending our water elsewhere, genius

    @tianagarcia251@tianagarcia251Ай бұрын
    • Wisdom!

      @cristalak@cristalakАй бұрын
    • Whose house you talking about. America is doing just fine. Do you even own a home?

      @LIV-FREE-VET@LIV-FREE-VETАй бұрын
    • Relax, you guya are very rich. Your nation is top 5 richest in the world. If you give me just 200 dollars, i will be able to build a mansion in my home country

      @chinazaokeke44@chinazaokeke44Ай бұрын
  • Hilarious Austin: We want to see Ukraine as a democratic country! Hahahahaha Then we can overtrow the president again. Thats our main power through history

    @hectorlavoe3712@hectorlavoe3712Ай бұрын
  • That BS was hard for him to spit out. He needs to ware his Raytheon hoodie for these meetings.

    @poppystars9005@poppystars9005Ай бұрын
    • Bro they trump maga politician didn’t even give him time to give detailed answers. What video you watching, do you even lift or read bro?

      @LIV-FREE-VET@LIV-FREE-VETАй бұрын
    • @@LIV-FREE-VET Better than you write. You should read your comment if that’s possible.

      @poppystars9005@poppystars9005Ай бұрын
    • @@poppystars9005 Bro the trump maga politican didn't even give him to give detailed answers. What video were you watching, do you even lift or read bro? He was probably trying to say that but I don't get how the "do you even lift or read bro?" part is needed.

      @winterinvicta@winterinvicta22 күн бұрын
  • What about defending our own borders from the invasion we are suffering now thanks to JB?

    @AlexisLopez-fs2tk@AlexisLopez-fs2tkАй бұрын
    • Invasion by the UN

      @John-lj8rv@John-lj8rvАй бұрын
    • Dorkov!--bot!

      @WangAiHua@WangAiHuaАй бұрын
    • How would you otherwise have entered US, Mr Lopez?

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • What invasion? If immigration is invasion then you're an invader.

      @adwaitnaravane5285@adwaitnaravane528514 күн бұрын
  • From an European perspective: I find Def. Sec Gen Austin embarrassing. I mean what kind of questions he was expecting to receive? He remind me of a student that did not do his homweworks and got examined by the teacher. "how do you define vitory" :well u know ...bla bla no point WTF This is the man who is supposed to direct the defense strategy of US??? God Bless you guys.

    @vecioalpin8998@vecioalpin8998Ай бұрын
    • It seems so. But senator asking complex questions, but expecting simple answers. That's a bit silly from him. Its not so simple to stop Russia or China. And its not smart to give them, all they want

      @batmanyk@batmanyk26 күн бұрын
    • @@batmanyk Asking Russia to accept Ukraine inside NATo is also "silly". The main problem with this is Russia would lose access to Black Sea. Imagine Mexico reclaming California since that state is full of spanish people. Would the US accept it?? How do you define victory? That was an illuminating question cause Austin has no clear answer. This means that this administration has not designed a path to return to normality, either through a total defeat of Russia or through negotiations. This is not how it should be.

      @vecioalpin8998@vecioalpin899826 күн бұрын
    • Or they simply do not want to share it with the public. Average Mary and Bill should mind their common men business and note poke their noses into geo-politics.

      @RussianAngel120@RussianAngel12024 күн бұрын
  • Follow the money...who's getting rich over this?

    @user-xu8ki2kn5x@user-xu8ki2kn5xАй бұрын
    • Putin and his friend Trump

      @highvoltagee@highvoltageeАй бұрын
    • ​​​US-ISRAELI BANKERS AND AIPAC. USA BELONG TO THE........M​@@highvoltagee.........

      @aldinokalla868@aldinokalla868Ай бұрын
    • ​​​​​​​@@highvoltageeUS-ISRAELI DEEP STATE. US-ISRAELI BANKERS CONTROLE USA................................

      @aldinokalla868@aldinokalla868Ай бұрын
    • ​@@highvoltageewhat about zelensky, his income have been doubled in just one year amid war, when US people are paying their money for ukraine, hiw does he spend his money , think about it

      @arulelisa@arulelisaАй бұрын
    • Zelensky just bought a 20 million dollars mansion in England.

      @donelpapu2714@donelpapu2714Ай бұрын
  • Jeez, you ask this guy a yes/no question, and you'll hear everything except "yes" or "no."

    @miululu7432@miululu7432Ай бұрын
    • Yes for Ukraine help, No for Russia to succeed. Does it help?

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • @@sherion80 “Ukraine cannot win”, this was verbatim reported by TIME & multiple Western publications last month. the US thought they could defeat Russia through massive sanctions, they failed. If the US continues this Ukraine may turn into either a landlocked failed rump state or disappear from the map. Ukraine should’ve never listened to Nuland/CUA and Boris Johnson.

      @YouTube_Enjoyerlol@YouTube_Enjoyerlol24 күн бұрын
    • @@KZhead_Enjoyerlol US didn't even start to defeat russia. If they had balls to do so, russian mafia regime and wannabe empire would be already history.

      @sherion80@sherion8023 күн бұрын
    • That's all politicians

      @pezwarrior4@pezwarrior422 күн бұрын
  • Good luck getting Crimea back buddy

    @scar00000@scar00000Ай бұрын
    • Crimea has been Russian since 1783 and Ukraine basically were only administrators. Most people in Crimea are employed in Russian tourism or employed by the Russian navy. There is nothing there for Ukrainians. It is a holiday destination for Russians. If Ukraine gained control what would they do with it, nobody could afford to travel there and holiday from Ukraine. Crimea would be bankrupt inside 2 years.

      @awalk5177@awalk5177Ай бұрын
    • @@awalk5177 The whole point of Crimea joining Ukraine is to put a USA base in the Black sea. The rampaging hegemon has lost the plot.

      @UrosStankovic@UrosStankovic8 күн бұрын
  • Good question: "How do you drscribe victory?" "What is a victory for Ukraine?"😂The guy couldn't even answer😂😂😂

    @paulbrou6723@paulbrou6723Ай бұрын
  • Translation: just give me money. And no, we don’t really want Ukraine in NATO.

    @ericp1139@ericp1139Ай бұрын
  • I've never seen such a weak administration.

    @TengoMetekhi@TengoMetekhiАй бұрын
  • ❤Simple answer. No VICTORY FOR UKRAINE .

    @petergreen5337@petergreen5337Ай бұрын
  • I posted “no more $ for corrupt Ukraine “ and YT pulled the comment. I wonder how long this will stay up. I guess you can’t say corrupt and Ukraine in the same post

    @arcademaster1@arcademaster1Ай бұрын
    • Ten days now

      @nguyenho5859@nguyenho5859Ай бұрын
  • Isn't the nato thing what started the war???

    @auspiciousnkomo3071@auspiciousnkomo3071Ай бұрын
    • No, the US started it in 2012 when Obama/Biden/Nuland stages a coup with the help of Georgian snipers and authentic Nazis that ended democracy and a war when the Nazis tried to invade the Donbas region. Russian speakers were stripped of all right so they could not vote, all broadcast was changed from Russian, a language everyone knew to Ukrainian which was spoken mostly in the west where there was less population. Russia did not enter until 2022 when the newly independent LPR and DPR had legally declared independent and 17,000 Russian speakers has been murdered in the east. Almost all the war has been east of the Dnieper River which is legally Russia. Everything you have been told by the media and US is dead wrong, completely fabricated but so has every war or invasion by the US. Just since 2000 the US has staged coups or invade 202 times and not one was reported honestly.

      @stanspb763@stanspb763Ай бұрын
    • Which country invaded Ukraine can you remind me please?

      @alexcross8297@alexcross829722 күн бұрын
    • @@alexcross8297 You should ask yourself "WHY" they invaded ukraine.

      @ulcho@ulcho21 күн бұрын
    • @@ulcho , please elaborate

      @alexcross8297@alexcross829721 күн бұрын
    • @@stanspb763 It became obvious to smart observers with Yugoslavia/Serbia just how reckless, arrogant and greedy the West is. Population was easier to control back then, MSM did an amazing brainwashing.

      @UrosStankovic@UrosStankovic8 күн бұрын
  • How much of the 100 billion will he see in shares and whatever

    @allanmcdowall6568@allanmcdowall6568Ай бұрын
    • The usual attack-the-person strategy. You are a Russian agent.

      @accountcreatedforrussiantrolls@accountcreatedforrussiantrollsАй бұрын
  • What a small minded person not fit for office

    @stevencharnock9271@stevencharnock9271Ай бұрын
    • That's why he is in the office! In order to encomplish they dirty plans they need small minded one's otherwise they would have disagreements in the office.

      @illayreich8373@illayreich8373Ай бұрын
  • Before the coup d'état of the NATO countries in Ukraine 2014, Ukraine was neutral and independent. Why then did NATO do the coup d'état that started the conflict where the Russian speakers became second-class citizens without rights. This NATO war is abominable considering all the fallen and injured Ukrainians who may now be at least 1.5 million soldiers.

    @lassel1344@lassel1344Ай бұрын
  • Austin does not know what to say. Lies are the only things he can say with ease

    @felicehomestream1650@felicehomestream165023 күн бұрын
  • I hadn’t thought of it that way but He made a really good point saying that our military arms producers are not producing the equipment that will help America if something were to happen. Instead they are busy producing arms for Ukraine all for the purpose to launder money.

    @krisk31@krisk31Ай бұрын
    • STOP LIE.

      @kunik61@kunik61Ай бұрын
    • The defense industry isn't producing arms for Ukraine. The US is giving Ukraine old equipment that has been collecting dust. Nearly all of the foreign aid is spent on US defense firms to replenish US stock after giving Ukraine the older equipment.

      @GentlemanJack705@GentlemanJack705Ай бұрын
    • ​@@GentlemanJack705if that's the case then the U.S. dosnt really want Ukraine to win this war. Either way the U.S. is dishonest here.

      @sausaigeham1104@sausaigeham1104Ай бұрын
    • 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂​@@GentlemanJack705

      @MC8News@MC8News13 күн бұрын
  • If 60 billion dollars is given now another 6o billion dollar request will be forthcoming September by the sounds of it

    @randomracki9453@randomracki9453Ай бұрын
    • Anche più presto di settembre

      @lorycotiga4231@lorycotiga4231Ай бұрын
  • HOW CAN THIS GUY BE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE AND BE ON THE BOARD OF ONE OF THOSE U.S. DEFENSE CONTRACTOR COMPANIES???? ISN'T THIS A CONFLICT OF INTERESTS AND HE SHOULD IMMEDIATELY BE REPLACED OR FIRED????

    @John-ol5vk@John-ol5vkАй бұрын
  • Just imagine, open acknowledgement that the money is going to USA...

    @mondaykingsleysmd3711@mondaykingsleysmd3711Ай бұрын
  • If this is what America calls brains then I'm sorry America has got no brains at all... what! It's pathetic this crop of American leadership. Americans, please accept my deepest condolences, you have expired!

    @samuelarthur8425@samuelarthur8425Ай бұрын
    • You ask like putin is good for Russia. Over 500, 000 dead Russians, the ruble is less then a US penny, Noone really wants to deal with Russia, thousands of sanctions, the economy is bottomed out, NATO is bigger than ever

      @jayhaugabook7393@jayhaugabook7393Ай бұрын
    • America don't understand Russia warm them that Ukraine campaign was big mistake. They still sending billion dollars a years may effect US abilities lead to defeat. Russia other hand make checkmate here,Putin have save last laugh at United States that American political make silly move to send aid package. That where Russia want you right there . Because idiot person sending way too soon. Now Russia continue push more and more capture Ukraine territory. Ukraine people don't want this war, because Ukraine people wanted peace to beg their policies end the war....if not....going be hell broke lose over there Ukraine.

      @JosephineBovain@JosephineBovain29 күн бұрын
    • That's so true. How could a top leader look that weak, man even the medium size company project manager can have better than this.. in term of plans and strategies. This is just a simple question for the thing that already last for 2 years. Even if he doesn't want to reveal the project, he would know what to be delivered to the public.

      @XuanThanhLe-wb4ty@XuanThanhLe-wb4ty25 күн бұрын
    • Yeah, right. Why would you tell your plans while your enemy is listening?

      @alexcross8297@alexcross829722 күн бұрын
    • @@alexcross8297 You arent really smart, are you?

      @ulcho@ulcho21 күн бұрын
  • My question is what is this aid going to achieve that the past aid couldn’t?

    @LennyLaserdisk@LennyLaserdiskАй бұрын
    • It will drag the war for a while.

      @basithali1196@basithali1196Ай бұрын
    • @@basithali1196 If the USA does not provide assistance to Ukraine, the US army will enter the war earlier. Russia clearly states that it wants to change the World order.

      @anatoliismikhula9501@anatoliismikhula9501Ай бұрын
    • Nothing

      @LEGIONARIO1970@LEGIONARIO1970Ай бұрын
    • Exponential. But the problem, is there enough manpower to achieve it?

      @paijokotak6996@paijokotak699624 күн бұрын
    • It's not aid It's a loan

      @MuawuyaHaruna@MuawuyaHaruna7 сағат бұрын
  • They must be taking the piss if Ukraine is democratic country😅

    @egorkazachkin725@egorkazachkin725Ай бұрын
  • Do many American know how this war was really started? Or just a handful seriously understand where their money is being spent?

    @magicsmurfy@magicsmurfyАй бұрын
  • Very weak questions. Will there be another request post September

    @user-xz5vg6tc3j@user-xz5vg6tc3jАй бұрын
    • Zelinsky will continue asking for money even after the 60billion of dollars sent soon. All because Zelibsky doesn't care of any ukrain victory, but care and love US dollar.😂😂😂😂 Zelinsky does not like Europran Euro currency at all😂

      @paulbrou6723@paulbrou6723Ай бұрын
  • Geez, to say this was discouraging is an understatement. If Austin is the best we got for Secretary of Defense Washington DC gotta big problem. That was 4 minutes of mumbling, and a lot of ah, ah, ah, ah ....

    @Decoy0527@Decoy0527Ай бұрын
    • It’s a common theme for this administration

      @lambdee7006@lambdee7006Ай бұрын
  • Ukraine is honestly a bottomless pit for US tax dollars. Russia manufactures its own weapons at a cost vastly lower than that of US supplied weapons. Socialism is winning against capitalism in this case.

    @tlp3482@tlp3482Ай бұрын
    • Russia is more pure democratic than any NATO country In a typical federal election there is no barrier to running, the 40 main parties plus individuals can run without any money. All candidates get free equal broadcast airtime and all are invited to nationally televised debates. The second most popular party is the oldest Communist Party because the elderly still favor communism but everyone else prefers one of the liberal democracy parties so the main difference is specific policies. Putin has won due to every person you talk to agrees that their lives and the country has improved every single year, the only country where the people actually see increases in rights and services. The people hating Russia have not been to Russia, know only western claims about it It is safe, very low crime, has more access to culture than any country on earth, great free medical care, very low cost of living, great cheap public transportation so it is faster getting somewhere then driving, 58 min paid vacation days, no taxes.....sales tax is included in the listed price, nothing is deducted from the payment for work, the employer pays the tax, long paid family leave, grants to buy larger homes if they are having a baby. Most people over 20 own their home clear of debt, twice the percentage of population with college degrees than the US, and no debt for university, police who do not kill people, the last time police killed anyone in a country of 150,000,000 was 4 years ago. Crime is so low that in 2017 73 prisons were closed due to lack of inmates. All the 200 native ethnicities that make up the population get a long, no homelessness etc. Doctors even do house calls, free. It is very easy and cheap to start a business. The population is highly educated and highly cultured, healthy and if you have ever seen a Russian woman and don't fall in love, check your pulse, you are clinically dead. If you see someone fat or badly dressed, you know they are tourists

      @stanspb763@stanspb763Ай бұрын
    • We've seen your great ruzzian culture in Bucha

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • Russia is a fully capitalist country since 90's.

      @fakt7814@fakt7814Ай бұрын
    • @@fakt7814 Filly rogue mafia country. True.

      @sherion80@sherion80Ай бұрын
    • @@sherion80 Do you mean the so called "massacre" staged by the British secret service?

      @markusberzborn6346@markusberzborn6346Ай бұрын
  • It is not about Ukraine, it is all about PNAC.

    @bfa-xi1py@bfa-xi1pyАй бұрын
  • Dithering all the time with questions asked. WTF!? How difficult is it?

    @henrypang4734@henrypang473422 күн бұрын
  • that summed up perfectly why Russia is winning. Incessant humming and hawing around basic questions that Biden and co haven't even considered, let alone answered.

    @duncansmith7562@duncansmith7562Ай бұрын
  • So a total of 300 billion for ukarine in a war that is certain for a humiliating loss for nato. Wtf we have 35 trllion in debt and counting and interest payment has outgrown our defence spending wow

    @seahaws1@seahaws1Ай бұрын
  • Brilliant senator

    @MyMail8080@MyMail8080Ай бұрын
  • Another never ending war

    @theresnocomingback@theresnocomingbackАй бұрын
    • Vietnam part 2

      @shyguy9102@shyguy9102Ай бұрын
    • ​@@shyguy9102it's Vietnam War in reverse. USA(Russia) supply the ukraine(vietcong) to repel the russian(American). But the outcome is obviously different. Russia fighting in their border, closer to home and ease on logistics.

      @royk7712@royk7712Ай бұрын
  • austin licking his lips like a reptile

    @sashakeltane4763@sashakeltane4763Ай бұрын
    • He is...

      @SkywalkerPaul@SkywalkerPaulАй бұрын
    • The lizard people have returned😂

      @sausaigeham1104@sausaigeham1104Ай бұрын
    • I have a pet lizard .... please don't insult my little guy with comparison to Raytheon pawn ....

      @randygram9310@randygram931020 күн бұрын
  • Lies,lies,and more lies

    @kevinford6420@kevinford6420Ай бұрын
  • Define victory!!!!

    @JustinBasil.i@JustinBasil.iАй бұрын
  • I noticed he stammers answering the questions showing he is not sure or what He is saying isn't true.

    @cristalak@cristalakАй бұрын
  • No more money to Ukraine

    @cathycarter5451@cathycarter5451Ай бұрын
  • Woke generals 💩

    @MfBadass@MfBadassАй бұрын
    • A affirmative action appointment

      @bjohnson1489@bjohnson1489Ай бұрын
    • @@bjohnson1489 You had to be the one to play the race card.

      @larynOneka8080@larynOneka8080Ай бұрын
  • The amount of stutter when he is asked about the Ukrainian victory says it all.

    @alekssakota3825@alekssakota3825Ай бұрын
  • Im not american but im having hard time breathing listening to Austin on how he speak... dah dah dahh dah

    @joyrama2908@joyrama2908Ай бұрын
    • When you are trying hard to defend something that is true this is how you sound.

      @TreboR1966@TreboR1966Ай бұрын
  • somebody please explain to Austin that Ukraine has upheld its elections and is imprisoning & torturing those who criticize its government and so therefore it is not really a democratic nation

    @HLeoncio61@HLeoncio61Ай бұрын
    • True even if Ukraine is fully in the right. Legally the west will be funding a foreign dictatorship. Not exactly the look I want for my country.

      @sausaigeham1104@sausaigeham1104Ай бұрын
    • Hmmm. Rouge nation? Sounds like dictator alright over there

      @JosephineBovain@JosephineBovain29 күн бұрын
  • You’re right

    @OtisBBarry@OtisBBarry21 күн бұрын
  • For a US politician/military explaining what constitutes victory or loss in military conflict since 1945 must be the hardest intellectual task yet!

    @ciseaux@ciseauxАй бұрын
  • And that's why Russia will accept nothing less than unconditional surrender from Ukraine... Austin admitted the money is going straight in the pockets of the M.I.C. They don't give a Rat's Ass about Ukraine .....War is a Racket....

    @anthonygil1522@anthonygil1522Ай бұрын
  • ....asking the right questios....👍👍👍

    @mihairusu3224@mihairusu322422 күн бұрын
  • Ukr is about to end😂

    @zakrewzakrevskii3208@zakrewzakrevskii3208Ай бұрын
  • Look at a map. Do you think Russia became this big because they distributed flowers?

    @marcbjorg4823@marcbjorg4823Ай бұрын
  • They speak as if they are losing money yet they are actually investing. Also the problem is that to them this is about winning and not saving lives, if negotiations started today I guarantee not losing life is victory.

    @auspiciousnkomo3071@auspiciousnkomo3071Ай бұрын
  • Stop sending our damn hard earned money to Ukraine!

    @marvelvisionary@marvelvisionaryАй бұрын
  • Define victory, Putting President Trump back in leadership.

    @whitehaze259@whitehaze259Ай бұрын
    • Shit with feet Biden dictator, Leaders mediate, negotiate, Rulers are out fighting corn pop all day....

      @marvinpratt257@marvinpratt257Ай бұрын
  • Absolutely shameful us administration.

    @AB5yiytrreew@AB5yiytrreewАй бұрын
  • Now that's how it should be..everyone must be held accountable.

    @footballbharat@footballbharat14 күн бұрын
  • independent country, but if they US+NATO does not like the government of any country. They will interfere and remove any leader of any country if they don't like. Just like what happen in LIBYA, Iraq and even in the Philippines during Ferdinand Marcos era.

    @macariosakay2951@macariosakay2951Ай бұрын
  • Administration not able to have any clarity about war, financial burden, what not, not an idea of victory....nice, legislature slowly spins from stones!

    @krishnamurthyalappan7995@krishnamurthyalappan7995Ай бұрын
  • Most politicians are not honest enough to give a direct answer bcos they themselves do not want to lose their status at all so they need to keep playing these kind of games until something comes in favour of them

    @GurdeepSingh-vq5lw@GurdeepSingh-vq5lwАй бұрын
  • The honesty and intelligence presented by Secretary Austin is a joy to watch. The man is role model for morality and humanity. I am being somewhat sarcastic…

    @ericwedin4154@ericwedin415424 күн бұрын
  • Western and American weaponry has been left with a big question mark, it is only effective against poor countries with mediocre armies or rather against civilians. America will have to enlist superh

    @user-tk4tk4zv2p@user-tk4tk4zv2pАй бұрын
  • No!US and NATO won the war in Ukraine in pockets....in battlefield?you'll knew who?

    @almahilum2233@almahilum2233Ай бұрын
  • Keep sending money aid to ukraine for war but not sure hownits gonna win against russia. Ukraine might have more money in the long run but populations decreases and land cannot take back. So its a lose for ukraine what ever might happen

    @archiearevalo5648@archiearevalo5648Ай бұрын
  • A lunatic mind cannot answer a simple question...a you have a madman in charge of Defense....the country must be CRAZY!

    @jmxxx123@jmxxx12318 күн бұрын
  • It's a money laundering racket

    @loris9744@loris974419 күн бұрын
  • This so called Aid Package is all about the Biden Admin. wanting to prolong this loser war, a bottomless pit which will cost countless more lives and wealth...until after the election of course

    @leewilkinson8609@leewilkinson8609Ай бұрын
  • Écoutez-nous bien, ils ne font que contredire ce que la Russie a gagné en Ukraine, la Russie ne s'en prend pas au peuple ukrainien car ils sont même amis et frères depuis 8 siècles, au final, la contradiction Occident contre Ukraine ne produit rien du tout, Russie il faut conquérir la puissance occidentale en faveur de l'Ukraine, sinon c'est comme ça. 64 pays, avec pour leader les États-Unis, tous n'ont pas réussi à repousser la Russie ne serait-ce que d'un mètre. Les États-Unis occidentaux doivent mettre fin à leur théorie contre la Russie et l'Ukraine, etc. Eh bien, les États-Unis devraient sortir de là pour devenir une puissance dans le monde. le monde et son hégémonie ont complètement disparu.

    @kanyamagaraabdallah8300@kanyamagaraabdallah8300Ай бұрын
  • Buying weapons like interceptors does not mean you have people to fly and maintain them that takes years to build up and then they have 0 combat experience. Ukraine has never been independent or Democratic in the first place that's the whole reason of this war, winning or losing it wil not change that.

    @ricardoblikman2676@ricardoblikman2676Ай бұрын
  • “What does victory look like”? IT DOESN’T!

    @glichasasha750@glichasasha7508 күн бұрын
  • NATO is loosing and someone needs to tell them about the news

    Ай бұрын
    • To whom, is it at war with someone? So far it’s only Ukraine fighting against Russia alone.

      @alexcross8297@alexcross829722 күн бұрын
  • Keep spending monies that the U.S. doesn't have to throw down the old rabbit hole. Ukraine is losing and will lose.

    @paulcross5149@paulcross5149Ай бұрын
  • Ce sénateur est excellent ! 👍

    @darthtleilaxu4021@darthtleilaxu402126 күн бұрын
  • "I can assure you this request is not dishonest". Can we hold you to that, Mr Austin?

    @richardkroll2269@richardkroll226917 күн бұрын
  • Sounds like Afghanistan 2.0.

    @yousefsafa5248@yousefsafa5248Ай бұрын
    • The US occupied Afghanistan for twenty years and was building civil infrastructure during that time. The US lost 2,000 soldiers in those twenty years. Ukraine on the other hand has only been going on for three years and already the Russians lost 100,000 soldiers. Calling Ukraine just like Afghanistan is laughable. For context, 9,000 Americans are murdered in American cities every year. It was safer for a twenty year old American to go to Afghanistan than to live in Chicago, Detroit, Memphis, St. Louis, Washington D.C. etc...

      @thebigmon@thebigmon21 күн бұрын
  • In Germany we say : " Alles hat ein Ende, nur die Wurst hat zwei ". This translates literally into ''Everything has an end, only the sausage has two. '' The English version of this proverb is: ''All things must come to an end"

    @Hans-Wolff@Hans-WolffАй бұрын
  • That was uncomfortable 😂😂😂

    @kevinford6420@kevinford6420Ай бұрын
  • No $ for crooks in Ukraine

    @thethrasher3091@thethrasher3091Ай бұрын
  • Madness!

    @arthurchonyera7031@arthurchonyera7031Ай бұрын
  • How is this not on the front page

    @jonathonpowers7788@jonathonpowers7788Күн бұрын
  • Victory hahahaha.

    @PrecisionKing85@PrecisionKing85Ай бұрын
    • Do you believe that the US should be defeated?--Are YOU rooting for RuZZia to win?

      @WangAiHua@WangAiHuaАй бұрын
  • Affirmative Action strikes again. Poor guy is forgetting what he was supposed to say.

    @doctorb9264@doctorb9264Ай бұрын
  • Perfect

    @igby457@igby457Ай бұрын
  • claiming victory is delusional. They need professional personal help

    @emiliomagnus940@emiliomagnus94025 күн бұрын
  • Ukraine is the one and only European country that needs to join a defence alliance to protect itself against a ruthless aggressor as soon as *possible*, i guess ?

    @azibi69@azibi69Ай бұрын
KZhead