Putin risks losing the initiative as US aid brings end to Ukraine shell rationing | Scott Lucas
2024 ж. 24 Сәу.
74 270 Рет қаралды
"The window for the Russians is whether they can mount an offensive before the aid gets there."
Putin is now on the clock to make gains in Ukraine but will already be facing increased defence from Ukraine as they ease ammunition rationing ahead of US aid arrival, says Prof. Scott Lucas.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Commentary from Scott Lucas is always worth listening to. Thank you Times Radio for bringing these voices to KZhead with sensible, measured interviews.
Slava Ukraini! 💙💛
HEYROJIV SVALKA
It's emtpy words.
@@dkrawk8309and
Marjorie 'Traitor' Greene
Not "Moscow Mike" anymore. Now he has cracked and is simping for the MIC.
Imagine being like you and somehow thinking not giving money to another country makes you a traitor 😂,if anything those American politicians who gave American taxpayers money to another country are the traitors
I prefer Marjorie ‘treasonous’ Greene personally
A vile character
Moscow Marjory 😂🤣 What a great nickname 😂
There are no winners in this conflict. But Ukraine has no choice than to prevail and survive somehow to live free and in peace.
Russia didn't win in Afghanistan which was a smaller and less sophisticated and well armed adversary. It takes overwhelming strength to occupy and subdue a country and Russia simply does not have an overwhelming advantage.
Did America win in Afghanistan?😂
@@donatta1857 idk but I do know america will win this
@@donatta1857 That was not the question though.
Please explain how when America have lost most credibility around the world, most of the world are dumping the dollar and wanting to join BRICS, they are sooo much in debt and cant even produce enough shells to even nearly compete with Russia? @InfinityHS
America with a coalition with UK Austraila and others can't even beat the Houthis😂😂😂😂 The Houthis😂😂😂😂
THEY will never break Ukraine's will, it's their country! 🤔
Ukraine knows what it is like to live under them.
Crimea belongs to its people, not Ukraine
@@user-yi8rt5zq9e We all know that the USSR was *PERFECT* ... Pravda told us this all the time. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
@@user-yi8rt5zq9e The USSR was going to lead the world revolution -- what happened to the world revolution, botski? Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
@@user-yi8rt5zq9e Then Crimea belongs to the Tatars...
Russian can spin any view on this war but no one can deny the war has been a disaster for russia and ukraine
Everybody can actually
_Russia is now one twentieth of one percent larger than it was in 2022, and all it cost them is half a million lives, and the respect of most of the world._ 😨 - j q t -
yeah that's what happens when you get the Americans involved and their lapdog Europeans, they have 3 decade track record of disaster
@@quill444 actually most of the world simply doesnt care about the war and continues normal relations with Russia. the only country that matters is China in the end.
@@quill444 By adding 4 new regions Russia got more population and territory than before the war not to mention millions of Ukranian refugees fled to Russia, Russia also secured landbridge to Crimea so its not vulnerable anymore
Slava Ukrainia 🇺🇦 ❤!
Heyrojiv svalka!!
But are not the russians worried about jewish space lasers?
The Jewish weather machine is more scary
If putler said he wants SuperJoe you can be sure he wants his lapdog donald. Never ever believe what putler says.
Oh yea. Why would he a fear a dude who has shown nothing but submission and admiration. A dude who is famously swayed by flattery. I’m constantly surprised by how useful idiots can actually be.
@@olorin4317 Me too, unless they're ruZZian and then they're no use what so ever.
@@olorin4317He's been instrumental in getting the aid to Ukraine, pointing out again and again to Maga nuts that it was a bipartisan effort. He's far better than the useless idiot Donald Jenius Trump who would acquiesce to every single "peace" demand Putin would make, such a spineless jellyfish.
destroys the Democrat narrative doesn't it that Putin would rather have Biden in the WH than Trump. know why ??? because he's more predictable, this war would have never happened under Trump.
@@olorin4317 why cant you people talk like normal adults? saying 'putler' all the time makes you sound like a child.
Russia lost quite a few conflicts. And not just Afghanistan.
But they beat the Germans in WWII.
@@michaelmaguire9330only with the help of Lend-Lease program where the West gave Russia massive amounts of equipment
@@michaelmaguire9330 That was a fight for actual survival. So they went all out. They lost millions of people and they still would have failed if it wasn't for the allies. So that's not exactly russian-only victory. But they did lose various smaller conflicts, like the Winter War.
@@michaelmaguire9330Only with American aid.
@@kardahaspindal In WWII the Russians stopped one of the biggest fighting machines of the twentieth century. If Russia has not won on the Eastern Front it would have been very difficult for the British and the Americans to defeat the nazis. The Brits and the Yanks suffered KIA of less than 500,000 each. The Russians losses, well they were in the millions and millions. If you did not study WWII I would recommend some reading. Max Hastings is a recommended source. All the best.
Margie the Manchurian Candidate 😂
Oh god lets hope not
At least the Ukrainians are making good use of USA and NATO weapons given to them unlike the South Vietnamese and Afghans who just gave it all to their enemies and ran away, Ukrainians stood up and fight and 2 years later still fighting hard standing strong vs. continued Russian attacks with a ferocity not seen since WW2 Eastern Front.
I know right. We should be going into Afghanistan right now and getting our $12B of equipment back, ukraine actually needs it. I wish biden wasnt so incompetent and pathetic
Putin speaks = Putin lies Incredible this still needs explaining.
KZhead friend here. I don't know who is going to win. It is my hope that Ukraine wins and gets all of their country back.
Ukraine will win. Its Russia against the civilized world, barbarians against elegance and eloquence
It Wasa given Russia would lose the initiative when the aid flowed. Putin likely never expected it to be so quickly
Viva Ukraine ❤ Viva Ukraine ❤
This man knows so much🎉Obvious Ukraine will win against Russia and in the comings months they wont be begging for another aid.And they'll not loose their territories as they have been gaining some and even gaining Russia territory. I think by July Kiev will capture Moscow 😂great analysis as always
Not according to Dmitry Kuleba who states No [aid] package can stop the Russians,” he said in an interview with the British publication The Guardian, commenting on the US aid package.
What War has Russia ever one Afghanistan I seem to remember they got their Arses Roasted like what’s going happen in Ukraine 🇺🇦 in a moment
Why would Putin a fear a dude who has shown nothing but submission and admiration? A dude who is famously swayed by flattery. I’m constantly surprised by how useful idiots can actually be.
It's really interesting to look at how news media affects different people, because the different sides of the story are always vastly different and yet everyone thinks they are the objective truth. We live in the information age where we have gotten acustomed to fast verifiable information being readily available, however, that has led to our own hubris in thinking the information can't be suppressed or altered when in reality, a lot of the information we get about both the Ukraine war and the Gaza war are indeed biased one way or another.
I bet you Margie Traitor Red is having Russian lessons!
🎉❤ Slava Ukraine ❤🎉
Bless Ukraine!
Putin has burnt himself and it could end up in a conflagration. Pride cometh befall a fall - and Putin will never let this go.
They feel they must corrupt any possibility of an culture that can be compared to it from succeeding in their determination and coarse which exposes this inability.
Hoy no estoy 100% seguro con las propuestas de xochitl, pero si estoy 100% seguro de que no quiero lo que propone la candidata de enfrente para Mexico. No quiero un país gobernado por una sola opinión, que mienta, que se burle de los mexicanos, que lucre con las ayudas sociales, que no se haga responsable de lo que sucede en Mexico!. Viva la democracia! Vota tu y tu familia!
Times Radio, please can you fix the sound. I've noticed on a few recent videos that this host is always a notch quieter than his guests.
'' Crying Wolf''. ?? Who on Earth would think Ukraine were doing this. Obvious to Everyone that the US aid was vital.
ATCAMS were already there earlier this month hitting Crimea.
Let's come back to this video in a couple of months 😂
Meanwhile, in other, more important reality-based news: *Poland could deport Ukrainians for conscription* *_Defence minister says country will intervene if necessary to support Kyiv as it struggles with dwindling numbers of soldiers_* But hey, the ‘aid’ is on its way, so no panic. 😂
From 1 January 2024, the maximum age of conscription will change from 27 to 30 years old. Russian authorities have also passed laws allowing for the draft notice to be serviced to the conscripts online, preventing conscripts from leaving the country once the notice is registered and sent.
@@stream2watch • Reznikov June '22: _"Million-man Army!"_ • Zaluzhny Oct '24: _"We need an extra 400-500K men"_ • Media everywhere, since: _"Ukraine fronts are collapsing; severe manpower shortage; conscription age lowered to 25"_ What could it all possibly mean??? 🤭 *_#UkraineIsSTILLWinning_**_!_*
Dear T Radio. You need a banner on every screen to tell everyone WHO + Title & WHERE & WHEN & WHY anyone should listen. I still don't know who the bearded guy is.
this guy does realize we can search lucas on ukraine and watch him consistently be wrong for 2 years right?
i watched this last night, how is this 1hr old news.
Looking forward to Ukraine joining NATO and EU and I would be very surprised if not Belarus also want to join EU and NATO after that.
Putin better back off.
And what aid, when Ukraine has almost no manpower anymore? And are you aware how big are Russian stockpiles of weapons and how much they can produce? We saw how aid helps, helps in a way till the last Ukrainian. And someone would need to be jailed for crimea made by Ukrainine, both against Ukrainians and and against Russian civilians .
It's maybe more important to be in a better negotiating position reality speaking wise
I liked the slip we the russians then what the russians where doing.
"Putin Loosing ". Again lol😂 nehere do they find those idiots to spread BS
Lotsa wishful thinking for a lost cause.
Losing the initiative? 😂
Yeah good old Scot!
Times Radio is to reality in Ukraine as Star Wars is to astronomy
Russia has the body bags
How is he is losing? Though
Russia lwas defeated in afganistan 1979-88 and soviet union was more powerful. And way way more people
Yeah, they should have won in 3 days Remember Stop the bull😂. Reverse psychology doesn't work on me putin
The operation was actually ending in little more than 3 days as peace negotiation was drafted until Boris and the US racked it. So now Russia is essentially fighting NATO and that takes a long time.
@adsfwef1331 No, Russia isn't fighting NATO so shut up. Putin is also the one who can't stick to agreements, nobody else.
@@yehldyehld Its disgusting how US led NATO is feeding those corrupt Ukrainian politicians with billions of taxpayer money to destroy a whole generation of Ukrainian men instead of using that power to push for a peace settlement.
@@yehldyehld Tell that to the US, French, German troops in Ukraine and all the billions USD worth of weapons given to Ukraine instead of leverage our power to influence peace. US and NATO are warmonger, always have been and always will.
I, mostly, like Times Radio videos, but one thing I'm not a huge fan of is when we get a new upload, and it's just a clip from a previous upload. I get the point is valid, maybe to bring attention to a point that was deeper into a video than the first 20 minutes, but maybe emphasize this with a link to the full video? It just feels like recycling videos for the sake of uploading more videos.
Great reply! I fully agree. This was not released in the last few hours. It's reboxed from a prior release. It was good news, then. If they could have used it and added to it would have been worthy. I also agree that it still has value. By shortening the message may be the value as more people might watch. Your as sharp as a tack. I like your kind.
If only USA per owned Military hardware provided 10% what Poland* provided this war will already and and Russians will go back to their Country. *(30% Poland military equipment was transferred to Ukraine)
🔱💙💛✌
TDS ? I think this one has no clue
It occurred to me that Putin is like that gambler that initially thought he would go in big and win quickly, and get out a winner. But now he's chasing his money, doubling down and hitting the "ATM" into the wee hours of the morning. We all know how this goes.
But what choice does Putin have? He has no choice but to double down, because if Russia has to retreat with their tail between their legs, there's a high likelihood a disgraced Putin "accidentally" falls out of a 12 story window.
surprising someone with a grey beard like me isn't old enough to say let's backtrack this bufferzone nonsense and keep away from the bear
Russia has a very long history of loosing wars. Ukraine will just add to that history.
Russian troops are in Ukraine, Ukrainian troops should follow the Prigohzin trail to Moscow. The King is dead god save the Queen.
Times has become the most ludicrous outfit out there. Do they do it on purpose? I mean, it's more ridiculous than the "Deutsche Wochenschau" in April 1945.
What a ridiculous statement. Are you implying you live in something akin to natsee germany too? Then why don't you just leave?
Moscow Marge
Started off interesting then ended up like a monty python sketch.
34000 civilians killedin Gaza😥
This thread is about Ukraine!
And half of Israel is Russian.
Please indicate in the title, this is a Repeat.
so what ? ..so good we saw it twice !
lolololololol before the ‘aid’ gets there. 😂
The aid is already in Poland and it's now going over the border. lololololololololol
The political system in UK is rotten 😂😂😂😂
...
Tories yes!!!
Every person in the free world has to keep up the pressure on our elected officials and vote for pro-Ukrainian candidates. If we hold firm and continue to invest on our military factories Putin can't win.
Putin absolutely wants Trump in the election!
Stopped watching when you started talking us politics.
😂
🙏🙏🌎🌍 Is Hause 🇪🇺🇺🇸 NATO+🇺🇦 🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️🛡️💪💪💪🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
More nonsense, the aid run out and then what, Zelensky the lapdog will be begging, then slagging off to get even more aid😅
Yes he's desperate to protect his country. How about ruzzia invades their near peer instead, say USA instead of picking on the small guy? No? I didn't think so.
Days behind as usual. Sleepy old Times 🥱
I see you have the old Obama lackey back.
LOL.. What tv series are you watching...??? remember... russia marched the french back to paris.. and the wermcht back to berlin... we started this war.. and they are going to finish it GARANTEED!!!
The Napoleon war was well over 200 years ago and would not have been able to reach Berlin in 45 without Allied support. They will lose this war in the long term GARANTEED
And Russia folded to Germany in ww1, and also fell for the most elaborate Intelligence plot, when Lenin was brought back to St Petersburg in a sealed carriage with his pockets full of German gold, to change Russia forever and cause untold millions of Russian losses.
@Arnold_Slater1223 Russia.. in ALL its wars.. 87% were fought on its own soil.. ie ..they were attacked... and in EVERY case they enemy was driven back .. swedes. poles. germans , french .germans again In this case.. USA /UK /NATO in 2014 put banderites in power in Kiev.. just for this purpose!!! THe USA WANTS this war.. dont be fooled by the media narrative. THIS is the true nature of human evil.. when powers use war and killling for thier own purpose.. CURSE the Victoria NUdelmans and the Kagans ( her husband) and the rest of ther reptiles ARE YOU UNDERSTANDING ????
Russia would have lost to Germany if it were not for Allied aid, arms, and assistance. The allies cut Germanies supplies in Africa, and opened multiple fronts. This time its not Russia getting allied aid. Its Ukraine getting allied aid and Russia is losing badly and Putin is a complete failure.
"Russia losing" meanwhile ukrainan units retreating as we speak
Haha watch the video first troll
Some desperate comments on here 🤣🇷🇺🇬🇧
Says the frogposter contrarian. Hardly anybody has that opinion where you pretend to live. Get back to 4chn
But ... but ... but Russia was going to win in just three days! Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
@@boink800 Thanks for confirming my above comment
@@davidjones-wt2qqFrom the ruzzian trolls, yes.
Putin trapped by his misguided beliefs, no way out. It'll continue to be a war of attrition and will consume the Russian economy. Demographics are shocking, the war hasn't helped in that respect either. How many more years has Putin got? The kremlin will fold once he's gone and there's no one like him to take his place, they are all just UIs. 👋🇷🇺
Either russia stops attackking or russia will be attacked.
They lose initiativ. 200+61 bilion dollar later and Ukraina lossing. Thwy have no solders to fight
Zoom out on the map. If they have no soldiers, how come Russia has been stuck within walking distance of their starting point for 2 years?
Mr.. It is not a matter of initiative any more! Ukraine is on severe defeat level!! It must be done a huge mistake from Vladimir, to lose this battle which ehters at finale in a won position!!😁 So,that means you're a liar..
You need to pay more attention, with US military aid, $100bn worth of additional military aid forthcoming from NATO countries, this will drag on for years, it's the end of the RF
@@WeejimmySnazberry No WR can't be won with billions.. And the most decisive characteristic of a Super Power is she adapts in new data and prepares the answer and improve immediately the weapon!! Ukraine, has some possibilities but certainly NOT Russia's.. See the fact with fortresses: They immediately improved and produce Fab 1500 and 3000!! There's no Fortress can hold such a hit.. We see it lately happens in Ukraine! You're young.. Right? Have a nice time,
@@petrosmpampalis6097 Russia's fate was sealed before the invasion of Ukraine, look at it's demographics, even more skewed by the losses to both war and those escaping into other countries. Irrespective of whatever they do with their fab glide bombs they are done. Sanctions will continue to hinder the economy long term, just like the Luna 25 "success" they overestimate their abilities.
@@petrosmpampalis6097 Russia thinks it's a shovel, but it's only a spoon
@@WeejimmySnazberry Well, only time will show.. But there are many military analyst like S. Ritter who says that Russia has won! Probably he means if it wasn't West, Ukraine would be past..
Repeated interview and repeating content. Yawn.
We could draw pictures instead.
I'm hearing that Ukrainian units are starting to abandon their positions and flee in the Avdeevka area. If other units start doing the same, it's over.
It's actually comical the timing of this...the Ukr front is collapsing as he speaks. this latest american money is for golden parachutes not munitions. the leadership is about to jump ship....
@@apokatastasian2831 Other rumours coming in that Ukrainian officials have been ordered to stay in Kharkov or be sent to the front as infantry. It all sounds very 1945.
Fiction, wishful thinking
All packages working against Europe citizens and them own economic
Internet for Indians was a mistake.
Is the BJP going to win again? Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
As Russian Troops Broke Through Ukrainian Lines, Panicky Ukrainian Commanders Had No Choice But To Deploy One Of Their Least-Prepared Brigades The situation in and around Ocheretyne is desperate for Ukraine.😂
Ok botski
That little appendix of a push will soon get smothered though. Russia is still bogged down, by definition.
Your heroes have moved 14 km forward in the last two years. 7 km a year. What heroes! Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
@@Kodakcompactdisc Look it up it's the truth.
@@boota1979 The "truth" ... from the Internet Research Agency? That could be hard to find. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
We will wait for end of the hear to see what this guy will brag again..
Russia decides when it ends. Sadly
Yes and no. The hope is they can be brought to a place where they cannot afford to continue their war and will be forced to retreat.
🤣
Maybe they will hear of evil tidings on their (far) Eastern front...
Get rid of Putin and the war ends today. The Russian people have that ability
These are the same Americans that said the American trained Afghan military was more than a match for the Taliban. The army folded within a week. Why should we trust an American to tell us what is going on in Ukraine. What happened to that great Ukrainian counter offensive? What happened to tea in Crimea in two weeks?
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💪
As usual all talk
Why do we speculate with videos like this when in reality NATO has no capacity to deliver such mass production of shells like Russia??
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💪💪✌️
I'm here to find out what the Russian bots, who DON'T ACTUALLY SUPPORT the UNELECTED PUTINS WAR think and a bit of comedy from them. 😂😂😂
they think?
Comedy is good. And predictability. Like theyre all reading from the same script. Orwellian par extremis
@@stream2watch They always write the same thing, don't they?
@stevenmartin8828 No opinion about the devastation being wrought on Ukraine or the slaughter of human beings.. Lets just talk nonsense in the most asinine puerile fashion. Which does nothing whatsoever to help the people of Ukraine.
@@boink800 Indeed. I wish Jim Browning or some other scambaiter would expose their "callcenters". These people literally do this for a living, and it is obvious they do not earn a lot. Would be so interesting to learn about them.
Russia Russia 🇷🇺 🇷🇺 💪💪
Ukraine never had initiative. Even Prigozhin ranted in anger that Russia pulled out of the north and the east, without a fight. I am not pro-Russian. But I hate lies and that is what you are telling.
oh russia has always told the truth of course
Prigozhin lost 20k in Bakhmut ... Prigozhin said that himself.
@@boink800 Oh so you agree that Prigozhin was the only honest Russian?
@@boink800 Losing 20,000 does mean Ukraine had the initiative. Ukraine has lost 75% of their troops and that is not a win.
@@ragingmonk6080 We could say that Prigozhin was the only "sane" Russian. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
Ukraine needs to end its occupation of ukranian land
India needs to end its occupation of Kashmiri land, Nagaland, Galwan valley.
@@rmdomainer9042 that’s true it should make a settlement your right
@@dilonkumar4960 Please stop using Hinglish. Express yourself as if you have received an education.
@@rmdomainer9042 will do
Russia wanting to invade Europe is like me wanting to invading the Insane Asylum.....🤠
@mcrick8931 no it's like the insane asylum wanting to invade Europe...
No, they really do. They repeatedly say this on their RT propaganda TV channel. And the presenters on that channel never say anything without getting the OK from putin first, or else they will have the "window trip".
Yet people are dying to get into Europe. Russians are freezing trying to cross the Finnish border, and Africans drown in the med.
Putin: We will not invade ukraine.
@mcrick8931 no it’s like the insane asylum wanting to invade Europe…
Russia decides when it ends , rightfully so.
If that was the case it would have ended 2 years ago they are not going through this for a laugh.
@@kethughes8266 the Russians wanted to end it when your clown prime minster Boris when to Ukraine and told Zelinsky not to make peace , to keep fighting , because that’s what their masters in washing what’s him to say , and that the west would back him all the way.
The Russian people need to decide when they will have the guts to rise up against the Cowardly war criminal UNELECTED Putin and remove him from power. Then the war will end and the Russian people will be free of his dictatorship.
How is 3 days SMO going?
@@Blanka1100😴😴😴😴
The ukriane had initiative in what??????
BRAINWASHING 101
It's amazing watching you guys lie to your audience every day
Despite the first hundred or so billion, and help of 50+ countries including NATO, Ukraine still managed to lose 20% of their land to Russia.
It was initially way more
@@Amradar123 now, it’s going the other way around and Russia is gaining more territory. All could have been avoided by abiding by the Minsk agreements and being neutral 😔
@sunnyboner676 all they gained in 2 years is 20 km while losing the black sea and the crimean harbours. They evacuated the remnants of thir sorry "fleet" back to Moscow. Russia is losing this strategic battle which will define the winner.