Giants trade up for McCarthy?, Jayden Daniels is favorite for No.2 Pick, Vikings | NFL | THE HERD
FOX Sports NFL Reporter Peter Schrager joins The Herd to discuss the upcoming NFL Draft. Schrager discusses the New York Giants and whether they could trade up to No. 4 to draft J.J. McCarthy. Hear what he had to say about the Minnesota Vikings and Jayden Daniels being the betting favorite to go No.2 to Washington.
#TheHerd #NFL #Giants
SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from The Herd: foxs.pt/SubscribeTHEHERD
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4uouolb
►Watch the latest content from The Herd: foxs.pt/LatestOnTheHerd
▶The Carton Show's KZhead channel: sprtspod.fox/SubscribeCartonShow
▶First Things First's KZhead channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFIRSTTHINGSFIRST
►UNDISPUTED’s KZhead channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeUNDISPUTED
►Speak’s KZhead channel: sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBEtoSpeak
►The Skip Bayless Show KZhead channel: sprtspod.fox/SUBSCRIBESkipShow
►What's Wright? with Nick Wright KZhead channel: sprtspod.fox/whatswright/youtube
See more from THE HERD: foxs.pt/THEHERDFoxSports
Like THE HERD on Facebook: foxs.pt/THEHERDFacebook
Follow THE HERD on Twitter: foxs.pt/THEHERDTwitter
Follow THE HERD on Instagram: foxs.pt/THEHERDInstagram
Follow Colin Cowherd on Twitter: foxs.pt/ColinCowherdTwitter
About The Herd with Colin Cowherd:
The Herd with Colin Cowherd is a three-hour sports television and radio show on FS1 and iHeartRadio. Every day, Colin will give you his authentic, unfiltered opinion on the day’s biggest sports topics.
Giants trade up for McCarthy?, Jayden Daniels is favorite for No.2 Pick, Vikings | NFL | THE HERD
• Giants trade up for Mc...
The Herd with Colin Cowherd
/ colincowherd
Watch The Joel Klatt Show now: bit.ly/JoelKlattShow
Giants drafting Mcarthy is like trading Daniel Jones for Daniel Jones
Brilliant observation!
LOL
Isn't this guy a tool?
Actually JJ is everything they wrongfully convinced themselves that DJ was.
It’s way worse!! McCarthy isn’t even as good as Jones!
Why Colin is sO certain a first round QB would sit a year behind Darnold is a mystery to me.
He’s delusional
I think he dated his daughter, or was tray lance. It’s spacing me
@@camerontinney9684Trey
Because that is how it will play out. It makes more sense than anything else!
you must be new here-Colin is the OG Sam Darnold glazer
The media selling JJ so hard it’s crazy
people talking about football analysts and player scouts like it's the evil fake news media is just so lame lol like what are we trying to do here also heard many in "the media" say that he's overrated and not worth a first round pick too, how taking him Top 5 would be insane etc, does that mean "the media" is also trying to take him down? that's not how things work, and people making generic "the media" comments to act like they have a take is just weak
Yeah… he sucks
What are u talking about? Media does nothing but hate on him, because stats….It’s the scouts and people inside organizations that seemingly like him
It’s not the media it’s the Agents. If you need an agent call JJs guy
Media? Teams take chances on QBs like no other position because it's make or break. JJ 〽️cNatty is waaaaaaay more talented than Harbaugh let show. He's a 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Colin one of the only mainstream guys always talking about the Vikings. It's hilarious because it's obvious it's due to his man crush on Darnold that he's had for years.
Peter got every pick wrong except 1 last year so take what he hears with a grain of salt
Honestly taking Penix Jr later on in the draft is so much better then blowing resources for JJ McCarthy. I don't know enough about Maye but believe in Williams, Daniels and can see Penix Jr working w the right team and right pieces around him. Maye has all the psychically capabilities to be Josh Allen 2.0 etc. McCarthy looks like a backup style or maybe a game manager Cousins type at best to me
If McCarthy becomes like Kirk cousins that is a successful career.
Get Penix at 11, take a chance, lose no picks, yes?
The only reason that Penix isn’t the #2 QB on the board is his injury history. He’s sooo much better than JJ on the field.
@@NateBeePenix is the third best qb in the draft. If Vikings pick him up at 11, he’s gonna win Rookie of the year.
We need to take Nabers at 6, he'll have the same impact to the team as a Franchise QB he's that good, he'll open up the field for Hyatt he's a deep threat and Robinson is explosive. I'll be excited about the Giants if we draft a #1 WR and sign a vet CB
Best decision!!
Who’s we 😂
Not sure how you guys would get Nabers at 6 unless the cardinals or chargers get a huge haul to trade down.
@@shooksrule I think the Cardinals will take MHJ & The Chargers will trade down to take a tackle & if both teams stay put im ok with taking Odunze we just need a #1, hopefully Odunze can be that
@@themoneyman1752 nabers > Odunze imo but we will See
Drafting tiny little JJ would seal NYG's doom for the next 3 years
The eagles collapsing again this year would be hilarious. Little cry baby coach
5yrs
@Chris-cs2rw they won't get a chance to collapse. Not with that defense. Bet under 10.5. Free money
J.J. Mccarthy is 1 inch shorter than Tom Brady, little man.
If I were a rookie QB I want to play in Minnesota! 💯
Nobody wants Belichick in charge of their draft.
who even wants him hiring a coaching staff these days? he was gonna have Matt Patricia follow him in the building like a puppy dog, maybe to coach his offense lol who knows Bill Belichick's overall resume = legendary, but Bill Belichick in 2024 and beyond = out of touch stubborn old man
There is ZERO WAY Giants move up from 6 to 4 to get JJ McCarthy. This is a big joke 😂
Seems very unlikely
So what you are really saying is you think they will stick with Daniel jones
Colin trying to recruit live on air lol
At this point Minnesota should just stay put and pick two first rounders.
Passing up a QB because you lack weapons is terrible logic. If you find the right QB, you take him immediately and then fill out the rest. Wrs can be found everywhere. GB rebuilt almost an entire receiving/te room in 1 year.
FINALLY SOMEBODY GETS IT.
Actually the studies say you should build your Team then get your QB. The last 4 Super Bowl winning TEAMS had that formula.
But McCarthy and Maye are not those guys. Giants drafting Daniels or Caleb would be a smart choice without any weapons. McCarthy or Maye would go bust getting picked up by the giants.
@@maaliemaal1373 this is what I understand to bbe true
Yeah how that work out with Mac jones? 😂😂😂 dumbest observation I’ve heard.
2 of the best
Colin’s “Shrages” had Shrages close his eyes for a good second 😂
I think Penix Jr and Bo Nix are better than Drake Maye.
Maye is a backup at best!
Vikings should trade up for a WR and roll with Sam Darnold, and the best receiving core in the NFL.
That’s delusional
@@shooksrule That’s basically what the 49ers are doing
Please lord let him be wrong 😂
Jayden, Drake, and JJ are very reliant on their 1st read, Jayden and JJ especially (one defaults to running and the other late on his progressions once the first isn’t there). Drake is the best of those 3 . Penix falling is a great example of NFL Scouting groupthink. He’s the most composed, accurate, smoothest progressions, great over the middle throws, and deceptive running speed. Once the dust settles, he’ll be on Caleb’s tier as the best QBs in this class.
I don't doubt that, but his health is the big scare with him that will probably cause him to fall.
um....no
does Penix throw to the middle of the field? From what I understand he's the worst of all the would be 1st rounders against pressure
All I know is Michigan was begging him to throw to the middle and he couldn’t. He is great at the deep ball, helped by world class receivers.
Colin thinking the Vikes will let his lad Darnold start for a year. Lol, get real Colin. Vikes coach has no interest in getting fired after a 6-11 year. Darnold is there to be a backup, nothing else.
If the draft turns out like he said everyone is fired in 2 years
Darnold definitely better than the 3rd/4th qb in the draft right now. He’s starting
who is starting then?
They fixed the Audio 🎉🎉🎉
In all honesty I just feel like it doesn’t really matter. Don’t they literally have “The next Best thing” at QB almost every single year? And for the most part, no one ever really knows, and it’s very hard to predict how these guy’s careers will go. This is just from my perspective. (Someone who hasn’t really watched Football since Brady Retired). Nor do I really have an interest to.
I don't think so. Alt, that's what we need. Offensive line! PERIOD..
As a Vikings fan, I'd be happy if Schrager's mock plays out that way.
I'm not sure about the CB he has them taking at #11, I'm just not that familiar with him. But I will be very happy if the Vikings fill 2 conditions. 1) Do not try & move up in the draft. 2) Do not draft JJ McCarthy unless the first round is over.
Giants drafting McCarthy only makes sense if they trade next years pick, so you can get him a WR cause RN the giants have a bottom 3 offense rn
McCarthy sucks
What do you mean next years pick? Giants would have to give up 6 to even be in that conversation and it would likely cost a 2nd or 3rd to do it
I get taking Arnold at 11. Harrison Smith is probably in his last year. But that could be addressed in free agency next year or cuts this year. I would take Byron Murphy II because they need a DT. Nix is fine I guess. I don't know enough about him. He may not be there at 23. So THEN what do you do?
is your mic ON? Pump it up boy
If Nabers is there at 9, the Bears are drafting him without a shadow of a doubt.
If the Giants trade up for JJ I will officially abandon them as a franchise I root for. They clearly don't know what talent is because they already went through this by picking Daniel Jones top 10 years ago. They doubled down on this stupidity by signing Jones to a multimillion dollar deal over their pro bowler RB. I pray this is all pre-draft hype
Wow
Winning that game against my Vikings was the worst thing that could’ve happened for giants fans…
Same
I will do the same if my Pats take him at 3
@@jackharrington697 Tom Brady to JJ McCarthy… what a world
Bruh JJ will be a bust simply because of expectations of a top 5 pick.
Love the Harrison to my chargers. Gonna be a great tandem between him and JH
PLEASE FIX YOUR AUDIO LEVELS...how long do we have to ask?
Colin needs to chill on the Sean Payton man crush getting old. Dude only one 1 SB as a HC... he's not a magical guru
It must be excruciating for a team like the Giants. The thought of losing draft capital to move up 2 spots because you are afraid that Minnesota could swoop in if they want to. The Giants should trade out and accumulate more picks. It makes sense for Minnesota to move up to get their guy. The Giants need to rebuild their roster.
Giants drafting a qb would be disastrous for the qb.
Sound!
please fix the sound
If i were the Vikings i would grab Pennix at 11 or move up to 7 for him if we're boxed out of top 4 qb. They could keep 23 & 2025 1st rounder
McCarthy is Mara’s idea. Mara is a known meddler.
As a UM fan I have watched almost every snap JJ has ever taken and I am very appreciative of what he gave to the program. But I can also say as a Giants fan drafting at 4 or 6 will be a big mistake. DJ 2.0
Love Schrags
JJ mc carthy is the only QB who is worth a first pick..way to go giants...
This is how it's gonna go: 1- Caleb to the Bears, 2- Jayden to the Commanders, 3- Drake Maye to the Patriots, 4- Marvin Harrison to the Cards, 5- Malik Naybors to the Chargers, 6- The Giants trade with Minnesota. Minnesota takes Mccarthy at 6. Giants get 11&23. 7-9 I don't know how any of these teams pass on Odunze. 10- The Jets may trade back to 13 with the Raiders plus the Raiders 2nd round pick so the Raiders can get Penix. 11- Giants take best available. 12-Denver may take Nix but they should consider trading back to accumulate more picks. Sean Payton is already off to a disastrous start in Denver. If he misses on a rookie QB he is cooked. Take the capital and build your roster.
Denver guy is Nix, no need to trade up.
As a Vikings fan do not understand this Kevin O'Connell hype. We have 1 great season n then get pooped 💩 on by the terrible Giants in the first round of the playoffs at home. Then next year I know people bring up Kirk injury but they all seem to forget we were 1-5/1-4 with Kirk don't remember exact record but I remember being excited that we might get Caleb. But then we won a couple games late. But a terrible season
Colin with the dig at GMF….
Schrager saying the Vikings take a corner at 11 and Nix at 23? Terrible. Thats a nightmare scenario. If they actually do that... I want KAM fired immediately.
We ain’t drafting no cb in the first round, d line all the way or a good guard.
The Giants absolutely would go through the motions to do their diligence on QBs to get talent to fall to them. Giants brass should be fired if they do this. And then Vikings draft Bo Nix? LMAO
People forget after Success Jimmy Johnson, Ditka, Parcells, Walsh, others all failed with other teams Belichick could probably be the same.
He reasoning is clearly slanted against the Vikings
If the giants do this I can't cheer for this team anymore.
All smoke! Giants will get a WR, OL, or will trade back. WAYYYYYY too many holes on this team
Bo Nix is better than McCarthy and Penix is one big hit away from a body cast.
These "analysts" know nothing about football, personnel or current team rosters.
I’ll beat the Bears trade up to get MHJ especially with Arizona trades out of the 4
McCarthy is a career backup. He is the flavor of this years draft
He is just like Will levis
I have a now major problem with any credibility with this guy. “He also needs to look at Spencer rattler” who hasn’t been good since highschool but was on a tv show.
this is pre draft fake, they goin WR or trading down
If jj is a giant they will lose a third of their fanbase me included especially if they give up picks they desperately need for him
So you want to stay with Daniel jones?
McCarthy at 4 is all time draft stupidity
Giants fan since 85 if NY move up and waste picks for JJ I will throw out all my GMEN gear please don't do it Giants
DRAFT ELITE JJ MCCARTHY FIRST OVERALL
Anyone else think that Schrager is a tool?
Giants trading up for MHJ and sniping him from Arizona.
Chicago won't be trading down, they'll stay at 9 or trade up to get someone they like.
ZACK WILSON??
Hey Colin In talking about the kid from Washington going to New York to play for the Jets Surviving in New York He ll only see NY if he drives over or takes the train on his own time The Jets practice and play in New Jersey!
Vikings Drake Maye >>>>… Has flaws and needs time to gel, but the hatred and overanalysis is too much at this time of year. Teams pass on great quarterbacks because they overthink it. If he has the talent, and has shown on film the ability layer the ball, and make the type of throws necessary at the NFL level, trust your coaches. If not, I’m perfectly fine with Penix, ceiling is a left-handed, CJ Stroud
No one came to his birthday thou
Maye is gone at 3, keep dreaming haha
@@markmccreadie6212 we can trade up… We have the draft capital
@@markmccreadie6212lol. Not if my Viking straight up for him with the patriots… If they are starting a rookie quarterback, which many are better than Jacoby Brissett already, then that kid is immediately going to fail.
Vikings will not pass on Nix and Penix for Arnold. One of them will be a Viking at 11 and Broncos or Raiders take the other.
The Giants will draft Joe Milton…. It is in their DNA…
If Drake May Falls to the Patriots at #3 pick. We are going to see a three way trade. The Patriots trade down to the 4th pick from the cardinals and receive Minnesota's 2025 1st round pick. The Cardinals get the 11th and 23rd pick from the Vikings for the 3rd pick. Thus the Vikings get their guy at the third pick of the draft.
The cardinals said they require 3 first round picks to trade down. So no way they will trade down for just 11,23
@@shooksrule They can ask for that, but they’re not going to get it. Three of the top quarterbacks are gone by that pic 4. The kid from Michigan is being talked up. But he really is a mid to late first rounder. I would say, even Will Levis is better than the kid from Michigan, and look where he fell. Know if Drake Maye was there at pick a number three, then yes, give next year’s number one and 11 & 23 this year. Get your guy @ 3.
@@thomaspower221 I understand it may not happen but then the Vikings won’t trade up and will miss on a QB. If they don’t get a QB they are in a very tough spot and the cards and chargers have all the leverage with so many QB needy teams looking to trade up like Denver and the raiders.
@@shooksrule As disappointing as it may be to miss out on Drake Maye or Jayden Daniels. Perhaps they like another guy. And we’d more likely see what Kevin O’Connell can do with Sam Darnold. I don’t believe that I am the only one curious about that. Don’t forget how young Sam was when he came into the league. Now that he is a grown man, with a good quarterback-friendly Head Coach, not unlike Kyle Shanahan. Folks are starting to talk about a Renaissance for Sam. Not that different from what we’ve seen out of Baker Mayfield.
@@thomaspower221 I guarantee if Sam Darnold os the plan moving forward Jefferson will ask for a trade or sit out
Bo Nix couldn't hold Sam Darnold's jock. The Vikings don't need a QB.
Colin’s burner account spotted
Mark my words, Maye and McCarthy will be busts. Maye for sure and McCarthy will get the benefit of the doubt but he’ll end up like Zach Wilson
NE and Arizona both move back. But Arizona needs a QB. Ad. Kyler sucks. He won’t be resigning with Arizona. Facts
This draft is taking too long
I hope Peter is right. I've been having nightmares about my Vikings even taking JJ, let alone trading up to get him. I think the idea of drafting him in the top half of the first round is insane.
Same I have been having nightmares of my Pats drafting him at 3 dear God....If they do I may go to a new team
@@jackharrington697 Pats taking him would like drafting Mac Jones all over again
I don't know many people noticed this the Giants only pick white qb
Well unless you want them to take Penix, they’re not getting Caleb or Jayden
Maybe because there aren’t any black ones available. And even if there any available, are they good? You sound like a woke left girl.
@@NinjachickenfingersJayden Daniels will slide. Biggest smokescreen I’ve seen in a while. Dude is not going to be a good NFL Qb lol. He’s much more in need of a year watching than Maye is. Lot of people on DraftKings payroll right now 🤫🤫
always overreaching for a mediocre wyt QB. That said, seems like EVERY year a mediocre wyt QB's draft position gets elevated by the media. It's like they have to have at least ONE be in the mix and discussion smh lol
When has a blacc one ever been available?
JJ would be there at 6...
Trade up for JJ so have no experience and no weapons wow
I doubt that, smoke screen
This would be terrible. JJ is definitely not a number for overall. He would get crushed more than DJ has gotten crushed because he was actually bred to be a QB unlike DJ. I could also see DJ shocking the world and playing his best football this coming year. That would be not awesome Because then you have to move on from him next year and there’s no guarantee that JJ will be ready. I think this is a little bit of a Smokeshow because people know that Schrager has a connection with shame and will think that he got direct Intel. I don’t think that’s the case. We will wait and see.
Its the best time of year for bad content
It’s not what I would do , it’s what I heard from a Ruth Cris waiter , wow , teenager rumors got a job
I hope after JJ wins his first SuperBowl you apologize to him!
Lol thats not going happen he is going be Zac Wilson or Mac Jones
Bad trade up. Hope this doesn't happen
is the audio ever going to be fixed so we can hear without being at max volume? I keep having to turn it up and then get blasted for the outro. This episode was particularly bad with the volume changing throughout the video.
As a bears fan, I’m praying the Vikings trade up for McCarthy 😂
The.Vikings will hold for Pennix or Nix and keep all their picks. The NYG are run poorly and give away the house for JJ
G-men really looking for that great white hope at QB lol
Bo nix dallas
Passing on the right QB because the team isn’t good is dumb logic. It’s the most important position & honestly nothing else really matters. You can have a stacked roster with no quarterback and still be watching the playoffs
How often is the 4th or 5th QB the right QB? We’re not talking about passing on the 1st or 2nd QB 🤦♂️ Drafting a QB because fans don’t like the current QB is dumb
Oh and tell that to the 49ers or you think Purdy is a top ten QB? lol
Will someone buy me a new tooth brush 🪥 why are they like $100
If JJ McCarthy goes to the giants he is going to flop so hard in the nfl.
Dumbest take in history like wtf stop with these stupid scenarios!
No-good 😢
I just wanna know who he talked to that said the Bears are looking for a CB over taking Nabers at 9. This guy is a joke and talks to no one in the league.
If the Giants did all that, it's not because they want to move up. It's because they know there's a big change JJ McCarthy is available at their spot.
Schrager is a hack. And Cowherd has become a weatherman. (I reserve the right to change my opinion when new information arises!) Great. He spends three hours a day telling you it's going to be sunny, then the next day tells you it's going to rain. Corporate jackasses, the both of them.
So Colin thinks the Patriots need "like seven players.' they had a top ten defense and 7 of their losses were by one score or less.