Armenia: Alone Among Enemies | ARTE.tv Documentary
2023 ж. 28 Қар.
55 591 Рет қаралды
When 100,000 Armenians fled from Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia at the end of September 2022, Azerbaijan took control of the territory, which belongs to it under international law. For Armenia, the loss of Nagorno-Karabakh is another bitter blow in its tragic history since the genocide of Armenians in Turkey in 1915.
Subscribe to our KZhead channel: / @artetvdocumentary
Armenia: Alone Among Enemies | ARTE.tv Documentary
🗓 Available until the 23/10/2053
ARTE.tv Documentary is here to tell you more about what’s going on in the world of culture, news and current affairs with powerful, refreshing and entertaining docs subtitled in English for our international fans.
Discover a whole world on #ARTE.tv
#Azerbaijan #artetvdocumentary #armenia
WATCH NEXT 👉🏻 Iraq: Kurds against Mullahs | ARTE.tv Documentary kzhead.info/sun/fMtrqM6DbXVogI0/bejne.html
Մեզ ծակ խոստումներ պետք չեն,աշխարհը նույնն էր ասում,միայն ասում են եւ եք։
God save Armenia and armenians! Good wishes from Bulgaria!
God save all people of the world! armenians, azeris, ukrainians, russians, jews, palestinias, americans, chinese.... all humans!
Bulgaria is Macedonia and language is Macedonian
@@Bosniak803 I am not a doctor, sorry.
You can't be ... Low inteligency coificient + Neo colonial mentality @@AzAz-jp5ox
In Bulgaria turkish , people even built the metro, hospitals, Acibadem and other infrastructures, ungrateful Bulgarians 😮
I’m Lebanese, I pray for Armenia. 🇱🇧
А по национальности ты кто? Проклятый армянин или Араб?
Ok Arab, go and rescue your armenian sucker Phalastinjan friends
You're Lebanese, your country needs prayers more that Armenia does.
@@elbagrau My village is paradise. 🏖
@@elbagrauLebanon is a beautiful country
Healt and happynes,from Bulgaria,hope,for the best,for all armenians
Армяне Богом проклятые люди. Приветствую вас из России!
asian brotherhood solidarity
Love and sympathies to armenians from india and best wishes and prayers for their future.
But Karabakh is azerbaijan land
@@elseverseferov5424keep it
Keshmir is Pakistan!!
@@ercanylmaz967 try it
@@ercanylmaz967yes now please come to Kashmir and say this once !
Praying for Armenia
FCK for Armenia !!!!
i stand wth armenia
😂
Thank you for making your voice ❤ This world has no justice, only gas, oil and money 😢
right and so sad
ARMENIA WILL ALWAYS BE HERE
Hahahaha !!!!!
Long live Armenia and we surely WILL!
Yes, after your comment they will try to live long ))
@@OYANEKU2011 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenians
İf they dont attack to neighbours
The.world,need.to.help,Armenia,Jesus.with.you.armenia.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Armenia needs Allah and islam
No one is with them
@_____Z_____ Sure, but Armenia is a Christian country and always has been. Can you elaborate a bit more-
Who cares what is their "nonsense" beleive.So far what I know, Armenia is way backward than their neighbors and people are very uncivilised with medeival mentality ... It is something special to be Cristian lol@@rubymvd9005
I met the map 🗺️ guy in person in Yerevan. He gave a talk and I have his book. 📕
As a minority group in Africa it is worrying to be surrounded by hostile groups. You will however survive and keep your identity is the will power is there
If your comment is about Christian solidarity, there are also many Christians in Azerbaijan. If you are saying this for justice, then you should also say that its Armenia occupied Azerbaijani oficially recognized lands between 1992-2020 and expelled 1 million Azerbaijanis from their homes and even now tehere are 8 Azerbaijani villages under control of Armenia. Look at Aghdam, Fizuli, Jabrail, Zangilan,Kubatly,Lachin,Kalbadjar through Google maps all of these ruins were big cities, villages were homes of azerbaijanians kzhead.info/sun/Z9WMZqWIbmKkm3k/bejne.html kzhead.info/sun/itildKWJaaGFqYU/bejne.html
Go back to Germany
What kinde of hostile groups ??? Iran and russia is main ally of them
Long live Armenia Land of Noah
Land of Nothing
Land of loser
@@Bosniak803you speak only of yourself. Loser with no identity
@@Bosniak803 found the turk
That's your relatives,you looks like them ... Asiatic ,btw. @@koolkay_222
I am Canadian; I pray for Armenia!
For people in this discution who said Armenia didn't existed 100 years ago they can come to England/London national musium and they will see more than 2000 years old clay map which in north east is written Armenia. Regarding whose land is Artsakh and who attacked whom, you need to see how Nagorno Gharabagh and Nakhijevan which was 85% armenian in 1925 end up under Azerbeijan. This designed by Stalin. Why because the same english politics, cause conflicts and rule them for ever. After Soviet Union collapsed Artsakh people with referendum announced their independents. This didn't go well with Azeri government and they programmed and orchestrated kind of mass killing in Bako and sumgait and some other sities On armenians. And here you go that's why war started. And because Russian they were playing their dirty politics as usual helps armenian to take over more teritory (again for future conflict). This caused another conflict in 2020. This time Russian played another dirty game, they help Azerbeijan against Armenia. Of course they knew that they will attack to Ukrain ( That is different story, who was behind of this war) and they needed support and they knew Turkey, specifically Erdogan had Ottoman dreams. So they made a deal with Turkey which they will help Azerbaijan and Russia will come as a saver after Azerbijan took over everything. Now Russia needs that zangezoor or Sunik coridor to export and sell its oil and gas under Azerbeijani oil and gas and transport it through Armenia (Sunik corridor) and sell it in Turkey to Europe, Israel and elsewhere. At least be honest if you judge. What will happen later, It depends how the war in Ukrain will finish.
FACTS: What are recognized borders of Armenia according to UN? The recognized borders of Armenia according to the United Nations encompass the territory that was internationally recognized as part of the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic within the former Soviet Union prior to its independence in 1991. These borders generally correspond to the administrative boundaries of the Republic of Armenia as it declared independence. While Nagorno-Karabakh was de facto controlled by ethnic Armenian forces, it is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan's territory. The United Nations, like most of the international community, does not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent state and considers it part of Azerbaijan's sovereign territory. What are recognized borders of Azerbaijan according to UN? United Nations recognizes the borders of Azerbaijan as those defined by international agreements and relevant UN resolutions. For Azerbaijan, the internationally recognized borders generally encompass the territory of the country as it was before the outbreak of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict in the late 1980s and early 1990s. This includes the regions of Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas, which are internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan. Everyone (USA, EU, UN, other reasonable countries) recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan - there is no doubt that Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan. Armenia has previously (1991-1994) occupied that part, and Azerbaijan regained it in 2020.
100,000 + 30,000 + fled around the 2020 war. 7,500 + soldiers and other civilians died 145,000 + people lived in entirety of Artsakh before Sep 2020
Thank you for truth!
Russia's role has been the most shameful in the region esp. during the conflict. Russia wants to be the big brother but at the same time during times of conflict it pretends to look aside.
Ungrateful Indian
Hey Pajeet, some countries have other priorities than just basing their whole external policies on hating Muslims. You know, like grown up people.
Armenians just disspointed that russians are not going for another crusade with them. Russians cant. If someones want to come we are living here and will be ready
Armenia chose the US over Russian . GOD luck to them
@@vladislavfeldman6562From what I understand, they asked for Russia's assistance first and they turned a blind eye. This led them to resort asking the US for aid. This is why you see such comments.
This happens when you don't talk about the Currupt politics, curruption in defence sector... May God save them... Amen...❤
We Indians always have high regards for Armenians. We support them with all pur emotions against snakes besides. Because, we as Indians can feel how being surrounded by snakes feels like.
You may be a snake yourself for the others.:))
armenians dont care, now move own
@@iqbalsandu8182 they do!!! I have plenty of Armenian friends and as a Christian, I know their suffering under that religion that came encroaching the native Christians of Ethiopia, Georgia, Assyria, Aram, Galilee, West Bank, Nineveh, Qatar, Bahrain and Yemen.
Xəstə beyin, xəstə təfəkkür
@@z.veli.1239yeah you have
8:50 Don't portray this conflict as a religious one! It's an ethnic and territorial conflict perpetuated by Russia (started by the Soviets and fueled by Putin now). Azerbaijan is the 13th most irreligious nation in the world and has serious issues with Iran. I believe in the union of Caucasian nations without borders and the infuence of regional powers. It's a big dream but realistic! We should put history behind and unite to prosper. Germany and France had had centuries of enmiy and war but they decided the same and became leading nations in building the EU.
Turks destroy everything armenian and christian related in the armenians indigenous lands..... so yes this is a religious struggle aZ well.
We all see how these 2 countries are building EU 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Now all europe work for their american boss. Armenia with Pashinian decided to became american slaves aswell. Nicely done 👍
We've been trying to tell Armenia now for 30 years to stop allying with Russia and they never listen. No one is even religious anymore, this isn't the 14th century, but so many russian-diaspora can't get over the past
@@johnbower3002 as the turks grape and pillage my race off my homeland.... You still wanna talk about corruption like it is 1994? U helped the turks
@@johnbower3002 If you are from Azerbaijan, that's rich coming from you.
Eastern Turkish Armenia 🇦🇲 is as far as i got, back in 1983 💜
This documentary tries to paint the Armenians as victims. That Azerbaijan is the aggressor. But it also show you that it is Armenia that is still Illegally occupying Azerbaijan land. And Armenians desire to create greater Armenia in Turkey. They need to leave their neighbours alone and make peace.
Azerbaijan also claims Armenia as “Western Azerbaijan”. Azerbaijan is currently occupying 140km2 of internationally recognized Armenia after it attacked Armenia in sept 2022.
Chosing Russia as a friend and partner is not a very noble act
May God help you Armenians, one of the greatest nations on Earth
3:12 "-and kill all the Turks" says more than a word. Just need to remind him what happened to the people in the same mind in Karabagh since last 3 years.
are you referring the the videos of elderly armenians being beheaded? i cant understand why armenians would be bitter against you, you seem like such nice people
In the meanwhile you’re probably someone who supports Hamas and justifies their massacres as resistance. The truth is, Muslims will always support each other no matter what crimes they commit
Excellent - thank you
Thank you 🙏
Thanks for watching!
You forgot Georgia, they are acting just like Azerbaijan and Turkey towards Armenia by fully supporting the two mentioned states. Unfortunately and unexpectedly.
Armenians simply should not lead agressive policy against neighbours and leave in peace with them
🤜🤛👏👏👏👏👏👏🤝🫶
tell this story to the greeks. All aggression in history are ame from the tartars (turksish tribes).
@@Maharaaja. Hey fellow Iranian, are you a zoroastrian in real life?
Islamic republic of Iran supports and helps Armenia. Why are you lying?
What about main armenian ally,Iran
I am iranian... armani and irani braders...
Beautiful @@sasanmohamadzade4094
May God be with the peace of the region for the rest of eternity.
FACTS: What are recognized borders of Armenia according to UN? The recognized borders of Armenia according to the United Nations encompass the territory that was internationally recognized as part of the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic within the former Soviet Union prior to its independence in 1991. These borders generally correspond to the administrative boundaries of the Republic of Armenia as it declared independence. While Nagorno-Karabakh was de facto controlled by ethnic Armenian forces, it is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan's territory. The United Nations, like most of the international community, does not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent state and considers it part of Azerbaijan's sovereign territory. What are recognized borders of Azerbaijan according to UN? United Nations recognizes the borders of Azerbaijan as those defined by international agreements and relevant UN resolutions. For Azerbaijan, the internationally recognized borders generally encompass the territory of the country as it was before the outbreak of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict in the late 1980s and early 1990s. This includes the regions of Nagorno-Karabakh and surrounding areas, which are internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan. Everyone (USA, EU, UN, other reasonable countries) recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan - there is no doubt that Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan. Armenia has previously (1991-1994) occupied that part, and Azerbaijan regained it in 2020.
So much disinformation in one video.
A national fasting prayer is necessary for the Armenian Christians to Jesus, like Esther and the Ninevites. Pray for this country where there are many Christians! Hope them to still love their invasive neighbors with Godly love! If those strong countries with long Christian tradition will not help this nation, the only way out is to keep praying to Jesus and make sure what His will is to them.
There is a lot of lies in this reportage. No one claims a control over Armenian territory in Zangezur corridor. No one forced Armenian population to leave Nagorno-Karabakh for Armenia. İt was their own wish because they didn't want to live under Azerbaijani rule after Azerbaijan regained it's internationally confirmed territories. As for Armenian churches and convents in the region they all are under control of Azerbaijani police and military to prevent any attemp of causing damage.
I do not believe that Armenia will loose their own territory. They only lost the territories that they do not own.Nationalism will only harm small nations like Armenia. I hope the Armenians will have a better future O
My love and sympathy for you Armenian brothers ! I pray for you! Stick with the real God, Jesus Christ, you are not alone, you have the mightiest ally on you side ! (a Greek)
My paternal grandmother was of Turkish Armenian descent. May she rest in peace. Our family told us that they went through a lot, but not from Turks but from the Armenians and Russians themselves who came from abroad and terrorized the neighborhood and the area. The Turks neither took anything away from us nor looked askance at us. We have a lot of land in Trabzon that has belonged to us for centuries. Armenia is responsible for its own bad situation. Anyone who thinks they should listen to their diaspora and follow other people's games with empty promises will come away empty-handed! Who attacked Azerbaijan in a night operation in 1992 with the support of Russia and occupied land that does not belong to us? Maybe Armenia should finally stop playing nationalistic games and care about the well-being of its nation instead of blaming others for its miserable situation.
Armenia as a State,as a Kingdom existed long time before turks from Altay came to this region . They came with a sword, and brought a lot of trouble with them.
Armenia have not had independance for thousands of years even before turks came. These lands were always multicultural. European nationalism started divisions and it would have happened no matter what nations lived in this lands. You were fighting georgians, armenians massacred so many kurds too. Are kurds nomads too?
The fuck you're talking about? the fact that your AREMNIAN grandmother was forcefully ra*ed and turkified under Islamic sharia now you're acting like a disgrace. You know English and have access to free internet, do your research.
You can't compare the Ottoman Armenian era with the aftermath of Turkification, ethnic cleansing, and the Turkish drumbeat of "enemies" that it still needs to enforce unity...even against Turks, Kurds, Greeks, Syrians, Iraqi Kurds, Syrian Kurds, Cypriots, and everyone else.
@@accuratetaxes5504 Greeks occupied the Armenian Kingdom.
We need to speak about the role of Russia in all of that. Everything is comming from Moscow.
I just love that quote oh how true thank u for your insight
well arte tv is french company and it's no wonder that this video is one sided and that they portray armenians as victims which is not true.
As a Turk if I had a chance I would give all the lands of Turkey, Azerbaijan, and northwest of İran (where the Iranian Azeris live) to Armenians. Then exchange the Turkish population with any other nation. After the whole world could see, Armenia and Armenians will be in the same position as now. A nation with at most 10 million all over the world tries to rule more than 100 million people coz they told as their grand grand grand grand grand father came here earlier than the Turks.
thats not true. I´m armenian from Diyarbekir (Tigranakert). I dont want it back. Armenians just want peace with Turkey and for turks to recognize the armenian genocide as a respect of what happened to my family and all the rest. Just let the armenians in Karabakh have Karabakh....120 000 people today that are homeless, for WHAT? Azerbaijan will turn everything to shit as they did in Nachijevan
@@pisimonian7403 Were you saying the same when Azeries was forced to be homeless?
That's very sweet of you to say. We don't want it back. We just want peace with our neighbors and normal trade. One thing armenians would love is to visit Ararat
@@pisimonian7403 How many "Tigranakerts" do exist in your fantasy :)).? I know at least 5 cities Armenians refer to as "Tigranakert". Sort your legends a little bit, to make them more plausible. This fairy tale of "120K homeless people" do not match as well. First of all the official numbers speak about 100K, that means 20.000 still remained there. Second, the Armenians have been given a chance to stay, but they chose to leave. Third Azerbaijan waited 26 years and 3 years afterwards to give Armenian chance to change their attitude, but Armenian understand only the language of war. For comparison, your "honorable" Monte gave 10 hours to people from Kelbajar to leave their houses. Feel the difference.
It’s irony however much Azerbaijani and Turkish governments lend hands to Armenia the Armenians live still centuries backward assuming there are enemies around. Why Azeris are more friendlier than Armenians and why Armenians holding on to the racial pride tells you more why Armenians are stuck in quicksand. During the Azeri war to retake NK Azeri government didn’t target the civilians and just compare this to how Israel treats Palestinians. Azeri government offers equal citizenry but as Armenians you don’t have that broad mind to accept that equality. You didn’t even offer similar equality to the Azeri minorities from the area Armenia expelled the Azeris. Should have some conscience.
I believe this is the made of Russia and Armenia . 1988-1994 Armenia did unimaginable crimes against Azerbaijan. # this documentry is one side story only . In every story there are two sides !
Yes, and there are documentaries that present the Azerbaijani side of the story. This one is ours.
They can learn from ASEAN on how to live peacefully with the neighbors❤❤❤
Someone is being delusional here.
Oh you sound deluded tbh@@gerardkhachaturyan4814
@@gerardkhachaturyan4814lol
If you can shake hands with the neighbor who has killed your whole family and occupied you home... then congratulations to you. We all can learn a lesson of forgiveness from you.
You mean submissively, living under an uncivilized dictatorship?
Great documentary,
Thanks for watching!
It is a fully biased report. I am disappointed about this channel.
The loss of Nagorno Karabakh is unfortunately an incontrovertible fact but from this Armenia can start again for a strong and lasting economic development because now its neighbors can no longer claim other territories without themselves facing a reaction from the United Nations and the international community international: I don't think the civilized world will allow Turks and Azerbaijanis to go further without paying a very high price.
They even claimed and invaded other territories, now the conflict is ongoing.
Which civilized world??? 😂😂 invader USA , colonial Uk ?
@@Deniz-gz4srYes like the US... Those who invades and apologize for their past crimes. That's what civilized nation's do. When will your nation who is founded on occupation and genocides from Balkan to the Caucasus ever apologize?🙂
Countries especially China and Iran are angry hearing those who love to claim their bubble as civilized world. Those are not civilized world, but bubbled world. They only think that it is only them who have the right to own this earth.
@@Deniz-gz4sr no one is perfect but the west so much better than russia iran and other thug nations . but nice try with the bait and switch garbage
Armenia attacked Azerbaijan a few days after independence and commited several massacres and ethnic cleansing. And Azerbaijan took back land, which was stolen. Moreover Armenia is allied to both pariah states of Russia and Islamic Republic of Iran. Russia still has the largest military base in the Caucasus in Armenia and Iran even threatened Azbaijan for the sake of Armenia. But according to them, they are the innocent.
Azerbaijan started it, don't play around.
@@theyeeningnonsense. Armenians belongs to Hague not in Armenia.
😁😁😁 why you think that normal person would believe this shit. Only azeris love such a stories. Azeris like fantasy 👍🏻
@@theyeening You should read more history than your state propaganda school books.
@@theyeeningwe all remember miatsum. So who started?
Long live Armenia turoki maman kounem
They are double faced people. Azerbaijan will not destroy church. There was not any single fact but armenians demolished too many mosques, but they are facts
iran is olny supporter
I can totally understand Armenia situation as someone from Serbia.
Portraying the Armenians as the last rampart of Christianity, the authors of the documentary seem to forget about the Georgians, which are living in the same region, are Christs as well, but somehow manage to have wonderful relationships with Azerbaijan and Turkey. :)
Azerbaijan is the Muslim country that is the least religious muslim country in the world. But they make it sound like it Syria or Qatar
Armenians have a strong lobby, don't expect anything fair coming from these clips. Even in 1920-ies they apparently wanted to claim Trebizond lmao, the city that's never belong to Armenians.
also, all of these conflicts have nothing to do with religion.
@@davidaleksidze3381 "Armenians have a strong lobby, don't expect anything fair coming from these clips" ahahahahahahahaha, LOL
i dont get it why do the georgians i know love azerbaijan more than armenia please explain somebody
Only option for armenia is to get along with Turks and be a good neighbor. Or they will be poor forever.
Actually, the country's economy has been seeing record growth over the past 2 years, despite all this... GDP has almost doubled in that time.
@@adoberoots If you want permanent growth and peace you get along with your neighbors. If you prefer to be Russia's puppet, you know
I have nothing against getting along with Turks. But that doesn't mean I want to open the border. We have no interest in being a Turkish colony.
How can they even ''get along'' with the Turks if the turks are actively trying to take lands from them? Think.
@@adoberoots For a homeless unemployed dude, doubling your income is not that hard. GDP per capita as well as GDP is lowest for Armenia and highest for Azerbaijan in Caucasus Region and you cannot even compare any of them to Turkey with its diversified and heavy industry, even though there is economic crisis. 🤣
So many lie in one video. Europe takes side of armenia although everyone knows that armenia occupied azerbaijani lands
During Roman Reign, you weren’t allowed to go to Western Anatolia. Turks made you prosper for centuries. You betrayed Turks for Russians, then after deportation you blamed Turks for committing genocide which is a complete lie. In 1994, you invaded Azerbaijan’s land with the help of Russians and moved people from Lebanon/Syria to claim it’s yours plus you deported Turks. Now you lost and cry, as this is the only thing you can do. For all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword. Matta 26:52 One additional note: This population that Armenians moved from Middle East will cause problem in Armenia soon.
Armenia located in Asia, and Georgia too. It's not Europe.
who told you that, look twice in geography and history and think twice, you aren't stupid enough to make comments like this right?.....or are you?
Thank you, Arte!
Thanks for watching!
why can't armenia and georgia support and help eachother?
Mind blowing documentary 👌 🙌 👏
Why don't you say anything about Azeri deportation from they lands which you now a days call armenia ? Mass deportation of Azerbaijanis from аrmenia took place several times throughout the 20th century, and sometimes some of them have been described by some authors as acts of forced resettlement and ethnic cleansing. Prior to the October Revolution, Azerbaijanis had made up 43 percent of the population of Yerevan. November, 1987- Deportation of Azerbaijanis from Kapan and Meghri districts of the armenian SSR. Hopefully there will a time that they will return to this places !!! The Azerbaijani population endured a process of forced migration from the territory of the First Republic of аrmenia and later in the аrmenian SSR several times during the 20th century. Under Stalin's policies, approximately 100,000 Azerbaijanis were deported from the Armenian SSR in 1948.
" According to the historian Vladislav Martynovich Zubok, with the filing of “the first secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Armenian SSR Grigory Arutyunov” who had lost his hope of the return of the “ancestors' land”, Stalin ordered to deport the Azerbaijani population of the Armenian SSR to Azerbaijan in order to free space for the Armenian repatriates, whose number was estimated at 400 thousand." According to Vladislav Zubok, 90 thousand Armenians came to Armenia. The majority of them were individuals who had lived through the Armenian Genocide and/or were descendants of those who had either escaped or been forcibly deported by Turkish government during it, and who could not return to their homes in Western Armenia. The Azerbaijanis were forced to move to the Kura-Aras lowland of Azerbaijan, where cotton growing developed rapidly, and their places, as planned, were taken by the newly arrived Armenians." - Deportation of Azerbaijanis from Armenia (1947-1950) It was Stalin's order not an Armenian's. Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Deportation_of_Azerb...
@@Ryuk_Judge 1. The Azerbaijanis were forced to move to the Kura-Aras lowland of Azerbaijan !!! 2. And Stalin did this with the insistence of the First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the аrmenian SSR, grigory arutyunov. So read it properly :) !!!
@@sachakulmik9669 1.#"1. The Azerbaijanis were forced to move to the Kura-Aras lowland of Azerbaijan !!!" forced to move by Stalin. 2# "2. And Stalin did this with the insistence of the First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the аrmenian SSR, grigory arutyunov. ", my point still stands that Stalin gave the order, Armenians in Armenia weren't the ones who wanted to do this, I may also add that grigory arutyunov insisting such a thing at that time does not make any sense so I would like to see where you got that information." So read it properly :) !!!" next time you decide to respond. My point is that Stalin gave the order.
@@Ryuk_Judge Based on the insistence of the First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the аrmenian SSR, grigory arutyunov. So read it properly :) !!!
@@sachakulmik9669 Can you site a source or do you have any proof he insisted such a thing? Because as of right now you are telling me this and in my reply I told you to show me proof that he insisted such a thing, "So read it properly :) !!!" Please
3:12 pretty much summarizes it all. This is what many of them believe. And until they realize that this is not the way to proceed, this conflict will not end.
I mean what do you expect them to say to a country that killed hundreds of millions of Armenians? You expect them to be with open arms to the turks? Of course not, they wish misery upon them. So unless you don't have anything better to say by knowing the History of Armenia then you have no right to talk about them saying that "until they realise that this is not the way to proceed". I mean look at Armenia now and compare it Turkey and Azerbaijan. You think a country that size can destroy Turkey? Obviously not, its a dream and forever will be a dream for Armenians who hold a deep grudge and hatred to the Turks. War isn't the way, but to say that to a country that has suffered similarly to the situation of Palestine is not cool at all dude
WTF So turks can come to Armenian lands, steal them, carry out a genocide, and then you say "until they realize that this is not the way to proceed, this conflict will not end". WTF
This is from one of the best encyclopaedias in the world: For centuries the great mountain plateau of Eastern Anatolia-in present-day eastern Turkey-was inhabited primarily by Christian Armenians who shared the area with Muslim Kurds ... Armenian political independence was largely brought to an end by a wave of invasions and migrations by Turkic-speaking peoples beginning in the 11th century, and in the 15th and 16th centuries the region was secured by the Ottoman Turks and integrated into the vast Ottoman Empire. Then happened the Armenian Genocide (and not only the Armenian, but the Greek and Assyrian Genocides too). And now you want Armenians to forget that all and talk about peace?
And I'm not talking even about Nakhichevan and Artsakh which also were Armenian for centuries until turks came in
@@Qwertyasdf923do you belive that all europeans and armenians should come back from united states, so only indians aztecs and incas lived and ruled there. Say yes, I will applaude
Great job 👏 ❤
Этот репортаж как всегда предвзятый , рассказывает только с армянской позиции !!! Тогда как жертва этой оккупации являются азербайджанцы - 1 миллион беженцев , которые были изгнаны дашнаками с родных земель! Армянские вандалы стерли с лица земли целые города такие как Агдам и Физули!! Кто вернет нам эти прекрасные города !!?? Никто не позаботился о наших беженцах , они ютились в палатках, никто не помог!!!! Политика двойных стандартов , жизнь азербайджанцев ничего не стоит , только потому что они мусульмане !!
When you are surrounded by enemies it's time to look into the mirror to see who the problem is.
We would have been surrounded by enemies no matter what.
@@sakogekchyan7366 totally agree with you.
@@sakogekchyan7366 That's simply not true, that's just your brain disease. You will never understand decency.
They have also friends, Iran and Russia, the two pariah states. 😂
What enemies? Only Azerbaijan is our enemy. Of course turkey 🇹🇷 supports you because Azerbaijan is a muslim- turkic nation . Aremsnia is on good terms with Iran, Russia , Georgia, Syria, Lebanon, Greece and most of the west. Don't talk shit if you can't back it up
Its russia fault
For not declaring war against Azerbaijan to protect the terroterries of karabakh that Armenia itself abondoned? It s Pashinian fault for choosing to sell the country and become a western slave.
Love and sympathies to Azerbaijan from Pakistan. Long live the brotherhood.
Armenia will truly be alone, if it continues its pivot to the U.S. and the West. As tough as the loss of NK was to swallow, Armenia’s interests are still best served as part of the collective security coalition with the Russian Federation.
Russians can not be trusted and I am saying that as Indian
French propaganda...
God bless Armenia and its people!🇦🇲
Thank u God bless u 🤜🏼🤛🏼
Damn them all ! hayastan kunem
@@lucaazeri1700 Awe does somebody need a hug?
Then Armenia has to stop claim land from Georgia Türkiye and Azerbaycan
@user-sb3yq5hi5p Those are historically armenian lands, Armenia has right to claim lands from turkey and azerbaijan
For Armenia beeing to close to Russia did not bring anything good.
Amazing culture and people, they sure know their social-civil issues and responsabilities as a country.. May their faith keep them strong! #Armenia #Aloneamongenemies #Social&CivilConflicts #Internationallaw #Genocide1915 #TragicHistory #Amazingsurvival #Art #Culture #ShortDucumentary #2024USA❤🧡💛💚💙💜
Turkiye and Azerbaijan are not enemy of Armenia, they always want to make peace deal with Armenia, just let the corridor btw Nakhcivan and Azerbaijan, let all borders open btw Armenia, Azerbaijan and Turkiye, just collect tolls linking the trade btw China and Europe, prosper Armenians, it is easy. This is what Turkiye and Azerbaijan want.
@@kzgntosbaga6255 I say trade btw Europe and China, how turtle brain are you :D
@@kzgntosbaga6255Its source of money. You guys are weird. Egypt open their canal for the world to cross, and got money from it. Singapore open the malacca strait for the world to cross, and got money from it. Thailand planning to make a corridor, a tunnel, a transportation goods, as another option of malacca strait, to get money. If its in my country. The question is not whether opening the road or not. Its unquestionable be Yes. The main question is, how much money we could get from the road. The bargaining will be like hxll.
Lol. Then why do turkey and azerbaijan deny the AG?
You meant the Singapore Strait rather than the Strait of Malacca? Strait of Malacca is part of Malaysia and Indonesia. Strait of Singapore is part of Singapore and Indonesia.@@sukmapradana7812
@@sukmapradana7812 You forgot to mention that Azerbaijan wants this road to be under Azerbaijan Military control
If you have enemies all around, then blame yourself.
So same for Israel
Pashinyan was your leader, he still doesn't know English, you don't go with Azerbaijan, fight with yourself, your nation is left out, your political leaders are fighting over the position
Armenia is a democracy surrounded by hostile larger countries ran by dictators. The West should stunt by them. Love and solidarity from Greece
Since when Greece is a democracy? Cause you kill and drowned migrants in the Mediterranean Sea or stole billions of bailout euros?? Clowns 🤡
who is the dictator of Georgia ???
What kind of democracy Armenia is? Tribal democracy? Other countries think about making business. Armenia is busy in thinking about Greater Armenia.
:))) @@__Man__
Armenian their leader is a puppet
Don't worry Armenia, INDIA is with you! 💪
LOL
@@kzgntosbaga6255 why?
Much love, bhai 🤜🏼🤛🏼
Phul sapport always phrom Indian baradars saaaaar.
Yeah but Armenia is with Palestine......and Azeris are with Israelis😂😂😂😂😂so decide now..........lindu bro.......
Then stop making enemies with people who are trying to help? Armenia's #1 problem is Russia, but they seem to not understand that
Since when have you ever ever ever been trying to help us? Give me a break man.
After 1st Nagorno-karabakh war Armenia govt. drove away all the Azerbaijanis from Nagorno-karabakh as well as 7 surrounding district.
Вы видимо не ожидали что придется расплачиваться за агрессию и 30 лет оккупации азербайджанских земель. Будете расплачиваться ещё долго.
they made themselves alone, and now they are playing the victim!
😂no one believes in azerbaijan lies. Infact here in the USA no one had even heard of azerbaijan.
Stay strong Armenia, Georgia stands with you 🇬🇪🇦🇲
Ateş olsanız curmunuz kadar yer yakarsınız Gürcistan Ermenistanin yanında olsa ne yazar siz kendinizi ne sanıyorsunuz aslında size cevap yazmak bile doğru değil Karabağ Azerbaycandir o kadar
NO.
Really? Then free Javakh and let them unite with Armenia.
Thank you
Don‘t speak for Georgia
First of all, A youtube chanel making documentaries should not have been this much ignorant... The So called Mountain Ararat (real name: Ağrı Dağı ) have belong to Turkish states for almost 1000 years, not 100 years... Secondly, Armenians have to stop behaving this much offensive against their neighbours... They still talking about taking lands from their neighbours... This is a very worrying situation...
"The current international boundaries were formed throughout the 20th century. The mountain came under Turkish control during the 1920 Turkish-Armenian War. It formally became part of Turkey according to the 1921 Treaty of Moscow and Treaty of Kars." - Mount Ararat Wikipedia Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Mount_Ararat
@@Ryuk_Judge Now I'm starting to believe that you are deliberately distorting the history... When did Mount Ararat become part of Armenia? When was a state called Armenia established? Where is Armenia in the Ottoman-Russian wars from the 18th to the 19th centuries? 15.,16.,17.,18. century, where is Armenia in these centuries? With whom did the Ottomans sign the Kars Treaty in 1920? Which dynasties existed in Iran from the 16th century to the 20th century? When was the name Persian Empire last used? Don't try to deceive the world with nonsense and false information anymore...
@@bubulimi 1# "Don't try to deceive th", I wasn't deceiving anyone, I provided you my source. 2# I never said the mountain was ever established to be part of the Armenian state, even though it was under the control of the Armenian Kingdom, I just pointed out it was only established to be part of Turkey 100 years ago. 3# Ararat got its name Ararat (Western Armenian pronunciation: Ararad) is the Biblical Hebrew name cognate with Assyrian Urartu, of a kingdom that existed in the Armenian Highlands in the 9th-6th centuries BC. The mountain was named after the Urartu people who Armenians are a descendant of. 4# Urartu is the Assyrian pronunciation of Ararat, since the Kingdom of Ararat (historically accurate name of Urartu) was located on Mount Ararat of the Armenian highlands. The people and area who lived in this area was the Armenian kingdom of Ararat (in Assyrian: Urartu). Armenians lived here for nearly 3000 years. #5 You asked many questions and didn't give any answers so I will answer the for you, since I already answered "When did Mount Ararat become part of Armenia?" 6# Question:"When was a state called Armenia established?". Answer: The Kingdom of Greater Armenia was established in 190 BC by Artaxias I, founder of the Artaxiad dynasty. The Kingdom of Armenia rose to the peak of its influence in the 1st century BC under Tigranes the Great before falling under Roman suzerainty. 7# Questions:"15.,16.,17.,18. century, where is Armenia in these centuries?" and "Where is Armenia in the Ottoman-Russian wars from the 18th to the 19th centuries?". Answer: In the 15.,16., Armenian political independence was largely brought to an end by a wave of invasions and migrations by Turkic-speaking peoples beginning in the 11th century, and in the 15th and 16th centuries the region was secured by the Ottoman Turks and integrated into the vast Ottoman Empire. Armenians retained a strong sense of communal identity, however, embodied in the Armenian language and the Armenian Church. That sense of distinctiveness was fostered by the Ottoman millet system, which accorded non-Muslim minorities significant administrative and social autonomy. The great majority of Armenians were poor peasants, but a few found success as merchants and artisans. Armenians' involvement in international trade led in the 17th and 18th centuries to the establishment of significant Armenian settlements in Istanbul and other Ottoman port cities and as far away as India and Europe. Between the 16th and 19th centuries, the traditional Armenian homeland composed of Eastern Armenia and Western Armenia came under the rule of the Ottoman and Persian empires, repeatedly ruled by either of the two over the centuries. By the 19th century, Eastern Armenia had been conquered by the Russian Empire, while most of the western parts of the traditional Armenian homeland remained under Ottoman rule. During World War I, 1.5 million Armenians living in their ancestral lands in the Ottoman Empire were systematically exterminated in the Armenian genocide. In 1918, following the Russian Revolution, all non-Russian countries declared their independence after the Russian Empire ceased to exist, leading to the establishment of the First Republic of Armenia. By 1920, the state was incorporated into the Soviet Union. The modern Republic of Armenia became independent in 1991 during the dissolution of the Soviet Union. 8# Question: "With whom did the Ottomans sign the Kars Treaty in 1920?". Answer: Signatories of the Treaty of Kars included representatives from the Grand National Assembly of Turkey, which would declare the Republic of Turkey in 1923, and from the Armenian, Azerbaijani and Georgian Socialist Soviet Republics with the participation of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic. Armenia was still trying to recover from the Armenian Genocide that Turkey carried out. If Armenia wasn't in this recover state and wasn't being pressured by the other countries and leaders having to do with this treaty the outcome may have been different. 9# Question: "Which dynasties existed in Iran from the 16th century to the 20th century?". Answer: Safavid dynasty, (1501-1736), ruling dynasty of Iran whose establishment of Twelver Shiʿism as the state religion of Iran was a major factor in the emergence of a unified national consciousness among the various ethnic and linguistic elements of the country. Qājār dynasty, the ruling dynasty of Iran from 1794 to 1925. 10# Question:"When was the name Persian Empire last used?". Answer: The exonym Persia was the official name of Iran in the Western world before March 1935, but the Iranian peoples inside their country since the time of Zoroaster (probably circa 1000 BC), or even before, have called their country Arya, Iran, Iranshahr, Iranzamin (Land of Iran), Aryānām (the equivalent of Iran in the proto-Iranian language) or its equivalents. 11# I hope that answered your questions. All the answers I gave were searched and are what the same answers given by most historians, sites, and videos, when researching the topic/question.
@@Ryuk_Judge Sociology and history cannot be explained by copy-pasting from websites... That's what I'm saying... That's why I say the videos were made ignorantly. Every answer is a good support.... If you just say that Mount Agri became Turkish territory 100 years ago, it would be understood that it was Armenian territory before that, so Armenians want it back. You wouldn't be telling the truth. But if the state established in 1991, while there has been no Armenian state for 1000 years, claims rights on Turkish lands, this is called aggression... First, get some education to eliminate your ignorance, then get some training on transferring resources... then you can continue with the videos.... In addition, This current aggression by Armenia has nothing to do with 1915... You are sharing inaccurate comments on this subject, as well. They committed great massacres in the Ottoman Empire during ww1 and in the 1990s, they committed great massacres in Karabakh. You call this post-traumatic stress disorder? nonsense....
@@bubulimi " Sociology and history cannot be explained by copy-pasting from websites". Buddy, those websites were made by researchers and people who studied history, and they put all their information on that topic on the website. Did you think I was going to take your word for it and not do research? I searched up the questions for answered and I copied and pasted the answers to show you the truth. Where do you get your information from then if not the internet? "If you just say that Mount Agri became Turkish territory 100 years ago, it would be understood that it was Armenian territory before that, so Armenians want it back. You wouldn't be telling the truth. But if the state established in 1991, while there has been no Armenian state for 1000 years, claims rights on Turkish lands, this is called aggression", Mount Ararat was part of the Urartu Kingdom and later the Armenian Kingdom for thousands of years. If you took time to do your research, you would know this. The fact that Turkey had "claims rights" is not true, being known that the Armenian people and their ancestors have been an influence for the name of the mountain, Ararat is what Assyrians called the Urartu people who are the ancestors of Armenians. Not to mention Turkey committed the Armenian genocide which they don't even acknowledge. "While there has been no Armenian state for 1000 years", I would like to know where you're getting this information from, because there has been an Armenian state since the Armenian Kingdom was established. " First, get some education to eliminate your ignorance", excuse me but I did got education on this topic when I researched this topic before replying to you, and then after I responded you said, " Sociology and history cannot be explained by copy-pasting from websites", and you seemed to not understand that those websites I was copying and pasting from were made by historians who studied history for many years. "Then get some training on transferring resources", the information that I gave can be found from a simple google search of the questions you asked, and the top website that shows up to give the answer to your question answer. It's very simple, so I felt no need to site the source because all I did was google search and click on the top website that showed up, I read through the information. "Then you can continue with the videos", what videos? "This current aggression by Armenia has nothing to do with 1915", it has absolutely to do with 1915. Imagine someone does something horrible to you and ruins your family's life and then they say it never happened. "You are sharing inaccurate comments on this subject, as well.", well then, I guess the historians who studied and researched the past for years are wrong. "They committed great massacres in the Ottoman Empire during ww1 and in the 1990s, they committed great massacres in Karabakh.", what are you talking about? Have you ever done research on the Armenian genocide? Turkish people committed massacres on Armenian people, you can look this up, please do your research before making such statements. "You call this post-traumatic stress disorder? nonsense", I never called it that, so I don't know where you're getting that from. But if you're talking about Armenians being mad about the Armenian genocide, they have a right to be, horrible things were done to them. Do your research.
Extremely biased video
But why they have so many enemies? How come a nation with history and culture (as they say) can get so many enemies? Are they really innocent as they try to show to the whole world? Perhaps the problem is in armenians themselves, isnt it?
This is a religious war, They want all Islamic neighbors and Armenia is stopping that. This was also the same reason turkey committed the Armenian genocide, which was really a genocide of all Christians in turkey. Christian's, Muslims, and Jews, have been having wars with each other recently, and its mostly because of religion.
Claiming territories to their neighbours Azerbaijan ( Karabakh ), Eastern Turkey and Javakheti in Georgia, and playing the role of victim :))))) Among enemies :)))
😂you forgot to mention hiw Azerbaijan has claims to northern Iran. 🙄
I pray for Azerbaijan. Armenians left Karabakh voluntarily, and Azeris never used weapons when they left. Why Armenia has so many enemies? Maybe they have learned to live in peace with their neighbours? I wonder why all Armenian neighbours hate them? Can you please ask them next time? They show themselves as victims, but in reality, they are not.
Can you tell us who from the region doesn't hate turks . I'll give you some examples. Greeks Bulgarians Arabs Kurds Assyrians Persians You koyunloo herders always make stupid claims.
We will always be there. My beautiful ARMENIA 🇦🇲 is strong 💪🏻
Armenia Stay Strong , you have 3000 years old history.
😂
3000? Most humans have hundreds thousands years of history. Maybe armenians are just starting to evolve
you are wrong Armenia have 8000 years old history
Karabakh and Zangezur is Azerbaijan!
Troublemaker found
Azerbaijan is 🇮🇷
its Syunik, not Zangezur Amina koyim
What a poor peace of "unbiased" journalism:)
For me, it is unclear why Armenian people always start speaking about 2000 years ago. The borders change constantly, nations win wars, and nations lose wars. However, the reality of the modern world is that internationally recognized borders of the countries must be respected, no matter who ethnically lives there. Armenian people of Karabakh have the right to be Azerbaijani citizens and live at home. There is no point in being radical, dogmatic, or unnecessarily emotional about it. Armenian people will be happier when they look at the world more rationally
You tell me.why Azerbaijan claims all of armenia as "historic Azerbaijan land along with north iran? Hypocrisy at its best
My family bible from 1896 is older than Azerbaijan
Oh so jungle rule should be acceptable for you as long as you're stealing someone else's land, but once you're done stealing, your borders should be recognized? Gotta love Aliyev logic, eh.
@@eric6616 Azerbaijan is the remnant of the Iravan Khanate, Iravan Khanate was a part of Selchuk and later Iranian and Ottoman rule. From the 960s to the 1910s, there was not a single Armenian state in the area that is always called the Armenian Highlands.
@@alaattintufan9408 Istanbul was greek Constantinople and "Anatolia" was Armenian highlands until the Turkic nomads from far east came so you see there is no such thing as Turkey , THERE NEVER WAS. GET OUT OF MY LAND.
Love Azerbaycan.
09:24 Mount agri is part of Turkey for exactly 100 years. because turkey founded exactly 100 years ago, but in practice of course it is 1000 years.
Хотя мы и враги в политике, нас связывают исторические узы дружбы. тем не менее, я не ненавижу армян. нет плохой нации, есть хорошие и плохие люди. Я люблю армян и народы всех культур. Желаю мира нашему Южному Кавказу и всему миру, никакой войны. ❤️🩹❤️🇦🇿🫂🇦🇲❤️🩹❤️
Another single-sided tv show that fuels unrealistic Armenian aspirations. Not a single Azeri voice! This kind of biased programs don't help Armenians and undermine peace efforts.