Thailand's Deep South conflict: Is there hope for peace?
2024 ж. 1 Сәу.
112 310 Рет қаралды
In Thailand's Muslim-majority Deep South, authorities and the region's main separatist group are making fresh attempts to broker a peace deal. But is the path ahead as uncertain as ever?
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service for must-read stories:
Telegram - cna.asia/telegram
WhatsApp - cna.asia/whatsapp
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
TikTok: / channelnewsasia
Terrorism has no religion , but terrorist have common religion. 🤔
Bom Bali 2002 😢 Mereka tidak bisa menerima perbedaan
@@GalihAji-ks3wz mereka lu bilang, klo memang begitu cara lu berpikir, jadi bisa ku anggap bahwa kelompok lu juga berpikir begitu ya. Dah klo begitu cara mainnya, udh dari dulu bakal diadakan pembersihan agama selain islam. Tapi nyatanya?
@@GalihAji-ks3wz klo memang islam mengajarkan begitu, udh pasti lu dan keluarga lu g bakal ada bro...
@@KacangTasty agama biang rusuh
@@GalihAji-ks3wz bukti nya dong, klo dimana agama itu sendiri yg nyuruh rusuh?.
There's something wrong with Islam. Same here in the Philippines. They want to make there own country. As if Sharia law is the most perfect law.
It seems every country has their own palestinian problem. Now it makes more sense why Hamas went after thai and philippino people in Israel without any pause.
Infidels will be calm in Muslim-majority countries but Muslims will be harassed in infidel-majority countries. Do you understand at this point? 🇮🇩
@@user-su8ny5eu7g same in Muslim countries. They force Christians to be Muslims. Muslims force their way of life, their religion, and law. Example Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, etc.
And which country support Terrorism across South East Asia? It's Malaysia.
@@user-su8ny5eu7g don't understand fiction.
These people cause problem everywhere
What people?
@@kicokuciii islamic people
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in southern philippine but its between British & Spain.
@@ctyramzi r u joking? No one can seperate Thailand. Malaysia always need more land.
@@themak3647 What it has to do with Malaysia. Malay-pattani the one who demanded for independence from Thailand. Stop blaming Malaysia if Thai gov. cant give equal right to SouthThai native.
This religion of peace will never find peace until they put every infidels to rest in peace.
Haters gonna hate
@@trueteentrue is lame is a hateful k ult
You mean Israelis? Cool
Bruh it's cultural not religious specifically . U must not have watched the video.
They don' t interact with the majority always blaming. Thus creating lots of trouble until Thailand government gives in. Same goes to southern Phillipines. Create a homeland and expand
Muslim majority province in a non-Muslim majority country. What could possibly go wrong?
similar to a non Malay majority city dwellers compared to Malay majority country, they can always come to Malaysia, Malaysia will gladly accept them.
The main cause is economics, even if they reunite with their race in Malaysia or lndonesia, they will likely remain poor and find a new scapegoat to vent their frustrations of poverty onto.
that province used to be from an old muslim kingdom pattani
@@ectas741 haiz… the poor me who still live as a minority in an poor economy nation like Malaysia.
@@rollinghippo2940 but that begs the question, how far in history do you want to go until it is justify the situation? For example, the area used to belong to Jews but later on Arabs, so…. It is used to be Pattani but now is Malaysia.
it is an Islam thing? Not really surprise, seem like a common culture among them
No. It also happened in Indonesia where the majority is christian (mollucan RMS and papuan OPM)
i agree. I'm from Southern most part of the Philippines. They want to make their own country. An Islamic Country.
Yeah only Islam stands upto injustice and is ready to fight that, other religious groups just gets converted to sheeps, and licks boots of those in power
And wherever British went, they got out by creating a border problem and British mostly went to Muslim majority lands. Example, India Pakistan, Israel Palestine, etc
No, its a thai thing. Imagine if thailand didn't invade patani. Patani is malay, the same culture as malaysia. Imagine if siam was still under burmese rule and they revolted, bet you would be calling them freedom fighters lmao
I am Filipino and i believe Muslims should have their own Nations and should not live in a Secular Nation. They cannot adapt to secularism and causing conflicts. So I believe they should be given their independence and in turn, Indonesia and Malaysia should also give the non-Muslim communities their independence because being a minority in a Muslim State is also horrifying. So I think Muslims should only live in Islamic Nations and Secular Nations should have no Single Muslim population.
it's not going to change, look at muslims countries like Pakistan, Algeria, etc,.. after getting their own muslim country, they just run away to secular countries, try to change them and espect the country to change
are you suggesting thailand should give out part of their country to Muslims?
True
@@uriels4097just like in uk...muslims go there to change the law of that nation
East timor?
I'm Thai and I do believe things that is going on in Southern Thailand is similar to what happened in Northern Ireland during The Troubles - It's not about religion but rather than nationalism. Trust me, even people there were Buddhists, some of them would still act like this because they consider themselves to be Malay rather than Thai.
Same with Philippines.Never thought it also is happening in Thailand. I now see that every country has an Islamic problem when they are not the majority but has enough number to occupy a region.
Nah. Read the history. Malay and Thais have been figthing since they were both hindus and buddist. Thais were the invaders from the North, just like how Indian views Pakistan.
but arent they the good guys according to the leftist? 😂😂😂every Nation had a muslim problem
Malaysia Funded it, they want to expand their territory 😅😅
@@MeltzTorralba In 1914, there were Muslim separatists in the Philippines. In Thailand, there have been Muslim separatists since the 18th century. Malaysia was founded in 1963. How come the separatists still exist before Malaysia was formed? Stop blaming others, blame your own incompetent leaders
@@srikandisuryavarman222 wow. A Malaysian bot, coming from Indian descent
Here I feel the world needs to learn from the Chinese. They have done an amazing job in taking care of separatism.
You mean the Xinjiang concentration camps? Yeah, sounds about "right".
No we don't like greedy
To greedy
Lol they are the opposite of separatism, they actually take the land and sea 😂
meaning muslim trouble makers
Islam strike again🤣🤣🤣
You mean Air Strike?
you mean islam killed 35,000 in gaza?
In Malaysia we also got Siamese people but Malaysian nationality we never got conflict with them,they rule is simple just be respectful and embrace the differences
👉☪️😅
because muslims are in charge there will be no problem..
Because Siamese are kind people, not like Malays , disrespect other ethnic but also same time claimed everything what other ethnic have as you call "warisan".
@@deanbowie3774yeah, what do you want? Everything? Why so greedy?
@@deanbowie3774 Do you agree that Malaysia should follow Thailand's approach and force Chinese and Indians living in Malaysia to speak Malay, use Malay names and abolish vernacular schools?
Another Religion of Peace same Problem here in the Philippines
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in southern philippine but its between British & Spain.
@@ctyramzi Same...very same. Their reasons for a separate region? Heard it before.
@@jmvs5294 they're belong to malay not other
@@thetruth7962 so can the Chinese claim everything because they say they were the first? Can these people become separatist then? Indian-Americans? How about black-americans returning to Africa as they have a problem with whites? How about Australians to go back to England? Do you see the chaotic effects of this mindset? How about filipinos going back to Borneo and parts of Malaysia as the Tabun man are the original settlers of the Philippines? Like where will it end?
@@jmvs5294 they're belong to malay nothing similir to u
Thailand's South Muslim should fully assimilate with Thai majority instead of making troubles like separatism / terrorism. Thailand government have been showing much of tolerance yet still getting hands bitten by them.
Hard baby, its the religion of peace. You can see that no matter which part of the earth, they will have conflict with anyone.
@@chuayeongwei3019 Do you agree that Malaysia should follow Thailand's approach and force Chinese and Indians living in Malaysia to speak Malay, use Malay names and abolish vernacular schools?
never gonna happen, patani defeat thailand many times in the past and they will sure defeat them again soon. patani is a malay muslim nation with thousands of years of history starting from langkasuka more than 2,000 years ago. their genetics shows that malays are indigenous to the region while thais came from china and only invade the south in the 13th century ad. out of all people you have the least right to say this to patani malay people.
oh really? i could say the same thing to chinese people but i'm not racist like you@@chuayeongwei3019
@@srikandisuryavarman222 Unrelated. Malaysia is Malaysia. Thailand is Thailand. If you are Thai Citizen you must speak and be Thai. You can speak other language and practice culture too, but need to understand Thai culture and language first. Very simple. Thai people very happy people for a reason. In Thailand, the Thai people will always come first. Not another country or people. Because Thai people care about other Thai people. Nothing will change that. And it is important to take care of your own people first. Only then you can take care of other people.
Whichever part of the world, as long as a certain religion of peace is involved, violent happens
As always.. who else you expect.?
Only china has the antidote of this pandemic
@@Prashant-im5mr yeah as cruel as it is
@@Prashant-im5mr anti dose is nice but living conditions with no freedom is hell xD
Same goes to Indian here
They should take inspiration from the Phuket Muslims and Satun Muslims who identify as Thai and not with Malay separatist identities.
As a Malaysian Chinese, I think it is possible for Thai Malays to identify as a Thai citizen while keeping their ethnic identity as Malays. If Thailand is unable to settle the conflict, sorry to say but I think Thailand should cut its losses and allow Patani to be independent
Satun n phuket thai Muslims are the weaker part one. But in those 3 region they are of a great kingdom of malays. Greater than malacca sultanate. The fact that the thai is stealing this great kingdom and annexed them. It's like Singapore n Johore splitted into two diff entity.
@@yokelenglengOr they could just become refugees in Malaysia.
@@yokelengleng How Thailand was built and how Malaysia was formed were totally different. When the modern Thailand was built it was already ruled by a one powerful ruler (the Thai king), on the other hands, Malaysia was formed by negotiations and cooperations between different Malay states. Cutting Singapore out back then, then was not a big deal for Malaysia. The countries that historically have one strong ruler, unified land and never been colonized by the west like Thailand or Japan, separating parts of the land is "the most serious crime", it is a thick red line that people are willing to sacrifice their lives to protect it.
@@forlua9211 ohhhh thanks for the info💪
I was in Pattani a few weeks ago. It does not feel like I was in Thailand. The 7-11 does not sell alcohol nor does it sell tobacco. All women are required to cover even if they are not Muslim. Women are rarely seen with the exception of the elderly women. It was different.
Don't know what the rebels are fighting for what. Even if they snatched the land away from thailand it's not as though they can merge the lands back into Malaysia to begin with as that will create conflicts between Malaysia and Thailand. Form independence then? Just a small piece of land caught right between both Thailand and Malaysia. You think you will have good life and good days ahead even if you got these lands? Wake up lah.
Fundamentally two different groups of people. Thai speaking Buddhist vs Malay speaking Muslim.
Separate by tongues aka language but ultimately united and tied together by the same currency unit aka money. If can't get along then don't speak just focus on making more money to live better instead. Interracial marriages will also dissolve identity issues away as well too. These are border territories villages not capitals and metropolis. Want to live in peace or want to live in violence it won't made a difference in their lives nor change their destinies in it. It is their choices whether to want to live a peaceful life in their lands or turn it into a living hell instead. I choose the former if I am a part of them.
Malays in malaysia of course will support what the rebels are doing even though it is killing innocent people in thailand. They dream of merger with satun, song kla, narathiwat, yala. They always justify violence with something else even during british administration long ago.
เพื่อพระเจ้าของเขาไง เขาฝันจะใช้ชารีอะห์แบบในกลันตัน
They're fighting for cultural rights. It's literally mentioned in the video
I see you Singapore. I guess Singapore reminding and keep reminding Thailand not to build that Kra Canal. 😅😅😅
Thailand should build the proposed land bridge and give the land separated by the bridge to the separatist. Problems solved. Everyone have ""temporary happiness"" until money runs out.
To begin, the railway is far far away. And any canal wouldn't be a threat,the time savings is negligible. In fact lower end shipment can go through that canal. Russia and that Arctic route is the real threat.
No, this was not about the new canal plan. This network is an Israeli agent
CNA is like CNN or BBC with Singaporean flavour.
Malaysia behind it.
There's no proof Malaysia behind it.
Here in Malaysia we literally trying to send the seller of Shoes that resemble the name Allah to jail becareful of Malaysia everyone
Yeah i saw they jail people to eat in day time and non Muslims cant sell anything
Not surprising for malaysia government Even the time SEA game was held there they rig it
Without LIES, Islam DIES
It's truth ur lies
Report je
the truth. 😂
@@thetruth7962 ey no disrespect Mohammed married 9yr and that A truth and fact of Islam xD also kinda SUS
Five provinces of Southern Thailand (Pattani, Yala, Narathiwat, Songkhla, Satun) which predominantly Malay Muslims were under Langkasuka (Old Malay kingdom) from 2nd-15th century, then from 1457 until 1902 were under Sultanate Pattani. In between in year 1786 it was conquest by Siam (Thai) and the last Sultanate was deposed in 1902. In year 1909 The Bangkok Treaty (Anglo-Siamese) has separated Malay Kingdom 5 provinces remained under Siam (Thai) and 4 Malay states (Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan, Terengganu) in Malay Peninsular under British administrative until gained independence year 1957. Malay provinces in southern Thailand considered still under occupation of Thailand and Malays/Muslims forced to be assimilated with Siamese cultures and language. The Thai government had relocated many non Malays/Muslims to the south to balance the demographic of Southern Thailand population. They also develop tourism mostly in the south and most of them not respect sensitivity of majority Muslims beliefs/cultures who are native to the land. Many Thai Malays new generations lost their mother tongue language and cannot speak Malay fluently anymore mostly in the western part eg Hatyai. Malay Muslims been discriminated by Bangkok government in terms of job, education opportunities etc and until just recent years more opportunities given to the communities due to resurgence as their voices never been heard before.
Just like what happens in Sabah Borneo. Same tactic different country.
But as NOW nobody force them to assimilate and y'll can still speak Malay lol(read the book xD) government maybe shitty but most regular thai people not go out of their way to disrespect malay Muslim belief or culture lol And for discrimination of education and job nah that y'all problem people need to get out of their house to work and go to school lol
@@NekomiyaTH Easy to say after hundreds years of discrimination and prosecution, their land been taken away..similar to Israel towards Palestinians.
@nikhassan7713 first of all thai and middle East totally different in severity And second people can't compromise and living with what they have lol it already mordern day people still can't talking it out lol.
@@NekomiyaTH Most Thai people especially non Muslims don't know how Malay Muslims were struggled during Siamese occupation since hundred years ago, many Muslims murdered, tortured.. even in this century. Just ask Thai Malay Muslims and you will know the real story as I have family and relatives of Thai Malay Muslims.
Ahh religion of peace again
Ah...a Cohen, what do you expect? They're fighting for their culture, language and their rights. The religion is not being oppressed. Know your facts, watch the whole video, Zionists.
Ahh jews again
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help.
@@ctyramzi I mean we didn't go out to enslaved lol(maybe we do but then it get abolish later on xD) and under thai flag y'all still free to practice Muslim lol getting land back not like gonna make people of patani going to win 50 million dollar lottery lol.
@@ctyramzi stop spamming ...desert cu1t
Oh muslims? 😮 I'm so surprised!
Melayu + muslim...😂😂😂😂 Kombinasi sempurna
@@GalihAji-ks3wzlu paling pendatang ,Atao Londo Ireng
Southern region of Thailand are more related to Malaysia Peninsular by culture and religion. Anglo Siamese Treaty 1909 made them to separate....
I'm a Singaporean and iv been living in Yala South Thailand for about 7 years and the conflict is not as bad as you think it only occurs once in a while but what I wanna say is that the Malay are Native to the five southern most province in Thailand its their Homeland which was seperated thanks to none other then the British who are mostly the main source of conflict worldwide iv been living amongst the Malays and the Thai Muslim and they don't hv a problem at all the only problem is that the Thai government is trying to Ethnicly wipe them of their identity culture and language there's a whole Wikipedia page dedicated to it, I myself have experience first hand in the inequality disrespect and insults that the Thais say to the Malays sometimes when they can't speak thai well enough in the officials rub it in their faces reminding them that they are a people defeated so accept the defeat and speak thai which is commonly made by high ranking officials or doctors "probably corrupted one" it is because of these people that makes the majority of the Malays feel disrespected and the desire for their freedom and atleast or if not the majority of the malay people have experienced this atleast once in their lifetime this is why the Thais and the Malays don't get along and live in separate villages or neighbourhood and I can say this because I have lived with these people for 7 years so to them this is a big problem because Islam and the Malay culture is deeply intertwined you can't seperate Islam from the Malay culture and these people hv a rich history of Islamic Knowledge and they are proud of it so by trying to erase the language and culture and forcefully assimilating them into the Thai custom is an insult to them and their religion and making them feel less equal and respected and less muslim, this is quite true and you can see the effect it has made in the neighbouring province of Satun (Google it), the Malays hv tried couple of times in the past to establish an autonomous state down south but after nine attempts by the malays the Thai government tried to end the petition by using violence and assassinat one of their leaders (haji sulong) this resulted in the malays taking up arms and fighting back for their rights over a land which was taken by the Thais over 300 years ago the Thais could hv ended this conflict 60 years ago but Thailand wasn't keen on giving up 4 provinces and wanted full control over them and the people so in summary I would say Thailand was the one who caused all this, for example there are around 20000 Thais who are not native to Malaysia living in Malaysia but there is no conflict between them and the Malays because Malaysia understands peace and Respect them for who they are and allowed them to maintain their cultural identity traditions and language, so there was no reason for them to be upset with the Malaysian government same goes to Singapore but for Thailand on the other hand did the exact opposite, I'm not sure if this conflict will ever end but I can assure you that the situation is not as bad as it sounds, skirmishes rarely happens and the local Thais aren't even that disrespectful towards the malays it's mostly the officials who are so if peace was to prevail the Thai government would have to respect all races and not try to impose the Thai customs on other people
thank you very much sir
mmmm... Sorry but are you saying that every country that has a conflict with muslims is because of the gov't? Why is it the same in the Philippines? Indonesia? In the west? In Europe? in Africa. The only exception is if a country is majority is Islamic. So don't lie.
Whats the core of their separatism view? Different race/etnics or because religion?
@@garfield2742 because of religion. They don’t a democratic governtment to rule them. Especially the Islamist. In the Philippines, we made peace with the progressive muslims and everyone are represented in the govt. Both muslims and christians now push for change peacefully and without terrorism but only if they let go of the Islamist Terrorist ideology.
@@jmvs5294Honestly yes, it is. Islam strongly influences people's lives, from daily habits to the application of its laws. This influence is the type that dominates in all aspects. Therefore, as their numbers increase or become more influential, the "old ones" feel marginalized. However, the problem is, Muslims only take care of themselves and are proud of their own identity. Contrary to the old one, using methods to suppress Muslims by trying to erase their identity or something, not the way Muslims do (by spreading).
In Indonesia, the provinces of Aceh and Papua are also currently in conflict
Aceh end in 2004 Megawati era. Only central papua now
@@carkawalakhatulistiwa freedom acjeh and papua Allahuakbar
@@da_ve13591free you from evil virus in your mind, don't spread propaganda and make conflict for good people living in peace.
Aceh no more conflict oredi lah
Udah habis gam
if there's a Religion of Peace involved? i wouldn't be that optimistic at all.
i didnt know Israelis/zionist/IDF are muslims
Every country has its own problems, and separatism is one of those problems.
Like Malaysia & Singapore?
@@wanhaziq9880 sorry, you guys are out of league of those countries
@@f.s.firdaus8106 ohh you from Indonesia no wonder
@@wanhaziq9880 yeah, you from Malaysia. No wonder
@@f.s.firdaus8106 Its not our class either to have conversation with a countries 128 years behind of our education system
Whole world is suffering from one religion
ITS not about religion. South Thai people(malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand and british. Cause that land didn't belong to thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai native (Malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in Southern philippines but ITS between Spain and british
This the problems in many country even in the Islamic Majority country. This is happen in Myanmar, Thailand, Indonesia, and The Phillipines.
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help.
@@PK-se2jh And this is not Europe unluckily… we know our own history as natives in here where British steal our land and separate our land into 6 countries. Better make research for yourself 🥱
@@PK-se2jh Yes, our ancestors are Hindu-Buddha, Before all of us voluntarily revert to Islam. Hindu-Buddha also not native of Southeast Asia because our people worship the nature at the 1st places. So in Hindu-Buddha era we still practiced Hindu-Buddha & worshiping nature until islam modernisation. People like you always thought muslim is being brainwashed by religion, while you are the one who being brainwashed by western media. Most of you can’t even differentiate between religion & culture (islam=Arab)🤣. Our people didn’t copy paste American / Arab news like other countries did. We always get fresh news, so West/Arab propaganda didn’t work for us. Especially when you try to twist the facts. *Free references for you:* Buddhism and Hinduism have common origins in the culture of Ancient India. Buddhism arose in the Gangetic plains of Eastern India in the 5th century BCE during the Second Urbanisation (600 BCE - 200 BCE).
@@PK-se2jh People like you always thought muslim is being brainwashed by religion, while you are the one who being brainwashed by western media. Most of you can’t even differentiate between religion & culture (islam=Arab)🤣. Our people didn’t copy paste American / Arab news like other countries did. We always get fresh news, so West/Arab propaganda didn’t work for us. even though you try to twist the facts. Yes, our ancestors are Hindu-Buddha, Before all of us voluntarily revert to Islam. Hindu-Buddha also not native of Southeast Asia because our people worship the nature at the 1st places. So in Hindu-Buddha era we still practiced Hindu-Buddha & worshiping nature until islam modernisation. *Free references for you:* Buddhism and Hinduism have common origins in the culture of Ancient India. Buddhism arose in the Gangetic plains of Eastern India in the 5th century BCE during the Second Urbanisation (600 BCE - 200 BCE).
@@PK-se2jhthis problem Will never be happen if those west never colonize other countries and draw country Border without care how cultural related those people
Base of Religion religion religion again and again conflicts, sad isn’t it ?
Easy money maaaa no need to pay ads one liao i oso like if liddat
Read history. Thai invaded them
@@ernestoguevara8599you buz lims have no shame
Know their history.. not like singapura we gave up to Chinese because stupid our leader give independence to Singapore
Compared to worldwide wars based on racism, nationalism, liberalism wars based on religion is nothing
Peace ? Muslim ? sure ?
Seems like an oxymoron eh?
Cristen? sure ?
ur comment is amusingly ignorant and indicative of your absolute lack of depth in knowledge with regards to history.
@@carkawalakhatulistiwa It's true though. Countries with Christian minority don't have issues, but could you say the same with those countries with Muslim minority? lol
@@kzm-cb5mrthese abdoul doesn't like if people tell the truth
6:44 ก่อนที่จะไปพูดถึงผลประโยชน์คุณปฎิเสธิรึเปล่าว่า BRN ไม่มีจริง? ถ้าเขาเลิกก่อเหตุ ทหารก็พร้อมออกไป เเต่นี่ไม่เลิกเองเเละมาอ้างอะไรเรื่องผลประโยชน์ ถถถ
เพราะเค้ามองว่าฝั่งของตัวเองถูก คนของศาสนาตัวเองไม่ผิดไง เค้าเลยโยนความผิดให้เป็นของเราทั้งหมด เค้ามองว่าคนพุธไม่อยากอยู่ร่วมกับคนมุสลิมถึงมีปัญหา แต่จริงๆแล้วเรื่องมันเกิดจากชาวมุสลิมบาง(หลาย)คนอยากจะแยกประเทศให้เป็นประเทศมุสลิมเลย เสนอให้เราเปลี่ยนมาใช้ภาษาราชการเป็นภาษามุสลิม ใช้กฎหมายเค้า ใช้การปกครองของเค้าเอง คือถ้าจะขอขนาดนี้นะใครจะให้ได้ถามจริง!! แล้วกับมาดูที่ว่า ไอคนที่ไม่อยากอยู่ร่วมกันจริงๆอะมันใคร เราหรือเค้า? อยากให้คนพวกนนี้เปิดหูเปิดตามาดูที่ภาคกลางบ้างว่าศาสนาต่างๆเค้าอยู่ร่วมกันยังไง เค้าก็อยู่กันไม่ได้มีปัญหาอะไรเลย
@@nekoyama5460 อยากได้ดินแดนคืนนั่นแหละ xD ได้คืนก็ไม่มีอะไรเปลี่ยนแปลง lol
oi Melayu dekat Thailand, kalau tak suka undang undang thai, keluar dan balik Malaysia/Indonesia 😄 jangan bebankan negara
dirorang jadi orang malaysia ok gak..boleh meriahkan kedai makan siam kat malaysia
these melayu in indonesia and malaysia keep telling chinese minorities to go back to china or go to singpapore same with the india minorities too 😊😊
Bagus juga, boleh tambahkan lagi ramai Melayu di Indonesia/Malaysia. 😇✌🏻@@nannon2934
@@nannon2934but that land belong to malay, they were colonized by siamese why you want them out from their own land?😂 israel huh?
@@zmc2585 It has nothing to do with Malay. All about Islam Chiang Mai has no problem. The northeast has no problems even though it is occupied as well.
If Yala, Pattani & Narathiwat is still Buddhist Majority, this case of separatism won't happened... it's also the old problems: Muslims values can't be aligned in other cultures I don't understand...
@Broskisnowski I mean if we go back to the era of Indianisation like the time of Tambralinga in the 10th century, then all of those areas were Buddhist (and Hindu).
@@user-jt3dw6vv4xHindu but malay. That's malay land so stop saying your land
@Broskisnowskilearn takbai thai soldier killed innocents people and then you want them to forget about that?
It is not about the religions, Muslims live peacefully in other parts of Thailand. One should blame the nationalism.
Southern Thailand origin is Malay Hindu Buddha kingdom
muslim separatist in the Philippines and Thailand are supported by Malaysia
In 1914, there were Muslim separatists in the Philippines. In Thailand, there have been Muslim separatists since the 18th century. Malaysia was founded in 1963. How come the separatists still exist before Malaysia was formed? Stop blaming others, blame your own incompetent leaders
Yea, those should learn the real history ( not the stupid western history)
@@srikandisuryavarman222what kind of stupid reasoning is that. just because they existed earlier don't mean they can't be supported now. my parents and grandparents existed before i did, that doesn't mean i don't support them now.
@@srikandisuryavarman222He meant Malaya... You see Thailand having problem with Muslim. Philippines having problem with Muslim, Europe having problem with Muslim, US having problem with Muslim, China having problem with Muslim Xinjiang. Malaysia predominant Muslim in the West denigrate the predominant Christian Sabah and Sarawak. Sabah and Sarawak is lightly esteem..
@@truthful3777 There are differences between the circumstances faced by Muslims in Thailand and the Philippines and those in Western Europe. Muslims in Western Europe are refugees from the conflicts that Western nations have committed. However, Muslims in Thailand and the Philippines have been fighting for independence in their native lands. On the other hand, China has no problem with Islam. but there are problems regarding separatist groups such as Hong Kong, Tibet, Inner Mongolia and Uyghur Muslims. Hui Muslims in China live a very peaceful life. By the way, Sabah is a state dominated by Muslims. Islam and animism were Sabah's two biggest religions even during the British colonial era.
Very informative
There is only one cure in this world for deeply religious folks too entrenched in their faiths and for uneducated people who feel faith is more important than anything else in this world. They need to be introduced to both science and secular education. Only this can break the spell and hold religious doctrines have on them. Bring them out of their legends and lala land and they will start to wake up and see this world in an entirely new way.
It's always good to remember and honour god but all people need to learn one simple thing in life when approached and facing clergies and religious institutions. Ask them to prove and produce proof of what they are trying to tell you. The minute you learn to do that they won't be able to touch your mind anymore.
God speak to you from within and through his creations. You want to find and connect with god you have to do these things. What you cannot do is to listen to people who are trying to tell and convince you they are teaching and speaking to you on god behalf. Anyone who do that you can ask them to go fly kite already.
Did u even watch the video ? Or is the english is not sophisticated enough for u? 🤔
Kind of hard, I bet their parents themselves are religious, who are not exposed to science and secular education. Lets say a newborn who are exposed to science and secular education for 8 hours and 16 hours to some 7th century desert cult teachings. In the end, which side do you think that the newborn will lean to?
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help.
here in the philippines too
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in southern philippine but its between British & Spain.
Not only in Phillipines but in India too
@@ctyramziต่อสู้เพื่อเอกราชที่คุณหมายถึงโดยการไปฆ่าครู พระสงฆ์
@@ctyramzi indigenous people in Mindanao were Lumad and Negrito people. not related to Malay
@@ctyramzi come and fight back only one 🇹🇭🇹🇭💪💪🔥
what peace do you expect from the malay people?
Suddenly the southern thailand conflicts awakened in singapore news? is it due to Kra cannal latest update?
i was thinking the same. actually the separatists group has no active member. most of them just 'give up' or dissolve
Killing in the name of their deity. Most religions abandoned that centuries ago.
Hope the issue is resolved peacefully, separatism is not the answer. Love from Indonesia~
The one who sent separatism agents are Indonesian. It is similar like what you guys did in Mindanao, Philippines
@@Ryo-my6jk Can you enlighten us with your proof?
@@muhammadrizkihidayat6440 the mindanao alone already the big proof. The separatism group were consist of Indonesian people
@@Ryo-my6jk Waste of time, you claim something but can't provide credible evidence. Shame on you
@@Ryo-my6jk Remember that in the past, the Philippines was the largest supporter of Timor Leste separatists in Indonesia. Even the Philippines is backing Indonesian separatists in West Papua.
I hope the case in southern Thailand is resolved so that the people can live peacefully
If I remember right, Thailand's southern violence was not originally an Islamic militancy by nature, as Thailand has a great degree of religious tolerance (even as far as the old Ayutthaya Kingdom, Muslims worked in the Buddhist Thai government with no problem). In fact there are even a lot of mosques in Thailand sponsored by the Buddhist government, many are found in the north (Chin Haw and Thaified Arab-Persian community) and many Thai Muslims did attend Buddhist schools to get monkhood experience. Weird to see how this violence transcended into a growing jihadist network like now.
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help.
When Phibul Songram was Prime Minister of Thailand, he passed laws to restrict freedom and economic dominance by the Chinese. Chinese schools and Chinese newspapers were dissolved. On the other hand, Plaek Phibunsongkhram set in motion of a process of Thaification which had as its objective the cultural assimilation of the Malay Patani people, among other ethnic groups in Thailand. By 1944, Thai civil law was enforced throughout the land including the Patani region, over-riding earlier concessions to local Islamic administrative practices. The school curriculum was revised to be Thai-centric, with all lessons in the Thai language, to the detriment of the local Jawi. Traditional Muslim courts that formerly handled civil cases were removed and replaced with civil courts run and approved by the central government in Bangkok. This forced assimilation process and the perceived imposition of Thai-Buddhist cultural practices upon their society were irritants to the ethnic Malay Patani.
Tolerence my ass. Read Perang Musuh Bisik. 2004 clash. etc
@@ctyramziBritish didn't help anything and they not happy with this war and Pattani got defeat easily that the brit has no time to take any action.
But how many non-muslim religious worship place has been sponsored by govt. is I$lamic majority countries ? Ans. Zero 😢
A truly peaceful ideology: -in conflict against atheists in China -in conflict against Christianity in UK, France, Ukraine, Balkan, Armenia, Lebanon, Nigeria, Syria & Iraq -in conflict against Hindus in India & Kashmir -in conflict against Buddhism in Myanmar, Thailand & Sri Lanka -in conflict against Judaism in Israel -in conflict against fellow Muslims in the Middle East, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen & Indonesia
You forgot to mention Philippines. Hahaha
Separatist movement is not exclusive to 'religion of peace'. Almost every religion / ethnic groups has it own separatism, which is the advocacy of cultural, ethnic, tribal, religious, racial, governmental, or gender separation from the larger group. IRA, Basque, Catalonia, Tamil Elam, West Papua, Donesk, Crimea, Transnistria, Quebec, Tibet, Taiwan, even Scotland want to separate from the UK.
@@Resol26 yes. But if in the a secular country and they reach atleast 5 % in population. They want to install Islamic government, and sharia law.
Islam is the problem here too
I remember celebrating Songkran in Yala province few years ago. I was so surprised seeing armed policemen guarding the Songkran prayer ceremony.
Seriously, I' thought the fight was permanent stopped years ago. I' was waiting for traveling there. Look like have to reconsider.
Yes and no. many former separatist in Malaysia told they currently have less active member. meaning the group actually under ceasefire or dissolve. sometimes thai govt fake terror attack to blame them. i think the group you should be worried is drugs cartel there not this group.
Now known as Nakon Si-Thammarat, before that Ligor, and before, Tambralingga.
So what? get patani yet?
@@lolsiahsahf The main point here is that Thailand's thaification is rather extreme. Making minority groups, including the Malay, Chinese, Khmer, and Mon, adopt Thai names
@@srikandisuryavarman222 thaification?!?!?! 🤣 idk why meleyu like spread fake news so much why dont you try search parliament speaker name is that thai name or some islamic name???
@@srikandisuryavarman222 sungai kolok is not even thai name its need to rename to thai or something thats not meleyu?
@@lolsiahsahf Maenam Kolok 🇹🇭 Sungai Golok 🇲🇾 - A golok is a cutting tool, similar to a machete, that comes in many variations and is found throughout the Malay archipelago.
Thank you CNA. This gives me a better understanding.
Actually, all these nationalism and theocracy goals, they are just modern creations. There is a simple reason Thailand can rule over Pattani. The people are similar enough to the ones in Satun or Songkhla. If they were to actually speak their Pattani I wouldnt be able to understand them anyway. Maybe the Kelate know what the hell they say.
They are Malay ... they speak malay with patani dialect... I can clearly understand what they speak event I am not kelantanese ...
@@idolakunizar that's because you learn your standard Malay. Kalau cakap Pattani, kami pun tak faham.
They refuse to be a sexpat destination.
yeah they malay, im from indo actually supprise they dialect more smillar indonesia dialect. I even understand what they said compared to subtitles.
Why didnt this video mention bangkok agreement 1909 ?
because CNA has a nefarious agenda
peacefull community in action 😂😂😂 did this everywhere, so typical
Kunci pintu surga ada padanya 😂 Awas kamu nanti masuk neraka 🤣
Dari pada kaum Pilihan Tuhan Tapi Genosida Anak Kecil
Diam keling
5:11 เเมนๆ หน่อยลุง บอกไม่อยากเเบ่งเเยกดินเเดนฟังเเล้วกูเขียม เเผนบรรได 7 ขั้น คืออะไร ถถถถถ
Got Malay staying there, they think the land belong to them.
You mean the land that consists predominantly of Malays and whose main language is Malay. That's because it used to belong to Malaya before the British decided to give them to Thailand.
Of course. That land is Malay land..hence we called it "TANAH MELAYU"...land of the malays. Malays live there long before thai people live in thailand.
@@kelantan4k842 are you sure belongs to Malay any proof, how come the province name Thai word
The Brits are masters at this. They did the same for Palestine, they did the same for Chinese-India McMahon Line, Pakistan-India. Purposely trying to divide and cause future tensions.
@@samchan3240 read history & demographics bro. It shows you don't know history or ignorant. My family lives there, 90% of the places name in these provinces are still officially in Malay, not converted to Thai language. These 3 provinces are 95% Malay Muslim, only 5% are other ethnicities. They used to be ruled under the Patani Sultanate together with Kelantan as 1 state. British & Thailand made an agreement under Bangkok Agreement in 1909 that conceded these provinces to Thailand & nullified the authority of the Patani Sultan.
Thank you CNA for this, I never knew about this!
😂😂😂. Where do you live. If you in South east Asia, dude i pity you
what does the royal family have to say about this conflict? that wasn't discussed here. curious
How to build canal in such a troublesome place?!
Did Singapore funding them?🤔
the peaceful religion strike again
The Philippines knows how it feels the same kind of people who do conflict in the southern area, guess which country is near both Thailand and Philippine's southern part
If You Cannot Fix Your Problem Don't Push The Blame To Other Country
@@sayfolman7752Agree, but Malaysia like to blame western and singapore too😂
@Broskisnowski Oh? What religion did Philippine natives believe before Islam came to the region then?
The Malaysia shade 😭
@@user-xp5xn2vy3l Animism, Hinduism and Buddhism. Rajahnate of Butuan, for example, was a Hindu-majority kingdom in Mindanao, southern Philippines.
Basta pg my mga muslim tlaga, magulo, mahilig cla ng gulo at gyera.. iba kc mga pag-iisip nila..🤭🫣🤫
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in southern philippine but its between British & Spain.
@@ctyramzi // fight for independence for long time for their native land how can ISLAM OWN LANDS? how can someone own lands in the name of religion and not call it colonialism? when others do it is colonialism/imperialsim BUT when Islam/Muslims do it, its for their INDEPENDENCE cause they were native to that land? youre saying MUSLIMS/ISLAM is NATIVE in SOutheast Asia? get lost.
@@lifeisgood9789 Did I say Islam native in southeast Asia? I say it’s the land own by Malay-pattani who is native and muslim. It’s clearly seen that you never know about their history (kedah-langkasuka). The oldest empire in Southeast Asia. My question to you- Did christian native in southeast Asia?
@@ctyramziPlease check all the conflicts around the world, majority of them points to one entity and you knew what it was. Even in Europe they want to impose their Sharia Law
Who said they are religion of peace?
ITS not about religion. South Thai people(malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand and british. Cause that land didn't belong to thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai native (Malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in Southern philippines but ITS between Spain and british
Deep south is already 50% or more Muslim probably due to Thai government neglect of this areas. Building the Kra Canal is suicidal for Thailand. It’s like giving this part of Thailand to Malaysia. Couldn’t Thailand let the Muslim people in this area migrate to Malaysia if they so wanted, with the blessing, incentives, mutual arrangement, etc from both countries. If one want to live here one have to call themselves Thai, NOT Malaysian (Since one is still in Thailand). If one want to call themselves Malaysian than they should migrate to Malaysia. Otherwise peace will be very difficult to come by here in Deep Southern Thailand.
They're not Malaysian, dear. those are ancestral land of northern Malays. you can't simply ask them to migrated to Malaysia while the Thais migrated from north to south. it's their homeland not for thais.
They call themselves Malay, not Malaysia. The southern region of Thailand is & forever their home. They have every right to stay there.
They can be Malay under thai flag? And they can live there even they gain independence nothing gonna change in that region.
00:08:18 This is a good summary of the conflict ... "Regardless of your religions and your skin colors, if you speak Thai and you behave like Thais, you are Thai" ... Thailand was created based on so-called "Thai values" which refer to 1) Central-Thai language 2) Thai cultures. As we all know Thailand does not pursue multiculturalism but instead prefer a "culture-based homogeneous society". In Thailand, we have Thai-Siamese, -Laos, -Khmere, -Chinese, -Mon, -Vietnamese people, nowadays all these people identify themselves simply as "Thai", we don't have a distinction between different races, for example, Thai-Chinese, Thai-Laos, etc don't see their Chinese, Laos, etc heritages as identities but they see them as decorations, added values or something to be appreciated. In daily life, we don't live in separated communities unlike in Malaysia or Singapore. ... "There is relatively no racial conflict in Thailand" ... Thaification (Thailand's assimilation process) indeed killed some non-Siamese cultures but also adopted/absorb many non-Siamese cultures into the Thai culture, and most importantly, it get rid of one of the most challenging problems of humankind, namely "a racial conflict". To kill some cultures but to save several million lives from being killed from racial conflict, isn't it worth it? Cultures can be revived and recovered but people lives cannot be resurrected. ... What I have just described two paragraphs above and what has been explained at 00:08:18 are totally different in ideologies, and that is "the root of the conflict". It is a choice between "Being Thai who is living in Thailand and being proud of Melayu heritage" vs "Being Melayu who is living in Patani State and being proud of Melayu heritage".
i am glad Thailand stays strong! resist the beginnings!! if not we all see how it ends, there are multiple examples in history
💯👍🏼👍🏼
So what's malays doing in 🇵🇭 and 🇹🇭?
Fighting for independence for their land! Because it belong to them not Thai people. Malay kingdom already exist in 1st century (Kedah & Langkasuka) way before Thai came to Malay peninsula. It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help. This situation is same as southern philippine but it between British & Spain. They are Malay pattani and southern thai is their native land. Thai people should moved to north Thai instead of them move to Malaysia
There's no malays in the Philippines
@@srikandisuryavarman222 Really are you sure?
@@ctyramzi Yeah sure. The Muslim-majority Philippine ethnic groups according to the Bureau on Cultural Heritage (BCH) of Bangsamoro include: Badjao, Iranun, Jama Mapun, Kalagan, Kalibugan, Maguindanaon, Maranaw, Palawanon, Molbog, Sama, Sangil, Tausūg, Yakan ©️ Wikipedia
@@srikandisuryavarman222semua dunia ini adalah Melayu gimana sih😂
Long live the Malay Patani from Sultanate of Magindanaw in Southern Philippines.
This is not about religion. Yeah, Thais do not forbid the Pattani malays to practising Islam. But most of the professional works and government sectors in the South of Thailand are dominated by Thai immigrants from the north while native Malays are denied to work in that sectors. Only a small number of Pattani Malays work in professional work/government sectors even though it is their land. You can see in the provinces of Satun and Songhkla used to be inhabited by the majority of Malays now these provinces are inhabited by majority of Thai immigrants from the north
Just like everywhere, its the same peaceful people that have a violent conflict to separate the part of the country.
ขอบคุณที่สนใจประเทศเราครับ
Look at siam people in Malaysia.. they part of Malaysian and consider as Bumiputra but they practice thier religion without gov intervene... while Malay in Thailand struggle get thier right and even have to died to protect thier own land
Dealing with malays is easy.. but you have to accept if you lose or win.. we dont protest but we will fight for our own right with anybody who interfering our custom/religion ...all this problem create by colonial master.. they take part of malay land and give to Thailand which known as Siam back then..they the one should be blame for.. iam malay from Malaysia, we dont have any issue with thailand.. we consider them as close neighbour and we share a lot of similarity...
@@RadziNayan yes i was shocked when i know that siamese people are also considered as bumiputra in Malaysia after what they have done to the malay peoples in pattani, kedah, singgora and other northern malay states. better give bumiputra status to baba nyonya though.
@@ezwan7656 the goverment used to give Bumiputera status to Baba/Kristang but they were exploited by the newcomers. The bumi status was then revoked. These days, you can't distinguish Baba from the newcomers anyway.
@@ezwan7656 indeed.. after google it now i know. Most people might not notice the fact that Baba Nyonya has the status of Bumiputera, However, due to political reasons and the change in social status in the regions, especially in Malaysia, Baba Nyonya has lost its prestigious status when a policy by the Malaysian Federal Government was introduced that showed all Baba Nyonya are categorized as Chinese. Better give to them bumiputra cause they practice Malay culture.. if chinese in Malaysia dont want to integrate with malays they have to learn from baba & nyonya how they assimilate in Malays State.. somehow different from chinese Mainland... Nowadays hard to identify which one Malaysian Chinese vs Mainland Chinese.. 🤧
You not even siamese how you know
Thai should respect ✊ southern folks fairly population , they are most Muslim peaceful folks 😊😮
Bro we way respect to them than the rest of the world lol
Is it safe for Farangs in these provinces?
Vietnam does not tolerate these kind of instabilities.
Lucky you , you don't have border with Malaysia in the south India border Pakistan Myanmar border Bangladesh Philippines and Thailand border Malaysia at the south
@@Clarksville000 C'mon pinoy, Separatists in the South of the Philippines existed since the early 1900s while Malaysia existed in 1963. If you accuse Malaysia of funding separatists in the South of the Philippines, but you have forgotten; 1) The Philippines used to fund the Moro people to attack Sabah in the 1960s to claim Sabah. 2) The Philippines, the most vocal country in Southeast Asia, supports the separatists of Timor Leste in Indonesia 3) The Philippines supports and funds the separatism of Christian West Papua in Indonesia.
Oh the sweet irony of watching these Malays fighting for their own identity and language, especially considering what their brethren in Malaysia and Indonesia did to their minorities.
minorities in Malaysia ( chinese,Indians,Punjabis ) are not Natives of southeast asia.
Malays are also ethnic minority in Indonesia.. People think Sunda, Java, Bali, Dayak people are Malays, but they're Not.. They're the same Austronesian family, but different ethnic group.
I’m from indonesia and while I support the thai gov in this conflict, you are mistaken. Malays make up less then 10 percent of indonesian population
In malaysia, malaysian chinese and indians are free to practise their religion and tradition, their ethnic language, traditional cloths, celebrate their traditional and religious holidays and even vernicular schools.
Thats malay land they were colonized by siam of course they will fight😂 or are you supporting colonisation?
Islam brings trouble anywhere!
ITS not about religion. South Thai people(malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand and british. Cause that land didn't belong to thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai native (Malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in Southern philippines but ITS between Spain and british
for your info : one upon a time, the south thailand is the part malay region, but when the british invade the malay, the invader seperate the land, the north malay a.k.a pattani, yala, narathiwat and give it to thailand without permission from malay sulthanate,
For your info: When a land is conquered, the victors get to decide what to do with it.
It has nothing to do with Malay. All about Islam Chiang Mai has no problem. The northeast has no problems even though it is occupied as well.
@@Rockman-qo7zyc.m,, minority,,not same😅😅
@@alcyoneaquila9670 Yes, not the same. Khmer minority, Mon minority, Indian Chinese minority, all of these have no problems. (Burmese also)
Malays in Penninsula are immigrants different ethnic group from Indonesia Archipelago. Bugisnese, Javanese, Boyan, Banjarnese, Madurese, Acehnese, they occupied land of Orang Asli. This different ethnic group in Penninsula transform become Malays, i mean Fake Malays, because Malayization/ ethnicization
People need to understand that earth is a place to live and let live and heaven is a place that is only accessible when you die. By trying to bring heaven to earth, that's when we have a problem.
The Religion Of Peace at work as usual.
There are seperatist rebels in Indonesia in West papua and Maluku. Are these Muslims?
They have balls to fight against injustice
It’s not about religion. South Thai people (Malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand & British. Cause that Land didn’t belong to Thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai natives (malay) land with British help.
@@AzmiBesar weird isnt it, that it is always christian or muslim separatist... wonder why 🤔
@@LethargicShaman are Tamil tigers in Sri Lanka muslim or Christian? 🤔😂😂 Just asking - thats 1 of the biggest rebels seperatist group.
To be in thailand is better than in Malaysia or seek independence. Thai Baht is so stable and strong now. FDI injection also better than malaysia. Once they complete the land bridge southern thai will prosper. If they build the canal southern thai automatically become a new singapore.
similar to Indonesia, separatist groups often carry out acts of terror, such as Papuan Christians or there are examples that are now independent, such as Timor Leste. Previously they were Catholic terrorist groups.
Maybe ask yourself if Papua is truly Indonesian territory?
@@Skiddo0284 Based on the UN it is very clear that Papua is part of Indonesia.
Palestine stand with free papua.
They doesn't like the fact. @@Skiddo0284
@@ismail_soekarnopoetraBased on the UN back in 1947, there is a State of Israel but no mention of Palestinian State. Does that make sense also?
No. If they can't even keep the peace between their own political party rivalries, how can they even try to bring peace in the area that is far away from their capitol?
But why are other areas peaceful but only one area has problems?🤔
who caused all the violence?
May all have freedom!
Sabah and Sarawak!
Ya Allah berikan pertolongan dan jalan keluar untuk sauadara kami di Patani
❤BE A BUDDHIST LIKE YOUR ANCESTORS AGAIN AND HAVE A PEACEFUL HAPPY LIFE IN THAILAND,,,,,LIKE SRI WIJAYAN TIMES,,,MELAYU BUDDHA
Oh yeah sure Buddhism is so peaceful that the deadliest wars that Thailand ever faced was with Myanmar and Cambodia, who are both BUDDHISTS
@@blueshirt26 BUDDHA TEACH PEACE,,,,,,DAJALLIC LEADERS FIGHT
@@MAHAMADAMAHAMADA-wb2ep Islam also even if in an alternate scenario they are still Buddhist I don't think they're gonna be happily ever after
We all know who support these separatists.
Why attack Thai land ? Muslim n other nation live peacefully .
Because Pattani is Malay.. but British give it to Siam in 1909
@@motorcyclesdream6921British never give Pattani to siam in 1909, Pattani is under siam control before that, in the other hand in 1909 Anglo-Siamese Treaty of 1909 make siam to transfer theirs own land like Kedah,Kelantan,Perlis and Terengganu to malay(British protectorates)
@@phimmawat5433 Siam must give Pattani back to Malay.. its simple like that. Even British give Tanah Melayu back to Malay.
BBC Asia try to make SEA citizen fight among them self.
If you look at the staff from Linkedin NO SINGLE SOUTH EAST ASIAN
The higher up of the two group want money to flow so they continue the conflict that will never ends, Thailand always is so corrupt and that's always the case, that's why there's so little information about this conflict, we have a road that building for 50 year and it never end because higher up get to eat tax money.
The four provinces in Southern Thailand, Yala, Narathiwat, Satun and Pattani if integrated with Malaysia will probably form backend of Malaysia heartland. But they are happier as they get to retain their Malay identity.
You think Thailand will cede sovereignty just like that?
@@1ewi5 I don’t think so. But sometime possessing something doesn’t mean it is a good thing. There are things have to let go. These four states will give the most headache to Thailand and Malaysia. It is something like Timor-Leste against Indonesia, Indonesia against the Dutch, Malaysia against the British. India against the British etc…
Satun isn't associated with this conflict. Most people there are Muslims but they don't identify as "Malay", they identify as Thai.
@@user-jt3dw6vv4x They're still Malay by blood
@@srikandisuryavarman222 Okay and how does that change anything?? They still identify as Thai and view themselves as Thai.
I love how some ignorant just blame Malaysia for some reason
1963 was the birth of Malaysia. Yes?
The problem is the Thai military and the government. The Thai invade Cambodia took alot of its lands. Then, Thai invade Lan Xang (Loas) toke alot of their land also. Later, stole Lan Na their Capital is in Chiang Mai, completely took that country by writing fake Thai history claiming that its thier land and asking British to help them acquire LanNa's land. Lanna people and Lan Xang (Loas) people are force to assimilate into Thai. Now the Thai stole this land from these Native people. Thai history is hard to trust with all fake fabricate news and history.
But someting we can trust in Thai history is that Siam is the strongest SEA kingdom, Meanwhile malay still be colony lol
And unlike the malay Thai people never cry about the land they lose 10000000 years ago in the past.
@@lonelyman6437 It seem you are very young. In this world, everything changes, countries rise and fall. Mongol Empire rise then fall. Khmer Empire rise then fall. Toungoo (Burma) Empire rise and fall. Love is the secret that hold this universe. Think you are strong and better than the other is just an illusion. Soon Thailand going to collapse. The Thai are fighting among themselve and Thai making problems with all their neighbors.
@@noblenb collapse by Who? Cambodian Laos Burmese malay? They are all weak lol. Even the Vietnamese at it peak can't panetrate the border
@@noblenb Fighting among themself? I don't see anyone die yet bruh, accapt refugee form burma employed a hundred thousend of Laos and Khmer worker is defienitely causing ploblem for all neighbour huh?.
I am a Thai living in the three southern border provinces of Thailand. I have been waiting for peace for many years. The military has been indecisive in dealing with Islamic extremists😢🇹🇭
ITS not about religion. South Thai people(malay-pattani) want independence from Thai government. They already fight for independence for long time for their native land to free from Thailand and british. Cause that land didn't belong to thai migrants in the 1st place. Thai steal south thai native (Malay) land with British help. The same situation happened in Southern philippines but ITS between Spain and british
Is it still dangerous for tourism?
its not just about jobs or money. until the thai government sees this they can never understand what's going on
I can't blame them. Muslims are very conservative. Imagine living in country where sexpats routinely are going to. South Thailand like Pattani should join Malaysia because the culture is very similar. It's also same with Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM). The culture of philippines is not suited to ARMM. Philippines is famous for sex tourism now and illegitimate children are very common. The society is not fitted with muslim.
It has nothing to do with Malay. All about Islam Chiang Mai has no problem. The northeast has no problems even though it is occupied as well.
@@BravoCoy cristian separatis in indonesia supported by philippines? Also singapore and australian join the game.
@@ismail_soekarnopoetra Filipinos will not support separatist
Your.idealogy sabah should be free
@@ismail_soekarnopoetra Them are racial.