FOLLOW - 몬스타엑스 (MONSTA X) [뮤직뱅크 Music Bank] 20191101
Пікірлер
Jooheon 🥺😭 he looks like he’s been crying.
@farrahyoung16384 жыл бұрын
Shownu looks like he hasnt slept or stopped crying
@imarock87634 жыл бұрын
kbaby boo he probably couldn’t. Especially after that bish HSH said he made someone cheat on her husband
@wonhoscake12144 жыл бұрын
All of them... Poor guys
@normis66204 жыл бұрын
Like when they did Hyungwon's entrance all I could see was how shaky and heartbroken he looked
@brandiwilliams25334 жыл бұрын
they look so sad
@dari_sam15634 жыл бұрын
No smiles. You can see that they are in pain and are clearly not okay
@ralphds75824 жыл бұрын
They don’t have the same energy as they did before. Even though it’s a serious concept they look so unhappy to be there
@KIMIMUSIC4 жыл бұрын
They look as if they were forced to do this show :(
@kookie-py4 жыл бұрын
이때 재녹음하랴 동선 바꾸랴 정신적으로 육체적으로 정말 정상일 수가 없었을텐데 이 악물고 무대해줘서 정말 고맙단 말밖에... 넘어져도 꼭 다시 일어나겠단 말처럼 다시 일어나서 달려와서 결국 커하 찍었고 정말 멋져 앞으로 더더 행복하자
@user-qp9uq7mj1r3 жыл бұрын
앞으로 점점 더 커하 찍을거임 꼭 그렇게 될거야
@mercy40782 жыл бұрын
혹시 커하가 뭔가요??
@user-en1yq3fz3z2 жыл бұрын
@@user-en1yq3fz3z 커리어 하이 줄인거에용! 앨범을 지금까지 판거중에 제일 많이 팔았거나 음원순위 높을때 커하찍었다고 해여
@syenedittomrade2 жыл бұрын
정말 웃긴게 이슈로 이 노래 오히려 뜸 ㅋㅋ 남잔데 이때부터 입덕함
@user-on2os5kj9j2 жыл бұрын
하나도 안 웃기고 애틋한 활동 팔로우.. 진짜 명곡.. 정말 '이 악물고'.. 이 말 공감.정말 앞으로도! 더더 높이 넓이 오래오래~ ㅎㅎ함께 해줬으면 좋겠다 멋진 사람들
@user-jh8qs8tg6n2 жыл бұрын
몬엑이들이 살벌한 돌판에서 커하 찍을 수 있었던 건 저 독함...진짜 본받고 싶음 내돌이라서가 아니라 한 인간으로써 진짜 본받고싶다...우리애들보면 인생 열심히 살고 싶게 만듬....진짜 사랑을 넘어선 동경이야 다시한번 깨닫는다 아이돌은 극한직업이다
@eh3uxhru3j Жыл бұрын
It feels so wrong watching them as just 6 cant imagine how they feel
@baekhyuniee27764 жыл бұрын
I really wanna cry :( This broke my heart in many many pieces
@LorenitaEV4 жыл бұрын
Even in the beginning I was kind of waiting for Wonho to show up
@Xan11204 жыл бұрын
And it's because of this girl. Ughh I want to see her burn in hell
@endive75624 жыл бұрын
Ikr :(
@eriel2644 жыл бұрын
Anger and sadness, that’s what I see in their eyes.
@meral_k4 жыл бұрын
I know right...
@deeevilyin66664 жыл бұрын
보면 개빡치는 영상 1위 한쳐먹게 되는 영상 1위임 새벽까지 녹음하고 동선 맞춰서 흠잡을거 하나 없는데 여기가 아쉽다 저기가 아쉽다 평가절하했던 그 팬들 절대 못 잊음ㅋㅋㅋ 6명 전부다 너무 잘해줘서 고마워 우리야 보는 입장이니까 마음 아프고 말지만 본인들이 무대에 서겠다고 마음먹기까지 무슨 생각이였는지 아무도 가늠 못할거야 무대 서줘서 고마워
@user-ur7qf9rp8z3 жыл бұрын
대체 누가 그랬어요? 아니 팬이란 사람들이 대체 무슨...
@violettea62733 жыл бұрын
ㅇㅈ… 그때 진짜 환멸났었음.. 다 기억함..
@Moksuunnieya3 ай бұрын
ㅠㅠㅠㅠ늦베베는 정말 얘기만 들어도 가슴이 철렁..... 하루만에 그걸 다해따고요...? 하
@im.babykitty3 ай бұрын
어떻게.. 이날 무대를 세웠냐 진짜 다들 낯빛이 잿빛이네
@user-jv7xq6qo9y4 жыл бұрын
this is the saddest comeback live I've ever watched
@vnssaa97924 жыл бұрын
Same
@meggy63004 жыл бұрын
rt
@carinaantunes26574 жыл бұрын
😭
@elxdieem4 жыл бұрын
Same :( there is no enthusiasm
@laviender4 жыл бұрын
Same
@Bananajaem134 жыл бұрын
This was one of the most heartbreaking videos of 2019.....
@btsvtskztxtateezbp55544 жыл бұрын
BTSVTSKZ TXTATEEZBP I agree
@loveforsunoo4 жыл бұрын
Ik. Non of the other groups with departed members have made a comeback. There’s just came out on Monday
@Sunset-um5vo4 жыл бұрын
I agree
@xitlalitucker79824 жыл бұрын
It literally is. Like I cried in the intro.
@nanagoingcrayyyy4 жыл бұрын
몬베베들 없이 비공개 사녹...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ많이 힘들었을텐데 무대 너무 잘해줘서 고맙고 진짜 사랑한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@dol_jumeok4 жыл бұрын
아그래요ㅠ다들참아픈시갼이 저안에있네ㅜ
@jpg-np5xl2 жыл бұрын
몬엑을 얼굴밖에 모르던 시절 이때 사건 뉴스에 뜬거보고 ‘아 또 한그룹 난리났구만’하고 그냥 넘겼는데 이젠 애들 표정만 보고도 독기를 한가득 품고 무대 끝마치기위해서 노력했다는게 보여서 마음이…미어진다 미어져…
@Love_Me_tight Жыл бұрын
I can tell that everyone has been crying. Look at their eyes.......
@somchaisweetly52134 жыл бұрын
Yup
@minhyukismxskey72864 жыл бұрын
Yeah. Eyes don't lie~
@ensiklofidia4 жыл бұрын
Their eyes were all at least somewhat puffy and I cant blame them cause I've been bawling my eyes out too
@4mb3rj434 жыл бұрын
Yeah it seemed to me the same
@modis_omar4 жыл бұрын
I agree with you 😔
@juwairiyahthofani5514 жыл бұрын
You can see how hurt they are when you look them in the eyes ...it’s just so sad, upsetting and unfair that all of this had to happen like this
@jujum61314 жыл бұрын
Yes it was an absolute soulless performance
@samrobot64 жыл бұрын
Norhane M. Salah completely agree
@jujum61314 жыл бұрын
What happened to wonho i'm so dizzy
@user-oq1dr2pe1e4 жыл бұрын
@@user-oq1dr2pe1e he left the group 😞
@rednatsdlog99444 жыл бұрын
Some people (including a girl which was involved in a lot of rumors and lawsuits earlier this year and literally ever) have brought up some things, wonho was allegedly involved in, that happened yeaaars ago (some of them where right some of them their entertainment ‘starship’ denied)so he left the group out of his own will not thinking about himself but more of the image he would leave on the group as a whole if he stayed
@jujum61314 жыл бұрын
이건 진짜 대단하다는 말 밖엔..다들 보통 멘탈이 아니다..몬엑을 깊게 안지 얼마 안됐지만 인트로 표정만 봐도 평소랑 너무 달라서 흠칫함ㅠㅠ 실시간으로 모든걸 겪었을 저 순간의 몬엑과 몬베베들 너무 고생많았어...
@user-px2ph9en2u2 жыл бұрын
다들 평소에 비해 어두워보여 마음이 아프다ㅜㅜㅜ 하지만서두 다들 너무 프로라서 딱 봤을 때 무대가 거의 완벽함 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ follow는 특히 안무가 대박인듯 ...
@kuromi83263 жыл бұрын
안무 너무 멋있음
@iamground. Жыл бұрын
When you can see their swollen eyes, the anger in their dance, and the pain of losing a brother on stage. Shownu lost so much weight his cheeks are gone too. I can’t watch this anymore.
@evetong53024 жыл бұрын
The sadness in their eyes
@kyuyeon44964 жыл бұрын
When I first saw them arrive, I saw how sad they were, I.M looked so sad..
@ilikeshippingwaytoomuch83684 жыл бұрын
It ain't that deep
@msuarz66664 жыл бұрын
@@msuarz6666 The guys literally spent the past four years close together after a harsh time in a survival show. It really IS that deep. They basically lost a brother.
@WreathStorm4 жыл бұрын
920921 it literally is though
@hwaseongs4 жыл бұрын
STARSHIP, YOU LET THEM PERFORM AMIDST THIS CHAOS THAT'S HAPPENING??!! COULDN'T YOU SEE THAT THEY ARE SAD ABOUT WONHO'S DEPARTURE?!
@asu_chae4 жыл бұрын
It was prerecorded
@lindamarie54254 жыл бұрын
@@lindamarie5425 but wonho is still missing...
@francinelove9574 жыл бұрын
@@lindamarie5425 wth are u saying it's not pre-recorded. if it's pre-recorded, wonho still there duh
@leedokyeomsvt4 жыл бұрын
@@lindamarie5425 it's still after Wonho left and that's not ok
@GloomyMarshmallow4 жыл бұрын
@ggotee pre-recorded or not, they still perform today isn't it? so it's after wonho departure
@leedokyeomsvt4 жыл бұрын
유기현 독기 진짜,,, 무너지지마 절대
@musicyoutube76193 жыл бұрын
늦베베 되어서 이제 보니까 진짜 기현이 눈빛에 독기 장난 아니네. 잘 버텨줘서 고맙다
@minahhan2 жыл бұрын
*Do you wish to delete 2019?* *yes.*
@ParkJimin-jl4vw4 жыл бұрын
Park Jimin definitely more than anything
@childofchrist52834 жыл бұрын
I would sell my soul for this
@lous36474 жыл бұрын
Yesss💔
@roma70374 жыл бұрын
Yes OFC!!!!!!! 😔
@adelamelissa58164 жыл бұрын
Park Jimin absolutely!!
@rosemonstaxwonbebe10744 жыл бұрын
Kihyun’s eyes really look like he just had a tough cry
@joongshin94444 жыл бұрын
Joong Shin he probably did........😭
@HK-bl5uf4 жыл бұрын
Yeah I can see that I’m soo sad 😞 I really that girl for ruining their life and also STARSHIP for not able to handle it properly
@leenye-un69404 жыл бұрын
They all look (the most at the beginning) really tired... and sad, I guess..
@hereisNana4 жыл бұрын
와....엠카 컴백무대 보고 이거 다시보니까 원호 파트를 전부 기현이가 했네......유기현 진짜 독기 장난아니다
@levres3131 Жыл бұрын
입덕하고 보니 맴아픈 무대...
@GIGI_703 жыл бұрын
2222
@violettea62733 жыл бұрын
I cried when wonho left imagine how hurt they are right now can we rewind back in time? 😔
@user-tk6ev1xt9w4 жыл бұрын
Why did he left? Did I miss something
@zkashbeauty4 жыл бұрын
Zkash Beauty yeah he left Monsta x yesterday :(
@sewphy3334 жыл бұрын
@@zkashbeauty if you search up his statement you can find it and it broke my heart
@-shine-77804 жыл бұрын
@@zkashbeauty but I think theres some stuff now happening to do with shownu as well
@-shine-77804 жыл бұрын
Just read!!! Its heartbreaking. Stay strong monobies. Love from EXO-L
@zkashbeauty4 жыл бұрын
*googles* how to delete 2019 out of world history
@seliny.13064 жыл бұрын
Aa türk mdksnďkdndnkdns
@tucetucee4 жыл бұрын
I mean not the comebacks, just the bad memories
@melkab47654 жыл бұрын
Yes!!!! 2019 has not been kind to the kpop world
@Akivi934 жыл бұрын
🇹🇷💜
@armyaslelif90624 жыл бұрын
살은 다들 쭉 빠져버렸는데 눈은 부어서... 마음 아프다
@user-ms3xu3xc3n3 жыл бұрын
바로 전날 엠카에선 7명으로 무대 서놓고 다음날 6명으로 다시 녹음하고 동선바꿔 무대 선 몬스타엑스.... 늦베베라 이때 당시 팬들 멤버들 심정 모르지만 진짜 어떻게 하루만에 그걸... 그때 녹음하고 동선 연습하면서 무슨 생각 했을지 감히 상상도 안됨
@im.babykitty3 ай бұрын
Remember when I.M said 2019 is gonna be Monsta X year? ...
@belomettinavyy10684 жыл бұрын
True...
@annelise010404 жыл бұрын
It's not cause they are so sad and it's the worst year ever for them cause they have lost a brother and a member wonho so ....😭
@choimika3254 жыл бұрын
Oh...yes
@Emma_214 жыл бұрын
2019 was so close to being their year 😭 they only had 2 months left to call it their year. 😭😭
@ryder37hehe4 жыл бұрын
I can't believe starship actually made them perform without Wonho, I mean it's been just one day after the news, at least let them process what is going on :(
@karennaranjo10404 жыл бұрын
exactly
@felina91874 жыл бұрын
Ikrr I was shocked when I saw a performance that came out today
@heehee61134 жыл бұрын
True!! They look so sad here 😔
@yimdiw62364 жыл бұрын
Istg for a second i thought this was done earlier WITH wonho bcs i never thought they'd ACTUALLY fo it without him and TOO SOON
@charijma4 жыл бұрын
i agree:'(
@althafizhdeimonputra33244 жыл бұрын
와…전날 엠카는 7명서 하고 바로 다음날 다 수정해서 무대 선거구나.. 진짜 대박 다들 마음 진짜 안좋을텐데 무대 하는거 보니까 내 기분이 묘하네
@LookMJ2 жыл бұрын
늦베베라 그 일 때는 몬엑에 관심 아예 없었고 그 사건에도 전혀 신경안쓰고 넘겼음 근디 입덕하고 나서 이 영상, 이 날짜 보니까 아 괜히 싱숭생숭하고 다른 영상들처럼 헤헤 거리면서 볼수가 없네
@user-jf1tl4eq9d3 жыл бұрын
No man. I’m honestly crying. 2019 doesn’t count as a year in my life
@st4yla394 жыл бұрын
Chaela Dance it's just music chill
@emmafrostnr.1fan6624 жыл бұрын
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 it has nothing to do with song but a misfortune within the group.
@unicorncrossing63764 жыл бұрын
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 It's not when you stan a group you stan people not just the music
@lalaforeverxxx4 жыл бұрын
Music and movies(theater) are made to entertain us ✌️ whatever they do or whatever drama they bring I'm just gonna enjoy their "work" ☺️ IT'S 👏 NOT 👏 THAT 👏 DEEP 👏
@emmafrostnr.1fan6624 жыл бұрын
well ok snow flake
@emmafrostnr.1fan6624 жыл бұрын
Is it only me who thinks that they r mad and sad at the same time?
@seyeon61844 жыл бұрын
Of course they are...they lost a precious member/friend😔
@ninikim47284 жыл бұрын
Wonho Lee hes not dead lmao chill, they can still be friends
@damnitaintright4 жыл бұрын
@@damnitaintright I will give you chill... He is "gone" from the group because of false allegations some stupid idiot made cuz she was mad YG dropped her...
@tessagrey16564 жыл бұрын
@@damnitaintright I know he is not dead,i meant that they lost him cus he left,you can chill too and of course they are mad
@ninikim47284 жыл бұрын
@@tessagrey1656 they need to stop giving her attention then she will make a louder noise but eventually leave bbecause thats the only reason she doing this, her parents didnt give her attention so she getting it somewhere else
@markramsey24544 жыл бұрын
진짜 이 악물고 한게 보여ㅠㅠㅠ 보면볼수록 프로답다 너무 멋있어 힘냈구나ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@spaik7713 жыл бұрын
아제발 몬스타엑스 분들 30대에도 활동 해주세요 이렇게만 쭉 갑시다
@teav81444 жыл бұрын
현 30대 이렇게 활동중임미다 히히
@im.babykitty3 ай бұрын
This feels wrong ... 2019 feels horrible.
@abahacuun54134 жыл бұрын
solar solar this feels very wrong, they look so down...
@haven99624 жыл бұрын
solar solar stays you guys are so strong I love you guys🥺
@monbebe4ever4944 жыл бұрын
It's what i felt throughout the video😔😔😔
@houseofplayboys64134 жыл бұрын
Stan Monsta x Thank you, us stays really just want what's best for Straykids, but honestly this week has been really hard on us all... I'm actually also a monbebe ( even tho straykids is my Ulta) seeing all this happen at once with wonho leaving too hurts. But in our situation we knew that straykids was hurting just as much (more) than us... So as their true fans it's our responsibility to make sure we are always by their side (just like how they are to us) I hope other monbebes are ok... It's gonna be a rough road to cross, but you'll get there *promise💕😉*
@abahacuun54134 жыл бұрын
2019 has been the worst 🥺 Wonho leaves MonstaX, Woojin left Stray Kids, and Hwall leaves The Boyz I miss them 🥺💖💞💘
@jess-tk5ux4 жыл бұрын
Jooheon’s face at the end says it all 😔
@Kris10Banci4 жыл бұрын
kris10manuel yeah :c they all look so unhappy...
@Xan11204 жыл бұрын
Given what has happened they still have a good performance. Gotta give them a round of applause for holding it together.
@kelleythompson71934 жыл бұрын
kihyun looks M A D mad tho
@yuyukit4 жыл бұрын
Kelley Thompson they danced it to the Tee i agree but their facial expressions just hurt me... pretty sure they’ve been crying too
@Kris10Banci4 жыл бұрын
I want to still be here to support them it’s just so hard without WH there
@Kris10Banci4 жыл бұрын
나는 그일 있고나서 애들 막 돌리길래 주헌이가 웃는게 정말 좋아서 웃는게 아니라고 생각이 들고나서부터 뭔일 나겠구나 했더니 아니나 다를까 주헌이 활동중단.. 다른 멤버들도 멘탈적으로 체력적으로 다 함들었을텐데 오히려 본인들이 활동하겠다고 한게 더 멋있고 마음이 아프다..그래도 지금 괜찮아진거같아서 다행이지만 힘들땐 쉬어가자..사랑한다 몬스타엑스❤️
Am I the only one who has like an empty feeling watching this? 😔
@themultistan4 жыл бұрын
i feel the same bruh . . neomu apa
@rafaelasis91644 жыл бұрын
I keep seeing the empty spot 😭😭
@SA-nm1lm4 жыл бұрын
Same and you can tell the boys felt it too they weren't even trying to put on the best show which is completely understandable I wouldn't want to perform if one of my members/bestfriend/brother is going through such a tough time but you can tell especially with jooheon and I.M . My poor babys man... im pissed
@barbzwired4 жыл бұрын
This is the worst thing ever, their eyes can't lied they are having so much pain.
@esperanzarivera5184 жыл бұрын
I am literally crying
@debjaniguha34204 жыл бұрын
Fortunately "Follow" is a kind of fierce song so they wouldn't have to fake smile but the eyes can't lie either .....
@hanienz60724 жыл бұрын
They were forced 😭
@ceyujin4 жыл бұрын
They look so broken, it so sad to witness
@normis66204 жыл бұрын
**This is just my view on this video. ** To me after that stage it looks like they had no choice but to perform. It looks like there hearts and souls were gone with Wonho. No emotion at all like I will just sing the song and dance the dance but the emotions are nonexistent. I honestly think they shouldn't have performed at all then. Give them time to work on themselves and the whole issue first. Performances are nice to watch but this was painful to see there eyes so dead. **Remember that this is just my opinion!! But I will still support Monsta X and Wonho and the rest of the members too.**
@unbreakablevow13504 жыл бұрын
최근 입덕하고 거슬러올라가는 중인데 당시에 팬들 마음이 어땠을지 댓글만봐도 알겠다
@violettea62733 жыл бұрын
진짜 눈에 독기 가득이다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이 힘든걸 어떻게 하고 어떻게 견뎠을까ㅠㅠㅠ
@haha_ho12342 жыл бұрын
kihyun and jooheon look like they're shaking with anger honestly.
@nonarygame4 жыл бұрын
and maknae I.M looks depressed...
@ilikeshippingwaytoomuch83684 жыл бұрын
@@ilikeshippingwaytoomuch8368 i can't imagine how hard he's taking this, changkyun loves his hyung. we'll make things right though, it'll be okay.
@nonarygame4 жыл бұрын
What part?
@lightsforsan65174 жыл бұрын
*True*
@nicolealiten12674 жыл бұрын
No they not
@LeonLove-si6gw4 жыл бұрын
Literally the first time I can’t feel their energy through the screen TT
@wxhcbjl4 жыл бұрын
Exactly.
@oikawasmilkbread22054 жыл бұрын
Yeah 💔💔💔
@ari_03284 жыл бұрын
그래도 무대 서겠다고했을때 그 마음이 어땠을까 진짜...
@user-yd7pv7np4y3 жыл бұрын
These boys are trying so hard to make monbebe happy and the amount of people saying they're not monsta x without wonho upsets me. Monbebe should be cheering them on and encouraging them. Obviously loosing Wonho is incredibly hard on them..they dont need us to flood their social media reminding them. The rest of the vocal line did an amazing job covering Wonho's parts on such short notice. Be the support Monsta X needs monbebe! I'm so proud of them for how hard they're working through this!!
@DeeDarlingX_4 жыл бұрын
@@ElevenForti I never said anything about forgetting Wonho? All I said was nothing but supportive towards the members. At least that was my intent. If you felt otherwise, I would say you misunderstood my words. I've supported monsta x for years and seen them live many times. I want nothing but happiness and support for these hard working boys.
@DeeDarlingX_4 жыл бұрын
When Kihyun started singing Wonho's part I felt that 😢😢😢
@itz_eyshayo92714 жыл бұрын
😭😭😭
@Steplly4 жыл бұрын
Their eyes show how sad they are. But they're trying to hide it.
@airasuhh3264 жыл бұрын
Well... It isn't working...
@Mixiearts4 жыл бұрын
@Baby Dragon wonho is not more a part of the group
@domelen4 жыл бұрын
You can tell all of them have been crying ... Those bitches really got away with what they did and that's what has me livid
@barbzwired4 жыл бұрын
@Baby Dragon Cuz Wonho left the group. He left because of a girl named Han Seo Hee, who accused him of ownign her money and, cuz of this, he received lots of hate from knitizens, and then, he's being also accused of using marijuana. His contract with Starship was finished, without any of these things being proofed to be truth
@Mixiearts4 жыл бұрын
2:00 랩 미쳤다 ..남자아이돌 무대는 젝키랑 HOT 후로 끊었는데..ㅎㅎ이친구들은 대단하네 다들 실력파인 듯. 랩과 보컬이 아주 훌륭.. 노래좋고 춤 멋지네. 더 승승장구하길 바랍니다
@MsLeesangsoo4 жыл бұрын
나 이거 이제 볼수 있네...그때 너무 힘들어서 팔로우활동 못봤어
@user-uc9pk4jf4b3 жыл бұрын
Kihyun covering Wonhos part is heartbreaking :(
@an82024 жыл бұрын
Its the most hesrtbreaking part of the song hmmm feels like crying
@majalipio4 жыл бұрын
I cant even watch this without crying i miss wonho 💔💔
@katethomas33654 жыл бұрын
The only thing I see is how broken they are and this makes me cry
@noahbellavia2224 жыл бұрын
Jimin’s Bae yes, same
@begumi.4 жыл бұрын
same 😔
@user-im6xi4ch5f4 жыл бұрын
In JESUS name everything will be ok 😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏
@mgisvrich36274 жыл бұрын
처음 등장할 때 멤버들 얼굴이 너무 부어있어서 이 무대는 진짜 못보겠다ㅜㅜ 지금까지 함께 하고 있는 것 자체로 너무 고맙고 더 바랄게 없어ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@lalasweet10153 жыл бұрын
그동안 맘 아파서 못보다가 보는데 다시보니까 애들 눈빛하며 표정하며 독기가 가득 차 있는거 보고 눈물 왈칵이다 진짜..
@txtxxtx78332 жыл бұрын
they all look so frustrated and done, the way starship handled this situation was awful at least give the members some time to recover.
@myrrahshapoo82544 жыл бұрын
it feels they are performing without a soul their faces shows how painful this is for them
@lilyshinki48964 жыл бұрын
Right
@ihavedonemybest16544 жыл бұрын
Lily Shinki looks like you can tell they were crying beforehand in the beginning
@supermiiemiie53524 жыл бұрын
their eyes tell everything.
@hunter75364 жыл бұрын
Their faces look puffy like they have been crying... They also look angry
@zarav7314 жыл бұрын
마음이 박박 찢어지는데도 너무 잘생겨서 그와중에 너무 좋음....ㅠㅠㅠㅠ얘들아 사랑해....
@user-zu2ny1uv3d Жыл бұрын
this doesn’t even look like Monsta X, it makes me cry 😭😭😭
@danielagarcia21164 жыл бұрын
I'm crying when kihyun singing wonho part 😭
@miftahulhasibuan2384 жыл бұрын
Me too😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 cuz he my bias
@armsoal4ever5204 жыл бұрын
You can see the anger, sadness in their eyes. Starship this is wrong. Being human is normal, being perfect is toxic~
@KATIE-ne9gh4 жыл бұрын
mUlTi fAnDoM he was accused of stealing stuff, though. If it's true, it's not just "being human" it's a crime.
@mariahbd83654 жыл бұрын
monbebe i beg yall to not reply to this troll^^^ and yeah it's heartbreaking seeing the boys like this as if they just got done crying.
@AzulGlare4 жыл бұрын
It's not "being normal human" by refusing to pay debt and stealing stuff lmfao.
@linhttm584 жыл бұрын
he was fully prepared to pay back the debt and everything she wanted. in the texts released his lawyer wanted to meet up and to negotiate. but instead of doing that, they decided to spread rumors about him and his bandmates. please get your information right and check the sources. as for whatever crime he committed, he served his time. i'm not saying he was right, i'm saying he might have changed. this was almost a decade ago and he has since not been charged for any offences whatsoever. i'm not a monbebe and thus not as clear on the situation, but i know enough to not dismiss him as a criminal. why are they releasing all thus information now? why didn't they just settle things with him and his lawyer instead of publicizing it? it's clearly a ploy to drag monsta x and wonho knows it, which is why he left.
@rebellerene4 жыл бұрын
It wasn’t just starship it was so wonhos choice
@StarLost964 жыл бұрын
이것만보면눈물난다...고생많았어진짜..
@miles_43593 жыл бұрын
Anyone crying at how they even had the 7th area in the middle but no one came out and it was a different color than the others :( My heart goes out to all the monbebes monteen forever
@soapsaps5314 жыл бұрын
IM I THE ONLY ONE THAT' CANT FEEL THE ENERGY OF THIS SONG ANYMORE
@crazyformyself78004 жыл бұрын
I agree
@tawandacampbell73654 жыл бұрын
You're not alone
@Nane-wm4sx4 жыл бұрын
the song symbolizes a devastating time for the group and Monbebes.. even though the contract is terminated I feel as though we all should keep fighting to get Wonho back. This whole situation is uncalled for and unfair.
@Punkcherry4 жыл бұрын
yoongi's shootdance same
@lizbethbeltran59174 жыл бұрын
Yes, not only you because I can’t either. It’s not Monsta X’s stage presence. 💔
@user-gc4pr5lm2n4 жыл бұрын
basic math 7-1=0 monsta x has 7 members, one is missing then its not monsta x
@yananismyboy62634 жыл бұрын
Yesss, trueee 12-1=0 (hwall) Missing one is not the boyz 9-1=0 (woojin) Missing one is not straykids 7-1=0 (BI) Missing one is not ikon
@valenciaeunike45634 жыл бұрын
@@valenciaeunike4563 we think the same dw!!
@yananismyboy62634 жыл бұрын
😢
@kesiadiniz90104 жыл бұрын
I've obviously been learning the wrong math because this is the truest thing I've seen all my life.
@sweetjojoba4 жыл бұрын
@Jkyun We aren't dissrespect what they are doing! But, are you suggesting that you don't want wonho back?
@yananismyboy62634 жыл бұрын
어떤 마음으로 섰던 무대일까 감히 짐작도 못해보겠다.. 대단하고 또 대단해 진짜.. 그럼에도 버텨주어서, 늦었지만 너희들을 알아볼 수 있는 기회를 주어서 정말 고맙다. 진짜 고생 많았을텐데..ㅠㅠㅜ 오래보자 더더욱. 오래 보고 싶다
@josim_sss2 жыл бұрын
의상 개예쁘다 그걸 또 찰떡같이 소화하고 안무도 좋고 노래좋고 몬엑무대 다 좋아하지만 팔로우무대가 제일 본새쩔음 완전 내서타일
@user-id5143 жыл бұрын
Forcing these men to perform in this kind of situation is pure cruelty.
@marialuizamota52714 жыл бұрын
Welcome to the kpop industry 💔
@priceymashups76924 жыл бұрын
@@priceymashups7692 I know!! We continue to support our favorite groups/idols exclusively because of them! All these companies can go to hell tbh 💔
@marialuizamota52714 жыл бұрын
yup i feel them
@nursyamimi59374 жыл бұрын
@@priceymashups7692 it's not the kpop industry it's business. they company put out money and want to make the returns off of it as soon as possible
@romanHederer4 жыл бұрын
i dont think they are being "forced"... but we have to understand that they work really hard for everything... this events were already schedule.. they cant just drop everything.... i believe that everything happens for a reason... lets just suport them Monsta X as 6 and Wonho ...
@QueziaJones4 жыл бұрын
I can't believe that a song like this makes me cry.
@sally94364 жыл бұрын
I can feel u
@ihavedonemybest16544 жыл бұрын
늦덕 후회공인데 진짜 눈물난다ㅠㅠㅠ 스타쉽 제정신이냐고 다음날에...
@dainsong993 жыл бұрын
저두요..
@user-jq8fw9ep6t3 жыл бұрын
애들이 하겠다고 한겁니다. 상황이 이랬지만 남들에게 이슈때 더 열심히 해서 빛을 봤죠..애들이 현명했다고 생각해요 마음은 아프지만
@user-rm1lm1rm6d3 жыл бұрын
근데 진짜 이 당시 팬들이랑 몬엑 심정은 직접 겪어보지 않는이상 절대 모를거같음 그만큼 엄청 잔인하고 힘들었음..나도 입덕 한지 얼마 안되고 첫 컴백이 팔로우였는데 그때 든 생각이 몇년동안 함께 해왔던 팬들이랑 몬엑은 오죽할까 싶더라..이 시기가 있었기에 지금의 몬엑이 있는거같음 정말 대단하고 자랑스럽고 수고했다고 말해주고싶당
@txtxxtx78332 жыл бұрын
They just look sad and angry- and the intro they clearly had just finished crying. 💔
@esulsmith10424 жыл бұрын
Kihyun singing Wonho’s part totally broke my heart. I can’t imagine how they are getting through this.
@lillaboo81124 жыл бұрын
I cried when not hearing WonHo's voice at the first part. I am even thinking They are all sad but tried so hard for Monbebes to be Ok😭😭😭
@leanmalabuyoc81154 жыл бұрын
Mine too. I feel you. This situation is so sad and hard. On top of that Wonho was my bias. I chose him after thinking so hard. And now... He's gone. I hope he comes back.
@fauzanree19834 жыл бұрын
맘 아파서 도저히 끝까지 못보겠다..
@user-gt9cb2cd4k3 жыл бұрын
정말 독기 품은 눈들... 대견하다 얘들아. 고맙고
@user-xw8wu5dd6z3 жыл бұрын
You can see the sadness in their eyes. This is wrong
@Anna-in7xy4 жыл бұрын
Trueee 😭😭😭
@alex_skzismyhome4 жыл бұрын
I can tell all of them have been crying.. my heart hurts
@lyalways86124 жыл бұрын
I have seen two performances of follow and this performance is for me false😭
@anna-mariakonig40394 жыл бұрын
I'm crying, it's not even a joke, I'm really sitting here crying. I can't imagine how difficult it must've been to perform.
@SuperCupcakeeee4 жыл бұрын
I think is because about Wonho left? Or am I wrong?
@xiuliz4 жыл бұрын
They are performing yes but there is no soul, no energy, no happiness on the stage, this is just a force!
@bahanurceylan87474 жыл бұрын
Yes exactly and it is just so sad
@samrobot64 жыл бұрын
Norhane M. Salah Yes, it is even hurting much more than truth
@bahanurceylan87474 жыл бұрын
Yes, i can feel it ㅠㅠ
@nyeongan19114 жыл бұрын
Starship seems like doesn't care at all
@shanon12174 жыл бұрын
@@shanon1217 I know it's sad but they need to do it because it is still a work that needs to be done, they need to be professional.
@astrospear4 жыл бұрын
그냥 행복하던 순간 멤버가 뜯겨져 나가서 그냥 모두가 벙쪘고.. 그때 팬덤은 진짜.. 😅 지금은 유입도 많이 생기고 많이 나아졌는데 옛날 팬덤 반이 까빠(?) 일 정도로 할 말 않할 말 구별 못하는 사람들 넘 많았음… 특히 트위터 네임드;; 암튼 지금은 다들 모두 행복하고 사적으로도 친한 건 여전하고 멤버들 행복해진 것 같아서 보기 좋음..
@Moksuunnieya3 ай бұрын
빅뱅 다음으로 좋아하게된 그룹,,,,,,,
@user-ld7zg9il9f3 жыл бұрын
Shownu looks too thin, Joohoney looks so angry, and Changkyunnie looks so depressed. I’m really hurting for these boys right now.
@rebeccajohnson9014 жыл бұрын
And minhyuk looks so minhyuk like always...
@Boo-xp7sx4 жыл бұрын
I mean to be honest, this is heartbreaking. Joohoneyy looks like he has cried to much and he eyes was clearly red.
@xiuliz4 жыл бұрын
don’t forget to notice kihyun’s eyes..
@nabila.45064 жыл бұрын
in the face he looks thin, but on his body it’s the black. black tends to make people look skinnier
@yourmomshouse7794 жыл бұрын
I just don’t see that energy, starship u r so cruel
@jaquelinepv4 жыл бұрын
Exactly...my heart is broken💔💔
@supripandey85814 жыл бұрын
It's not starship fault
@MrBerrator4 жыл бұрын
it's not starship
@alen11744 жыл бұрын
Starship didn't do anything
@Nope_ihtt4 жыл бұрын
Fyi wonho didn’t even discuss with starship and the members so it’s none of their fault. It’s wonhos choice
@wxhcbjl4 жыл бұрын
나도 이 당시엔 팬 아니었는데 지금 입덕하고 보니 이때 잘 버텨줘서 너무 대견하고 고맙다 난 걍 이렇게 6명이 좋음
@elliei756511 ай бұрын
갠적으로 이 무대 인트로부터 좋아..
@user-on2os5kj9j4 жыл бұрын
There's no smile , there's no enjoying there's no fanchant that was really hurt.... that wa really quiet 😭
@devianadka54274 жыл бұрын
Deviana Dka the reason there were no fan chants is because they didn’t allow Monbebe’s in the building.
@cassiea.35424 жыл бұрын
I'm crying right now T_T
@Shironoichi4 жыл бұрын
not even shocked i wouldn't have been able to chant either
@agustdankk27844 жыл бұрын
hyungwon looked like he was about to cry when he first appeared
@Patty-vg5ow4 жыл бұрын
They all look emotionally exhausted
@plattagon85324 жыл бұрын
팔로우 무대는 볼때마다 멋지지만 맴찢
@nunu84014 жыл бұрын
팔로우 무대 볼때마다 내 마음이 너무 공허해... 전 날 엠카였는데... 그날 밤에 감정을 다 정리하고 몬베베 슬픈 걸 알았고 무대에서 그 슬픈 감정 보여주지 않고 그냥 3분만에 몬베베들 위해 행복한 시간이 만들어주고 싶은 우리 몬엑 진짜 다단하고 사랑해. 호석이도 고생많았다...
@aaa.a1232 жыл бұрын
2019 really is a joke, this just hurts
@le0xx4 жыл бұрын
yeah,it's hurt so much
@sweethanie67134 жыл бұрын
hurts so much
@pinkypiggy04 жыл бұрын
Yeah.... all my favorite groups are just falling apart and I can't do anything but stand on the side lines and watch it happen.
@halieuwu91484 жыл бұрын
@クリームCream both them as well
@JT936413 жыл бұрын
These boys did their max here, they are really brave to get through the whole song, but we all know and feel without Wonho its incomplete simple as that. Please bring Wonho back to his members he belongs here. His private life has nothing to do with Monsta X. This is crazy!
@btsforme4 жыл бұрын
Sadly, image is everything in Korea.
@lonefaith99624 жыл бұрын
정말 이시간..이때가 몬베베로서 제일힘든시간이었는데...이무대보고 나도 정신이번쩍했었음...우리 몬엑도 견디는데 내가견뎌야지생각했던시간이었음... 솔직히 그 멤버의 팬이었지만 지금은 몬엑의팬이되었음..못 잃어..나의 몬스타엑스♥지금도 많이 응원해♥
@user-xc1vi9qz4y11 ай бұрын
정말 몬엑은ᆢ지난 3~ 4년간 지켜봐왔지만 정말 대단하고 존경심이 드는 그룹ᆢ
@user-up5up5zu3e2 жыл бұрын
who else cried their eyes out after this edit: i feel so empty what about yall i hope monbebe gets better
@VagVampp4 жыл бұрын
I cried even before just hoping to see him one last time, hoping that all of this was a dream
@anmyawest66404 жыл бұрын
I had this slight hope that he would be there and then my heart broke when I saw just six of them and I started sobbing
@ikramgenereux3644 жыл бұрын
ikram genereux me too 😭 I hope you feel better baby stay strong
@KIMIMUSIC4 жыл бұрын
*crying before clicking, watching and left still crying*
@skrrrt12044 жыл бұрын
Meeee im so sad😭😭😭😭😭
@chimmixmochi65804 жыл бұрын
This is for those saying to respect Wonho's decision/ Starship's decision. We won't and will never let Wonho leave Monsta X just like that because we, Monbebes, know better than anyone else that Wonho really don't want to leave. For someone who keeps on saying that MX x MBB to be together for so many years, suddenly saying he will no longer be part of Monsta X... no... I will not accept it. And see the eyes of the members? It shows how much they want to protect him, each one of them. They don't want Monsta X to be just a group, they want it to remain as a family and we will make it happen.
@angelageronimo28704 жыл бұрын
Exactly... Leaving wasn't his decision
@ZtoATV4 жыл бұрын
Even if you're a Monbebe since the beginning, you're not there when Wonho did something like this. Nobody's perfect and we don't know if he really didn't do it or did he? One thing is for sure, we have to pay all the things we do, whether it's good or bad.
@blakeblock93764 жыл бұрын
@@blakeblock9376 I know. But what I'm saying is the way he loves MX and MBB. And the investigation is not yet over.
@angelageronimo28704 жыл бұрын
@@blakeblock9376 there is actually a post the came out this morning talkon about how someone heard hiz voice and smelt weed in a living room. When hw haunt out wit.
@Kiara-cs5ki4 жыл бұрын
ZtoA TV finally someone realizes that he didn’t choose to leave starship. Starship told him he had to leave
@vale-hs3sk4 жыл бұрын
나는 아직도 19년도 겨울이 잊혀지지가 않음..지난날이지만 몬엑도 몬베베도 하루하루가 벼랑끝에 서 있는기분 이였는데 팔로우 영상에 탈퇴멤 얘기 꺼내는건 진짜 양심이 어디로 간건지...가수고 팬이고 똑같다 정말....
@user-rm1lm1rm6d2 жыл бұрын
날짜만 봐도 심장이 아프고 손발에 힘풀림..ㅠㅜㅠㅜ 진짜 무슨 느낌으로 임했을지 짐작도 안가ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠㅠ
@user-qz7ik5xv4f2 жыл бұрын
I never knew a Monsta X performance would hurt me this much. Why did 2019 happen 😭
@Zarghoonakamal4 жыл бұрын
fr tho
@agustdankk27844 жыл бұрын
Same😭
@PrabhatDagar4 жыл бұрын
before wonho was dismissed, I was so excited for these stages. Honestly they can keep it... smh
@Nunmisonu4 жыл бұрын
same here man, but have you looked on twitter? our hashtag to get wonho back is trending and apparently, people are saying that he is planning to come back soon. so when the next stage comes around lets all hope to see our wonho on stage again
@ramen88264 жыл бұрын
wonho back soon
@lalainegarcia82334 жыл бұрын
_"눈물의 무대"_ 더 이상 설명할 길이 없다...
@user-np6od6dp5e3 жыл бұрын
늦베베라 이무대에 얽힌 이야기는 몰랐는데 이날 무대에서의 눈빛이 너무 다 이악물고 하는것 같아보여서 ㅠㅠ맴찢이네.. 이때를 잘 버티고 이겨내줘서 뒤늦게라도 내가 입덕 할 수 있었어.고마워 그리고 고생했어 늦게온만큼 앞으로 더 사랑할게 꽃길만 걷자♡
Jooheon 🥺😭 he looks like he’s been crying.
Shownu looks like he hasnt slept or stopped crying
kbaby boo he probably couldn’t. Especially after that bish HSH said he made someone cheat on her husband
All of them... Poor guys
Like when they did Hyungwon's entrance all I could see was how shaky and heartbroken he looked
they look so sad
No smiles. You can see that they are in pain and are clearly not okay
They don’t have the same energy as they did before. Even though it’s a serious concept they look so unhappy to be there
They look as if they were forced to do this show :(
이때 재녹음하랴 동선 바꾸랴 정신적으로 육체적으로 정말 정상일 수가 없었을텐데 이 악물고 무대해줘서 정말 고맙단 말밖에... 넘어져도 꼭 다시 일어나겠단 말처럼 다시 일어나서 달려와서 결국 커하 찍었고 정말 멋져 앞으로 더더 행복하자
앞으로 점점 더 커하 찍을거임 꼭 그렇게 될거야
혹시 커하가 뭔가요??
@@user-en1yq3fz3z 커리어 하이 줄인거에용! 앨범을 지금까지 판거중에 제일 많이 팔았거나 음원순위 높을때 커하찍었다고 해여
정말 웃긴게 이슈로 이 노래 오히려 뜸 ㅋㅋ 남잔데 이때부터 입덕함
하나도 안 웃기고 애틋한 활동 팔로우.. 진짜 명곡.. 정말 '이 악물고'.. 이 말 공감.정말 앞으로도! 더더 높이 넓이 오래오래~ ㅎㅎ함께 해줬으면 좋겠다 멋진 사람들
몬엑이들이 살벌한 돌판에서 커하 찍을 수 있었던 건 저 독함...진짜 본받고 싶음 내돌이라서가 아니라 한 인간으로써 진짜 본받고싶다...우리애들보면 인생 열심히 살고 싶게 만듬....진짜 사랑을 넘어선 동경이야 다시한번 깨닫는다 아이돌은 극한직업이다
It feels so wrong watching them as just 6 cant imagine how they feel
I really wanna cry :( This broke my heart in many many pieces
Even in the beginning I was kind of waiting for Wonho to show up
And it's because of this girl. Ughh I want to see her burn in hell
Ikr :(
Anger and sadness, that’s what I see in their eyes.
I know right...
보면 개빡치는 영상 1위 한쳐먹게 되는 영상 1위임 새벽까지 녹음하고 동선 맞춰서 흠잡을거 하나 없는데 여기가 아쉽다 저기가 아쉽다 평가절하했던 그 팬들 절대 못 잊음ㅋㅋㅋ 6명 전부다 너무 잘해줘서 고마워 우리야 보는 입장이니까 마음 아프고 말지만 본인들이 무대에 서겠다고 마음먹기까지 무슨 생각이였는지 아무도 가늠 못할거야 무대 서줘서 고마워
대체 누가 그랬어요? 아니 팬이란 사람들이 대체 무슨...
ㅇㅈ… 그때 진짜 환멸났었음.. 다 기억함..
ㅠㅠㅠㅠ늦베베는 정말 얘기만 들어도 가슴이 철렁..... 하루만에 그걸 다해따고요...? 하
어떻게.. 이날 무대를 세웠냐 진짜 다들 낯빛이 잿빛이네
this is the saddest comeback live I've ever watched
Same
rt
😭
Same :( there is no enthusiasm
Same
This was one of the most heartbreaking videos of 2019.....
BTSVTSKZ TXTATEEZBP I agree
Ik. Non of the other groups with departed members have made a comeback. There’s just came out on Monday
I agree
It literally is. Like I cried in the intro.
몬베베들 없이 비공개 사녹...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ많이 힘들었을텐데 무대 너무 잘해줘서 고맙고 진짜 사랑한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아그래요ㅠ다들참아픈시갼이 저안에있네ㅜ
몬엑을 얼굴밖에 모르던 시절 이때 사건 뉴스에 뜬거보고 ‘아 또 한그룹 난리났구만’하고 그냥 넘겼는데 이젠 애들 표정만 보고도 독기를 한가득 품고 무대 끝마치기위해서 노력했다는게 보여서 마음이…미어진다 미어져…
I can tell that everyone has been crying. Look at their eyes.......
Yup
Yeah. Eyes don't lie~
Their eyes were all at least somewhat puffy and I cant blame them cause I've been bawling my eyes out too
Yeah it seemed to me the same
I agree with you 😔
You can see how hurt they are when you look them in the eyes ...it’s just so sad, upsetting and unfair that all of this had to happen like this
Yes it was an absolute soulless performance
Norhane M. Salah completely agree
What happened to wonho i'm so dizzy
@@user-oq1dr2pe1e he left the group 😞
Some people (including a girl which was involved in a lot of rumors and lawsuits earlier this year and literally ever) have brought up some things, wonho was allegedly involved in, that happened yeaaars ago (some of them where right some of them their entertainment ‘starship’ denied)so he left the group out of his own will not thinking about himself but more of the image he would leave on the group as a whole if he stayed
이건 진짜 대단하다는 말 밖엔..다들 보통 멘탈이 아니다..몬엑을 깊게 안지 얼마 안됐지만 인트로 표정만 봐도 평소랑 너무 달라서 흠칫함ㅠㅠ 실시간으로 모든걸 겪었을 저 순간의 몬엑과 몬베베들 너무 고생많았어...
다들 평소에 비해 어두워보여 마음이 아프다ㅜㅜㅜ 하지만서두 다들 너무 프로라서 딱 봤을 때 무대가 거의 완벽함 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ follow는 특히 안무가 대박인듯 ...
안무 너무 멋있음
When you can see their swollen eyes, the anger in their dance, and the pain of losing a brother on stage. Shownu lost so much weight his cheeks are gone too. I can’t watch this anymore.
The sadness in their eyes
When I first saw them arrive, I saw how sad they were, I.M looked so sad..
It ain't that deep
@@msuarz6666 The guys literally spent the past four years close together after a harsh time in a survival show. It really IS that deep. They basically lost a brother.
920921 it literally is though
STARSHIP, YOU LET THEM PERFORM AMIDST THIS CHAOS THAT'S HAPPENING??!! COULDN'T YOU SEE THAT THEY ARE SAD ABOUT WONHO'S DEPARTURE?!
It was prerecorded
@@lindamarie5425 but wonho is still missing...
@@lindamarie5425 wth are u saying it's not pre-recorded. if it's pre-recorded, wonho still there duh
@@lindamarie5425 it's still after Wonho left and that's not ok
@ggotee pre-recorded or not, they still perform today isn't it? so it's after wonho departure
유기현 독기 진짜,,, 무너지지마 절대
늦베베 되어서 이제 보니까 진짜 기현이 눈빛에 독기 장난 아니네. 잘 버텨줘서 고맙다
*Do you wish to delete 2019?* *yes.*
Park Jimin definitely more than anything
I would sell my soul for this
Yesss💔
Yes OFC!!!!!!! 😔
Park Jimin absolutely!!
Kihyun’s eyes really look like he just had a tough cry
Joong Shin he probably did........😭
Yeah I can see that I’m soo sad 😞 I really that girl for ruining their life and also STARSHIP for not able to handle it properly
They all look (the most at the beginning) really tired... and sad, I guess..
와....엠카 컴백무대 보고 이거 다시보니까 원호 파트를 전부 기현이가 했네......유기현 진짜 독기 장난아니다
입덕하고 보니 맴아픈 무대...
2222
I cried when wonho left imagine how hurt they are right now can we rewind back in time? 😔
Why did he left? Did I miss something
Zkash Beauty yeah he left Monsta x yesterday :(
@@zkashbeauty if you search up his statement you can find it and it broke my heart
@@zkashbeauty but I think theres some stuff now happening to do with shownu as well
Just read!!! Its heartbreaking. Stay strong monobies. Love from EXO-L
*googles* how to delete 2019 out of world history
Aa türk mdksnďkdndnkdns
I mean not the comebacks, just the bad memories
Yes!!!! 2019 has not been kind to the kpop world
🇹🇷💜
살은 다들 쭉 빠져버렸는데 눈은 부어서... 마음 아프다
바로 전날 엠카에선 7명으로 무대 서놓고 다음날 6명으로 다시 녹음하고 동선바꿔 무대 선 몬스타엑스.... 늦베베라 이때 당시 팬들 멤버들 심정 모르지만 진짜 어떻게 하루만에 그걸... 그때 녹음하고 동선 연습하면서 무슨 생각 했을지 감히 상상도 안됨
Remember when I.M said 2019 is gonna be Monsta X year? ...
True...
It's not cause they are so sad and it's the worst year ever for them cause they have lost a brother and a member wonho so ....😭
Oh...yes
2019 was so close to being their year 😭 they only had 2 months left to call it their year. 😭😭
I can't believe starship actually made them perform without Wonho, I mean it's been just one day after the news, at least let them process what is going on :(
exactly
Ikrr I was shocked when I saw a performance that came out today
True!! They look so sad here 😔
Istg for a second i thought this was done earlier WITH wonho bcs i never thought they'd ACTUALLY fo it without him and TOO SOON
i agree:'(
와…전날 엠카는 7명서 하고 바로 다음날 다 수정해서 무대 선거구나.. 진짜 대박 다들 마음 진짜 안좋을텐데 무대 하는거 보니까 내 기분이 묘하네
늦베베라 그 일 때는 몬엑에 관심 아예 없었고 그 사건에도 전혀 신경안쓰고 넘겼음 근디 입덕하고 나서 이 영상, 이 날짜 보니까 아 괜히 싱숭생숭하고 다른 영상들처럼 헤헤 거리면서 볼수가 없네
No man. I’m honestly crying. 2019 doesn’t count as a year in my life
Chaela Dance it's just music chill
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 it has nothing to do with song but a misfortune within the group.
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 It's not when you stan a group you stan people not just the music
Music and movies(theater) are made to entertain us ✌️ whatever they do or whatever drama they bring I'm just gonna enjoy their "work" ☺️ IT'S 👏 NOT 👏 THAT 👏 DEEP 👏
well ok snow flake
Is it only me who thinks that they r mad and sad at the same time?
Of course they are...they lost a precious member/friend😔
Wonho Lee hes not dead lmao chill, they can still be friends
@@damnitaintright I will give you chill... He is "gone" from the group because of false allegations some stupid idiot made cuz she was mad YG dropped her...
@@damnitaintright I know he is not dead,i meant that they lost him cus he left,you can chill too and of course they are mad
@@tessagrey1656 they need to stop giving her attention then she will make a louder noise but eventually leave bbecause thats the only reason she doing this, her parents didnt give her attention so she getting it somewhere else
진짜 이 악물고 한게 보여ㅠㅠㅠ 보면볼수록 프로답다 너무 멋있어 힘냈구나ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아제발 몬스타엑스 분들 30대에도 활동 해주세요 이렇게만 쭉 갑시다
현 30대 이렇게 활동중임미다 히히
This feels wrong ... 2019 feels horrible.
solar solar this feels very wrong, they look so down...
solar solar stays you guys are so strong I love you guys🥺
It's what i felt throughout the video😔😔😔
Stan Monsta x Thank you, us stays really just want what's best for Straykids, but honestly this week has been really hard on us all... I'm actually also a monbebe ( even tho straykids is my Ulta) seeing all this happen at once with wonho leaving too hurts. But in our situation we knew that straykids was hurting just as much (more) than us... So as their true fans it's our responsibility to make sure we are always by their side (just like how they are to us) I hope other monbebes are ok... It's gonna be a rough road to cross, but you'll get there *promise💕😉*
2019 has been the worst 🥺 Wonho leaves MonstaX, Woojin left Stray Kids, and Hwall leaves The Boyz I miss them 🥺💖💞💘
Jooheon’s face at the end says it all 😔
kris10manuel yeah :c they all look so unhappy...
Given what has happened they still have a good performance. Gotta give them a round of applause for holding it together.
kihyun looks M A D mad tho
Kelley Thompson they danced it to the Tee i agree but their facial expressions just hurt me... pretty sure they’ve been crying too
I want to still be here to support them it’s just so hard without WH there
나는 그일 있고나서 애들 막 돌리길래 주헌이가 웃는게 정말 좋아서 웃는게 아니라고 생각이 들고나서부터 뭔일 나겠구나 했더니 아니나 다를까 주헌이 활동중단.. 다른 멤버들도 멘탈적으로 체력적으로 다 함들었을텐데 오히려 본인들이 활동하겠다고 한게 더 멋있고 마음이 아프다..그래도 지금 괜찮아진거같아서 다행이지만 힘들땐 쉬어가자..사랑한다 몬스타엑스❤️
주허니 활동중단해써요?ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@im.babykitty 예전에요 ㅎㅎ
입덕 전에는 팔로우 무대보면 아따 신난다 다들 실력 대박이네 정도로만 생각했는데 입덕하고 이무대 보니까 심장이 미어터져....ㅠㅠㅠ
Am I the only one who has like an empty feeling watching this? 😔
i feel the same bruh . . neomu apa
I keep seeing the empty spot 😭😭
Same and you can tell the boys felt it too they weren't even trying to put on the best show which is completely understandable I wouldn't want to perform if one of my members/bestfriend/brother is going through such a tough time but you can tell especially with jooheon and I.M . My poor babys man... im pissed
This is the worst thing ever, their eyes can't lied they are having so much pain.
I am literally crying
Fortunately "Follow" is a kind of fierce song so they wouldn't have to fake smile but the eyes can't lie either .....
They were forced 😭
They look so broken, it so sad to witness
**This is just my view on this video. ** To me after that stage it looks like they had no choice but to perform. It looks like there hearts and souls were gone with Wonho. No emotion at all like I will just sing the song and dance the dance but the emotions are nonexistent. I honestly think they shouldn't have performed at all then. Give them time to work on themselves and the whole issue first. Performances are nice to watch but this was painful to see there eyes so dead. **Remember that this is just my opinion!! But I will still support Monsta X and Wonho and the rest of the members too.**
최근 입덕하고 거슬러올라가는 중인데 당시에 팬들 마음이 어땠을지 댓글만봐도 알겠다
진짜 눈에 독기 가득이다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이 힘든걸 어떻게 하고 어떻게 견뎠을까ㅠㅠㅠ
kihyun and jooheon look like they're shaking with anger honestly.
and maknae I.M looks depressed...
@@ilikeshippingwaytoomuch8368 i can't imagine how hard he's taking this, changkyun loves his hyung. we'll make things right though, it'll be okay.
What part?
*True*
No they not
Literally the first time I can’t feel their energy through the screen TT
Exactly.
Yeah 💔💔💔
그래도 무대 서겠다고했을때 그 마음이 어땠을까 진짜...
These boys are trying so hard to make monbebe happy and the amount of people saying they're not monsta x without wonho upsets me. Monbebe should be cheering them on and encouraging them. Obviously loosing Wonho is incredibly hard on them..they dont need us to flood their social media reminding them. The rest of the vocal line did an amazing job covering Wonho's parts on such short notice. Be the support Monsta X needs monbebe! I'm so proud of them for how hard they're working through this!!
@@ElevenForti I never said anything about forgetting Wonho? All I said was nothing but supportive towards the members. At least that was my intent. If you felt otherwise, I would say you misunderstood my words. I've supported monsta x for years and seen them live many times. I want nothing but happiness and support for these hard working boys.
When Kihyun started singing Wonho's part I felt that 😢😢😢
😭😭😭
Their eyes show how sad they are. But they're trying to hide it.
Well... It isn't working...
@Baby Dragon wonho is not more a part of the group
You can tell all of them have been crying ... Those bitches really got away with what they did and that's what has me livid
@Baby Dragon Cuz Wonho left the group. He left because of a girl named Han Seo Hee, who accused him of ownign her money and, cuz of this, he received lots of hate from knitizens, and then, he's being also accused of using marijuana. His contract with Starship was finished, without any of these things being proofed to be truth
2:00 랩 미쳤다 ..남자아이돌 무대는 젝키랑 HOT 후로 끊었는데..ㅎㅎ이친구들은 대단하네 다들 실력파인 듯. 랩과 보컬이 아주 훌륭.. 노래좋고 춤 멋지네. 더 승승장구하길 바랍니다
나 이거 이제 볼수 있네...그때 너무 힘들어서 팔로우활동 못봤어
Kihyun covering Wonhos part is heartbreaking :(
Its the most hesrtbreaking part of the song hmmm feels like crying
I cant even watch this without crying i miss wonho 💔💔
The only thing I see is how broken they are and this makes me cry
Jimin’s Bae yes, same
same 😔
In JESUS name everything will be ok 😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏
처음 등장할 때 멤버들 얼굴이 너무 부어있어서 이 무대는 진짜 못보겠다ㅜㅜ 지금까지 함께 하고 있는 것 자체로 너무 고맙고 더 바랄게 없어ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
그동안 맘 아파서 못보다가 보는데 다시보니까 애들 눈빛하며 표정하며 독기가 가득 차 있는거 보고 눈물 왈칵이다 진짜..
they all look so frustrated and done, the way starship handled this situation was awful at least give the members some time to recover.
it feels they are performing without a soul their faces shows how painful this is for them
Right
Lily Shinki looks like you can tell they were crying beforehand in the beginning
their eyes tell everything.
Their faces look puffy like they have been crying... They also look angry
마음이 박박 찢어지는데도 너무 잘생겨서 그와중에 너무 좋음....ㅠㅠㅠㅠ얘들아 사랑해....
this doesn’t even look like Monsta X, it makes me cry 😭😭😭
I'm crying when kihyun singing wonho part 😭
Me too😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 cuz he my bias
You can see the anger, sadness in their eyes. Starship this is wrong. Being human is normal, being perfect is toxic~
mUlTi fAnDoM he was accused of stealing stuff, though. If it's true, it's not just "being human" it's a crime.
monbebe i beg yall to not reply to this troll^^^ and yeah it's heartbreaking seeing the boys like this as if they just got done crying.
It's not "being normal human" by refusing to pay debt and stealing stuff lmfao.
he was fully prepared to pay back the debt and everything she wanted. in the texts released his lawyer wanted to meet up and to negotiate. but instead of doing that, they decided to spread rumors about him and his bandmates. please get your information right and check the sources. as for whatever crime he committed, he served his time. i'm not saying he was right, i'm saying he might have changed. this was almost a decade ago and he has since not been charged for any offences whatsoever. i'm not a monbebe and thus not as clear on the situation, but i know enough to not dismiss him as a criminal. why are they releasing all thus information now? why didn't they just settle things with him and his lawyer instead of publicizing it? it's clearly a ploy to drag monsta x and wonho knows it, which is why he left.
It wasn’t just starship it was so wonhos choice
이것만보면눈물난다...고생많았어진짜..
Anyone crying at how they even had the 7th area in the middle but no one came out and it was a different color than the others :( My heart goes out to all the monbebes monteen forever
IM I THE ONLY ONE THAT' CANT FEEL THE ENERGY OF THIS SONG ANYMORE
I agree
You're not alone
the song symbolizes a devastating time for the group and Monbebes.. even though the contract is terminated I feel as though we all should keep fighting to get Wonho back. This whole situation is uncalled for and unfair.
yoongi's shootdance same
Yes, not only you because I can’t either. It’s not Monsta X’s stage presence. 💔
basic math 7-1=0 monsta x has 7 members, one is missing then its not monsta x
Yesss, trueee 12-1=0 (hwall) Missing one is not the boyz 9-1=0 (woojin) Missing one is not straykids 7-1=0 (BI) Missing one is not ikon
@@valenciaeunike4563 we think the same dw!!
😢
I've obviously been learning the wrong math because this is the truest thing I've seen all my life.
@Jkyun We aren't dissrespect what they are doing! But, are you suggesting that you don't want wonho back?
어떤 마음으로 섰던 무대일까 감히 짐작도 못해보겠다.. 대단하고 또 대단해 진짜.. 그럼에도 버텨주어서, 늦었지만 너희들을 알아볼 수 있는 기회를 주어서 정말 고맙다. 진짜 고생 많았을텐데..ㅠㅠㅜ 오래보자 더더욱. 오래 보고 싶다
의상 개예쁘다 그걸 또 찰떡같이 소화하고 안무도 좋고 노래좋고 몬엑무대 다 좋아하지만 팔로우무대가 제일 본새쩔음 완전 내서타일
Forcing these men to perform in this kind of situation is pure cruelty.
Welcome to the kpop industry 💔
@@priceymashups7692 I know!! We continue to support our favorite groups/idols exclusively because of them! All these companies can go to hell tbh 💔
yup i feel them
@@priceymashups7692 it's not the kpop industry it's business. they company put out money and want to make the returns off of it as soon as possible
i dont think they are being "forced"... but we have to understand that they work really hard for everything... this events were already schedule.. they cant just drop everything.... i believe that everything happens for a reason... lets just suport them Monsta X as 6 and Wonho ...
I can't believe that a song like this makes me cry.
I can feel u
늦덕 후회공인데 진짜 눈물난다ㅠㅠㅠ 스타쉽 제정신이냐고 다음날에...
저두요..
애들이 하겠다고 한겁니다. 상황이 이랬지만 남들에게 이슈때 더 열심히 해서 빛을 봤죠..애들이 현명했다고 생각해요 마음은 아프지만
근데 진짜 이 당시 팬들이랑 몬엑 심정은 직접 겪어보지 않는이상 절대 모를거같음 그만큼 엄청 잔인하고 힘들었음..나도 입덕 한지 얼마 안되고 첫 컴백이 팔로우였는데 그때 든 생각이 몇년동안 함께 해왔던 팬들이랑 몬엑은 오죽할까 싶더라..이 시기가 있었기에 지금의 몬엑이 있는거같음 정말 대단하고 자랑스럽고 수고했다고 말해주고싶당
They just look sad and angry- and the intro they clearly had just finished crying. 💔
Kihyun singing Wonho’s part totally broke my heart. I can’t imagine how they are getting through this.
I cried when not hearing WonHo's voice at the first part. I am even thinking They are all sad but tried so hard for Monbebes to be Ok😭😭😭
Mine too. I feel you. This situation is so sad and hard. On top of that Wonho was my bias. I chose him after thinking so hard. And now... He's gone. I hope he comes back.
맘 아파서 도저히 끝까지 못보겠다..
정말 독기 품은 눈들... 대견하다 얘들아. 고맙고
You can see the sadness in their eyes. This is wrong
Trueee 😭😭😭
I can tell all of them have been crying.. my heart hurts
I have seen two performances of follow and this performance is for me false😭
I'm crying, it's not even a joke, I'm really sitting here crying. I can't imagine how difficult it must've been to perform.
I think is because about Wonho left? Or am I wrong?
They are performing yes but there is no soul, no energy, no happiness on the stage, this is just a force!
Yes exactly and it is just so sad
Norhane M. Salah Yes, it is even hurting much more than truth
Yes, i can feel it ㅠㅠ
Starship seems like doesn't care at all
@@shanon1217 I know it's sad but they need to do it because it is still a work that needs to be done, they need to be professional.
그냥 행복하던 순간 멤버가 뜯겨져 나가서 그냥 모두가 벙쪘고.. 그때 팬덤은 진짜.. 😅 지금은 유입도 많이 생기고 많이 나아졌는데 옛날 팬덤 반이 까빠(?) 일 정도로 할 말 않할 말 구별 못하는 사람들 넘 많았음… 특히 트위터 네임드;; 암튼 지금은 다들 모두 행복하고 사적으로도 친한 건 여전하고 멤버들 행복해진 것 같아서 보기 좋음..
빅뱅 다음으로 좋아하게된 그룹,,,,,,,
Shownu looks too thin, Joohoney looks so angry, and Changkyunnie looks so depressed. I’m really hurting for these boys right now.
And minhyuk looks so minhyuk like always...
I mean to be honest, this is heartbreaking. Joohoneyy looks like he has cried to much and he eyes was clearly red.
don’t forget to notice kihyun’s eyes..
in the face he looks thin, but on his body it’s the black. black tends to make people look skinnier
I just don’t see that energy, starship u r so cruel
Exactly...my heart is broken💔💔
It's not starship fault
it's not starship
Starship didn't do anything
Fyi wonho didn’t even discuss with starship and the members so it’s none of their fault. It’s wonhos choice
나도 이 당시엔 팬 아니었는데 지금 입덕하고 보니 이때 잘 버텨줘서 너무 대견하고 고맙다 난 걍 이렇게 6명이 좋음
갠적으로 이 무대 인트로부터 좋아..
There's no smile , there's no enjoying there's no fanchant that was really hurt.... that wa really quiet 😭
Deviana Dka the reason there were no fan chants is because they didn’t allow Monbebe’s in the building.
I'm crying right now T_T
not even shocked i wouldn't have been able to chant either
hyungwon looked like he was about to cry when he first appeared
They all look emotionally exhausted
팔로우 무대는 볼때마다 멋지지만 맴찢
팔로우 무대 볼때마다 내 마음이 너무 공허해... 전 날 엠카였는데... 그날 밤에 감정을 다 정리하고 몬베베 슬픈 걸 알았고 무대에서 그 슬픈 감정 보여주지 않고 그냥 3분만에 몬베베들 위해 행복한 시간이 만들어주고 싶은 우리 몬엑 진짜 다단하고 사랑해. 호석이도 고생많았다...
2019 really is a joke, this just hurts
yeah,it's hurt so much
hurts so much
Yeah.... all my favorite groups are just falling apart and I can't do anything but stand on the side lines and watch it happen.
@クリームCream both them as well
These boys did their max here, they are really brave to get through the whole song, but we all know and feel without Wonho its incomplete simple as that. Please bring Wonho back to his members he belongs here. His private life has nothing to do with Monsta X. This is crazy!
Sadly, image is everything in Korea.
정말 이시간..이때가 몬베베로서 제일힘든시간이었는데...이무대보고 나도 정신이번쩍했었음...우리 몬엑도 견디는데 내가견뎌야지생각했던시간이었음... 솔직히 그 멤버의 팬이었지만 지금은 몬엑의팬이되었음..못 잃어..나의 몬스타엑스♥지금도 많이 응원해♥
정말 몬엑은ᆢ지난 3~ 4년간 지켜봐왔지만 정말 대단하고 존경심이 드는 그룹ᆢ
who else cried their eyes out after this edit: i feel so empty what about yall i hope monbebe gets better
I cried even before just hoping to see him one last time, hoping that all of this was a dream
I had this slight hope that he would be there and then my heart broke when I saw just six of them and I started sobbing
ikram genereux me too 😭 I hope you feel better baby stay strong
*crying before clicking, watching and left still crying*
Meeee im so sad😭😭😭😭😭
This is for those saying to respect Wonho's decision/ Starship's decision. We won't and will never let Wonho leave Monsta X just like that because we, Monbebes, know better than anyone else that Wonho really don't want to leave. For someone who keeps on saying that MX x MBB to be together for so many years, suddenly saying he will no longer be part of Monsta X... no... I will not accept it. And see the eyes of the members? It shows how much they want to protect him, each one of them. They don't want Monsta X to be just a group, they want it to remain as a family and we will make it happen.
Exactly... Leaving wasn't his decision
Even if you're a Monbebe since the beginning, you're not there when Wonho did something like this. Nobody's perfect and we don't know if he really didn't do it or did he? One thing is for sure, we have to pay all the things we do, whether it's good or bad.
@@blakeblock9376 I know. But what I'm saying is the way he loves MX and MBB. And the investigation is not yet over.
@@blakeblock9376 there is actually a post the came out this morning talkon about how someone heard hiz voice and smelt weed in a living room. When hw haunt out wit.
ZtoA TV finally someone realizes that he didn’t choose to leave starship. Starship told him he had to leave
나는 아직도 19년도 겨울이 잊혀지지가 않음..지난날이지만 몬엑도 몬베베도 하루하루가 벼랑끝에 서 있는기분 이였는데 팔로우 영상에 탈퇴멤 얘기 꺼내는건 진짜 양심이 어디로 간건지...가수고 팬이고 똑같다 정말....
날짜만 봐도 심장이 아프고 손발에 힘풀림..ㅠㅜㅠㅜ 진짜 무슨 느낌으로 임했을지 짐작도 안가ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠㅠ
I never knew a Monsta X performance would hurt me this much. Why did 2019 happen 😭
fr tho
Same😭
before wonho was dismissed, I was so excited for these stages. Honestly they can keep it... smh
same here man, but have you looked on twitter? our hashtag to get wonho back is trending and apparently, people are saying that he is planning to come back soon. so when the next stage comes around lets all hope to see our wonho on stage again
wonho back soon
_"눈물의 무대"_ 더 이상 설명할 길이 없다...
늦베베라 이무대에 얽힌 이야기는 몰랐는데 이날 무대에서의 눈빛이 너무 다 이악물고 하는것 같아보여서 ㅠㅠ맴찢이네.. 이때를 잘 버티고 이겨내줘서 뒤늦게라도 내가 입덕 할 수 있었어.고마워 그리고 고생했어 늦게온만큼 앞으로 더 사랑할게 꽃길만 걷자♡