Putin in limbo as 'reckless' military casualties cause unrest with Russian elites | Michael Binyon

2024 ж. 20 Мам.
241 614 Рет қаралды

"They have a very poor record for saving lives on the frontline. They throw in wave after wave... The elite youth have either fled or their hoping that military recruitment won't pick them up because that would cause upset in influential places."
Michael Binyon analyses Putin's conscription dilemma: as he continues to lose soldiers on the frontline but struggles to recruit younger troops without causing upset with Russian elites.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...

Пікірлер
  • It’s not victory unless Ukraine recovers ALL of their territory back to the 1991 borders.

    @longandshort6639@longandshort663920 күн бұрын
    • Ditto.

      @muricans4ukraine@muricans4ukraine16 күн бұрын
  • The Ukrainians do not need to ‘push’ Russian forces out of Crimea they just need to make their situation there untenable. If the Russian airforce can no longer over-fly the Crimea without fear of being shot down and if the Russian navy cannot sail near the Crimea without fear of being sunk then the remaining Russian land forces will no longer be able to rely upon re-supply and will eventually withdraw.

    @joe2mercs@joe2mercs20 күн бұрын
    • 😂

      @londanintshangase@londanintshangase20 күн бұрын
    • Nice dream, but most Russian forces are re-supplied by the land bridge now, not via Crimea.

      @CountDuckEgg@CountDuckEgg20 күн бұрын
    • ​@CountDuckEgg false, the land bridge isn't the main route which is why Russia is desperate to protect the bridge.

      @garethhhhh@garethhhhh20 күн бұрын
    • MARIUPOL MAY ALSO NOT BE DOING SO WELL FOR PUTIN EITHER, IF THERE IS MUCH MONEY LAUNDERING GOING ON BETWEEN HIS GENERALS.

      @NefetariMoonRay@NefetariMoonRay20 күн бұрын
    • That copium is so strong 😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅

      @RuslanVaslov@RuslanVaslov20 күн бұрын
  • Crimea is Ukraine.

    @user-yb6eo1xp2f@user-yb6eo1xp2f20 күн бұрын
    • Ukraine is Blackrock's. It has nothing.

      @ConnorJane@ConnorJane20 күн бұрын
    • No it's not

      @goonerboz6023@goonerboz602320 күн бұрын
    • @@goonerboz6023 You mean Crimea is Turkish/Tartanic? What a beautiful guy you are. Crimea has always been Turkish with a Tartar population. So good of you to recognice this. Peace!

      @musicmaker1617@musicmaker161720 күн бұрын
    • @@musicmaker1617 not anymore

      @goonerboz6023@goonerboz602320 күн бұрын
    • @@goonerboz6023 No now they are Ukraine. And before they were Tartar Turkia. They had a middle periode of being Russian. That was the worse periode that no one want to relive.

      @musicmaker1617@musicmaker161720 күн бұрын
  • Dear Russians, Get rid of Putin and save your lives, your economy, your relevance. He is your road block to the decent future.

    @tabithan2978@tabithan297820 күн бұрын
    • So trur, a pitty the Russian don't look it up on internet. Ukraina is a demokrati. The hole world hates this war. Russia do not need more land. Putin is a terrorist.

      @user-qi8kc8jk1l@user-qi8kc8jk1l20 күн бұрын
    • You poor deluded fool.

      @johnseabrook1703@johnseabrook170320 күн бұрын
    • Go study history. Russia was a mess under Yeltsin. Putin has revives the economy and allowed Russians to again be proud. That's why he has the highest approval rating of any politician in the world. Stop looking at him from the US propaganda viewpoint and instead examine Russian history.

      @michaelwilson9921@michaelwilson992120 күн бұрын
    • Bloody imperialists teach us.. ironic

      @user-ho6ng1gw4x@user-ho6ng1gw4x20 күн бұрын
    • Didn't know that fantasy Island was on again. Look boss The plane The plane

      @AntonioRomero-te4cb@AntonioRomero-te4cb20 күн бұрын
  • That's like saying historically India has always been British.... come on

    @simonphelps3680@simonphelps368020 күн бұрын
    • Note also how he said it's only belonged to Ukraine since 1953. Doesn't matter a whit. Israel is only five years older than that. The real point is of course that in the modern era respect for borders is non-negotiable. Actually I bet that _was_ a veiled shot at Israel. Found the tankie!

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
    • India was never british.

      @celestineoc1123@celestineoc112316 күн бұрын
    • @@celestineoc1123 India was owned by Britain from 1757 to 1947.

      @Blaidd7542@Blaidd754214 күн бұрын
    • @@celestineoc1123 was British ruled

      @yamudda364@yamudda36410 күн бұрын
    • How come we split it in half then if we wasn't in control?

      @yamudda364@yamudda36410 күн бұрын
  • Crimea history. 1800; 92% Tatar 6% Russian, 1945 0% Tatar. 1991, 57% of Crimean residents vote to join an independent Ukraine.

    @stephenhill545@stephenhill54520 күн бұрын
    • The usa and their puppet countries can do nothing about crimea. Fkn cowards 😂

      @jamesgreen1116@jamesgreen111620 күн бұрын
    • Yeah in 1991 what about more recently eh ... according to the 2001 Ukrainian population census, 58.3% of the population of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea are ethnic Russians, 24.3% are ethnic Ukrainians and 12% are Crimean Tatars. Polling in 2008 by the Ukrainian Centre for Economic and Political Studies, also called the Razumkov Centre, found that a majority of Crimeans approved the idea of joining Russia (63.8%) neither the world nor Crimea are stuck in 1800 nor 1991 Note thats ONLY Crimea the rest of the Ukraine did not wish to join Russia

      @steve.k4735@steve.k473520 күн бұрын
    • @@steve.k4735 There is no ethnic difference between Ukrainians or Russians, or Germans or Poles. Their wish to identify as Ukrainians is based on language, traditions and mentalities. You are invoking racist (Russian, actually) arguments.

      @jens1450@jens145020 күн бұрын
    • And were bitterly disappointed afterwards.

      @dalecrocker3213@dalecrocker321320 күн бұрын
    • @@steve.k4735 Figures presented by the russia government.

      @ghostlightx9005@ghostlightx900520 күн бұрын
  • Listen to Churchill's advice. We have had all these years of continuous problems with instability and dictators in Russia because we did not heed Churchill's advice at the end of WW2 . Let's not make the same strategical error again please.

    @ChristopheSmith@ChristopheSmith20 күн бұрын
    • Explain more. Sounds interesting.

      @encryptedemail8272@encryptedemail827220 күн бұрын
    • You've seen too many movies, man. UK and USA are not democracies. Churchill was a war criminal. You are delusional, like 90% of all the people.

      @corradoroeper7092@corradoroeper709218 күн бұрын
  • A North Korean missile has hit Ukraine, so how can Moscow complain about western missiles being used by Ukraine?

    @tabithan2978@tabithan297820 күн бұрын
    • Because he wants his cake & to eat it. Anything that doesn't result in a "W" for Russia results in him being a b***h about it.

      @RocketPropelledWombat@RocketPropelledWombat20 күн бұрын
    • ...and Iranian shaheed drones.

      @muricans4ukraine@muricans4ukraine20 күн бұрын
    • As long as Ukraine strikes inside Russia, Russia has valid claims to defense and can escalate accordingly. Ukraine is just the stage for Europe vs Russia....a warmup match so to speak.

      @TheSkaffen@TheSkaffen20 күн бұрын
    • ​@RocketPropelledWombat the original version of that saying is "you can't eat your cake and have it too". Wish people would go back to using the version that actually makes sense

      @magnumxlpi@magnumxlpi20 күн бұрын
    • North Korean missiles are Russian

      @Patrick-el8zs@Patrick-el8zs20 күн бұрын
  • the level of understanding of history and particularly crimea among western commentators is frightening how easily they can be manipulated by russian propaganda. there is no excuse for annexing part of another country, so what if it belong to russia for a period of time during which they commited a genocide of crimean tatars? should uk give back london to italians? internationally recognised borders of countries should be respected and that's it, russia has no legitimate excuse to do so

    @testing52009@testing5200920 күн бұрын
    • No Russia does not have the right to take by force but its not so simple as your example suggests 58% of Londoners do not self identify as roman do they ... according to the 2001 Ukrainian population census, 58.3% of the population of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea are ethnic Russians, 24.3% are ethnic Ukrainians and 12% are Crimean Tatars. Polling in 2008 by the Ukrainian Centre for Economic and Political Studies, also called the Razumkov Centre, found that a majority of Crimeans approved the idea of joining Russia (63.8%) Note thats ONLY Crimea the rest of the Ukraine did not wish to join Russia

      @steve.k4735@steve.k473520 күн бұрын
    • not sure about the italians, but OK

      @16252@1625220 күн бұрын
    • @@steve.k4735 interesting, but when it comes to national sovereignty it isn't local democracy that determines who can separate and join other countries, or the map of Europe would be very different

      @16252@1625220 күн бұрын
    • @@steve.k4735 in this poll the same people express willingness to be part of ukraine, the answers were contradicting each other but you didn't mention for some reason. why is that Steve? the reason there were so many ethnic russians and not crimean tatars in crimea is because they commited a genocide and decreased their percentage from 90+ to single digit percentages, well done for trying to give such practices validity. In the end it was a land grab of an independent country by force.

      @testing52009@testing5200920 күн бұрын
    • @@testing52009 Yes they did but you ignore my comment on 58% of Londoners not identifying as Roman don`t you? Which you don`t address for some reason, why is that 520? I don`t give validity I am well aware of Stalins destruction of ethic groups in Crimea, but acknowledging present facts is not giving validity is it, it happened and the make up of the Crimea now is what it is, same as England's is after 43 and the Romans and 1066 Normans they are historical FACTS ,,, what are you advocating cleansing Russians from Crimea to bring it back to pre WW2 However I agree it WAS 100% a land crab by current Russia they had no right they are wrong in their actions without any reservation, their actions in the Ukraine paint both Russian Leaders and Putin as war criminals.

      @steve.k4735@steve.k473520 күн бұрын
  • 'Crimea has always been Russian'! What nonsense! A quick look at the history books will reveal phenomena like the Tatars and the Ottoman Empire. Saying that Crimea has always been Russia is about as sensible as saying that Scotland has always been Irish.

    @nigelhaywood9753@nigelhaywood975320 күн бұрын
  • Russia should be given its original lands.. which includes all of the Grand Principality of Moscow around 1462 CE. Everything beyond that is what Russia stole from others.

    @TarisSinclair@TarisSinclair20 күн бұрын
    • For first: China want their land back. A lot of Sibiria are actually chineese.

      @musicmaker1617@musicmaker161720 күн бұрын
    • Yeah China will be taking their land back and they won’t even need their weak military to accomplish it.

      @ZootyZoFo@ZootyZoFo20 күн бұрын
    • Reality check, Russia is going to take what it wants in Ukraine and there is nothing you nor Ukraine or nato can do to stop them!

      @MrThartofwar@MrThartofwar20 күн бұрын
    • @@musicmaker1617 If you look at that land via satellite, Russia is doing nothing with it. While China is growing on every square inch on 'their' side

      @multipl3@multipl320 күн бұрын
    • @@multipl3 give it to china!

      @powervr@powervr20 күн бұрын
  • There is the 1994 treaty that recognized the borders of Ukraine, including Crimea. This cannot be ignored, 1954 or not. Things change all the time. Koenigsburg was German for centuries. When will Germany get it back?

    @normm1619@normm161920 күн бұрын
    • Koenigsburg needs to be part of negotiations/reparations.

      @anthonyhulse1248@anthonyhulse124820 күн бұрын
    • Crimea was annexed in 2014. Welcome to the party, you're right on time

      @wenterinfaer1656@wenterinfaer165620 күн бұрын
    • When are you signing up?

      @stockdale829@stockdale82920 күн бұрын
    • The 1994 treaty was on nuclear nonproliferation. i assume you are talking about the treaty on Friendship, Cooperation, and Partnership between Ukraine and the Russian Federation was an agreement between Ukraine and Russia, signed in 1997, effective in 2000. This treaty was renewed every 10 years, however, because Russia assisted the people of Donbas and Lughansk in fighting an illegitimate regime in Kyv from 2014 . Ukraine announced its intention not to renew the treaty in September 2018The treaty consequently expired on 31 March 2019. Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko signed a decree not to extend the treaty.on 3rd December 2018. On December 6 the Ukrainian parliament declared the Treaty to be terminated starting from April 1, 2019.[21]. The borders between Russia and Ukraine had never formally been agreed and it was Ukraine who unilaterally marked out the borders.

      @georgesibley7152@georgesibley715220 күн бұрын
    • The UN Charter and Russia regonized Ukrainia's borders in sovereignty in 1991. If Russia can't respect that, then it is time for Russia to step down from the UN Security Council.

      @badluck5647@badluck564720 күн бұрын
  • Kalingrad once belonged to Germany, parts of historic Finland are occupied by Russia as is parts of historic China and I could go on. Russia needs to be careful in applying its warped logic as others might do the same.

    @johnstringer5359@johnstringer535920 күн бұрын
  • BS. Ukraine will get Crimea. And there was NO understanding that Russia had rights to Ukraine; there was a clear agreement signed. This guy will have to eat his words.

    @MidnightWarrior1976@MidnightWarrior197620 күн бұрын
    • Ukraine will get crimea? What's yours basis for that exactly?

      @SgtAndrewM@SgtAndrewM20 күн бұрын
    • Crimea is russian.

      @jamesgreen1116@jamesgreen111620 күн бұрын
    • @@jamesgreen1116 Like Moscow is Mongolian.

      @physically3027@physically302720 күн бұрын
    • @@jamesgreen1116 ....and everything going according to plan🤣

      @Jacob-Sa@Jacob-Sa20 күн бұрын
    • @@SgtAndrewM Take the illegal bridge out

      @GeorgeGreene931@GeorgeGreene93120 күн бұрын
  • Imo not to retake crimea would be appeasement. Who is this person...

    @TonyHobbs@TonyHobbs20 күн бұрын
    • I asked myself the same question. Also about other things this man said…..

      @a3muller52@a3muller5220 күн бұрын
    • A tankie, of course. The antecedent of today's American students.

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • Ukraine should get Crimea back.

    @peterclarke3020@peterclarke302020 күн бұрын
    • Ukraine should be restored to its 1918 borders.

      @dragonade85@dragonade8517 күн бұрын
  • What people choose to forget is that in 41,435 BC it was all owned by Neanderthals. Return it to the rightful owners!

    @randomgrinn@randomgrinn20 күн бұрын
    • Most land is currently owned and run by Neanderthals who were voted into power by their Neanderthal followers who are still mining for wax crayons as there main source of food. 😂

      @dkgambituk@dkgambituk17 күн бұрын
    • It’s still owned by Neanderthals

      @jld593@jld59316 күн бұрын
    • @@JN-xb6pq Brilliant. I am part neanderthal myself and don't forget about the compensation.

      @user-ez4qv3rp4g@user-ez4qv3rp4g13 күн бұрын
  • Crimea voted in 1991 in a free and fair election to be In Ukraine. This is not a war over territory it is a russia’s war to exterminate Ukraine. This man like so many cold warriors have such a difficult time understanding this. Ukraine will not abandon its people to extermination.

    @barrygropp759@barrygropp75920 күн бұрын
    • I agree 100%.

      @a3muller52@a3muller5220 күн бұрын
    • The statement "Crimea voted in 1991 in a free and fair election to be in Ukraine" misrepresents the actual circumstances of the 1991 referendum. The 1991 referendum in Crimea was about restoring the Crimean Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic within the Ukrainian SSR, not explicitly about choosing to be part of Ukraine as opposed to another state like Russia. At the time of the referendum, both Crimea and Ukraine were still parts of the Soviet Union. The overwhelming support in the referendum was for the restoration of autonomy within the structure of the Ukrainian SSR. In 1992, after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Crimea did declare independence briefly. The 1992 Declaration of Independence by Crimea was influenced by several complex and interrelated factors: Political and Nationalistic Aspirations: Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, there was a surge of nationalism and regionalism across the former Soviet states, including Ukraine and Crimea. Many ethnic Russians in Crimea felt a strong cultural and historical alignment with Russia rather than Ukraine. The declaration can be seen as an expression of these local nationalist aspirations aiming to assert greater autonomy or even merge with Russia. Ethnic Composition: Crimea had a majority of ethnic Russians who were potentially uneasy with the new Ukrainian government's policies and the prospect of Ukrainian nationalism. This demographic was instrumental in pushing for policies that would secure greater autonomy or a closer relationship with Russia. Economic Uncertainties: The early 1990s were a period of significant economic upheaval. The breakdown of the Soviet economic system led to instability and uncertainty. Regions like Crimea, which were heavily dependent on industries tied to the wider Soviet economy, faced particular challenges. There was a belief that a more autonomous or independent status might allow Crimea to navigate these challenges more effectively. Legal and Constitutional Dynamics: The Ukrainian government was in the process of forming its own identity and constitutional framework, which included defining the status of Crimea within Ukraine. The 1992 declaration was partly a response to these dynamics, as Crimea sought to assert its position and negotiate from a point of strength. Reaction to Ukrainian Policies: The initial moves by the Ukrainian government to impose its control and integrate Crimea into its administrative and legal systems were met with resistance by many in Crimea. The declaration was a pushback against what was seen as encroachment on local autonomy. Ultimately, the declaration was short-lived. The Crimean parliament rescinded the declaration later in 1992 following negotiations with Kiev, which led to Crimea being recognized as the Autonomous Republic of Crimea within Ukraine under a new Ukrainian constitution. This status provided Crimea with a degree of self-governance, although the tensions and complex issues around Crimea's status persisted until the 2014 crisis.

      @fritzvonrichthofen6568@fritzvonrichthofen656820 күн бұрын
  • he implied that the war is somehow not full scale and that Crimea is russian historically, very incompetent

    @povilaskimutis1409@povilaskimutis140920 күн бұрын
    • He is correct

      @Durnyful@Durnyful20 күн бұрын
  • What limbo? This is so not true. Russian elite simply does not care about the pile of casualties of the ordinary serfs. They just don not. You guys need to understand this.

    @nikolaiv386@nikolaiv38620 күн бұрын
  • Ukraine will secure their borders including Crimea.

    @Discus1948@Discus194820 күн бұрын
    • They have secured them. Russia control them, securely.

      @greggrimer354@greggrimer35418 күн бұрын
    • Dont be absurd. In what fantasy world are you living in. Its over

      @user-kn3de9li1u@user-kn3de9li1u15 күн бұрын
    • @@user-kn3de9li1u I’m not going to be rude so I’ll just say you’re confused, misinformed and out of touch with reality.

      @Discus1948@Discus194815 күн бұрын
  • Mr Binyon needs to brush up on his history of Crimea.

    @milesnixon9554@milesnixon955420 күн бұрын
    • He does. I would point to 3 facts; 1. In 1800 92% of Crimea residents were Tatars, then byi 1944 after some good old fashioned colonisation was 25%, in 1945, after some ethnic cleansing it was 0%.

      @stephenhill545@stephenhill54520 күн бұрын
  • By the same logic, Slovakia should be part of Austria and present day Hungary

    @patrickdolinski7105@patrickdolinski710520 күн бұрын
  • Crimea is Ukraine agreed

    @marymilner7304@marymilner730420 күн бұрын
    • Since when?

      @IliyaOsnovikov@IliyaOsnovikov17 күн бұрын
  • This whole war is *about* Crimea. It's mind-boggling that any supposed expert could believe that allowing Russia to retain Crimea wouldn't end in disaster for Ukraine, and eventually the region as a whole. But leaving all that aside, it's utterly preposterous to act as though Crimea is some sort of impregnable fortress. It's extremely vulnerable. As another commenter stated, if Ukraine has the military assets to sink Russian ships, shoot down Russian planes, target Russian ground assets with long-range precision munitions, and prevent resupply to the Russian army in Crimea, as will soon be the case, how, exactly, is Russia going to hold it permanently? 😵‍💫

    @michaelramsey3643@michaelramsey364320 күн бұрын
  • Meat grinder about to be turned into a food processor!

    @maggotman2024@maggotman202420 күн бұрын
  • Crimea was Ukrainian and Tatar until the Russians invaded the region at the end of the 18th century. They brought a lot of russian colonialists and established serfdom immediately.

    @FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA@FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA20 күн бұрын
    • Tak jest!

      @patrickdolinski7105@patrickdolinski710520 күн бұрын
    • And Jewish

      @patrickdolinski7105@patrickdolinski710520 күн бұрын
    • Being Irish this reminds me of my own history

      @josephfisher2100@josephfisher210020 күн бұрын
    • @@patrickdolinski7105 That's right.

      @FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA@FR-PL-UA-WARSZAWA20 күн бұрын
  • The THREAT that Ukraine can retake Crimea is the leverage required for Ukraine to win a beneficial peace outcome

    @mrharry448@mrharry44820 күн бұрын
    • But it is not a threat. It is a fantasy.

      @dalecrocker3213@dalecrocker321320 күн бұрын
    • ​@@dalecrocker3213 Said the 🤡 🐓 Sxkx

      @stevo091@stevo09120 күн бұрын
    • Very funny, yanks won in Vietnam as well

      @user-tt6il2up4o@user-tt6il2up4o20 күн бұрын
    • I think it's better to leave Crimea alone and just focus on Eastern Ukraine. 2016 and 2019 surveys showed that Ukrainians in Donbas preferred a Ukraine state. I suspect that since the invasion the number has increased

      @giftedtheos@giftedtheos20 күн бұрын
    • @@giftedtheos Surveys in Ukraine make US election polls look reliable. Very many civilians have fled the war zone, perhaps the majority to Russia. The new population will depend upon who wins.

      @dalecrocker3213@dalecrocker321320 күн бұрын
  • The west had to decide does it want Ukraine to win….

    @ianransome855@ianransome85520 күн бұрын
    • does the West decide for Ukraine?

      @costadorada2842@costadorada284220 күн бұрын
    • @@costadorada2842 hopefully not, but if the West is going to support Ukraine, it should stop coming up with reasons why not to….

      @ianransome855@ianransome85520 күн бұрын
  • It seems that is always the poor and the minorities who end up on the front lines.

    @JosephJohn-fb9wx@JosephJohn-fb9wx20 күн бұрын
    • In WW1 British noblemen and other elite died in the trenches, presumably because they considered it noble, and it would be "over by Christmas."

      @Longtack55@Longtack5520 күн бұрын
    • @@Longtack55 Class envy is so very repellent.

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • why is volume so low.... cant hear this.

    @rustynutsnboltz@rustynutsnboltz20 күн бұрын
  • The issue is not when the war will stop or that if Ukraine recapture their land the problem is when this phase of battle stops with Russia what will the Free world do with Russia will they go back as business as usual even if Russian troops are still in Ukraine that's what Putin's is counting on but if the Russian knows that they can't get back into the free world market then that will be a big problem for Putin

    @gl1941@gl194120 күн бұрын
  • The audio is way too low. You've posted multiple videos like this recently. It's frankly an embarrassment at this point.

    @sharkboi7555@sharkboi755520 күн бұрын
    • Try turning up your volume?

      @MendicantBias1@MendicantBias120 күн бұрын
    • @@MendicantBias1 I've just arrived from watching BBC, CNN and DW - needed only half volume. Here at Times Radio full volume - still hard to hear everything. TR is always like this, low volume, bad microphones, scratch-scratch sound... Idk. It has become their trademark 🙃

      @oneshothunter9877@oneshothunter987720 күн бұрын
    • ​@@oneshothunter9877 I have it half volume and I hear it well.

      @fenrirgg@fenrirgg20 күн бұрын
    • Got to agree with you. I have the volume maxed and can't really hear it.

      @heffo67@heffo6720 күн бұрын
    • Hmmm🤔...Radio advertisers backsliding to their old tricks of pumping up the volume for ads. Yep, de-evolvement is embarrassingly shameful. Hilarious!

      @davebauman4991@davebauman499120 күн бұрын
  • When military experts speak about unexpected success on the side of the Ukranians (surprise), I always doubt a bit their expertise. Were they with those experts who predicted Ukraine's collaps within two weeks? Does this also go for him?

    @afishcalledwanda@afishcalledwanda20 күн бұрын
  • A repeat of Mr Chamberlain, you showed this yesterday.

    @paulyoung4422@paulyoung442220 күн бұрын
  • Essential in these interviews where sweeping historical judgements are made to ask for references; underscores the very Russo-centric version popular in the post WW2 era.

    @patrickdolinski7105@patrickdolinski710520 күн бұрын
  • Times Radio, why is your audio always so low? You need to sort it out, it's so frustrating having to crank up the volume to hear any dialogue.

    @neekBG3@neekBG320 күн бұрын
  • Krim must be taken back.

    @user-qi8kc8jk1l@user-qi8kc8jk1l20 күн бұрын
    • Already got that back, ten years ago.

      @ConnorJane@ConnorJane20 күн бұрын
  • I definitely believe in the multi verse now. Where are these guys coming from?

    @willhall4037@willhall403720 күн бұрын
  • The problem with dictatorships ios that they are not answerable to their people.

    @jimmeer@jimmeer13 күн бұрын
  • Why all Times Radio videos are so quiet?

    @artursstradins607@artursstradins60720 күн бұрын
  • How long can the 'west'put up with these threats?

    @nicolaswheeler3738@nicolaswheeler373820 күн бұрын
    • How long the world will put up with the nato threat to the entire world

      @user-uf6zd6ng6t@user-uf6zd6ng6t20 күн бұрын
    • the west is a joke diddnt you know this

      @frankrenda2519@frankrenda251919 күн бұрын
  • Michael Binyon shines as an expert in military affairs, and James delivers a scorching interview bring viewers in the UK and around the world and across the channel from you up-to-date. Early in the interview Mr Binyon sheds doubt on the Ukrainians ever getting Crimea back, but here is what I have heard and my disclaimer is that I am an artist and have never served in the military. America's greatest living general---again, in my unschooled opinion---is General (Ret.) Ben Hodges whom has said repeatedly that Ukraine will not survive as a country if the war ends and they don't have Crimea back in the fold. What General Hodges says to back this up is that if Crimea remains in Russia, then the Ukraine will forever be at mercy of the Russian Black Sea fleet and ditto for the coastal cities in the Sea of Azov. President Putin's crown jewel is Crimea and once you know that, even an armchair defense analyst like myself sees the only main objective for the Ukrainians in the war is to do everything in their power to make the Russians flee the stolen land and then see how long the Russian people will support a president who has lost their main prize from the Ukraine 'military exercise'.

    @TEKANNON-bz9fm@TEKANNON-bz9fm20 күн бұрын
    • What Black Sea fleet ? Are they not at the bottom of the Black Sea ?

      @maxcuthbert100@maxcuthbert10020 күн бұрын
  • It also wasn't five minutes ago, historically, that a British - Turkish alliance threw the Russians out of Crimea. Ukraine is much older than Russia and if one had a claim on the other it would be the other way around. If Putin wants to blabber about the return of Historical territories, then he needs to grab all Russians and withdraw to about 100 miles south of Moscow and give it all back to the Swedes. I'm sure he'll love that idea.

    @brand8590@brand859020 күн бұрын
  • It’s absurd to pretend that NATO affiliated support services within Ukraine is unjustified or necessarily escalatory, Russia invaded & it doesn’t get to determine who is allowed within Ukrainian borders. Russia’s war is widely & increasingly recognized as villainous & disastrous, its always possible their autocratic State controlled media foundations could crumble at any time. Those risking & fighting in Ukraine should have a greater voice in the process of negotiation, strategy, and reconstruction policy.

    @boxcutter0@boxcutter020 күн бұрын
    • Nice.

      @RocketPropelledWombat@RocketPropelledWombat20 күн бұрын
    • Мы защищаем свою государство от вас. Как ваше правительство наплеван на международное право, вторгнулось в страны ближнего восток

      @user-yd6ft9ko3o@user-yd6ft9ko3o20 күн бұрын
  • Here is why I believe Michael Binyon is wrong about the potential of Ukraine to gain all territories to 2014 borders. Russia is vunerable to defeat in so many different ways. The collapse of the Russian Federation might not only be military, but could also be economic and political. A political coup for example is ripe and the new leader will gain support domestically and internationally on a platform of trading territory for peace and the recovery from the horrific reign of Putin. The weakness of Russia is multifaceted and collapse will be sudden and may come in many different forms

    @chucknaussie@chucknaussie20 күн бұрын
  • Why can’t they get them out of Crimea. If you were in charge. Yes…it would be impossible.

    @michaelvoisine7075@michaelvoisine707519 күн бұрын
  • The person who writes Times Radio's KZhead thumbnails is clearly posting from another dimension. Actually all YT thumbnails are bad, but Times Radio is particularly embarrassing.

    @anaryl@anaryl20 күн бұрын
    • Not sure what you try to tell us?

      @The1234Franc@The1234Franc20 күн бұрын
    • I thoroughly agree. But it's deliberate of course. One mustn't mistake _shameless cynicism and lack of respect_ for incompetence.

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • Is it just my system ? The volume during these Times Radio Interviews is often far too low - I can hardly hear any of this broadcast. But the Adds come in much louder !! Very irritating !!

    @user-bd7rj3wu7s@user-bd7rj3wu7s20 күн бұрын
  • "Crimea has historically always been part of Russia". Don't invite this guest for another interview until he reads a history book about the Crimea.

    @ThisIsInconceivable@ThisIsInconceivable20 күн бұрын
  • 🇺🇦❤🇺🇦❤🇺🇦❤👍💪🇬🇧

    @gherkamum@gherkamum20 күн бұрын
  • Says a lot about a radio station that can't seem to get audio levels correct.

    @Galerak1@Galerak120 күн бұрын
    • Year after year after year after...

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • Crimea has never been 'always' russian ;) It's a bit overstated...

    @marcingrynberg3641@marcingrynberg364115 күн бұрын
  • An iPad means you do not need people on the ground. A live link can do the same as a person standing beside you.

    @seanbrown701@seanbrown70120 күн бұрын
  • why is the sound so bad? I have my speakers right up/

    @potoo6122@potoo612220 күн бұрын
  • Sound problems yet again. Then an advert comes on and nearly blows the speakers out!

    @matthewcummings9024@matthewcummings902420 күн бұрын
  • He sounds like he has a soft spot for Russia.

    @bauer9101@bauer910120 күн бұрын
  • Крим це Україна!

    @active85858585@active8585858520 күн бұрын
    • Agree!!

      @luminyam6145@luminyam614520 күн бұрын
    • Поплачь, он Русский!

      @user-yd6ft9ko3o@user-yd6ft9ko3o20 күн бұрын
  • I disagree with the idea when Russia invaded Crimea Ukraine was like “meh”. I was on the ground then and you had a military that had been stripped and a country dealing with a lot. Ukraine simply couldn’t deal with it at the time and there was no help from the west

    @saberint@saberint13 күн бұрын
  • Pytin 🇷🇺 Now Kadaf Pytin now Vill loses

    @NEVS-yo2gp@NEVS-yo2gp20 күн бұрын
  • Crimea is so easy to cut off in the future how can Russia even defend it with no bridge and all supply lines in range

    @walterrwrush@walterrwrush20 күн бұрын
  • Neville chamberlain with a dash of Lloyd George

    @napnap5094@napnap509420 күн бұрын
  • Love that you’re keeping this story alive! However, you do a LOT of repeated interviews in “different” videos. I heard this exact thing prior to this video being published…

    @michaelc3416@michaelc341620 күн бұрын
  • If Crimea is part of Russia and just fine for Russia to keep, what does that say about Taiwan?

    @eb8984@eb898420 күн бұрын
  • TR, fix your sound issues. There's a problem in nearly every clip. This time the sound is so faint that one has to set the volume very high. So when ads interrupt with two milliseconds warning, they are mind-shatteringly loud. Enough of this _amateur hour that's lasted years!_ Fix your sound once and for all.

    @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • “Crimea has always been Russian.” Sure it has - and the Iberian peninsula has always been Roman…

    @wilberwhateley7569@wilberwhateley756911 күн бұрын
  • Audio is so low

    @calibfurrytour8124@calibfurrytour812420 күн бұрын
    • Have you had your hearing tested lately..The audio was fine.

      @jeffreyuprichard3754@jeffreyuprichard375420 күн бұрын
  • Lloyd Austin has already said the Ukrainians can do what they like with the Atacms. This guy is already behind the times.

    @lordbiro@lordbiro20 күн бұрын
  • Volunteer specialists or active duty?

    @ronjamski3911@ronjamski391119 күн бұрын
  • #StandWithUkraine!

    @aresivrc1800@aresivrc180019 күн бұрын
  • I'd suggest that you interview the British guy, Alexander Mercouris, that speaks on The Duran and also on his own channel.

    @humanyoda@humanyoda20 күн бұрын
    • Classic shill post. Do you use the same line and insert Ritter, MacGregor randomly?

      @rmdomainer9042@rmdomainer904220 күн бұрын
    • Mercouris the debarred lawyer that got caught forging documents found a new graft

      @rmdomainer9042@rmdomainer904220 күн бұрын
  • The reason Krushchev would have given Crimea to Ukraine and Russia didn’t dispute this in 1991 is most likely because it makes more sense. It’s almost an island and was dependent on Ukraine for fresh water and tourists. Putin had to build the Kerch bridge to try to restore the economy after the annexation because it was dying. A big reason for the size of the Russian population there was the naval base which was leased to Russia.

    @marymarlow3646@marymarlow364620 күн бұрын
  • We've heard this line countless times. Until we witness concrete action its safe to assume theyre still on board and making money over this heinous war.

    @Mr.Canuck@Mr.Canuck19 күн бұрын
  • Michael Binyon - Emotional Damage 😆

    @loppadus@loppadus20 күн бұрын
  • Crimea is Ukraine. The Prince of Darkness has my absolute confidence, and it’s no surprise to me that he has been successful. Binyon is old school, and yeah, he seems to know a lot about putin….not so much about his adversaries. I suppose it’s good to know the enemy. I’m surprised that James Hanson didn’t ask Binyon about Ivanov. More info on the Shoigu/Ivanov debacle please!

    @war-painter@war-painter20 күн бұрын
  • Even within the bounds of one channel we are locked into a journalistic case of ‘chasing the error’; the relentless broadcast of sequential contrary views. Most of the analysts have become obsolescent.

    @RalphBrooker-gn9iv@RalphBrooker-gn9iv19 күн бұрын
  • Would have been nice if you had listed who was who in this interview. However, I noticed the "expert" did not answer the entire question with regards to a Ukraine victory. Point 1 is would the "Western Allies" allow Ukraine to retake the Donbas and Luhansk before a ceasefire was called? The war will not stop until they achieve that and it means betrayal of Ukraine if the West stops supporting them. Secondly, a lot of attacks in Russia, such as Belgorod are coming from clandestine teams in small units with fast vehicles or Russians who are rebelling against Putin and his policies. Finally, the eviction of the Russians from all territory of Ukraine will not end the war. It might result in the cessation of fighting, but that will simply mean the Russians will rebuild for a new attack. Even it Putin is deposed, the people most likely to replace him are just as hawkish. The clock on this cease fire would run to Ukraine joining NATO before the Russians feel strong enough for another go.

    @Bodkin_Ye_Pointy@Bodkin_Ye_Pointy20 күн бұрын
  • Conscription is coming.

    @carolyngarman1422@carolyngarman142220 күн бұрын
  • Ukraine doesn’t need to take Crimea for a tactical victory over the province. If it can demonstrate that maintaining a military presence in the peninsula would be untenable due to lack of reliable supply corridors to garrison meaningful presence to launch any kind of attack, it would be pretty much a bleeding wound in which Russia would have to negotiate terms, continue to burn money it doesn’t have to maintain their positions in Crimea, and it incentivizes Russia coming to the table because it can claim (probably not Putin himself) that they have ‘demilitarized’ some of the contested territories between Moscow and Kyiv. Kyiv needs to be supported at least to the point where it can control key high grounds and junctions that can be fortified to the point where direct attacks would be unproductive, and that all critical supply corridors would be under threat from entrenched Ukrainian outposts that essentially bleed Russian coffers trying to maintain forward support to their positions inside Ukraine.

    @TheGhostOf2020@TheGhostOf202020 күн бұрын
  • ❤Ukrainian ❤

    @Gayzenon@Gayzenon20 күн бұрын
  • Old school Red..

    @paulborg9239@paulborg923920 күн бұрын
  • SLAVA UKRAINI!!!!!!!

    @mitchellculberson9336@mitchellculberson933619 күн бұрын
  • They are daydreaming

    @kimkim-dd4qg@kimkim-dd4qg20 күн бұрын
  • Not wave after wave again. How boring

    @Worldturnedupsidedown@Worldturnedupsidedown20 күн бұрын
    • no, its all airborne drops and helicopter assaults by a mobile army

      @icu17siberia@icu17siberia20 күн бұрын
  • "A pocket full of mumbles, such are promises"

    @craigmiller4528@craigmiller452820 күн бұрын
  • The comedians are back on business. 😂

    @mayhem4899@mayhem489920 күн бұрын
  • Loyd George he reminds me of

    @napnap5094@napnap509420 күн бұрын
  • Sound is very bad. Better for the ads though!

    @harrylyme2913@harrylyme291320 күн бұрын
  • Were their Soviet advisors in Vietnam? Um huum

    @acmelka@acmelka14 күн бұрын
  • Bizarre analysis!

    @samkeino6810@samkeino681019 күн бұрын
  • If you’re going to accept historical borders then China will be having a huge claim on its historic territories

    @AngusAbbott-qf8xm@AngusAbbott-qf8xm20 күн бұрын
  • For a moment there I wondered if the interviewer had fallen asleep.

    @ClaudeInsecte@ClaudeInsecte20 күн бұрын
  • I find it odd how people who are safe and sound make noise about how another nation should accept "victory". I wonder what the guest would say if scotland invaded the north of england again under the pretences that it is in their existential interest to do so, whether he would say ah well london is fine, england is mostly intact so lets just give them the north to keep the peace.

    @pfccalico7676@pfccalico767620 күн бұрын
  • One thing that annoys me is people who say that Ukraine cant push back russia to its borders,people who say that dont win wars.

    @s1nb4d59@s1nb4d5920 күн бұрын
    • If you are so annoyed, why don't you enlist in the Ukrainian army?

      @corradoroeper7092@corradoroeper709218 күн бұрын
    • @@corradoroeper7092 Why has what you said anything to do with what i mentioned about defeatists?.

      @s1nb4d59@s1nb4d5918 күн бұрын
  • volume is way too low on this.

    @tyfawkes@tyfawkes20 күн бұрын
  • The Crimea bit was a total brainfart

    @MultiMenvafan@MultiMenvafan16 күн бұрын
    • To clarify, Crimea is not "historically Russian". It was taken from the Turks in 1774, and the Crimean tatars were subsequently persecuted. Crimea is historically Russian in the same way US is historically British.

      @MultiMenvafan@MultiMenvafan16 күн бұрын
  • France aided Argentina in the Falklands war

    @yorkshirepudd7532@yorkshirepudd753220 күн бұрын
  • Are they paid in Rubles or dollars is the big question ❓

    @jayclarke6671@jayclarke667120 күн бұрын
    • Neither. They don't end up getting their promised money.

      @dixonpinfold2582@dixonpinfold258217 күн бұрын
  • British legacy media spinning so fast it's making me dizzy but the reality is we are losing

    @shauneason5897@shauneason589720 күн бұрын
  • I use to say my wife is always right about things. And she usually are. So now Mr. P. I'd suggest you better run and hide.

    @henrikarboejensen812@henrikarboejensen81220 күн бұрын
KZhead