Israel-Palestine conflict - Summary on a Map
2018 ж. 5 Сәу.
2 920 909 Рет қаралды
This video summarises the Israeli-Palestinian conflict since the Balfour Declaration of 1917. Let's trace on a map how the conflict arose and developed until the present day.
Part one of this video, titled "History of the Jews" and posted in February 2018, addresses matters prior to 1917. • History of the Jews - ...
English translation & voiceover : Rahul Venkit / @rahulvenkit
Original video in French: • Le conflit israélo-pal...
Music: Trapped - Quincas Moreira (KZhead's Audio Library)
Being British, I cannot agree more with this old Iraqi saying : if two fish fight in the Tigris, the British are behind it.
@@izzamindset unfortunately I couldn't agree more. But if we're talking about in the last 50 years or so, the US definately takes the cake and probably invaded it for oil too 😂😂😂
@@hydrowolf363 take it back more to the time where US was not yet discovered. Brits is really the roots.
@@izzamindset yup
Wholly true IMO, and I'm not excusing past behavior, nor discounting the enjoyment I read from your quote ;p , but I'm just not sure the blame game and/or any consensus of blame makes virtually any difference in a potential solution.
@@sarahlesliem21 Well...It's better to know the criminals than to glorify them
The arab and jews: preparing for war against each other* UK: Adios
bullshit One side has no Weapons
@@jasonhay1956 arab have money but they not supporting each other
America usually has to clean up European screwups. Often with unsuccessful results.
@@sean5419 you know America does this only for there own interest, has nothing to do with that the US wants a better world.
@@edofluit6568 I refuse to debate people that can't spell.
Thank you! This history is something we can go and reference today, as tragedies are continuing, and attempt to understand the extensive history behind what’s happening.
Indeed it has to do with the Gaza gas resources, I have a vid on it.
Id what yo said is true and Israel are doing this war for this gas resources, then it is very extra he that Israel has accepted a deal with libano recognizing a large portion for libano that enclose a very large deposits of gas that Israel could also has a large portion of it if the dispute continues. So by accepting the news border Israel renounced those resources,and likewise as Hamas Israel could easily overcome libano and hezbola armies and take those resources by force since it is a disputed territories in the sea borders...
Awesome map/year/narration combo. I never knew this progression on the history of the world. Thanks so much🙏
Knew
@@ASTeer1699 good catch:)
politics aside, I like seeing the borders move over time in all these vids; it really helps.
Yeah, especially how New Zealand disappeared in the world map. Interesting borders...
I Think Jesus 🤔 Is Involved In La Costa Nostra 🇨🇷 He Joined The Italian 🍕 Mafia
German empire has the best looking borders
@@michaelferguson2401 don't complain bloke its over there 0:08
@@keanu3035 I mean the map at 6:00, New Zealand should be included on that map, if you can fit madagascar you can fit New Zealand
Israel did not withdraw from Sinai under international pressure in 1973/74! It withdrew in or after 1979 after signing the peace accord with Egypt in Camp David.
yeah this video is full of bs "facts"
Am from israel i know you rigt
Well this video is quite inaccurate after 1900..
Corect so much is left out of his videos but unfortunately this what the general uniformed public believes.
fidius01 i agree that is true and dont forget that peace treaty was with syria as well for the territory, that was won in the 6 day war
For completeness, you forgot the 1956 Sinai War, during which Israel conquered the Sinai peninsula for the first time and was forced to give it back immediately.
@@hossamafndina-wx8mq True, though it can be seen as just a long conclusion to the Six-Day war, or the prolonged set-up for the Yom Kippur War / October War, so it's not ultimately as important to mention. It was a very interesting conflict though, no doubt.
@@hossamafndina-wx8mq (Also there were no border changes on the map, as far as I know. Just... y'know... attrition.)
@@hossamafndina-wx8mq I'm Israeli. And you?
@@hossamafndina-wx8mq In short, a brilliant strategic move by Saadat (if tactically deficient), which ultimately benefited everyone - though it's tragic that it couldn't be achieved diplomatically. And you haven't answered my question...
🤔 Huh. All his posts disappeared. I think he blocked me. Oh well. Nice talking to you, I guess.
I have watched both parts. Good use of timeline graphics. Thanks
Everyone is a goddamn history professor in the comments.
True
Well doesnt mean that all they say is true some people are just assholes with big ego's
Because all truth comes from authority. Public education worked then. Doing your own research and coming to your own conclusions is overrated apparently.
@@weathforjr the problem with history is, who really knows what happened, who got the research right? Who can you trust? The only people which know what really happened, are the people in power/made the decisions at that time. Because I am sure they didn't tell the truth back then just as much as they do now. Just look whats happening in the us with republicans and democrats. If it would be for the republicans the democrats are all monsters and the democrats think the opposite way. If you would have this setting a few hundreds years back you would probably get a civil war with the winner writing the history books, and making themselves look pretty. The only thing we can agree on is that we have been manipulated over centuries. Sometimes by people which did it intentionally, sometimes by people who didn't know any better.
@@mrpanda7777 Yeah, it's a system of faith. A story we have to take people's word on. I think Stalin (another story) showed the world that the narrative could be altered to fit whatever the people in power need it to be. There's a movie called Hara-Kiri from the 60s that demonstrates your point. Are you by any chance of the nihilistic or existentialist/absurdist persuasion?
4:50 - Israel did not withdraw from Sinai due to pressure of the Oil Embargo. It was the Egyptian President Anwar Al-Sadat who decided to announce a peace initiative and visited Israel. The following negotiations under the hospices of US President Jimmy Carter led to a peace agreement between Egypt and Israel. As a result Israel withdrew from Sinai and returned it to Egypt which paved the way to normalization and diplomatic ties between the two countries. This was the first peace agreement in the Israeli-Arab conflict and has since been in effect until this day. The peace makers, Mr. Anwar Al-Sadat and the Israeli P.M. Menachem Begin received in 1978 the Nobel Peace Prize.
Not one mention of the PLO (formed in the Mid 60’s) until the 80s. Hmmm, what were they doing for two decades that the author conveniently leaves out. Way too much selective history here.
Yep true
@@green444 yea weird
@@green444 He did mention them and their founding in Algeria. It's just a brief thumbnail overview sketch of Israel/Palestine, not meant to be an exhaustive analysis...not everything is a conspiracy Cletus.
@@green444 they weren't doing enough to warrant time in a outline of the situation.
A lot of people don't realize that Britain did the same thing with India and Pakistan - they withdrew and left a mess that still hasn't been resolved. The difference is that the India/Pakistan problem is Hindu vs Muslim (among other issues) and in Israel/Palestine, it's Jewish vs Muslim, and in the Holy Land, so the Israel/Palestine conflict gets a lot more attention.
It's not Jew vs Muslim. It's Jews vs Palestinians Arabs. Not all Palestinians are Muslims
@@siamsami4115 over 90% is Muslim.
Amazing in depth analysis! Hats off to you!!! I’m going to watch all of the videos made by you!! Please keep them coming!!!
It probably looks like good info to someone who doesn't know much.
@@Crimea_Riverwhat do you recommend instead?
Absolutely no mention of my mate Steph who went on holiday to Tel Aviv and brought me back an ashtray. This doesn't qualify as history.
Sean G lol
haha.
Because the united nations did not had a resolution that wants you to return the ashtray.
Yeah man, that sucks. Your mate steph who went on holiday to Tel Aviv and brought back your ash tray really should’ve been in the video. I hope people hear the truth.
Sean G boy u so funny .y u so funny.
This video, which can be seen as more controversial: comments allowed Part one, which is less controversial: comments disabled
Part one is more controversial because a lot of that story has not been told. Like why did jews get kicked out of the Roman empire? There is also Cicero's monologue that speaks about that. Pogroms and all other expulsions were not because of antisemitism, more it was about Talmudism.
Part one has the comments disabled because it would just be " khazars this" " white europeans that" "hebrew isrealites this" "the REAL Jews were X!!".
@@stephenweinelt1175 ohh
Dude, he said that muslims built the aqsa mosque when they conquered Jerusalem. it existed even before the jews!
@@wariare12world95 dude muslims didn't exist before the jews For gods sake muhammad is the last prophet, succeeding moses and eliahu and many more
Thanks for an easy-to-understand history, a very useful video for understanding the origins and processes.
Impressive presentation. Clear. Concise. Graphics are the icing on the cake.
No mention of Egyptians part in the Gaza blockade
this video is biased.
why not mention Benjamin H. Freedman's speech? And the Jewish role in the Russian Revolution?
MOHAMADXD meme expert kinda funny how everything is American\Zionist\Jews fault and Arabs have no responsibly for Anything EVER...
MrJonnyHW The Egyptians don't blockade the coastal border. Israeli Jews even kill people on the high seas.
Christine Q do you understand what the word blockade is? if Gaza had an open border with Egypt there would not be any blockade. because in order to have a blockade you need to BLOCK all point of entry and exist this is what blockade means. of course Egypt need to block only its border with Gaza in order to be a part of the blockade...
I pray for the peace and prosperity of ALL those living in that region.
I agree with you.
Nigga nobody gives a fuck
TAO TAO dumb
there will be peace when the jews give back the land they never owned. jerusalem always belonged to the arabs.
TAO TAO I commented “dumb” on this a meant to comment it to the dummy below you, sorry!
Great info. Loved the music, it fit as well.
Very informative. But most importantly the soundtrack has got that smooth baseline. Most def am vibing on that.
"No mention of..." "You omitted..." "You left out..." Jfc it's a short overview, how long do you expect the video to be??? I guess he should've started with the big bang and gone through literally everything that ever happened anywhere ever up til now.
so true lol
god u made me laugh 😂 True
A short overview of the israel palestine conflict should show all relevant historic events related to the conflict. Leaving out important events for brevity this way should change the title to "according to the palestine propaganda".
An unrelated argument is gonna start in this comments section just wait
I agree But he made some parts to simplified, for example: he only said „following tensions with her Neighbors Israel declares war on...“ Normally this statement would be ok but especially in this Conflict he should have said (Simplified) what these tensions were
The comments will be amazing to read
This is not a place to write such a comment.
@@AngelSnowflakes I agree, this comment section is a........... War zone.
I think I will get offended as an Arab 😐
My first thought... "ohhh boy, the comments are going to get crazy"
Someone said ... the JEWS left their BLACK and return white... REVERLATION2v9... hum ... what about the Middle Pass and Slavery in America of the Black Jews from the West coast of Africa...I wonder who supplied the Slave ships... just saying ...
Which software did you use to create this video? For maps?
Absolutely fascinating. Thanks!
Back when Jordan was going through his Trans phase
Arch Enemy 😃 Transjordan was definitely more fun.
@@Tunsmandie may I ask why?
@@magnerath you serious? lol transjordan is more fun!
Hahahhahahahaha
I'm Jordanian and this comment is hilarious 😂😂 Although the name was changed after independence in 46 so I think it's a mistake in the video
I haven’t read the comments yet but I’m sure everyone has an open mind and is accepting of everyone no matter their differences 😁😁😁
Nevermind
😂😂😂😂 The cause don't need open mind it's need one thing which is that... British don't had Palestine and it gave Palestine for Isreal then... Arabs don't want Isreal take the Palestine and Isreal want to make its own country on that area so... A war begun And who wrong it is clear Who don't have (British) gave for who don't deserve (Isreal)
@@osamajbara7237 !
@@osamajbara7237 and
@@jouma5295 Apartheid? Israel has 20% Arabs and they have a better life than most of the Arab world. Get a clue!
Thank you for your great job 👍
Damn, I watched this video to simplify my understanding of the conflict, now it’s more complex, obscure, and convoluted. Just gotta press for peace and cooperation and a better future.
Oh, what an original thought. Almost like nobody has ever thought about that or tried it multiple times throughout history. You can't make peace with people whose whole existence is dedicated to the extermination of your own.
The thing is, one of em doesn't want to simplify it, they want it all, they want their stolen properties back (clue in ottoman regime).
He is summing up one of the most complex situations of the previous century in less than 9 minutes. Of course things are going to be left out
Things are not left out as much as they are lied about.
@@MohamedSaad-yo5ls If everyone goes back to their country the problem is solved! Arabs will go back to the Arabian peninsula and leave all previous lands that used to belong to other cultures.
The problem with these video is not that some parts are left out, but WHICH parts of the story are being left out. In this case, I think the video was relatively neutral.
Seriously, man
@@MohamedSaad-yo5ls they split it bro 😂 and you can’t blame the Jews for immigrating there after the holocaust
“This move was condemned by the UN” “This move was condemned by the UN” “This move was condemned by the UN” “This move was condemned by the UN” “This move was condemned by the UN” like how are you going to take them seriously enough to put it on your video. The UN is more like a circus today than an International organization to preserve peace and stability in the World. It proved its Uselessness at Srebrenica and Syria and now Palestine
True.
lol
It IS A CIRCUS. All by design.
😂😂😂😂😂 Fun fact This comment was condemned by UN too 😂😂😂
Actully UN is nothing but a puppet of America if it want to take action USA stop it bcz usa not want any nation to b happier its policy to give trouble some.
Given unwavering US support of Israel since its creation it has always seemed weird to me that the US has had any kind of role in the peace process. If you have a dispute with your blackjack dealer you would not turn to the casino to mediate the negotiations.
Seriously you’re surprised America which has a large number of Jewish peoples in positions of power are interested in Israel. Just wow.
Seriously you’re surprised America which has a large number of Jewish peoples in positions of power are interested in Israel. Just wow.
The US support for Israel was actually quite limited until the 1970s, when the Soviets started pouring money and weapons to their Arab allies in Middle East, leading the Americans to provide more weapons to Israel. The US was neutral during the Six Day War. Only after the Yom Kippur War with the Camp David Accords did the US start to develop a close relationship with Israel.
But the countries with unwavering hatred for the Jews having a role in the process is fine for you huh?
Thanks. This is exactly what i was looking for. Simple with easy to understand maps. More details-- which would encourage even more political based criticism-- would have defeated the purpose of this being brief. I suggest some of the critics make their own video clarifying their concerns rather than bashing of your efforts. I agree with most of the posts which credit you for your project.
You missed.... Two Lebanon wars
Which one of them my dad fought in
And a war of attrition
@@TravelersParadise and you're proud , Zionist ?
he missed 4 wars in 1956, 1970, 1982 and 2006
@@seifsherif8142 I am the proudest Zionist you'll find!!
You didn't even mention when Godzilla attacked.
@SEVEN GOLDEN CANDLESTICKS SEVEN SPIRITS OF GOD umm... It's a joke not a hate comment
I don't think that Godzilla ever attacked this region! When was that?
Huge mistake on his part
When
@@brunorosi I think it was around 1960
thankyou you are like one of the only history youtubers brave enough to touch on this subject, also its a really good video
Informative, interesting, and educational, both pt1 & pt2
You were wrong about mentioning that Israel has returned Sinai to Egypt because of pressure from the global community. Sinai was brought back to Egypt after signing on a peace treatment in 1979. Also, Sinai was brought back to Egypt only in 1982, not 1978.
Thats not wrong. You did not say hownitbwas wrong.
Camp David
Yes, failure to mention the Egyptian peace treaty with Israel is one of the major oversights here, along with Egypt placing the Sinai as a buffer, destroying homes south of Gaza so they wouldn't be used to smuggle arms, and essentially closing and militarizing the border in order to enforce the peace treaty with Israel.
No mention of the Arab/Jewish consensus that falafel and hummus are delicious.
As an Israeli, it's fucking delicious
@@illuminat121 I hear you also like the taste of illegal colonizations
@@highonlife2323 nope, i don't like this, and I don't like terrorist that almost killed me twice, personally i try to stay away from this because there's no way to end this without a miracle
@Aayan Ismail yes, and that idiotic conflict won't change my mind about neither side, wonderful people live on both side, but the small amount of radicals leave everyone else no choice but to take their side because both sides hope for a total victory
@Aayan Ismail they were offered peace five times, and also had half of Palestine but they decided to go to war with Israel that existed for just 8 hours at this point, both people have the right to this land because of idiots like you it's impossible, this aggression and listening only to Palestinian side which lies a lot, believe me, they start a war on their own, launch hundreds of rockets a day and nobody in the world until THEY have loses, at what point shooting 4 thousand ot rockets in 11 Days deliberately at cities to kill as much civilians as possible became something other than terrorism
Thanks. This is so consistent with the several years of narratives.
Are you here 2024
Wonderful summary, giving a birds-eye view of the changes and conflcts and, sadly, the current impasse. Let's pray for some wisdom and peace.
The summary lacks many parts, making it support the creator's political opinion....
@@ramnaftaliavni6532 Could you help to fill in the missing information?
There is too much information that this video is lacking. Barley any talk about the Jew's or Palastinian's relation to the Land of Canaan; A horrible misstatement that made the Holocaust look like a part of WW2 and not as planned enslavement, torture, and genocide; Wrong dates; No mention of other peace efforts such as the Peel Commission, the London plan, Olmert's proposal (97% of what the Palestinians claim would be given, and they refused), and many more efforts; A sided claim that Israel "bomb houses" just because, not to mention the war between the PLO and Hama's, resulting in the terror organization winning, which led to Israel constantly being bombed by Hamas, which also led to the blockade by Israel AND EGYPT (no mention of Egypt) - no mention of Hamas hiding in civilian houses, kindergartens, hospitals and more, and firing rockets from there; And so much more, that I couldn't cover here, neither in a stupid attempt to cover one of the most complex situations in the world, in several minutes.
and why didnt they mention egypt extremely harsh blockade on gaza. they literally have shoot on sight policy without anything going in or out unless its underground.
qweasdzxcname because this is a video on Israel vs Palestine, not the whole world vs Palestine
No, this video is only about Jews as the title suggest, history of the Jews...
Because violence between arabs is not something the media wants to cover but when Israel tries to kill terrorists that use their own children as body armor, Israel gets the criticism.
He does not have to include every single fucking detail lol it’s impossible to say EVERYTHING about this conflict in an 8 minute video.
@@exophoenix3229 oh I yes I forgot the media is trying to protect the Arabs who along with their region, have been a neo colony for the foreign powers for the past century and are too weak and divided to even beat Iran, forget Israel mate, Iran is f*cking intervening in Arab countries now. That's how we weak they've gotten after years of Western meddling and control. The media is protecting these sorry artificial nation states and attacking the Jews aka your overlords? F*ck off, you're living in a fantasy mate 😂😂
*British promises arab land back if win the wars* *arabians joins* *british take the land and split up with france* Arabs: so thats a f*cking lie
Moreover Britain gives Arab land to Jews as a gift.
@@AngelSnowflakes If to be correct it was Ottoman land, Stop being an idiot and learn history.
@@itzikashemtov6045 So Ottoman were not Arabs?
QuickTutorials I was referring to Palestinians since it never belonged to them. Israel belonged to the Jews way before Islam was a thing.
@negro bsr I am born in Morocco, I am a muslim. My ancestors were Amazighs, so I am not an Arab? Being an Arab differs from being a turk, tunisian, amazigh, etc...It has got a larger meaning nowadays...
I didnt kno this was the cause of the 70s oil crisis
Great maps 👍 love the detail, I'll add from wiki 3:50 In April 1967, Syria shot at an Israeli tractor ploughing in the demilitarized zone -which Syria considered an ongoing practice of Israeli encroachment on contested land. The event occasioned an escalation into a prewar aerial clash. In May 1967, following misinformation about Israeli intentions provided by the Soviet Union, Egypt expelled UN peacekeepers who had been stationed in the Sinai Peninsula since the Suez conflict,[1] and announced a blockade of Israel's access to the Red Sea (international waters) via the Straits of Tiran, which Israel considered an act of war. Tension escalated, with both sides' armies mobilising. Less than a month later, Israel launched a surprise strike which began the Six-Day War.
There are a couple of important details skipped in these videos.
I'd like to add that the surprise attack was launched on egyptian military preparing to attack israel
@@itamarplayz3153 That would be on the list of skipped facts.
@@itamarplayz3153 obviously, do you expect them to attack territory that has almost no military presence
@@charlie8344 Except it's not just about the military presence, it's about the military intentions. They were massing on Israel's border getting ready to attack. It would be like if Ukraine had realized what was going to happen and attacked the Russian forces who were massing near their border in an attempt to prevent them from gaining the upper hand.
me: *reads a comment* Comment: *100+ replies* me: ah shit, here we go again
It do be like that though.
😂😂
Ah shit here we go again
I hate having to read all of that
Yep
Judging from the comments, this conflict has legs. Maybe 200 more years
You're probably right. When every other corner of the entire planet consists of peaceful and friendly nations, this conflict will be alive and "well" and continue to stand as an example for the rest of the world not to follow...
Elgsdyr forgetting about Sudan
Angel Snowflakes An exaggeration, but a valid point nonetheless. Britain is responsible for a disproportionate amount of both good and bad things. On balance good. A superpower of soft power. And formerly of good old fashioned brute force. I think we have learned from our history. I hope...
When you deal with people who's average IQ is about 70 then yeah, It will continue for a long time until they get better education and stop breeding with each other.
Especially when one side is absolutely committed to the destruction of the other and rages with hate fueled by Islamic Jihad
Regarding the Israel-Hamas conflict, it seems that while there is extensive media coverage, there is relatively little reporting on the historically significant influence of the United Kingdom on Israel.
What a great video! Surely the comment will be civil!
Just like "civil" wars!
The American Indians, & other native people's suffering, that they had to endure, until recently. It's equally the same, unjust, un- deserved suffering by all the Palestinian people's. How can ànyone that kñows, give credence to a band of murderers, bent on destroying the entire earth, which is their intention. They been at it, since time imorall, & they're still @ it. It is a pity. If things were àll peace, they way it should be. Iceland has been freed from the Rothschild's, & Zionists. We need to 5he same also, asap.
From Wikipedia: In 1979, Egypt and Israel signed a peace treaty in which Israel agreed to withdraw from the entirety of the Sinai Peninsula. Israel subsequently withdrew in several stages, ending in 1982. Israel ceded the Sinai peninsula in 82, NOT IN 1974, as is mentioned at 4.53.
This video lost all credibility when it started in 1917
@@datofficial6062 There's a Part 1, friend.
this is fkae news! you should read up on the real history, stop using wikipedia as a source.
@@datofficial6062 Look around and you will find Part 1. This is Part 2.
Source: an internet-based dictionary that anyone can edit.
A lot of inaccuracies. Especially about how the Sinai was given back
its like...super useless to mention them but not name them...
@@Elnaroth The Sinai was returned in 1982 as a result of the 1977 peace deal with Egypt, not directly after the 1973 war.
i might need to step in if things continue like this for much longer!
It's interesting what is left out. To keep the time to a manageable length things need to be trimmed. I would have wanted to include a mention of Hizballah and Lebanon, and the various conflicts there. Perhaps even some discussion of Iranian politics.
I appreciate the OP for trying to convey complex information in a quick and accessible format. The input from reviewers is invaluable and is the icing on the cake.
But its not complete
I totally agree, users had givenme more feedback too, thanks all!
@@egoistic_moroccan. There's a lot missing, but considering how much history he had to fit into a 10 minute timeframe, I think he did a fantastic job-maaaaybe a bit too biased in favor of Palestine. The biggest issues I see, in no particular order, are 1) The PLO is only mentioned in 1988; while its previous history and terrorist activities (which had a HUGE impact on the conflict's development) are not. 2) They also do not explicitly state that Hamas explicitly calls for the genocide of Jews-which would have only taken up an additional 3 seconds. 3) They do not state that on several occasions, Jewish militants killed or expelled Arabs from their homes, that this was the main reason so many Arabs fled in 1948, and those responsible were by and large not punished by the Israeli government afterward I think all of the above three things could be added without extending the video length by over a minute. These next three would also be really nice but would probably require the video to be more like ~12-13 minutes long. 4) They don't discuss how the ideology of Pan-Arabism, and especially Nasserism, shaped the conflict and Israel's diplomatic relations. 5) Debates over 'The Right of Return', especially with regards to the conception of Israel as a 'Jewish State' are never mentioned 6) The current situation of Palestinians living in The West Bank isn't explored in any depth, nor is the Palestinian refugee crisis & worldwide diaspora. 7) Changes in Israeli demographics and politics in the 21st century, in particular, the rapid growth of the Haredi population and increased popularity of right-wing and far-right politics in Israel
@@p00bix there's too many things you said that has a bit of israeli propaganda, but at least you stayed in middle
it is such a sad story. i hope everyone will find peace and live happily
Same!
There are some rather relevant bits missing, but otherwise this is a really good presentation. I agree, the West Bank is more complicated than ever and it seems that at some point, it almost has to boil over into another general conflict within that region.
We need a part three
Some details that are not correct: - The Six Days War (1967), Israel did not just declare war. The Egyptians blocked the Straits of Tiran, one of Israel's main trading routes, which is an act of war. Then, Israel responded and the war started. - Israel did not give Sinai back to Egypt due to international pressure. It was a part of the Israel-Egypt peace treaty which lasted for over 40 years now. It was a fair deal that brought peace from the south-western border. - Israel has decided, in 2005, to withdraw from the Gaza Strip. The Palestinians there chose Hamas, which is today a recognized terrorist organization by the US, EU and UN. Hamas' intentions are different from the PLA's (Fatah), and that is a huge barrier for peace. - "Israel imposes a blockage in the region (Gaza) while Hamas regularly fires rockets", that's the other way around. Hamas used their waterways and border crossing with Egypt to smuggle rockets and weapons, which were then targeted toward Israeli towns. Then Israel started blockading the border. In this blockade, any supply is welcome as long as it goes through Israeli ports first and being scanned and searched for illegal weapons. Then transported into Gaza via an Israeli border crossing. Israel is still the largest supplier of medicine, water, electricity and food to the Gaza strip.
Ariel Weinberger seems like a pretty biased video to me...
Ariel Weinberger, Israel was defeated in 1973 and barlef defense line was destroyed and we win in depletive war so Israel was weakened and we blocked the straits of Tiran to prevent any sort of help to come to Israel and the Arabian countries refused to give petrol to america to supply Israel, and we have cut connections with america since they deceived us that Israel won't attack us and we are fools to listen to them that lead us to our defeat in six days war! Plus Israel won because she attacked our military airports so we got no air cover! You cannot say you win us by toe to toe, you win us by cheating! And surprise attack! I cannot say we lost but we lost honorably not winning with cheating! In 1973 we have deceived america and Europe and said "we won't attack Israel" while building our military in secret! And the European fools have been deceived so the Americans, they came to help Israel after we defeated it in 1973, we restored half of Sinai and the other half after the 1979 peace treaty which called camp David treaty, which is located in america unfortunately! That's the truth, the others are lies, if you don't believe then watch a video about moche dayan and he admitted that Israel failed in that war and Egypt won with the help of god then the Arabian countries! While we defeated Israel, america and UK. Listen to the real truth I swear!
Ariel Weinberger Hamas is terrorist? Then what is Zionist.
Belal Bolbol Israel didn't lose in 73. But it was a disappointing victory for Israel. Because Israel wasn't prepered for it.
Miss. Dark Under eyes I would like to hear why you call zionists terrorists. For now I will say why Hamas is inherintly a terror organization: A terror organization is an organization which its purpose is to kill civilians. Hamas, more than once, said that it wants to kill all Israelis. And as it seems, it acts to do so. Blindly shooting missiles into Israel in order to kill civilians. In 2014 alone they shot approximately 10,000 missiles. And that's wothout talking about what they do the Palestinians.
Who Is Here After What Happened In Jerusalem In Sunday/Monday/Tuesday May 2021?
Me. I do not support anyone, I just want these two nations to live in peace...
@@raxtushdmapper7248 well thanks for us Muslims we just need access to the asqa mosque which is the 3rd holiest site in Islam and it is in Jerusalem so that’s the man in reason
At the end we all are at fault
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
@@diybetterbasics7379 there never was a nation named Palestine. The nation of israel was first ruled by king david in Jerusalem around 900 bc.
Nice video!
Thank you for your brilliant narration!
Everyone: **Arguing** Me: Bro where you get this music it claps cheeks
ikr
Me accidentally watching this at 1.5x speed: wow he’s really flying through this, huh?
I love you my babe
@@cartman9652 Woah
@@cartman9652 sniff sniff... I SMELL SIMP
@@cartman9652 😂
@@cartman9652 lol simp moment
Very informative well done
was the blockade in 2014 on every side of the gaze strip as you've shown? I'm pretty sure the Egyptians didn't block their border with Gaza...
The Holy Land looks like it's getting more unholy every day.
Yep. I reckon I've got socks that are holier.
Well because it's holy it's wanted. Everyone in history wanted a piece of palestine.
@@youssefkandeel3667 You mean a piece of Israel.
Knight Boi exactly, it started in Israel with the canaanites, why can’t Bethlehem and Nazareth belong to the jews? Technically the ottoman empire overruled Israel until the last century when Israel gained enough power to take their holy land back. Islam is in the mecca, they only care about throwing out the jewish people of their land and creating an islamic state. It was Hebrew territory first. Also why is this the biggest conflict when all throughout history nations have been conquering land by forceful rule and violence since the beginning of civilizations. Interesting how this is considered the biggest conflict in history...
@@welt2526 Nope. Just holy land. not israel nor palestine. It shouldnt have been a state in the beginning. It was going well before UK and us decided to give zionism a free pass
4:45 Touch American oil prices and that map moved SO FAST 🤣
For an easy comparison its the Roman Empire of our day, its territory is huge, its sphere of influence is practically global (at the height of the Roman Empire they went basically everywhere there was to go in the old world) and if you touch something that matters to their commerce or power, they will either directly or indirectly, push your shit in.
Lol
Is it possible to have a shared capital?
Seems like common sense right
Good grief - imagine what could be accomplished if they just got along with each other instead of fighting for property.
Israel GAVE Sinai back to Egypt, as an exchange for peace, and recognition.
Pelaaja KaksiYxi its ok, this video is as neutral as hamaa
Yes that’s what he said in the video...
Pelaaja KaksiYxi Israel won’t just give Sinai for the sake of peace. It was the 1973 war that Israel witness a major defeat and unexpected advance of the Egyptian troops into Sinai causing Israel to panic and ask for reinforcements from the USA and I quote “We can’t stop the Egyptians”. In conclusion, Israel won’t “give Sinai back to Egypt, as an exchange for peace”. It was the defeat at first then the negotiations. The zionist state knew they won’t be able to survive in the region surrounded with many enemies. Making peace with Egypt was a huge victory for Israel, but definitely didn’t give in just for peace!
yep, after pressure tho, why would a country give land almost its size, israel was def under pressure not peace loving lol
Tito -> That's the usual Arab nonsense that they like to use for the 1973 war. The Israelis crossed the Suez canal and surrounded the entire Egyptian southern army. With no protection from the SAM missile batteries the entire southern Egyptian army was exposed to the Israeli air force and completely surrounded. The Egyptian southern army would be wiped out. Sadat asked to stop the war as a result. At the end of the war Israel still had the Sinai. Sadat seeing that he could not get the Sinai back through military means made a historic trip to Israel that eventually led to a peace deal in 1979. Look it up.
1:38 Ireland wasn't a part of Britain then and were not involved in WW2
True
Dude, look at the size of Czechoslovakia
@@AllanLimosin isnt it correct?
It's funny that is the thing that you think is wrong about this video I mean You're not wrong But that's like being in armageddon and complaining about the dust in the air
Well Sinn Fein were supporting the Nazis
does anyone know if this military training that is mentionied in 2:23 includes starting fires in patagonian forests? Every year a stupid visiting military-trained israeli causes some fire in our patagonia... suddenly, one is closer to understand why they are hated everywhere.
Well explained with live map.
Israel didn't return Sinai because of international pressure. They signed a peace deal with Egypt and returned it
And what precipitated this peace agreement? What was the catalyst?
Israel originally didnt want to return sinai to us, this was evident in their refusal of 242.
@totally not572 Israeli population was around 50/50 but strong leadership convinced them and today you won't find many Israelis who regret the decision.
@@lionzion32 I know. What I am saying is that they only did it because they were forced to after losing the war, not because they actually cared about peace when they were winning
Video completely ignores the 1956 war in which France and Great Britain seized the Suez Canal, while Israel seized control of the Sinai peninsula. Israel returned the Sinai with a UN peacekeeping force. It was the Egyptian removal of the UN peacekeeping force that led to the 1967 Six-Day War.
William: The arab belligerent speeches by their leaders, promising war and to annihilate Israel, also led to the 1967 Six-Say War.
@@simon-jt9fr also the fact that they put a a lot of forces in the border of Israel
@@Bachars Pretty much. Of all the words I could use to describe Arab leadership in the 60s, "subtle" doesn't exactly top the list.
Also forgets to mention USA Liberty been attacked by Israel, than after that if there were not any witness the blame Egypt and that allows the USA to attack Egypt.
the 3-4 arab countries declared war against israel in 1967
can you make a video about egyptian israeli war from 1967 to 1973 but with deep details?????
I'm sorry the comments were turned off in the first video and very happy they were left on here. I have always been pro Israeli and never quite sure why, I think I know more now and I want to thank you for that.
if you want more info im pro palestine, so we can share views
This needs to be a part 3 alot has happened since
Especially now
@@liorputintsev9111 Especially now (2)
May 2021 enters the room
Just comment your opinion summart
and tensions Flared up on May 6 2021 Also the colonial Pipeline was hacked by cyber hacker group dark side on this date.
Clarification: The US voted the. Jerusalem Embassy Act into law in 1995. Every president since has promised to move the Embassy there.
Oru's and Or nots President Trump did it!
That's Zionist Bullshit. Every President has OPPOSED the theft of Jerusalem from it's rightful owners: the Arab Palestinians who have always lived there.
@@67DUTCHMAN the Arabs you call Palestinians are exactly that , Arabs that immigrated from Jordan and the surrounding areas. There is no two State solution nor will there ever be
@This is the beginning what drugs do you take?
@@ayhamjarrar2698 The land you are illegally occupying is not your land to take back because it was never your land to begin with you need to make go back to Jordan
Part 3 now??
Good presentation, although lacking some depth. Maybe under pressure of making it short. Extending by 10-15% would allow making it more reliable and balanced, as (for example) ignoring peace treaties between Israel and Egypt & Jordan leaves a big hole in the story, making a strong impression that the author took side in the conflict. I would also add at least one sentence about the aspirations of each side in respect to the resolution of the conflict, to demonstrate the complexity. But this is a developing issue, which probably deserves another, third chapter…
Peace treaties between 3rd party countries and israel will not justify any of the illegal acts that israel has done to Palestine. The UN proposal in 1947 was unjust by giving most of the land to only the 10% of the Jewish population (before the Nakba and Palestinians got kicked out or killed), the same reason why the British Proposal was unjust. israel has received huge amounts of weapons from the West which is why surrounding Arab countries were pressured into peace agreements but in reality they still have no love for israel since their existence is illegal but currently forced.
I enjoyed both videos but it's interesting how you say "a conflict between two very different people", a perception that has arisen because of that very conflict and which is incorrect. Israelis and Palestinians have in fact, much more in common, culturally, historically and genetically than either of them would like to admit! It's a shame how the politics of hate all around the world divide peoples who, outside of such politics would actually get on with each other splendidly
x iLeon: Agreed!
Imagine just turning up, from another planet, and dropping into Palestine-Israel. "Dudes, y'all look the same, eat the same food, worship the same crazy sociopathic fiction, wear the same clothes, etc. etc. What the hell are you killing each other for?!" I don't think you'd ever to able to explain the situation to the visitor where they didn't just stare at you blankly.
Absolutely agree with your general point but surely the casual reference of "a conflict between two very different people" is more to do with, well, ahem...peoples version of the big man in the sky?
@@horzathirteen if it were only that, wouldn't he have said "two nearly identical people that bicker over nonsense"? They're people of the book. They agree on nearly everything. The differences in the religion are trivial.
I disagree. The Palestinians ancestors were (or were like) the Canaanites, one of the greatest enemies of the Hebrews (modern Jews/Israelites).
thank you for your succinct history. the maps showing the change in territory are very helpful.
Bro, u want.more detail, go and makenyour own video in length duration 600,000 minutes.. Dont be deepshide, this is simplified and likewise easy access history, u need detail, read books dont watch video.
@@asyrafyahya717 ???
2:00 Why was it carved up so messy?
Really leaving out the part where hamas uses schools and hospitals as human shields
This is the real Battle fro Middle Earth.
"Only the dead have seen the end of the war." ~ George Santayana
I really appreciate your objective narration.
This is not an objective point of view, he forgot to mention the rocket fire from the Gaza Strip towards Israel and the terrorists who carry out attacks several times a year
Я конечно прошу прощения. Но почему нет русской версии этого ролика? Просто немного трудновато.
3:39 Israel did not declare war on Syria and Jordan, only on Egypt (after egypt commited an act of war by blockading the Israeli port in the red sea). Jordan and Syria declared war on Israel after getting false information from egypt that egypt was winning (they were not).
Egypt's land, Egypt's rules, we can close the canal whenever we want. You're the ones who declared war but are too cowardly to admit that, but that's ok, because humans don't easily admit their mistakes.
@@meltup3668 Your right to close the straits. Our right to declare war on you.
@@meltup3668 Not to mention the Egyptian army was half militarized on our border. Thankfully we were the first to strike, because I'm not sure if a Yom-Kippur war in Be'er Sheva would have been the same as in Suez.
@@meltup3668 Not to mention that until Camp David Israel was technically at war with you, like we still are today with Syria and Lebanon, like ROK is with DPRK, and like ROC is with PRC.
MELT UP isn’t the canal an International waterway? All ships have right to passage whether during a time of war or peace
Your choice of music is absorbing and perfect for considering all of the detailed information
Agreed! It's something you don't automatically think about. Then again, that's how you know it works.
Very useful and informative - many thanks. The only solution - one state. A single, secular and democratic State that protects / respects Jews, Palestinians and others alike.
You propose that after October 7, the Jews will place their security in the hands of people who want them all dead??? What are you smoking?
At 2:55 it is incorrect, the armistice information is wrong.
What an unbelievable inaccurate and misleading video. The Sinai was exchanged with Egypt in a far-reaching peace deal that remains one of the most successful compromises ever reached in the region. It was not, as suggested in the video, given back due to international pressure over rising oil prices. You have a duty to all your watchers and followers not to provide false information. This video in many places is factually incorrect.
He didn't said its given back due to international pressure over rising oil prices. he just stated historical order to what happened in the "Public Eyes". he said "Part 1: After a ceasefire, oil-exporting Arab countries decide to punish the US and Israel's allies by increasing the price of oil by 70% and decreasing production by 5%. this causes the first oil crisis of 1973. Part 2: Israel under international pressure ceded Sinai back to Egypt and a part of the Golan to Syria" OK the part where i said "Public Eyes", you need to look at this as politician or economist not as Nationalist or Religionists. First you need to visualize the economic situation of the world post World War II era which started with 1944 Bretton Woods Accord (where USA forced UK to make the dollar the new world currency instead of Pound sterling as a condition to help UK against the Germans) now the war ended and USA is even over 50% of the world GDP in the 1950s but the hunger for more money to help USA spread "there way of democracy" against the USSR in Korea Vietnam Cuba and so on as u know all about cold war or even for better quality of life for its own USA citizens the hunger for more money is always endless. As American economist Barry Eichengreen summarized: "It costs only a few cents for the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to produce a $100 bill, but other countries had to pony up $100 of actual goods in order to obtain one", in the 60s the growing of the USA economy even with the on going wars in Korea made other countries feel there is something not right with USA economy. In February 1965 the France President Charles de Gaulle announced his intention to exchange its US dollar reserves for gold at the official exchange rate. He sent the French Navy across the Atlantic to pick up the French reserve of gold and was followed by several countries. As it resulted in considerably reducing US gold stock and US economic influence (which indicates that USA was printing more dollar than the deposited gold in there bank), it led US President Richard Nixon to unilaterally pulled out of the Bretton Woods Accord and end the convertibility of the dollar to gold on 15 August 1971 (the "Nixon Shock"). This was meant to be a temporary measure. but this didn't help the dollar to reclaim its strength as it was. so Richard Nixon started the petrodollar recycling scam to help the dollar by inviting Faisal Bin Abdulaziz Al Saud to USA and negotiating for a deal that makes Saudi Arabia exports crud oil with only USA dollar in exchange for protraction from USA to Saudi Arabia. Later all other OPEC countries started to do the same, exporting the crud oil with only the USA dollar. you see Richard Nixon used basic market mechanisms supply and demand. by connecting the dollar to the oil and making the oil less in the market which in return will make demand for dollar is more to buy the rare oil. after this part of connecting the dollar with oil is done, the 2nd part of the plan had to start "the demand" by making wars that involve oil in it. Daniel Yergin (American author, energy expert, and economic historian) has said that the embargo "remade the international economy". what we call today the " The New International Economic Order " , 1973 the 4th fourth Arab-Israeli war the first oil crisis, 1980 Iran-Iraq War the 2nd oil crisis, 1991 Gulf War, 2003 invasion of Iraq, 2011 Libyan Civil War, i would assume next war either would be Iran or Venezuela since both of them are crud oil exporters and both of them are against USA. Oil-exporting Arab countries leaders did what Richard Nixon asked cause its win win for both sides. The dictators Arab leaders will be seen as good leaders in there citizens eyes as they helped other Arab countries in there wars. and the USA will reaping the benefit of oil shortage in the long run. Peace we earned when we crossed what your people called the strongest defensive line in history The Bar Lev Line, we crossed it in only 2 hours but years of preparation. and if you want to go technical we only lost the war when Israel requested the aid of USA army and they send the Lockheed SR-71 Blackbird the fastest air-breathing manned aircraft to take spy photos of the Egyptian army. theaviationist.com/2013/09/01/declassified-sr-71-mix/ I tried to be as neutral and objective as possible, even though I am Egyptian and Muslim, i hope every one sees the bigger picture. Good luck and have a nice day
That's because the history was told not from an Israeli but probably from a Palestinian who needs to leave Israel because it's not their land God gave that land to the Jewish people and nobody else all foreigners who don't want to recognize Israel need to leave
@@Mark-fr2eb thank you!! I'm not Jewish, I'm a proud Catholic but I stand with Judaism (: God to this day protects His chosen People.
A peace deal that the US pressured Egypt and Israel to adopting. The Camp David Accords of 1978 was mediated by the US by then President Jimmy Cater. What, do you think Israel and Egypt came to this decision on their own? At many times during the negotiations Egypt and Israel executive officials (Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin) did not see eye to eye but Carters persistence helped to convince them that it was in their countries best interests to consolidate a peace treaty.
@@Mark-fr2eb God didn't give any land to anyone
This and part one are exceptionally well done videos as far as teaching points are concerned! keep up the great work!
Super interesting. I don't know if this makes sense, but the community called the Hebrews, did they have a state or country? If so, what happened and what was the relation, if any, to Israel? Can this be map-traced as these videos do?
Jews are the Hebrew people. The Hebrews were the descendants of Abraham through his son, Isaac, and then his grandson Jacob. Jacob was renamed by God to Israel, and his 12 sons became the 12 tribes of Israel. Lots of drama occurred over centuries and after King Solomon, his son, Rehoboam became the king and he was terrible. 10 tribes in the north rebelled, took on their own king, Jeroboam, and became known as Israel. The two tribes in the south, Benjamin and Judah became known as Judea, which is where Jerusalem is. The Jews are called that as a derivative of the place, "Judea". The tribes in the north became known as Samaritans, because their capitol was Samaria and eventually their land called Samaria. After the Assyrians and Babylonians conquered that region, 700 - 500ish B.C. the 10 tribes became assimilated into those cultures. Judea also suffered conquering and oppression from the Babylonians, then the Persians (less so), then the Greeks. In the Bible, there is a parable Jesus tells of the Good Samaritan. The Jews and the Samaritans were not friends because of their very fractured history, which was the point of the story that the Samaritan stopped to help his enemy. He also meets with a Samaritan woman at a well and talks to her, which was outrageous as he was not only a man but also a Jew, and she was known to be a promiscuous woman. Also, the Hebrew people have been in that region since around 2200 B.C. Islam wasn't founded until the early 600s A.D., about 2,800 years later. The issues in that region are as much religious (if not more so) than political. Abraham had a wife, Sarah who seemingly couldn't bear children, so she gave Abraham her maid so he could have an heir. Ishmael was the son born to Abraham and Hagar. Later in her very old age, Sarah became pregnant with Isaac, who became his legitimate son, and Sarah had Hagar and Ishmael leave. Isaac is the direct lineage to Abraham for both Jews and later Christians. Muslims trace their lineage back to Abraham through Ishmael. This is a very OLD conflict and did not start with Zionism in the early 20th century.
@jessicagaulden2819 well, I researched some and to put it in less complicated terms... Hebrews were desert, nomadic people who, after becoming followers of Yaweh, invaded Canaan (allegedly per Yaweh's mandate), took over more territory and trandformed the region in Israel. Later was divided Israel (north) and Judea (south), and from there the Jews originated. Much later the region was conquered, renamed, and restructured by Rome; at some point becoming Palestine. This isn't well understood by most. Yes, it's an "old conflict", but Israel was no more since before Christ, and Jewism became a religious designation, not a nationality. I would argue that there was no more "conflict" either until the WWI and II agreements with the Zionists; the rest is what most know. What most don't know is the nature of the modern "conflict" which is very geopolitical and, recently, energy resources were added to the mix. Things are very different than those biblical perspectives. Other powers and interests are involved, which manipulate media and politics to deceive people worldwide. This must stop.
@@juliobro1 Yes, in general. But your first comment seemed so ignorant (I don’t mean this in a derogatory way, just completely unknowing, if that makes sense). You can divorce Jews from the Bible but that’s exactly where their “nationality” came from. Read Genesis 12. There are 5 significant covenants in the Old Testament and this one, with Abraham is THE most significant. You can generalize and modernize your description of this group of people, but you cannot possibly divorce it from religion. Hamas does not, the Jews do not, and as a Christian - I do not. Modernist like to paint in terms of oppressors vs victims. There is a strong argument that the Hebrew people have been one of the most oppressed over millennia. The Assyrians, Babylonians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, then in waves - Europeans. And, YES, Arabs. Dispersed, cast out repeatedly. I’m suggesting that this is a lot more complicated than the average young person waving the Palestinian flag understands. There deserves to be outrage for how the Palestinian people have suffered. That does NOT excuse Hamas and the atrocities committed on 10/7.
@@jessicagaulden2819 the covenants are religious in context. Regarding nationality, can nomads be a "nation"? Does a "nation" involves a fixed territory and other elements?
@@juliobro1 You keep going on about them being nomads. Not true if you put it in context. Abraham was from Ur, a city-state in Mesopotamia. He gathered his family and headed to Canaan. Skip forward to the time of Jacob and his 12 sons. There was a major famine. Joseph had been sold into Egyptian slavery by 10 jealous brothers. A lot happened, he became very important and powerful in Egypt, had a vision years before and began stockpiling food. The Hebrews moved to Egypt bc they were starving. Over the next centuries they assimilated into the culture and were eventually enslaved by the Egyptians. During the time of Moses, they fled, heading back to Canaan. They wandered in the desert - Jewish and Christian teaching suggests this was necessary for the oldest generation to die out so God could reshape their culture into being specifically Hebrew without Egyptian influence. That’s why the book of Exodus is full of very precise rules about all kinds of things, and very Orthodox Jews still abide by those rules. They made it back to Canaan and assimilated into the culture. They’ve been trying to get back to that part of the world repeatedly throughout history.
0:20 where it all starts
I hope for everyone who lives in that area to find eternal peace and I hope for unity between the Arabs and the Jews
Our Gardening Channel I know they were there first
@@ourgardeningchannel3094 Palestinians like to say "How would you feel if another country with a different religion, culture, tradition, etc invaded your country and moved all it's people their" You are being a hypocrite
@@ourgardeningchannel3094 it is all israel
@@ourgardeningchannel3094 he didn't say it wasn't. But it's all Isreal now.
Oh we have an internal peace, it's just the extremes of both sides are stoning each other and the palestinian police with IDF dont know how to deal with it
**Random** what is the title of the song in the background...it's awesome...
Why was the PLO in Algeria I wonder? 😅
right very random if you ask me
Time for a new section of this video.