Single Ukrainian Tank Destroys Russian Armored Column !?
2024 ж. 9 Мам.
89 904 Рет қаралды
Recently we got a video of a Ukrainian tank engaging a Russian armored column, taking out some armored vehicles.
Patreon: / redeffect
Outro: "face away" - svard
red effect knowing the tank model by looking at 4 pixels always makes my day
"1 bit pixel" *Tiger*
Average war thunder player
But it's not that hard??
@@Anarcho-harambeismpotato pc of wt player 😂
@@BHuang92seeing that reference again makes my day 😆
2 pixels - Red : "I cant tell which tank it is" 2 sec later "is a T-72" man i love Red's videos
Well just saying it's t72 doesn't say much. It like saying its a panzer about a nazzi tank
@@reload5817 No it was meant to be a joke i love Watching Red so chillout
@@NocKme well yes and no, it was a joke, but using your panzer theory is like mixing up a bmp and t-72 not a T-72 and T-80
it includes t90 since those have exhaust on side too. more like t72 family
@@reload5817 well PzKw III ,IV and StuG would fall into his use of logic. All 3 use the same hull, 2 out of the 3 names start with tank and if u don't speak German the use of the word would be more important than the meaning. so I would say "I not impressed" by ur comment XD
Can we appreciate how he shows all sides of this war.
hello chad turtle
t's funny that at the time, a pig called him "Vatnik" how silly...
Only people who call Red a Russian propagandist are insufferable NAFO trolls. He's by far the most objective tank youtuber out there.
Hi Chad turtle
Where ever you go on youtube you find this turtle.
Stays wild to see footage like this. Who would have thought we would get to see war like it’s a football match with drones recording from above and sometimes even pov videos
be thankful you were randomly born in your position to watch
Well, it has been very similar to this even in 1990 during Desert Storm. Although those pictures were even less clear and many were just tracers in the night. I remember that one scene in 2003 when the embedded reporter was riding with a tank crew and suddenly went off the air in the midst of battle and I thought "crap, now they were hit", but it was just a technical glitch.
@@donaldduck830 well yes, 1940s germany already produced footage like this with the famous "prinz eugen film" for example; but what we're referring to is mint footage of nearly every engagement. more akin to usa's 2nd season of warcrimes and crimes against humanity in the middle east, after the false flag attacks on the towers, where there surface alot of videos on yt, and still to this day marines upload personal gopro footage
I think We should just admit that tank-to-tank engagement is just a romanticized idea of modern warfare.
Yeah kind of I don’t think that it’s a thing anymore as it’s usually who gets the first shot off
@@spitfire3003Plenty of videos of it from this war tho
There are literally videos of tank on tank combat in an open field from this war
@@Pieguy223 Yeah, but not the one where huge collum or armors clash. Most of the modern engagements are just a single tank; take a peek, shoot, and retreat.
@notani3533 cause crew members and soldiers in general want to stay alive probably
Your analysis of these engagements is next level.
I don't think the first vehicle that exploded was hit by the tank either. I watched the video in slow motion. It explodes on the wrong side and from under.
I think the terrain has a slight curve blocking the view of both sides how can they have not seen each other in such a short range without a blocking tree line. The tank qould have hit the other tank first before the bmp. So yeah it was probably a mine
It could be a mine plow trap. Attach a active mine or other explosive device to explosive wire, explosive wire attached to none "active" mine with c4 further back. The plow hit the front mine or explosive device, which then sets of the mine further back which now is directly under the tank.
Great video with a good analysis of what is presented. Thank you.
I watch this channel for its logical analysis of war footage. It is gratifying to listen to such analysis. I am not a "tank" person, nor do I watch any other "war" channel. Keep up the good work!
1:30 the explosion appears to be closer to the back of the tank, the explosive effect is most likely delayed to counter mine sweeping equipment, both sides are known to use that trick
The story behind the video is that the Russian mine clearing tank are trying to clear the Ukraine mine fields and attack the Ukraine position. However, they are spotted by the Ukraine's UAV and the Ukraine counter attack. The Russian mine clearing tank panic and tried to flee. However, the Russian mine clearing tank struck a mine while trying to flee.
So the Ukrainian tank shot (and probably missed), but the Russian tank panicked and was hit by a mine instead?
@@WimiBussard ukrainian tank shot only the first bmp but not the others.
fleeing by moving forward? is this a new tactic or you just biased
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
@@JayJay-cl4py Yes, because Ts have no reverse speed. I swear, the Z logic... "No reverse speed is no big problem, soviets bever retreat!" "Look, glorious tank wasn't reversing, not a retreat!"
imagine all the tank battles in the beggining of the war that we could not see,
Im not sure if there were that many - Most Ukrainian tanks were destroys by airstrikes and Russian tanks were being ambushed by infantry.
I'd wager there's quite a few tank battles happening (well, probably very small engagements), it's just that they're rarely recorded.
A whole regiment of Ukrainian tanks were abandoned by their crews near Kherson without a shot. Much of the proxy army's tanks, planes and ships were lost in the first week. The western media will never report the terrible losses of Ukrainian manpower which has increased from early 2023 - it only reports nonsense Russian losses supplied by propagandists in Kiev or Washington.
@@rare_kumikoYou'd think that if either side uses tanks in defence, the likelihood of tanks running into each other is elevated. Video material of this seems to be relatively scarce. Although it was different on the different fronts, the early part of the war mostly consisted of the Russians trying to go around major population centers to cover as much ground and gain control of as many objectives as possible by rapid movement. They apparently thought that the violence of their action would work to their advantage, like this is the Iraq war or something, which seemed to be the operational inspiration for this plan. They got bogged down by problems with supply and resistance of territorial units and other light infantry-heavy units with advanced AT weapons.
@@herptekдоброго времени суток, уважаемый! Вам не приходило в голову? Что Россия обходила большие города по причине милосердия? Чтобы не страдали мирные жители!
the first BMP-2 was hit before the arrival of the Ukr. tank, first video you have 3 of vehicles at move and the BMP-2 gets hit while moving, as for the second video when the tank hit the BMP-2 it was already not moving nor any vehicles around it
Arrival? You know a tank can hit a moving target several kilometers away. So you dont have to "arrive" within frame to do so.
@@ThorSuzuki1 if that tank hit that BMP-2 from kilometers then you are asked to show the proof, otherwise it's as the video shows, BMP-2 got hit, dudes ran away, after that Ukr. send a tank to clear what is left.
@@alikaraahmet5050 It is as much speculation as your statement.
@@ThorSuzuki1 can you prove the otherwise ? with actual video or linking other than actual "speculations" you can clearly see on the second video that the tank shooting on non-moving target with nothing behind or in font of it !
This is normal in AFU videos, they cut and paste video out of order to create a story. The real sequence of events may have just been all 3 vehicles ran over mines and then the tank showed up to support the infantry in capturing them.
I have been waiting for this breakdown since I first saw this footage.
Hey redeffect, I think there was another video that came out recently of a Ukrainian tank engaging a Russian tank and destroying it, with a few atgms missing it as it retreated. If you have seen it, do you think you will cover it on your channel?
I think that was a Russian tank not a Ukrainian tank
@@AndRei-yc3ti just went and found the video again. Looks like it was a Ukrainian tank but it wasn't really a duel, because the Russian tank had hit a mine while retreating and was abandoned just as the Ukrainian tank started firing on it. Still an interesting video because it seems to show the Ukrainian tank using a kinetic round to finish the disabled Russian tank, and the atgms hitting nearby. But I don't think that he'll cover it in this case, since it's not a duel
Can you do a updates on the armor in the Balkans it’s been a while since you did a video on those
Having drones on top of the tank column is a Must nowadays...
Hey red effect you think you could talk about the burlak project?
Good. An unbiased analysis of a battle.
It would be nice if you do a video comparising the russian light tank sprut SD vs the american M10 Booker
What is the small explosion behind the tank seen just after the tank fires (0:22), I think it's from one of the bmp and it nearly hit the tank
I mean ffs , you have a column of tanks in an open area , how much would it cost to send a drone just to make sure there is no enemy tanks in the area 😂😂😂
At 2:15 you can see a shell land next to the UKR tank while it fires the main gun.
Which would qualify this as a tank battle :-)
Red effect, I know I asked you this before. But by any chance you could make a video on Japanese type 90 mbt?
At least some crew made it out with their lives, no matter how wrong a government was to send them to war, individuals who haven't committed war crimes against prisoners or civilians deserve to live their best lives away from a pointless war.
Oh man 😂 yall are so nice and naive... RUSSIA or Ukrain treat thirt prisoners of war worse than dogs 😂 my granpa was in ww2. He was in the red army and told us all the crazy stuff they would do to prisoners 😢
That was almost 80 years ago now. @@mikefrost4320
Russia wasn't wrong from the Minsk Agreement to numerous warnings and it's push for negotiations last year, only the West is to blame.
@@mikefrost4320 Spotted the idiot who equalizes Ukraine and Russia. 🤡
@@mikefrost4320врешь. Если бы Красная армия плохо относилась к пленным, миллионы пленных немцев не вернулись бы домой живыми. То же самое относится к современной России - пленных берут и они живые, а вот про отвратителное отношение к пленным Украины информация есть даже из западных источников, что и не удивительно для радикалов, особенно вида нацисты.
There was a counter-shot very short after the first hit, looked like a smaller caliber, but missed ...
prbly rpg
@@alphanomad511 or it was a shot from the bmp, those are kinda like rpg rounds too. At least the bmp 1 and 3
@@potatoo_69 bro copied my pfp 😂 😎
Stil surprised YT algorithm allowed this. But hey, praise the Omnissiah.
Super nice footage, but why did the first shell have smoke trail following it all the way to target, but no such for following shots?
Could be a barrel-launched ATGM, or a tracer from HEAT round. Following shots are likely just HE, with no tracer
Solid report.
what is the small explosion after the ukrainian tank fires at 2:18 It exploded almost behind the tank, or side or so.
But you can see one round closely missing the Ukrainian tank and gotten close to its rear, which could be fired from the Russian tank. Which I would call a tank Duell :)
I can't tell what that is, but I doubt it's a tank round since there's no muzzle blast that I can see from the Russian side (whereas the Ukr tank has a massive muzzle blast and the round it fires also has a tail) or any other indication the Russian side even fired. Maybe it's a mine?
*duel
@@Pos3id0n. Or a missile, which wouldn't have much muzzle blast either.
Wonder if they opted to shoot the bmp because they didnt have a round that was good enough for the tank? Usually yiu try to knock out the lead vehicle and then the trailing one
Looking more and more like a WW1 Battlefield.
What else do you expect? Look at the scale of this war. It's huge!
@@4epa1012 the scale of this war is very small compared to the great war and WWII
@@4epa1012 I was referring to the numerous shell hole craters like in WW1.
@@jtl05 The length of the front in this war is over double the 400 miles of the Western Front in WW1, but the troops involved and intensity of fighting was greater back then, as you say.
@@jtl05 You can't compare this war with WW2, although technically this war is a WW3 but not full scale yet, and I hope it will never escalate to full scale WW3 🙏
It's not necessarily a T-72 since old tanks like the T-62 and T-54/54 also have the exhaust on the side like the T-72. Though it's most likely a T-72 but we have seen some T-62s on the front so it's not impossible.
It’s probably a bit rare for a T-64 to have both a mine plow and a cage. They would probably keep those for higher value tanks
@@breezygamer1179 I was talking about the T-62 not the T-64 because as we can see with the exhaust, it's not a T-64. I would have thought that it would be smart to use outdated vehicles for the very dangerous task of taking point when clearing a path though a minefield. We know the Russians have remote controlled bomb vehicles, why not put some plows on old T-54s and remotely send them to clear minefields?
where do you find this footage, out of curiosity? do you use Russian and Ukrainian telegram channels?
KAOTIC
It was released on twitter by the Ukranian MOD.
@@bootlegpete7984 thats a gore site tho and they put their shitty watermark on every video which I dont see here
Telegram has a lot of often uncensored footage from both sides, but the majority of 'kill' footage tends to be Russian.
@@Orcawhale1 right but they never claimed it was one tank destroying an entire column
what is this obsession with tank duels (or the lack of them)? Teamwork between different arms of the military is the winning combination.
Can you say what shell the ukrainian tank used?
could it have been a earlier T-90 model because the exhaust is also in a similar position
What is the background music and how can I listen to it?
Red is the tank version of th GeoGuesser guy.
Good question...
It’s crazy how my personal favorite Russian tank the T80 turns out being the best one on the battlefield. The Russians are on track to be making about 240 new tanks a year btw.
Why and how is it the best on the battlefield?
@@sebastianbaez-serrano2298having 11kmh on reverse can be a live saver
The T90M absolutely outperforms it in every aspect but reverse speed
@@luizviniciusvieiraalexandr4979That is not enough to outweigh all other drawbacks
There's a talk about restarting T-80 production from scratch, but they're probably going to be new variant that will have a lot in common with T-90M than with current T-80s
Does anyone have any information on the tank and bmp crew ? Did they survive ect ... ?
tank might have a chance survival, bmps, unfortunately are KIA
BMPs are definitely dead
@@ligmasurvivor5600 even the guys on top of the bmp ?
Looks like a t64 by the rear exhaust
The russian "tank" looks more like a sturmgeschütz lol
Basically every video with the name "ukrainian/russian tank DESTROYS a column of ukrainian/russian tanks SOLO" is heavily biased and nearly impossible
Not if it’s a column with no anti tank weapons
Gotta rethink all of those stories I've heard from WW2, when there weren't drone videos to have deep analysis of events.
It would easily have been possible if all 3 crew members of the solo tank had been lv100 War Thunder players who played for over a year as a squad on discord. But alas, we haven’t seen such powerful force of nature assemble yet. Legend has it that if you can assemble a full tank company of veteran WT players, they can summon a nuke in the middle of combat.
The ukrainian nationalist shrek comes with a based take damn
lol@@thomaszhang3101
Mines really are the terror on both sides
its interesting that the leading tank wasn't visible to Ukrainian tank crew and in close up we can see thermal net covering the Russian tank.
I'm not sure what it is but is a t72. Mate you are really good 👍
You should be everyone's new source
People, we need to be happy redeffect is here, or else the only thing we would have is constant propaganda
Serious question. Is there any forest in eastern Ukraine? I always see only flat lands with some bushes.
The majority of the territory is steppe, the whole eastern part of Ukraine is steppe, except for the forested areas near the Siverskyi Donets River.
Must be a hell to have war there. @@ferum112
"So Sadly, no tank duel took place" lol
Red effect gives the pro Russia version of events and I like that because it gives a balance in the information war, you got pro Ukraine one side pro Russia other side and somewhere in the middle you got the truth, but this guy dose know his stuff, and he dose give a fairly honest low down, and I love his Slavic accent
First Ghost of Kiev now Specter of Wittman
Can you make a vid on t-44?
Can you make a video on Argentina’s indigenous TAM tank?
This is some warthunder level shit right here.
It’s weird to me seeing a field full of artillery craters like it’s WW1
Amazing
These are two separate events and the video has been edited. In the first part, the BMP is most likely hit by a 155 mm Excalibur projectile, the explosion is extremely powerful and the smoke of the explosion goes towards the T-72 tank in front, later destroyed by a mine, while the trajectory of the ucrainian tank's projectile, visible in the second part, is missing. In the second part where we see the Ukrainian tank firing, something is already burning behind and the Russian tank, very close in the first part, is nowhere to be seen while the target the Ukrainian tank is shooting at seems to explode only after multiple hits who do not appear in the first part of the video. Also the explosion of the vehicle hit by the Ukrainian tank is different from the one of the BMP from the first part, the smoke going towards the tree line and not in front. I also have some doubts that the vehicle hit by the Ukrainian tank is a BMP, these vehicles have a relatively small amount of ammunition on board, unless it was specifically used to transport it.
@@SashaW- Those are slow and their trajectory visible.
@@AlinsieventualCalinnot with the quality this video was shot in
@@gies1714The quality of the video of the BMP exploding is OK but there is no trajectory to be seen while in the much lower quality second part at 0:21 you can clearly see the trajectory of the ukrainian tank's (HEAT?) projectile.
@@AlinsieventualCalin indeed, nice catch! The video in where the BMP first gets hit does however not leave much room to see a potential projectile from the side of the Ukrainian T-64. The smoke could have faded. Your theory does have some merit however.
It's okay having a dozer blade but you need to know how to use it. Also who builds a tank with a slow reverse. How do you fight in a hull down position if you cannot pull back before the enemy gets a chance to hit you. I know the old Soviet idea was huge waves of tanks rushing in massive waves through the Fulda Gap but that leaves you with a one trick pony.
Watch RU supporters claim this is the opposite and that it is somehow staged
I have yet to see a single person say that lol
@@mcnuffin1208 @Gator-357 already did that. It's further up the comments section.
LazerPig ain’t gonna like you knowing what tank that was.
Bro what kind of explainers are you you just knows the T72 with 144p quality 😮😮
It was not a T-72 that ran over the mine, but a BMR-3(M). The BMR-3(or BMR-3M) is a Variant of the T-72 (Variant of the T-90 if BMR-3M). You can tell due to the box shaped structure on top of the tank. Thought it does look like it added something to it.
I tend to agree. Looking at the BMR-3 Imagery I can find I really fits better than a t-72 with a cope cage. www.pioniertechnik.de/bilder/bmr-3m.jpg
Wonder what was the objective. Could be: -Go as far as you can. -Try getting this try line occupy. The reason the mine got the tank may be that they where SEVERAL stacked, and when sweep they keep clumped and blow below and side of the tank, that exploccionwas quite big.
redeffect compare ztq-15 with m10 booker!
Wrong, it was actually a Leopard 2a7
A video where I understand what was portrayed! What have I become?!
Tank duels can result in casualties.Don’t you think that is sad too?
I hope you don't get demonitized by showing that uncensored footage, tanks tho, nice video. The Russian Dude (who's pro-Ukraine) now has to blurr footage like this. Very good channel, he has all the actual updates on the frontline each day. Just advertising him here a bit now I'm at it
I wonder how many AFU Leopard 2s the Russians have knocked out over the past several days?
how much?
@@user-xw2os2fu5p Tens of them.
That's not much tho @@ZhaoYun3154
thats one hell of a cope cage
Interesting wideo
He is ike Geoguesser for tanks
Ukraine tank knows it should be the only one out there. Russian tanks dont, probably spotted it but thought for a moment maybe one of ours, bmp gets shot, nope.
"It popped smoke" 10 meters above where it is supposed to be.....
Technically speaking it wasn’t a tank duel, tho it was a duel still in the literal sense of the term. Either way, good on the Ukrainians for fucking up that BMP!
At 2:17-18 something exploded/hit the ground near ZSU tank
Source: Ukraine Spring Offensive 2023🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Since the video asked the question, here is my answer. NO
The middle vehicle was hit by a mine.
I don’t overtly disagree with your conclusion of a mine. That said, why would Ukrainian infantry move into a minefield to take prisoners? There are far safe for ways to make that happen!
Perhaps they weren't aware of the mine/mines. Think about how many have been placed since the start of the war. Must be millions. I can't even remember where I put my car keys.
The tank got lifted up off the ground dude. It was a mine
It was an anti tank mine which infantry cant set off as it requires too much weight/pressure
@@hanzup4117could also be only AT mines which don't trigger on infantry
@@heyho4770 True
Sometimes I forget that Ukraine also has soviet tanks along with western tanks. From the top it's not clear if it's a Russian T72 or Ukrainian T72, although the Russian ones usually have Z or V somewhere.
Ukraine has less than 200 Western tanks, and more than a thousand are Soviet
You forgot the O group
@@i_cri_evertim O group?
@@DNG12900 its zov not zv
Banderites love to paint Z and V on them, too. Especially on their destroyed ones. Also fascinating when you got a burned out tank, but the paint of the V or Z is all fresh.
more markava vids plz !
Tank specially ukrainian not go to the front without cover,mines or infantery antitank rockets,I see a lot of videos where leopards have companions of a lot of AT soldier 10+ thats a lot of AT,and is rarely but ukrainian not have so much tanks avaible thats why they do that Ukranian need surender or no men for the future
Ambush is still ambush
"Sergey Chemezov, the Head of the russian Rostec state arms corporation, announced that in 2023, the russian defense industry increased tank production sevenfold, according to news media, controlled by the russian government. Based on these claims, Russian military "expert" Viktor Murakhovsky calculated that the country's defence industry supplied the Russian army with a staggering 2,100 tanks of various types in 2023, ranging from T-54/55 and T-62 to the latest T-90M Proryv." "Cancian, senior advisor at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. “To produce 400 complete tanks per year is a huge endeavor,” he said. “By comparison, the U.S. roughly currently manufactures 100 per year"
Yeah but the US isn't fielding 70 year old T55s.
Why would the Ukrainian tank not engage the Russian tank first? Surely that is the immediate threat. The video is cut, and apparently geolocation is inconclusive, so may be something other than what it claims to be.
It never ceases to amaze that in the comments of every redeffect video. without fail, you have people calling him a pro-ukrainian propagandist and a pro-russian propagandist at the same time.
russian armored column in ukrainian propaganda- one tank and two cars xd
BMP and BTR = cars, ok
@@user-xw2os2fu5p armored cars, ifv, not event light tanks.
Still makes it an armored column tho @@nanab256
Are the russians trying to cross their own minefields?
It honestly can be a possibility.
So you title the video for clickbait effect and then explain in the video that the title has nothing to do with the video. Excellent coverage.
😎
all these are mine explosions
Oh damn I'm pretty early
Shit happens. RIP to all heroes who lost their lives
Те самые Российские Брэдли) Тот самый украинский т-90))