What is Gnosticism?
This video gives an overview of the so-called "Gnostics", particularly the group that is often otherwise known as the 'Sethians'.
Check out Andrew's channel "Religion for Breakfast": / religionforbreakfast
Support Let's Talk Religion on Patreon: / letstalkreligion
Or through a one-time donation: www.paypal.com/paypalme/letst...
Sources/Suggested Reading:
Brakke, David (2012). "Gnostics: Myth, Ritual, and Diversity in Early Christianity". Harvard University Press.
King, Karen (2003). "What is Gnosticism?". Harvard University Press.
Van den Broek, Roelof (2013). "Gnostic Religion in Antiquity". Cambridge University Press.
Meyer, Marvin (ed.) (2009). "The Nag Hammadi Scriptures: The Revised and Updated Translation of Sacred Gnostic Texts Complete in One Volume ". HarperOne.
#Gnosticism #Christianity #Religion
Check out Andrew's channel "Religion for Breakfast": kzhead.info Support Let's Talk Religion on Patreon: www.patreon.com/letstalkreligion Or through a one-time donation: www.paypal.com/paypalme/letstalkreligion
He's really bias in favour of gnostics for some reason! He is presenting ideas as facts, and imo, twisting reality into his narrative. Dismissing other Christian writers of the time as liars and deceivers is strange.
@@LJ7000 who is doing that? I’ve never seen either of those things happen on this channel or on Let’s Talk Religion. I think you’re taking dispassionate historical analysis as some form of polemic. I would examine why you think this if I were you.
This intro is great! I'm used to seeing academic discussions online about Gnosticism assuming the theory that Gnostics didn't really exist and we need to drop the category altogether. It's good to finally see Brakke's work given the attention it deserves and presented to a popular audience! I take it that you don't follow Turner's theory that the Sethians eventually wandered away from Christianity, becoming more Platonic in the process?
It finally happened!!!
When you say that "religions are internally diverse", there are members of religious groups that will disagree with that. Many Orthodox Jews in Israel don't consider Reform Judaism to be a legitimate form of Judaism. And many Jews don't consider people that blend Christianity with Judaism religiously Jewish.
Gnosticism means to seek God look inward. This takes the preacher out of the equation as the middle man. No wonder the church hates Gnosticism. It's bad for their business model.
Protestants seek God individually a lot of Protestants are gnostics and don’t even know it. I don’t know what sect of Christianity you are referring to when you talk about the Church but if you are talking about Prots then Martin Luther already took out the middle man.
Right. Bad for the business model. Par for the course the church has forgotten that being in touch with the Spirit can't fit into a cerebral style of understanding. This is why Jesus was so upset with the phariseeism of that day. The Spirit of God cannot be catagorized by the human intellect.
555555555555555555555555555555 55
"Bad for business" was mentioned a few times in the movie " The Godfather". Life is very curious !
But apparently the states been effective. Or atleast their propaganda has been. I like that Ukrainian flag bro lol
Finally you managed to do what no one else seems to have been able to do. To explain Gnosticism in a wonderfully coherent narrative. It’s quite an accomplishment, thank you.
Couldn't agree with you more....My Baptist pastor when asked said that the reasons the Gnostics were left out of the mainstream christian faith was because they didn't believe in Jesus Christ as described to christians.....The way christianity was brought in Kenya and explained to us is wanting in many levels..
@@gracemogaka7486 How ironic of your pastor when that period Kenya was still believing in Shamanistic religions.. the Gnostics are an Umbrella group of Jesus, Mani, ZoroAster believers, who had key knowledge that no one else in the physical realm had access to.
@@magnuscritikaleak5045 that's nonsense. They clearly considered the God of the Jews to be evil and the devil as a servant of their Invented God. You can see how the cults have used these ideas as they follow Lucifarinism. "it was good" is a claim from Torah for each thing God created. Gnostics are clearly childish thinkers who arrogantly believe that if they were God they could have done a better job- their simplistic ideas about life feed this. Job "if we take happiness from gods hands should we not also take suffering" Adults don't want to live in a non suffering world of candy floss and cushions. Gnostics are children in the extreme
@@jollyyeholiver1578 Why do you belittle a group of people who have a different ideology to your own? Instead of offering insight or opposing views, you choose instead to belittle and mock; such comments are far more childish than the complex belief system you so easily abhor.
@@WhyOhWhy123 which is where we have to disagree, they are not very complex in there theological concepts. It's a highly simplistic theoretical approach stemming from an arrogant assumption that they could do a better job at creation. They have no support in scripture, which is why they have to ignore it and invent ideas out of thin air. Considering that the gnostics end up supporting the serpent, kinda supports the notion that the Gnostics are an early branch of Luciferianism. They accept christ and the snake- and have probably sown the seeds of the Lucifarin cults that today see Jesus as Lucifer. I see nothing in their theology that deserves to be respected and ridicule they deserve. Adding stupidity to stupidity can add to the complexity doesnt do anything for the search for truth however, actually makes people more lost.
As a Buddhist, I find Christian gnosticism quite similar with our beliefs to some degre. This is really interesting.
The similarity is knowledge
Gnosticism emerged from Buddhism :-)
@@janhavelka5081 so true!
@@janhavelka5081 Confucius is better and wiser, than any false prophet you see whining on television for big bucks.
@@janhavelka5081gnocism came from the early Christians who were murdered by Paul formerly Saul along with Stephen.
I have often heard the term 'Gnostic' thrown around in my adult life, and having been raised Christian, the incredibly little I thought I knew seemed too weird to be understood. Enter a band called Meshuggah, and one of my favourite songs by them is called 'Demiurge'. After hundreds of listens, I recently thought to do a bit of an exploration of what it might be referring to. I'm only sad that I didn't do it sooner. My mind is absolutely blown. Thank you for such coherent content for a true novice like myself to perhaps just begin to try and understand all of this. Truly excellent starting point.
True hermeticism. They are kinda glass half full while gnostics are glass half empty. Not saying it’s bad, I just enjoy learning
There is a sect in Christianity call Gnostic Christianity :)
@@wisdomoftheages8026 it seems that the hermetic, gnostics, and alchemists each claim to be the progenitor of the other. If you believe jung's interpretation alchemy originated in china then traveled throughout the world copulated with other cultures and back and led to hermeticism as well as what is said here then there are the hermetists who claim all occultism stems from them but are only half true but perhaps I don't know the proper hermetic texts to read. I keep hearing a lot of them are corrupted
All hail the mighty Meshuggah 🤘
meshuggah is incredible
Man, Japanese creators really loved Christian mysticism in 90-s. Xenogears (Big one), Final Fantasy 7, Neon Genesis Evangelion...
They used to admire western civilisation before we fell into self destruction and wokism
@@sebozz2046 you mean until it was only about the distruction of others, as it has been since the begining of western civilization?
I love seeing this interaction between East and West in honesty. One of my other favorite examples is the West Östlicher Divan by Faust, inspired by the Persian poet Hafez.
@@ImperatorGrausam "And to Allah belongs the east and the west. So wherever you [might] turn, there is the Face of Allah. Indeed, Allah is all-Encompassing and Knowing." Surah Al Baqarah Verse 115
Other big boys like Megami Tensei series and Eden!. The 80s and 90s Japanese pop culture seems to have some sort of fascination with Gnosticism?
Gnostics: Sophia, can we ascend to the Pleroma to see God? Sophia: You already have a god in your world God in our world: *Yaldabaoth*
The communication from God our creator, and our creation. Demiurge. Jesus/Lucifer
In a way this is akin to the Vedic notion of Maya; it's not that all is illusion, it's that our perception(s) are illusory due to ignorance. The One True Reality or God *is* here and now because there is only God in Reality.
@@333STONE Wrong.
@@profile_01 I wonder if the Wachowski's are aware of Gnosticism? This all seems prime for a twist in a Matrix movie.
21st century gnostic teaching, through memes.
I read the entire old testament in high school and thought to myself "This doesn't make sense. How can this truly be the God that everyone talks about". Since then, I've read the Kybalion and most of the corpus hermeticum looking for answers, but after finding this video, things are actually starting to make sense. I've ordered a translation of the nag hammadi yesterday and can't wait to learn more. I feel like a huge hole is starting to get filled and my questions are finally starting to get answered. Thank you for making this video, and I thank the all for taking me down this amazing journey.
Humans can’t tell you about God
@@skrillawarlock Neither can god apparently.
@@skrillawarlock So then you think that Jesus wasn't human?
here we go the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;..............................................,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
@@divestedhappyblackwoman3465 The force of living and what constitutes it is self-evident. God wouldn't need to tell anyone nor would be obligated to. I'm an Agnostic btw.
For a long time I've tried to understand what is gnosticism and handled it poorly because all the explanations I've read were too complicated and vague. Your video is full and eye opening, thank you for such an amazing work!
Sabbath is no longer for us to keep, otherwise we would ruin the 6th commandments, which says: DO NOT KILL! Matthew 5:21 Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment: it is the sabbath or the 6th commandment. Cant have both. Souls, know and understand the bible as we all should: 2 Timothy 2:15 Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth. The 2 most important commandments for us to keep TODAY are: Matthew 22:37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. Matthew 22:39 “And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.”
Great video as usual! Looking forward to future collabs.
Thank you for appearing in the video and for your expertise! And likewise! :)
nice
Its wonderfull you Both together
OMG I love the content both of you guys create This is amazing!
Ditto! Some of the best learning channels around
The Sethian breakdown of reality is SO similar to Hindu Vedanta. Even assigning the male gender to characterize the "Ultimate Oneness" and the female gender to "the Ultimate Original Thought", which in Sanskrit is called Brahman, or Purusha (male) and Prakriti (female), or God and Goddess. It is all within the Ultimate One and never (really) separate. I'm so grateful you took the time to teach us this... thank you. It's the best overview of Gnosticism I've ever seen so far.😍
Seth=Annointing
Bad comparison, the Vedic deities will be relegated as divinities sprung from The Abyss much of how Greco-Roman deities and Hindu Pantheon are often attributed by early Hindus as born from the bowels of Abyss or the primordial waters of Tehom, whereas Sethian texts akin to "On The Origin of The World" considers these Pagan worship of Primordial Abyss/Tehom as false Even the concept of Brahman comes after centuries if not millennias of development, on top of Buddhist rivals of the pivotal battles between concept of Hindu eternal Atman/Jivas and Buddhist Anatman/Shunyata in India, some of The Sethians and General Valentinian Theology also considers the concept of Psyche/Self as belong to second category of Yaldabaoth/Demiurge/Craftsman's belonging, akin to how Christian and Jews are belonging to repentant Sabaoth and his Retinues (resembling of Eternal Buddha of Lotus Sutra in terms of achieving enlightenment by countless Kalpas before creation of The World after he found Prajna and achieve Enlightenment in remote metaphysical realms or as Adi Buddha with his consort White Tara, much like Sabaoth gained Sophia's own daughter "Zoe" for accompanying Sabaoth to helps his missions to gather the "Psychics" so they can saved and became "Pneumatics") The Pneumatikois is considered to be superior to Psikhikoi/Psychics (belongings to Temples, Synagogues and Churches) and Hylics/Materialists (Pagans and Atheists, as even Platonists like Plotinus happens to criticise the Christian Sethians and Valentinians too), if anything the three categories resembles more of Islamic distinction of Mu'min/Believers, Ahl Kitabi/People of The Book and Kuffars/disbelievers/polytheists
Europeans and indians have Aryan origin. Thus we have huge similarities in religion and culture, more than we would like to admit. Just compare Greek and early vedic gods.
@@ohamatchhams I disagree. The similarities are too obvious to deny. I wasn't talking about "original Hinduism". I specifically said "Vedanta", which includes a variety of post-Buddhist schools of deeper self-inquiry with the pursuit of an experiential understanding of "god", the "self", and "existence" and our relationship with "existence", along with "what's required to exit the cycle of samsara". They have framed the much older ideas of gods and goddesses in this way to create a vocabulary for more esoteric ideas.
@@myfuture3453 So true! I am not a scholar but have spent thousands of hours studying and reading "Hindu" literature. Millions of hours still wouldn't make a dent in the subject. But I was amazed at how familiar their stories are and how relatable the characters are too. It isn't so "exotic" or "unapproachable" as one would think. Our cultures are much closer linked than we are taught to believe. The cultural "divorce" between India and the West became finalized when Great Britain ruled them for a hundred years.
I thank you for taking the time to go thru and explaining the rough draft of how Gnosticism works and applied in both the physical and meta, keep up the good work breh, greeting from New Caledonia btw
I used to help out at a local funeral home after I got out of the military and I went to an Egyptian Gnostic funeral service and at first I was really aware that I was the only white person, but they offered me food, took my phone number, talked to me after the service, wanted me to attend their church, and were overall the nicest human beings I've met to this day. While I'm a Christian and didn't end up attending, their kindness has lasted in my heart ever since. Mad respect for explaining their religion better than any other video I've found! Human cultures and religions are so interesting to learn about, especially hidden gems like gnosticism!
Modern Gnostics in Egypt? Are you sure you aren't confusing gnostics with the coptics or Copts (they are the biggest Christian group in Egypt and are largely brown)?
@@diansc7322 yeah, they were Johannites or something like that, they weren't Coptics. Johannites have a few churches in the Northeastern United States and at the church I did the service at, they were all Egyptian, however I believe one man was Libyan. I guess North Africa largely being Islamic maybe led to an increase in emigration for Christian communities but I'm also just a dude with very little understanding of the religious goings-on in North Africa so take what I say with a grain of salt 🤣
@@definitelynotfbi119 interesting, I haven't heard of this group before of of christians in Egypt besides the mainstream sects (orthodoxies, Catholics and protestants), maybe I should look on them
@@diansc7322 Gnostic christians were decimated by mainstream orthodox christianity; therefore, they had to go occult for survival.
here we go the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;
Your videos have been a big factor in me realizing how passionate I am about religious anthropology, and now its something I'm looking into for my major!
Congrats
I'm a little late buuuuuuut DO IIIIIT!
Best of luck in finding a job after 🙏
@@luizmatthew1019 education is not always about finding a job.
@@davidstone5595 If it isn't good luck paying rent
I'm so glad you and Andrew collaborated. You two are among my favorite channels on the platform. Great content as always
this is so fascinating!! thanks for taking the time to properly set the stage, beautiful video
This is probably the best in-depth video on this topic on the whole platform. Thank you!
The hard work and effort you put into this
Gnosticism is represented tpday with a new name, "Freemasonry", "G" they recruit members from unitarians, rotary club. lions club, YMCA, boys scouts, etc. they rule the world, the UN their headquarters..... they are before everybody, but no one sees them!!!!
Again I thank you so much Brother. Your research and explanations are extremely beneficial and helpful to me as confirmation of what I've been getting intuitively. Namaste
This may be my favorite episode yet. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us!
Thank you for being so positive but also intellectually responsible. Definitely a like and subscribe! I wish conversations like these were more mainstream. Not to claim someone as right or wrong, but to truly see history and how it effects every era. Well done!
He was actually very irresponsible by claiming a consensus when there is not one in order to present his view as the only viable one on early christian history.
@@nisibonum7634 his consensus is his own conclusion. It does not stand as a finality. I didn't even see it that way. Like I said. I like how he tried to site his sources, named the era, and did HIS best to explain what he's researched. Doesn't have to be perfect. That's why I said I respect the effort. Please tell me your response though (not being sarcastic at all), like what sources should be checked out or read to dispute his?
@@theDAVIScomplex No that's fine, I'm not trying to be sarcastic or mean in my decent either! What I mean specifically is at 28:00 he states that the idea there was 1 church and people broke away in heresies has long been abandoned by scholars. This is simply not true, plenty of biblical and historical scholars still hold this view. He is eather gate keeping scholar to not include these experts, and doing so without being transparent of such, or simple lyings. In both cases he is presenting his view as a consensus in a deceptive manor.
@@nisibonum7634 I think I see what you mean
@@nisibonum7634 I think most scholars who maintain that position are not only scholars of religion, but scholars who are religious and want to maintain that narrative because it suits there interests, in other words, they are compromised. In every video on the history of religion, there are going to be people belonging to some mainstream religion saying "No this guy is wrong because actually, my religion invented everything and only hack scholars disagree." Not all scholars are equal, not everyone gets a say. That said, I'm not an expert on the subject and there may very well be actual talented scholars and experts that are *not* partial in the matter, but if so, you should state a few of their names and their points so as to start a discussion rather than just say "Nuh uh not true, nope."
What an amazing video, you have finally made the Gnostics make sense to me. Extremely intriguing. Thank you so, so much.
I have been looking for these teachings all my life...thank you for opening my eyes after my eye has been opened. 🙏
Excellent video and explanation. Look forward to learning more from your channel.
Such a fantastic episode. So interesting, wow it’s complicated, really intriguing. Thanks, great job.
Great collab! That was interesting, thank you !
I'm so grateful for this knowledge and explenation you shared... it helps my journey a lot!
here we go the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;..............................................,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
You did an amazing job explaining the basic points of this in a really coherent way, very complicated ideas, but you clarified them so nicely. Great job’
I have awoken! Thank you. I watched this several times this year
I've seen multiple comments from seemingly devout Christians, complaining about the thumbnail image of Judas kissing Jesus... as the gospels LITERALLY state. 🙃
It's an internet photoshop that doesn't exist on the walls of any church.
Yeah, I seriously doubt that THAT among all this garbage is what Christian’s have the largest issue with
@@universalconquest4447 Even though it’s very much stated to be true? Get your facts straight.
@@paulrance5445 The picture was photoshopped to appear as if they are kissing on the lips. Learn your Bible Paul and then act as if you know what you're talking about...
One of the most interesting videos you've done so far! Extremely interesting to see how the different perspective on Christianity have come and gone throughout history. Thank you for your hard work!
Gnosticism is represented tpday with a new name, "Freemasonry", "G" they recruit members from unitarians, rotary club. lions club, YMCA, boys scouts, etc. they rule the world, the UN their headquarters..... they are before everybody, but no one sees them!!!!
@@davido3026 I bet a lot of ignorant people call you crazy. Just know that educated people agree with you.
@@davido3026 in Reality Freemasons are Orthodox Christians, who hijacked the movement, because they rejected Mandaenism and Manichaeism, the are not actual Gnostics.
@@demonlord8398 aww nice man. Who are they?
@@ColossalPenisMcgee Who are who?
Didn't even realize 40 minutes had passed by, very well put together video !
This video gave me about 5 great trivia team names. Thank you so much.
I've been listening to this for a few minutes waiting on it to start before I realized it premieres in 14 hours 😶
😆
😂
here we go the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;..............................................,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Thank you for the lucid introduction to the "Gnostics" of early Christianity and their religious thoughts!
You are either missing the hidden agenda behind the entire message, or else in full agreement with it.
Thia is one of my favorite channels on KZhead I have just subscribed to Richard's channel , also. With the deepest appreciation and admiration for your wisdom .❤🙏🎶🕊
Dude no matter the topic, your videos give me this sense of calmness, idk if it's the music in the background but I love your channel.
This actually just blew my mind! I found so many things about the modern Christian faith to be confusing or contradictory and this video has been a true education. Thank you
Yes also beware of false teachers Who call their channel word2believe.
It's good for be weary, but if you check the channel a bit more you can decide weather or not it is propaganda/adoctrination. I've decided that it's not Christian propaganda, but to each their own.
Check out Elaine Pagels, Hans Jonas, and Carl Jung. They all have works on Gnosticism that many Neo-Gnostics are influenced by.
@@AbandonedVoid Theosophist Madam Blavatsky had interesting takes, but her massive influence unfortunately influenced tyrannical dictators and questionable people.
@@gweenpoole3545 No such thing as Christian Propaganda.
Top tier content. This is the kind of information that makes both hardcore orthodoxies and skeptics rethink everything they know about religion
Ephesians 9 (What does “he ascended” mean except that he also descended to the lower, earthly regions[c]? 10 He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens, in order to fill the whole universe.) 11 So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, 12 to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up 13 until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. Research The Shrud Of Turin proof of The Living and resurrected Christ, Let those who have eyes to see and ears to hear discern the eternal truth of Christ!!! Give no room to false doctrines of devils and satanic belief systems DO NOT BE FOOLED by WARLOCKS AND WITCHES !!!! Praise The Living Christ pray to download the Holy Spirit of YAHWEH, to accept and cleansed by the blood and covering of Christ, and to become one with The Heavenly Father : YAHWEH EL ELYON ELOHIM EL SHADDAI with Holy Ghost Baptism, seek deliverance renounce the kingdom of Satan and repent from all known and generational sin!!!! In the name of YESHUA HAMASHIACH ADONAI , THE HOLY ETERNAL CHRIST (The Anointed One)!!!
Very enlightening. Thank you for taking the time to to explain this complex subject.
Ephesians 9 (What does “he ascended” mean except that he also descended to the lower, earthly regions[c]? 10 He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens, in order to fill the whole universe.) 11 So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, 12 to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up 13 until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. Research The Shrud Of Turin proof of The Living and resurrected Christ, Let those who have eyes to see and ears to hear discern the eternal truth of Christ!!! Give no room to false doctrines of devils and satanic belief systems DO NOT BE FOOLED by WARLOCKS AND WITCHES !!!! Praise The Living Christ pray to download the Holy Spirit of YAHWEH, to accept and cleansed by the blood and covering of Christ, and to become one with The Heavenly Father : YAHWEH EL ELYON ELOHIM EL SHADDAI with Holy Ghost Baptism, seek deliverance renounce the kingdom of Satan and repent from all known and generational sin!!!! In the name of YESHUA HAMASHIACH ADONAI , THE HOLY ETERNAL CHRIST (The Anointed One)!!!
This is the greatest channel discovery I have had in a while. Awesome stuff man, keep it coming!
Gnosticism is represented tpday with a new name, "Freemasonry", "G" they recruit members from unitarians, rotary club. lions club, YMCA, boys scouts, etc. they rule the world, the UN their headquarters..... they are before everybody, but no one sees them!!!!
A collab everyone was dying to see.
I’m working my way through the Nag Hammadi. Videos like this help give the reading context.
Thank you for making this video❤
Thanks. This is good work. I personally take "gnosis" to mean what we experience as a result of what we call Meditation. You reach a certain point in meditation when you know things, but it is not "data" type knowledge. And, most people that perform the practice can understand each other, yet it eludes formal language.
Gnosis is the spiritual insight gained from theoria. It's a specific part of Christian mysticism. Look up "Theosis" and "Quietism"
I would say “understanding” rather than “knowing”. Successfully applying understanding.
Innerstanding
As Jesus said - “you take away the key of knowledge because you did not enter with yourself. And those that were entering, you hindered”.
True understanding implies information being transferred losslessly without any added noise. It simply doesn't occur in objective reality to any degree of true knowledge. The only information that can be understood is the fact that the universe exists and you are a viewpoint of it. Almost everything else is only made up categories made up by humans agreeing on certain logical axioms. Nirvana like experiences reflect on that one fact and the difference between objective reality and subjective reality. All else is inferred subjectively by the individual by experiencing existence itself and knowing it's an illusion greater than the ego and the one truth tells us we're the universe more than we are ourselves.
I've been binging your channel for a couple days now, and I love your content. You should do a video/videos about Kabbalah, it would be really interesting to listen to you break down the Zohar.
look up his friend and colleague Dr. Justin Sledge at ESOTERICA another youtube channel, plenty of academic content on kabbalah there.
just wanna say this is a great video, you explained it all very well :)
I have always wanted to learn about the lost scriptures that were found and why the catholic church rejected them. Thank you for clarifying a lot of questions that I had! Great video! Great job!
Rome didn't want to accept Islam because of the strict prohibitions against paganism and alcohol whereas Christianity was easily molded by the Vatican to cater to the Europeans who could not let go of their traditions. Even the Christian-Roman image of God is eerily similar to the depictions of their original top deity, Zeus.
@@phillipholland6795 my God please educate yourself lol
@@mariskamahi6335 Even the Neo-Latin languages like Portuguese and Spanish say Deus to mean God. It is you who needs to educate yourself.
@@phillipholland6795 I'm no linguistics expert, bit I know that Deus isn't just Greco-Roman. It is derived from the Proto-Indo-European language for the Sky Father, Dyeus Phater. I'm not sure you could use that to say they couldn't let go of older pagan gods. That being said it is quite possible that Constantine syncretized the Christain god with the Roman sun god Sol Invictus.
@@jonathanshepherd5515 You will find no argument about that. However, Constantine himself worshipped Sol Invictus and received some kind of "revelation" from the sun (according to him, apparently) which influenced his conversion to Christianity somehow. Let's keep in mind the fertility worship of rabbits and eggs, the fertility goddess Ishtar from Babylon (and several coastal mediterranean pagan religions) which all got incorporated into Easter. Or the ten day Winter Solstice celebration called Saturnalia, which showed appreciation for the end of the sun's cycle, the shortest day of the year, and end of the dreaded winter that ancient Europeans dealt with year to year for centuries. It was a holiday of drunken cheer and debauchery, and gift exchanging too. Santa Klaus is a later Germanic/Nordic addition, draped in his hellish red fur. Krampus also originates from that region. Fire worship (Yule logs), Evergreen and mistletoe worship (because they survive freezing weather), and ancient pagans in Northern Europe always worshipped reindeers (and bears). Syricans never had any experience with elves, reindeers, yule logs and mistletoes, painted eggs, or trick or treat practices. They never dressed up as demons parading through the the town asking for candy. It appears many of these traditions survived in SOME form through modern Christianity. I wonder who's responsible for that. My guess would be some kind of money making machine, which was highly organized and exclusive, and would probably need to have a good grip on the people (having some kind of claim over Rome perhaps? the largest and most prominent empire of the time, which was at it's peak and in a period of peace and stability, and were already starting to experience an influx of Germanic people by the 2nd and 3rd centuries AD). Just a thought.
Now THAT'S the crossover I was waiting for :)
It is amazing to see how the story of Christ is continually comprehended, interpreted, and explored from early Christianity onward. It gives insight into how other faiths across the world have come to develop canons and concrete traditions. The creative power and free will that God gives is capable of so many good things as well as so many bad things.
Lol
Dude, these are false texts... this isnt the bible at all
@@ToyotaNutjob Can you tell us how the Bible was compiled?
If you think theres anything good about gnosticism youre delusional and a heretic.
Sipping on ?
Thank you ever so much for this enlightening overview of Gnosticism. Yes, I subscribed.
Really well done. He's got just the right touch ... clear, concise, nuanced but not pedantic ... both respectful and skeptical at the same time. Just signed up for Filip's patreon.
Great job! Amazing content 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Interesting how this aligns with ideas of enlightenment in Hinduism and Buddhism and being conscious of the duality of things.
I had to learn about gnosis in my school teaching and society class! Have to learn the roots of knowledge before learning to teach. It was super interesting
This was so well done. So much information, but all in a easy to understand and digestible way. Thanks.
Informative as usual, still one of the best channels on KZhead.
Having come from eastern esoteric tradition and simultaneously being well versed in many other traditions except the Semitic ones and so only having a rudimentary grasp of the Gnosis and Kabbalah and understanding them through the inner vision rather than in conceptual or scholarly fashion I appreciate your efforts to summarize and describe various traditions in a non-biased way so I can relate to the conceptual side of things. That's sort of rare, it requires some serious philosophical extensity and depth.
Irrelevant details, Simply when you need to prepare a sandwich, learning the life history of the man who first made sandwiches is totally irrelevant.
@@Thewonderingminds You may have commented on a different comment than intended, since I didn't talk about history of sandwiches. But in case you have intentionally replied on my comment, please do expand a bit on it, cause I totally fail to follow what are you up to with these sandwiches.
@@DanielJackson2010 Experientially I'm stating that it's totally futile attempting here to explain with a few words or statements that which is passed on and transferred with immediate interaction of questioning.
I love some of the art you use in your videos. some of it I've never seen, wish there were annotations or sources on them
here we go jo the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;..............................................,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
The definition of Gnosis you mentioned that references a kind of spiritual knowledge is similar to the Sanskrit word “gnan” or “gyan” or “jñan.” Makes me wonder if there’s a shared origin. I’ve also been delving more into Bernardo Kastrup’s views, which seems to accommodate parts of the Gnostic worldview you described. Nice work with this whole channel!
Well, gnosis is knowledge in Ancient Greek. So I suppose they are related in a sense that both languages are indo-european.
Could gnan/gyan be related or the same as the Jhanas known from Buddhism?
@1dog915 no, that's another sanskrit word - dhyana. Could be related to ñanas in Buddhism, but I'm not sure.
What a wonderful overview of Gnostics. Thank you for this.
why is it when read the bible "something is missing" and then read gnostic "ah there it is" and at same time if read only the gnostic text "something is missing"...... well the orthadox fills it, despite being "incompatable" [note that the pike document which predicted ww1 and ww2 (passed) sied WW3 will in part be triggered by tricking athest and christains to kill eachother] - all are just "a side of the SAME coin"
Excellent! You summarized this so well. Really appreciated.
Very interesting and well explained. Thank you for your work.
This was absolutely fascinating!
This was very helpful thank you!
this feels so life changing to me, thank you for making this video essay❤
I keep coming back to this video
@@hannahlennertkristiansen4797 how was it life changing for you? If you don’t mind me asking
You did a supurb job explaining that, especially the differences between the Sethian and Valentinian teachings. Thanks
Thank you for making this message possible for us and amen have a great thanksgiving day and amen
I love both your channel and Andrew's. So needed ones to spread real history!
My two favorite channels collaborating… love it!
Interesting , concise , and informative . Human intellectual history is definitely reflected or dare i say defined by the religious beliefs and concepts and the growth of consciousness is definitely recorded in it . Very well done and thank you !
Wow. This is the best (ie. the clearest and easiest to understand) explanation of Gnosticism that have encountered. I really feel like I understand the concept much more clearly than I did previously.
Hands down the best breakdown of Christian Gnosticism I’ve come across yet. Well done Let’s Talk Religion and Religion For Breakfast! Keep up the great work.
Ephesians 9 (What does “he ascended” mean except that he also descended to the lower, earthly regions[c]? 10 He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens, in order to fill the whole universe.) 11 So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, 12 to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up 13 until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. Research The Shrud Of Turin proof of The Living and resurrected Christ, Let those who have eyes to see and ears to hear discern the eternal truth of Christ!!! Give no room to false doctrines of devils and satanic belief systems DO NOT BE FOOLED by WARLOCKS AND WITCHES !!!! Praise The Living Christ pray to download the Holy Spirit of YAHWEH, to accept and cleansed by the blood and covering of Christ, and to become one with The Heavenly Father : YAHWEH EL ELYON ELOHIM EL SHADDAI with Holy Ghost Baptism, seek deliverance renounce the kingdom of Satan and repent from all known and generational sin!!!! In the name of YESHUA HAMASHIACH ADONAI , THE HOLY ETERNAL CHRIST (The Anointed One)!!!
I would argue that the Marcians should be included as a gnostic group, but overall I see why you and many other scholars don't include them, and this was a really great video, especially considering how exotified gnostic beliefs are in our culture.
Ephesians 9 (What does “he ascended” mean except that he also descended to the lower, earthly regions[c]? 10 He who descended is the very one who ascended higher than all the heavens, in order to fill the whole universe.) 11 So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, 12 to equip his people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up 13 until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. Research The Shrud Of Turin proof of The Living and resurrected Christ, Let those who have eyes to see and ears to hear discern the eternal truth of Christ!!! Give no room to false doctrines of devils and satanic belief systems DO NOT BE FOOLED by WARLOCKS AND WITCHES !!!! Praise The Living Christ pray to download the Holy Spirit of YAHWEH, to accept and cleansed by the blood and covering of Christ, and to become one with The Heavenly Father : YAHWEH EL ELYON ELOHIM EL SHADDAI with Holy Ghost Baptism, seek deliverance renounce the kingdom of Satan and repent from all known and generational sin!!!! In the name of YESHUA HAMASHIACH ADONAI , THE HOLY ETERNAL CHRIST (The Anointed One)!!!
Great info as always
Thanks so much for posting.
Henry's early insight feels like an epiphany. The oral traditions and, eventually, early scriptures did not have instructions; people were free to believe, interpret and choose the gospels as they deemed fit which would spur an overload of different, clashing ideologies.... It makes so much more sense now why there was such a violent outlash at heretics. Not because they challenged the status quo, but because they were direct threats to BE the status quo. Or, in other words, how the modern Catholic Christianity is, quite literally, theology as seen by the victors. The Sethians themselves, their origin story is absolutely trippy - some Azathoth level of weirdness really - but the explanation of the material world is WAY more sensical. It explains why the Old Testament God is so cruel, why our world is so imperfect and full of pain if God is so good, etc. I really liked it. Besides, having heard about the Book of Judas before, things become even clearer. The apostles worship Yaldabaoth, not the Unknown God.... Except Judas. Judas has the gnosis. It's awing. Jesus is not much different from the serpent, really. And I can DEFINITELY see why they were so violently fought - their views violently depart from a large portion of the Christian mythos. Absolutely amazing video.
I know these types of videos always note the Nag Hammadi find (which is the major find in the field, no doubt about it), but let's not forget quite a few "gnostic" texts were discovered beforehand in the the Codex Brucianus, the Askew Codex and the Akhmim Codex. Those seem to get over looked.
So glad I discovered your channel! You're awesome.
Good research and excellent illustrations!
I would love to see a broader comparison of the philosophical underpinnings of Gnosticism with Vedanta, particularly Advaita Vedanta as exemplified in the teachings of Adi Shankaracharya.
Devas in Hinduism are considered to be Fateweaving Archons in Christian Gnosticism, in fact Manichaeism has equation of the spawns of fallen rebellious Archons to be among them being devas, which also equated to Zoroastrian daevas with very demonising of Vedic/Rigvedic deities alongside Buddhism which sees Hindu devas to incapable to deliver sentient beings out of suffering/Dukkha Vedanta/Advaita Vedanta Theology worships Atman as "eternal soul" which is fallen under the categories of "Psychics" and "hylics" in Valentinian School of Gnostic Christianity
here we go jo the truth coming up,actually turah&bible were from god but they had been corrupted afterwards as a result god sent down quran upon prophet muhammed&god said i`ll preserved the quran thereby god had fulfilled ,let me show u friendly&honestly the truth,okee dokee.sheding the light on christianity to know the truth first of all there is no original bible the 4 main bible are contradicted to each other yet there is 1 quran but who is the writer of bible the answer is paul the jewish who hates jesus let us discuss about the significant event which is crucifixion why does your claimed god left his only son to crucify without any sin he had committed the disaster reached its uttermost when u found bible said on the tongue of jesus my god my god why do u forsaken me means jesus never crucified willingly have u an idea why do they crucify jesus because it`s a penalty of impure &particularly crucifixion because dindn`t touched the earth make it impured that what paul said jeasus get impure for us &see the authentic god what does said in quran chapter 3 verse 55 by the name of god the most gracious&most merciful , O Jesus, I will take you and raise you up to me, and had purified you from those who disbelieve, and He will place those who follow you above those who disbelieve until the Day of Resurrection, then to Me is your return, so I will judge between you regarding that in which you differed,the authentic god rose jesus to the sky before they kill him in addition he had purified him from a false accusation that he is impure the quran verse is comply with the bible itself :So they lifted up stones to stone him. But Jesus did and went out of the temple, passing through them." ( John 8:59 ),let alone of many verses in the bible incites to violence thus u found the largest massacres had happened in history the ww1&2 christian countries against christian countries 100 millions had been killed not to mention the sex stories in the bible nay u never found a single sex word in quran,don`t take it in personal just i clarify u the plain truth,bible said woman when she during the menstruation she gets impure &any thing she would touched it will be impure &should stay at her room till had done of it don`t see that an insulting to woman &how does the claimed god in bible said so he demeans& underrates his own creatures, yet islam honored the woman &she has a complete chapter its name women show us her rights,let us look at modern medicine which refutes the bible, ovulalation happens every 28 days from overy next month from other ovary when fertilization fails to happen mestrual bleading happens it always stops when a female gets pregnant ,menstrual cycle ovulation the female genital system consists of one uterus to overuse vagine& externat genital organs ,,the blood during menstruation could cause diseases to spread and that’s why a woman during her menstruation needed to isolate so the blood would not be passed around to other people And diseases not be spread that`s what god said in quran and they ask you about menstruation say, isolate women don't come near them untill they get purified verse 222 chapter 2,why there are priests,pastors&nuns reverted daily to islam,yet u never a muslim clergy left islam as per western media said that islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,i didn`t like to push islam onto u god said no compulsion in religion verse 256 chapter 2,figure it out then make up your mind;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;..............................................,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Thank you for this great video of gnosticism, I've read hundred of pages now and still confused about them until I found thins masterpieces
I’ve heard of Gnosticism before but had so much trouble wrapping my mind around the beliefs. Thank you for this unbiased, academic explanation that was backed up with sources!
Great content, well done!
Loved this! I only just found out about Gnosticism and it answers so many questions I’ve had for a long, long time. Could you please make additional videos about Gnosticism, like what exactly their teachings were, and particularly more on the Aeons and what they are, what they mean, and Sophia’s role/meaning/etc. …. And how all this applies to the idea of multiple dimensions, or even other planets with intelligent life, etc.??? I am so thirsty for more info on what the Gnostic teachings are but it is soooooooo difficult to find quality videos explaining it, let alone videos about it in any meaningful sense. Thanks for creating this great material!!! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🤗👏🏻🙌🏻🙏🏼😇
How about reading and researching the internet and books? Videos can be very pretty and easy to watch but are limited when investigating on an intellectual level
@Mark Ulis it's about how the fairy tales are written, and who by and where from. Keep learning, fairyboy.... will we all get there somehow
Sophia = Mary Magdelene
@@felixdiaz420 could you explain this?
For the time will come when men will not tolerate sound doctrine, but with itching ears they will gather around themselves teachers to suit their own desires. So they will turn their ears away from the truth and turn aside to myths. 2 Timothy Chapter 4. That's you. Repent, for the Kingdom of Heaven, is at hand!
Fascinating, thank you. Food for thought.
Nice explanation, super didactic. Thanks for sharing the knowledge.
I have previously made an overview of Gnosticism, however, it did nt seem as intricate as this. very intriguing. there are so many puzzles to understand the reason and purpose of our creation. good work, and God save us all bro.
Greetings, fellow seeker. I would like to offer my translation service into Spanish at whatever cost you consider offering. This would not only be a way of practicing my skills as a future translator, but would also make available all of this knowledge and synthesis to Spanish speakers worldwide. Thank you for considering this offer, and for such great content!!
Well done Sir.
Absolutely fascinating! Thank you!
I enjoyed this lesson. Very interesting and very well presented and organized
Great work again, and thank you for doing this.
It is amazing what ideas people over the centuries have come up with. I wonder how these ideas came to them. Perhaps there is a common stream of knowledge accessible to some but not perfectly understandable so the stories vary. Who knows.
Hallucinogenic mushrooms and plants
You are a pleasure to follow! I find great ease & understanding as well in your voice & dialect! Thank you so much! Where are you currently residing? What is that delightful accent you speak with? Sincerely & Best, Stacy
Enjoyed this. Well put
Love the video and the collaboration! I will subscribe to ReligionForBreakfast also now. Keep up the good work! Thanks!
I enjoyed this presentation
This was very helpful thank you so much ❤
This helped me understand greatly.. Thank you 🙏