The non-Muslims in Malaysia and Indonesia living under Islamic policies
2024 ж. 31 Нау.
329 277 Рет қаралды
Jenny Hia once made headlines for refusing to wear the hijab in school despite being Christian. And increasingly, non-Muslims like her in parts of Indonesia and Malaysia have to live with Syariah-inspired restrictions they deem prohibitive.
Read more: cna.asia/3xhV82N
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service for must-read stories:
Telegram - cna.asia/telegram
WhatsApp - cna.asia/whatsapp
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
TikTok: / channelnewsasia
Where Muslims are minority, they want secularism but where they are majority they want siriya law.
لا اله الا اللهFREE PALESTINE🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🕋🕋🕋
@Sdinfotainment7703 Yes, Your Statement is True!
@@vasme-ju1hkWomp Womp should have told Palestiniens to stop lying and acting the victim
@@vasme-ju1hkask all@h. Is he sleeping?
@@vasme-ju1hk go and fight for it IRL.no one give a sh it bout ur false claim
In Malaysia, people can convert from other religions to Islam but not allowed to convert to other religions from Islam.
I didn't know that. The more you know. I think the Malay also hate Chinese/mandarin people
why?
@@crusaderknight4469 Cap 🧢
@@user-rr6qd7oj8snot disallowed but you will face many blockage from the authorities and public backlash might also death threats as it is sinful to them
WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😡I WILL NEVER GO TO INDONESIA OR MALAYSIA! 😡 THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🥰🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL MUSLIM AND WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🥰🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🥰🇮🇳🇮🇳 🥰🇮🇳🇮🇳 🥰🇮🇳
Prime example of why Europe should be worried.
We're coming 😂😂😂u continue to take fake news in medias as usual.
@@thebrainwashedbeliever1inislamwe are waiting kid
@@supersaiyan460 🤣🤣 I'm talking to your 4th generation not u
CNA is misleading news. Just promoting fear.
Europe????????? What's the relevance?????????? Is Europe near Asia???!!!!!! 😂😂😂😂
Islam offended by everything but ashamed of nothing
Those sound very logic. If they become majority, they always have to be the most dominant and their religion laws must be followed and obeyed, even you're not a muslim, especially some of them from the radical and fanatic ones.
Sounds more like communism 😂
You mean Israel
Sounds like zheeoneesm
Literally describing Zionism to a tee
Where's Al-Jazeera now???
Don't worry, Al-Jazeera is still a successful media, what do you want from them?
WOW VERY DANGEROUS SIR! 😡 I WILL NEVER GO TO INDONESIA OR MALAYSIA! 😠😡THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD🤗 🇮🇳 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL MUSLIM AND WOMEN🤗 THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🤗
They are now 🤐🤐
tewwowist sponsor state media wouldn't put themselves at a disadvantage
This is not a big deal..😁wait for anti muslim..news.
56 countries will be silent now, but reverse the situation and you see 56 countries crying for justice. Double standards
They dont like the truth
The 56 countries don't really care much about their brethren if you ask me, except for those in Israel.
What double standards? Explain
😂😂😂
@@incikjaykee1569Non Muslim women/girls forced to wear Hijab by law in indonesia and Malysia hower if muslim women are prevented from wearing hijab/viel in France/Switzerland or any other European countries muslims make hue and cry.This is double standards.
I'm from Malaysia and its true we are facing discrimination here
Yes I also feel the same with you.
what a big lie, stop play victim
Play victim
@@AndrewWes2005 stop lying bro my close friends and neighbors are non-muslim and they and go to church or hold pray in their house fine no problems. I in Indonesia btw.
Ga betah di negeri Melayu pergi cari kenegara asal
Non Muslim are suffering too much inside Muslim country.
It's two local province that west extreme not the whole country
Bahrain is different and doesn't discriminate against other religions yes of course they have strict laws. After MBS Dubai is changing I really need to appreciate this guy...
Yet too many non muslims are dying to work in dubai, qatar, and the muslim countries 🤤🤣🥱
Suffering? I don't feel that way?
@@Bethany_Wongso Dubai, Qatar, and Bahrain never discriminate any citizen like these and one more there more strict rules for Muslim in this country and freedom religious expression is given... I have kept Indonesia in this list but this incident proved to me it's a myth . Whereas in Malaysia there are always incidents of vandalising non Islamic believer sites and having clashes with its minorities..
Not only Europe, UK,USA,India, all countries experience the same attitude by Islam
So called 'progressive' media like AJ+ never reports anything negative about islam, the bias is so obvious to anyone with a critical mind
Yes and too many bend to them
add the hidden migrations of such countries to Latam too
They think people are not watching their hypocrites 😂
if France can force muslims to take off their hijab, then why can't Indonesia force non-muslims to wear hijab? same thing innit???
This is the most dangeous cult out there
Hindutva is catching up and the Jews and Christians were always up there
Religion is being socially accepted cults while cults are not socially accepted religions.
@@fredriksundberg4624 this one is the worst
now world will know what indians and persians have faced
Hindutva is nothing different. Just another side of the same coin
@@priyankarchakraborty3874 lol hindutva means no cate , unity , pure knowledge , women empowerment , freedom congress type hindus means radical islamist
Hindutva is political movement ... Radical movement from hindu you talk something bad about Muslim .. but you forget a few week ago ..hindu temple open in Muslim country ... While Muslim in your country you killed ..now you exposed double standard and hipocrysy
@@priyankarchakraborty3874 far far Much better than islam
Hijab is for respect n before in Hindustan also there was hijab so what is the issue it's teach girl good manner. They are not killing or physically abusing someone like Indian hindu do with Muslims
As a non-Muslim that grew in Indonesia, not all regions supress us with Sharia law, but yes there are still several areas that force us to wear Hijab in Government schools. And, Freedom of Religion is not equal in the eyes of the law 👌
Meccan and Medinan Saudi Arabians are laughing.
That's why I go to Thailand
Latest about Thailand transgender is allow to married@@TitB1199
Saya merasakan hal yang berbeda. Produk halal dan budaya TimTeng menjajah bangsa ini. Kita dijajah ideologi Islam, dan sebenarnya sangat dirugikan. Babi itu sehat dan murah, biaya untuk mendapatkan protein dari babi adalah 1/10 dari sapi. Makanya generasi kita cebol2 dan tak bisa tinggi. Kita menghambur2kan trilyunan setiap tahun untuk umroh dan haji. Satu tahun saja uang umroh-haji itu ditabung cukup untuk membangun sebuah kota kecil.
@@igedeagussukrisnawan7590 emang wong bali tinggi2😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 minoritas dikasih hati ngelunjak
It is interesting that while Arab nations are slowly opening up to minority rights, Islamic states that had religious minorities in their midst, like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Malaysia etc, are becoming more intolerant.
Never trust any of them.
Enak tenan hidup dibawah naungan mayoritas Islam, cuma minoritas tuh ngelunjak
They are converted.
Coba kalo di negeri Modi RasisMan umat muslim India ditindas n masjid dihancurkan, di Malaysia n Indonesia non muslim aman n sejahtera
The law mandatory for muslim only😂 if muslim practice their beliefs and you means they are intolerant??? 😂 Indonesia ❌, West Sumatera ✔️ What the bias covered by CNA! The fact there is even no law in West Sumatera to push non-muslim to wear hijab. This video only covered the case in one shcool 3 years ago, and even the shcool has apologized.
No Islam know peace Know Islam No peace
cap
hoax
Facts🎉🎉❤
Bro thinks he did sth
Menyedihkan, tapi memang seperti itu kebenaran nya
I remember a non-Muslim friend in Australia was having a bbq in a park there. Halfway through, a middle-eastern man came and asked if they were cooking pork. And they were not allowed to do so there. He was full of threats. My friend felt really scared. One of her Muslim neighbours from Bosnia are drug dealers and bringing home different partners.
Hypocrisy😂
U forgot they don't drink alcohol 😂😂😂😂but they bear 20 kids n govt need to feed them😂😂😂😂😂😂
So, when people do all the things contrary with Islamic teaching, you still called them Muslim?
@@lalalostyou7546 lol they are indeed muslim, can't simply assume they are no longer muslim just because they done what other muslim think it is false
"They can't eat pork but they can take drugs and lead a promiscuous life." This is exactly what a young north African who worked as a butcher in France (he sold pork but also sold halal meat) pointed out on Tik Tok before being kidnapped and tortured by hardcore Islamist, not long ago. Everything was posted on internet and he still got no justice...
Indonesia will impose "halal" label for every food stall in Bali. This is OUTRAGEOUS!! As a Balinese this is a form of spiritual oppressions. Pork and wine has been our food culture and it taste good and no health problem moderately consuming it. I feel "colonialize" by Middle East culture proxy. Imposition of any label such as Halal or Kosher or any other religious specific diet should be ILLEGAL, because it is discriminative.
its just a label tho just ignore it
@@amirkhanisnice Yeah many people are not sticking it tho..
@@akshay.kumar.k ya true
It's just a label calm down
Look up the WHO on alcohol.
Whereever Islam is dominant, people will be opressed.
Terbalik
Yeah that's true
@@learnaccount8459 Then what is the function of British?
Then British is an exception?
Please specify non-muslims suffer
strange how everyone even the so called defenders of islam choose to live in Christian and secular countries but they don't think about going to their wonderful sharia lands
Till today, the 7th century Arab merchant made the world dark.
A warlord
As a Malaysian, the trader spread Islam not by Sword, but by lies, deception and Brute Forces
@@norule0 unlike Jesus we've never seen any Mohammad movies, because his life will make Hitler look like a saint
Womp womp
@@Thekomokoro Austrian painter was a saint
It's a shame that Indonesia has sold its soul, traditions and dress codes to a religion from the desert. I think most people in the world also think that Indonesia is an Arab country without its own identity. Indonesia is the fourth largest country in terms of population, but no one knows what Indonesia is.
that's what happened to all 56 nations COLONISED by islam. they ALL lost their identity and culture. and as a result many of them DEVOLVED. ancient persia was a leading culture on the planet. today it's just another middle eastern country. but it's decolonising islam from it's culture which is great.
Most people know what Indonesia is but generally from what I've seen, they just see it as a nice tropical place for a vacation.
Country with one identity will surely be confused with Indonesia that has many identities and heritages
@@xvgm24 Yes, a tropical place with Islamist desert culture. But it is not only that. The most famous Indonesian place in the eyes of foreigners is Bali which is actually a Hindu influenced area. That culture is what helps in attracting the tourists, not saying that it is the only factor of Bali.
Nice joke 😂
I'm from Malaysia they literally discriminate us by giving housing discounts to the majority and also in terms of education they give them entrances to public Universities despite Chinese people scoring way higher grades here. Literally someone can score 10As in a test here while the Muslim here with 6As are able to enter the University but not the Chinese or indian people here. The 10A thing is literally not exaggerating it happens really often
Malays come to the US on scholarships attend third rung universities where as Indians and Chinese attend top notch universities and excel and stay back and move up the ladder in corporations. Remember Malays call Tamils as Pariah and Sundar Pichai of Google is a Tamil!
Universiti mana tu selain dari UiTM? Rasanya semua universiti awam selain UiTM ambil pelajar berdasarkan merit, bukan lagi bangsa.
Isu lama,Masih di main-main kan lagi. Pada tahun 2023 majority lepasan SPM tidak mahu melanjutkan pelajaran ke university. (Majority is malay Muslim)
PMX has said,before DEB launch in1970 majority university course have 0% Malays in certain course. During at that time the intifada was happen in Iran. In order to avoid Malays people supporting PAS and becomes like Iran,umno must do something to helps if want to stay in power. Anak anak melayu ada yang pandai tapi banyak Dari keluarga yang susah macam B40 zaman sekarang.
This also happens in several school in Indonesia. My neighbor can’t become a docter although he is one of the best student in his university. No wonder plenty of chinese, buddhist, and christians here become a trader, and they also hate us even more because of that
When in minority they want full rights to practise their religion, But in majority they deny others the same . Religion/cult of violence and intolerance. May mankind one day find the courage to eradicate this evil
What happens is that those who are not Muslim will always live with a shadow of fear. Because the government includes religion in the regulations
Really?
I don't see any Muslim Majority Country in the world have clear separation State and Religion. It's like poison to the democracy.
Justru hidup dibawah kaum non Islam yg tidak toleranst.! Lihat saja dinegara Barat sana,muslim di tindas..!
Not exactly sharia law but the law base one islamic teaching. There is no law in West Sumatera that force non muslim wearing hijab, but for muslim only (reminder this region is 99% muslim). The case happen 3 YEARS AGO in one shcool, then the shcool even apologized. I think normal in many place of the world also especially in democratic country like Indonesia when the law accommodated the majority of their people. It is not intolerant if the mimority have the rights of choice.
Fear of what. It is made it clear in sharia law regardless of religion, one should not be punished unjustly.
My best friend is a Muslim living in Malaysia but she wants to convert her religion and want to marry her Christian boyfriend but her country is not allowing her to change her religion that's so sad i mean there people can't even get marry to their lovee ones in these muslims countries
Very true, almost all muslim majority countries(oic) criminalise apostasy while forces other religious minorities to convert to marry a muslim. Government sponsored islamic institutions strictly regulates this and sends atheist & gays to 'religious correction centers' until they conform to islamic policies. Its really inhumane and does not get enough media coverage
this. You are not allowed to leave Islam. It's a cult that wouldn't exist anymore if it had allowed its followers to choose their religion.
@@pikapi6993 thats why over 1000 people had changed their religion just in few of the Germany cities during Ramadan. Ohh people are forced to revert to Islam how sad 😂
@@farimahkarimi6549 lol, what kind of response is this, when we are talking about a case where a person is not allowed to leave Islam, even though she wants to? Her government is not letting her. You are helping to show people that something in your mind is not working correctly. BTW most people who convert to islam in the West, click out of it soon afterwards. People get duped into it because they fall in love with someone or need friends, but then they realize that this religion is all about haram haram haram or jihad jihad jihad. And very hostile to women. And then they leave it. Or when the relationship ends. It's not because they are convinced of Allah and MoMo. There are many Ex Muslims who converted to it and share their experiences online ;)
@@pikapi6993false. You are freely change your religion in Indonesia. My aunt did that for the same scrnario (to marry a christian man). I can't say about Malaysia as I am not aware of how it is over there.
This is a warning to all secular countries. If you allow them the freedom to practise their islamic faith, it will not be reciprocated when they have expanded and are in the majority. The same freedom that you extended to them you will not get back. Same with halal establishments. You give up your inclusive space to let them halal-lise the premise which then becomes exclusive. Think long and hard before extending freedom to them to practise their faith, it is tantamount to you giving up your inclusivity and freedom.
Is the old saying goes they demand people to be tolerant of their religion tolerant of the way they're going to live their lives yet when they're no longer a minority but a majority then they're going to demand Everybody follow their religion or wind up wishing they had unfortunately there's people who will read something like this and say that's hate talk. No it's not it's truth it's what's going on in every single country that they've come into while they're laughing at the idea of people calling it as being an invasion yet even the KZhead people who have put up the videos of saying that it was nothing but insecurities of frightened children who worry about the influx of people coming into Western Europe and not into other Muslim countries. And they were laughing at people saying that it was on an issue of them being an invasion Force to take over a country. Yet in every country they come into since the Syrian war that was facilitated and created by that Democrats and especially Obama and Clinton with their formation of Isis and the Muslim Brotherhood
It's like cancer spreading
if France can force muslims to take off their hijab, then why can't Indonesia force non-muslims to wear hijab? same thing innit???
you let Islam became majority. They will take your freedom in the future.
@@az-fy3mp Take off during work and while workin in government. They can wear it any other time of the day. I personally dont mind if someone wants to wear hijab at work and hope they are allowed to do that. But the main reason strict secular countries dont allow religious attire at work (especially government) is cuz they wanna stay secular. I dont dislike Islam or other religions. But plz dont pretend there isnt a conflict in France that could get nasty in the future. The beheaded teacher is a perfect example how barbaric religious conflicts can become. Regardless of the reasons, europeans have long move away from beheading ppl. It speaks miles when this is the answer to disagreemts. And it scares ppl. So instead of turning blind eye, please help address it. I know there is racism in France against innocent muslims too. Which is not ok. But i wont pretend as if all religious extremists are innocent. Indonesia whips gay ppl in some parts cuz of religion. France doesnt. Meaning indonesia is already treating non-believers worse + as subhumans by whippin them. And it's barbaric lefotver from abrahamic religions that found its way into the legal principles of the constitution. This is why it is important to protect the secular spaces and principles as good as possible from ALL religions. Nice day
As Indonesian i feel bad for our non muslim. I just remember that if non muslim want make their church or etc it will be difficult and some of muslim people are going crazy and protesting about that. But when muslim make a mosque, everyone are silence 😂. That the reality of my country
Apa dulu alasannya, klo d area lokal situ lebih bnyk muslimnya ya jelas susah dpt izin BUT klo lebih bnyk non muslimnya gampang aj ni kota ane gereja bsa ad 2 buah dlm jarak +- 300 meter , knp ? Krn d stu bnyk kristennya sedangkan msjdnya yg lebih longgar. Itu kota ane gak Tau kota lain but tngok dlu apa alasannya.
I mean it's very difficult to build a mosque in korea you know? They even put pigs head in front of site. So what's ur point?
Nice pfp
@@syahmiwafiy2675 lmao how many church, synagogue, temple , monastery are there in Saudi arabia?
Dimana bumi dipijak, disitu langit di junjung. Main main lah ke timur Indonesia. Terbalik disana Kurang main jauhnya bosq
Most Indonesian public schools are essentially secular-in-name-only. In reality, they are nothing more than Islamic schools but with the Islamic part being very watered down. This is why many minorities typically look to Christian/Catholic or other private schools that have much better education and conducive learning environment.
You forgot the part where most private christian schools like donbosco and gonzaga are very expensive, while ordinary schools are practically free and often barely have enough budget not to go bankrupt. Ngl though, I sometimes hang out and hide in hindu class during noon prayer lol. It's very watered down indeed.
Many Indonesian and Malaysia come to Singapore for education 😊
do you live in indonesia? i am indonesian and studied at public school but didn't experience such things. i have christian and buddhist friend at school and they can express their religion freely. they is christian school club too (for buddhist i dont know because they are only 1 or 2 buddhist).
@@kawaiikoto8800why are you hiding?
@@kahfattyue7358 because few people in indonesia and malaysia but considered as many people in singapore
I dont understand Islam, they are willing to kill just for their faith. Isn't killing also a sin in Islam?
And there you can see that you don't understand islam...
What's the punishment for blasphemy and apostasy in Islam?@@adamdaniel8909
@@adamdaniel8909 i mean techinically terrorists screaming alahuakbar when they blew themselves up, soooo
There is a rule where it is excusable to do so for the objective of propagating the religion.
Well it was never, when you'll get to know the real Islam and how it's actually started and it's base.
This is the only media house that has balls to criticise islam, albeit indirectly.
bcz they came from china and conquered singapore and thought propaganda like this one could get them to take all of southeast asia😂
@@syahmiwafiy2675 lol why would they want to. They're richer than most of them.
@@CandleWispbecause just like Zionist, they aren’t any different. After the Jews, it is Chinese that are land grabbers as well. Or let’s just say East Asian.. I mean Mongolian example is good enough. If it was possible they’d want to expand all the way to Spain.
I live in jakarta. In my community, you can't have dog as pet. The muslim syaria law is ridiculous and nonsense
You can't have it as a pet, but you have it to guard your agriculture against thieves or what not...i mean you still can be kind to dogs, give it food or water. To me, it doesn't sound completely bad.
Hmm. Weird. I see even muslims celebrities have pet dogs in Jakarta. Maybe you are just not famous enough to have dogs as pets.
@@Qtpie5805yeah , nothing sounds completely bad till one actually comes face to face with such situations!!!
@@ptaeiy bold of you to assume I want one of your kind
@@ptaeiyIndonesia, expecialy in java housing condition is very crowded, unless you have large yard or some kinda noise reduction in your house, you be better not having dog as you're pet. Because no one will like to hear barking all day night, and many pet owner kinda ignrance about this.
Absolutely important issue to address. They want recognition and respect for their traditions when they are in minority but not willing to provide it to others when they are in power. The same situation in other Asian and African countries
All of this stems from this 👇🏼 Fight those who do not believe in Allah and the Last Day, nor comply with what Allah and His Messenger have forbidden, nor embrace the religion of truth from among those who were given the Scripture(Jews and Christians), until they pay the tax, willingly submitting, fully humbled. Q-ran 9;29
@@Negev-Israel correct
100 % can switch between victim and supremacist when it suits their aims.
@@Negev-Israel this comment should be pinned (although its a reply)...for all of those who still believe islam is a religion of peace
It is only in a couple of province the hijab issue. Nation wide it's not mandatory. The gambling and swimming part is so bottom of the barrel that you know minorities have little serious problem with minorities rights .
in my observation and experience with Muslims in the Philippines, they are a minority however, there are some segments within the Muslim community that looks down on the Christian majority and impose their terms. that is why, many of us Christian businessmen don't what to do business with Muslim traders... it seems that they are only fair to their own kind, unfortunately.
There is this concept in Islam called "Muslim Brotherhood" google it. It will give you clarity on why that happens.
They even cheat their own
You know what bro, because at their eyes to see us as Non-Muslim it's kosher being play by them, deceive or being surrender to them if it's necessary. That's their plan. They're still respect to you as Majority in Manila, but when it's the time their number are largest than you thought, they're gonna taking down your people as well. I'm Catholic Man from Indonesia. Kumusta po?
They are harmless till they are minority
Yes
Critics who screamed “Islamophobia” when French school banned headscarf will tell you its OK when Indonesian school make headscarf mandatory 🤦🏼♂️
from what I know. Malaysian government forced their indigenous people to enter Islam. if they dont, they wont get any benefits from government.
As a muslim who follows quran only, it sickens me of the double standards practied by traditionalist muslims (not majority of em tho, but minority is notably loud)
@@syarifmirza1195aku tengok ramai saja budak pompuan muslim yg pergi sekolah xpakai tudung pon! Okay saja. You saja yg terkoyak lebih.
your comparison is not relevant…..in indonesia headscarf compulsory to muslim student only……in france they banned headscarf for all student…..what if france compulsory to eat beef for hindu student…
According to Indonesian law ... headscraf is not mandatory nor forbidden everywhere, including public school
With the threats of becoming a Islamic country, church bombing and discrimination towards the non muslim, my parents always told me that when it's getting too unbearable, we'll move to western country. We love our country, but living for 30+ years with extra careful of what we say and act, sometimes it felt too much. My friend told me that his religion allow him to kill me (though not legally lawful) and I should be grateful to him that I kept as his friend, and another friend of mine was forcefully moved home after complaint to the local mosque for being too loud. Moslem people will NEVER understand what we're going through.
thank you for reporting this. Yes Malaysia is heading backwards and a lot of restriction have impose on non muslim. And its getting worse every years
This is just sad and they dare to screm Islamophobia over France
France is free country.Why someone can't wear hijab if she want 🤔
@@iqbalismail6436 I wonder🤔
@@iqbalismail6436Indonesia is a democracy why someone have to wear hijab in school if she didn't want to
@@iqbalismail6436France is a secular nation, know their history before defending your religion which I'm sure you know nothing of.
@@pranavmohite8544Well indonesia and malaysia aren't secular countries🤷🏼
I’m from Indonesia and specifically from a province with tendencies to adopt sharia-inspired bylaws and I’m thankful for CNA for this report. Most Indonesians are quick to say that these things only happen in Aceh as the only sharia-ruled province out of the 38 provinces that we have, but we often overlook the fact that there are other provinces that are quietly creating local bylaws that are inspired by religious laws. The public schools that made wearing the hijab an obligation is located in the province of West Sumatra, not Aceh. Just because in your city/province you have a good relationship between religions, your children can choose to wear hijab or not at public schools, people who are not fasting can freely eat and drink during Ramadan, non-Muslims can build their places of worship etc it doesn’t meant the same things can also happen in some cities/provinces with sharia-based bylaws. We need to have this conversation before it’s too late.
Shariah law is only for Aceh. For West Sumatra majority are moslems
Blame your own governor and your own provincial govt. Stop blaming the entire country just because some provinces were dominated by muslim conservatives.
Di Indonesia, ada setidaknya 3 etnis yg mencampur etnisitas dan agama yaitu Aceh, Minangkabau, dan Melayu, Etnis lain tidak seperti itu. itu adalah akar masalahnya
@@141Travish ....JUSTRU ADAT DAN BUDAYA DARI KETIGA SUKU ITU TERIKAT DENGA SYARIAT ISLAM.... TIDAK MASALAH TOH....
@@ignatiusryd2031 THERE IS NO MOSLEM CONSERVATIVES ACTUALLY...
很多马来人认为华裔和印裔 之所以身份地位不被承认， 是因为他们只懂得讲自己的母语。 即便大马华裔和印裔从一开始 就能够掌握好马来语文， 或已经可以说一口很流利的马来语, 非穆在这国家的待遇会有所不同吗？ 答案是不会,因为肤色和宗教的关系。 无论非穆再怎么努力融入马来社会, 其实也是无功徒劳和自讨苦吃， 依旧被当作外来移民看待, 因为马来人早已认定这是他们的土地, 把别族对国家的贡献视为理所应当, 他们会找一堆借口理由来否定别族， 把别族当成假想敌或侵略者来仇视。 有许多大马华裔称呼马来人为友族， 但马来人从来不把别族当友, 还不断用“kafir”(异教徒)称呼着别族。
Muslims don't have to see non Muslims as same as Muslims. That's don't make sense. You guys have your way of life we have ours. As long we live peacefully and prosper together and stand with you for truth and justice over the land , it should be sufficient. It's like you don't have to be considered a family member as a neighbor as long as we go along well in harmony.
@@sunset2.00 hmm, interesting & good answer
是的，没错
@@sunset2.00Very Melayu response
"Islamophobia" is nothing but common sense; the UN resolution passed for Islamophobia to shun critics of Islam.
IDk how people r so sensitive and ignorant blaming CNA of bias or Islamophobia. You know CNA also made documentaries about what minorities face in Singapore in a 2 part series including racism faced by minorities in many contexts.
This is exactly why the west is collapsing because the Islamists and wokes are shutting down all forms of civilised discussions about issues they are easily offended by. It's the victim's mentality in operation aided by a ego that won't allow them to be criticised. It's always the other party's fault, a group totally incapable of introspection.
The video said 700. But only gave 1 example which is hijab in public school and already gave conclusions like intolerant and repressing minorities. I think that is very biased and Islamophobic.I want to know what else are there those 700 sharia inspired regulations. Don't tell me it is something like illegal to sell alcohol except in hotel, cafe or bar. Or you need to have a permit to build a place of worship. Because it is dumb to think that is base on syaria.
@@jokebapack2 lol you can search on google itself being phobic towards particular community and showing the truth has difference isnt it true that sharia influenced laws are prominent in malaysia and indonesia? no secularity is practiced there... as we know people will oppose it if it goes against their belief system... let this world be secular for real... we dont need it to go backward
They are sensitive because they are fragile. So fragile that they need anti-proselytization laws to keep them from hearing the truth and anti-apostasy laws to keep those who have heard the truth from leaving.
@@user-xp5xn2vy3l prove it to me that there is an anti proselytization and anti apostasy law in Indonesia. If you can't then you are just talking from your 455.
No one should force their beliefs on others especially in the public domain. We should integrate and not assimilate into each other culture.
You are so right. If only the rest of your community think like you, the world would be so much more peaceful.
@user-xp5xn2vy3l ... Yeah, that's right.. Everything about Islam is always wrong by those who definitely share the same views as you. This is year 2024. Stop all these race and religions issues. You work hard, you get rewarded.
@@buhari9Indeed, more and more people all over the world are waking up to the real nature of Islam. I hope one day you will too.
Each country has their own mechanism of how they unite people. Integrate comes in different levels too so don't expect the countries to be perfect at integration. I like the idea of integration but it is hard to achieve.
John Lennon said we can only imagine...
Stop Islam at anywhere Will make your country great again. In Nederland, their Prime Minister didn't give a damn about fatwa. We need example like him at anywhere else.
Based President
he is chad
Muslims in non-muslims area--🤗 Non-muslims in muslim area--😵
How abot muslim got killed in india? 🤔
@@iqbalismail6436 muslims getting butchered in muslim countries too ..... What do you wanna say about that??
didn't your country discriminate against the Muslims in India?
U wrong
@@iqbalismail6436 Muslims getting killed in Islamic countries too
Thank God my family can afford me to grow up in a 'secular' and good community in Indonesia where I don't have any government officials telling me what I should believe or wear! Nor I ever have to be personally exposed to religious fanatics in the country. But maybe I am just very lucky!
What happen to the Tragedy in 1998?
You are, most are controlled by the govt on what they wear
They never bring you to jail ?
What truth? You don't even read the Quran but pretend to know the truth. Empty vessels make the most noise
Unless you are still schooling, you won't experience the hijab problem. Also if you are a man, you won't experience this type of problem.
It will start small and grow by making changes here and there. when it has reached full power it will show its true form.
Same is happening in western Europe due to immigration. Step by step. Untill it is irreversibe.
Wdym? In Indonesia muslim always is a majority side, muslim have been gain full power from the start in Indonesia
@@--Traveler-- are you learn history from mc donald? which islam country colonized indonesia? islam spread by marriage and trade here
@@raihan7422 well u were dirt poor before...so these kinda things didnt come into discussions b4....now along with development u will see the issues coming up more frequent and more aggressive...im giving it 10 yrs...u wont say the same things then
@@--Traveler-- MuSliMs CoLoNisEd InDOneSia never heard of Wikipedia? here's the link en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spread_of_Islam_in_Indonesia read it, does it contain any words about colonialization? it seems that you got butthurt because Indonesia refused to accept Hindus.. heck even Bali Hinduism is different than the Indian Hindus.
Be careful Europe. Coming are way. Stand up now.
Europe and america sometimes can become annoying too. Let them experienced this as we do so they would be careful next time.
I have friends staying in both Indonesia and Malaysia. Both the countries are turning more and more radical particularly in the provinces. It was not like this earlier. Political parties who are losing support are trying to retain power by adopting radical policies. While Saudi Arabia is liberalising at a fast pace, Indonesia and Malayasia are going in the opposite direction sadly. This trend will be bad for them in the long run and will impact development.
wdym, saudi arabia still oppressed the minority until this day
I always wondered that how come Indonesia and Malaysia are not like Pakistan and Bangladesh.. thanks for debunking my myth.. So thats the established fact whenever are they in majority, oppression begins.
different cultures i think between indo and the rest indians. as an indonesian, it depends where exactly you live. if you live in padang or aceh or some provice who had region law that inspired by sharia, yeah it's gonna be hard for you if you are a minority. but if you live like in jakarta, bandung, surabaya, or even bali. it's pretty secular. also, the majority indonesia have progressive mindset so many indonesians also against with the law that happened in the viddeo
This is not just about religion. Had that been the case there would have been Sharia law even in Turkey. This is about poverty AND religion mixed together. That leads to majoritarianism everywhere.
@@curious_one1156 erdogan lost in election, turkey will be back as secular agaim
Because Malaysia and Indonesia weren't conquered by Indianish idea... Remember how Pakistan Bangladesh Nepa Sri Lanka India were once British Raj? What an irony 👽👽Lol
But same thing is happening even though they are/were not part of subcontinent.. and both were colonized if you dont know the history thn I am not here to educate you about history.
Racist. And yet defending himself with twisting and misleading words. Greed for power and wealth. Not compassionate and no spirits of Malaysians.. Somehow he dares to speak to the international media of his narrowed and divisive thoughts... Malaysia, does not need more of these political leaders... We need more considerate and moderate leaders..
Totally agree with u. Beware of green wave PAS spreading across Peninsula Malaysia. Only Sabah & Sarawak is truly of "Malaysian Spirit".
You're absolutely right. He said: Melayu is majority muslim and dominant. So the country should be under syariah law. Racist and stupidity act.
PAS is a real threat & culprit. It goes against the secular nature of the Federal Constituition. #Sarawak's Peter John said best "Malaysia does not belong to 1 race or 1 religion"
@@RGraf-ey5uyYour laws even full of corrupted. So, what’s the different? None.
@@torangclayruz4098 RACIST! *Sahih Muslim Book 41, Number 6958:* “Allah's Messenger (May Peace Be Upon Him) said, _‘The Last Hour_ would not come until you fight with a people having small eyes and broad snub noses.’” *Sahih Muslim Book 41, Number 6960:* "Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: 'You shall fight in the hours to come against a nation with faces like hammered shields and small eyes.'"
I think this report is sad. Malaysia is getting worse and harder for the people having to live such a harsh restrictive life with no future under Muslim Sharia law.
And engdonesia also getting worse everyday
There was no syaria law in malaysia except for muslim
indonesia is christian country
The Indians and Chinese are welcome to return...
his video about refugees but still millions poor chinese communists prefer Malaysia refuse to back to xi communist country. Visa free chinese government now DAP Chinese and Hindus refugees to Malaysia feel entitled to free land, education food, billionaire so cna made video of genocide of native Malays by chnese refugees is it? Where? Or 90 percent on death row Malays and indians? where?
here in the Philippines even though we are Christian Majority we dont force non christians to commit things that only chirstians do. For example in my university... muslims are not required to Do the sign of the cross because they the freedom to not to . They may also wear hijab if they wanted to. So I see that everyones culture and religion must be respected in any way
imagine other non muslim countries imposing their religious rules to all including muslim. would that be an issue?
Ofcourse they have been doing it , name a country which didn't harass muslims
@@Wazid-rh5ee my country 😁
@@Wazid-rh5ee Easy. China, Russia and Singapore. I work in Singapore. As long as people dont mix religion and politics, no one tries to kill each other.
ever heard France?
@@zarulluraz7033 France didn't impose their common religion rules on Muslim. Their school is secular.
Indonesia (or Malaysia) is neither a secular country nor an Islamic country. Since both countries are Muslim majority, sometimes they are more Islamic than secular.
You can make that argument for Indonesia, but Islam is officially the state religion of Malaysia.
Malaysia has islam ad state religion, Indonesia has 6+1 (kepercayaan)
Islam is the official religion in Malaysia, but does it make it an Islamic country like Iran or Saudi Arabia?
@@omaronnyoutubeYes, because that's exactly what it means to have an official state religion. Just like Greece is an officially Christian state (the only one from what I know). If the state stills allows or tolerates other religions to be practiced or not is a different matter.
@@filipbunalti….many other religion exist n practiced also
I am a frequent traveller to Indonesia and have watched the country since Suharto was kicked out become more and more fundamentalist. And mosque and madrassa building is a huge industry over there, one on every street corner it seems. Apparently the money is coming from the middle east to build them all. Indonesia same as India is not really progressing economically as well as they should be, and its the same reasons . Focus is on religion, not economic progress.
same thing in India, mosques everywhere being built, hindus getting killed regularly too
What?, 5 percent growth annually, and one of the fastest growing ones. biggest economy in Southeast Asia, first bullet train in Southeast Asia, we make our own trains and sell them to other countries, we make weapons ranging from tanks to warships. We have the biggest E commerce market in Southeast Asia, everyone’s quality of life is getting better. maybe some regional areas have unchecked power that they keep to themselves. You don’t see people complaining over Texas. But the National interest has always been a desire for prosperity and progress. Just look at our elected president.
@@029_rafeehidayat3 Indonesia could be doing so much better, and with its huge wealth it should be, it has the same issue all majority Muslim countries have. Lack of productivity, and that is due to religion. I know quite a few Indonesians who have come to live in Australia and generally they are surprised at how hard Australians actually work. 5-6 days a week of actually working. And my reply is always the same, thats why we are a tanah maju. You cant get productivity when you spend most of the day preparing for prayer and going to prayer.
India is economically growing at a rapid pace ,you should not judge certain thing's solely on the basis of negative publicity from Western media
@@zentriffid look, phillipines is predominantly christian and is worse than is, we southeast asians are still trying to find our way in the global space, and i think progress is doing much better than before.
Finally news outlet are talking about minority persecution in Islamic countries- its something thats so normal now, its not talked about. Please also do in depth analysis of Hindu and Sikh minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
May Lord Krishna protect all the Non Muslims around the world from Islamic Tyranny and cruelty😓🙏🙏💙💙
Are you making hate of Islam?
@@lelongbashiNo he is stating facts about Islam saying facts are not hate quran chapter 8 Verse 12 quran chapter 9 Verse 5 This is Islam teaching 😂🤣
@Hmm19872 Quran chapter 8 verse 12 - this chapter explains that Meccan People who are disbeliever of Allah went goes to war and fight against the other Meccan people who are believers of Allah and follow the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. Why disbelievers attack the believers? Because they rejects Muhammad s.a.w worships to the Only true God which is Allah. Quran 9 verse 12 - this chapter is the most misinterpreted verse from Islamaphobic, always used by the media people who are just quoting the verse like you (not reading the full context). The verse of the Sword, you have to understand in the context of the 9th Hijrah after the conquest of Mecca Paganism (Musyrik) is being eliminated.
Quran Chapter 9 verse 12 Allah says when is the sacred Months finish? Some scholar says it is the sacred months are the famous months of hijr calendar. Allah called the four months in the verse 2. These 4 months are the sacred months, who cannot fight or go to war on for this particular year. Basically when 4 sacred months are finish, then what? Then you have open licence, you can fight or eliminate them, or take prisoners whatever you like that it needs to be done. No, this verse was revealed for the haram and the Arabian peninsula that is not going to be paganism, idol worship in the scared anymore. You cannot worship in the lands of Haram (Mecca). They were given four months, you have 2 options - get rid of an paganism (disbeliever) if you accept Islam, allowing to pray or zakat then you allow them to be what they want to be. Meaning you have 4 months, you can either pack your bag and get out or FACE WAR. And that is because it is not allowed in our Islamic sharia law for idolatry to be practiced in Arabian Peninsula which is in Mecca just like in Malaysia, Middle East or Islamic dominant country
@@Hmm19872 Could you explain it? You dared to refer to the Quran but refused to describe it. Are you the type "oh, go and read it yourself"🤣🤣😂😂
In Malaysia, after the isolated and minor May 13,1969 race riots between the Muslim Malays and Chinese voters in Kuala Lumpur where the majority Muslim-Malay population (UMNO party) lost the votes to the Malaysian Chinese (Democratic Action Party (DAP), the government took a drastic stand to pull the poorer Malays out of poverty. It did this by announcing the 1969 New Economic Policy (NEP) which was a massive affirmative action national program in every sector exclusively for the Malays. It was supposed to last only 30 years but even after 55 years, this policy still exists now with much resentment by the non-Muslims ! The program became skewed, hugely racist, corrupted and manipulated by elite ruling Malay politicians and their leaders especially by the notorious, 22-year massive corrupt rule of ex-PM Mahathir Mohamed who all fabulously enriched their families. During this time, Mahathir also cultivated pro-Islamic, anti-Semitic, anti-non Muslim policies which turned Malaysia from an English-speaking, top-level nation in education within Asia to a huge class of Malaysians with a poor standard of English and falling school standards. He also led the proliferation of Islamic schools called 'madrasah' and colleges which further eroded the racial unity in Malaysia. Malaysia's ringgit currency was once the pride of Asia (parity of 1:1 to the Singapore $) in 1965 but now has sunk to an unfathomable RM3.5 : 1 Sing $. The damage has been done and this has led to the brain drain in the country of so many wealthy and educated non-Muslim Malaysians emigrating !
That is why Singapore exist.
Good summary@Carsten 👍
It did actually encrich alot of minority non muslims during that dictatorship while same time blue pilled indigenous bumis plus muslims in general .. it was purely dirty politics plus wealth building among cronies, nothing about enriching the indigenous local muslims .. you need to watch deeper than that , dont get bought into stereotyping plus media propaganda .. Msia primarily full of false flags plus fakery ..
Excellent summary
Please do not lie. The fall of the current Malaysia's ringgit currency vis a vis the Singapore dollar is not the fault of Mahathir, but due to the multiple mismanagement by the current PM Anwar Ibrahim's regime.
This is so true! I live in a Muslim majority country (Indonesia), I often being harassed from my fellow schoolmates for not being a Muslim, they often mock my religion. This is true discrimination we are facing.
Seems like the South Indian Cholas need to pay another visit to the Malay area
@@ashokathegreat4534then what are doing here man? go there to Indonesia and Malaysia
Both Indonesia and malaysia lost their souls when they relinquished their original faiths, culture and converted en mass. Indonesia is the strangest country in the world I have come across where their entire ancient and medieval UNESCO listed large monuments are either Hindu or Buddhist and most of their national symbols and names derived from Sanskrit language while calling themselves Islamic nations. Confused cultures and identities.
No we are diverse, our identity is not to be categorized by western standards
I really wonder and love to know the actual history of Indonesia and Malayasia from times before Islam and how they got converted enmass
Yeah how sad....they throw Animism and Dynamism for Hinduism, Christianity and Islam😢
bro you know one fact Indonesia was a hindu majority country before muslim s arrived
Imagine schools in india forces students to wear tilak in schools . Thats what indonesia is doing
It's just 2 provinces (Aceh and West Sumatera) out of 38 provinces in Indonesia. but it's still wrong nevertheless. Aceh is special case because implementing sharia laws was part of MoU for ending conflicts between Aceh's separatist movement vs Indonesia. Looking at the history of Aceh, it was the last region that was fallen to the Dutch indies colonials, for only about 4 decades (1903-1945), but it had been under Indonesia for 65 years but they had to abandon their way of life like forever? so they decided to try to secede, but anything that can stop them from doing it was just a win-win solution for Indonesia. So it's kind of misleading to include Aceh as an example of islamification of Indonesia. West Sumatera was just being dick. many Indonesian founding fathers were from there, but they seems didn't like to continue their ancestors creation.
But India doesnt disturb muslim students
@@cikicikibumbum259 other left out region will slowly slowly become like this 😂😂 we Indian know very well about muslim and there mindset
But they force to take off hijab which is the same thing as force to take hijab.
@@selvaselva2491 No . Its actually reverse . Hinduism has no concept of " Only my religion is right and you will go to hell of you don't belive or convert ".
Jika anda orang Indonesia.. Pasti anda tahu partai politik yang secara terbuka ingin membuat seluruh provinsi di indonesia menerapkan hukum syari'ah.. Dan di Sumatra Barat (Padang) mereka menang..
PKS
siapa lagi kalau bukan pks yg kampanye kadang suka bawa bawa agama untung aja banyak yg gasuka sama partai politik ini salah satu gue, gue muslim tp gue paling benci liat orang yg ga bisa toleransi
Bad for ekonomi bisnis.
Perda hijab itu yg bikin adalah bupati2 di sumbar dari partai golkar
@@raihanfauzan44 taqiyah melulu
west sumatra still have sin they not apologized or regretted to north sumatra, mainly to the north sumatran non moslem. in late 1800's a west sumatran man known as imam bonjol, the leader of padri force launching attack to the bakkara kingdom of north sumatra and causing 3/4 of bakkara citizen who live in the south next to west sumatra to be perrish. it is the worst genocide in indonesian history after g30s communism purge of 1968. the crazy thing is, west sumatran promoting and succesfuly making imam bonjol as national hero of indonesia just because his force fighting against the dutch, including dutch force in north sumatra who trying to help bakkara force to stop the genocide eventhough at the time dutch and bakkara are mortal enemy. to this day, descendant of padri genocide still protesting imam bonjol national hero status and demmaning the status to be removed from him. imam bonjol him self never regretted his decision to attack and taking life of 3/4 southern bakkara citizen. he only regretted his decision to coup pangaruyung kingdom and launcing civil war in the kingdom because pangaruyng is moslem majority. while for bakkara is parmalim majority. parmalim is a monotheistic local religion of batak ethnic where bakkara are part of it. imam bonjol see them as non human and even not worthy to burry. his view on parmalim people are the one that causing his force to lost over 95% of it's soldier due to the bodies become the source of pestilence plague that taking life of over 95% of padri soldier to this day, batak people remembering the moment where padri soldier lost their life one by one to the plague as "the sacrifices for the pestilence", or "enemies who killed by the dead"
Let’s not forget that Indonesia was not originally Muslim. They took over the country. Be warned people be warned
No body took over like Israel. Indonesia and Malaysians are converted people who converted willingly. Historically the only foreign oppression was by western colonialism.
Yeah they were not originally Muslim nor Hindu but Animism and Dynamism
Being a division one officer in the Malaysian government service he saw the country going down the road of race & religion in the horizon & advised us to emigrate from Malaysia. It can only get worse as the political clergy increases Islamization in every aspect of society under the guise that Islam is being threatened in the country, by imposing more of shariah that is more suitable in the 7th century.
Not enough freedom of speech and expression. Love the people and everything, but too much you know.
@@nicktan4530which countries thats you believed can be the role model to follow?
That’s progress considering democracy is from the fifth century 😂
@@TheOneAndOnlyUnity Democracy may be from the 5th century but it is timeless & valid for all, unlike shariah.
@@faiqhimajid3686 Simple! Follow the braindrain from Malaysia to the country the smart people are emigrating to.
😢😢 there is daily attack on minorities here😢😢 please take it to United Nations. Please help😢
that is horrible, I'm sorry you have to experience this. Unfortunately the UN is not as freedom loving as a lot of people expect. Islamic Republic of Iran chairs the human rights council... There should be more media attention on this 100%.
They don’t care, no Jews no news
What about GAZA??
@@Petro72690talk about oct 7? Where people are celebrating?
@@Petro72690no need to worry about that. They are dancing on october. Im sure its a sign that they can take care of themselves.
Same religion, same behavior no matter where...
For me as a Indonesian Muslim, i have to disagree with the requirement of Non Muslim to wear hijab. its forcing for the Non- Muslim
Please save innocent non Muslims from hatred crime n forced conversion ❤
We are not india buddy,dont worry 👍
@@fsl6973 pancasila ideology forced hindu to believe in one god. Dont worry for muslims only🤣🤣
@@fredericksimatupang6244 im not muslim tho lol
@@fsl6973what are you?
@@budsdude7615 i believe in God gaben
In Thailand, Muslim also have Siam name 😂
Yea normally the Muslims of central or northern Thailand but the Muslims of south Thailand who are majority malay such as satun pattani and songkhla they normally have just Arabic names meaning that they were descendants of malay people but if they have thai names it means that they or their forefathers are converts to islam
Once in majority.. the tide turns
Thats why they want independence
@@nasilemak3320 yep true
only in malaysia integration happen….thailand and indonesia wont allow it…..they prefer assimilation…..
This is misinformation. Minorities are never forced to wear hijab in Indonesia. If you see here, Indonesia feels more secular than Islamic. All religions' holy days are public holidays in Indonesia. Compare that to UK, US or Western European countries where you have to take your leave to celebrate your holy days if you are not Christian.
same with malaysia
As a Malaysian non Muslim.. they enforce and expect you to respect their ways. It only works one way. You can practice your religion though but in controlled setting. The fanatics have a special hatred towards Cristians and if given their way will close all churches
lies
@@TrilliumM6 truth bec I lived it. So do the thousands of non Muslims who are oppressed and bypass
@@ll-bb1nj As a Malaysian who is born muslim. Where's your source telling about this fanatics hatred towards cristians and close all churches?
@ericxoring7105 it's all in the news. Where have you planted your head. These fanatics have been screaming when when new churches are built, they see crosses on buildings they find it offensive, they won't greet Christians Merry Christmas. They get crazy when non Muslims may run for top positions in gov settings. My friends were forced to wear head scarves in some local colleges. A school was caught forcing the students to eat their meals inside toilets so as not to offend during ramadan, can't serve pork in local eateries but serve beef without having any sensitivity to our Hindu worshippers....shall I go on???? You obviously do not know and are living in a secluded bubble
seconding the comment before me. i’ve never heard of churches being destroyed in malaysia out of hate
Singapore is lucky to have escaped the clutches of her neighbours. If we were part of a country of religious fundamentalists and with a dominant race that believes it owns the land and all other ethnicities owe it a living, we'd still be an impoverished third world state today.
So keep your birth rates high yeah. Don't let them catch up.
fertility rate in singapore is 0.97 and this is not reversible. for a nation to be in stable population it has to be 2.1 good luck with that
Hidup seperti roda, kadang di atas dan kadang di bawah
@@thewaywardcyclist3992 Doesn't matter if the population grows or shrinks as a whole, you just have to outbreed them to keep their influence in check. But alas, the opposite has been happening.
@@thewaywardcyclist3992 That's why Singapore brings in Malaysians (especially Chinese and Indians) to make up for the very low fertility rates of the Chinese-Singaporeans (0.94) and Indian-Singaporeans (0.97).
6:18 PAS dude just contradicted himself
hahahah
fight for certain race what. not racist, not racist...*trying to convince
thats why east coast banjir every year.
@@CattleFarmer667That one is just geography. Maybe also where the houses were built, but try convincing anyone to move and you'll know it's difficult.
and all who takut dengan shariah, just bcus they’re most ppl are pencuri, isn’t it?
Its a shame and backward moving away from civil progress. While we acknowledge and respect all religion (including islam), not wanting to embrace forward moving mindset is as dangerous as trying to be protective in certain idealogy.
You have to clarify what you meant by forward moving mindset as word like that can mean anything from each person's point of view.
Talk about Indonesia, I will advice you My Friend. If any body here has some family member going holiday to Bali, either your family is Male or Female, just be careful at there. Because too many of those Muslim coming around to Bali Island, especially this time, they're gonna trying to taking down your family member by dating each other religions, and they're trying to approach them by convert to Islam as well. That's a real tragedy. Be careful at there.
What do you mean by dating? If you mean girlfriend and boyfriend going out to know each other for marriage purposes...
@@sunset2.00 what about if approach with convert to Islam. Do you agree?
@@sunset2.00 I don't mind if they're getting married at there, as long is not with Muslim and not convert to Islam.
I think you mean they try to establish a relationship with a foreigner possibly asian muslim female and white male tourist. Yeah,thats a common case. First they want your genes so they could have mixed blood child. Second,its for religious mission and try to recruit as many as possible through marriage.
@@KamKam-zo6xh exactly. You know what I'm thinking about that. The most Important thing that they are make use all of tourist genes to create population of them. And then, automatically those tourist must follow their husband or wife to stay in Indonesia, have a child raised at there, and trying to make sure their child from their relationship to become Army or Police at there. And most dangerous first thing if their children serve in the Military Force at Indonesia, they're trying to against their own people of tourist come from. That's why I keep telling to all of you to be careful about this one.
On 5 May 2024, there was an incident in South Tangerang, Indonesia, when local muslim residents rushed and stopped a bunch of Catholics (some are young women) who were praying rosary in their rented room. The local muslims insulted and beat them saying that they were annoying and asking them to hold such occasion at a church. An arrest was made against the perpetrators but we, Indonesian Christian, don't think that the case would be treated fairly.
Until now, Indian and Chinese in Malaysia are seen as "immigrant" despite being officially recognised. Not to mention the 13 May incident that happens between Muslim and non-muslim. I have since moved to Singapore to avoid this issue. Lovely country and stronger currency for sure.
Welcome to Singapore! I am a Singaporean of 36 years as a born Singaporean citizen you'll find my country paradise in Southeast Asia though it has its flaws, it is way better than Indonesia or Malaysia!
The racial riots in 1964 Singapore happened after Singapore entered merger with Malaysia in 1963 and Singapore chose to contest the Malaysian GE in 1964 which also create tensions , and the offspring party from Singapore, the DAP contested in 1969 for the first time also led to the racial riots in KL May 13 , 1969 hence DAP politics is NOT suitable for Malaysia. So from there you can see instigations can cause racial riots. when before 1963 all races in Malaysia lived peacefully and harmony.
@@jameslim3850 why are all the Malays getting all the better benefits, and the Chinese in Malaysia are getting none clearly there's a discrepancy even bias for the worse.
@@jameslim3850 Only u speaks some sense compared to these majority of greedy buffoons.
welcome to Singapore, you are safe and accepted here.
Its very confusing, i mean less decentralization means more power to the people. Leading to more democracy, but now it ends up being less democracy. You cant really wim em all, let those blokes on west indonesia decide their own fate.
Decentralization is a double edge sword for sure but still, other Indonesians outside Aceh and Padang are just sat with their popcorns watching those two places falling deep into the abyss.
In Malaysia, non Muslims live with full freedom
It’s always comes with changes in rules, then it will finally proceed to the normalisation of cleansing and oppression on the minority non-muslims.
Non Muslims Don't have to wear Hijab.....
@@RGraf-ey5uy There is some regions (even public schools) that force non-Muslims wearing hijab 👌👌
@@user-qz3zi2dl3elike in Malaysian non muslims are not compulsory to wear hijab in public school BUT they must either tied their hair or cut their hair short NO EXCUSE TO KEEP A LONG HAIR OR DYE HAIR WITH COLOR IN SCHOOL, OUT!
@@user-qz3zi2dl3e Hoax!!! Hoax!!! Hoax!! There is no shcool or region in Indonesia that force non-muslim wearing hijab by law/regulations. If you refered the case 3 years ago in one shcool at West Sumatera, the shcool has apologized. So the case is very locallize not become general view of West Sumatera.
@@editorizal Mereka bikin video ini kaya punya tujuan tertentu, Sumber yang diambil ga lengkap seolah memberi kesan kontroversi.
1 Corinthians 11: 2-16 even in the bible should cover their head .. just look a nun christianity has been fallen down
Feel sorry for the minorities born in Malaysia and Indonesia. Contrast that to Singapore where our government went the extra mile to ensure equal rights to all races and religions, both majority and minority, even though it is not perfect, then again which government in the world is perfect? at least our government doesn't stop trying.
Minorities in INDONESIA n MALAYSIA are Very RICH...but they NEED to RESPECT the RULES of the MAJORITY POPULATION....(They are FREE to PREACH what they believe without any INTERFERENCE from the MAJORITY GROUP...)..
did you even watch the video? In what part did they disrespect any part of Islamic rule? The audacity to spew such nonsense when the MAJORITY GROUP is the one forcing their rules upon the minority, and you make it seem like these minority groups are the problem@@abdulrajaf6
First of all, stop stereotyping minorities in Indonesia as being rich, thats just blatantly wrong. Anad even IF it is true, what does them being rich have anything to do with these rules that they have to unreasonably adhere? @@abdulrajaf6
@@abdulrajaf6 first of all, stop stereotyping minorities in indonesia as rich, thats just blatantly wrong. and EVEN if it is true, what does them being rich have anything to do with these rules that they have to unreasonably adhere to? second, did you even watch the video? in what part did the minorities DISRESPECT any part of Islamic RULE? The audacity to spew such nonsense when the MAJORITY GROUP are the one forcing THEIR RULES upon the MINORITY, and you make it seem like the MINORITY are the problem. what a joke.
Do you think the minorities in Singapore are happy?..😷😷😷
chinese non muslim here......religious conservative people are the same everywhere.....i find it funny CNA would make a video attacking a particular group or religion.... obviously America is a "secular" state and seperates church and state and their policies are not influenced in any way by any religion....if u so much believe them, though i believe america is far more conservative and religious than secular that they would have u believe, their money even says "in god we trust" and often when u see the things many US politcians say and their beliefs and their mannerisms.....it would have alot of their religion's undertones.....and alot of US western policy is often antagonistic against muslims and islamic countries but my main point is there is a part of america namely the southern republican states that is highly religious and conservative.......about 10 or 13 states or so covering a few million sq km.......within these states of about 100 million americans or so, alot of their local state laws and policies and culture and society and schools and attitudes are highly influenced and shaped by their religious christianity and conservative beliefs and views......even recently they have passed laws banning abortion rights..... if u are going to criticise and condemn these states and people in indonesia or whatever country for their syria law or their highly conservative policies and culture and practises...... why dont u go to these american conservative states and do the same?go down there and criticise and condemn them for not accepting certain minorities rights or condemn them as being oppressive?why dont u do things or better yet be things that antagonise them and go against their religious views and beliefs??and see the response and hostility,u might even see the end of the barrel of one of their favourite things!!!guns!!!why dont u go down there and tell them maybe to be a little more flexible u find alot of these muslims practises and beliefs baffling and incomprehensible,guess what i find alot of highly conservative christian beliefs and practises baffling and incomprehensible too!!!! and i find it funny cause islam and christianity share so many similarities, they are both against homosexuals, they both enjoy a bit of bigotry against women in their views now and then...and the scary part is religious christians in america try to cover this up by pretending that a woman who enjoys conforming to those ideals is a traditional woman or something..yet for some reason the two cannot get along with each other!!!!!
"Why is it when muslims are in the minority they scream human rights, but in any muslim majority country human rights are nowhere to be found." -Douglas Murray
Very bad assumption
There are Human Rights in Indonesia, if you see through Media, you can only see half of the reality
@@MoskusMoskiferus1611 Saudi Arabia, the birthplace of Islam is a very oppressive country.
In Malaysia the muslim majority mostly malays are in Peninsular Malaysia but in the Borneo state of Malaysia in Sabah and Sarawak they are the minority. The problem here in these two states are they define those from other etnic groups that converted to islam as Malay.
The constitution states that Malays are muslims(sunni) in which they are not allowed to change religion. Other minorities are forced to convert to register marriage with another muslim whether they like it or not. Even other muslim denominations like shia, sufi, ahmedis are banned. Its very intolerant and is getting worse every year
Bruh , Sabah is muslim dominant states
Cap thats is fake
is this really necessary? regardless of your faith..gambling, alcohol, revealing clothes, smoking, sex before marriage, are prohibited in most religion..even if you're not religious, if you're in the right mind, you know it is wrong, you know it's a bad thing..both Malaysia and Indonesia did it right..may Allah bless both of these country..
right or wrong is not for you to decide. ppl have rights to live their own way. you find it wrong to drink alcohol? i dont find it wrong at all. nothing wrong with gambling either, it's personal choice. you also gamble everyday by stepping out of your house, you wont know what will happen to you but you take a chance by doing so. your life is a gamble.
Not you comparing a christian country with a muslim one.
When minority: democracy, secularism. When majority: everyone must follow Sharia
What is scary is that these countries are advertised to the world as examples of how tolerant Islamic society can be.
Many younger one refuse to give up their civil liberty and sanity to the extremism promoted and practiced by these 2 states government, unlike their older parent, they have a longer life span ahead of them, still full of 'hopeful' dream inside, unwilling to give up easily and submit to policy of these religious fervents treated them as third class citizens.😳
Racial harmony, peace and prosperity are essentials to economic growth
without islam majority
@@smilingface2006 just "without Islam" because we had 1% of Chechens terrorize the country.
@@smilingface2006Exactly.
As a Muslim , I agree .I think most Muslims will also agree. Politicians wants to divide and control power.
@@sunset2.00 politicians steer, politicians incite, politicians generalize, from the thought that's already inside citizens' minds of a particular nation. you won't be affected when there's no resonance to start with.
this is so true. i recently commented on a post that was stating that Palestinian Christians used the word allah and we all should come together . i emphasized the fact that in malaysia, christians cant use the world allah and i got so much hate accusing me of being a islamphob, bot, liar etc and how they are giving in to minorities like they cant use the word kaffir, cant do their prayers in public in penang etc. when i posted an articles online to support christians in malaysia cant use the word allah apparently article is bias. best part this are malaysian malays ganging up on me but its just ironic when the fact that non muslims even christians cant use the world allah in malaysia but i got cursed out.
Hypocritical isn't it?
Interesting. This could happen to some European countries too.
In Indonesia also non-mu$lims face such problems & are not given equal rights & freedom to propogate their religions like mu$lims.😔
Like what?
Ribet amat cok. Muslim juga sama di negara kristen dpt perlakuan diskriminatif. Al quran dibakar, ga boleh pake hijab, mesjid ga boleh di bangun. Kl ga suka diindo ya pindah ke negara kristen
Oh cow warship talking😂
@@mrizaldi7199 Orang2 kyk gini bang elu yg bikin indonesia masih dongo
@@mrizaldi7199 membandingkan keburukan negara sendiri dengan keburukan yang terjadi di negara lain tidak menjadikan indonesia lebih baik. sama aja. harusnya kalo negara lain melakukan diskriminasi terhadap kaum minoritas harusnya indonesia berlawanan dengan itu. pada akhirnya yang dilihat itu tindakan akhirnya.
I'm Canadian living in Australia and people tell me to visit Bali/Indonesia all the time and I'm like "No thanks... I won't visit Muslim countries"
Well said ❤❤
We dont care
Good decision, don't waste your money in I$lamic countries.😊
bali(hindu) is a good place !! i(indian) will visit there to understand their culture and make some report only bali.
We Indonesian dont care.. 😂
Legally it is not a islamic country, but in fact it has become a islamic country, Malaysia history textbooks only highlight malay contribution , no Chinese and Indian history in the textbook. without lies islam dies
Of course.. U atuk and nenek are pendatang brought by british to work in lombong and estate..where ur atuk and nenek when japan invade Malaya. .??
Gagal sejarah?
That will be the UK in a year.
The Indonesian government is not serious about defending Christians being persecuted by the majority Muslim population in several regions. The Indonesian government has never acted fairly.
They never have been.
Didn't the Indonesia government had abolished right wing group? Ain't that a proof about how serious the Indonesia government is? And did you know that some other province have this thing called "autonomous region" where local government rule autonomously based their local Agenda, that included aceh where they had their culture centered around Islamic value. Meaning if you want them to change, doesn't that make you an invander or a rude guest?
@@naoe2067 No, I have great respect for the people of whom my mother had great love for, but I also know of the great wrongs especially over the Intifada that was only an excuse for people around the world to commit murders and blame it on Jews. Of which no country had more Christians killed than in the Indonesian islands.
@@charliebrownie4158u should see pakistan, north korea, and china.
@@charliebrownie4158why do people think that the 13 of may was because of Islam in itself. It was a tragedy yes, but it’s more a race issue, paired with the Asian financial crisis that Indonesians have been impacted the hardest out of every other country. It was the year that finally broke our dictators back It was horrible, but We are not taught to be monster.
Very sad, if you don't have a foundational culture to be proud of, then you are bound to adopt any foreign culture which is imposed upon you. This is exactly with Indonesia and Malaysia.
Yeah why not advocating for indonesia should cast out indian foreign influence as well, since many hindu nationalist and islamist alikes seemed to misunderstood Indonesian culture. Indonesian are friendly, they adopt many foreign influence that enriched Indonesia, just another layer like onion. It seems you are not familiar then of indonesian foundational culture.
@@abcddef2112 Yeah you think so? Less than 2% of them are trying to save their hereditary practice and is dying fast because of abrahamic imposition on a peaceful lot.
@@satyajitray5889 Yeah example of first layer onion, can you be more specific of what you are talking about? Which 2%?
@@abcddef2112 Ever been to Bali?
@@satyajitray5889 Ah you meant balinese? You do know what you call balinese is actually migrants fron Java right? Original Balinese did not practice hinduism, but animism and nature worship, they are called Bali aga. Have you ever been to trunyan? Only 63k of the 3 million balinese, are you advocating for them? Since its definitely even less than 2%. Even Balinese hinduism is different from what you find in India because as i said its just a layer of onion, scrape deeper and you would know its called tirta (water) tied to the mount agung river and the sea, animism, buddha reverance (hence often called siwa-buddha), and ancestor worship among other stuff. You understand now, how rich it is, dig deeper. There is muslim minority (and christian balinese) and even they preserve their ancient of mengibung and ngejot, of sharing with other who have different faiths.
How about France? Are you blind about how they banned Hijab for muslim women? How about India? see what they do about muslim in their country?
tell me what they do??? In india, our agency exposed PFI group who want to establish Islamic State in India Guys you are so annoying
Google says... In Islam, JIHAD can also mean "WAR AGAINT NON-MUSLIM ... to establish the religion (of Islam)". It is also understood as "just war" or "holy war!". .
That's google. jihad means in Arabic to struggle. Islamically it means struggling against your bad self (major jihad) , and struggling against enemies (mostly non Muslim enemies back then in war ) which is minor jihad according to a sahih hadith.
@@sunset2.00 Which jihad, minor or major, gets you straight to the highest house in jannah alongside Allah and allows you to pick your family and friends who will join you? ...We have read your books. Stop trying to deceive us like Allah (who is the "the best of deceivers" - Quran 5:34)
@@sunset2.00taqiyya..
@@LondonsFinestSon you can view us all you want and we can be different in interpretation, and practice