Student group brings Palestinians, Jews together in dialogue
2024 ж. 26 Сәу.
40 244 Рет қаралды
Atidna International is a student group founded by a University of Texas at Austin student with the goal of creating a space for Jewish and Palestinian students to engage in conversation.
These are the kind of college students that I pray my daughter will find her peers. ❤
For generations, Mothers and Fathers have taught their children to hate. Children are not born hating others. These young people are a miracle.
As their parents work their ass off at 2 jobs to pay their tuition. Over my dead sons body!
You don't know anything about the Palestinians Nicole take a f****** seat
@@guybeingaguyexactly none of these kids work for anything they don't know how so self-entitled I could care less what happens in Gaza we're not supposed to all be together it is what it is
@@MaryHartman-ei9pvIt’s been that way for a long time old man, even during your time. Also “self-entitlement” naturally comes with Youth.
“I could care less what happens” - It must be nice to live with so much privilege
God bless y’all for being brave, standing up and challenging all the paradigms that control our understanding of what’s right and attempting to reconstruct the meaning of what Americans see as freedom both at home and over seas.
Genocide and refusing genocide. I guess there is a middleground to be found. Portraying picking a clear side in this debate like mutual incomprehension is outlandish, we"re way past that
Thank you 🙏🏾
The younger generation will quite possibly save our world with efforts like this - to talk, reach mutual understanding, and eventually peace ❤
You do understand they have been throwing rocks at each other since the pyramids and I have underwear older than all of them. Light another bowl and dream another dream. Go to Haiti and bring some brooms!
referring all problems to what you call if ( children/ ((young)) ) is not correct and age discrimination , practically its smartphones, tiktok, insta and social media Gen, which basically does'nt have certain age limits , also deviding people into nonsense age limits,groups and generations is blind age discrimination , same time ignoring all other influencers, journalists who done great work ,and ppl who woke up from all different ages. simply now conditions are different , if there were no such smartphones, socials and internet now you wouldn't have seen such movements.
Hope this attitude multiplies and prevails.
I hate how medias portray these protests. People aren't okay with US full onboard with supporting a genocide. At some point, centrists refusing to recognize this help this situation to persist.
Now this is what politicians should be following. Instead of a war, it should be a roundtable of conversations to talk about problems people are facing like adults.
And yet my generation doesn’t have enough power in voting or in politics it’s mostly a bunch of older people that are stuck in the past that are leading we need new intelligent young people in politic.
@@Windds intelligent young people need vote in all elections and run for positions in govt. That's how we make an impact. We are not powerless in this.
Pro human being. Listen to these unbiased young people tell us there is hope for the world.
referring all problems to what you call if ( children/ ((young)) ) is not correct and age discrimination , practically its smartphones, tiktok, insta and social media Gen, which basically does'nt have certain age limits , also deviding people into nonsense age limits,groups and generations is blind age discrimination , same time ignoring all other influencers, journalists who done great work ,and ppl who woke up from all different ages. simply now conditions are different , if there were no such smartphones, socials and internet now you wouldn't have seen such movements.
What works in the US doesn't work in the Middle East. Naive snowflakes
Great to see young people engaging in the kind of dialog that their adult counterparts seem unwilling to have.
young isn't the opposite of adult, adulhood orginally and biologically is the start puberty, and later defined number 18 .
thank you! we need to spread love not hate!
Where is the hate in fighting a genocide ?
@@hfaouzi4332 where's the hate in responding to stealing our people you're not getting a f****** thing until we get our people back and that's how simple it is do you know what an eye for an eye is you crossed the line with the people of Jesus Christ now you suffer the consequences and Allah is not helping you lol 🙏✝️✡️🇮🇱🙏✝️✡️🇮🇱 we are in charge of your destiny you're just not getting it yet you're not getting it yet Jesus Christ is King we're running the show now pack your bags
@@hfaouzi4332genocide from hamas they only play victims wake up
@@hfaouzi4332 War is being presented to us as a tribal land conflict which is very real but the parallel economic war seems to be between economic power brokers. In the west it’s the silent investors of companies involved in the war based economy. It seems to me that it is the economic war that is far more in control of the actions of the government leaders than the tribal war. Hamas, an extreme religious war threat, was given countless billions of dollars to purchase an endless supply of armaments (largely Russian) They built Gaza into a fortress designed for guerilla warfare. It is a given that Israel cannot have rockets endlessly raining down on its population and that they would respond with the use of billions of dollars of war product to eliminate the source of the problem. What was a local tribal conflict which may have resulted in the loss of hundreds of lives now becomes a global threat with the potential loss of millions of lives and this has been happening all over the world, particularly in Africa. Where you happen to be standing in either war will totally change your perspective and the picture becomes much more complex than any individual person can fathom. These people in this video will find peace in their lives regardless of what is happening in the world and the more people like them, the better.
Which genocide. The one Hamas did on October 7. The war would have ended the day Hamas gave back the hostages. Hamas chose not to do that. They started this war.
The adults are probably pissed that the young gen is not indoctrinated
young isn't the opposite of adult, adulthood orginally and biologically is the start puberty, and later defined by number 18 . those are clearlly post puberty biological adults, and over 18 legal adults. referring all problems to what you call if ( children/ ((young)) ) is not correct and age discrimination , practically its smartphones, tiktok, insta and social media Gen, which basically does'nt have certain age limits , also deviding people into nonsense age limits,groups and generations is blind age discrimination , same time ignoring all other influencers, journalists who done great work ,and ppl who woke up from all different ages. simply now conditions are different , if there were no such smartphones, socials and internet now you wouldn't have seen such movements.
It's good, but the premise is a bit odd: many Jews have been at the forefront of fighting for Palestinian liberation. Depicting Jews as somehow all being somehow tied to Israel is also wrong.
It’s not surprising that these media outlets ignore groups like jewish voice for peace, things get more clicks if you split people up and sensationalize things that aren’t actually bad
Unite in the light or perish to the darkness
The most intelligent thing students have done about this conflict.
If all were to read about the history of the WW2, we would have solved the conflict easily. Find what is the root cause which is the Israeli occupation happening on Gaza and the West bank. If we stop it, we will have peace in the future...
The occupation exists because there are many Palestinians who view the whole land as occupied and want to fight for it. It is unclear how large that proportion is among Palestinians, but it is clearly significant. Right or wrong Israelis think that Palestinians will continue to attack them once they have a state. The more paranoid Israeli view is that why would we give them a state when they will then just attack us? Cycles of violence on both sides push the other to be more extreme, which is why we see Hamas control over Gaza, and the most right-wing coalition in Israel's history today.
Occupation is a lie. You got nothing from this
This is what Hindu and Buddhist perspective is all about. Om Shanti to these enlightened young souls
But still the BJP blame their country problems to Muslim. It just like how Hitler blame German problems because of Jews. What astound me was, Muslim in India are the same dirt poor as their Hindus counterpart in the country, and still being blamed for the India economic problems. I can understand why Hitler want an easy scapegoat for German economic problem when Jewish community whole lots of gov millitary and even corporate banks and industry in German. But it still wrong.
I wish I could give these two men a hug.
❤❤ just LOVE for these fine people
Why don't you bring Jews from both sides instead, stop acting like it's a Jewish vs Palestinian thing, equating a foreign governments view as same as all Jewish people is rediculous and these protests have major Jewish attendance
these protests do NOT have major jewish attendance, almost all jews support israel maybe it feels like theres attendance at rallies because pro-palestinians categorize them as "one of the good ones"
Plugged your ears
You guys are so amazing!
Such profound insight. Let these young people lead the world into the light.
This! Can we please have more of this? I love these students' willingness to be vulnerable and potentially criticized by their families and friends.
Sounds like a good group, working for peace
Human solidarity. We come into the world the same way, we bleed, we hunger, we thirst and we long to be safe and free....all of us. This is wonderful....so proud of these young people.
"This century should be one of dialog." Dalai Lama (paraphrasing).
One side is concerned with human life, the other side is repeating the genocide in Gaza. Anti War does not make you anti-Semitic.
You are anti-semitic because you're pushing anti-Israel propaganda. You are lying and creating a strawman scenario to demonize. THAT is what makes you anti-semitic.
If you describe it like that, you don't actually understand the situation. You need to join a dialogue (or trialogue) group like the one presented in this video.
These students are the ones that will make the difference in the future an show be given more air time then the crap out side
Who said the conflict in Gaza is between jew and Palestinians. No matter of fact it is about occupation and injustice.
True, but media censorship doesn't wven allow rhe mention of words like genocide , ethnic cleansing, occupation, etc. So this is just window dressing coverage.
Discuss before Oct 7. The Nakba, massacres ... the future.. it is not about civility, its about the genocide going on now.
It's not it's the Arab league vs Israel and the U.S because if they colonize Israel with global support they will come for Europe and the west next, as seen by the protests they've already done a really good job.
Gaza is not under occupation since 2005. And that made things worse. The sad true is that if Gaza had been under occupation, 7oct would have not happened. Palestinians have a real problem with their own society and how they inject irrational hate on their childrens.
When was the state of Palestine established?
wow they see both sides it’s so rare to see someone so moderate and reasonable these days ❤
Hats off to these students
This is not a Palestinian and Jewish issue. The media is over simplifying the heck out of this. The vast majority of protest organizers are Jewish. This is a humanitarian issue.
Vast majority. And SJP is a national group doing a lot of the driving of this. If you say Palesitiniens are animals or call for the killing of all Jews, it is indeed a Palestinian/Jewish issue. It is also a god issue. Stupid old tribalism and dangerous deadly faith.
The vast majority of jews support the war
Nope. Terries we berries
Why would you bring a "Jew", do you mean "Israeli"? The confounding of Judaism with the state of Israel must stop.
Its a lot harder to find an Israeli than a Jew, a Jew might have family in Israel. But yes, I agree with you.
@@SerpenttineOkay, instead of “Israeli”, say “Zionist” then, because the point still stands that Jews aren’t a monolith and shouldn’t be treated as such.
Just a few hours ago I saw a video of college students (or pretend college students) with Muslim head coverings blocking an entrance of UCLA so that a Jewish student couldn't pass through. And you think it's just about the state of Israel and Israelis?
@annonimiss6422 they are blocking Everyone, not just 1 group of people silly
@@napakapa1046 not just blocking...but also throwing anti-semitic slurs, to the point that the said jew had to hide his identity. I wishe they were just blocking, apparently not. They are pushing jews not to be openly jews
much love and respect
Peace and Love from river to the sea.
Israel will be free?
@@nacorcarmonablanco4414 PALESTINE WILL BE FREE*
One of the rare objective coverage on this matter and positive energy
Never compromise with an abuser. The right people will always get along with others. But predatory individuals will never sit-in on meetings like this. It's either they leave people alone. Or they go to jail.
🤦🏻♀️
A dialogue is what we needed in this horrible and complicated conflict between two peoples. I agree that we can be both pro Israel and Palestine all at the same time. And we definitely should condemn Hamas and Netanyahu’s actions pray for both people 🇮🇱🇵🇸
Amazing there is no other way forward but peace!
This gives me hope for all of us.
This gives me hope for the future ❤
What a breath of fresh air!
This is awesome ❤
If they listened to speaker Mike Johnson they would never had a chance to speak to each other. Trying oppress freedom of speech is a symptom of fear of the truth
Wrong. You don't understand the bill
it is like the neck trying to speak with the sword
Who is who
Thanks ABC for covering this. These young students give a sense of hope for the world and future generations to come.
It is not about religious fighting...it is about colonialism project. Foreigners settlers come to the land and claims with violence
Get out of your Marxist bubble
Aka radical Muslims. Jews lived there long before Islam existed.
I, too, am afraid. But I find solace in knowing that this group is committed to keep this dialogue going... for OUR FUTURE.
These people have a brain
Being pro-Palestinian is comparable to feminism - just because you support the one that is historically oppressed does not mean you hate the other side, you just want freedom and equality.
But zionists claim we’re lying when we say that and that we’re nazis, because the right media has convinced them of that with propaganda.
Palestinians are only oppressed by radical Islam. Israel has just existed, and they are attacked for it. Also feminism has also been hijacked by extremists.
Also the attitude on campus shows Jews and Israel absolutely are hated. What world are you living in?
True😊
A glimmer of hope and peace❤
These people in this video will find peace in their lives regardless of what is happening in the world and the more people like them, the better.
Respect
Love it!
Thank you for this ABC
This is how it’s gonna happen
This is holy and Godly!
dude, you need an Israeli in the room.
We are one family.
The future
Take notes Mike Johnson!
This is what we should do everyone live in peace together.
No compromise on freedom and full equality.
This man needs to fix his brow on god.
"Heal the world. Make it a better place, for you and for me and entire human race. They are people dying if you care enough for the living. Make a better place for you and for me." - Michael Jackson.
Conclusion: There should be no Palestine. Palestinian can thrive in the state of Israel but vise-versa is not true.
Sorry you're wrong. There was a time when Palestinians welcomed European Jewish refugees during and after the Holocaust. How did they repay that kindness? Stole their lands, killed their people and oppressed the ones that remained. Jews, Muslims, Christians all lived in peace before the British betrayed Palestinians and formed an alliance with Zionists. This is about occupation. Zionism is racism. You have to acknowledge the wrong before you can heal. Stop ignoring the injustices that happened and are still happening 75 years later to Palestinians. If there is such a thing as "the chosen people," I believe they are Palestinians. Who else could bear the pain for as long as they have?
Please allow the protesters to watch "Screams Before Silence".It's available for free and provides testimonies from women involved in the October 7th massacre, including footage of Hamas from the event.
We are moving backwards in this country
It’s been like this since Bush
Pro peace all along ❤
ICC considering issuing war crimes arrest warrant for Netanyahu.
That’s probably one of the dumbest thing I’ve heard all day
Is the person the head of Hamas ?
Netanyahu is the Good Guy and Hamas is the worst of the worst who committed the heinous genocide in Israel on October 07, 2023 killing innocent civilians, raping women, decapitating babies and putting them in ovens, if you are a supporter of Hamas, SHAME ON YOU !
@@androsc1418 Is Amnesty International the head the Hamas? Is the head of Human Rights Watch the head of Hamas? No? Then why did they classify Israel as an apartheid state where Palestinians are treated as second class citizens. Israel can act like this is an act of antisemitism but it is not. We are protesting against war and genocide, which Israel is committing.
“ICC considering issuing war crimes arrest warrants against Netanyahu, others”. The Jerusalem Post 4/18/24
"we are all human" "WERE all HUmaaans" "We are all Hooooman" Okay, that's great... doesn't solve anything, but yea... thanks for pointing that out I'm so dumb thank you!
you are the problem
Ah... how about before we all watch this and get teary eyed, just a peripheral observation and question: how is it our democrat run Universities are selling 1/2 all enrollment spots to FOREIGN applicants of ANY nation, over that of US citizens and TAXPAYERS?
Ah yes the ugly part of America lives well in you, morons like you don't realize that most students protesting 80% are American and 40% protesting are Jews so stfu you loser
1. Irrelevant. 2. Profit. Hope this clears things up
Foreigners pay more, which means the school has more money for US-citizen students. I graduated from UC San Diego; more than half the students were foreign, and most were from Asia-primarily Chinese, Indian, Korean, Japanese, Arabs, Iranians, and other East Asians. We also had a large number of Europeans. I was one of the only Mexican-Americans, which at the time was about 7% of the student population, and in a state where half of the population was and still is Mexican American.
It isn't just that they pay more, but that the pool of people in the world is much larger than the pool in the US, thus by allowing ourselves to have such a huge pool of talents to pick from, more talented people can be found. It is beyond doubt, that the US's current scientific dominance is owed largely to us taking brains from other countries.
@@LasaroMorell I think what you say is true, but the foreigners also pay more. I'm sure the university likes the extra money.
🤔interesting that most were identifying as hyphenated Americans…excepted for the masked one
very small and eloquent young folks.
Hamas won’t like this
No, you won't like this. But as they say, ignorance is bliss.
Nazi zionist wont like this 😂😂😂
IDF and Bibi wouldn’t either 😂
Plus Netanyahu would hate this
لَا يُؤَاخِذُكُمُ ٱللَّهُ بِٱللَّغْوِ فِىٓ أَيْمَٰنِكُمْ وَلَٰكِن يُؤَاخِذُكُم بِمَا عَقَّدتُّمُ ٱلْأَيْمَٰنَ ۖ فَكَفَّٰرَتُهُۥٓ إِطْعَامُ عَشَرَةِ مَسَٰكِينَ مِنْ أَوْسَطِ مَا تُطْعِمُونَ أَهْلِيكُمْ أَوْ كِسْوَتُهُمْ أَوْ تَحْرِيرُ رَقَبَةٍ ۖ فَمَن لَّمْ يَجِدْ فَصِيَامُ ثَلَٰثَةِ أَيَّامٍ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ كَفَّٰرَةُ أَيْمَٰنِكُمْ إِذَا حَلَفْتُمْ ۚ وَٱحْفَظُوٓا۟ أَيْمَٰنَكُمْ ۚ كَذَٰلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ ٱللَّهُ لَكُمْ ءَايَٰتِهِۦ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَشْكُرُونَ , , . ,, ...
Blessed are the PEACEmakers. Hopefully, From now on, hopefully many, many, many more people will finally believe the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ and finally be saved and have everlasting life. Amen. LOVE.
Genocide does not need dialog
I spent this week very sad about what is happening on college campus' but now suddenly I feel like theres hope and still great gen zers out there
While you were sad about the protests, the good people around the world, like the protesters, are sad about the children in Gaza massacred daily by Israel.
@@lbs7774 Virtue signalling. I put it to you that the people in the video care more about the children in Gaza than you do. You only care about how they serve your purpose.
@@naomiharbour7841 What a sick twisted mind you have.
Am i the only one who just wants both sides to co exist?
❤
FORGIVENESS “Now his older son, upon learning that his father has slaughtered the fattened calf for his brother, became angry and refused to go inside. ‘Look,’ the son said, ‘I have never disobeyed your orders. But you have never given me even a young goat. Yet for him, you slaughter the fattened calf!’ The father answered, ‘Son, you are always with me, and EVERYTHING I HAVE IS YOURS. We had to celebrate and rejoice, because this brother of yours was dead but has come back to life - he was lost but has now been found.’” -Luke 15:11-32
Except the leaders and elites are different from the common views!
I tried to ask a Palestinian protester where a bathroom was and she was like, “NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ARGH YOU CANT TOUCH ME NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO ARGH NO NO ARGH NO NO NO!
This is nice. I’d say it’s almost ‘cute’ . Unfortunately is far too late for dialogue to save the war /conflict. It’s never too late to keep trying and these efforts are noble and worthy - although believing that their little group will cause peace to reign is fantasy . Their vigils and group therapy is nice for the feel-good in a college campus but worthless in the real life situation in the Middle East /Gaza
These people and the peace makers in Isreal/Palestine will find peace in their lives regardless of what is happening in the world and the more people like them, the better.
the cutting edge question that could make or break this dialogue is: Do you condemn the Hamas assault in October 7, 2023?.
These young people are well meaning, but I really don't think one can remain neutral on the issue of Zionism, any more than one could remain neutral during the Civil War, WWII, or the Rwanda massacres.
Wait… but why are they having conversations? You get more accomplished when you block roads, set up tents, and yell the same phrase over and over while not listening to anyone trying to talk with you.
What do you think a protest is, smart aleck
There are 10,000 religions in the world. Is it logic if we said each religion has the right to exist in a separate country 🤔?? Of course no We respect to jews in all religions. No religion has the right to kill another nation to exist in a separate country
Having Dialogue is a First step, so this is Interesting especially during uncertain times. October’s Very Own, I had no idea when I bought my umbrella 🇨🇦 🇺🇸
Talk is good. Muslim history is Destructive
The title of this video says it all. Why are you bringing Palestinians and Jews together and not Palestinians and Israelis? There are all sorts of religions in the Palestinian ethnic group, including Christians and yes, Jews.
Ahh yes…brings some faith in humanity back in me….but we’re in Murica folks…spoiled by a blessed Geography. We can say whatever the shite we want…bless our old folks who decided to bring us to these lands before the fights began…not just in the middle east but the rest of the globe. What we should do is talk…reach agreements…then go help fight…but…it’s just talk nowadays so more suffering will happen.
My best friends in college were Jews . They were even better friends that some Arab friends .
There are Arabs in Israel living alongside Jews, Christians, Muslims, Bedouins, Druze, All are different Arabs. Who are the Palestinians!?
Then why have a different set of rights for Jews and different for the rest of the people? Why can't "Arabs" as you said, vote? Why have a system of apartheid? Israel's own human rights group B'tselem published their investigations and findings. Why are Israelis taught since they are born that Arabs are inferior? Look it up. Read.
I don’t care about Gaza
❤
Pro Palestinians protesters and pro Israeli students should get together for the cease fire of Palestinians civilians and Israeli hostages both victim of this conflict especially now
I would ask the Jewish kid=> "Go travel a week to the occupied Westbank and maybe Gaza and let's see how this both side-ism will fall flat in your sorry face!" Israel = occupying apartheid force, Palestinians = oppressed people... You can't both side-ism this subject, especially after the current onslaught in Gaza...
90% supported Oct 7, hamas happily kills their own people, the leaders even celebrating the deaths of their own kids. It's a death cult.
I understand what you're saying but I do think everyone in the group agrees what is happening to people in Gaza is inhumane. What it seems like what they are trying to do is to explain their experiences and issues as Palestinian or Israeli students by attempting to bring to light about how the extreme polarization are causing them to be silenced, at least that's what I interpreted. I hope that makes sense!
@@tartapple8090 I understand, my whole point is that this whole narrative that history started at 07th of October or even asking the question "do you condemn the Hamas attack on the 7th of October?" shows how disingenuous the media depicting this conflict is. International Law stands with Hamas (as controversial and horrible as this sounds for a centrist, leftist or right leaning person) Occupied people have the moral right to resist oppression using violence. There is not a single instance in human history where the oppressed resisting occupation didn't make mistakes... (Regardless of EU /US putting Hamas on a terror list)
They probably know more about it then you do. And they are also closer to a viable solution then you are.
@@naomiharbour7841 "They probably know more about it" ===> Are you certain? That's a bold claim. In terms of viable solution; you can't come up with a solution unless and untill the Jewish part admits THEIR part of the problem and how it affects dystopian ways of living for the Palestinians TODAY... In terms of who is going to sacrifice the most when coming to a viable solution; it sure as hell won't be the Palestinians. Since they suffered the most! Israel created a horrible society where they can freely chant the eradication of Palestinians and even now they are protesting for Netanyahu to use EVEN MORE FORCE!!! Even inside Israel they get less facts on the ground than International News Media and that's beyond atrocious! If even Israelis saw a fraction of what is happening today, they would be horrified! From surviving Holocaust to turning Gaza into a death camp. How ironic and cruel! I bet those that fled Europe to Israel today would turn in their graves! This artsy liberal co-gathering is a flop...
Sadly, the whole conflict is derived from religous views and agendas. Humanity and human rights has nothing to do with it.
War is being presented to us as a tribal land conflict which is very real but the parallel economic war seems to be between economic power brokers. In the west it’s the silent investors of companies involved in the war based economy. It seems to me that it is the economic war that is far more in control of the actions of the government leaders than the tribal war. Hamas, an extreme religious war threat, was given countless billions of dollars to purchase an endless supply of armaments (largely Russian) They built Gaza into a fortress designed for guerilla warfare. It is a given that Israel cannot have rockets endlessly raining down on its population and that they would respond with the use of billions of dollars of war product to eliminate the source of the problem. What was a local tribal conflict which may have resulted in the loss of hundreds of lives now becomes a global threat with the potential loss of millions of lives and this has been happening all over the world, particularly in Africa. Where you happen to be standing in either war will totally change your perspective and the picture becomes much more complex than any individual person can fathom. These people in this video will find peace in their lives regardless of what is happening in the world and the more people like them, the better.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇸🇩🇸🇩🇸🇩
Stop genocide. They must know/ understand the history of Palestinians suffering.
Propaganda
A whole lot of talking about talking without actually talking.
Loveree 🇵🇸❤