NATO's Inevitable Defeat as Ukraine's Army Has Been Destroyed | Ray McGovern
2024 ж. 11 Мам.
74 266 Рет қаралды
Ray came to Washington from his native Bronx in the early Sixties as an Army infantry/intelligence officer and then served as a CIA analyst for 27 years, from the administration of John F. Kennedy to that of George H. W. Bush. Ray’s duties included chairing National Intelligence Estimates and preparing the President’s Daily Brief, which he briefed one-on-one to President Ronald Reagan’s five most senior national security advisers from 1981 to 1985.
raymcgovern.com
I live in Sweden and can say that we Swedes do not want to belong to NATO. We weren't even asked. Our leaders, like many other leaders in the West, have gone completely mad.
you voted for your leaders. "He who does through others does himself." --Blackstone
As a Norwegian I can absolutely understand you. You have been neutral for so long.. why change that now!?
@@egay86292 I don't vote for any of the 8 parties that are in government now, but I vote for one outside that I hope will grow. Alternative for Sweden. But large parts of the Swedish people do it and they are brainwashed thanks to our twisted media swedish television.
You got to love how some people think they talk for the whole nation they are citizen of. With quick internet search you can easily find topics that tell you that about 2/3 of swedes support joining nato, and no topics of how you feel about things.
Ref to Op lockstep
Putin himself is reserved. Some politicians in the West perceive this as weakness. They forget that Putin's restraint is a professional quality due to his work in intelligence.
Western politicians have become feminized. They are overly emotional and feel like they have to respond to everything ASAP in the current news cycle lest they are seen as weak. Putin is coldly calculating, and if it means that he feels he can do better by not responding immediately but by playing the long game he will. Western politicians no longer understand this and think if the response does not come in the current news cycle they have scored a victory.
President Putin very much someone who says what he means and means what he says. his economy with words is remarkable and commendable very much in line with his global statesman stature. esp when u look at the empty suits blabbermouths in eu from junkie beggar elensky to little napoleon to little richie to pirate scholz to 360baerbard (can't rem her surname. she's that forgettable) to vonderliar to jungle joseph and more european buffoons.
Seems rather clever, to me.
Unlike the idiots in the whth money hungry politicians
In his eighth decade this analyst is still one of the best.
Ray , being 84 years old is actually in his ninth decade
Top analytics in most eloquent articulation. Can't get enough of Ray's insight.
LOL. These clowns babble on about the same delusional nonsense every day. Whatever Putin is paying them, its too much.
@@YawehthedragondogofEL Aee you stupid or something?
I agree! He’s excellent.
Ray McGovern is an excellent geopolitical analyst ...
@@micnorton9487 he's a tool.
What upsets me is the State Dept, Pentagon and Intel knew the Ukraine would lose from day 1 but threw over 200 billion towards it.
Look up the definition of proxy warfare. You fight through others to save your own army.
That’s 0.2T, we have bigger problems
Look up the definition of proxy w. You fight through others to save your own army.
Look up the definition of proxy war
You fight through others
I have a new found admiration for Mr McGovern since his talk about his Irish heritage and analyzed that speach that someone from Ireland made.
Ray, Nima, there's an American hedge fund manager/ lawyer, who ten years ago, in his book: The Case for Gold, praised Russian Central Bank Governor, Elvira Nabulina, as one of the world's best Central Bank chief. Nabulina instrumental in guiding Russia & the Rouble thru Sanctions
I fully agree with you 100% !!!
Ray couldn´t agree more than with regard to Germany not promoting its own interests first, this is exactly what Jeffrey Sachs is saying.
Probably because the Greens are American agents and Scholz is,,,what he is.
I have heard that Washington wanted this war because they are interested in Russians natural resources and also to break the trade bond between Russian energy/ German technology. You guys should join BRICS and leave EU-parliament ,, which is a sinking ship.
Живущая в Лондоне Юлия Воробьева сообщила в соцсетях, что голосовала за Путина. Некий украинский активист Назар Смык, разузнал, что Юлия работает в лондонской компании Egre, закатил скандал и призвал наказать россиянку. В итоге с женщиной прекратили контракт. Раньше неприлично даже было интересоваться у человека, какие у него взгляды и за кого он голосует. Не говоря уже о каком-то осуждении и тем более увольнении за взгляды. И эти люди заявляют, что мы угроза демократии. Какой демократии? В чем она? Израиль за 4 месяца поубивал столько же людей, сколько погибло за 4 года во всех конфликтах, но они спокойно попали на Олимпиаду, не говоря уже о каких-то санкциях и поставках оружия. Запад украл деньги России, положил их в банк, процент хочет отдать Украине и утверждает, что это нормально. В чем ваша демократия? Что там защищать осталось?
UK has some serious blood debt built up.
Your sense of uncomfort is legit an honest. You are several layers away, don't be disappointed and Keep searching for the truth, on day it will be shown before your eyes as bright as the sunlight appears after dawn. One more thing, search outside the mainstream media.
😅😅😅😅😅😅
The west has cornered itself
Only the slaves of Russia fear Putin. Free people never will comrade.
😂😂😂 What a nonsense : in reality: (Russia lost 300 000 troops vs NATO: 0 troops lost) Sweden+Finland joined NATO vs Moldova and Armenia left RUSSIA sphere of influence Over 40% of Russian Black Sea fleet already sunk + 45% refineries are damaged 😁😁👍 Putin can't even protect Moscow from ISIS - despite warnings from the USA what a loser - "Belogroad People Republics" is being created by Free Russian corpus (inside Russia)😂😂😂 Also because of TRUMP - every one in NATO is paying its share now 👍👍
The ‘west’ Will kill us all…dangerous warmongers…and it’s time the people (us) wised up!
@@YawehthedragondogofEL So you ARE stupid
But the US ambassador to the UK just told Sky News (25/3/24) that the UA is winningt.....
BOTH China 🇨🇳 and Russia 🇷🇺 have a strong manufacturing base which can sustain a long war in their own neighborhood! The USA has exported MOST of their manufacturing with exception of its military industrial complex which is a hungry killing machine! BUT cannot sustain a war so far away its neighborhood with its manufacturing base spread all over the world INCLUDING in China and Russia!
Not to mention giving away most of it's stockpiles to UKR for 2 years & can't replenish fast enough for ourselves. Never mind supplying 2 other countries.
One of the reasons for the Ukraine conflict is to create chaos in Europe, resulting in migration of capital, skilled labor and manufacturing capabilities from Europe to USA. USA is winning no matter what.
@tsorevitch2409 If the US have the capabities to pay these skilled individuals hansomely then I would believe you. But right now, with housing prices skyrocketing, interests rate as well, and a country with a debt of over 40 Trillion and growing. I highly doubt it. What the US and EU wanted is to cripple Russia with this war. To make them bleed money,young men, equipment, ammo, and halting their industrial complex by shifting their production to war effort at the expense of Ukrainians.
@@Rockboygg why should they pay handsomely when USA can just make their life miserable In their home counties? Skilled labor will pay their own expense to move as poor or just modest life is way better than suffering.
@@RKZX2Agree,, you also have to add the military materiel necessary to stock 1000 overseas American bases, and that's still not mentioning the amount of weaponry and ammunition that goes to maintain stooge governments.... The diabolical tentacles of Wall Street...
Macron is a clown like zelensky. they must be in the front line to entertain the soldiers hahaha😂
and Trudeau, ...
And Biden + Trump 😂
Brilliant analysis by Ray McGovern.
Q: Who would want war to expand ? A: The family that dominated the war theater For the past 243 years.... And their name begins with the letter, ROTHSCHILD
Invest!!!!!!! Not their way.
"Israel" has been described as "Rothchild's army base."
@@sarldorissimo7916Well I think it goes farther than just one family or group of oligarchs,, and laying all this on The Tribe is too narrow because the military industrial complex is owned by WASPs AND Zionists among others...
Remarkably articulate, factual and prescient from the illustrious Ray McGovern. Of course Russia has no intention or reason to attack Europe, an important past and future market. It will defend itself from potential or actual security, economic or strategic threat from the U.S. neocon regime Pariis
Why would Russia want Europe? A failed EU with a destroyed economy.
Good interview Nima; you let the man talk. Good overall coverage, Ray. Thank you.
Thank God for one voice of sanity, one voice of reality !
note your god's pretty goddamned stingy with the peacemakers.
Ukraine might become a member of NATO after it ends up in the middle of the Atlantic.
Hahahahahaha
"So much Russia winning alone while the EU and Nato loses together" Me in 2023
What about n.korea and Iran? russia not alone, also many Indians tricked into fighting for russia
Thank you both Keep bringing us truth
❤ Great Episode 👀🤠🇨🇦
He moved 'heaven and earth' and uncovered the pit of hell.
Just because I have low self esteem does not mean I am smarter than the folks with too much self-esteem!
Smarter nor dumber! The fact that you mention you having low esteem most likely makes you smarter😊
Remember who dropped a meteor on Japan 🤔
2 meteors actually...
Why am I being censored(by Google I'm sure) for suggesting that if Russia gets attacked with non-conventional weapon so will the US homeland?
Because Google censorship is now quite heavy handed. And many people are shadow banned. If you comment on certain things.....your comments will be automatically deleted
Don't worry just say that VICTORIA NULAND IS A BEAUTIFUL INTELLIGENT TENDER CARING HUMAN BEING and that will bypass censorship. Perhaps even AI. BEST OF LUCK
lol join the club. yah praise collective west, condemn China & Russia, call genocide biden the most compassionate sharp strong intelligent leader amerikkka ever has, and youtube will not only clad yr comments with gold, it will also promote yr comments.
That happened to so many people, soon you will read that censorship does not happen in the USA it only happens in Russia and China and Iran .
Very scary 😢
i HOPE THAT RAY COULD BE IN CHARGE OF THE US DEFENSE DEPARTMENT...HE HAS AN HONEST BRAIN.
And heart.
He'd make a great president...and he's old enough to join the race.
He's a little old. But yes, he would be a fine President of the US, as well.
@@jollylollypop1Chronologically around the same age as Biden and Trump...but psychologically he has kept his mind in a state of what I would describe as mature youthfulness. He has achieved what we should all be seeking to attain in advanced years...a healthy wisdom.
Ray and Larry Johnson should be in charge of two 3 letter US agencies dismantling!
A pleasure to listen to this man in a world spinning out of control. Reason and common sense. Thank you Ray!!
На самом деле, те кто думают, что они могут победить Россию, хоть в обычной войне, хоть в ядерной, как правило дилетанты в военном деле, совершенно не понимают стратегии и вообще мало что знают о России в целом, по сути их уверенность в победе основана на собственных амбициях и мнимом превосходстве, но реальность такова, что Россию в принципе практически невозможно победить в войне. И дело не только в том, что Россия почти 1000 лет своей истории постоянно защищалась от нападений и просто умеет воевать лучше всех, а как минимум в одном очень важном параметре - Стратегическая глубина. И тут не обязательно быть великим полководцем, что бы это понять, достаточно посмотреть на карту мира и увидеть, что Россия занимает 1/6 часть всей суши планеты, а это значит, что она может очень долго и постепенно отступать, и находясь в обороне наносить колоссальный урон нападающим, а когда придет время, силы противника будут измотаны, то перейти в наступление и победить. Более того, если посмотреть на самые крупные нападения на Россию, например Франции с Наполеоном, проанализировать и понять, что ровно такой стратегии и придерживалась Россия, в следствии чего измотала армию французов, а потом практически уничтожила и вошла в Париж. Второй пример Германии с Гитлером, когда Гитлер напал на СССР, то по началу все видели его успехи, а СССР постепенно отступали почти 2 года, при этом Гитлер за это время не смог захватить даже 20% территории СССР, в итоге армию немцев измотали и наступил переломный момент, когда СССР за следующие 2 года не только освободил потерянные территории, но и пол Европы и остановился уже в Германии. Более того, если посмотреть как развивались боевые действия на Украине, то можно увидеть, что Россия не рассчитывала воевать в принципе и первые 2 месяца дошла до Киева только потому, что рассчитывали на переговоры, когда же переговоры сорвали, то все остальные боевые действия со стороны России напоминают оборону, даже отступали немного, а сейчас, когда Украина понесла колоссальные потери, когда вымотана, когда условный запад тоже вымотан финансово, Россия может легко победить, и единственное что останавливает Россию, это сдержанная политика Путина, который все еще надеется на здравомыслие западных стран, и который просто не хочет уничтожать Украину, так как считает ее братским народом.
your first day in the thermonuclear age?
@@egay86292 вы имеете ввиду, мой первый день после ядерной войны? А нет ни какого плана на этот счет, но если выживу, то буду восстанавливать свой дом и свою страну. А вообще, в России одной из самых популярных послевоенных песен является песня с названием "Хотят ли Русские войны?" Вот вам текста этой песни: "Хотят ли русские войны? Спросите вы у тишины над ширью пашен и полей и у берез и тополей. Спросите вы у тех солдат, что под березами лежат, и пусть вам скажут их сыны, хотят ли русские войны. Не только за свою страну солдаты гибли в ту войну, а чтобы люди всей земли спокойно видеть сны могли. Под шелест листьев и афиш ты спишь, Нью-Йорк, ты спишь, Париж. Пусть вам ответят ваши сны, хотят ли русские войны. Да, мы умеем воевать, но не хотим, чтобы опять солдаты падали в бою на землю грустную свою. Спросите вы у матерей, спросите у жены моей, и вы тогда понять должны, хотят ли русские войны." Суть в том, что Россия много раз побеждала в войнах когда на нее нападали, и Французы, и Немцы, и Турки, и Поляки и еще пол европы, но каждый раз Россия помнила, что победа давалась огромными жертвами, и именно по этому мы лучше всех умеем две вещи - Дружить и Воевать, но выбор по какому пути строить отношения с Россией делаем не мы, так что я искренне надеюсь, что те кто это все спровоцировал, в итоге выберут дружить, а не воевать.
Well said
I think your analysis of the landmass and history of warfare is interesting andvimportant
MY RESPECT MR MCGOVERN 👌👌👌👌👌
why we ought to stop shitting on our old people. they know us better than we do.
Hubris ripening nicely.
This posturing by Macron is an effort to make France’s presence felt in Eastern Europe. Last 2023, a French think tank stated that the center of gravity in Europe has shifted to Eastern Europe: to Poland and the Baltic states, to those nearest to Ukraine. Hence, the sudden and weird turn-around of Macron who, until recently, was proud of his friendship with Putin and was eager not to humiliate Russia. Unfortunately, France doesn’t have the capacity to decisively influence the situation in Eastern Europe. Worse, he’s endangering France, a country many of us deeply love. Please, Macron, be realistic. Wake up!
Macron is acting tough to cover the humiliation France is going through, been thrown out of African countries who filled French coffers.
I like Ray and Nima. I am from Sweden and I can say that NATO has NO democratic right to be in our country, because the corrupt government never asked the Swedish people. Worryingly, however, not many did enough to oppose this dictatorial decision. But it looks like this in parts of Europe also, that the majority have become obedient to the villains in power. Many are afraid, cowardly, indoctrinated... etc. Unfortunately, those qualities are of no value when it comes to defending freedom, integrity, democracy..and so on.
Best interviewer ever! Nima ❤
What do you mean? They repeat the same delusional nonsense day after day.
@@YawehthedragondogofELleave
Putin hides in a bunker pooping himself like a coward while hundreds of thousands die for his ego. Why don't you go join them?@@rainhazelton3068
@@YawehthedragondogofELReal Name Is HAROLD 😳,, 👀🤠🇨🇦
Putin's slaves die for nothing.@@johngibson4834
I always love it when Ray calls Putin Poutine.
Poo tine
It is actually the correct pronunciation .or Puteen!
@@stanandollie7041 Yes, but poutine.
Pure madness. 😢
no more tigers. maybe no more horses. definitely no more little chocolate donuts with pink sprinkles. sure we wanna go there?
dangerous times...
you have no idea how dangerous.
Hello from Brazil! Thank you!
Thanks for this great content Mr Ray Magovern 1:11 1:13
Thanks
Thank you
No more banker wars!!!
5000 years ago Ramses III complained his Babylonian bankers cramped his military style in the Levant with their financing demands. think your comment will stop that?
RY McGovern, voice wisdom coming from the West
Most, if not ALL of that $60bbwill go to paying outstanding Accounts Receivables that Lockheed ($24b) Raytheon ($17b) etc are holding, BETCHA!
ask who owns their stock.
Thank you Ray.
Great video. Thanks
Macron, who can't fix the mess at home, now wants to be the savior of Europe: what a clown!
Like the way Ray pronounces Putin's name, Poutine (in the "french" manner).
"the pouter," in French. perfect.
Thanks for what you're doing, telling the truth.
All these Americans coming out getting air sign of it’s not rolling anymore
It's a conflict between Europeans.
Excellent, Ray!☺
I would be a lot more confident in the whole situation if Russia and China would kick out their Central Banks.
As long as the central bank of a country is controlled by that county, everything is fine.
@@djape1977 When the banks lend money without ursury (interest), then thongs will be as they should.Their economies will skyrocket just like Germany's did from 1933 to 1937. - the real cause of the Jewish WWII against Germany.
Why does McGovern, Ritter, Macgregor, Davis and Johnson, all professionals in their fields all say much the same thing while the people we have in charge are utter ......... Insert preferred word due to U tude censorship.
Imagine this point of view, from the creators perspective. Imagine everything is so stupid that you can't stop it. So that we can see clear now.
read Kafka.
All of them Excellent interviews. How can I buy a coffee ? Thank you
Challenger II got challenged Leopard II got hunted Abrams got tanked All these NATO "game changers" are now rusting in peace on the Ukrainian steppe.
And they're all trying to pretend they never called them game changers in the first place, and that losses were always reasonably expected and so forth. It's so tiresome talking to pro-UA cheerleaders. Always moving the goalposts.
@@Someone-hd2vu Heard that too. Comments like "Tank did its job, crew survived"
$60 billion is 4 USS Gerald R Ford Aircraft Carriers.
Physiology of Plunder When Plunder Becomes A Way Of Life For A Group Of Men In A Society, Over The Course Of Time They Create For Themselves A Legal System That Authorizes It And A Moral Code That Glorifies It Fre'de'ric Basiat
Ukraine is missing more than 8 million people but you still push 100.000 casualties number.
He actually said 480k plus that are dead, casualties are of course much higher in number. And then there are those that are misSiNg, the Immigrants. Those who exiled themselves. About 10 million plus.
12 million Russians.
@@ShamanKish 🤡
@@ShamanKish Dear Lord.
@@ShamanKish Did Cokelensky share his gud sheit with you?
Speaking of rhetoric and public opinions. A very curious phenomena, people don't trust the word of media and politicians that we all know and acknowledge.. EXCEPT for some reason when they talk about foreign policy and other countries, then it is taken as gospel.
Since when?
❤❤
👌Ray.
"Do Americans still support this kind of ... " That after stating that we didn't even know what they were doing? How can we 'still support' something we didn't know about in the first place? I'd like to believe, that had we known what this bunch of criminals were doing... we'd never have supported even one of them.
King 👑 JESUS is Coming. God Bless you Nima and Ray
try adjusting your meds, before you something silly.
@@egay86292 before....what?
Date,time?
@@user-bh9eq6wy9w read the Bible. The season is here. No one knows the date nor hour
Macroon ain't sending military troops...he was misunderstood....he is sending a theatrical troupe to rehearse "The Tin Soldiers". He was himself a failed serie C amateur actor in his college and in fact ended up marrying his acting teacher, who turns out to be a man...How about that for a coup de théatre?...France is en-tranced...but not, like Queen Victoria, amused...One for Jollywood...
surely you meant to say "Follywood"?
@@egay86292 depends on how you get your jollies...
Thank you for this super explanation. Personally, I am astonished about the foreign policy of my government (Italy). As if they are blindfolded…
Thank you! Understanding the mechanics of stepping into war makes us better citizens making informed decisions. Chilling consequences of “let’s see what happens if…” History doesn’t just happen, news carry many faces.
Ray Mcgovern always make sense of what's really happening in Ukraine, Russia, western Europe and USA. Very good analysis of the current war bet Russia and Ukraine.
Our arrogance and ignorance strengthened and accelerated the formation of BRICS.
Something for younger people to be aware of in this discussion too. About 20 years ago Neo Con think tanks were convinced MAD no longer applies and were publishing papers about how they thought the then new ABM systems meant the US could win a strategic nuclear exchange. Alot of the people in power now come out of that same group of people.
100%, Ivy League Morons of Mass Destruction.
U bedoelt het zijn gewoon gekken. Niet meer en niet minder
Clear to most of us but not to most of americans....
Greetings From Finland 🇫🇮
I have no idea who to believe 😢
Putin may be the Lion as per Christopher Walking's lion story on KZhead. Food for thought
just raise taxes $
Wouldn't it be relatively easy to use the high risks of a nuclear exchange as a pretext to begin very officially instructing peace negotiations? An excellent use of nuclear deterrence where no one should lose face.
According to NATO's charter a country at war can't become a NATO member and we/NATO wants to move into Ukraine a country at war and what NATO moves in and if Russia should attack Ukraine then what wilĺ NATO declare an article 4 and now a war between NATO and America and Russia would exists.
Not a good time for France's Macron to be threatening Russia with the 2024 Olympics in Paris coming up soon.
👍🏽🇦🇺
Alternate Universe? Yeah, these clowns are delusional.
@@YawehthedragondogofEL I dont see Byeden or Cokelensky in the Vid.
Truth is hard to take dragonater
Putin can't even defend his elites in Moscow. He doesn't care though. He is hiding in his bunker having his diapers changed. LOL.@@deadpoolguy283
@@YawehthedragondogofEL Reeeee harder, VirginNazi! Hitlensky is done, and you know it!
God bless you guys 💓
great
Avangard 33,000 kph +
The British are sending troops hundreds are being deployed ordered to travel to embarkation in civilian clothing this week .
Go Putin.
Zeus! One loves his sense of how easily supplies and people get from France to the Ukraine, constantly, day after day, for months or years, non-stop. Or does Macron mean France will use nuclear weapons and nothing else? France can deliver those pretty easily.
Number one song in Ukraine is The End by the Door's
Notable in the Vote in Russia, the Votes did not come in 4 Weeks late.
Ray is so likeable that even in his inimitable reenactments he projects this likeability on even the most unlikeable characters.
Red lines means nothing, just a phrase...
Np xog can win a lion😊
NATO has been seeing the signs of russias defeats,But still playing the dirty cards
CIA analyst without a clue on Russian nuclear doctrine? Well. what's new?
Really? Can you clarify what it is?
Morning S. Hard to understand ice when you live in a desert. Regards England
Over simplification by ray.has been out of touch for a long time
Russian nuclear doctrine is defensive. It’s in their constitution.
@@soniavadnjal7553 Sure I can and so can you if you know how to use google search.
bismillah,salam.ALL being having right in hear & speak.BUT "SINCERE WORD'"from true viewing giving reward .
Amir Weitmann in an unhinged rant said Israel will supply weapons to Ukraine that will hurt Russia, will they supply Zelensky a nuke ?
i will also point out that these terrorist have been threatening the lives of 115 million people with nuclear weapons and threats. how would you feel after being treated that way for decades? it is inexcusable to treat them that way.
🙏👌👍💯
What is this?
I’ll take “Fantasies & Fables” for $200, Alex.
Its disturbing to hear a former CIA Analist pronounce Putins name like some Canadian fries dish.... come on.... be better... its not that hard !!!
are austin et al delusional or just reckless?