Will Xi Jinping Invade Taiwan? John Mearsheimer Answers | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Will Xi Jinping Invade Taiwan? John Mearsheimer Answers | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Who’s winning the war in Ukraine? What role does India play in the current world order? Will Xi Jinping invade Taiwan in this decade? Catch America’s top political scientist John Mearsheimer answer these questions in a conversation with Palki Sharma.
---
John Mearsheimer | Xi Jinping | Taiwan | China | Russia-Ukraine War | News18 | Rising Bharat Summit 2024 | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#cnnnews18 #russiaukrainewar #taiwanchina #xijinping #risingbharatsummit #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Chinese media talks about China's accomplishments. India talks of US accomplishments and complain about Chinese accomplishments.
And your point is?
@@henri3651what is self ruel, and what is a serfdome ruel?
@@painterQjensen Rule NOT "ruel". I was asking @freedum_3.0 to clarify his or her statement. Do you @freedum_3.0 live together? If so, clarify the statement for me. This could be the golden opportunity for you to get some free English lessons. At the very least, to learn how to spell.
because Indian media thinks they are so intelligent. but American kalistanees thinks they are not...
@@henri3651 India is a frustrated nation.... #world Happiness Index..
Invade ? United Nations document says: Taiwan is a province of China. It's means Taiwan is neither a country nor a nation.
100% correct. The US and west all honor "One China" policy which essentially says "there is only one China and they ack Taiwan is a part of china. Since all these countries have diplomatic relations with China (not with Taiwan), that means Taiwan is not a country.
do you trespass on your property?
Neither Republic of China (or the so-called 'Taiwan') nor People's republic of China (the socialism China) officially denies that Taiwan is a province of the whole China.
@@MrMingsyinUN is invalid today. They are even involve in terrorism.
@@willengel2458India tranpasses Shikkim, Bhutan, Pakistan, Kashmir Goa
I am curious to know how Indians feel about such remarks from John Mearsheimer, he is clearly explaining the imperial mindset of the US, he even said when Indian continues to grow stronger, they should rest assured that the US would put its gunsight on India...and the audience feel comfortable with it?...
Lol it's not a news to anyone,india isn't that naive although we'll take the support of their market's to grow our economy just as china did and now that is to big to handle for us they'll support us until we become a headache for them too and most likely india will not end up like china being us rival because i believe china threat is here to stay for a long long time unlike ussr
Because the audience know that it won't happen 😅
@@dhirendrasingh1382 which part won't happen, the India growing stronger part, or the US putting gunsight part? 😂
@@rickzeng1882 The US putting gunsight part because US will always need India and both US and India are two great democracies.
@@dhirendrasingh1382 hilarious…throughout the whole period since India’s independence, you country has longer time of being closer to the Soviet Union and Russia after that, then why weren’t you closer with US in those time as the same great democracy? Never mind, believe in whatever you like haha
Chinese strategy: Bide your time, hide your strength Indian strategy: Chesthumpting, boasting
China's strategy:bully smaller nations and expand your territory at any cost India's strategy: don't bully any one but if some one does bully you know how to give it back to them
Also China hide its weakness and show offs its strength like making enemies with its neighbors and doing expansionism through land grabbing
China has made serious enemies admit it and no one can save them now 😂😂😂 everyone knows that China is just an expansionist who likes to land grab, that's why it is sanctioned too and for the last 5 years China is just declining only nothing special China did 😂😂😂 why because they just copy things up from US and Russia lol
Not even russia treats China like an ally that's why Russia never shared its technology with China but is sharing it up with india
Mind Begs the Question: - If under a Indian PM/Govt - Protesting Rapes is Sedition,Jailed - Gang Rapists are Garlanded,Freed - Indian PM/Govt is Democratic or Fascist?
Why deleted the part where Palki asked if John Mearsheimer consider India a great power, along with US, China and Russia?
Because it’s embarrassing for India !! Can’t handle the truth
Because the woman always brainwash her people for making money, you know. The unfavorable information of India cant appear in the screen.
yes, they really deleted it
7:15 "...you can rest assured the United States will put its gun sits on India..." Yap! This is the John Mearsheimer I know. Never forget he said that "America doesn't like peer competitors."
This is the bad news for India. But the good news is that China will not collapse and consequently India will not be subject to US scrunity over human rights in Kalisthan, Manipur, Nagaland, Kashmir ect.
what human rights.. please provide data.,.I am keenly interested in vacuous statements for analysis purposes.@@nmew6926
No mofo likes competition ! A pimp always wants his territory so his girls can get all the customers. China does not like India to compete and vice versa. The best product, price and technology will reign supreme. Right now, China is competing on price and to some extent on quality. However, to reach Japanese or German quality it is at least a decade off. I mention this, because India never competes on quality or tech, only price. So India is a couple of decades away from being a real competitor. America has no interest in India except as a bulwark against China. Same way China uses Pakistan, even tho Pakistan is as far away from any cultural or commercial value. India just does not cut it on the world stage. The Indian FM is a dandy for the RSS, and he is seen like that. A RSS clown in a suit.
@@nmew6926 the us has overturned roe v wade and will overturn several progressive policies and laws.... The us will have a lot on its hands and seeing that the us did nothing when people in other countries were forced to abort their pregnancy against their will ... We can all say that they don't really go by ethics but just opportunity
@@nmew6926 by the way there is no place called khalisthan or kalisthan like you mentioned... So please get your facts straight 😅
John Mearsheimer has openly stated many times that "the U.S. does not tolerate peer-competitors". The U.S. effectively stopped Japanese economic growth with the Plaza Accord in 1985. It's not a coincidence that China's troubles with the U.S. started occurring in a major way around 2012, the year after the Chinese economy overtook Japan's economy to become the second-largest in the world. The key indicator seems to be that, once an economy becomes roughly 1/3rd of the U.S. economy, the U.S. government will then view it as a potential threat and seek to repress it.
An Indian can't believe what Mersheimer says
The "good guys", ala G.I. Joe, are the ones that have 800 military bases spread around the world stationed as colonial outposts to mind the serfs and look out for any upstarts that may try to break free from the leash. 4% of global population thinks they are God's gift to the planet, that they inherently "better" and thus have the "right" of heaven to point guns at anyone that says otherwise. Its a slight inconvenience in 2024 that the "good guys" are actively engaged in the mass slaughter of over 30,000 women and children, all while Blinken's toasting the toadies at the "Democracy Summit". 1984 was a look in the mirror. Mearsheimer certainly will over look the inconvenience of the US suddenly relying on over 80% of its market cap tied to AI which has a single source in the foundries of TSMC, located in the Republic Of China, so proud our their heritage they built the 國立故宮博物院 as a beacon of their cause, making NVIDIA chips Chinese made, in the hands of Han Chinese, reading/writing/speaking Mandarin Chinese. Don't worry US investors, Jenson's got this one under control. What's that? His entire companies fortunes and thus the fate of the US economy is a mere 100mi offshore the mainland missile silos? Mearsheimer should have a field day explaining how the US just has to do what they're doing, they are the good guys, and good guys don't allow peer-competition, just like Jesus taught.
China 2025
True, the US has a very long history to keeping countries economically dependent on the US and preventing economic growth by enforcing policies the U.S. would take use at home.
China will overtake the US economically and militarily
In other words John is saying US is trying to use India agains China and India is falling for it. :D
when this Jew talks USA will walk
Is it not a good thing for bahrat to fail? Would you rather want it to be come a proper puppet state?
Chjna has consistently harmed India for decades.... India is not falling for anything.... India has finally opened its eyes to what the US can provide.... Us has also actively tried to harm and undermine Indian interest for decades in support of papistan, so India cannot trust either... Not taking alies to a common problem would be utterly stupid
Lol. India harmed itself more than China ever did. China only defend it's borders. Nothing else. The border clashes are small potatoes not even worth talking about. India has had 8 decades to grow and develop but it has gone nowhere. Also USA has harmed India way more than China in terms of keeping it backwards and undeveloped. China invested in Indian and traded with India, USA has done nothing. Even today India relies on China for many things like raw pharmaceutical goods which Indias pharmaceutical industry is reliant on. Same with cheap quality smartphones and other stuff. without China most Indians won't even be able to get online since they can't afford apple or Samsung phones etc. India is too corrupt. Every infrastructure project you need to pay 50% of the total project cost just for BRIBES. just like everything else in India. completely corrupt bribery country. No wonder it will get nowhere, regardless of growth rate. All the growth is wasted on bribes and goes into the rush like pocket while normal and low caste Indians are starving and working for peanuts and their lives don't improve.
@@Shss701 India says China is harming India. China is saying India is harming China. Just because India is louder doesn't mean the issue is one sided. Anyway, there is no option but to engage in dialogue and compromise on both sides. The way as it is, China is winning due to its growth and wealth accumulation. It is in India's interest to engage with China so India can take advantage of the Chinese growing market.
He is brutally honest and does not mince words. A ton of takeaway for indian politicians and media. Don't keep harping on your achievements till you have actually achieved much much more than what we are at now
India is good at blowing its own horn and listen to its own music
@@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq not India , the politicians. The rest of us sometimes feel good and mostly feel cringy... Well aren't all politicians all over the world like that??
I agree. Many Indian wants to be the next or surpass china, they don't realize that it's a TALL order & quite a miracle. There is only ONE country in the world with 1B+ population that can achieve what China has achieved and it is china..... Now I am not saying that India can't do it but we need to look at the facts. There are only 2 countries with population 300m+ that can do what china does, China & US. But we need to realize that US were the least affected country where all golds went to during ww2. It was 40% of worlds GDP & has been experiencing economic decline ever since. If you lower the population to 200m+ (7 Countries), you still only see China & US. Lower it again to 100m+ population and you only see 4 countries, China, US, Japan & Russia. 3 in which were already heavy hitter before WW2. There is a reason why India has been called the next miracles by time magazines in 2000 but it's still at its stage now. It's not easy to pull up 1B+ people especially using the system basically borrowed from western countries with way less people.
@@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq when most of the world only focuses on its failures, it's only right to talk about their own successes. ... No other country I guess apart from one in the middle east is reserved for this level of negative press
For India to claim superpower status, it needs to 1. Raise literacy levels to over 90% , 2. Equality of both genders in education and employment opportunities. 3. Massive investments in health care and infrastructure. 4. Adequate sanitary facilities for the general populace n reduce open space defecation. 5. eliminating red tapes to attract more foreign investment. 6. Reduction of brain drain overseas amongst its elite scholars n professionals.
Indian superpower has just been shot down by Mr Mearsheimer.
It doesn't matter what the man says. As long as the lady says India is the greatest power, that's the one counts as it make 1.4 billions Bhaaratians happy 😊😂😂. The one who entertains better gets many more fans, truth does not get as many fans, this is the world reality.
@@fajarliongso true, so true!!😂
@@fajarliong the lady is taking you for a ride.
No US will shoot down first . USA wants poor and messy India and on the outside it will keep praising India as champion of democracy . Champion largest democracy of the world ( indians themselves proud to call it foolishly ) . Remember the two POPULAR words DEMOCRACY and HUMAN RIGHTS are easy to weaponise and they are being weaponised Wake up India ,you can never be rich nor superpower if you keep shouting ' we are largest democracy in the world 'who cares except US CIA .
@@yongdeng1813 😂😂😂
She must have been disappointed that he did not say India is a great power now. Also must have been disappointed to know that India will be treated like China by US if one day India grows big enough.
That's when the bubble burst. Bharat thought that they were the darling of the West.
they are already pushing India to pick sides. They wanted them to stop buying Rusian gas, and they want them to join a military alliance to encricle China. Whatever happens, remember the US is not your friend!
sad
If a country thinks it is doing great, then no need to ask a foreigner how my country is doing. I do not hear any reporter from China and US asking such questions. They are confident about their countries.
Was just going to post similar. This is pathetic pandering to your master race. Lol. Get out of that stupid caste system mindset
Indian journalists always ask question to answers we want to hear. That's not journalism.
hindutva rss extremist
there are just like IDF organized terrorist.
That all journalism do
"Farmayeshee Questions"
Distance from China mainland to Taiwan 100 miles. Distance from US to Taiwan 7500 miles. Who has the disadvantage? Also the material warfighting experience in the US in recent decades is with third rate powers that didn't even have the GDP of one city in China.
👍
And what war have China fought beside the since 1979 ?
CCP supporters always conveniently forget all the US military bases and allies in Asia, and how US aircraft carriers go through Taiwan straight like their backyard. If you truly are loyal to China, say things just to feel good is not going to help your country.
Good lesson for Palki, palki always mocking China's economy collapse... 😂😂😂
That's what dents her stature as a journalist.
@@marietheresa7866just a propagandist not a journalist
Hahaha, their self delusion
Did you not see their recent tofu drag construction? Or gutter oil ?? Or children stuck inside a collapsed gym? The parents were only allowed Access to their children's bodies if they signed away their right to take legal action against the administration?? You didn't see all that news ?? Assessing your neighbour is a must ... Just because someone else sows seeds of dissent by their opinions doesn't mean really is untrue
Yes, agree with you 110%
Palki having a shocking lesson
Looking out from the well is what she sees.
Those calling Hamas terrorists, what do we call a country who preached freedom and right when they dropped Atomic bomb on innocent lives. Lets keep Hypocrisy aside.
Both are abrahamic evils
If India chooses to fight for USA against China direclty, it will be the biggest mistake India will ever make geopolitically in history. Think before you do.
Look at Ukraine before you want the US to support you
Mind Begs the Question: - If Majority of India dictates - What Minorities can/can't do - Take Minorities Religious Rights away - Democracy or Majoritarianism/Fascism?
Agree. India will play both sides though, and I think that's smart. Benefit from two great powers trying to gain your favor but don't pick sides. But if you HAD to...definitely China. Anyway, India needs to focus on development on the ground first and foremost
@@supahsmashbroIndia dispute is merely due to McMahon's line which was drawn unilaterally. In 1949, India did communicate with the KMT govt then in China and the will of renegotiating the error. However the matter was reversed to an aggression and land grabbing especially after 1962 war when China was plunged into a greater internal chaos after KMT defeat, korean war, etc. Moreover, India was wholely ruled by a imperialist British empire. Thereafter, India had become a young, proud and ambitious India with a Big Brother ambition. And still is! I reckon many Indians dun know much with the border issues except politicians' rhetoric which are making use of nationalism to hide their own failures and diverting attentions for votes!
@@Facts..Checker You put it very well
To all Indians, always bear in mind that the late Henry Kissinger said that " It is dangerous to be an enemy of the United States, but to be a friend is FATAL!" We all are seeing this in Ukraine, who chose be a member of NATO instead of staying neutral! The Chinese way of a WIN-WIN solution is still the best alternative!
India is wise....hope this wisdom will overcome her fear & loathing of China.
Do you know the context when Kissinger said this? If not, it is rubbish. It was stated during Vietnam war, when a Vietnamese leader who was friendly with the US was killed by the red forces. Now you know the context. Stating it as fact is idiotic!
Yes China always want a win-win scenario with their neighbors 😂😂😂 I mean, they want their neighbors not to react when their territories are grabbed 😜😜😜 That's what the meaning of Win-Win for them. Stop your ambition to dominate. For years China grows peacefully, now they want to be destroyed loudly 😜😜😜
There is nothing to gain in a relationship with Chi na. Only they gain, gain and gain. They want to make and sell everything industrial and buy only mineral and agri-commodities. Unless you are only a commodities exporter, there is only loss for a country dealing with Chi na. Worst, their border claim is always 5 kms into the line claimed by you if you are a neighbor and even if they agree on border they don't want you to put fence on it( Guess why ?). So what's the point of any relation with them.
@@Jake00001 do you also know the context of having a hostile, greedy, land grabber neighbors? 😝😜😜
Professor Mearsheimer is so honest. If the PRC goes the way of the USSR and becomes much weaker then the USA, then the USA does not need a strong prosperous India. Things can change quickly in this day and age.
The CIA will start funding and supporting rebellion in Punjab, Manipur, Nagaland. Washington DC will give instructions to Western media to investigate on human rights violation in these regions particularly
China is different from USSR, it will not break apart like it.
I don’t think so, the US would profit heavily if India lifted hundreds of Millions of people into the middle class like china did. They’ll need another foreign consumer economy powerhouse if CCP falls. Also the west and India actually share pretty Sinclair values compared to ussr or CCP.
The only country amongst those you mention that is realistically in danger of falling apart is ... the US
@@gdiwolverinemale4th hahaha that is actually funny bro
India is not even the same league as China! and really when you visit both place there’s is no comparison
Who said both are in same league, they said india is becoming wealthier
True, but intend to reach there. China was nothing in 80’s like Bharat. They took off and we didn’t then.
CHINA WAS A POOR COUNTRY
@@SathishKumar-ck4gt Both eagle and chicken can fly 1 meter high. But chicken can never reach the height eagle flies.
But every indians addicted to fake news, that's the power of Bharat
I hope the Indians appreciate Mearsheimer’s candor. The United States views other countries as either instrumental or adversarial. You’ve been warned: Proceed with caution!
Indirectly said India is poor 😂
Didn't say poor. He said still not wealthy enough unlike China and USA. Remember India is world's 5th ranking GDP. And world's fastest growing economy set to surpass Germany and Japan and become the third largest after USA and China
And still is able to compete with China 😂😂
Economy bada ha, rich getting richer. In comparison to every other country you mentioned, our living standard is the bottom. India will surpass others thanks to Adani Ambani but never really get it's population out of poverty.
@@yam2050 No NRI wants to live in yhe crappy living conditions.
India is dirt poor. Poorer than many African countries.
Thank you for shedding the light why China and Russia will continue to have each other's back indefinitely.
Very sadly, China and India don’t fight side by side against the west colonialism.
Only because of the border dispute
Century of the brown man and the yellow man.... And God save everyone else.
India admires the west for such a long time and desperately wanna be like one of them. Chjna just wanna be china and not bowing down to the west. Thats the difference!
@@yongdeng1813 😁😁😂😂oh ho we are only civilization who is continue by nature look your China europe imported communist ideology China is European communist ideological state but we're continue hindu civilization thousand of years
Yes Brown man and Yellow man
Always been a fan of J. Mearsheimer. His perspectives upon the geopolitics has been a standout.
It seemed so at the beginning. But his predictions about the war in Ukraine were wrong. His hawkishness on China is misplaced. His love for liberal democracy is misguided.
Agreed. With so much propaganda and BS flying around nicotine only on the MSM ( as usual ) but KZhead as well he is a great source for how things actually are, not how people want them to be.
It is as simple as the rules of jungle.
bro, ur avatar is illegal🤣 although I know it is a Buddhist swastika
Every neighbor of |ndia hates |ndia because of |ndia's expansionist policies. If one neighbor hates you, you are probably not the problem. However, if All your neighbors hate you, you are definitely the problem. |ndia IS the problem. For example, 1) Maldives wanted "|ndia out" 2) 2015 Nepal blockade and the |ndian annexation of Kalapani from Nepal on year 1962 3) Afghan embassy in India shuts down 4) 2001 Bangladesh-India border clashes and now, Bangladesh wanted "|ndia out" too 5) Chinese and Bhutanese officials wrap up new round of border talks and agree to work towards formal diplomatic relations? India? 🤭 6) 2013 |ndian Annexation of Moreh from Myanmar 7) Tensions between India and Sri Lanka are on the rise as Sri Lankan fishermen complain of continued bottom trawling and overfishing by Indian? 8) Pakistan conflict with |ndia is well documented. They don't see eye to eye. 9) |ndia tried to invade China through forward policy and tried to play victim on year 1962 war? |ndia tried to block the Henderson Brooks and Neville Maxwell report when it was leaked momentarily in year 2014 on the internet? Why? Something to hide?
It is imperial n thought it ought to inherit n behave like the British in their hay days
1. Pa*ishan shut down its internet on election day. 2. So many global apps are not accessible in surrounding counties 3. Ties with srilanka are quite well, that's why they didn't let the chimese research ship dock 4. On one side the Maldives want India out but their other ministers are coming to Indians and begging them to come visit and after that video of their assembly got out, it's better to let them figure out what they want 5. The opposition party of Bangladesh copied the India out campaign from Maldives in hopes of winning but failed miserably 6. Nepal and Bhutan are still heavily dependent on Indian exports and the anti India element in Nepal has lost its seat..... So whatever you are saying is just surface level and can be quickly refuted by real data and information... Of course internet access was suspended since they were used to radicalise the youth. Please tell me why internet was shut down in Pa*istan on election day ?? Why are all major information sites banned in Chjna??? Glass houses ladies and gentlemen
The best and most precise interview I have seen this year
We Inddians are 0bsessed with chinna
His an extremely astute observer of geopolitics. I would even go so far as to say he is probably the best out there. People like him should be kept close foreign policy decision making.
@@Superpooper-2020Palki is one the reason... She is a cheap propaganda puppet, selling fake news to fool you people
Robert, maybe John talked about things you always wanted to hear... John is great, but not God... 😊
John, India can never ever keep it's promises & it's deadline in every big projects.. India is the paradise for corruptors.. 😊
Fool😂
@@starbrother806 Look at the mirror and you will find the big fool... 🤣🤣🤣
@@user-qz7un9ch9f If you notice things happening in recent history you know that its not true... Sure there have been delays but not like neighbours of India where entire pipeline projects have been delayed for years or buildings have been taken down due to corruption... India has completed all of its promises and in things like sustainable ecological promises, it has surpassed its goals 😊
@@Shss701 even in the protectors of the nation "Indian Army".... Big corruptions...... Google it
we atleast our rockets have fuel instead of water like china
China has been giving their citizens professional education and training to make their people capable of productive force but for India it will take years to build scalability.
China also forcefully terminated scores of pregnancies... Does that mean other countries should copy that too??
@@Shss701Nope , those are other countries own decisions China does not interfere with..
India's best talents are now making big fortunes in USA.
@@jishuzhou6640yes, even their elites do not like this shithole
This man is one of the greatest realist minds on the planet now
That would be trump
Palki made a flirt with Mearsheimer, "should India help US fight China?" What she really wants to say is, "how much are you going to pay India to make such a posture?" And Mearsheimer said, "frankly speaking, India will only help indirectly. And India will remain on the fence." LOL 😁🤣
Ok dear Pakistani citizen😊
It's not about the money, it's all about the image. India wants to be NOTICED.
Ya, you can see her face expression of disappointment.
If India get involved, it may repeat the history of Italian invaded Greece during WWII.
Why all so negative questions and alwayys thinking about war palki ..
Warmonger that's why ..just like US
It is India problem not just this lady. The whole Indian mindset from top ranking officers to bottom untouchable people like hers. Hopeless country.
If China invaded Taiwan, I don’t think the US would get directly involved. They will supply weapons to Taiwan but won’t go to war with their largest trading partner and a country that might be able to actually seriously hurt the US both militarily and economically.
米尔斯海默对于军事真不太了解 中国对台湾的大规模轰炸和征服几天就搞定了
6:56 "*.. if India get rich, rest assured America will point its guns on India...* Palki reaction:".... Gaza, Middle East, Israel... " 🤣🤣🤣 A good journalist should be able to improvise questions following such statement,
Palki is a typical Indian. Bla bla bla....
Rest assured India will not be rich and become a superpower, mainly because it does not know how to cope with the pressure that comes along with richness and power.
Why in Asian countries want to fight against each other yes there are differences between them but always give diplomacy a chance
US divides and conquer..ever since
6:36 he said quite part out loud. 🤣🤣🤣 US always keeps neighboring countries enemies. 🤣🤣🤣
one thing to consider is: which countries do not? because there are countries that are in a stable, friendly relations with their neighbors and people should learn from them more
@@Pilvenuga but still, it uses pak to keep india in check. It uses india to keep china in check. It used ukraine to keep russia in check which back fired. Just few examples. Still there are many out there. It's like divide and rule. Yes, people need to learn to be stable with neighbors.
Palki Sharma is a disgrace for Indian journalism, she does not have her own point of view and objectivity about wars, she says what the USA dictates to her.🤮 Many thanks to Professor John Mearsheimer.🙏
Are journalists supposed to have their own point of view? Or are they supposed to just report the news ??
I have never had a genuine, interesting, concise and well articulated interview and response from realistic people like this. Palki u are a great woman.
He is the greatest connoisseur of world international relations and he predicted all that what happening now , more than 30 years ago,
i don't know what china did to palki. she is like always anti china 24/7/365.
John is a library. Always a pleasure to listen to him
Thank you both
Now I know why USA helped China get rich
Taiwan is integral part of china just like Andaman is integral part of India,there is only one China that is people republic of china,this fact is recognised by India,America and most of countries,then why America is sending weapons and soldiers to Taiwan,this is equivalent to sending weapons and soldiers to north east of India,will India allow sending weapons and soldiers to north east,Kashmir,India should oppose sending weapons and military to Taiwan,otherwise one day America will send ,is it ok for India,this is what America doing in Taiwan
you are perfectly correct ...the American way which is the British empire way, the "maritime" empire built on pirates attacks ... now are just more sophisticated but the imperialist mentality is still the same
Palki not prepared for this interview
she wanted to attack china but fail
She is not even a elite reporter, most of her videos are trashing China and today she must be sad cause she got none of her answers
She is A China hater and just mimics news from other sources!
@@KijjiSale She's just a proxy for the BJP talking points.
@@deezeed2817she is an hindutwa malware..
John Mearsheimer one of the best in the geopolitical analysis... great job Palki interviewing..
He believes Israel doesn't want a two-state solution and he considers the west should not help Ukraine militarily => I don't see him as a good analyst. Actually I've heard him multiple times and he seems more like a Russian propagandist. Some of his points are valid. So he provides a mix of good judgement and propaganda
He is an offensive realist and I think he has a point
@@paulianas he has been right on the money with every prediction. He warned back in 1990s that Ukraine ought to keep its nukes. Then both him and Bill Burns recommended in 2000s to not do anymore NATO expansion.
Venpul, maybe John talked about things you always wanted to hear... John is great, but not God... 😊
@@user-qz7un9ch9f he is at least sensible in his analysis not like the mainstream media BS’ing big time… I never said he is god…
Straight Questions Straight responses
Straight question stright answer and the naive palki is shock... She is talking about helping tbe US contain China.. But forgot one day US gun will be on Indian head...is India get stronger.. India is too naive like Palki
I love your question but don't be too happy for India because America do not have friends,,,if America make India grow at some point they will do to India what they are doing to China now,,,America goal is to remain on top
Mr Meisheimer is one of the honest and accurate geopolitical analyst. Predicted Russia Ukraine war atleast 5 years in advance.
india controls Malaka straits ? Since when ? who told this lady that ?
Palki asking questions like a robot. No humor and banter. Making mistakes and stammering at times as usual
Out of her league for sure.
When u used to tell lies then all of a sudden u are in front of a geopolitical giannt, u feel so small and become tongue tight!
@@yongdeng1813maybe you are talking about urself😂😂😂
@@h02ctnrapid fire questions dude there is no time for articulate and whitty questions
Palki is not a one on one interviewer...she is a greater narrator and story teller
The host was sorely disappointed that the guest did not give favourable answers about India's strength. Chest thumping is always India's forte. LOL
Same observation
Not really, if you watch her other videos then you would should her views align the guest
India is still a long way to bridging anything. Sort out your infrastructure first.
so true. unfortunately, India's bridge never last long😅😅
Population is an asset when they are wealthy and educated, and enhance the power of a nation. Population is a liability when they are poor and uneducated, and burdens the development of a nation.
说的不错
She should ask him whether kashmir should be free ???
At least for now India is a faithful student of the US. As he said soon when india shall be a threat to the US, trouble will begin .
It was not like an interview it was like rapid fire quiz round
Multipolar? It's more bifurcated, with India trying to sit on the fence. Sitting on the fence becomes a real pain in the *ss.
But United States lost all the war they fought
The US benefits from wars, not only from wining the wars.
Anchor was terrible , guest replied fantastic 😢
🙌🙌 i actually dont blame her, u just cant act smart if u arent!
You need a brain and knowledge of English to understand Palik!😅
@@blandingscastle3729 anyone wastes any brain cell on that chick is a real fool!😂
I just remember at one point of time the west went to Africa to talk about China too.
Tks, Palki ('Jewel of India'), for bringing John for this precise & concise summary on such big issues of our time! On Ukraine, I diagree with his position that the USA is responsible for letting Putin invade it by breaking promise of not expanding NATO beyond East Germany (unwritten!). A cruel justification, I'd say. I wish u let him go in detail on this. His other points make much sense. Namaska!
Remember the "bay of pigs", Cuba 1961/1962? What gave the US the right to invade Cuba? And why shouldn't Russia be allowed to do the exact same thing in Ukraine for the exact same reason as the US did back in the 60's? Moreover, I don't know about you but I'm an honest human (rare breed nowadays in an age of lyers, criminals and terrorists) being and when I give you my word you certainly don't have to write it down, I'll honor it!! A man a man, a word a word!! If you even consider that a gentlemen's agreement has to be written down and if not it doesn't count and all is either permitted or prohibited you're as fake as the US and NATO are!! I'll be forced to treat you as someone that is between a lyer and a terrorist simply because of the fact that I cannot TRUST you!!
Yes, she is the jewel of India truly representing the bullying, lying, libel and slander culture of India.
He is spot on with his analysis on the US foreign policy for Ukraine. The war in Ukraine is indeed because of NATO'S expansion. They thought that Russia was weak and had an antiquated army so there was no need to negotiate with them. That is there biggest mistake and has cost them their grip on power throughout the world.
@@sabrinakhan8217 Need Burnol ?
@@sabrinakhan8217your name is enough to know how frustrated you are 😘
woww .i can listen this man all day... very good future analysis of geopolitics
India will always fight for their MASTER regardless what ever it cause to their own ppl.
That mentality lies in Western society
Yes. India will always fight for the one and only Pārtha-Sārathi, he who is the eternal leader of all Indians, as per Indian national anthem.
@@JusticeAboveAll-ro3sm who made you above all who even doesn't know the definition of justice?
😂😂😂 I have a doubt for India fighting with US they will end like Japan being a US lapdog in their lives.
@@Themanwhocantbemoved-zb7py America doesn't fight directly with big nations so it uses proxies and we are able to give befitting reply to them
Well done interview. Quick/rapid fire questions of great importance and popularity.
There is no need for Xi to invade Taiwan. If he so wishes he can do it over some weekend when he is not too busy with more important tasks.
Prof Mearsheimer as usual is so articulate, consistent & a brilliant communicator. Good to see him in India - he is bound to have many admirers here !!
This is going on in Washington DC, not India
5:00 WTH paiki think India control of Malacca straits. Malacca straits belong to Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore & maybe Thailand. I doubt she knows where is Malacca straits? 😂
I doubt you know the borders of India. 😂
spoken like a true chinese bot!!#! malaca strait is very close to andman and nicobar also if india wants to block it what can malasiya or thailand, etc, etc do about it india is stronger?????????????//>>>>>>>>>>>>
This host asks questions to provoke and makes the guest choose sides. India is a major power, not a great power. Ok?
The way she includes India in everything is now boring will end up calling this an Indian channel
Can't anyone see the selfish interest of the US?
Foolish people always become leaders and the world is always in chaos
If India boasts a population of 100 crore affluent individuals, it requires no external market to sell goods. With a staggering 1000 million wealthy customers who purchase goods and contribute to taxes, India will become an attractive destination for global trade. Currently, China has established its own ecosystem with a customer base of 1000 million individuals.
How are they stuck in GaZa? And the whole world is asking them not to invade raffa The last and only hold for HAMAS SO HOW ARE THEY STUCK
Guerilla warfare, urban warfare, terrorism and Hezbollah- look those up
@@angaatkeeda7971 Yup
Jewish people are always stubborn.
@@angaatkeeda7971did you say terrorism? Who is more terrorist than those whose agenda is to invade, kill and colonize people? Answer me if you're bold enough.
It is only a zombie who doesn't know that the Israeli are stuck in Gaza.
Palki lady Blood Boiling after he said China not invading Taiwan
@Palku Prof. Mearsheimer requires a 2 hour long podcast. These questions require depth and many follow-ups.
This is an extremely polite way for john to say "no, you india is not a great power".
I hope India sees what’s really going on here!!!
Straight to the point! I like it
She's pro American 😅
A part of the multi billion dollars anti China propaganda funded by american tax money.
Well documented!!!👍
She's AntiChina 🤣🤣🤣 Pro India
She and her whole country worship the US
All the indians became pro American after that Galwan Clash occurred in 2020.
Great Palvi you got John. He predicted the Ukraine conflict before it happened and the reason
Wrong question and title. If not every Chinese living around the world, at least majority of them want unify Taiwan with mainland China.
Chinese media talks about China's accomplishments. India talks of US accomplishments and complain about Chinese accomplishments. She must have been disappointed that he did not say India is a great power now. Also must have been disappointed to know that India will be treated like China by US if one day India grows big enough. The Chinese way of a WIN-WIN solution is still the best alternative! Very sadly, China and India don’t fight side by side against the west colonialism best comments of the day....
Mearsheimer always tells it as he sees it
prof. John Mearsheimer is the greatest connoisseur of world international relations and he predicted all that what happening now , more than 30 years ago, and Jeffrey David Sachs is no less an objective expert. Follow their lectures and interviews and you will have a real, objective picture of who is to blame and what is the truth in today's international relations and conflicts.
❤💯👍
If India was going to be a great power it would've become one already, 400+ years of colonization and it's still acts like an Anglo colony and it shows. John Mearsheimer said exactly what India needed to hear.
India always eat banana in dream
Nice interview!!
When he said US help China to getting rich,you can understand how ignorance he is.American’s money comes in to China there is only one purpose:earn more money!Even today the relations between two countries is so bad that still so many US money don’t want leave China,these we can see how much they are getting from China! China is not been rich by charity but from Chinese people’s hard work! What about the United States? Reaping the world through dollar hegemony！To transfer America's domestic economic problems to the rest of the world to maintain The prosperity of the American economy ，That is really unacceptable and more and more countries realizes these and it will don’t last too long ，we will wait and see!
And he mentioned China’s army never fight a war since 1979 but American’s army fighting war all the time and these he can conclude Chinese army is weak and seems very proud US have a strong army by bully other weak countries, but he forgot the Korean War and Vietnam War!
Since the Tiananmen Incident in 1989,China has been under sanctions. Moreover, the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, so they dont need China any more. His points are riddled with contradictions. Even South Korea's ability to enter developed countries in the past ten years relied on China ，because South Korea was stuck in the 2008 financial crisis. South Korea cannot get out without China's help.
You're right. What he said, depends on the audience. Apparently he's a guest of Indian, that's why he flatter them - Indian people like to hear that Chinese people are bad/weak, that's why Indian guys are incurable.
The Korean and Vietnam Wars were before 1979. In any case, your casualty was very high in Korea, 1-2 million estimated. Inexperienced and untrained Chinese soldiers.@@user-bt8cu2tu1q
That’s great interview
The approach of the questions is very poor, there's no need for Palki to exhaust her prepared questions in the session which is what she was trying to do thus not allowing Professor Meashama to digest each in his response.
We will never forget Us supporting Pakistan😂
India is trying to catch up. Let’s feed those children. Even China gives them a rice bowl. Come on India!!!!! Thanks Parkisha Sign
First time one hears from an expert on India's position in the world: aspiring great power.
So awesome to see Mr. Mearsheimer on your show. The man is a jewel! The most insightful geopolitical commentator in the world.
This woman did not like his answered lol😂 great nation need population and wealth 😢
No she certainly didnt!!
Indians heart will be broken to hear USA will also contain India if Indians become rich
He just tell the truth
Only a matter of time… and the world will do Nothing but talk Bull
As a huge fan of both Palki and John Mearsheimer, this interview is a dream come true!!
This man is good
Your best interview where you let John Mearsheimer provide his answers.
This is very interesting. It seems like Palki and so many Indians are obsessed with China bashing. On the other hand, the Chinese are hardly talking about India in their news. I suspect a lot of Indians are still suffering from the colonial mindset. They were abused so much from the West/Brits in the past. Why would Indians hate Chinese so much that I don't get it. I think Indians came from great civilizations and cultures for over a few thousands of years. Even Chinese cultures were greatly influenced by ancient Indians teachings. I think Indians need to stop trying to please the west like they're still under the western colonialization...
Prof. Mearsheimer's analysis is as genuine and as objective as it can get. That is why the CNN's do not invite him as much as they do to the so called experts, tuned to justify externally defined missions. Palki's hypothetical scenarios seem to unconsciously imply the presence of a central power from which multipolarity can be built. Instead, those who strive or are set to build a sustainable multipolar order ought to think in terms of playing their respective role as in placing themselves around a circle where no one among them is sitting at the center. Idealistic as it may seem, that may be what to aspire to. Palki Sharma a fav journalist, except for her excessively hard hitting stance on China.
No matter how India can never past china
It's already crossed in terms of population.
@@tbraghavendranyep after china's one child policy
@@tbraghavendranwhat an achievement 😂
The background's frequent change attracts the audience's attention and is not good for the speaker on the stage to present their idea.