A.I.-She Does Not Love You
2011 ж. 9 Мам.
133 514 Рет қаралды
For my final presentation/essay on how empathetic robots in film alter the idea of singularity. For 21L.706 Film Studies. No copyright infringement intended; all rights go to the creators.
Singularity is the idea that machines could have the capacity to evolve at a faster pace than humans and is linked to the fear of robots gaining too much control. Blade Runner, AI, Bicentennial Man and I Robot present how this fear is complicated when Robots are presented as empathetic, humanistic creatures.
Joe deserved better than the ending he got. He risked (and eventually lost) his own existence frequently through this movie to protect David, who was programmed to only truly care about the person who abandoned him.
Joe said the saddest thing possible: the truth.
and the truth of humans what we can do in the flesh fair, sooo brutal destroying machines with bare hands it can be truth in the near future the truth can hurt sooo much
And he gets it right back and gives it right back... Every time I think maybe this isn't my favorite Spielberg film... without rewatching it all again a single clip just hits now so right in the ways that are totally opposite of... something
Sad thing is Joe is completely right. Monica never actually loved David, not really. She was just using him as a replacement for her real son Martin. She only wanted David around to fill the emotional hole left by Martin while he was sick and when Martin got better, she no longer wanted David. Sure she tried to keep David with Martin but she never treated the two boys as equals and always treated David as inferior to Martin and ignored the fact that Martin was bullying David and manipulating him and favoured Martin. When she no longer wanted David she just threw him away like garbage which is something no mother would do to their child if they truly loved them. Monica never really loved David but David always truly loved Monica and never forgot about her :(
No, she just left him because Martin nearly drowned when David's mind told him that Martin would protect him and it was really Todd's fault.
@@eleanorhogan8643 Yes Todd is also at fault for convincing Monica to get rid of David but Monica was supposed to love David like a son but couldn't give him the same love when her real son returned. If David was a human boy she had adopted, she couldn't just throw him out when he was showing difficult behaviour. She never respected David like a real son even though he thought of her as his real mother. She would've treated him differently if he was human but he clearly feels human emotion and she shouldn't have just abandoned him. The film is all about how we have responsibility over things that love us and Monica made David love her by imprinting on him and when she couldn't reciprocate that same love she didn't take any responsibility for what she had done to David
That was the point though. Don't you remember the first question the lady at the beginning of the movie asked the Inventor when he first suggested making a robot that can love? She said, "Yes, you'll be able to make them love us, but will you be able to make us love them?" I guess the answer ended up being no.
David was the real human... In this movie.. good name too... David means beloved. In Hebrew.
Monica was lovin' David, but she was compeled so as David was killed ! She made what one could so as saved him!
Jude Law was the best part of this movie. He understood what it meant to be a mecha in a world where human's blame you for all of their mistakes. They were built for a purpose, a niche, to fill a hole in someone's heart or simply as an oversized toy, or like a replicant a job that human's deemed too dangerous, and were still treated as garbage or sins. We human's perfected the design of our replacement's in this movie.
Even more wisdom than you think, it is said the source of all love is selfish.
this movie is so good,it brings both perspective about reality,the false belief of David until the end,but it escalated it into a point when we don't even know what's right or wrong.What remains is just a poor robot boy with his so-called obsessive love for a woman(an illusion).What we only know that,human was mistaking as Joe said because they(we humanity) had taken over God's role in life and we must take the consequence that's the doom(cataclysm).And the sorrow for our creatures(A.I androids) which would never be solved.
and the flesh fair how the humans become so inhuman and destroying them in a game show, sooo horror to its core
@@jamesboulger8705 We don't just love what the robots do for us. We just love what anyone does for us. We don't actually love other people either.
@@sumanadasawijayapala5372False. Very false.
Teddy is the only one that's truly loyal in this movie. The rest are only in it for themselves. I still have my teddy from childhood, he never let me down.
He is indeed the Jiminy Cricket to David's Pinocchio
Gigolo joe was actually a real friend too. If you pay attention this scene is not about him trying to hurt David, but it is about him trying to warn David from trusting humans. Even after David left without listening Gigolo joe helped him at the end, by turning on the anphibiocopter to find the blue fairy (sorry for my bad english)
@@luflor4689 of course,David was choosing to live in the sweet illusion till the end,he is a poor boy created by the sin of humans.He could have chosen to live an humble and meaningful life with Joe and without his human mother who can't never love a robot.It's sad by the way
Agree. In the final of movie, Teddy 🧸 has really big impact!
I love this comment ❤
Jude law's acting is just fabulous
Yeah he did that!!
It always is, just like his beauty.❤
This movie struck a deep chord of uncomfortable truth. The way the Mecha are treated, are how all too many humans and creatures are treated by other humans. That was the most disturbing aspect of the movie
Such a sad and moving concept. It’s what all things artificial are made for
Joe foreshadows the ending when we jump year into the future where robots rule the planet and there are no humans left. Spielberg mistake though was making them look too much like aliens leaving people feel like it was a turn out of nowhere. Why are aliens in this movie?!? It even took me years later to learn they aren’t aliens, they’re mecha far advanced. Much like Joe says here, they’re all that’s left.
0:58 every simp needs to hear this
XD
Chroof!
lol...but I'd correct it and say "every MAN needs to..."
If this movie were made today just like it is it would be sensational
This movie's intelligence is way above that of the great unwashed. That's why the movie was unsuccessful.
One of the best Sci fi films ever made that touches so much on humanity and the consequences of developments without conscience and moral ethics
@@wongkengmun1103 Despite the fact that critics called this film syrupy.
How did Jude Law deliver that monologue without blinking?! My eyes would've been tearing all over the show! 😁
Gigolo Joe was the wisest of the A.I.
Imagine trying to come to grips with the fact your very existence was a specific purpose in mind regardless of your choice in the matter. Imagine you were created stupid, strong, computational, overly attractive, demure, aggressive, flirtatious, or maybe mute or deaf at the behest of a certain demand for such a mentality to be programmed. Your very default emotional, mental, or physical state to serve someone elses purpose as a form of currency or service.
That is the common existential crisis many of us face. Many who do not get the benefit of being born out of love or a proper purpose must feel that crisis daily. Rather sad really.
Robot: What is my purpose? Rick: You pass butter. Robot:.......Oh My God!!!
No different from today. There are things such as birth expectancy in countries. People need to be born to sustain an economy not enjoy life. And we all know that some have to clean toilets while others earn millions.
This is the most horrifying aspect of this movie. The mechas do exactly the function they were created to fulfill, even better than humans because they cannot falter. David's "love" for his mother is all he is, the same way Joe changes his form for his lovers. But David is trapped in the mind of a child who cannot mature or detach from that connection and it causes him to feel constant fear, unworthiness and unhappiness. One moment that always stuck with me was the mecha nanny who smiled as her face burned from acid, in an effort to comfort David, a child, a directive hardwired into her. David can never come to grips with the fact that his mother abandoned him and live on because he was never built to serve the function of being a full person outside of loving her. So he requires an empty replication of his mother's love in order to finally rest. Absolutely heartbreaking.
So relatable to todays world. She doesn’t love you. She loves what you can do for her. In the end…. We will be the only ones left.
I thought this movie was meant a warning to humanity just like the Terminator series. Honestly I think the threat will be GM humans not the machines.
Same with Blade Runner and even Ex Machina.
yeah
The machines are the good guys, really. Being human means being dirty and free.
Alien-looking mechas vs skynet.
@@ilyas6875 alien looking mecha are prob so advanced they can just wireless turn off Skynet.
This would make a kickass television series on HBO MAX. The concept of Artificial Intelligence being hunted down by Humans.
Just imagine: THIS was the actual beginning of The Matrix.
Ummm... no. We don't need the machines to destroy us. We'll do it ourselves.
@@sumanadasawijayapala5372 Well..that's what happened before the Machines took over.
I love this scene with Joe ,because if you really think about it it we are our worse enemy. Robots are just here to serve n fix our mistakes. But like the woman who asked the question in the beginning of this movie I wonder... Do we ... As they're creators...have an obligation to... Look after , nurture ,and love them? I would love to hear someone else thought?
ambrosia Bass Deep. Yes. When we bring a child into this world we do not leave it to fend for itself. We refine its abilities until it can survive on its own. These were made to be perfect but because they were made by humans, who are naturally and irredeemably flawed, so are they. And they are punished for that because of the hope we held for them to be perfect. Nothing can live up to the vast expectations of the human mind.
this movie is so good,it brings both perspective about reality,the false belief of David until the end,but it escalated it into a point when we don't even know what's right or wrong.What remains is just a poor robot boy with his so-called obsessive love for a woman(an illusion).What we only know that,human was mistaking as Joe said because they(we humanity) had taken over God's role in life and we must take the consequence that's the doom(cataclysm).And the sorrow for our creatures(A.I androids) which would never be solved.
@@anniewilliams6561 this movie is really deep in philosophy,of course it won't happen that human would be cold blood and immoral.However,it does happen,if the technology was fallen in the hands of evil beings,human lives and of course poor robots will be killed legally,the dark side of humanity.
Robots, AI, machine learning and deep fake, etc., are "smart" enough to simulate the weakest parts of humanity first.
You ask a good question. I think we should look after, nurture, and love anything good that we create. If one is inclined to believe that there are souls-preexistent or otherwise-they could inhabit robotic bodies just like organic bodies. That could provide an incentive to love, nurture, and look after a robot.
when i first saw this scene i thought David would understand that Joe was right all along and stayed with him in the end. They could have a father-son found family bond of some sorts. But of course David was too naive to give up on his hopes...
@@OddOfThisWorld That's what made him "human."
@@LordRayken Only Jude are fully sentient. Jude realized his role and knows how the world works. David on the other hand is enslaved by his program. If he was human, he should be more open-minded and think about it. But he was fully chained of his program to loved his 'mother' even at the fact he was abandoned and never come back. David was nothing but a machine, a stupid machine that unable to understand the human heart.
@@rogueascendant6611 that's what love is isn't it
@@ZackJohnson-yu7luCan David eat food, drink, grow older, swim, climb, and think independently? Or is he just meant to work a certain way as a machine? Does he have a brain, heart, nervous system or other natural bodily functions that would make him real?
Jude Law killed it in this character.
I remembered I cried after watching this movie and I was just 6 years old.
I feel like David exactly, I am living this
Brilliant film such good acting
I dont get why the kid is supposed to be special when it is clear in scenes like this that joe is also capable of love. He wasnt programmed to care for little kids or empathize with sociological issues.
Joe seems to be an adaptive ai, growing in wisdom as experience accrues, much as humans would. Joes love is an emergent property or side effect, of his being programmed with a flexible adult-level ai. David, on the other hand, apparently lacks any ability to learn besides navigating his physical and cultural environment in a very simplistic manner. David is a duckling who imprinted on the first thing he saw, and his capacity tops out at that point. David is weirdly a machine that is INFERIOR to human intelligence. Joe could learn to be a chef, david is a shiny toaster.
That's the dichotomy between robots with A.I created by humans. They are built with "humanity" in them. Like they said in the beginning scenes of the movie "we can program them to love us but can we program ourselves to love them". David was literally "imprinted" with her motherly love specifically like the latest iOS Update. Joe wasn't imprinted so his loyalty was always to fellow machines. To the point where in the end, he helped David with his quest even though he didn't agree with it
Joe is programmed to have empathy in order to be a better lover to his customers, it's only natural he established something of a connection with David after hanging around with him long enough. But you are right, the only thing special about David is that he is modelled after a child. The love he feels for Monica is not real love, it's completely his programming doing it's job, which is why throughout the movie it feels more like an unflinching obsession to be with Monica always than it does genuine human affection towards her.
A modern day Pinocchio
This was just a good, deep movie!
I really do. you are unique and special. you are more intelligent then people made you. aren't us, Orga, just as mechanical as you, Mecha? I have a battery called "heart" and cables called "nerves"and "vains". a skeleton to build my structure. Hormones to control how I feel, react, and work... I'm honestly planning to make a Gigolo Joe the time I can reach that technology
Monica loved him in a twisted way .... by the end of the movie what her clone said to him as genuine.. human beings are complex .. When her son returned from the death she got confused and afraid to love David more than Martin because David was the perfect “kid” she felt guilty..I hated her the whole time but she indeed loved him.
Joe means well he was David real friend besides teddy but Monica did love David if she didn’t she let him get destroyed but she didn’t but yes she went above and beyond about it the wrong way she had no other choice in the end David never stop loving his mom because Monica was everything to David not in a controlling sense that’s how he is programmed to love which definitely hard to do sometimes for humanity and also David was very forgiving he did not hold any grudges for Monica doing that and that’s incredible and inspiring.
1:37 Chatgpt
joe I love YOU.
I hate when it's said that Monica doesn't love David! "I have always loved you," she whispers. Even if it's her clone, it's still genuine. 💙❤️
10/10
when i saw this movie, for the very first time, I almost cry, ok no, i really cried. At that time, I was a kid, and I don't understand the real implication of the Davi's AI, I just turn off my brain, and imagined how ausome could be the future,... but, today,... oh, today. when I back to see the scene of Gigolo Joe, explain that the Mecha would be the only one who's left... I'm coming to understand the meat festival, the Monica's decisions, and the final scenes of Mecha and not aliens...
You are alone because of something you said that displeased them or being broke. You dont have to be a robot to experience this
Whoever disliked this…what even brought you here?
I like to think that humans could love a robot/machine.
NO THAT IS BAD CAPITALISM
Lol ai boyfri and/girlfri nd
Pinocchio of the modern age
"..and all that will be left is us." Yep, digging in the ice for a missing link to the humans that created a race of robots from which they evolved.
This is why we should never be experimenting with sentient androids. As incredible of a technological achievement it would be, we would never see or treat it as human, no matter how much it thinks it is. Also the phrase “we are suffering for the mistakes they made cuz when the end comes, all that will be left is us” is featured in the song Parasitic by Psyclon Nine. Random bit of trivia.
Thats some deep stuff..
Monica loved David its just she gave him the only fighting chance she thought she could she was terrified of him inevitably being returned to the factory and destroyed. She loved him and abandoning him was heartbreaking for her but Monica knew he would inevitably be destroyed and mistreated until something bad happened if he stayed around humans so she told him to find other mecha who could look out for him and take care of him when she couldn't what she gave him was a fighting chance even if a slim one she did the most loving thing she could given the impossible situation she was being put in. David being programmed how he was simply didn't understand just how much she actually loved him and assumed she didnt love or want him. She did love and want him but knew what would inevitably happen.
this movie is so good,it brings both perspective about reality,the false belief of David until the end,but it escalated it into a point when we don't even know what's right or wrong.What remains is just a poor robot boy with his so-called obsessive love for a woman(an illusion).What we only know that,human was mistaking as Joe said because they(we humanity) had taken over God's role in life and we must take the consequence that's the doom(cataclysm).And the sorrow for our creatures(A.I androids) which would never be solved.
It's so sad because he is a robot who became self aware as human and developed human emotions, even love and pain. Because of this, he is not really human nor robot, thus not belonging to any of these. Kind of being somewhere in gray zone, your mind is human but robot body. It must be so painful for him.
singularity would still occur with empathetic AI's.... we would just be included in new future most likely as transhumans
So I’ve only recently found this but David reminds me of how I saw my mother when I was little and sometimes even now. That if I do something right, if I’m everything she might want me to be, she’ll love me. 0:36 - 0:57 really hit me
I’d just like to say on behalf of all loving mothers, I’m so sorry you ever had to feel like this. One thing that did me a lot of good when I was young was when I realized that just because a parent is an adult doesn’t make them right. You can be an adult, and a parent, and still have your head up your ass. It’s honestly my life’s work to make sure that my children know that no mother what they do I will always love them. This movie hit me hard because of my thoughts of never wanting my sons to feel this, or to feel what David felt when he was abandoned. I don’t know you but I wish you love and happiness, go out and find it for yourself!
This is why I cried watching the movie as a child, constantly trying to prove yourself and do flips to make your parents proud or happy, yet they push you away. The message is that the problem isn't with us, it's with them.
Yeah, that part demonstrates how terrible some of the most innocent desires of the heart can become.
I think I could love a robot. The question is: Could the robot love me?
❤❤❤
This scene... There's so much truth to it! Red pilling!
But she loved him. She loved him enough to not sending him back to the factory for destruction. It was not the wisest decision, but a well-intentioned one.
An argument could be made that she acted out of empathy rather than sympathy. She acted out of her own selfish desire for him as opposed to what was best for him. Was abandoning him in the woods and leaving him vulnerable to the flesh fair really a better option? There is also a recurring pattern throughout the film of all the human characters acting selfishly out of empathy as opposed to logic and sympathy. The film seems to be commenting on how to love is to be selfish.
this movie is so good,it brings both perspective about reality,the false belief of David until the end,but it escalated it into a point when we don't even know what's right or wrong.What remains is just a poor robot boy with his so-called obsessive love for a woman(an illusion).What we only know that,human was mistaking as Joe said because they(we humanity) had taken over God's role in life and we must take the consequence that's the doom(cataclysm).And the sorrow for our creatures(A.I androids) which would never be solved.
yes but that's not the point of this movie
Mega Scoundrel Was Monica' Husband !
@@lanmichaelmix2818 We were so preoccupied with whether or not we could, we didn't stop to think if we should. Life, uh finds a way.
A lot of viewers seem to have forgotten that it was Henry who no longer wanted David, not Monica. I don't mean Monica wasn't selfish or hurtful because she was but I do think she did love him in her own way- just not enough. I believe she died regretting her decision.
I haven't seen this film in ages, but I watched it many times when I had free satellite ppv. Is this a deleted scene? Because I can't remember if it was in the movie or not..
does someone know in which minute of the movie this scene is i need it for an essay and i really need help! i cant find it
Many people treat innocent human being same as David was treated by Monica and rest of humans
This is so fucking sad watching this at like 10 was not good for me I cried so hard the whole movie
Like Alcatraz versus my upcoming court date versus Gattica.
😶David 😢it's hard worlds 😐maybe she Doesn't💔love 🙇🏼♂️😢🥺I'💟💖👨🏻💻thi's movie to me I me cry 😭😭😭
0:24 dicaprio pointing to tv
The primitive mechas lacked an understanding of love at all and David had only the barest one dimensional idea of it. He didnt understand how complex love is and it isnt simply doing things for people you love to make you love them.
What's the movie title?
AI (artificial intelligence)
I put this 2015 AI and it wasn't about David I like the movie it reminds me of a lot
I liked Minority Report way better, but this film after revisiting it really hits on a lot of spots with a robot created by desperate humans in a Earth Wasteland to fulfill a emotional need only to be blamed for the mistakes humans themselves made only for humans to go extinct while David is left alone desperately wanting an illusion he can never get!
There are both terrific movies, but like Minority Report this movie is about a loss of loved ones, but this movie is much more realistic and doesn’t have any sort of happy ending.
She does not love you.
I love you
' Your Mother 👁️ '
We have to break this silence what's happening with humanity
Black pill..
0:35
1:25 how some baby boomers view their millennial kids
Sheldon Cooper's AI
AI is a fantastic film, it is my favourite film of all time. It's sad and touching in equal amounts. Todays films are too glitzy and technical for my taste and I did not like avatar either, a load of crap in my opinion. AI is a much better quality film. It is well made and the cast were fantastic and the ending blew me away. I also like the films, Gladiator, Enemy at the gates, Mr Brooks and behind enemy lines. AI is the greatest masterpiece ever to be put on tape, screw the Moana Lisa, a horrible painting anyway. Just a picture of some boring average woman! AI is a complete masterpiece in it's own right. It's sad that Haley Joel Osment had to grow up, this film will be my favourite work of genius till the day I die!!!!
🦮👮🏾♂️🦉🥷🏽🤔
Man…speaking of Alexa right ?
菜油タ＆男郎
abrupt. XD
Actually Joe was right and wrong on both things, he was right about the mechas being the only ones left when the humans being extinct but he was wrong about David's mother not loving him, she did love him always.
Actually she didn’t and the film showed that humans cannot love robots, that’s was the heartbreaking piece of the film.
@@DMalltheway No she did love him, it even says so, but I just like to think that.
@@eleanorhogan8643 It even says so, but you like to think that? Dude you really need to watch the film analysis, she didn’t love him.
@@DMalltheway She did so, plus it makes the ending happier than her not loving him, plus she left him in the forest rather than take him back to the warehouse to be destroyed which shows that she cared about him.
@@eleanorhogan8643 Dude in the end that wasn’t really Monica, it was a recreated illusion.
DAVID IS SUS 1:45
I mean 0:45
I mean 0:52
M3gan will bring down these droids including David. Monica WILL PAY!
Gigolo Jude.
I cant talking arabica some one
Bluepill normie kid meets blackpiller
Not hating on any real people, but why was the “lovin” robot given a receding hairline? Like that’s on a woman’s wishlist? Like women robots with butch haircuts or big tummies is on a man’s ?
He was able to alter his hairstyle and hair colour at a whim.
Sam smith 😂
Geez that’s exactly how women are with Men, she loves what you do for her but she does not love you for you.
Women can't love a man in a way the men do.
@@ashleyatreides Because most chicks try to use their sexuality to play power games without realizing its got an expiration date and if they don't bring anything of value to the table it's natural for them to get replaced for the next generation that would at least be more attractive, it happens with men too, as soon as they bring nothing of value to the table they can get replaced as well, only much faster, they don't even know what hit them or what went wrong.
@@ashleyatreides Men are thrown away too, even faster when they are no longer providing social, emotional or monetary value which is when they are not genuinely desired and do not excite or arouse their partner, only Men don't discard their partner as easily if it's not a transactional relationship because Men are idealistic, women are realistic, we evolved that way.
When you’re just watching a really good moment from AI and wanna see some other takes on the characters, and then people in the comments try to turn a philosophical moment about technology into some sexist Im14AndThisIsDeep bs. Touch Grass. David could have been just as likely to encounter a Jane instead of a Joe. You’d look weird talking like that then.
@@MsScarletwings I agree that Joe and Jane would make no difference since David was not seen as a child but as an object of affection from the Mother, the film implies female imperatives and the need to save their offspring/reproductive imperatives from this object which is David and David's idealistic notion of unconditional love proves us that females don't do unconditional love it is mainly opportunistic unless it is their reproductive imperative, their child.
this movie had its flaws for sure...... but I guarantee you, that if you hand over this script and production to Stanley Kubrick(if he was still around), the guy would make this into one of his masterpieces...... SO MUCH potential to become one