Gravitas Plus: What is the Khalistan movement?
Gravitas Plus: The Khalistan movement is now history, but globally the Khalistan bogey has reemerged. How did a protest in India become a debate about Khalistan? What is the role of “foreign forces?” Palki Sharma explores how history is being used to hijack the present.
#GravitasPlus #Khalistan #PalkiSharmaLive
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
Khalistani doesn't represent Sikhism. Real Sikhs are against Khalistan. Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism, Jainism are one 🙏 Edit: Yeah Christianity and Islam too. Actually I was talking about "Sanatana Dharma". Anyways we are Indians first 🇮🇳
But ur sihk brothers raised khalisthan flag 🤔
@@fzlc7425 but on red fort it was NISHAAN SAHEB FLAG
@Vlad Tepes what the hell are you saying? Be mindful of your words.
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao what about hong kong and xing Jiang?
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao sit down Tank man you are tired, never forget Tiananmen square
Did you know Bhagat Singh was a Sikh, who sacrificed his life at the age of 23 for the freedom of India? For Freedom of INDIA not Khalistan.
Bhagat Singh was an atheist. He also wrote a book on "Why am I an atheist".
He was atheist bro
@@niceguy2938 Those urban naxals aka Maoists, worship the teachings of Mao and Stalin. Communism is just like any religion with its teachings and prophets.
No she didn't knew about this thanks for telling her and opening her eyes , she got her degree just randomly from ABCD University :-0
@@sadashivputra1627 BHAGAT SINGH WAS SANATANI... भगत सिंह को उनके दादाजी ने जनेऊ संस्कार के समय ही दान कर दिया था… वो ऐलान, जिसे ‘शहीद’ ने जिंदगी भर निभाया भागवद गीता पर लिखी बाल गंगाधर तिलक की टीका ‘गीता रहस्य’ को भी उन्होंने जेल में पढ़ने के लिए मंगवाया था. इतना ही नहीं नवांशहर (पंजाब) में उनके म्यूजियम में भी भागवद गीता की एक कॉपी रखी है, जिस पर खुद भगत सिंह के हस्ताक्षर हैं.
As a tamilan, I need to say this. We tamilans love and admire sikh people. The culture, Love, respect, tradition, dance and food. Man, you guys are awesome.
What about a country for you guys? That will not Sri Lanka since everyone knows where is your native grounds. :)
@@janakadandunnage8715 okay. If we want a seperate country. It will be not just part india. Tamil language and culture is originally practiced 5 counties such as India, sri lanka, Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia. So can we get one portion all the countries? Hell NO. There is a sentence "Unity in diversity", we must need to respect that. The only thing makes us unique is our diversity. A country can't separated by language and religion. That's would be one of the hateful decision in the history I don't know who's fueling this khalisthanis, but I worked with 9 sikh people on daily basis. They doesn't even seems have thought that they need a separate country. This what all our enemy countries want and even west.
Tamil Eelam and Khalistani terrorists ROCKS🔥🔥
This woman obsessed with Pakistan 😂😂😂😂
@@janakadandunnage8715 you mad our culture is spreading?
I am a Sikh, I am a Punjabi, and Most importantly I am an Indian. My family has served in the Indian army ever since my 3 generations have lived in India. My Uncle (Chacha ji) lost his leg during his development in Ranchi. I am well aware of these movements but they do not mean anything as long as Indian Sikhs are in Punjab.
We all are indebted to your family and alike. Every Indian is indebted to you all
Being a sikh and serving the country...how do you feel when a sacred symbol (the turban) of your faith is banned by France and India doesn't do anything...on the contrary they invite the French President at their Republic Day celebrarion and conveniently leave out the Sikh regiment from that year's parade march...And when Russia bans Bhagwad Gita the same India unanimously condemns it in the parliament
@@parampreetsingh8343 brother, there seems to be some confusion in your mind. Firstly, France has never placed a ban on Sikh turbans and it was even clarified by the French ambassador and the French embassy, they have only placed a ban on the burqa dress which we have no connections with. Secondly, The Sikh regiment is the most decorated Regiment in the Indian armed forces and it’s not true that they are intentionally left out of the republic day parade. India has a lot of regiments and every year Regiments switch places, meaning not all regiments are able to March every year. The Gurkha regiments is also a highly decorated regiment but it was not included in the past 2 years because they switched out with others. However Sikh and Punjab regiments are always included as there are multiple regiments for Sikhs and Punjabis, Punjab, Sikh regiments.
@@parampreetsingh8343 Bro why are you allowing mistrust to build in your heart...
We are blessed to have Sikhs are our brothers and sisters. Jai Guru Nanakji - true peace keeper of the world. Jai Sanatana dharma and jai Hind! We love you guys. ❤️
Sikhs are proud of India...No body should have any doubt about it.
Pakistan & leftists (in India) are stoking communal tensions within India
How are sikhs pride of India? Our unreasonable glorification has gone into thr head! Now they blv they saved us from mughals lol! As if rajputs,ahoms,marathas,dogras etc never existed!While they beautifully ignore how rajputs and marathas help sikh gurus and women multiple times,we keep glorify them for thr limited help in kashmir,punjab area only!
What about hindus?? Or our brothers who want us to separate.. muslims?? Nothing to say??
@MR SINGH yeah keep voting for Congress which killed Sikhs 😂
Yes bro,we are Indian,these news channel just doing bakchodi day and night
I m a hindu living in punjab , I love Sikhs coz they helped everyone in our area during lockdown also they stood for mandir in our area and in every hindu festival they organize prashad ( langars ) 🙏🏻
Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism, Jainism are all binded together in one soul, can't be separated; so are the believers
@@sudipklvm Sikhs are not Hindus
@@thesingh588 you are a dumb... Hindu is a civilization created and nourished in Indian subcontinent for 3000 of years... It's a culture and a way of living... Many sects emerged from here like Shivism. Baisnobism, Sikhism, Jainism, Buddhism like streams ... The existing concept of religion developed later post attack by the Arab Muslims since every son of the soil was desparate to save the culture from external attack ... In ancient India, religion was a personal believe, even members of the same family had the choice of practicing their own preferred religion .. like Emperor Askoka was a Buddhist, his father was beliver of Ajivika sect and his grandfather King Vikramaditya was a believer of Jainism.
There were lot of Great Sikh freedom fighters who fought with their lives for India's independence.. It still gives me goosebumps when i even remember Bhagat Singh..We are all one country and we all are brothers....Many will try to divide us but always remember we are one. Jai hind!! Wahe guruji🙏
I am from TamilNadu, I have a deep respect for sikhs. They are hardworking and most ethical persons. Their contributions to our nation is immense. 🙏
❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Dear Sikh, do you guys know? here in North India if you ask to us how are Sikh people, the answer of most of us will be: they are kind hearted amd generous people. Very often we post Sikh gurus' quotes and while talking we don't even realise that there is a separate religion. Love to all. Whoever wants us to get divided, it will remain a dream for him/her
very brave too
@Gaurav X jokes to Biharis and South Indians pe bhi banta hai!
@Gaurav X who the hell r you to represent the entire Sikh community here?! Replying to someone's comment, isn't that poking your nose?! Internet is full of Hypocrites!
Here in north india?? I am quiet sure that my state, punjab (home to sikhs community) is also in north .🙄
Only handful of people support it. Majority of Sikhs like us hate the idea of Khalistan.
I am Sikh and have four generation served in Indian and British Indian army,we should remember Khalistan is a political movement not religious Jai Hind Hindustan zindabad tha... hai or hamesha rahega
You were British army shame on you
@Sameer MAHAJAN but they should have fought for Subhash Chandra Bose not in favour of British army
@Sameer MAHAJAN you don't know he was alive till 1985 and living in faizabad up as Gumnaami baba please search you can know everything about him
@Sameer MAHAJAN Yes in Google it is written but Google also don't know truth he was officially died in 1945 please watch Dr Vivek Bindra video on Subhash Chandra Bose you will understand properly
Served in Indian army ? Yes that's what central government has left for Sikhs , to die on borders or to be agricultural and commit suicide as farmers under debts .
"A fringe cannot define a majority" ... Absolutely Yes
I am from România and I have much respect for Sikh people...they are brave and very kind good people...I think Mother India should stay togeder like brothers with all her religion
They are also hindu brother, but in last 150 years many power tries devide from hinduism and than result is ...... If anyone Read deeply sikhism then they'r found their gurus are actually warship hindu god and goddess.
Sikh are the most respected people of india. Its these khalistani's
I belong to a Sikh family and trust me it hurts when people/ news channels label Sikhs as khalistanis. We don’t want khalistan. Being from a Sikh family I know, no one in my family ever talked about being in Khalistan. These things I have only heard from my relatives in other countries. She said “a fringe cannot define majority” I hope everyone understands this.
@Trey Wilson Read about guru Nanak he mentioned India not khalisthan
Ma'am but I as a hindu very disappointed by the response of the average sikhs they are not actively opposing khalistan if you want that no one label you something you should start a movement and oppose these khalistanis where ever they ask for khalistan.
Canadistan and Pakistan funded terrorism is Khalistan
take that stronger and prove your patriotism sky high
Those sikh who doesn't support Khalistan there mom are Vaishyas of hindu ministers
The way this lady sits calmly and read out such topics.....
I understand 😁
She should have told the other side of the story also in detail. Why a saint ultimately chose the path of violence? What were his real demands? Did he ever ask for Khalistan? Did he start the violence? Or Did he first see the violence and the desecration of Guru Granth Sahib? Did he really ask to kill any innocent Hindus? Yes, he made one mistake by taking refuge in Golden temple. I don't support Khalistan but a lot wrong had been done to Punjab and sikhs by the Congress government of those times. A lot of punjabi Hindus, especially the ones affiliated with RSS and Sangh, were killed by the people hired by Congress. But it was easy to blame the sikh extremists. BJP is no saint either. They have tried to repeat it via 26 January incident.
Its palkeys manarism like Rajani kanth and Amitabachhan... Hahaa..🤣🤣🤣
@@Punjab_Punjabi_Punjabiat Saint won’t kill lives. No one is ready to buy your brainwashed stories. tata 👋
Please subscribe (SHASWAT BHARAT) Note- spelling should be correct
I am a Sikh, from Canada and I don't support Khalistan either. When people are smart enough to understand Indian Sikhs do not support Khalistan, they should not get dumb believing all Sikhs abroad want Khalistan. It's hardly 0.1% of all Sikhs from abroad who talk about Khalistan. Not all.
Punjab is not just sikh, I am a punjabi and I am an Indian first
So what it’s what majority supports not u
As a sikh i dont support and Will never support Khalistan walistan, I will die for my nation And Will do anything For my nation 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Btw i want khalistan in Pakistan Punjab
They already killed or converted most of the sikhs there , what are you planning to do with Pakistani punjab??... Rather bring remaining sikhs to India
Nothing less is expected from Sikhs.
You don't have to prove that We trust you We are indians noone is sikh and Hindu we are just indian This is our identity 🙏
then why are there photos of Bhindranwale in various houses and gurudwara of Punjab ??
@@rickisharma Bindrawale wasn't a Khalistani supporter his followers were.
I am a Sikh and proud of myself but honestly speaking I totally agree with you, whatever is happening in India is because of the Congress party for their political gains.
Open Ur eyes brave Singh,what RSS in indirectly n slowly doing,will discriminate all others except RSS followers.
and the true pain is that most of the sikhs of punjab supports congress...the one who organized 84 riots
@@johnhimal5913 lol you have no idea how even the RSS holds sikhs in high respect
@@johnhimal5913 Hey Rice Bag from Kerela If You Don't know about Punjab then shut up
ty bhaisab
I am also a Sikh and I proudly say that Sade dhrm ch kadi vi glt krna nhi seekhya sab equal aa hindu vi and sikh vi I also have hindu friends and my friends mostly like Sikh Kom ❤️
I grew up as a Sikhi in England and I lived in India as a young child. I have travelled all over the world, currently living in the Andes of Peru! I don't want Sikhs to become separate from Bharat! At the same time a lot of injustices have been done towards the Sikh people within it's own country, please treat our people with the kindness and respect they deserve which they willingly give others and they will always remain loyal to Bharat! Jai Sanatan Dharma! 🙏🇮🇳
Khalistani should get rid of calling them sikh and using the nishan sahib as their symbol. Real sikhs are in Indian Army and in India they feel proud of being indian.
I am a Sikh and I am an Indian , Govt of India should ban SFJ terrorists group site asap , thanks for the coverage Palki
Terrorist was not a problem in India , it's the NRI's who is fuelling this and finance this, Terrorist groups mainly Canada.
We neeed sikh community, every is a part of different colours of India. How can any one forget freedom fighters like Udham singh and Bhagat singh. We are living in free nation because of all freedom fighters. I read indias fredom struggle from 1957 to 1947. Can't foget pain of those freedom fighters of Gadar party,
Harnoor Dandona what is your opinion about PM Modi’s movement towards the growth of india ?
But, they keep on giving Visas to Jazzy b, Hard Kaur, Khalsa Aid people to come to India and spread poison.
Respect++
Don’t let Non-Sikh fool you: 1) Simranjeet Singh Maan won election on the name of Khalistan in Punjab and become Member of parliament. 2) Amritpal Singh raised his voice for Khalistan and million people joined him in rallies in Punjab. 3) Every years thousand of Sikhs chants slogan on June 6 for Sikh independence. 4) Wherever Sikhs lives they are organizing referendum for their independence. 5) Sarbat Khalsa (meeting where all Sikh leaders(jathedars) gather) passed resolution for Sikhs in Golden temple to fight until we achieved Khalistan.
I am a Sikh and i don’t want this movement. Stay together , stay united . No benefit in making a different state
yes😊
🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻🤝🏻
Who wants Khalistan than they should take it from Pakistani Punjab because Pakistan has more part of Panjab and So they should asked and fighting with Pakistan ! For there own country!
@@UniverseAZ so what it is the state where most Sikhs has been persecuted.. Sikhs Kartarpur and Lahore two sacred city is the there . So that Sikhs can claim...
We farwarded your request to sikhs but they spit on your request
@@AbdullahAbdullah-gb9zg learn English first
@@AbdullahAbdullah-gb9zg Yes they spit out request on green bedsheet.
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao Yeah, you're right. China is WORLD troublemaker 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Major General Kuldeep Singh Brar is a true sikh, not bhindrawale 🙏
I dont support bhindrawala but kps gill wasn't a good sikh either
Your head
@Vatsal hes a butcher dont u know rapes done by his CRPF men?? Rebiero himself wrote in his book"bullet for bullet" that's the reason he ordered kps to step down! Killed innocent people who were just suspects!!
@ᏒᎯᎻᏬᏝ destroyed punjab🙃
P hm.m.mmmmmmmm...ymmhmyllllyymmymmmmm(km.mmg_b
Well researched and rational analysis on all aspects. Rightly said- "A fringe cannot define majority." However many political groups with vested interest won't interest won't understand her unbiased opinion. That's why she has faced a lot of pressure inside the newsroom and had to resign two months ago. That's an ordeal of all honest journalists like Palki Sharma. Hats off to you!
In ur words, majority can define minority?? Correct! What a majority decides Mr Handa will follow.
What khalistan? We are all indians. I hope these people will acknowledge it soon
“A fringe cannot define a majority” 👏
Please subscribe (SHASWAT BHARAT) Note- spelling should be correct
Mahal saab we love Sikhs aara...Sikhs are sirmour of India...love from himachal
That is correct. I remember the day Indira Gandhi died. My mom was all torn apart, sad, least to say. While my neighbor a Sikh was celebrating. But my parents made it sure that our Sikh neighbors were protected and made sure that they had everything they needed. The Sikh families in my community in India were always close to us. We respected them and we cared for them in spite of our differences. When you have Sikh’s married in the family and friends who are Sikh’s, it very hard for me to think of a Sikh as not an Indian and least to say a Khalistani. !
@@abhinavbharadwaj13 me bhi himachali
I am sikh n i nevr thought abt a nation separate from India
♥️♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳♥️♥️🙏🙏♥️♥️💪💪♥️♥️
We don't have asked you
@Amitoj Kaur fr bro
@Amitoj Kaur seriously? Lol you wouldn't be PM of your khalistan, and every rulers has their own interests they won't listen to you.
@Amitoj Kaur you would’ve become like Kashmir. A battleground for India and Pakistan
Always proud of you Mam for such enlightening perspective that you share.
I am non-punjabi hindu, and ever since I was a child I've had immense respect for the religion as I felt it to be the most peaceful and kind religion unlike a few major ones. it breaks my heart over how all this is happening
Whole of India is a proud part of Sikh homeland.
@Sl Mi Modi himself and most of the BJP is from Most backward class., unlike Congress. chill!!
@Sl Mi what nonsense! I am a Tamil, ISRO chairman k.Sivan is a Tamil, India’s HAL chairman is a Tamil, finance minister and external affairs minister of India is a Tamil. If u work hard you can reach any heights in india regardless of who you are. Don’t get brainwashed.
Please subscribe (SHASWAT BHARAT) Note- spelling should be correct
@Sl Mi Nonsense
@@Purple_Neon and please don't forget Mr. APJ Abdul Kalam, the most beloved President of all Indians, inspite of him being a "Tamil" and a "Muslim". With love, from a "Central Indian" Hindu.
As a Punjabi Hindu I have stayed in Punjab all my early childhood. I have studied in Sikh school and have no hesitation in saying that I had best of my time and friends with Sikhs. My Sikh friends are like family to me and vice versa. Most lovely people they are. Seems like few people are driving the agenda. No lessons learnt from past. As a Hindu I have utmost respect for gurudwaras I have been visiting all my life. Whats the place for us if not United India!?
Very well said. United we stand, religion can’t divide us.
Yes as a Hindu utmost respect for Gurudwaras as on the time of protecting them , you would do Ur best to join the mob and disrespect them just like in1984 in all over India , Where the sacrifices were made to protect religious rights of Kashmiri pandits (Shaheed sees ganj Delhi) That was the same place which was vandalised in 1984 by same pandits ideology followers
@@babber2536 ਬਾਈ chaki ਰੱਖ kam
@@babber2536 1984 was caused by Congress and rest of the innocent Indians had nothing to do with it. Plus what was happening inside The Golden Temple is known to everybody so don't act like those people there were peaceful. We have to learn from the past and evolve. Stop spreading hatred in the comment section. I have seen you in almost every comment section talking ill of India and Hindus.
@@kakarotdb490 if you are so keen to put all the blame on only congress , or any other parties who were involving in these acts , then what would you say about today ? The Modi central government ,and any Central government who was there after Indira Gandhi still did the same with us , hence India and it's conflicts about castes , religions still exists today . Why there is not a single photo of bhagat Singh ? Kartar Singh Sarabha , ? Udham Singh ? Why the Gandhi manmohan still there on currency even after thh rule of Congress ? Everyone knows what kind of individual he was , who let loot all the precious things to British , Why there is still delay in the justice of massacring thousands of innocents of 1984 -1980s ? Why the culprits like sajjan Kumar Jagdish tytler Kamal Nath all wandering around still today ,why amitabchan not getting jail for Incited pogroms ??? Why the Sikh youth who do disappeared in 1980s to 2005 still not receiving a Penni of support from any government ? , why it's only khalsa aid (the foreign organisation ) who are helping the victims in Panjab ? Why no one is stopping the extremisms organisations like RSS and shiv Sena who are mocking Minorities thrice a year using harsh language on their faith ? ?? Why why why ?? Why the hundreds of innocent Sikhs like jathedaar Bhai hawaraa is still in the imprisonment even after bailing into 30 false accusations cases ??? Why don't Indian government letting human rights referendum occuring for Panjabis especially Sikhs ? Why they are arresting them for supporting their rights ? Why still Panjabi sooba or anandpur resolution still not getting approval ???? A pure demonstrated discrimination
As an African with so much respect for india, i pray peace rains forever. It is the only way development is guaranteed. The west undoubtedly always takes advantage of situations like this. Unite and do not give out yourselves to your larger enemies- the west.
Most Sikhs are a jolly bunch , easy going, passionate, serving of the community in times of trouble……true you cannot brush them with one stroke. Their contribution to Indian is in valuable. ❤
I m a Hindu and I can say proudly that the commitment that my Sikh brothers and sister gave to our country is beyond the horizon. There good gestures under all disaster have won each Indians hearts. Thank you for everything. We all Indians and we are happy to stay together. Jai Hind.
I salute you and your family sir. JAI HIND
We love each other n this is our strength. Unfortunately some just want to spoil our unity ...I don't know y they can't Nov in live n let live
@@akashdeepbawa1554 both hindu and sikh fanatics are responsible for this
@REPUBLIC PUNJAB since 2014 give me one genocide against Sikh community. Congress has been mostly ruling since 1947 and they were Hinduphobiacs and thereby haters of Sikhism,Buddhism, Jainism etc. They believed in Abrahamic religions and hence would do whatever possible to eradicate the 'non-believers'.
Sikhs are Hindu too.🙏
So Sikhs in the US, Canada, etc will tell what Sikhs in India wants
Sure they can, they use to be Indian citizens until they were forced to leave by the corrupt government. When they spoke up in India they were killed thats why they are speaking up from different countries.
@@gssaran88 haaa
@@blade4631 What's wrong with them speaking about their Homeland?
@@gssaran88 😂😂😂 did you hear what se said we waited for 2 years And be reasonable you wan a peaceful punjab or just Another kashmir
@@zangetsu949 not sure what your talking about.
I want to thank you for your journalism. This channel has been my favorite since 2020. I was born and raised in Vancouver and currently live in Alberta. I'm so grateful for your honesty and education. The PM of Canada is very WRONG to make the accusation he has without providing evidence. It's no shock that he is deliberately causing division. I truly hope and pray he fails. I'm very sorry for the loss and suffering caused by his mouth. I have a neighbor who is Indian. He gave me authentic l Indian curry. We don't talk about religion. He is a very good and generous man. We both like this channel, and he smiled brightly when I told him it was my favorite news channel.
Two years later this video becomes more relevant than ever.
As a sikh i can proudly say my community is the most respected community in India Across all RELIGION everyone does respect Congress jhandu party created this
Bhai as a right winger we love you. We are proud of sikh community. You and us both have to come forward against thode who wants a seperate country.
I am done I am tired my community never gonna wake up
Respect++
You a RSS element.
We never thought you are different from us and you have also not thought you are different from us.
The brotherhood of Sikhs and Hindus is like no other. My son retired as a Colonel of a Sikh Regiment, proudly.
I mean most Hindus are against Sikhism flourishing. many media outlets spit venom against Sikhs 24/7.
@@raath_sikh why ?, you are all indian
@@raath_sikh excuse me...we love them as our own....nasha karke aye ho Bhai?
@Clorox Bleach alag hi coma me jee rha hau
@Vimalpreet Bajwa idk where you witnessed it I live in kanpur there are a million Sikhs I never saw anyone hating a sikh
Excellent points and enjoyed the impartiality of the narrator. Sad part is the fact, humans cannot see beyond their self interest.
Sikhs has always been a majority of Indian army 🇮🇳
"a fringe cannot define a majority" Isn't she lovely....❤️
Namastey! Please subscribe (SHASWAT BHARAT) Note- spelling should be correct
I'm Hindu and living in Punjab,every Sikhs i have interacted and asked about Khalistan, they never supports Khalistanis at alll
They are afraid of u being an intelligence agent
@@adnanshoukat1793 And they also know you all belong to ola hu uber ride
Haan tujhe q bataein ge, tu unka mama lagta hai
@@BlueNinjaX11 tum logo ko itna hate faila ke milta kya hai?
We dont believe in having a separate country. We just want to be treated equally in our own country and get the same resources and rights as everyone else.
Would be helpful if graphic slides are used to better understanding
Here because of what happened in Canada. TBH Canada should have been watching these guys closely since its only the diaspora for the most part. Sad for everyone. I hope all of India and the world for that matter can learn to live with one another.
Being an Indian Sikh, I can vouch this report has aptly described the facts and it is more harmful to label the protestors by labelling them Khalistani
some people are trying to highjack this movement.
Nobody has the legitimacy to question Indian Sikhs but a VAST MAJORITY of Sikhs outside India are straight up Khalistanis & some who aren't stay silent intentionally.
@@seeker8238 wow Assamese 😍
Yaar nishansab wale jhanda ki to sab ko uski respect karni chahiye. I have no issues about nishansab flag. But media wale to aise dikhate hain jaise isis ka flag ho.
@@DemonicEmbrace but you'll never get it😂
India is proud of its sikh population. Stop doubting our bravest and most generous hearted community.
Thank you 💙
Thanks ❤. We all are Indians first before wer belong to any state or religion. But lots of Sikhs are just being tagged Khalistanis😔 . But Fringe can't define majority. But at the same time, everytime Sikhs will raise any issue or disagreement with govt, this government will just ignore by attaching them to khalistan which seems dark future for Sikhs too😔
@@rajrandhawa465 no dear there was a khalistani issue in that protest which needed to be addressed , not everytime , if uk the protestors used khalistani flag and many more z they tried to attack on Indian army and the army was also a Sikh . So u could see it has no religious connection , its all politics , Sikhs ar not khalistani , but few khalistanis are Sikhs brainwashed by foreign powers ( not naming them) . Sikhs are India's pride , we love our sikh community , Sikh is India , Buddhism , Jainism , Hinduism this is Indian sanatan dharam .... We have foreign ethnic religious like Islam and Christianity also .... Buddhism spread from India to many places . And don't get bothered by government , for them politics is a religion , every Indian loves sikh community , respects them ❤️🙏🏻
@@someonessweetheart3040 If everyone truly loves Sikhs then why dont they stand up for them against everything the government is doing to them? How can they can they not be bothered when they are always targeted and not allowed to speak up? Sorry to say but leaving comments on youtube doesnt help them much, they need more support.
Yehh sure...you wont say the same when you see that so called proud community in canada showing derogatory towards India flag.
Your channel is very interesting and informative, thanks, from Australia
Really love and appreciate your journalism
I am a hindu from delhi ncr, I spent 5 years of my life around sikhs in punjab due to my father's job. Honestly i never saw hindu and sikhs as two different religion with our tons of common beliefs we celebrated all the festivals with full spirit and joy whether it was held in mandir or gurudwara or even masjid. It wont be an easy job to divide us. WE ARE ONE, and are planning to keep it that way. My only message to my fellow countrymen is - no matter what your religion is, keep believing in love and unity, ignore these news media houses who wants to sensationsalize everything, ignore these politicians who only care for the votes and keep working for our nation we still have a lot to achieve for our country. STAY UNITED. Our bonds are way to strong to be broken by politicians, news channels or even these stupid terrorist organizations
Sorry, but we are not one. There are fundamental differences between Sikhism and Hinduism and those cannot be looked over. Sikhs MUST NOT worship any stone like moortis, we just do not believe in it. It is just a statue nothing else to us. India can only stay united if the govt. gives Panjab its full rights. The way it is going right now, there are more divisions than ever
Ahh that’s fine but we have nothing in common with Hinduism. We don’t believe in statue workship or ceremony that’s goes with it. Don’t believe in fasting, only believe in one god, no superstition, we don’t have CASTE, we have equal rights to women (no sati and Dhan Guru Amar Das ji, promoted window re-marriage in those days) and many more. Guru Nanak sahib ji said, your water will not reach sun, therefore give that water to a thirsty human. Which I believe in, serving humans. That jot of guru ji is present in every human being. Henceforth everyone is welcomed in Gurdwara.
@Omi Mishra just in case you don’t know about history when guru sahib ji was constructing it, there were two parts, do you know? One was purposely mishandled by pandits who wanted to make Sikhism their part. People like you, who couldn’t see other religion flourishing, so before arguing with me go and read the history and then talk.
@Julius Ramone what a stupid reply, those are people who are taught that Hindus and Sikhs are same. They are misguided by people like you. Ever heard Singh or kaur? That’s the basic principle to eradicate caste system that was deeply rooted in blood and bones of bhaaman like yourself.
@Omi Mishra also, u know the bani include work of Hindus and Muslims saints, hindi used ram to depict god. Say it Ram - allah or whatever but first word is EkON kar, one god. Dude you are deluded. Bye. Go and listen to some educated scholar not the one who come on tv and say hare hare
Beautiful Report. Being United is the key to success. One multicultural INDIA is more stronger than being divided.
India is not multicultural society
@@shubhamdubey9561 Your opinion doesn't matter as it is not a fact. You need to learn how multiculturalism is defined. A multiculturalism or cultural pluralism in which various ethnic groups collaborate and enter into a dialogue with one another without having to sacrifice their particular identities. It can describe a mixed ethnic community in which Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Buddhists and Christians all exist.
No need for islam, its a cult not a religion.
India was multicultural or not is less important for me. In my opinion, Being United is our strength and I respect vibrant multicultures of India now and forever.
Guys please stop bashing him. Why bringing his religion in between..hes also our brother ..hes also an Indian.. He just stated a beautiful fact about our country's diversified culture.. people from different faiths and background living and working together for the betterment of the country and future generations.. just appreciate it ..why bringing religion in everything .. Jai Hind!
Dear Madam, Kindly make one video on Hindu Saffron Terrorism in Indian Politics. Thanks
When there was Tsunami and many people in Chennai, lost lives, home and no food, an entire Sikh family with their Utensils came and fed thousands of Chennai people. They did not speak, they did what they could. This is India. We are bounded by love. This whole nation is one family. We will have disagreements in our family, we will not let anyone misjudge us and take us for granted.. Jaihind.
I am a proud Sikh ... N I love my India more then my life . Satsiyakal .(Satya - Shree- kaal) some useless ppl keep guiding me about this .. these ppls just looking for pronunciation n ,spelling to pull me down...they least bother about feelings love n respect...just hypocrite)... Jai Hind
@Mohammed Awang mere 12 baj gai ?? Mohammed... gaala naal Jawaab maerko wad ke koi nai de sakda....par farak hona chahida mere Nanak babbe te taa tere Naa Che. Apne Naa Di kadar Kar tee naal shanti diya galla karya Kar. Sat Shri akaal te naal Jai hind..(Listen Mohammed no one can compete me while using abusive words, but there should be difference in my god Nanak n in your name . Plz try to respect your name n spread love , Jai Hind)
😂🤣🤣future comedian LMFAO from which angle are u Sikh
@@khalsaikhajana9980 listen Pakistani my village is in sarhall near Tarantaran n My paili is there. At present m not in India. This year end I will come . Will meet u... Then I will show u a real patriotic sardar.
@@akashdeepbawa1554 good luck faking to be a sikh next time 😂🤣
@@khalsaikhajana9980 ok Pakistani, :)
Sikhs are part and will be part of our country I as a hindu proud of the Sikh community in India,we will and we together stand as one Indian citizen 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai Hind brother
@Rhode IslandAB94 you can go back to pakistan.. we dont need your hatred here..
Jai modi ji
@Rhode IslandAB94 and where did Sikh families come from?? Hindus! Guru Nanak created a panth, with set of values, not a religion.. and the first Hindu child (typically from Kshatriya clan-jatts ) of every family joined the Sikh panth to protect the weakest from tyranny.. (Hindu victims of Islamic rules then)
@Rhode IslandAB94 chill brother.. I was roommates with Sikhs in US.. and we never thought of any religion.. now I am in Australia, and have a few Sikh friends.. They are just sad that our govt has not provided Justice or a public apology for 1984!! thats it, but they love India!! AFAIK, most of the khalistanis are sikhs that migrated abroad during world war times before independence and a very few brainwashed Sikhs..
Very interesting and informative. I read these comments here and see much love between all the Hindus and Sikhs. Love from the USA
Hindus love and respect sikhs unconditionally, be it as prime minister or a decorated army officers. Sikhs are our friends and as trustworthy as our own brothers. Not really worth fighting brothers. Let not give some opportunists a chance to create a divide
92% Punjab population doesn't support khalistan
It's 99%
@@SayonHazra nai mai Punjab sa muja pata kitna log karta hai iss khalistan ko support kuch uneducated villager hai.
@@eren-dr2tr ap sikh ho?
@@SayonHazra nai hindu hu but hindu sikh dono religion ko follow karta hu
@@eren-dr2tr good 👍👍
People (radicals) living good life in western countries peacefully and are causing unrest in india. This should be dealt with strictest manner.👍🏻
What do you mean by “unrest”. No government is gonna crack down on free speech in order to appease Delhi.
What you mean, using democratic means such as voting in a referendum? How dare they do such terrorist activities and comply with UN provisions for persecuted minorities! I mean, what is wrong in invading a holy place on Guru Arjan Dev's Shaheedi Day knowing there'll be thousands of innocent pilgrims? And invade other gurdwaras where there were no Bhindrawales? Ok, they're not Hindus but surely they can forget it, and the widow's colony. They're troublemakers after all, just jealous that the genocide agitators prospered in their political careers afterwards, after November 1984? Surely you can expect for one of the largest armies in the world to stop supplies to Bhindrawale's few men I amritsar in June 1984? And what's wrong in killing people in Delhi because they're wearing turbans or wearing karas (bangles)? As Big B said on Door Darshan TV as he was a mate of Rajiv, khoon ka badla khoon, khoon ke shitey unhoke har ghar pohunchne chaahiye! That's fair...isn't it?
All hypocrite mama boys, that don’t get the same attention there. I vow to never reproduce with one, I was born in Moga.
@@Jenvlogs404 Your reproduction hopes are your own affair Jessie Boy 🤣
rich people often has problems that we working class people don't even have heard in practical lives 😂😆 (gareebi apna alag hi dharam hai)
Very well explained in a short video.
The day that operation took place was Martrydom day of Guru Arjan Dev ; lots of pilgrims were inside temple in hundreds, they were not given a chance to come out of temple. It was Genocide. Government never disclosed true figures.
I am a Hindu and I feel Proud to say that our Sikh and Parsi Brothers are an Asset for India. Their Contributions has made India more Strong. Jo Bole So Nihaal, Satt Sri Akaal 💪🚩🚩🚩. Jay Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳.
parsis were traitors in 1857 Also it was some indian King Jadeja who 1st let them in India .Jadejas used to say they are from Krishnas Yadav linage .But recently it was found out that they had nothing to do with the Yadavs and they got created by someone called Jamshed who was from Persia
@@murtaza-sangrur shut up man We are all living happily
@@murtaza-sangrur Do you even know what you typing you fool?? Please learn English or communicate in your language what you trying to say..
@@murtaza-sangrur Kya hai be tera problem chutiye
@@murtaza-sangrur Hahaha kya pagal hai re chutiye😅 chal
Me an Malaysian Sikh n I stand by modiji all the way
Bhullar saab don't go on internet narrative...see on ground...ask any...any Indian of middle class or poor...who are Sikhs? And he will tell you the bravest of the brave among all indians
Agreed!
@@abhinavbharadwaj13 Whts your point?
"Modiji " Is not India I stand with India I stand against khalistan I stand against Pakistan I stand against Hindu Rashtra
I am india but I always against Modi 😡😡
You're one of the best truthful journalist that we have... Much much proud what you do. Jai Hind!
Was looking for some new information. The narrative is nowhere close to the subject.
We are indian .We love our country .We love our Sikh brothers and sisters.They are part of my soul❤️
Yes yet billion of Indian won't care what happened in 1984 and constantly were continue till 1995 in the version of operation wood rose .
@Roshan Rajaraman and what have you done for tens of thousands that were massacred in it ? Did you raised any concerns ? Did you do any protest ? Did you protest for illegally killings of Punjab Sikh youth between 1980s to 1995 known as operation wood rose . Did you pay any tribute to those events that happened ?
@@babber2536 ithee v roon aa Gaya Tu ??
@@babber2536 vaddu pahe litte ne tu ISI Vallo.
@@babber2536 at that time we also war with Pakistan in Kargil
I love my India always remember United we Stand and Divided we fall
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao china took all the tibet and left sikkim alone and still waged war to even take away kashmir
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao India rehabilitated the Tibetans driven out from their homeland by invader China. India has also given refuge to thousands of Chinese Christians expelled by the Communists in 1949. India has not driven out any people from its soil. But you are welcome to create a Khalistan within China. But as world's numero uno trouble maker you are advised against causing another Wuhan type pandemic.
As a sikh from amritsar punjab, Sikhism can only be saved if we have own state where we are safe and secure.
My God Palki your Journalism is gold. 🥇🥇🥇🥇
Stay United all Indians. There's big conspiracy going on against our country.
Why do we need UP, Bihar? Big drain on resources. Communal and caste politics of that region is spreading to other parts now.
Omg
@@mundoormadan5624 why do we need need people like you who are spreading hate?
@@DD-cr8xi I want a developed India. Sharing will keep us all poor.
@@mundoormadan5624 dude UP and bihar people working so hard in factories and mills. Not a single state people can do that work that has been done by Bihar and up people. Without them manufacturing company will be shut down
I could never understand how Hindus and Sikhs can be seperated. We all have been supporting each other for so long without any selfishness. Both the communities believe in peace and sewa. This khalistani movement is pure terrorism. My heartfelt request to all the Sikhs brothers and sisters to not support this movement. My own Guru in life is a Sikh saint. I know Gurbani does not speak of killing the innocent. Please save India.🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼 🇮🇳
The weird thing about this Khalistan issue is that the people who want to carve out a separate nation for themselves in India so badly are not in India; they are all in Canada. And, now, chances are that India will never, ever, issue them visas to enter India. That would be totally within India's sovereign rights; no one in the world can challenge India over this. These Khalistanis are not very smart, are they? They can't now come to India: at least not their ring leaders, EVER . They will NEVER be allowed entry into India, EVER. Yet, they demand that India carve out a piece of its sovereign territory into a new nation called Khalistan. How ridiculous all that sounds? Do these misguided souls, or more appropriately terrorists, even realize how stupid and illogical their demand sounds? Let Canada create a separate province in Canada for these terrorists; India has no problem with that. Canada would be a big loser over this nonsense issue. Hard to figure out why Canadian govt. took such a foolish stand over this. But, talking to my family members living in Canada, it’s not all that surprising to them, coming from their dim-witted, narcissist premier. He’s coalition Govt. depends upon Khalistani support for its very survival.
Copious amounts of untraceable $$$ can help national leaders allow mass immigration , in some cases.
Sikh in India do not want anything but to live their life peacefully & prosperitily
I never thought I would get to see journalism like this. It's crazy how this channel doesn't have a Billion viewers
Conspiracy theory. Canada does not support Khalistan movement
@@canadiancanadian7620 Correction, not officially
All Day with hate journalism U never become Billion Views
Its a very bised channel.
@@canadiancanadian7620 it does
We strongly condemn the idleness of UK, Canada regarding the adequate security measures outside the Indian High Commission! India have started befitting measures which are indeed commendable. Whether it is North-East or Punjab, Bangladesh and its people stand firm with India against such separatist groups. Joy Bangla, Jai Hind 🇧🇩 🤝 🇮🇳
My mother was seikh and father was Hindus very good decent respectful kind loving family oriented India seikh genuinely good hearted They are brave heart ❤️💞❤️💞 They fought in all the war defenders I give the seikh of India my full support for there ardent fight against the haters of India long live the seikh of India ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Nice and Correct explanation on such Sensitive issue ,well done Palki Mam......👍
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao the world knows which country has the most border disputes... Hence the most trouble maker🤣
"A fringe can not define a majority" very well said. Loads of love and respect to all the sisters and brothers of Sikh community. Just like any other Indian, their commitment to India is immense.
@Faizan Ahmad "Just like any other indian", this statement includes all the people of India which includes Kashmir too.😊🙏
really is that why you blame Muslims for spreading covid?
This is why we would like to be a majority somewhere on this good earth, where we have the freedom to be guided by the morals and standards set by our Gurus. So that local corruption and 'justice system' can find be set straight with inspiration from a good neighbour. As you say 'fringe cannot define a majority'. And by the way, just getting bored with platitudes... 😞
Bro this fringe phrase is applicable in Islam too ..... Good night
@@BobtheBuilder_786 Sikh texts do not promote violence or separatism... That's why Fringe doesn't define the norm here.. In Sikhism... Don't put everything else in the same bracket.. The contribution by Sikhs to India - is immense !
There is a famous saying " if you want to invade India , you have to first invade Punjab Sikhs became a synonym of army.
As far I remember Indian government never declared him a terrorist.
Born Sikh, brought up in HR and then a major part of life in PB. Now living in HP. I appreciate this clear cut conversation about JSBhindranwala. Posters on cars, on T shirts, on few days in a year haven't changed and wouldn't change anything. I hope young blood would understand this.
Himachl m kha rehte ho
@@shubhamchoudhary9528 I live in Kangra and you? I teach French language.
@@anonymousrequests3427 kangra se me bhi hu. Jawalii
Tu sikh family paidaa nhi hoyaaa , bht kuch change hoyegaa puttar, sant ji dillan vich aa, tu tutte choose jaa,bakvass kardaa ,aap kisse jehe naa gal karnu rehe naa
@@amrinderbajwa2813 Sir, the language and aggression you use portrays the failure of education and upbringing. I really don't need a Sikh Certificate from you. I pity your ignorance and incapability to hold a amicable conversation. My home is still there in Mohali. Nothing has changed. Our CM has failed the trust of PB. And people of your likes get quota just for votes.
There was a tradition in Punjab where the first son of the Hindu Katri family was made a Sikh and dedicated to the Army. There was a good amount of sacrifice by the mothers to make them Sikhs. Also, their history is tied to India as guardians of the nation. Hope they understand and don't axe their own history, brothers and sacrifice that has gone into it.
@The Best Moviess respect the turban, if it was not for those who sacrificed themselves for motherland, you probably would have been a kid of a mughal
@@cheesebagel736 brother he is not even Indian they're Pakistani trying to break us
@The Best Moviess Turban is an Indian tradition. Many parts of India such as Rajasthan, UP Gujrat people wear turban. In north Indian wedding the groom and the male members wear turban. You are shamelessly denigrating your own traditions because you are insecure.
@@tritikshabaghel8617 you can check his subscription list.He is clearly a RSS guy.
@@inder9781 bro...hote u kuch assholes sab dharm m....ye bhi h humare m...ab Kya kre
God bless India 🇮🇳 🙏 ❤️ 🇫🇯 🇫🇯 🇫🇯
As a Canadian I can say Justin Trudeau is a complete embarrassment to Canada.
Woah!! We needed you to cover this!!🔥🙏🏻
@赵杨利Yang lee Zhao world know you China😂😂...
All the sikhs watching this i will say we love u as Indian and have always respected sikhs for their dedication and patriotism in the Indian Army. Please be united with the one an only Nation that is India 🇮🇳🙏
LOVE TO KHALISTAN.
My question is If army can do operation blue star and operation woodRose on Bhindrawale and supporters,Why don't Army did Similar operation on Rioters who were killing Innocents Sikhs(killed 4000 innocent Sikhs only in Delhi called Sikh Genocide) in November 1984.This is totally biased but true image of Indian Democracy towards Minorities.
@@inder9781 Congress government is the reason
@@inder9781 we also want justice for the killings of thousands of Non Sikhs Punjabis in Punjab during Khalistan terrorism. What was the reason?
@@SHIVAM-qe8uo can you provide any legitimate link,Any actual news report,any media news,any family members interviews of those thousands killings.
One simple question Pls share the FIR details which are lodged against Bhindrawala at the time of his death And one last thing Pls share videos in which Bhindrawala is asking for Khalistan
how is the movement dead in India? The Khalisatani flag was unfurled at the Red fort just a few days before this video dropped 😂
I am from Haryana and I am proud of my state but I live for my country and I will die for my country.❤️❤️❤️❤️
@ᏒᎯᎻᏬᏝ Yes you may be shocked but Haryana leads Punjab in per capita income, HDI, Wheat and Rice production, faster growing economy, no of soldiers in army and airforce, Medals won by athletes, Have cities such as Faridabad and Gurgaon.
@ᏒᎯᎻᏬᏝ Bata diya hamara man😂😂😂
WE from Andhra..We respect sikhs contribution to indian military..We have utmost respect..Jai hind
I m from visakhapatnam..
I am a proud indian sikh and embarrassed for these Khalistanis. They have no plan for a sustainable country. It’s all emotion
Excellent historical summary.
We all are indians, United we Dominate the world, United we are strong❤️
Yes WE Do.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh "United we stand divided we fall".
Salute To You 🙏Hare Krishn Hare RAM 🙏
Yeah United we stand like 1984 Sikh genocide right ?
@@babber2536 Why did that happen btw ? Cuz one Punjabi decided to kill our PM Indira Gandhi, just because she ordered the military to neutralise the khalistani millitants who were hiding in the Golden temple .
@@babber2536 Wrong my pakistani bro absolutely wrong ..the same way you Babbar Khalsa killed thousands of non sikh punjabies before 1984 was also wrong . But you who love to play victim card can not discuss those Babbar Khalsa activity which you have done in 1981 to 1983 against non sikh punjabies. Both were wrong difference was one was action and other was reaction . So stop playing a victim card and behave like a man . Talk about love and peace . And rest regarding Khalistan ..plz tak it in your dream cause in Your PUNNU and in Your Chawala has no power to touch even one inch of India;s Punjab. Chal hun Dafaa ho kanjaraa ithhoo..bloddy looser
@@babber2536 transistor bomb laa ke garibbaa nu maran wala aajj aaa gal kar raya wa...kakke symphony card khedna band Kar ..Appa sare ral mil ke rende ne taa appaa khush haaa...tu dudd che nimbuu naa paa...
Awesome narration particularly the end part
Indian sikhs are heart of India
Punjab is Khalsa, there is No khalistan. Never will be. Waheguru Ji Khalsa, waheguru ji futteh 💯⚔️🙏🏼🙏🏼
There was establishment of KHALISTAN two times before , This time it will be again , Khalistan ZINDABAAAAAD
Current Punjab is occupied by India , needs to be free
@Roshan Rajaraman it's occupied by India , The genocides and injustices and discrimination and rights of people of Punjab Livin under Indian occupation proves that all
@Sameet Pattnaik congress is the government of Punjab which was heavily supported by Hindus in majority , And still today about 45% Hindus supports congress in Panjab so that's one treating almost everyone as second class citizen and 3rd class in India
@@babber2536 Current Punjab is occupied by Pakistan