Clone Wars 2003 Re-Animated Side by Side
2023 ж. 12 Мам.
1 282 726 Рет қаралды
Just a quick comparison I whipped up to make it easier for people to compare the two.
Clone Wars 2003:
• Star Wars Clone Wars V...
My 3D Recreation:
• The Muunilinst 10 Ambu...
loved how quiet the clones were in this series. they felt more professional
@@extantfellow46but the stoicism is still cool and not all of them are chatterboxes.
@@extantfellow46 but they really talk too much and i like the silent clones better
These clones are Arc troopers special forces unit.
Real professional soldiers talk in combat, you have to verbally communicate sighted threats and your own actions as well as confirm you hear what your allies are communicating to you, private comms for an elite team of arcs works if that's how we're justifying their silence, however in TCW we see large scale combat with hundreds of grunts where it would be hard to integrate comms and have everyone be able to communicate clearly without talking over each other or communicating to the wrong people, so sure they might seem like silent badasses but they really should be verbalizing quite a bit, after all you have to make sure your buddies watch those wrist rockets
The newer clones are a lot more like soldiers though. Modern armies get into a lot of shenanigans and say weird shit even on the front lines.
I like how in this series, the droids legitimately felt like a threat. I always found it dubious that the CIS were taken as a credible threat when their battle droids couldn't hit a still target right in front them. 2003 actually showed them as the galaxie wide threat they are.
it showed both of the sides were dangerous, but that's more tartovsky's style. almost every other star wars show or movie depicts evyerone to be more cartoonish
@@jaybrielrosales9191 I just wish gendy didn't always take such a simplistic approach to warfare. Like that scene where the clones and droids were running towards eachother in an open field with no cover while firing.
@@thescruffinator8830 I agree but I think it's more of a narrative choice as well.
@@jaybrielrosales9191stylistic choice aside, I feel like B1s should be treated like the cannon fodder they are. They’re cheap, disposable, and easily repairable; not so with clone troopers. If a single B1 manages to kill a single clone before succumbing to its fate, it can still be repaired and put back into combat a few days later. That clone is dead, full stop. That’s why they’re so terrifying; they are relentless.
I remember my bf trying to tell me that they were a forced to be reckoned with until they made the clones. I couldn't help but giggle and think of the silly droids saying "Roger Roger"
I will never get over the those sniper droids going full auto. They get me every single time I rewatch this scene.
Right like it’s set up like they are targeting the specific clone up on the crash but then just “haha you thought” *blasters from EVERYWHERE* absolute chaos
I forgot they went full auto in this scene, I wasn't ready 😭😭😭
It's so funny. It always makes me chuckle. "Steady.. steady... YEEEEEEHAAAAAWWWWW"
1:08 I will never get over the perfect setup to a classic tense sniper scene. Victims visible in the enemy's crosshair, calm, quiet scenery, multiple establishing shots of both party's... and then it all gets thrown out the window by the "sniper" turning into a machine gun.
"You see Number 36, you won't miss if your rifle fire hits everything at once."
@@DarkJediHunter117And they say short, controlled bursts are more effective. Give me any weapon, and I won’t miss because I’ll be firing too many rounds to miss.
@@user-eh9rg6bo7l I think that is the purpose of a Squad Automatic Weapon, to help suppress the enemy into cover as you're throwing so much lead their way.
I mean it works, seeing as a clone got shot in the head with a precision laser spray.
In Battle Front 2 (2006 one) this weapon is actually a sniper
I loved how quiet and calm the clones were when their transport was shot down, especially the pilot. Clone pilot: So I guess we’re going down…
Just like the simulations tbh
That’s how you have to be in a life or death situation if you lose your head well…you really *LOOSE* your head
I think that they were always talking but the helmets isolated the noise from the inside so they were communicating through the radio
@@alanjefferson1127 that is definitely in the simulations of a pilot, how to 'land' without or limited flight capabilities
Another happy landing
I honestly wish more games would make rocket and missile launchers the counter to long range threats. Because that’s what the unguided ones are for. The guided ones are dual purpose but intended for anti vehicle purposes except in the case of anti aircraft launchers and other launchers that require a guidance system.
RPS-6 (canon) vs PLX-1 (legends)
If it’s unguided, it’s not a missile A missile knows where it is at all times. It knows this because it knows where it isn't. By subtracting where it is from where it isn't, or where it isn't from where it is - whichever is greater - it obtains a difference or deviation. The guidance subsystem uses deviations to generate corrective commands to drive the missile from a position where it is to a position where it isn't, and arriving at a position that it wasn't, it now is. Consequently, the position where it is is now the position that it wasn't, and if follows that the position that it was is now the position that it isn't. In the event that the position that it is in is not the position that it wasn't, the system has acquired a variation. The variation being the difference between where the missile is and where it wasn't. If variation is considered to be a significant factor, it too may be corrected by the GEA. However, the missile must also know where it was. The missile guidance computer scenario works as follows: Because a variation has modified some of the information that the missile has obtained, it is not sure just where it is. However, it is sure where it isn't, within reason, and it know where it was. It now subtracts where it should be from where it wasn't, or vice versa. And by differentiating this from the algebraic sum of where it shouldn't be and where it was, it is able to obtain the deviation and its variation, which is called error.
@@chrischrisdamanThat's such a great and unexpected reference! Lol
@@chrischrisdaman If I throw a rock at you, that makes it a missile.
I love how the clones don't scream or panic when their dropship gets shot down. They know a quiet mind is the key to survival and victory. Really imposes this feeling of "just like the simulations".
i hate that they became so unlike jango and boba
@@TONEDEAFSOUND They’re a product of their environment. Training does a lot for how you react to certain situations.
@@jesusofbullets i mean i hate how they tried to make them not act like they do in 2d clone wars later on
@@TONEDEAFSOUND They did the perfect blend of personality and professionalism in the 2008 Clone Wars imo
@catodes1295 nahh toomuch personality imo I mean it works in the show, but changed the whole dynamic
This looks really good
Thanks man
Thanks for 1 million views. Hoes mad
You did a great job considering the original was made by an entire studio. I like it!
@@SyPhase Thanks heaps :)
Sry, but you are wrong. Your version is far better. I was everytime disappointed about the animation quality in this film and the first seasons of Clone Wars were better but not very good. But after season 3 it got far far better. Thank you for sharing this 🙂
Nah bro dont down play yourself. Regardless if it was you yourself or you and a couple of bros, yall did that. That shit smooth asf and the detail is A1. Tbh if the whole series was out in your animation I’d more than likely would watch it over the original💯
It was still so cool don’t downplay it
I love the effort that was put into this. But I will stick with the Old 2D style. For me it just works better. But you’ve got mad talent. Keep up the stellar work
It was rhe clone pilot sequence for me that solidified the 2005 one for me
Old style made me pass on the series.
@@HowManyHintsDoYouNeed did you like samurai Jack?
@@peris_arts_film9699 as an adult yes, as a child no. It was ugly animation when I was little
@@HowManyHintsDoYouNeedodd for me ugly animation was stuff like ed edd and eddy or courage the cowardly dog, kids next door was fine but animation like this are the ones I liked, probably why I was a bit of a weeb when I was younger
I love the original 2D animation because it just felt like it worked so well with the way the story was written. But your animation is very impressive, you must be very proud.
I think why people like the 2D one is because the recoil seems appropriate for the 2D clones, where as here in fully fleshed 3D the recoil looks a little janky, still a god tier animation tho
@@nerdinvader6740 I agree, the movements and whatnot also look a bit wonky and sloppy. However, of course there's always room for improvement especially as technology evolves. Still amazed at this person's work, definitely got potential
@@clickbaitable9578 I think it's a pacing issue between the animations. The 3D motion is a bit too smooth and/or slow in some scenes which takes away from the ducking for cover feel of the 2D.
Thanks for the kind comment! Yes it took me quite a while to complete so I'm very happy with my progress so far. I'm still pretty new to animation and everything so I appreciate it
@@CheeseyBun wait wth do you mean you're "new to animation"? This is amazing!
lol I love how the sniper on the rooftop at 1:04 is like steadily aiming, checking his scopes, making sure he won’t miss and then just full on rapid fires 💀
I Guess it was an LMG
He might been zoomin in and all that for target identification. Not “aim at this guys face and hope the first shot hits before the recoil kicks in” so much as “oh those guys got colored armor, I’ll spray these 2-3 guys first”
Very cool, as much as I love the samurai jack style, a less exaggerated more realistic style rocks
Well, it makes sense when you think about it. Genndy Tartakovsky directed both series.
Never understood the desire for realism in fiction
@@misein2466 ik that but I never really thought that style fit star wars
@@ef4722Because it makes it feel more grounded? Not sure why you wouldn’t want realistic elements.
@@youdontknowwhoiam4349because it's star wars. Barely anything about it is, or should be realistic. Groundedness isn't conducive to a good story after all.
You did an excellent job but I kept finding myself watching the original without realizing it, probably just because of how iconic it is.
Of course, I would never deny that the original is better
This is neat; I recommend following the key pose composition more as the direction of the original was extremely purposeful. Especially look at the shot of the battedroid with the rocket, the original has clear posing and the eye is lead from the rocket to screen right with the body language and the smoke trail. In the recreation we can barely see what is going on with the droid. Just my two cents.
This nigga has the secret sauce
I appreciate the feedback, I deviated from the rocket shot with the battle droid simply coz I wasn't bothered to mock up another city in the background lol. I agree I would've loved to do it perfectly frame for frame as it does make more sense.
@@CheeseyBunI thoroughly enjoyed what you made and I look forward to seeing more of your work.
I liked that the 2003 version had the same tone in character. Anakin and the clones were how I imagined them to be: less babbling and more showing.
This version of the Clone Wars will always be surperior to me personally
@@_Dar_29same it’s the one
they had to nerf the hell out of the clones equipment, or else it wouldn't be a war. 360 sensors, hand held scanners and wall hacks, various forms of vision in the base equipment. the basic clone rookie was equal to a more modern clone Veteran, and each step up the ladder was even more effective. As dangerous as the droids were in 2003, that was largely because of either mass numbers, or ambushes like this one.
I mean, this is an ARC squad, so it stands to reason that they had special non-standard equipment. These are the highly trained veterans, not the rookies. Plus, there's nothing stopping the droids from having similar equipment
This honestly tricked me into thinking big named companies were working on this. Fantastic job!
This was pretty neat! One thing I'd recommend, in the event someone didn't say it already, is make the hand movements more snappy. Maybe not quite like the original, but even in rl military operations hand signals are quick and precise.
the 2d animation has more character in it. By that I mean that in some shots of the re-animation the clones looked more lethargic than in the OG scene. However, it's still a damn good animation. Genndy Tartakovsky is one of the all-time greats in the animation industry.
I loved how they actually fired quite a lot in the 2003 series. In Clone Wars you see hallways full of droids and Clones doing slow single shots instead of just hosing down the hallway like the 2003 clones do
"if you see something moving in that hallway, make sure you didn't see anything moving in that hallway."
The original has so much character in each movement by the clones. They're all similar, but still unique in their mannerisms.
That looks awesome! I've always love the style of this scene, no talking just pure professionalism from the clones.
Yeah no yelling “clankers”
From our perspective, we can't hear them. Why? Because they're talking through their helmets that have built in communicators. When we hear clones talking to each other with helmets on while in combat in the 2008 Clone Wars, we the audience can hear them but everyone else in the show can't hear them talking because they're using helmet communicators to talk privately
1:10 When you add a 20x scope to your M240B
Its amazing what we (the fans) can do with computers nowadays.
Oh hell yes, I can't wait for more! Good work!
Cheers!
Epic. Would watch the full length feature, especially the Mace Windu VS Droid Army episode. Well done!
Glad this randomly popped up in my feed. You did a ton of work and it really looks good. Should be super proud of what you made here
Absolutely incredible work! Have always wanted to see this in a realistic depiction, and you nailed it! I don’t think it could get much better than this! ❤
Thanks for the comment! Love your work too man
this looks incredible! congratulations and thank you for your hard work. I always get a good chuckle when the snipers go full auto haha
I like that you kept the vibrancy of CW 2003.
That sniper scene still cracks me up over how abruptly he opens up on them with that “sniper” rifle
I love how the Pilot was not faze when he was crashing I just assume he knew what was happening and accept his fate
As a clone should
Sure beats watching Disney Star Wars
This is so well done. Do smoothly choreographed. The editing is amazing. I honestly expected to like the new animation more but there’s something so cold about the original that draws me to it.
This is looking great, can't wait for the finished product 👏
It looks clean n flows well Good shit, i love the way they took the content seriously and made it as severe and badass as they did
Wow really smooth movement
My favourite thing about re-watching this scene is how stone cold the clones are during the crash landing. Really brings home that original intent of them being emotionless.
I love how quiet scenes like this were. This really felt like an elite force, kind of reminds me of the clone commandos in a way with the squad commands. Though I was will say adding voices and personally to the clones was the better choice, if they didn't we wouldn't have had clones like 99 be as respected as they are
I love this so much. May the force be w/ you all !
This is exceedingly well done, and is a great showcase for the strengths of each style. Maybe just a little more polish on some of the 3D effects and it would be a serious rival, but 2003 Clone Wars is almost perfect to begin with, so you've set yourself quite a bar to meet right off the bat.
Thanks for the feedback! Yes I'm still quite new to animation so im still getting used to it. Haha yes I could never top OG clone wars!
God, imagine how 2003 General Grievous would look if he had 2008 General Grievous animation.
Nah the 3D show was more slower paced i loved the 2D series because you had so much freedom and could pull off better feats. It’s just more entertaining honestly.
I gasped when I saw this thumbnail on my feed. Immediately I tapped and watched one of my core childhood moments evolve into something greater. This was incredible! A great example. I’d love for you or someone to go even FURTHER with it and go all out and make it top tier! Thank you again for making something amazing!
Haven't seen this In a while and good I miss this show. Your animation was amazing by the way! Keep It up!
This looks amazing! You did an excellent job!
Thank you!
That's not bad, definitely something to be proud of 👏
Holy crap! you did amazing work!!
LOVE this. I want to watch the whole series side by side. It’s perfection
The droid steadily aiming with its sniper rifle only to just unleash rapid fire with tons of recoil is always funny to me
As an animation student I can make some suggestions. The benefit of having a 3d world when you 3d model is camera angles and movement. In 2d animation they keep the camera still to make animating easier and they add life by exaggerated movement. Try making the camera move more and don't copy the animation exactly or you lose most of the benefits you get out of 3d animation. I would suggest watching an episode of the 3d animated clone wars and taking note of how they use camera movement in that and then trying to replicate it here. Your animation is great 👍
The sound design of the OG series was just amazing
I hope Gennady is smiling if he's seen this. Great job! Both versions are good in their different ways!
Nicely done
Thank you
Love the use of the lore accurate Alpha ARC Trooper design in the models, rather than the more new generic arc trooper design
20 years ago I had to record the Clone wars off cartoon network, convert it to mpeg and load it onto my sonystick to play on my clie. You have done an awesome job with this.
its really cool that it still feels like genndys work even in 3d just from the cinematography
you cant reanimate perfection
Dude you are incredible. Insane work. Thanks for sharing homie take care hope to see more
Thanks heaps man
THIS IS AMAZING
Great work! Even if it’s in live-action, the droid specialist’s sniper rifle becoming a straight up auto gun always has me laughing
God phase 1 armor was so cool looking
Re animated ? Whattt bro this is awesome
Incredible job on recreating the lighting!
Dude, this looks fantastic!!!
Fordo and the other Arc's actually have their own weapons, The Arcs use the WESTAR-M5 Blaster Rifle and Fordo use 2 "Commando Pistols" or possibly the DC-15s Blaster Pistol instead
wow, please, I need this series reanimated. This is amazing work ^^
Visual storytelling at its finest. Just *chef kiss* beautiful
Great job on the animation. I really love the original and you lovingly recreated nearly perfectly.
Making the animations more snappy on the reanimated side would make it look alot better
I could watch this version all day.
There was a lot of really good work put into this. IT does not need to surpass the original to be majorly impressive.
This reanimation was sick. Absolutely love the blaster bolts illuminating the environment. I wonder if they were quiet bc they knew their comms were hacked (being in a droid controlled environment by the looks of it)
when you get older and rewatch this, you appreciate the writing, the silence and simplicity, makes you focus on whats actually happening
back when soldiers knew how to use cover and hold positions lol. In the newer star wars stuff everyone just sort of gets out of cover and runs towards eachother. I'm always like "why have long range weapons if you're just gonna get into close range fights."
Absolutely epic mate
My favorite chapters of that show! Loved the hand signals. I hope you do the next chapter too!
Absolutely loved this
Looks amazing 👍
This is really good
Bro the reanimated portion makes it feel so much more serious and threatening, i also like how their is no blur and weird over lighting like the new shows, actually makes it visually clear
Always liked the fact as the Gunship was going down they were perfectly fine and still, crash and get out like "yeah, it's just a Tuesday for us" lol
This was my favorite scene in the history of star wars I'm obsessed with the gunship crashing to see it re-animated is a dream come true
I thought this was official before i saw the channel's name. A+ work! you are super talented.
Love it truly brilliant
Wow, that was very well done. Also, speaking as someone who has seen the animated Clone Wars Volumes, I really liked them. The way they made the clone dead quiet during that mission was an incredible way of showing that while they are genetic creations, they are still very efficient.
Much appreciated. I loved that detail about the original as well
i didnt know this existed but wow this is incredible goodwork
You are really good at what you do. You deserve way more subs.
Cheers
Great effort!
This deserves far more recognition. To me the 2D series encapsulated the tree horrors and realities of a real battlefield but made it bad ass and fun. Keep it up
very well done.
Man, these clones never flinched when they got shot down. They weren’t afraid to die.
The silent professionalism of a battle while you yourself aren't linked to the radio.
That's great work! I love it!
I still wonder how the hell those clones survived that crash 😂
Thank you, may God bless you all and everyone. ❤
God bless ✝
Bro cracked me up to see a PFP from my favorite game as a Star Wars youtuber
Coooool!!! Looks really like a live action! I want to see more of this stuff! Some scenes with Obiwan and Anakin would look incredibly cool! Keep working 👍😁
This is still the best of any star wars media undoubtedly. Before u respond just know I'm not a big star wars/trek fan so I don't care.
I love how even the regular clones got their chance to be competent
Looks amazing i love it!