Somalia justice
2012 ж. 28 Қаз.
149 422 Рет қаралды
In Somalia, justice can mean forgiveness, money or execution. Jamal Osman travels to Bossasso to report. This report was filmed by Ahmed Farah.
In Somalia, justice can mean forgiveness, money or execution. Jamal Osman travels to Bossasso to report. This report was filmed by Ahmed Farah.
Alhamdulilah this is the true justice. Love to my brothers in Somalia from Eritrea 🇪🇷✊🏾
Please don’t say alhamdulilah Islam teaches forgiveness if we keep killing each other welll never have peace and prosperity we need to learn how to move on and rebuild the country
@@daviroza4700 how can you talk when you have Osama as your name? These brother are following sharia law and it’s fair.
@@waleedsied3837 kzhead.info/sun/l62YnLJ-hKKdrYk/bejne.html
@@waleedsied3837 no their not
this is justice, not giving a a murderer 30 plus years of shelter, food, and entertainment.
Suliman haQ lol, justice based on words. Not facts. I hope you get treated by the Somali justice system and hope your innocent and trialed as guilty because I’m pretty sure the majority of the time you will be seen as guilty
3 years.... what are you talking about 30??
for a murderer yes but in Sharia law gays , apostates & adulterers also get the death sentence , ie: murdered.
@@RollingEasy wtf. This person killed someone. He will get the same curtsey. He killed a person, he dies because of a punishment.
@@patc7573 there is a reason why you people are arrogant. Read the Quran and learn the shariah law. There is a reason why countries like Indonesia have almost 0% Roberys, shootings, fightings and most importantly fitna. Compare it to the UK, gangs, drugs. Stabbing, innocent people dead. Abortion rates rising. Which country is more peaceful. And by the way showing that your gay Is against the law in sharia based countries. Respect the belief and go somewhere else.
Do not say Somali sharia law say it islamic sharia law
@Youssef Houaoui 🖕🖕
@yohan John Death row is even in the USA and other countries, i am happy that the Somalia are not corrupt, an accused persons wife died of natural causes and the court released him, the court system there is more efficient than those found in some corrupt countries.
@yohan John go live in Europe
Application of Sharia varies by country so its not incorrect to say "Somali sharia law".
The translation is as accurate and meaningful as it could be.
if u kill some one innocent intentionally you will be killed that is justice
This system would be great if there was real justice system in the country, and the lives of the people were in better situation. Sometimes is just accusations without physical evidence or proof of guilty beyond doubt. It is scary situation if you can imagine. Tribalism, revenge and corruption is pretty much in every step of the way.
These judges aren't corrupt I can tell you that with my life. But they could be too harsh and sometimes accusations without evidence could get more credibility than they deserve. I am not entirely sure on this though.
Don't you think at least they trying their best, better than most places in Somalia.
Corrupt? He just admitted to human trafficking. Putting ppl in boats, collecting money to send them to Yemen. We all know their date. Are you blindly following a strangers story bc he’s painting himself innocent in all the mess
point of correction Qisas is nt tradditional it's our islamic law we follow and life of it we have to follow our creator's law nt man made law you r speaking like that and claim u r muslim😯😯
Saxix
its not the 15th century its the 21st now grow up jesus
+Ibrahim Musa I know that am not choosing the violent way but My debate is Qisas is nt traditional it's Islamic law u have to understand my point u idiot
+Hybriđ Jesus ppuh is one of our most respected prophets of Allah
So your saying God Allah wants you killing someone else. Please don't be stupid no God will give anyone permission to kill .
I am fluent in both Somali & English and i am here to vouch that the translation is mostly accurate
He said he received a call at 1am but the transaction reads as 7am , when it comes to time east African time can confuse if you didn't get use to it. Otherwise, it's fine
98% accurate and please don’t make me rewatch and quote!
Is that how ur english is fluent ? while the reporter is saying Mohammed is sharing in the cell 40 other man instead of men
@Ancient Rageedi he said his son apty which is his bro in law
He kill his wife and they say“ it was Allahs will“... What a ridiculous law HE KILLED HIS WIFE...And the judge set him free...
kristy ann what hillbilly nonsense are you talking about?
Man I feel both mothered pain , the one that’s dealing with the loss of her son and the one who’s going to lose her son😭
Mothers will always be on the side of their sons. No matter what. That’s human nature. But justice has to be served
This is cold but eye for an eye is fair to me honestly like how would the victim’s family feel if the man who killed their beloved son/daughter is still breathing. If they choose to forgive him then it’s their choice!!
Qisaas is the best way to solve problems like this ALXAMDULILAAH cala nimcatul islaam The murders of my both parents r still alive. We r waiting them judgement day
May Allaah give you and your loved ones sabr. In Shaa Allaah you will do Dua for those murderers to guide them, forgive them and reunite you and them and your parents in the highest location of paradise.
Anigana kii abahay dilay wuu nola lkn last week buu dhintay ban maqaly
@@heathcliff89 amiin amiin
May Allah forgive all our brothers and sisters
May Allah fgive us all
@@fahadmohamud1132 It is your Allah who started this wicked laws in muslim dominated countries. Your Allah is not the true and living God. The true and living God is love, mercy, long suffering, slow to anger, quickness to forgive, and forever graceful to all. The true and living God loves us so much that he came to earth in human form, suffered and died to reinstate God to man. If such things were happening in Christian countries, you and you fellow muslims would be crying out foul against us. Only in Mulim countries by your overseer god (Allah), are such wickedness allowed for the public to see.
well you got to ask your ethiopean neighbors about that
Wow! I love the idea of equal retaliation. So much evil and killing would be avoided by way of it.
feeling sorry to that mother of the killer who's told to pay 20000$ yet can't afford.
She can't even afford her rent😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
What's the song in the beginning
It’s almost impossible to translate word by word. Therefore this’s the most accurate you can get!!
Tbh in all of mercy I would let the guy pay me or let him go if he is poor....Allah will do the judging for me...is Allah who takes and gives life
Yes. And He has given us the right to execute murderers. Remember at times, your prophet was not forgiving and had to execute his traitors. As with all crucial matters, great discernment, time, and scrutiny are required to cast judgement. Everything is circumstantial
Correct bro
until you realise allah is fake and he murders another man
I know this old man he lost his three sons by this way so sad story really 😢
"We don't give a damn." Savage.
@@kkkkiller5109 I was quoting the video, dumbass.
KKK Killer if you kill its fair to kill you to unless a family forgives you but you didn’t forgive the man you kill
@@basedblackbeard4456 what are you excatly quoting about the video
It is not Somali sharia law it is the sharea of allah subhanahu wata ala
FYI the Family Doesn’t Kill the Killer themselves, that would be traumatising them even further. The state, elders or people in charge handle it but since the war there is not much organisation. the Mentally Ill are Never killed because they don’t know right from wrong.
True that's exactly what I had in mind, this mf report is misleading the audience
The translations are wrong
It actually made me to shade tears
This is very just actually if you murdered someone you should be able to pray the price
Sad but everyone should pay for their crimes
... beautiful concept... the victim-family get the satisfaction of deciding the fate... the struggle and hardship endured to get the blood-money give the accused-family a taste of the the agony of the victim-family.
How can u ask a poor woman for 20k?
Can he get his sons life back..... No amount of MONEY can bring it back.....
I felt so sorry for his mother her sons life is determined on 20000 dollars which she does not have
This is justice the family chooses whether to kill the murderer with their own hands or take blood money estimated at 20,000 USD or forgive
Where would a poor mother get $20,000...it is sad to lose a son/daughter but that old man should just forgive him.
There is a difference between rushing when you kill a man due to a sense of guilt or rushing away because you've finished and you'd rather not gloat and watch a dead body. I doubt that there is guilt in attaining your long wished for justice.
actually i wondered why some of these people kill others! pay the way if u kill someone u will be killed
Im Proud My Country 🇸🇴 Implements The Islamic Laws✊💯...Whoever Kills A Soul, Unless for Murder or For Spreading Corruption in the Land, it is as Tho he has Slained Mankind Entirely 🌍. Quran 5:32 💯
Is it illegal to use tooth-brushes in islam? And, just how many meters down do the graves reach? Looks like the graves are about 4 meters deep. Do they think that if the grave was only 1.5 meters, that the dead person would escape?
4:12 That ringtone caught me off guard.
It’s best if they just execute the killers quickly. Imagine the stress and guilt for the poor mother knowing she could keep him alive but she has no way at all to get the £20k. The situation is killing her as well.
That shows how our people are justice🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
However, I feel very bad for the murderer's mother as she might have to be solely responsible for paying the blood money. It would be fairer to let the son work in order to provide the blood money, all under supervision.
R
5
Hooyooyin maxaa ladhibey hooydaas maanta hadaan lacag kufilan hayo waan udiri laha. Aad ban oga xumhay.
It has to be said, This system reeks with lack of education, lack of understanding fair trail, lack of human emotional intelligence. All those elements combined represents Somali's past and current state.
Somalia’s past? Really? I suggest you look into Somalia pre civil war before making such statements.
I'm afraid I don't have the time to look into Somalia's past, I know Somalia was a democracy state before greed and corruption took over. My statement was solely directed with the status of Somalia's current dismay. I'm Somali myself, However, America and the UK have driven the nation into more of a division than union. I would suggest we get rid of the current President or any other potential who are nothing puppets and who are giving the go-to Al-Shabab and other terrorist groups in Somali to assassinate Innocent professionals who committed to changing our nation to a better state.
Oh really? Should I take your little narrative notion to a consideration? instead of pointing out my strong, truthful statement to your own misconception interpretation which YOU who don't have any validation of the points that I made above, is not worth my time. Such negative interpretation of words and close-minded individuals such as you and the other guy (Wynapse) who didn't even understand my statements above are the very people who part take stopping individuals like (ME) to bring forth ideas and I mean... truthful, harsh, reality Ideas. If that deems me as ignorant, prejudice, bitter and racist(tribalism favouritism) .. Then well I'm guilty.. lool. Grow up and do contribute something worth talking about. P.S Please I don't have time to entertain, alternatively have something worth talking about (positive thoughts, good ideas of worth talking about, ideas and ways to suggest to improve the system shown on the video.)
This system is Sharia Law (Islamic law) So what is the system that you speak of System of Juhala( Ignorant)?
Are you really a Somali or not?
its weird bc it says his brother in law called him n said he died at sea, so how does a dead man call n say that!!
Back in 2012 camels valued around $900 if a man’s life Is valued for 100 camels. do the math his blood money should be around $90000 not $ 20000 according to what he said Jamal you got it wrong brother like you always do Bad bad Journalist. An individual who likes to broadcast the negative side of his own people. My god help these poor country.
You nailed it bro. He is evil and stupid journalist not deserve to have access in Somalia
🤣😂 very true indeed
I agree with this!!!
Jamal you need to increase your knowledge before translating somali to English.
Nuridin Omar agree with you most of his translation isn’t accurate
The translation from Somali to English is mostly wrong.
As long as u gat the idea 🙏apprciate their effort 😇
Jamal in ad dadkada masakinta dhibatadoda iyo cebahoda ad lacag ka radiso ama shaqo ka dhigato wa dib u dhac na hesto e walal iska da barnamijyada folxun ebow pls
I love Africa ❤️
Give justice to the subtitle please.
😢😢😢 this is sad 💔
This system of allowing the victims to choose doesn’t work and needs to be abolished.Bringing these people back in society is not safe. You do the crime you do the time!
The are doing the right thing
man that is some crazy logic
Somali sharia law first time I heard of it.
The reporter is great lair 5:21 "he said tradionaly called Qisaas but its fake it is religeously qisaas'kill' "so he must insure what he said
He said Judicial. Your grasp of the english language is weak, don't comment as if you're fluent. You're wrong.
This could be leading in our country bcz we are so proud of cultures where ever we are living thts must be good way
Sorry mum
Oh really? Should I take your little narrative notion to a consideration? instead of pointing out my strong, truthful statement to your own misconception interruption which YOU who don't have any validation of the points that I made above, is not worth my time. Such negative interruption of words and close-minded individuals such as you and the other guy (Wynapse) who didn't even understand my statements above are the very people who part take stopping individuals like (ME) to bring forth ideas and I mean... truthful, harsh, reality Ideas. If that deems me as ignorant, prejudice, bitter and racist(tribalism favouritism) .. Then well I'm guilty.. lool. Grow up and do contribute something worth talking about. P.S Please I don't have time to entertain, alternatively have something worth talking about (positive thoughts, good ideas of worth talking about, ideas and ways to suggest to improve the system shown on the video.)
Translation are wrong
I was 10 years old when witnessed neighbors son taken to be excuted his mother cooked him his last meal while crying and was taken in a car and we never saw him again The Family had enough money/ camels to pay to the victims Family but they refused and want to kill him 😢😢😢
what kind of court is this fake court
Bring all the Somalies here . we will take care of them. We have plenty
2010 baa xabsiga bosaaso iskula xirneeen sanbaara wall allaha ku fududeeyo howsha
Its crazy how the reporter is somali and half of what he’s translating is absolutely wrong. This is the second documentary I’ve seen of him translating his words wrongly. It’s like he’s doing it on purpose because he’s translating the serious thing wrongfully and it’s started to seem like he wants to make somalis look bad. If I wasn’t somali I would think somalia was the most disgusting country ever from what he’s telling his viewers.find another reporter or learn the language before u translate.
interesting. what are they REALLY SAYING?
whoa what kinda fucked up place is that? WEIRD!!!!
Qofki naf alle ku galabsado ha leeska cafiyo geerido waa dhacdaa anigaba walalkey asago waxba galabsan ayaa rag yaqaan dileen alla ha raxma inta dhimatay
Abshir Damac ciyaal waaberi murder Alle ya rahama
Jamal Osman he is in jail tonight 😢😢
Translations are so bad
Bro are u working as a youtube viewer lol.i saw you every where
This was way back in 2012 did they kill him or forgive him. This Somali system is fucked up that's why we have no peace
Barina saw qofkale dilimayo hadi laso dayo wa waxa ina rogay waxasi.
He should of forgave him and Allah Swt would have rewarded him tremendously
Qofki qof islam ah dilo in ladilo diinta ayaa na farayso cafiskana waxaa is kale waalidka dhibanaha ah ama diyo ha qaataan ama ha iska daayaan ayaga aya iqtiyaarka iska leh allahu waclam
I like it since it fair
Answers a call from his dead brother saying he died in the sea hahha
Listen again plz! He said his brother in law(uncle to his son) made a call to him informing that his son is dead. So the one who died is not the brother in law but the son that old man
May god bless our motherland isnhallah 🇸🇴
Nice people living in a nice country. Please remain there and keep up the good work.
Oh shut up
Wariyaha inaa aflagaadada lagu dhigo weeye dadka soo commentgaraynaaya shaqadiisii wuu kasoo baxay Somalidana muuqaal iyo war sax ah buu ka dhiibay, haday runto ku dhibayso waydii naftaada maxay kuu dhibaysaa runto lkn Wariye Jamal osman waa nin somali ah oo jecel inuu soomalida hambabariyana oo uu aragtidooda yara balaadhiyo
From the beginning the narrative seems to be skeptical and doubtful about the QISAS. The journalist seems to be biased ABOUT the QISAS ...AND that is wrong is ain't a cultural things but is the shariah of ALLAH MY ADVICE FOR THE JOURNALIST MIND YOUR LANGUAGE AND YOUR TONE AND DON'T TALK ABOUT THINGS YOU GOT NOT KNOWLEDGE...THANKS
Yooxanaa 3:16 Ilaah intuu dunida jacayl u qabay ayuu siiyey Wiilkiisa keligiis ah, in mid kastoo isaga rumaystaa uusan lumin laakiinse uu lahaado nolosha weligeed ah. Yooxanaa 14:6 - Ciise wuxuu ugu jawaabay, "Anigu waxaan ahay jidka iyo runta iyo nolosha. Ninna Aabbaha uma yimaado, xaggayguu ku yimaado maahee.
4 canal good news
.
Crazy frog ringtone🤣🤣
Was Mohammad eventually killed? 😢
If you kill my brother why i want to spare you , i don't get it. Yes kill anyone kill.
Mortal combat them song in the background as a guy is about to be sentenced to death feels bad man Edit:he already got sentenced to death
Mortal combat? Nah, its crazy frog.
these judges need to stop caring Saudi Wahhabi sharia laws of version
It create new murderer
Subhanallah, this law is from the heaven, it's the path tbat our lord order us. Qisas isn't a retailiation.!😢
Is fake justis .only poor.manority suffer..ppl wit major tribe.dont go down like dat.we all know
They all go but mostly they pay for the death
munaafaqadda aan ka dhex arkey barnaamijka waxaa ka kow ah kolkey islaanta hooyada ahi leedahey 20000$ halkaan ka keenayaa ilaahey uun baa i siin kara haddaad u fiirsataan af-naqa amba tarajumidda ku soo dari-maayaan ilaahey uun baa keeni kara.
"Somalia is often referred to as a failed state..." "With poverty ever present..."
Very wrong in many,many levels
I don't agree with u darling these ideological options for the victim's family because basically it's whatever that makes the victim's family happy nd hopefully the killer learns from he's or her's mistake if not I doubt there'll be a second chance
Allah is god islam is 100 practiced in Somalia. So why all this killing and torture. How can someone simply just accept islam is peaceful. I hope somalian will rebuild bring peace unity and growth to their country.
It's not practiced 100%. People wouldn't kill each other in Somalia if they did practice. No innocent life can be taken by any human being, that's the law of Islam.
What God will order (sharia law) or say to you take someone else life. That is not God but psychopath. Education, Education, Education.
Its wisdom that you missing to comprehend it yet. Almighty Allah decreed Qasas ( execution of the murderer) as a last resort in order to save the rest of both families/tribes from fighting over this issue. There other options such as taking blood money, forgiveness ( this one is most favorite by the almighty Allah that he said in quran encouraging forgiveness " And the retribution for an evil act is an evil one like it, but whoever pardons and makes reconciliation - his reward is [due] from Allah . Indeed, He does not like wrongdoers."42:40). However, is Qasas is the last option to check or stop human violence. I hope you get my point.
Order in society is kept in check by consequences
@@testing-je7yz By taking someone's life. What sin can justify killing seriously and if you still believe in that then your no different from the bad person.
Boring
The tree options is not a traditional thing it's the Islamic Sharia law and it's the only correct, just and fair judgment for the humanity because it's the law of Allah SW the Creator of All universe. Important is you have to apply Sharia correctly and thoroughly not pieces here and there or mixed with man made laws
*no wonder somalia is ... the poorest of poor*
Is it crime to be poor European wad poor before 100 years ago & still they're poor people in Europe,
Shut up Jew