5 BEST Small Subcompact SUV's To Buy For 2024 (And 5 You Should Avoid)
Top 5 small SUVs you can buy in 2024. We review and compare the best subcompact crossover SUVs on the market that have amazing reliability, safety, efficiency, and value. We also share the worst small SUVs that you should avoid buying. If you are buying a small SUV, make sure to watch this comparison review.
SUBSCRIBE TO CHANNEL:
kzhead.info/tools/qy-.html...
Website: www.carhelpcanada.com/
Instagram: / shari_pryma. .
TikTok: @shariprymak
My Favorite Undercoating / Rust Protection:
www.krown.com/en/
ABOUT ME
With over a decade of experience as a professional car buyer and auto consultant, Shari Prymak has helped thousands of consumers with their car buying needs. Car Help Corner provides honest, objective, consumer advice with all aspects of car buying and car ownership. For more professional advice, check out Car Help Canada, become a member, and subscribe!
Subaru crosstrek, Honda H-rv, Mazda cx-30, Toyota corolla cross, Lexus ux 250h 👍👍👍👍👍
I can confirm from my own experience (almost 5 years of trouble-free ownership) the reliability and quite low TCO for a Lexus UX 250h F Sport, chosen over an excellent CX-30 (Mazda) only due to a very special deal (-34% vs. MRSP) and the lack of a hybrid option
My daughter just bought a Mazda CX-30. I drove it, and really loved its handling.
I'm hoping Mazda come out with Hybrids in the near future, as well as Subaru.
I see not all the Japanese cars are the best, but all the best cars are Japanese.
Correct. The top of the best cars (based on the most important characteristics, that give you peace of mind: reliability, low costs and durability) is as follows: Lexus, Mazda, Toyota, Subaru, Acura, Honda, Suzuki, Mitsubishi (each is a leader in a different segment). Japan rulzzz.
It seems like when it comes to Japanese makes, Toyota, Lexus, Honda, Acura, Mazda, and Subaru are usually the top picks. The others like Nissan, Infiniti, and Mitsubishi are just average or less.
Absolutely agree
@@donaldwilson2620Mitsubishi is one of the best cars manufacturers…if you owned one of it you will know what i have said
Thank you for the great review! Absolutely agree with you!
Glad to see you listed the UX. It fits a certain segment of people just right but not for everyone. Often overlooked. Would consider some of the others if they had hybrid system.
Exceptional well explained video! 😊😊
I’ve been looking and researching an affordable and reliable replacement for my 97 RAV4 for five months. This is the most helpful and informative video I have ever seen. Thank you much!
Crosstrek is a solid choice. Great, practical car that looks fantastic.
I got CX-5 for my daughter. Preferred trim. 34000 out the door. Love it.
Did you consider the Turbo for your CX-5 ?
@@feleciawallace8420 No. Gas prices will only go up. I usually keep my car way over 100,000 MI. Don't want to have a deal with replacing turbo later on. And lifespan on the engine overall.
You are on point about MINI. I own a used countryman thank God I have an extended warranty.However once I got it up to spec, love it👍🏿😊
Go with 2.5 on the crosstrek for maybe a little more power, however in Canada you spend about five grand more for that one.
Love watching your videos. Can you make Video for RAV4 Prime vs Outlander PHEV (or any other PHEV Hyundai/Kia/Ford) including mileage as when you have 0% battery & best value for money trim for both& in the end verdict. Thanks!!!! also are PHEV actually worth the cost in terms of mileage? or just hybrid is enough
Good content Shari
Love my UX knowing it’s a good long term buy and super reliable
Mazda CX30 has THE BEST interior, it looks even better than Lexus'! The moral of the story: STAY AWAY FOR THE GERMAN VEHICLES, which are EXTREMELY UNRELIABLE WITH SKY HIGH REPAIR COST!!!
10000% correct... no German vehicles if you're smart...
@@feleciawallace8420all right👍👍
Mazda CX-30 was one of my 2 finalists. That much is true: Mazda went premium (so better materials and looks than the mass-market Toyota, Honda, Subaru). I also have a Miata ND2 RF (so I like Mazda), but I bought a Lexus UX 250h over the Mazda CX-30 because the luxury, comfort, silence, economy are far better than for the CX-30. Mazda would benefit from hybrid options, because otherwise their cars are beautiful, reliable, with a low TCO (Total Cost of Ownership), sporty etc.
@@codincoman9019 I think you can get CX-5. More roomy for the little bit more of money.
@@user-pl6nd2qs3c True, CX-5 is a legend. But for me, my wife and my dog is too big. Out of the 4 cars we use, only the Lexus UX has more than 2 seats and for us is (more than 90% of the time) still too big.
A couple of these are on my short list but I'm a bit concerned about the long term reliability of the CVT transmissions.
I was looking at the CX-30 and Crosstrek. We had a Mazda and a Subaru and were happy with both. Didn’t end up making it to the Mazda appointment as we decided on the Crosstrek. After a five month wait, it was finally delivered and I love it. We started out at the touring and ended up going with the Onyx for the 2.5 litre engine, since it’s mainly for highway driving. Even with snow tires, the cabin is quiet and the drive is smooth. My friend actually commented on how quiet it is while driving the other day. Even while I break in the engine and keep the RPM’s lower, it has no problem getting up to speed. You also have to love the all wheel drive, the thing feels like a tank with snow tires on. I know I’d be happy with the CX-30 as well but definitely glad we went Crosstrek.
This is silly. Making a choice without testing the rival? Btw, I had the CX-30 as a finalist (after drive-testing other small crossovers that didn't make it to my final, Crosstrek included).
I bought a hyundai kona 2020 4 years ago and it was just the base model, it has awd good for snowy days
Hi what about Nissan kicks S model 2024 is it worth to buy? Any brief feedback about it? Thank you
The VW TAOS. I got a 2022 model. VW finally delivered a SW TSB. It really refined the transmission. The 2024's should be shipping with the TSB.
Hello Shari, very good and informative video like always. Question for you. I'm looking to buy 2024 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid. Should I put a deposit and wait for a year and a half or should I wait till next year and should I try to negotiate a deal or some kind of discount or is no point anymore since waiting list so long
Thank you! I don't think there is any benefit to waiting. RAV4 Hybrid availability will likely remain limited so discounts aren't realistic for the foreseeable future. As long as you don't pay a markup or unnecessary dealer fees/add-ons you are good.
does anyone know where the model Y rates as a small subcompact suv?
Do same video for sedans please
how about hyundai tucson sel convenience ? is it worth to spend 40-41k on it ?
I have a 2017 Mazda Cx-5. Still going strong. Plan to keep it well past 10 years. Can’t go wrong with the Mazda CX series or the Honda Hrv/crv (my other option at the time of purchase).
I have a 2019 Mazda CX-3 and love it. It's very reliable and drives like a sports car...
I looked at the 250H. It is a sweet ride. Just a tad to small, just like you said.
Thanks
Another good list! I actually replaced a Kia Soul with the Subaru Crosstrek and it's been a great transition. I bought the Soul back in 2015 before all the engine stuff had come to light, and was going off the reliability of their older engines like the Beta II, once it became obvious that the 2.0L Nu engines were having the rod bearing issues, I started looking into a replacement, and the Crosstreks now coming with the 2.5L engine worked out as a good replacement. Better power, better fuel economy, and an overall better reputation for quality. I've only had it a year though, so, time will tell. To be fair to Kia, I had my Soul for 7 years, and put about 75K km on it without any issues other than the rear view camera breaking (which was fixed under warranty). A Kia mechanic mentioned, however, that most of the 1st gen Nu engine issues start cropping up around the 120K mark.
I would have done the same. Its days were probably numbered so why not trade in while it still has value. Many beat the odds and get very lucky, but the luck usually runs out sooner for Kia and Hyundai.
175000 on mine with no issues yet
@@carhelpcorner Yep, exactly. I babied that engine, but with the weak connector rod bearings just about anything could potentially cause a problem, so did not want to gamble. And yes you're right - used car prices were crazy high, so I got way, way more than I thought for it, and bought into the new car before interest rates went up, so paid 2/3 up front and financed the rest for 2 years at 1.9%. Will be paid off in 6 months. I have an older Kia Sportage, 2010 (2nd gen), but that has the old Beta II engine and is trucking along just fine.
@@davidmengle8269 - keep with frequent oil changes and baby it. Hope it stays that way (if you mean a Soul). If you meant a Crosstrek.... well, good news to hear! Hope I will have the same luck.
Is the Subaru a comfortable ride. We don’t have any dealerships in our area. I am seriously thinking of getting one but it would be an inconvenience to drive 100 miles to have it serviced.?.?
Hi Shari, you said in your intro "to help us buy car and ownership" could you make videos about maintenance and when or what fluid changes to do etc etc....just a thought, thanks
Already have! kzhead.info/sun/nKeRf7CxrXmAlps/bejne.htmlsi=lrsJSoBZWuN-cjq2
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:00 🚗 *Best and Worst Small Crossover SUVs* - Review of the best small subcompact crossover SUVs for 2024, - Comparison of reliability, safety, and value for money in these SUVs. 00:42 🌟 *Subaru Crosstrek: A Recommended Buy* - Strong reliability and value for money, - Available with a choice of engines and Subaru's excellent all-wheel drive system, - Spacious interior and impressive towing capacity. 02:05 🚫 *Kia Soul: An SUV to Avoid* - Kia Soul's reputation for reliability issues, - Reliability concerns with the 2.0L 4-cylinder engine, - Engine problems and recalls affecting Kia and Hyundai vehicles. 03:42 🌟 *Honda HRV: A Reliable and Spacious Choice* - Honda HRV offers reliability, safety, and fuel efficiency, - Surprisingly spacious interior and good cargo space, - Smooth and reliable 2.0L 4-cylinder engine. 05:07 🚫 *Volkswagen Tiguan: A Poor Choice* - Volkswagen Tiguan's dual-clutch transmission issues, - Underpowered 1.4L turbocharged engine, - Overpriced compared to more reliable competitors. 06:01 🌟 *Mazda CX-30: Stylish and Powerful* - Mazda CX-30 offers sporty ride, upscale interior, and stylish design, - Choice of engines, including a powerful turbocharged option, - Excellent safety rating and reliability. 07:26 🚫 *Mitsubishi Outlander Sport: Unremarkable Choice* - Mitsubishi Outlander Sport lacks standout features, - Dated interior and technology, - Limited safety features and lower safety rating. 08:37 🌟 *Toyota Corolla Cross: Affordable and Reliable* - Toyota Corolla Cross offers hybrid option for fuel efficiency, - Outstanding reputation for reliability, - Spacious interior, active safety features, and reasonable pricing. 09:58 🚫 *Mini Countryman: Overpriced and Underwhelming* - Mini Countryman lacks comfort and performance, - High price tag for what it offers, - Concerns about reliability and repair costs. 10:23 🌟 *Lexus UX 250h: Luxury and Efficiency* - Lexus UX 250h combines luxury, fuel efficiency, and reliability, - High-quality construction and materials, - Excellent choice for those seeking a premium compact SUV. 11:45 🚫 *Mercedes GLA: Overpriced and Underwhelming* - Mercedes GLA lacks comfort and refinement, - Small interior and cargo space for an SUV, - Reliability concerns and high repair costs. Made with HARPA AI
Excellent video with very sound information. I have driven all the good cars on your list and to me the Crosstrek with the 2.5 feels the most refined. It is tight inside so if you need more room then I would say the HRV is the best.
The Corolla Cross has limited leg room in the back seat if the front seat(s) are set all the way back. Also no spare tire. Besides that my experience with my 2023 Corolla Cross Hybrid has been excellent. Great gas mileage, lots of safety features, and a fun yet slow ride.
No spare?!!!
@MissNaturalMystery yes the 2023 Corolla Cross Hybrid does not have a spare tire. The wheel well has the high voltage cables placed there.
The gas engine models have spare tires. Only the hybrid doesn't to make room for the power cables.
@silvershadow013 that's true. But the hybrid has much more to offer than the gas version.
Since there's abundant choices in this segment, my suggestion is to avoid Hyundai altogether. One would spend more time having a Hyundai product in the repair shop than a Toyota product. Good luck!
Agree. Korean clunkers are better than the German ones (an their price is better too), but they do not belong to Top 10 reliability, owned by the best Japanese brands. Lexus, Toyota, Mazda, Subaru, Honda, Acura are far better choices. Even when compared to Suzuki, the Korean clunkers do look better and have more gadgets, but Suzuki is the rational choice due to better reliability and lower TCO. Just look at the huge cars' numbers of Hyundai/Kia recalls.
Hi Shari I recently booked 2 vehicles in Canada. Corolla Cross for my spouse and CX50 GT+ for me. Ur this review didnot cover CX50. Do u recommend it in this list ?
The CX-50 is an excellent vehicle. I made a video on it in Oct I believe. Great choice 👍
Please don't buy a crosstrek. My 20k mileage 2021 Crosstrek shit the bed due to numerous issues since day 1. Please avoid this car like the plague
Great video 👍👍👍 I am little divided with the Subaru recommendations. Often times Subarus are suffering from oil leaks, over heating issues and head gasket issues. I really want to love Subarus but their engines are not problem free or durable as their AWD systems. As for the Honda HRV, it is 100% more durable and trouble free than the Honda CRV with it’s disastrous Turbo engine. As for the VW and Mini, I am shocked these brands are still around. Absolute garbage quality unless you keep the vehicles within the warranty period. Outside of warranty, run fast!!!
Owned a 2016 Subaru Legacy that was bought new. Drove it for 100,000 miles in 8 years and only ever needed oil changes, tires, batteries and brake pads. It never leaked oil or overheated. Never had to add oil and went 6,000 miles between oil changes. Those problems happened years ago and has been fixed. Plus, it got 35MPG on the highway. Now I have a 2024 Crosstrek Wilderness and wife has a 2023 Forester.
@@raybonz7939Your experience is a anomaly. Leaks are part of Subarus heritage. Our shop consistently fixing all these issues related to leaks. We have a 2018 WRX that has only 70,000 kms that we are fixing oil leaks and burning oil issues. Client meticulously maintained it since new.
@@Thankyou_3 Does the WRX have a turbo? Thinking it's more of a turbo engine problem. WRX's tend to be driven harder, too.
@@raybonz7939This owner is conservative driver. WRX is a Turbo engine…It was clogged with the sealant Subaru uses. Disastrous…they are too cheap to use gaskets.
@@Thankyou_3 how do you reseal to prevent leaks?
I would like to know if you have any ideas of a good hybrid SUV with 360 surrounding Camara
Toyota Venza or Lexus NX350h are probably the best choices.
@@carhelpcorner thanks, I was also thinking of Lincoln Corsair 2022
What are your thoughts on the new 2024 Kia Seltos? Isn't the 2.0L engine new vs. the problematic ones from a few years ago?
¹q1q
Shari, will you ever get the chance to review the new 2024 Chevrolet Trax? Looks to be pretty competitive with the pricing
The review is coming very soon 👍
From what I've been hearing, the 2024 Chevy Trax has gotten rave reviews. Most reviewers have said that you do get a lot of features for the price on the Trax. The only question is how will it hold up when it comes to long tern reliability?
Crosstrek for me.
I'm 6'3" and did not fit in the driver's seat in the Toyota Corolla Cross.
Hi love your videos. What is your opinion on Audi Q3?
Thank you! I did a comparison between Q3, X1, and XC40. This should answer it: kzhead.info/sun/isN6iJyyp3qClGw/bejne.htmlsi=upEHxYPPN03qFImd
Which car would be best for fuel economy?
Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid 👍
I have a Lexus IS 250 best car EVVVVVER. The paint is crap 😭 on it but the engine is great
Thanks for the valuable information. Can you talk about Audi Q3 and A3 e-tron?
Hope this works. I did a comparison between Q3, X1, and XC40: kzhead.info/sun/isN6iJyyp3qClGw/bejne.htmlsi=upEHxYPPN03qFImd
I love Subaru so I'd buy the Crosstrek. As for high end European cars, you can keep them.
Have you made a video on the Audi Q5 or Alpha Romeo Stelvio? I love the exterior of both and am curious about reliability and if either are worth the money. Thanks!
I'm in Canada. I'm considering the Subaru Crosstrek, Honda HRV, Toyota Cross mostly for city driving with one annual longer trip across provinces (2 - 3 days of travel). I have a family of three with a young teen. Disappointed that there's no arm rest in the Honda. Looking for the best deal month to month. Any opinions on these three for my user case. Anyone have an opinion on the Hyundai Kona (not with the base engine discussed here)? I'd consider that too.
The Crosstrek and HRV are 1 and 2 in best in class.I bought the 2023 HRV and I’m quite happy with it. The cargo space is quite a bit larger than other choices. I managed to do a large Costco load without lowering the seats. I’m getting around 8 L/100km as well. I don’t miss my old CRV at all. I was leary about buying the Crosstrek because of the boxer engine and Subaru’s past issues with head gaskets. I wasn’t a fan of the Crosstrek’s look either. The HRV looks like a Porsche. I have a couple of criticisms though. As you said there is no arm rest. Also there is no handle on the roof in the front seats. My senior parents rely on those to hold on to get out of their seat. There is also currently a recall on the HRV for seat belt issues. If you drive in the City a lot you might want to consider a Corolla Cross hybrid if you can wait for one.
Only the top trim of Canada 2024 HRV has the blind spot detector. I feel it’s a really helpful safety feature that HRV shall installed to all its trims. But if that’s not a concern to you, I’m voting for HRV.
@@sylvainck4666I have the 2023 HRV Sport Trim and it has the blind spot detector fortunately.
My situation is very similar to yours. I bought a Corolla Cross hybrid. I get 44 mpg average in the city but in long trips I get 50 to 55 mpg. I will take my first road trip soon. So far I'm very happy with my choice.
Currently loving my 2024 Crosstrek Onyx. My other choice was the CX-30 as I was driving a Mazda and am happy with the brand so far. However, I just love the look of the Crosstrek. It definitely looks more rugged than the other vehicles (the cladding isn’t cheap plastic btw). Also, the ride is extremely smooth and the cabin is quiet.
Crosstek #1. Topgun. 💯
Would like to hear your reviews on GM 2024 Cars
Trash
Honda hrv not for tall people im 5"8 and hate i cant adjust the foot pedals bc the seat does not extend back far enough. Will be trading in mine
I’m six foot and I can fit in it just fine, both front and back seat with no issues. The Kia Sportage I can’t fit surprisingly. You should have test drove it before you bought it
Need reviews on North American vehicles
Your "Chapters" menu lacked "mini."
Hi would you please do a review on some Chinese suv ie cherry, haval,etc. Thanks
I was surprised to not see the Hyundai Venue on this list. I got a 2023 SEL trim Venue brand-new back in August and even though it's a tad bit underpowered I really, really like it. It's probably one of the best "value" buys out there at the moment. I've driven a 2010 Nissan Versa Hatchback for the last 6 years with practically zero problems but over the past 7 months or so it began having every possible issue imaginable, so it forced my hand. That being said, I could not be more happier with my Venue purchase!
Your opinion is irrelevant. I do hope the best for you, but the Korean clunkers are showing a lack of reliability in the statistics. So the best Japanese cars are owning the reliability and low TCO tops, no matter what you think (after ONLY 7 months of ownership). Let's talk after few more years 😏
@jacobsekela8691 You will get the odd vehicle(s) (from bad car brands) that will last with no probs, I would suggest buy a lottery ticket cause luck is on your side👍
@@codincoman9019 Can you share a link to those statistics?
Looking at recent reliability reviews from several major websites on the Kia Soul it's rated above average. I'm not sure about the Mini Countryman model but other Min's have also gotten good reliability reviews. Earlier models were very unreliable, among the worst at the time but they've gotten a lot better it seems.
You didn't document enough the Korean and German clunkers.
How about the Nissan Qashqai? I was hoping for your opinion, seeing that it’s picture is on the front page of your video. I own a 2019 and although it has been reliable so far (52,000km), I find it disappointing in terms of performance. It is just plain boring to drive 🥴
The Qashqai isn't sold in North America, except it is sold under a different model name.
@@damilolaakanni Qashqai is sold in Canada. It is Rogue Sport in the US
@@robertgravel5160 I had forgotten that the Rogue Sport still exists, especially since Nissan introduced the Kicks in 2018.
Nissan isn't offering it for 2024. It is an average vehicle. The biggest concern is long term CVT reliability.
My mother has a 2019 rvr and don't know where you are getting your info but its not noisy, it has a enough power, and the interior isn't dated in a sense.
The interior is dated, cheap and ugly.
@jcougot maybe to you.. not everyone can afford 50k vehicle.. and even then those are more dated looking then sone of the cheaper brands.
If you wear a fire retardant suit, you should be fine in the Kia Soul.
Weird, the GLA is the best of the bunch. And what's with the thumnail hating on Nisan?
The engine on the Taos is a 1.5 not a 1.4.
Correct. Thanks for the correction.
Kia and Hyundai are known to be very reliable these days. Yes they had an issue with the 2.4 and 2.0 as you said that supposedly has been fixed, but if you bring this up don't forget to mention when you review Toyota as they have also had engine problems and issued recalls (even during/since the Kia/Hyundai recall). This was in their 2.5L engine. Also, don't forget the Toyota brake issue, and the 280,000 cars that "may creep forward" while in neutral because the engine might not disengage entirely. Also, the 2.5 million Toyota and Lexus engines affected by a sludge issue where they were forced by class action to cover. Only mentioning to make sure you are not showing any favoritism as consistency in reviews earn trust. Sorry if this sounds negative, but just see so many reviews that only mention the negatives in cars companies they personally hate and positives from those they like. Example, I have a friend that will only buy Honda's and he will tell everyone he has never had an issue with his Honda's, yet I have picked him up on the side of the road with his broken down car. His emotions get in the way.
I understand your favoritism point, but I don't consider this an apples to apples comparison for two reasons: 1. The Toyota issues have been solved for close to a decade now and are a non-issue for anyone buying a new or relatively new Toyota. There's no point in bringing it up. The Hyundai/Kia issues, however, are still fresh with engine failures as recent as 2021 models. 2. The scale and severity of the Hyundai/Kia recalls not only far exceeds the Toyota recalls, but probably any recall in modern history. Over 10 million impacted vehicles, billions in loss and class action lawsuits, and engine failures/fires in the six digits. By every measure, it's on a level that nothing else can approach.
Where is Nissan rogue😅
How reliable is Hyundai Tucson
I don't know why are you asking about a Korean clunker. It didn't reach the Top reliable cars (not for this segment, but the right one), isn't that enough for you?
How reliable is kia seltos?
Here is a recent video: kzhead.info/sun/o8pwgsd5i4KsnH0/bejne.htmlsi=WkMfl5TK6C3lsLN9
Thanks
Do you make money selling Honda cars??? Ir looks like it.
Crosstrek is an overpriced Impreza-on-stilts. For just CA $3,000 more you can get a similar trim of a legendary Forester, which is a much bigger and better SUV. Honda HR-V is extremely expensive too. Entry level LX-B AWD costs a CA $1,000 more than Mazda CX-5 GX. With Mazda you will get more of everything. My conclusion: as a stand-alone review of sub-compact SUVs this video makes sense, but the bigger picture is missing. In most cases it just makes no sense to buy them at all.
What I realize . He isn't Car engineer or Car expert. More like hear say rumor like analysis. I tried to be patient and understand he isn't car owner or car expert but Year 2024 I just have to say it. Hyundia-KIA car company ranks 5th in the world in market share. I have disagree with your opinions regarding to Hyundai KiA cars. For example, I would buy KIA cars over Subaru any day or night. Not exactly sure were you come from with this weak engine crp.
CVT-> no thank you
Why are you covering foreign cars?
Mini is not an SUV never has been never will be
Nothing from Chevy, Ford, Audi, Volvo?
They are not reliable - as they used to be decades ago.
When ever his video pops up i could easily guess yeah Toyota and Honda. Nothing more
This is so narrow-minded. The most relevant statistics (on reliability and on Total Cost of Ownership) are showing also Mazda, Lexus, Subaru (and Suzuki for the rest of the world) at the top of many car segments.
@codincoman9019 What the hell are you talking about? Toyota is in the top 3 in ANY RELEVANT statistics pretty much on any class. And ofc Lexus's Toyota is there too, in top 5 depending on class.
@@blaaaaaaaaahify are you a functional analphabet or what? I wrote quite clearly, that there are ALSO other Japanese brands at the top. I didn't even suggest that Toyota and Honda are not good, on the contrary. The aggregate (reliability+costs+durability etc.) top of the best cars for me is: Toyota, Mazda, Lexus, Subaru, Honda, Suzuki, Mitsubishi, Acura etc. From where did you draw the conclusion that I am forgetting the #1 Toyota?!?...
Car Help Corner it's clear you just don't like MINI. Consumer Reports named them the 3rd most reliable brand of 2023. And while you state the Countryman is unreliable I See Cars gives it a higher reliability rating than both the HRV and Crosstrek. They also rate the Countryman #4 most reliable subcompact SUV. MINI's reliability has improved greatly with the current generation. I will agree though they are overpriced for what you get.
The last one I tested was nearly $60k. It didn't even feel like a $40k car to me.
Please look at the Consumer Reports annual surveys on a rolling base (the average of the last years). Only if you see a brand (or car) for many years in the Top 10 reliability you can trust CR. Otherwise - maybe for money - the CR is introducing and taking out of their Top 10 different brands (cars) that are only average. For example, over the last years the CR introduced (and afterwards took out) brands like: Mini, BMW, Audi, Kia,Hyundai, Dodge, Buick, RAM, Infinity etc. The Top 10 reliability belongs to the best Japanese brands/cars. The Consumer Reports is also guilty of Suzuki's withdrawal from the American market (proven false allegations about Suzuki Samurai/Jimny, the best small 4x4 worldwide).
Kia / Hyundai is garbage
I admit, I don't trust Consumer Reports as far as I can throw the magazine, but they state Kia and Hyundai are currently very reliable. Along with JD power, and a few others. I personally have had the most issues with Toyota and Dodge.
Kia had been trash for a long time!
Lol, you post the same recycled content. Gets old after a while
Add $4200 to the price of your Subaru for the cam carrier seal you WILL have to have fixed.