Russian SS - A Brief History of the Kaminski Brigade
One of the little known collaborationist SS units during WWII was the Kaminski Brigade consisting of Russians. They earned a terrible reputation for murder and violence against civilian populations on the Eastern Front and a during the Warsaw Uprising.
Dr. Mark Felton is a well-known British historian, the author of 22 non-fiction books, including bestsellers 'Zero Night' and 'Castle of the Eagles', both currently being developed into movies in Hollywood. In addition to writing, Mark also appears regularly in television documentaries around the world, including on The History Channel, Netflix, National Geographic, Quest, American Heroes Channel and RMC Decouverte. His books have formed the background to several TV and radio documentaries. More information about Mark can be found at: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Fe...
Help support my channels:
www.paypal.me/markfeltonprodu...
/ markfeltonproductions
Disclaimer: All opinions and comments expressed in the 'Comments' section do not reflect the opinions of Mark Felton Productions. All opinions and comments should contribute to the dialogue. Mark Felton Productions does not condone written attacks, insults, racism, sexism, extremism, violence or otherwise questionable comments or material in the 'Comments' section, and reserves the right to delete any comment violating this rule or to block any poster from the channel.
Credits: US National Archives; Library of Congress; Bundesarchiv
I've always thought it was interesting how the Waffen SS started with a bloodline requirement then progressed into a sort of foreign legion of everyone and anyone.
They still got strong rules for them
Though not about the Nachtagale Division SS?
that tends to happen when you have to start arming 13 year olds
It's called desperation and they were full of s*** to begin with.
Manpower issue for one.
"Assorted psychos". An obscure technical term used by some historians. Dr. Felton is the best!
Men without morals who would do the most horrible things imaginable which is very sick
When you study war and genocide, "assorted psychos," becomes an all too common phrase.
@@spectreandromedus8661 Sad but true Germany, Soviet Union, Cambodia, Rwanda + many more
For the German forces in Poland during WWII to be disgusted and embarrassed by them gives some indication as to the depths this brigade had sank to.
@@spectreandromedus8661 I believe it's kind of like the 2022 Russo-Ukraine War. The Russians took heavy losses marching on Kyiv, so they took their (collective?) anger out on the local civilians. They arrived with one mindset and left with another... I suppose the question is, did they become psychos due to battle or was it a predisposition due to their societal values? 🤔
Mark Felton is not a KZheadr, he is a professional mini-documentary producer/writer/director/editor and everything else he does. I believe the standards of these kinds of “videos” are set by mr. Felton. God knows how many ppl try to make these videos and fall far short
He is also a you tuber' soft lad.
This is the future, I watch what I want to watch instantly, he is a KZheadr or I would have never heard of him. Yeah since then I have noticed him in documentary’s with a fact here and there. I think he’s brilliant and I trust his words, he’s a great man, but thank god he’s on KZhead.
@@SGTDuckButter i dont think you understood the compliment. Mr.Felton uses the platform youtube to distribute his content. The term youtuber i use is to describe amateurs trying to copy and imitate real professionals like Mark.
I agree 💯!!!Mark Felton is in his own league!
He isn't much different than many other History Tubers, I mean beyond the channels specifically for none enthusiast. Simple History for example doesn't count as a proper History Tube Channel, in my opinion of course... among other examples. There are a number of proper channels who are either History teachers, or Historians themselves, and in all respects if you're researching history and producing even if it's content on youtube, which would make you a youtuber still even if you're a writer, or historian on top of that. Publishing content on youtube as an individual makes you a youtuber regardless of what you do outside of youtube. History Hustle for example is a History Teacher, so is the Metatron. Aviation History Visualized has published more than one book thus far, so he is more than just a youtuber as well. TIKHistory might as well start publishing his content proper, because boy I'd love to see him start getting books published, some of his videos might as well be called audio books with tons of citations and proper references. That being said, many history focused youtube channels just regurgitate information which doesn't help the discussion and progression of our understanding of history which is fine/dandy but that isn't really what a historian does in my opinion. As the job of a historian is to discover history, find things other historians might of missed or overlooked, and help make history more and more accurate over time, not just regurgitate. This is why I welcome when a channel post all the sources they used and even proper citations, even if you may not agree with their conclusions.
I forget where I read it but a contributing factor to Kaminski getting the axe was his unit started going after German nurses at Warsaw as well.
Isn't that something that Dirlewanger or the Soviets would do?
How awful do you have to be to have the German forces kick you out of Warsaw after becoming disgusted with what you’re doing? I can’t even imagine.
When the Devil invites you into their city and after a while they are sickened by your actions say’s a lot. 🏴❤️
Yeah that is something to think about
I mean drilwanger was active in Warsaw at the same time
Dirlewanger was not only a rapist, super alcoholic , murderer, and overall lover of all kinds of violence, he was even "allegedly" into necrophilia. These Kaminski characters were probably cut from the same baleful cloth.
You’re a moron. The German forces were compromised of honorable men. At least, the percentage of honorable men within the German ranks during the Second World War was the highest amongst any of the nations involved in the conflict. There were atrocities on all sides. Especially amongst the Soviet and Japanese ranks. People immediately associate all German soldiers in the war with death camps and mass genocide, even though less than 1% of 1% of the troops were even aware of any such activities, let alone actively partook in them. But hey, if you want to frame the entire war through the lens of post-war American propaganda mixed in with denazification and Israeli propaganda than go ahead I guess…
Honestly one of the most underrated history channels on this entire website
Except that he occasionally engages in Allied propoganda, such as when he accused the Army of committing war crimes in Afrika, which did not happen.
@@mikeggg5671 oh yeah you were there to testify I'm sure bud 😂
agreed patrick.
@@giantmanice no, but my grandfather was
@@mnbv990 sometimes he puts out amazing material, and then other times he simply spews leftist, anti-german propaganda. It's really sad. He will wow me with one video, and then come out with tripe like this in another
According to WikiPedia this happened to Kaminski: Heinrich Himmler used the misconduct of the Warsaw group as a pretext for having Kaminski and his leadership executed after trial by court martial in Litzmannstadt (Łódź). They were tried for stealing the property of the Reich, as the stolen property was to have been delivered to Himmler, but Kaminski and his men had attempted to keep it for themselves.Also executed with Kaminski was brigade chief-of-staff Waffen-Obersturmbannführer Ilya Shavykin. The men of the brigade were given the false explanation that Kaminski had been killed by Polish partisans. When Kaminski's men rejected this explanation, the Gestapo took Kaminski's car, pushed it into a ditch, shot it up with a machine gun, and smeared goose blood all over it, as evidence. The demoralized unit was soon moved out of town and stationed to the north, far from any partisan activity. The death of Kaminski and the unreliability of his troops as a combat unit brought the plans to expand the Kaminski Brigade to a division to an end. After Kaminski's death, his unit was placed under the command of SS-Brigadeführer and Generalmajor der Polizei Christoph Diehm
So is this correct then, or? Mr Felton, a comment on the WikiPedia info, would be much appreciated? : )
@@Superknullisch And why would it not be right? Cause morons that dont know how to check references on the page say it was wrong a few times? Wiki is as inaccurate as any non specialized encyklopedia. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronislav_Kaminski#References
Makes sense really the Germans killing them due to disgust doesnt fit but failing to give Himmler his cut yeah that makes much more sense.
@@Superknullisch The Doc mentions this as one of the possibilities but specifically says it is unclear. The only reference for that entire section is a single book by a Polish historian. Considering the love of the Germans for bureaucracy I find that odd that the book's contents have not been corroborated elsewhere, or the book even translated into English. I'd say leave it at unclear.
Yeah Wikipedia is notoriously inaccurate, if you’re relying on that for truth you can forget it. Stick to academic historians not Joe public who just keep their favourite pet pages looking just how they like. You ever tried to edit a Wikipedia page? Anything you put in that upsets someone is removed, no matter how well you reference it. Welcome to wokepedia
Mr Felton again a professionally narration of events taken decades ago. If you allow me to add , WW2 has so many facets to it, that is almost impossible to know every single one . But You are doing a good job though . Thank you.
I noticed something upon second viewing. I believe that the picture at 1:58 was actually taken when Wheremaht and Red Army cooperated in conquering the Polish Republic in 1939. It appears that at least one of the Soviet soldiers (the tankist on the right) didn't feel particularly comfortable with his new, temporary German allies.
Good eye Artur! I believe you are correct, and the photo looks quite familiar.
Definitely a weary expression
4 of my relatives were in the Polish army! Captured by the Russians,prisoners in Siberia, only 2 returned,Tomaz Lulek,and Anthony Lulek,my uncle Tomaz would always sing the Polish anthem at our family reunions,God bless his soul,and all who fought for peace and justice!
It was weird for Soviet people. For many years Soviet propaganda fought Nazis, then suddenly after September 1939 they became friends
@@RoboSapiens999 not friends and not ally Just business partners
These tales of blurred lines and loyalties are invaluable in contextualizing the often simplified realities of the Second World War and of national histories. Thank you again, Dr. Felton.
When your brutality shocks and disgusts the Waffen SS, you know you’ve hit rock bottom.
It wasn't their brutality, that was "fine", it was the inability of the "unit" to maintain discipline and control its "troops". These were the worst of the worst of former Soviets the Germans could scrape together.
Since when was the SS below the NKVD, Stalin, Lenin, Trotsky et al in depravity? Who terrorized and killed more people over the longest period of time? No contest.
@@drott150 This is like comparing Jim Brown with Frank Gore. The latter has many more yards, but needed twice as long as the former to get them. Not many would credibly argue that Gore was the better player. The NKVD, Red Guard, KGB, Kmer Rouge - all were brutal, disgusting and deserving of our disdain. But none approached the SS (1942-44 especially) in peak barbarism.
@@MBBurchette I don't know a single thing about Frank Gore or Jim Brown, other than I vaguely remember Jim Brown because he was in _The Dirty Dozen._ But you, stuck in a brain dead sports bubble, thinks everyone likes and knows about the same inane things you do, which are designed to distract ordinary people away from the real "sports game" going on in their lives. "Peak barbarism" as you call it, comes down to body count. Who killed more? If you add up the body count of communism, especially spread out over many decades amongst many nations and cultures, it *absolutely dwarfs* the SS and all other comers hands down. The fact that you are in any way confused about that proves you are a true _sports fan_ indeed! TOUCH DOWN COACH!!!
@@MBBurchette The one fellow above you is pointing out that the Nazis found Kaminski's actions to be perfectly moral and were only displeased about the fact they suffered losses, that's all.
Great research as per usual, with wonderful photographs and crisp clear narration. Truly one of the best WWII documentary sites on YT.
I found out a few of the blokes at work were avid Mark Felton fans by mentioning one of his videos (British involvement in Vietnam after the Japanese surrender) we all agreed he's one of the best youtubers and historians on the subject. These kind of documentaries are sorely needed in today's world given the amount of junk pumped out by more traditional, mainstream media outlets - they're effectively stupefying the population.
Hey Mark, such a funny coincidence. We both (almost at the same time) released a video on this topic. Cheers!
I doubt that he stole the idea from you. After all, it takes time to make a video.
@@TomasPetkevicius94 Obviously.
Also a perfect opportunity to advertise your channel, 🙂
@@TomasPetkevicius94 no shit, Sherlock
Felton is the Carlos Mencia of history documentaries 🤣
Another hidden gem of history lost for all if it hadn't been for Dr Felton. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you another brilliant piece of work. It is almost as if history is repeating itself.
Again and again the output and detail is 1st class.
Always an Outstanding video and presentation.
Yet again, a superb video. Concise and informative.
What a fascinating piece of history!Thx Mark!👍👍🦘🦘🦘🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
I had not heard of this unit before. When will you cover the Waffen SS Croats and Sovene police units? You may find the Latvian Waffen SS to be a surprising relief.
Make a video about the swiss ss
At the War's end The Latvian SS were interned in Neuengamme Concentration Camp, South of Hamburg. Most of them came to ENGLAND.
Yet again our favorite no bullshit history teacher has uploaded a wonderful video!
I always enjoy Dr Felton's videos and comments they'all very clear and easy to understand i give him 5 STARS!!! The highest Award Ever!!!
As always, very interesting. Tks a lot Marc! Best wishes from Switzerland René
An interesting note is that Kamimski himself was not an ethnic Russian. He was Polish and German.
Quite evident Kaminski was Polish with that surname!
@@benadam7753 A person's name is not a sign of his/her ethnicity or nationality.
@@MK-lm6hb In some cases yes. But usually it is! I have a German surname and I'm 50% German, I'm also 50% Italian!
@@benadam7753 Many Russians have Polish surnames.
@@benadam7753 Ethnicity is not an objective fact. Only the person concerned can say who he is in terms of ethnicity. Kaminski considered himself to be Russian. Whether you are German or Italian, it is your choice. You seem to think about human beings in biological terms. In other words, you essentialise what is existential.
Imagine getting out from under Stalin, only to wind up under Hitler. It must have been like being torn between two dogs. Those poor civilians must have felt cursed.
Outstanding stuff Dr Thanks for putting this out for us
Fine work as usual Mr. Felton! From Mr. Felker
Fascinating videos! Wonderful production quality. Bravo. You are better than history channel.
Mark. Thanks for providing my Sunday Night entertainment!
Enjoyed your video and I gave it a Thumbs Up for support
Mark , love your channel and videos thanks for what you do .👍🌟🇨🇦
Russian SS I had no idea! Thank you Dr Felton for teaching me something new .
Jep, today the Russians call them in today' s conflict: Tchechens or Kadyrov brigade
@Werner Pfeifenberger I knew about the Muslim SS , through Dr Felton .
Learn about Azov Battalion while you are at it!
@@emadbagheri what's it about? I'm always ready to learn.
@@jamestaylor7710 Azov Battalion is a Nazi paramilitary group in Ukraine, their insignia is a wolfsangel- swastika combo, they have been inducted into the Ukranian military recently and most of the prominent images of fighters in Ukraine, usually wearing the yellow armbands are of them. They are simply the latest manifestation of Nazism in Ukraine, tracing back to Stepan Bandera, who has a statue and a street in mariupol if I'm not mistaken
I love your history videos Mark, keep up the wonderful work good sir
Что ты любишь в этих сюжетах- смотреть как англия стравливала людей? И грабила страны?
As historian and reenactor of WW2 I only can say your videos are the best of the best.
What a good time for a good old Mark Felton video
Mark Felton is not a You-tuber, he is a Yore-tuber, and the best one ever.
Top notch content at the moment Mark.
I think fort VII would make for a good video Dr Felton. Again fantastic video I'm always learning. Thank you.
Thanks for all the interesting and informative videos Dr Felton!!
Look further, Ukrainian forces riddled with neo nazis today and worse back then! #OUM Nachtagale Division SS, Azov Battalions etc etc...
The increasing quality and research devoted to this channel is absolutely astounding. How it hasn’t gained more attention, is anyone’s h guess. Thank you for highlighting this seldom talked about area of WWII history, as you often do. Thank you.
Phfeww! I thought the preview pic was from Hogan's Heroes. Both programs are outstanding!
What a coincidence, the channel History Hustle just made a video about RONA a day ago. Let's compare them then! Edit: Both videos are very good and rather comparable. I would say they complement each other, as there are some bits of information present in one but not the other and vice versa.
IiiiIoiiiiiiooiookoiiioioooioooiiiiiiooikoiiikiiiiiioiiiiiiooioioiooioioioiikiiiiiiiooiioiioiiiiokiikiokooiikiiikiiiiiiiiioioiiiiiioiiiokiiiooioiioiiiiiiokioiioioiiiioiikioioooiikoooiioiiioooiiiiiiiiiiiooiiiokoiiiiokoioiioiiiiiiiiiiiioiiooiioiikiiioiiioiiiioiiiooiiooiiioikkiiiikiikkkiioiiooiooioiioioiiikikkkioooiiiiiioiiiiooiiiioooiiiiiiioiikooooikiiiioiiiioiioiiiiiiooiioiikkioiiiioiiiiooioooiiiiikiiiiioiiiiiioiiiookoiiiiiiooooooioikiikiioiioiikiikikkiiikkiikkiiiiiiikiiooiiooiioioiikiiikiiiiioiiiiioiiiioiiiiikiiioooiioiiooiioioiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiikoiiooioiikokooiiioiikiioiikiikkoooiiikoiioiiokiiikkikooooikiiioooiiiioiioiiooioiioooiiooiioiooioiiiioiiiiiioioioooioiiooiiikiikiiiuu K lol Ioiiio
5:52 A very accurate description 👌
Wow the amount of atrocities committed by German and Russian forces in WW ll is astonishing, Mark's incredible historical data base never ceases to amaze me, RIP to all who died in that terrible time thanks.
reds not we're Saints they make Many crines too
The Chinese and Japanese were worst. Which is saying a lot
You mean Soviet forces. FYI 18 million Soviet civilians were killed during the war. Not nearly as many Germans and other nazis experienced the same
@@lukecastle2538 the japanese not the chinese
I have been a WW2 aficionado for 50 years and appreciate the golden nuggets Dr. Felton provides that I have never seen anywhere else. Where does he find this stuff? Thank you Mark!
its all info you can find in books for around the last 50 years that ive been alive
Thanks Mark.. I just watched you in the documentary about Hiters train America... Great watch
The perfect combination...a cup of tea, a biscuit, and another great video to watch on a Sunday afternoon. Thank you Mark.
What a wuss. You wouldn't last one minute the US.
I recall that one of the "Russian" units who fought for the Germans surrendered en mass to the British in 1945. These were later handed over to the Russians and the British troops reported that many of the prisoners were shot before the British guards had left.
Interesting information!
A wonderful History Coverage of this Matter
Almost everyone had some Nazi cooperators! In Serbia we had Nedic with volunteer corps, Dimitrije Ljotic and SS Prinz Eugen division with recruited local Germans!
Dr.Felton deserve some sort of award 🥇 for his documentaries and narration
This is largely new to me. Thanks.
Never heard about this group Thank you Mr felton
Use Doctor if you're using honorifics.
Excellent short video, Dr Felton! Thank you for distinguishing the ROA from the RONA--many historians lump the together (much like the German Nazi's did in the end). General Vlasov was no Kaminski, and Kaminski was no Vlasov in the theater of battle imho. Kaminski was no better than Oskar Dirlewanger. Vlasov one can argue felt betrayed By Stalin, and upon his capture, sought to be of use to the German Nazi's for his homeland. Vlasov is a tragic figure who betrayed the USSR; Kaminski has no redeeming features in his tale as an utter villain.
The Anti-Partisan medal is definitely one of the most wicked issues by Nazi Germany. You know the recipients had to do some wicked stuff to get them in gold.
It was encouraged. In early 1941 Wehrmacht Chief of Staff Wilhelm Keitel issued the Barbarossa Order, the first of four "criminal orders" pertaining to the pending invasion of the Soviet Union that gave permission to German soldiers to commit war crimes. The Barbarossa Order explicitly told German commanders that persons suspected of being a partisan, or supporting partisan activities, were not the responsibility of civilian or military justice systems, but instead were the responsibility of unit commanders whose forces had taken these persons into custody. Combined with another subsequent order that exempted German soldiers from military court prosecution for murder, assault and robbery against USSR citizens, and it granted carte blanche to torture, maim and murder anyone suspected partisan on the commander's whim.
Not necessarily, there were legitimate large partisan movements that did a lot of damage to German logistics. Often actual fighting took place that could warrant a well earned medal, it wasn’t all arresting civilians and shooting kiddies, although this did sadly happen too.
Dirlewanger's unit started out by recruiting poachers from prison.
Although I have studied WWII for many years, this is a new chapter to me. I have no words for the depth of depravity presented here. Also look up Antonina Makarova.😢
*What Kaminski's Brigade of murderers and maniacs were doing in Warsaw, during the Polish Uprising in that city .... Germans were observing from the side. Because of the brutal methods of killing innocent civilian Poles by the Kaminski's "soldiers" .... some German officers couldn't stan it and they were puking beside the curbs of the streets !!!! :o(* That is of what my Godmother told me, I remember. She was a teenage girl, and she survived the Warsaw Uprising on the District of Wola, where the most killings of the Polish civillians took place at the start of the Uprising.
6:41 - Vladmir Putin on the left :D
I trust marck Felton more then any history book from school, that being said, where do you think his knowledge was learned from? Aside from visiting the sites, which is actually really cool.
A video on SS Cossack units would be very interesting. Such as the XV SS Cossack Cavalry Corp would an interesting video topic
How about this: make your own?
@@clvrswine How about this: shut up.
полк СС «Варяг». 1-я русская национальная бригада СС «Дружина». 15-й казачий кавалерийский корпус СС. 29-я гренадерская дивизия СС «РОНА» (1-я русская). 30-я гренадерская дивизия СС (2-я русская). 36-я гренадерская дивизия СС «Дирлевангер». 15-й Казачий русский корпус войск СС ФХА-СС - 3 дивизии,16 полков. 29-я Русская ФХА-СС - 6 полков. 30-я Русская ФХА-СС, 1-го формирования 1944г., - 5 полков. 1-я Русская национальная бригада СС «Дружина» - 3 полка, 12 батальонов. 1-я Гвардейская бригада РОА «Зондеркоманда Љ113″ СД - 1 батальон, 2 роты. Бригада СС»Центра противобольшевистской борьбы» (ЦПББ) - 3 батальона. Разведовательно-диверсионное соединение Главной Команды «Россия - Центр» зондерштаба «Цеппелин» РСХА- СС - 4 отряда спецназначения. Вооруженные силы Конгресса Освобождения Народов России (КОНР) (1 армия, 4 корпуса, 8 дивизий, 8 бригад). Русская Освободительная Армия Конгресса Освобождения Народов России (3 дивизии, 2 бригады). Русская Освободительная Армия Вермахта - 12 охранных корпусов, 13 дивизий, 30 бригад. Русская Освободительная Народная Армия - 5 полков, 18 батальонов. Русская Национальная Народная Армия - 3 полка, 12 батальонов. Русская Национальная Армия - 2 полка, 12 батальонов. Военно-Воздушные Силы КОНР (Авиационный корпус КОНР) - 87 самолётов, 1авиагруппа,1 полк. 582-й охранный (русский) корпус Вермахта - 11 батальонов. 583-й охранный ( эстонско-русский) корпус Вермахта - 10 батальонов. 584-й охранный (русский) корпус Вермахта - 6 батальонов. 590-й охранный казачий (русский) корпус Вермахта - 1 полк, + 4 батальона. 580-й охранный казачий (русский) корпус Вермахта - 1 полк , + 9 батальонов. 532-й охранный (русский) корпус Вермахта - 13 батальонов. 559-й охранный ( русский) корпус Вермахта - 7 батальонов. Русский легион «Белый Крест» Вермахта - 4 батальона. «Особая дивизия «Россия»» генерала Смысловского - 1 полк, + 12 батальонов. Бригада «Граукопф» - «РННА» генерала Иванова - 1 полк, + 5 батальонов. 442-я Особого назначения - 2 полка РОА. 136-я Особого назначения - 2 полка РОА. 210-я Особого назначения стационарная пехотная (береговой обороны) - 1 полк, + 2 отдельных батальона РОА. Русский охранный корпус Вермахта в Сербии - 1 бригада, + 5 полков. Русская «Народная стража» генерального комиссариата «Москва» (Тылового района группы армий «Центр») - 13 батальонов, + 1 кавалерийский дивизион.
1:17 Mark, I love the mastery of understatement demonstrated there. I am sure the Ukrainians indeed found the Germans to be as unpleasant as Stalin and his secret police. Nicely phrased.
My comments are limited to the narrative of Dr. Felton. Thank you for presenting your views. By your account, it sounds like your great grandfather’s social work in Ukraine left a positive impression on him.
@@Oberkommando : It would seem not much has changed since then.
@@Oberkommando depends on local German treatment. As Slavs they were of inferior blood and SS in particular treated Ukrainian roughly. One European Scale war game had option to treat Ukrainian better creating a great number of German Ukrainian troops. This did not occur due to local German oppression. So luckily in your example they did not receive the negative treatment to change their minds. I assume biggest amount of bad treatment was anyone wanting any say in how local government ran.
No, they didn't find the Nazis as unpleasant as Stalin and the NKVD. That's why the Azov battalion still exists today.
bot above
A very apt documentary to make these days! You should make one about Mr Bandera!
ANOTHER EXCELLENT HISTORY LESSON Dr. Felton!!!!!
It's just beginning. Thanks Dr. Felton. 🇦🇺
Just subscribed to your informative channel. Could you perhaps make a Documentary about the SS Division Galicia, and the Wolyn Massacre ? Thank you, that would be awesome.
kzhead.info/sun/n69sf8OghJ6tgYk/bejne.html&ab_channel=HistoryHustle
@@EarleALLEN I've seen it, it caters to a target audience , that loves shortcuts and a clear black and white view on historical facts. Spun that way leaves a few inconvenient facts out, It does not explain in more detail why sentiment, hatred and seditious jingoism where born. HistoryHustle has to be consumed with not only a grain of salt. Did you notice the virtue signaling ? Anyway, the TPV (Polish TV) produced a much more informative 2003 documentary called the Silverlands : kzhead.info/sun/rbWYdtSqhJ-ggas/bejne.html
SS Division GALICIA - THAT WAS THE UKRAINIANS!
@@von-Adler Yes, and Bandera provided the manpower needed to man a range of Concentration Camps. Furthermore, Ukrainian battalions fought against the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in 1943 and the Warsaw Uprising in 1944.
@@von-Adler there was a division from every balkan country
Well done sir
"just as unpleasant". that's one way to say it Dr Felton.
Would like to see a section on the Kuban Cossacks the most feared of the foreign SS units
I like this category of Mark Felton videos, people who very keenly throw their lot in with the Nazis then get ground up by the Soviets.
Very good!!
The last person who was executed from the Kaminski Brigade,was the executioner Antonina Makarova who the third woman in the Soviet Union's history to have been tried under capital punishment after the Second World War.
Mr. Felton, please consider covering civilian experiences in historical warzones and under unfriendly regimes. Were any groups able to survive or even succeed because of wise decisions?
Dr.
It would be really nice if you made a video on the incredible war crime that was operation keelhaul.
Maybe he doesn't feel comfortable doing that, because he's British
Curious topic for a curious time.
Love that opening music...what is it it's driving me to gigle fits trying to find out
Kaminski appears to have been the type of sociopath which time of war affords opportunities to do their worst. In time of peace some undoubtedly live ordinary respectable lives.
My apologies. A few weeks ago I sent an extremely critical review of your new videos. I was wrong. I am glad that you are still neutral and independent. All the best. Sincerely from the "cursed" Russia
Mark Felton is the GOAT
Thanks
The Kaminsky Brigade was not an SS formation and was composed mostly of ethnic Belorussians, not Russians. It was less a military unit than a marauding horde.
Kaminski Brigade was just the nickname of the Waffen-Sturmbrigade der SS "RONA". They recruited from different soviet territories.
A tragic tale of betrayal, hatred, and horror. What humanity had become....
@Mark Felton could you talk more about these executions you mentioned by the Soviet government until 1976. I had never heard of that.
I read about the Kaminski Brigade in Christopher Simpson's "Blowback", a first-rate book if you can find a copy.
Well do Sir Mark. 🇺🇸🇬🇧🏴
Bogus as hell to send them back to Russia they fought for Germany they earned the right to stay
They were Russians, and their countrymen--our allies--reeeally missed them. : )
I thought these guys were Polish and how would the SS ever trust them , sheesh ! thanks for sorting out the mess .
Can you do a video on Operation Bernhard?
Ill still never understand why Churchill chose stalin, over hitler, its unnatural.
look up operation unthinkable. It was made by churchill wich basiclly just meant for the british forces to keep pushing east
Influence of men with small hats 👀😬 Yeah declaring war on Germany for invading Poland yet ignoring Russia invading Poland at the same time. Most peculiar.
The Allies returned all Soviet nationals hwho were in Europe to the Soviet Union, the Soviets even convinced the Allies to repatriate the "White Russians" who left Russia during the Russian Civil war. Many were killed, and one of the main reasons was that the Soviet leadership didn't want people in the Soviet Union to find our that quality of life in Europe was much better than in the Soviet Union, so they had to liquidate anyone who might spread the word.
Fake
Lol.... Go ask everyone in Russia today if things were better under the Soviet Union or capitalism of the 90's and into today... Go ahead, I'll wait.
@@ProvisionalPatrioticAlliance And who are you? Who represents ALL of Russia an its peoples (Not even counting those countries who were under soviet occupation). Come on, Justify your nonsense, I can wait too.
White emigration was never a subject of any actions regarding Nazi collaboration. With the exception of those directly participating in collaboration (Krasnov being the most famous example), White emigration remained where it was. Many assisted the Allies, some served in Western armies, some have aided the Resistance, and so on. The majority of White emigration did not get affected in any way. However, there were times before the war when White emigrants were either lured to USSR by false promises of amnesty, or where forcibly deported back to Russia by some nations (including the US, sometimes), and in those cases, they faced quick reprisal from the Soviets as traitors to the people.
Yeah, the Soviet Union was a shithole. And even today Russia is a shit country. Nigeria with snow.
I can't think of anything interesting to say, but I'm commenting anyway for the algorithm.
Am I suffering deja vu or have I already seen much of this in a previous video?
You know your Unit is getting out of hand when their activities are so outrageous even SS and SD officers complain and have you executed!
Because kaminski work together with Dirlewanger? I didnt know kaminski got executed by other SS. I was thinking that he died by the allies
They were just as ruthless as the Direlwanger Brigade
So is the WikiPedia info in the "Felix Cortez" comment down below, correct, or plausibly correct at least? Mr Felton, a comment would be much appreciated! : )
Can you do a video about the SS Galicia division and the 1941 pograms? Somewhat relevant today and not very well known about
kzhead.info/sun/n69sf8OghJ6tgYk/bejne.html&ab_channel=HistoryHustle
Excellent information on little known despicable unit.