Goddamn mongolian broke my naginata!

I mean, he uses It as he should, its just that he can't thrust since that can damage the blade and the armor (remember that this is a sparring) and that really limits his resources to swing it like a long battle axe

I find it interesting that everyone on this website is an expert on everything all at oncr

Yeah, really the naginata is just a Japanese glaive with maybe a slight focus in being more spear-like.

​@@TholandThink Pending on the form of the Kissaki, a Japanese sword is actually quite good at thrusting too. It is to the point that Naginata were often used in home defence, as their tips were often pointed and made for useful CQC weapons as they did not need to be swung.

Lol strong work my guy 🤣 I'm totally new to the weapon, the learning curve is real

Facts i miss the good ole days when sparring ending with only one person walking away

​@Mike Sonnyfu sir those are called duels

@@COGsandwich51 ill duel you

@@mikesonnyfu that actually sounds really fun

​@@mikesonnyfu mans on that musashi miyamoto grindset

Nah, whatchu talkin' about? My man Hideki complains about Mongols breaking his Uchigatana and shit once a week! It's nuts bro, I'm telling you!

Japanese weapons aren't actually good in combat aside from anime or movies

@@schnitzel_enjoyer no, no even the Dutch (or the Danes, don't remember) like the Tachi's they mistankenly called the "Falchions" but liked them .

@@schnitzel_enjoyer Are u sure about that? First of all japanese weapon is one of the best weapon back in the day, it's unbreakable especially with the katana, they have limited supply of tamahagane (high carbon kind of steel) they make there weapon precisely good and durable in battle also there armor.

@@Yasuke-bh3de "katana was unbreakable", no quite the opposite, they were too weak, they bent easily without proper technique of swing and very sensitive to corrosion, even touch, they were showpieces of high rank warriors. If you know anything about actual history, they actually fought with spears and bows, katanas were personal last ditch weapons for very close combat (which was avoided). But yes agreed they do look cool in movies.

I doubt it, knowing that they actually fought the Mongols historically, and won the first time, and the second time the Mongols gave up because the waves were too heavy

This video seems to be at least wrong training or one of the weapons were fake.

@@TheSkyLasts the Mongolians actually razed an few islands.

@@TheSkyLasts The only reason the japanese won was because of the storm. Those 4’11 japanese samurai midgets would have gotten buttfucked by the mongols if it wasn’t for the weather.

@@stefthorman8548 not really, you see that’s a theory that isn’t really supported by history. A lot of people come up with the theory that the Mongols won against Japan and they didn’t really they may have took it over some islands. You might be right about that. But if you’re insinuating that they were stronger than the Japanese, that is really sorely mistaken. Because the reason why the Japanese one is because they had an advantage point because of Japan is an island. That’s why I always try to debunk a lot of things like knights versus samurai, is because people forget that tsunami‘s and a lot of other natural disasters like typhoons exist around Japan. I’m pretty sure a lot of sailors wouldn’t like having to sail through things like that. And you can’t really say that all they would’ve just planned an attack. Yeah, like they can see Japan all the way from Europe. This is what I call theory history. And the reason why is because it’s only speculated because people hated something. There’s not really much to say other than yes the Mongols did attack. Did they get anywhere not really. They had a lot of problems with getting to Japan, which kind of led to the defeat against Japan, or at least the failing of raiding Japan

I think they dug deeper too

nah they love seeing grown men play fighting

Alan Turing? You mean they being medically castrated in their graves?

No these are real warriors. Tough as nails, battle hardened, forged in the fires of war

I think they’d be happy that people keep what they did alive and remember what they did in some way and that people no longer have to do what they did for real. Aside from Henry of skalitz he would be in a blood rage that he missed a cumin and trying to come back to finish the job once and for all

Omg yas 💀❤️😂

It will not keilll

What's funny to me is that real athletes/martial artists never participate in this kind of shit, it's only the D&D croud that ever participates in these "fights" so they always look silly.

Lmao

Lmao

Underrated comment. Japanese flexing about folding until it gets really folded

⁠​⁠@@p2w383 the main reason why the japanese folded their blade so many times was due to their shit quality iron ore. Even then it used to break so easily. Idk why they flex so much.

​@@Karznaxthe folding expels impurities from the steel they have.

@@junkyyard2273 thats what i said

​@@junkyyard2273 Other guy is right. They were polishing a turd essentially. Nobody else needed to fold it that much because they just got decent materials in the first place. Japan was very backwards technologically.

Main issue with using bladed polearms against armor.... they suck This is why it was more common to see polehammers or halberds (with hammer heads) in European armored duels, because they actually can bust apart armor and transfer good concussive energy onto the opponent, a naginata does neither of those. As a fencer myself, if you were to ask me what to bring to an armored fight, my literal first response would be a polehammer with something like an estoc as a secondary.

@@anothnypitt443 id bring a gun

This comment is giving me american overweight father raging about the decisions his favourite football team does vibes.

@@anothnypitt443 all of this style of fighting is silly irl they would wrestle each other to the ground a chink with a knife People standing around bashing each other with bladed weapons just wasn’t a thing it comes from Hollywood where Jon Snow disembowels a warrior wearing mail and coat with a single slash

@@viveillyvi you might need to take a chill pill in that case Your comment gives me “I take joke’s literally” vibes

Or a quarterstaff

Or a sword

The most deadly weapon one can wield

All he has to do is strip naked and he wins against guys with AKs and full metal with that thing

Can be deadly tooo

We even broke katanas🤣

​@@munkhazaya29katanas are easy to broke because they aren't meant for primary, but for secondary

You can still duel with a polearm. The main issue here is that he wasn't using it like a polearm but stupidly closing in.

I've never heard of naginata being mainly used for anti-cavalry purpose. You'd be far better served with a thrusting weapon aka the yari. It's not just an ashigaru weapon. What I've learned is that the naginata was intended as a crowd control weapon.

Samurai would either Use a Naginata or a Yari than a Katana in battle lol

I discovered this in kingdom come deliverance. Use hammers on heavy armored knights to waste them haha 😎 🚬

​@@syndrathedarksovereign1609 失礼だが、勉強不足 11〜12世紀は刀、弓、薙刀が一般だ 16世紀になり、農民が戦闘に加わって集団戦が重要になったから槍が主流になった それまでは戦闘は武士の専門だったため、熟練度が必要な武器が使われていた。言ってしまえば、槍は素人でも使える武器ということだ

Они на своих пони пол мира захватили. Они бы и дальше захватывали если бы Чингиз не умер

the ships never came

He didn't bring a typhoon with him, skill issue

@@dargone3231 I like your funny words magic man.

😂😂😂😂

I have a subtle suspicion that he might have more experience with a naginata than you do.

Its rule of the fight buddy. You can only swing the weapon not thrust it since it will have greater effect and pierce the armor gap.

@@i_commission_dspriscilla_a7486 Nope. These blokes have not had a minute of formal training and bought their gear of WISH. If they had training - they need to get their money back. There is NO footwork aside from randomly shuffling around, They do not consider the distance between themselves and just bang their toys against each other. Naginata vs Dao / katana you can stay at a comfortable middle stance at 2/3rd extension and poke your VERY pointy blade against their center or head while circling at your leasure. You have the range and the leverage to just force their blade from the center if they try a bind. Traditionally - you would not bother with binds. At full extension a swing from a naginata could decapitate a horse. Blocking those swings was NOT an option.

@@christophedlauer1443 haha, kinda obv you’re talking out your ass at this point. Lets see your background, not that i believe you have any, what with you thinking any HEMA organization would allow WISH to provide gear. Couple that with your perfect hypothetical that would crumble in an instant when you’re in a sparring ring.

​@@christophedlauer1443 Naginata were basically just bladed spears. This guy is using it like a club. Half the time he doesn't even go for a blade swing, and wacks with the pole! If this fight is designed to be fought this way, then that is just so sad.

Was waiting for this

Damn! You beat me to it! But I posted it before I read the cmnts. Well done but if you'll look at the cmnt above, mine is a bit different lol

@@jacobcasmus1882 lol I like your take. I think its more city than mine ;)

mongoreane

Damnit I was thinking that

I agree

​@@genghiskhan6185 Dad?

​@@genghiskhan6185 daddy 😩

@@genghiskhan6185 ohh great timujin of the havens tell me what is your great wisdom

I feel like his title should be “The Great Daddy” due to his track record 😉

They'd both die

They'd probably run somewhere together

I'd give them less than 30 seconds. 😂

He didn't studied the blade.

Most skilled Asian bladesman

What you mean by that

The Japanese, the Chinese, Eastern European countries, the like

@@erdenebaatarbatmunh6841 South Park

Best people on the planet

@@erdenebaatarbatmunh6841 God damn Mongolians always destroying my shitty wall!

ikr!

I always wonder what would happen if even our most experienced HEMA and Kendo practitioners got to face even an average warrior from the feudal age, I bet the fight wouldn't last long. 😂

@@AK-lx1crin whos favor do you think it would go?

@@AK-lx1crsword fights never last long, but I favor the actual professional soldiers most of the time

@@menacingcar0449 I'd say that the average soldier would win 10 out of 10 times by the sheer virtue of having grown up practicing techniques of the sword our current "experts" can only speculate on through their interpretive reconstruction. To add to that, even if a warrior was average back then, they would still have actual combat experience on the battle field in a life or death setting, where as HEMA practitioners only do sparring drills. They simply wouldn't know exactly how actual soldiers from back then moved when they fought.

“ce”

Stupid chinese- tolui khan

He here for piano lesson, lah. You stoobid...

Destroy your sh*tty wall!

I knew someone would reference South Park 🤣

He'sh on his wrey to knock down shity warr

BEGIN OPERATION TOP SECERET SPY BAROON

He was hitting it with wooden part and after the ordeal. Samurai: Mongol broke my weapon

The composure it took not to burn down the defenseless hometown, when he was done.

The Mongolian blade is literally made to chop pole arms and spears in half not even sure why you’d try to fight at that close a distance with a pole arm weapon 😂

😂 mister big sword. While Japanese guy is disarmed, big mad! 😂

😂😂😂😂😂 i felt that

is it a Kipchak or a Cuman

@@nurdauletsarsenbay462 probably kipchak

@@nurdauletsarsenbay462 As the guy, its Timurid. Which was part of the Mongol Empire

I fucking died at this comment 😂

Damn cumans raiding his village and killing his parents.

One of the best gaming experiences I've had!!!

I was searching for those comment‘s 😂

I was looking for this comment

Wearing a makeshift yoroi and using wrong a naginata proves nothing about naginatajutsu, this is just ridiculous

Pretty much

I would even go as far as to say that even all the best pros we have today in all of their respective weapon of choice won't even amount to even a lowly footman

@Ready Set Mood! I fully agree these men and some women were connected to the sword and Armor as today they practice every so often ..... if you were to grow up with nothing else to do..... no internet, books, tv they probably dedicated their lives at a young age and were taught by good swordsman from a young age

Not because it was a women made for women, but because it was a weapon that gave an advantage against men.

​@@Kalidoscope1230 pretty much everything with more range than you has advantage if not close combat, the spear tipe of wapon was used a lot

It was mostly used by foot soldiers as an alternative to spears. Women are included a footsoldiers as they are peasant soldiers like most male farmers.

Of course, it is a weapon that men also use. However, Japanese spears were more difficult for women to handle, as they were mainly used to kill by striking rather than stabbing or slashing. Many women preferred the naginata, which gives a powerful blow just by swinging down the heavy blade.

​@@ZFilms11 actually noblewomen would also get trained in the naginata in case they had to defend their estate while their husbands were out on campaign.

Bruh 😂

The samurai would probably trow away the broken naginata and use his sword in those kind of situation.

He would have to resign and lose face, because he is a total FAILURE.

Yes,this is cuman or kipchak,not mongilian

Falchion I believe

​@@ethanelam9175 Naw. Falchions are almost exclusively one handed. My guess is literally what he called it. A Military Cleaver.

Probably a chinese guandao

Yea that’s a military cleaver

Yups that is War Cleaver, imagine Mongols Bokh swing it to cut off horse head

Depends on how long you were fighting already in a full set of armor.

energy and training these guys don’t have

The armor sets don’t even match with themselves

@@anon2427 ok cool. One has Mongolian armor on and the other has Japanese armor on.

this is a Kipchak or a Cuman. and this is not Mongolian or Turkic armor, there are only patterns from them

No he´s hmb fighter with cuman helmet and weird plate coat.

That's correct!

Its a Turkic helment from Cuman-Kipchak tribes.

He’s assumed to be a Cuman-kipchaq soldier from the Mongol army.

Mongols had every kinds of soldiers in their ranks. Yes, up to Persians and Lithuanians

Every European knight gangsta until not full armored leather Muslim knight with a normal sowrd appears.

@mine_mo7md655 No

​@@ALE-zk6tb what is it rereconquista?

The video is a single combat, non carbon steel sword can damage a full armor carbon steel. And dont bring religious or political shit here because you gonna lose the same, muslims countries are poor and shit countries where people prefers to die in the sea at live in this countries.

​​@@mine_mo7md665 Every muslim knight gangsta until ottoman janissary comes and takes caliphate from arabs

It was hickory, I'm new to the weapon and I kept hitting him with the haft. Just bad distance management, the new haft has been holding up nicely since I've been hitting with the blade lol

​@@fightswordradio3735you could have just said, "cardboard" . jk ofc 😉

Certamente quem quer que queira voltar não tem um cérebro. A espectativa de vida era de uns 40 anos no máximo.

​@@kaboon3489 Lmao fr

​​​@@gagida1829limão🍋

He has both. His facemask is notably Kipchak but he has Mongolian Soyombo symbol on the back of his skirt

@@JohnDoe-qn8mw oh really? Wow I understand Turkic armor better than Mongolian tbh😁. But it's quite historical! All of kipchaks were under Mongolian Empire

​@@eziodafirenze7962 the Turks did not participate in the campaigns against Japan because the Yuan army was involved there, that is, the Mongols, Chinese and Koreans

@@nurdauletsarsenbay462 личина на его лице тюркская, а костюм монгольский

Now they are merely china's lapdog. How the great fall