GTA 5 vs. GTA 4 | Ultimate CAR DAMAGE Comparison 🔥 This video, by ENXGMA, showcases the car damage difference in different scenarios for both GTA IV & GTA V. Let's find out which one does it better!
Chapters:
00:00 - Car vs. Train collision
00:50 - Car Fall Damage
01:59 - Body Scratches
02:46 - Fire Damage
03:46 - Car Engine vs. Water
04:25 - Max Speed Crash vs. Wall
04:52 - Car Explosion Damage-Chain
07:12 - Car vs. Baseball Bat
08:54 - RPG vs. Car
09:52 - Damage Effects on Driving
🎥 All GTA LOGIC videos! 👉 • Evolution of FOOD LOGI...
🎁 ENXGMA Merch! 👉 enxgma.creator-spring.com/
🔔 SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE!
#ENXGMA
• *New to the channel? Don't forget to Subscribe!* • *Let's hit 15k likes & I'll drop the next video.* 🔥
Yep
Here before the comment blows up
Bet
hi
But in gta v if most of it damaged car will stop working we can’t start it
Fun fact: In the old gen versions of GTA 5, the top of the car used to also get damaged. This was removed in new gen so the first person camera doesn't clip with the crumbled car part.
is there a mod to fix this?
@@donovanschoor1473 From a quick google search, there are a couple, not sure which is the best though as I don't mod my game. Search mods for vehicle damage.
facts
is there any video showcasing it?
Who drives in first-person? Not a single sane person does
I always loved destroying cars in GTA. For me, driving a car off a cliff and watching it crumple and deform was way more fun then a high speed police chase with many explosions.
👍
@leeleenatalweewee Not quite, GTA 4 police are little more advanced. LCPD behavior is more tame than LSPD and are more forgiving.
Then why don't you play BeamNgDrive instead
Same, its a fun feature to just punch and damage them since GTA 3.
Same, its a fun feature to just punch and damage them since GTA 3.
It's very impressive how cars manufacturers in GTA improved so much in just 5 years
Actually, cars nowadays are designed to deform more when an accident occurs. This is so that the driver will not have to absorb as much energy from the crash. Car manufacturers from GTA actually went backwards in the period of around five years, probably due to the recession. Or maybe Los Santos, California had different (and arguably worse) cars' body design tha Liberty City, New York. Correct me if I am wrong though.
@@sniperheroes3082 Very much correct (GTA Perspective that is), but yeah...cars are supposed to be designed to be soft or easily deformed so that the individual doesn't absorb the same energy as the crash, making a car hard makes it extremely dangerous (especially when the human brain is not supposed to experience a high speed kmh to 0 kmh in an instant, your brain will shake so fucking much that it might actually cause blunt force trauma by accident, and inside of it, which is worse) Also, we should also mention that with a harder car, if it does wrap you, you'll not be able to get out as easily in comparison to a car that is easily deformed AND removable, if ever like you said, an extremely sturdy car is legit considered impractical (depending on the situation, but if peeps were to be doing high-speed chases for example, yeah, a hard car is the worst case scenario). Other reasons why people have been designing cars to be easily deformed aside from to minimize the force absorption: 1. For them to easily remove other parts of the car (doors especially), I think it was somewhat proven back then that hard cars are more likely to jam (which would be unsafe for both driver and/or passenger). 2. Easily re-use / recycle the parts, I guess easy reusability is much better, though it's not always for the best... 3. Money (jk) 4. Reduce Weight Distribution to roads, pretty sure harder cars mean they're just heavier (or denser in this case), and roads do get affected by the masses of vehicles, this is especially visible when roads handle trucks, roads do get those weird level lower marks from time-to-time, and well, sometimes cracks or total wreck of roads happen due to EXTREME pressure contributed by gravity and the masses of the vehicles around it, I guess this is just a way to at least reduce that problem a bit). But then again, I'll repeat, your point is given, I just stated some of my observations as to why logically a softer car is ACTUALLY safer, that is unless if you get sandwiched, lol.
They are just copying cars from real life without the license. How is that improving
@@sniperheroes3082 was this the case in 2008 - 2013 ? Or recently
@@Theunfriendlyneighborhoodman Both, actually.
I don't know why but niko screaming for his life and jumping out of the car before the train hits him is one of the reasons why I love gta 4
I think he screamed after he saw train coming at him which makes sense
I think he just added the sound in because that scream only happens when Niko is falling lol
It was edited lol
Tho it wasnt mentioned i the video, GTA 4's car physics made it feel dangerous to drive fast regardless of how capable the car was. Hitting something at high speed always was a scary thing! I miss that
And it was a bit harder to drive because of the handling but you just has to go slow
@@sahalabdulgafoor4372 that's also what made chases with cops so nerve-wracking! "Do i go slow and preserve my car? Or do i just floor it?" XD
en GTAV si vas rapido en un auto de lujo con ventanal delantero grande, sales volando y mueres al instante o luego de reventarte conta cualquier cosa xd
@@avramnovorra when in doubt, go flat out
@@sahalabdulgafoor4372driving make harder and dangerous, that's why car driving in GTA 4 much fun
4:25 Ah yes, the OG comparison
Gta IV damages may look a bit overexagerated, but it also is in real life as well. As for GTA V, I wonder what are the materials used for such resistent alloy
Maybe Vibranium😅
@@debayanbaidya547 from Wakanda
In real life, after a strong blow, the car turns into a pile of scrap metal
No alloy. Cars in GTA V are made of carbon fiber.
Every car in GTA V uses the same material as the Regera lol
@5:50 Niko should’ve said ‘sorry cousin i am already seeing a show’
This is something I look forward in GTA VI, I hope that the deformations of the cars are similar or better than in GTA IV
It looks like it will be a mix of both judging from the leaks
GTA 5 is better than GTA 4. 👍
What would be better would be if they implemented the same soft-body physics that are used in Beam NG Drive. Now THAT would be something!
@@diarioninja sure man, your opinion
Same
When submerged under water, vehicles in gta 5 do not actually die when the engine is submerged. It's actually the exhausts that acts as the kill switch. If a vehicle's, exhaust touches the water, it immediately dies. You can play with this by using trucks that have the exhausts on the top and you can actually drive it in water for pretty long
Лол гта5 не тянет или чё? Даже сан андреас не тянет?????
@@user-gu4bu3li3sWhat were you trying to say😭
GTA 5 is better than GTA 4. 👍
@@diarioninja Not really, because what I explained is not practical in real life since a vehicle will die immediately as the engine is submerged in water which is not how GTA 5 works. Of course, while GTA 5 does a lot of things better than GTA 4, the physics and many other features from GTA 4 are lacking in GTA 5
@@Shaaaaaahin Physical??? Who cares about that in a game??? LOL GTA 5 has a better story, gameplay, character development and construction than GTA 4, super mega well-designed missions and much more interesting than those in GTA 4, which are mostly just simple missions.
In GTA IV the car can actually break down and niko will try to turn the engine back on again while saying things like: "come on you piece of sh*t start!" or come on, come on!!"
Yeah it's exactly the same in GTA 5 my friend
yes
@@thec.e.oofbasedindustries8013 yes with trevor "aargh this piece o shit!'
5:37 Glorious! 🤣🤣🤣😍
I think in GTA 5, the developers decided to let you have more fun with your favorite car rather then you accidentally hit it somewhere and it deforms too much leaving you sad and mad at it and continuously visiting Los Santos Customs for keeping fixing your vehicle or getting it destroyed in just few hits. Always see both sides! It was unrealistic but it isn't too much bad if you see from aspect I mentioned above.
Driving and the car physics are the opposite fun to me tbh
no they just downgraded things for laziness and casualization. GTA V downgrades many things. Also its held back by being a late 7th gen game ported to 8th gen with no real major upgrades.
yeah,I've always said this GAMEPLAY OVER REALISM.
@@DarkeningDemise ..or,gameplay over realism.
@@DarkeningDemise You have no clue what you are talking about, they literally could have copied GTA IV's deformation to V if they so wanted, but they didn't, they purposefuly changed it, that takes more work than just reusing it y'know? Also the game is overall just 2x better, more content, better graphics, amazing story, way more stuff to do, way more fleshed out gameplay (not just drive here, shoot that, actually fun missions.) Way more variety in general, its just a better game, get over your fantasies of nostalgic lust.
8:37 Bruh Franklin hitting the car synced up so well with the background music
Every game physics is a gangster until gta 4 car physics arrives 😎😎
Beamng enters the chat
@@ASMRJAMESY beamng has the most realistic car physics ive ever seen
@@ASMRJAMESY there's also wreckfest actually pretty fun game
The amount of detail in GTA4 will always be cool
I am hoping gta 6 is as good as it and better, If it ever releases
@@sahalabdulgafoor4372 Just hope Rockstar doesn’t screw it up like the last game they made
@@D_LGND they never screwed up GTA 5..?
@@LisssardManN Last game they made was GTA The Definitive edition
@@sahalabdulgafoor4372surprise 😅
8:00 Loved that Evil Niko laugh.
Please learn to time stamp properly. It happened at 7:58
@@TheKickboxingCommunity no need to comment if it's missed by a couple seconds.
@@Cr34tive People who didn’t watch the full video won’t know what you’re talking about
@@notTreydamanThank you for adding the proper one
2:08 me when my alarm goes off
Niko's screams will never get old! Also, 09:53 cool how peds react to the heavily damaged car.
7:04 Directed by Michael Bay.
6:42 onward made me drop an instant like 😂
6:30
Cars in GTA V typically blow up if you land upside down with 0 armor from a significant distance (like off the building, ramp - that’s not attempting a stunt, hills, etc.) If it’s turned at certain angles it will also blow up depending on how you land as well. Landing sideways is 50/50 depending if you were facing more upside down than right side up. Landing head on can oftentimes blow up instantaneously, rear side is tricky because it mostly depends on the angle in which you were facing. - from thousands of races, messing around in GTA Story mode and Online, and experimentation
couldn't a GTA 5 car explode on frontal impact with a wall if using booster pads and on a steep downhill ramp, basically depending on the speed the car reaches. and then with GTA 3, i believe that one, when you hit a wall, the hood of certain cars would get bent on impact.
Cars in GTA 5 doesn't blow up when they are upside down, you can turn the left stick to left or right and car will turn over
9:15 hey there's no driver on that boat!
5:45 why an extra ticket for show? Its already going!
GTA V: Oh, there's a scratch... maybe a little more than that GTA IV: "Sir... where's the car?" Oh it's right there... well, what's left of it
4:34 that minimalistic delayed camera makes the crash looking even better
*Roman:* Let's go see a show. *Niko:* Sorry cousin. I have no time for shows. *Roman:* Okay man, we should do something another time. At least the series of car explosions in Algonquin Bridge is a better show for Niko to watch.
Another great video. Also, the fact that vehicle deformation was so impressive in GTA 4 is but one of many reasons it's the best GTA.
Man is doing proper science experiments for our viewing pleasure. 😊 Love it 😊 😊
Here's a correction enigma: In GTA5 only when the exhaust(s) gets submerged, the cars stop working, you can try it with trucks that have exhaust(s) at a pretty high level from the ground
That doesn't make sense, in real life a car's engine only gets flooded and stops working if the intake (usually in the front of the car is underwater and pulls water into the engine. The exaust gases simply push water away and make air bubbles
@@PigIlFigo32you dont know nothing about cars
@@JoaquinOdorono that is correct
@@tammo02 just play snowrunner
@@JoaquinOdoroblud thinks snow runner is realistic
Another Banger from ENXGMA 🔥💯🔥
We need more mayhem compilation 😂😂
5:39 Badass and hilarious as hell!
5:27 live long modding 😂😂😂
GTA4 and GTA5 had comparable car scratching effects. I just think the scratches look different because of the shape of the car and what was actually making contact with the wall. GTA4 didn't look outright better
1:05 bro got lucky 💀
0:31 the level crossing gate closed after the locomotive passed LOL
Gta sa
Sometimes I feel guilty for enjoying mayhems, but they're very entertaining.
Gta IV Physics Is So Realistic 😬
@Royal Madman 🇮🇩 it is 😅
@Royal Madman 🇮🇩 umm can you speak English 🤣 that makes no sense at all
The thing I hated the most from four to five was melee combat. Four was much like RDR2, where you actually did a bit of boxing with people and the people who defeated would stagger off into the night after you knocked them out. Also, you could injure someone without killing them and an ambulance would come and cart them off. In GTA 5, if you punched a pedestrian with one punch, they'd just die and the EMTs would just make a report and drive away. THAT was my biggest disappointment.
Yeah absolutely it was down right embarrassing and trash in GTA V
Rdr2 melee combat is much better than Gta 4
The reason cars explode into flames from a fall in GTA5 is because the car hits the corners witch are classed as a weak spot (its stupid) so the only way to survive is by landing on your roof.
Hey man, always fun to look at your videos! Did you use a regular NPC's car in GTA 5 or a car with upgraded shielding?
the first example is pretty much solely dependant on where the train hit the car. in the gta 4 clip, you veered off to the side before impact, causing the impact to look vastly different than the gta 5 example, which was an actual head-on collision.
in GTA IV, near Brucies garage, there is a burning thrash can, that, if pushed near cars, can ignite and explode them, causing a chain reaction without getting a wanted star! My fav thing to do in GTA IV :)
Explosions in 4 also looked a lot better, in 5 it's just "some fire and POP", in 4 there is smoke, debris, sparks, it really looks like something blew apart and is smoldering.
Always loved the physics, weight, and damage in gta 4! 😁👍🏻it was all so much more fun and Satisfying! Also, niko reacts more realisticly by screaming and such! Great details! Love the cartoon squish noise! 6:29
man every time I watch your videos with that little music in the background and comparisons with other games it's too perfect bro we're together
GTA 4 - car blowned momentally. GTA 5 - rocket blown, after that car blown.
Gta 4's physics and Gta 5's map can make a master piece that only God can defeat
4:20 Its not about the engine, it's about the exhaust. When it is under water, the engine shuts down.
Gta 4 is still a MASTERPIECE
You are the only person I do like before I see the video😂❤❤❤ Continue ❤
Much appreciated! 🙏
3:02 hot wheels
😂
5:20 theres a perfect show right here
3:50 I don't think we can count that as a comparation, since as long as the car exhaust stays out of the water, the car is most like to be fine, since you kept the exhaust out of the water in GTA 4 but not on GTA 5, the car was fine in GTA 4, but of course not in GTA 5
Yeah of course, in real life you really don't want water entering via the exhaust but in real life you don't want your engine to be underwater too, it will still break, in GTAV if you don't have the exhaust under water you're fine which is a nice detail but at the same time it creates well this "bug" with some cars where the exhaust is side mounted
The explosive ammo cheat in GTA IV really showcased the amount of body deformation that could be done to cars. One shot and they would look like they were hit by a meteor
Rockstar focused more on GTA Online than GTA 5 when they made it, but I still like it
Not quite, they also had focus on their next projects.
Plus, they were probably pushing GTA V to the limits of the PS3 and Xbox 360, so that's why some things are downgrades in GTA V when compared to GTA IV. By that, I mean things like NPC AI, infamous Terminator LSPD cops, and how many less buildings that you can enter. You can actually improve car deformation by editing the handling file in GTA V, adjusting a multiplier near the end of each vehicle's definition to make it closer to GTA IV. I'm not sure why they made it so subtle in GTA V when the engine supports more realistic-looking car crashes.
Gta v is no near in realism compared to gta iv and i always loved to play gta iv❤
@Mr Bread Guy 🇮🇩 it kinda does
@@Mr_Bread_Guy cry for it🐁
@@Mr_Bread_Guy 🤓
Cars does hydrolock in GTA IV, it makes an audible click noise when listening to the radio as the engine cuts off
man that laugh 💀7:56
Imagine what this guy will accomplish with gta 6😮
Okay I do have a nitpick with the scratching, in the gta 5 scratch test you only hit the bonnet/bumper and didn't get the body of the car or the back so no scratches were put on there and the damage of the scratches on the front were a lot and if they were spread along the whole body like in the gta 4 test it would probably look more damaged.
They could've done better car damage for gta5, but Rockstar probably also had to take in the performance of xb360 and ps3 consoles, which were already pushed to the limits.
Thats what i wish more people were aware of, like the engine did as much as it could to account for all the new stuff
No. They could improve them any time they wanted on better devices and they didnt
GTA IV Got Amazing Physics!
7:42 Fun fact Papa Niko is in creative mode!
0:32 relizing the train gate closed after the train passed 💀
The chain explosions were the most fun in San Andreas lol. Just park a tank or monster truck right in the freeway coming into LS from the north, and you normally won’t even need to set it off because everyone will just start piling up and flipping their cars
Hope GTA 6 improves car damage by allowing individual car parts to break after collision. For example, tires separated from car chassis, engine seperating from car chassis, cars splitting in half etc. I know thats too much but if they do include these I will appreciate it
2:42 In this case, I think it was because of the car design (Banshee) and the wall.
Another great video bro!!❤
when it comes to games like GTA 4 vs new games I will always chose GTA 4 (besides rdr2 and some others) as it just had amazing physics and sometimes physics just beats graphics as games with good graphics means they spent to much time on graphics and not anything else.
In GTA V, if you submerged the frunk of an electric vehicle in water, the car will still run fine as the batteries are in the back. Most of the time fully submerging an EV in water in GTA V will not stop the car from working just fine.
That call from roman Always gets me 😂
Nice bro keep it up!!!
Man I LOVE this video,keep up the good content RESPECT
: Car Damage in GTA IV : Soft Like a Cake : Car Damage in GTA V : Hard Like a Rock
It's literally same, bro
Not sure why they devolved GTA 5. GTA 4 physics were amazing.
1:56 That menyoo sign of the back of the car ID reminds me of the Menyoo Cheat menu :)
@9:45 one thing you missed is that the point of impact from the rpg to the car does not show, however in gta 4 wherever the rpg hits, that is deformed and where the tire came off. Also If you keep shooting an rpg at a car in gta 4 even after it’s blown up, you can keep deforming it. However this isn’t possible in gta 5
In GTA 4, if you hit a car fast enough either your or the other car catches fire and in rare cases even explode.
GTA IV's car deformation physics is identical to Burnout Paradise City's physics.
Definately no, just try to play burnout now and you will see that its not so good as you remember :) Especially the fact that deformation occur only on fatal crash
@@Artsem4ka exactly my point!
@@Artsem4katf? Burnout is way better in terms of destruction,stop meatriding rockstar
@@Professor_Genki7 in burnout cars have primitive predefined destruction model like in NFS and only in fatal crash cutscenes car will be smashed using physics. In GTA 4 cars dont have predefined destruction models at all. Its always generared by physics and you can do weird things with it. So generated destruction model in gta is much better than standard predefined model in burnout
Idea : i wanna see GTA III destroy Cyberpunk 2077
I love how characters screaming and yelling. 🔥❤
Gta v damage is like a rock that being hit by hammer and only does few crack meanwhile gta iv is like a bread that got squished.
Damn correct
yes both are unrealistic
In real life car after crush would look a lot worse than in gta 4 lol
*The cars / vehicles should be dependent on the fuel level , and if the damage model 'd be on the IV's level of deformation + the mechanical damage inclusion , now that would be something I'm striving for*
that'd be too annoying,there's a reason gameplay over realism is a thing
You want that? Use a mod.
Thats, honestly pretty annoying…
Fuel would be hell, especially in missions where you have to do a lot of driving. "OH shit we gotta get to the other side of the map in a set time even though my gas is almost all gone? Guess I'll die!"
You make so amazing Content, Homie
6:42 The chaos with the music was hilarious 😭😭 lol 😂
gta4 still has the best physics until this day
@@ashey68 both of them are best
@@ashey68 Everyone prefers his favorite game, buddy, and for me, I prefer it from Grand 5
@@ashey68 ❤️
But the bumpers and side panels don't even come off like I GTA 5
Definitely no
9:47 actually they've updated the fire and smoke effects in the PS5 version, looks better than this now.
Im late but i can SAY that they added Just alot of smoke
@erander8522 smoke was just part of it but it may be the most noticeable difference at a glance. The fire was overhauled too, plus a new shockwave ripple effect added to explosions. Also new muzzle flash effects from guns.
*Almost everyone who plays GTA 5:* **Puts armor on their cars** The damage model is so unrealistic!
Fun fact I learned in GTA IV, if the car breaks down and doesn't start up. Call a random person and it starts the car up
1:39 that's what I absolutely hate in GTA V...
It's happening ONLY if you land on the trunk or rear bumper
@@Teimo_Pielinen01 No it happens when you not land on wheels, and yet people still call this game "realistic" lol
Fun Fact: your engine in GTA V will only ''drown'' if your exhaust is underwater it means that you can take a vehicle with high exhaust like the trucks and drive underwater as long as your exhaust is in the air
The mayhem in GTA V! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 That was epic!!!!!!
oh boy your content is as valuable as a Diamond and a music to my ears Bring More please i am hungry for More
GTA SA : stories GTA IV : physics GTA V : graphics
Stories is a tie between SA and IV
@@JFVideos960 no way gta IV story is trash and not fun
@@adhambutsaif5589 that’s not true. You’re just blinded by nostalgia
Gta 4 has better history
@@adhambutsaif5589 gta 4 is the best
Daymm ! 🖤 Enxgma is best ! ❤️ Tbh I've played gta iv more in ps3 so like both are good but gta iv more close to me than gta v but gta v has more things to do .. Gta iv lags in medium end pc too.. Ps3 is best for gta iv and all games ! I've played gta v rarely but it has to many things to do ! ❤️❤️❤️
That was really impressive homie 🤟🏿🤟🤟🏻
The damage in GTA V is not even half as impressive as that of GTA IV