The Israeli settlers campaigning to occupy Gaza | DW News
In Israel, a small but determined movement has emerged in the aftermath of the October 7th terror attacks calling for the return of Jewish settlements to Gaza. Some cite security, others ideology. Their demands have been echoed by two far-right ministers in Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir who said there should be a return to Gush Katif - the largest block of settlements Israel maintained in Gaza until Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s unilaterally pulled out of the strip in 2005. The ministers’ statements have drawn international condemnation and Netanyahu has called the idea “unrealistic”, but his government has not yet laid out an official plan for Gaza after the war.
DW’s Aya Ibrahim speaks to:
Daniella Weiss, an Israeli settlement leader who lives in the occupied West Bank.
Noga Tarnopolsky a Jerusalem-based independent journalist covering Israeli politics.
Ohad Tal, a member of Israel’s Parliament the Knesset from Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich’s Religious Zionism party.
Datya Itzhaki, an Israeli tour guide who lived in Gush Katif for 21 years and now hopes she can go back.
Avner Franklin, tour guide at the Gush Katif Museum in Jerusalem.
Chapters:
00:00 Daniella Weiss: The Israeli activist determined to resettle Gaza
03:00 Noga Tarnopolsky: The damage caused by the campaign to return to Gaza
05:16 Avner Franklin: Israel’s recent history in the Gaza strip
07:23 Ohad Tal and Datya Itzhaki: Between security and ideology, the arguments for a return to Gush Katif
13:36 Two state solution?
16:47 Noga Tarnpoolsky on Netanyahu’s ‘radicalisation’
Subscribe: kzhead.info...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Israel #Gaza #Settlers
If they say this so proudly, imagine what they say behind closed doors.
It's much worse.
Everyone else is akin to animals for the chosenites. I have heard many rabbis say exactly that.
They no longer care... they say it openly
Israel has full support from Germany.
@@sheriffmoola3456Of course, like a proud mentor, they took the genocidal mindset and actions to another level... Talk about brazen stupidity.
Im mindblown. Not only by how straight up evil the settlers sound, but also how confident and open they are about what they want
they own it.
They are supported by us, countries of the west and worst the US and now Germany is washing the blood of thousands of children out of their hand. See, Isaelis are clean.
start consuming better media than DW about the colonial aparth°°d state of is°°el. al jazeera does real reporting on pale°°°ne. you'll be able to see the difference.
If I had the US on my back to defend whitchever insane claim I had, I would be pretty confident on anything too
They are emboldened in their evil deeds bcos they have the backing of the West
I can‘t believe my eyes. The First time in 10 years that i heard something negative about Israel in German Media. I‘m mind blown.
25000 Dead, our german Media says nothing, this is Deutsche Welle u cant really call that german outlet. No german grandmother will ever see this Video in tv.
Is DW German??
@@HA-jq1mu it is a german outlet, paid by german Taxes, having their Studios in different countries, publishing in many languages. Based in Berlin and Bonn.
@@thelostvoicedieverlorenest8487 are they paid by german taxes? they arent ÖR afaik
You found this negative????😳
A Thief Never becomes an Owner!
That's right!
Correct
What about the United States, New Zealand, and Australia? They got away with the Theft (Colonization).
Sadly not true. In 500 years people will largely forget :(
"Whether nations live in prosperity or starve to death interests me only in so far as we need them as slaves for our culture...We shall never be tough and heartless where it is not necessary, that is clear. We, Germans, who are the only people in the world who have a decent attitude towards animals, will also assume a decent attitude towards these human animals." - Himmaer, The Posen speech to SS officers (6 October 1943) - On the 7th, it is crucial to understand that there were no direct attacks on civilians, only collateral damage. Out of the 1148 total names on haaret dataset, 473 military and 675 were civilians. Ratio of civilians to military personnel killed on the 7th was 1 . 4 : 1 - lower than any of the iTf "mowing" operations, which has a ratio of 7 : 1 According to UN OCHA data from 2008 to 2022; The collateral damage on the 7th was significantly lower than any of the ITf "mowing" operations, which had a ratio of 7:1 with 1,023 military personnel out of 6,541 total. On the 7th, with 473 military (418 were iTf military personnel, 55 belonged to the police) out of 1148 total, the ratio of civilians to military personnel was a mere 1.4:1 When including all casualties, not just deaths, the collateral damage ratio of the "mowing" operations is a staggering 162:1 From the 161,233 accumulated civilian casualties over only 14 years of "mowing" operations. A 162 :1 ratio means that for every 162 civillians, 1 military personnel is a casualty. The 7th had a ratio of 1.4:1, more than a hundred times lower. The 473 are - 55 soldiers, 13 privates, 59 corporals, 200 sergeants (45 of whom were sergeant majors), 48 commanders, 32 lieutenants, 5 lieutenant colonels, 6 colonels, 37 officers, 10 inspectors, 6 intendents, and 2 Lance Corp. This was a military defeat, and they are taking it out on the rest. The reported ages of the victims are as follows: 0-4: 2 civilians 5-12: 8 civilians 13-17: 14 civilians 18-25: 132 civilians 26-40: 119 civilians 41-60: 55 civilians 61+: 40 civilians Active duty military personnel: 18-25: 258 active duty military personnel 26-40: 60 active duty military personnel 41-60: 17 active duty military personnel 61+: 1 active duty military personnel haaretz datasheet titled title: xsraxl's Dead: The Names of Those Killed in Hxmxs Attacks, Mxssxcres and the xsrxel-Hxmxs Wxr There is a more detailed report of of oct 7th titled "I scrapped the information about 1096 of the 1460 killed on 7th of October Attack. Children Less than 1%" -Yocheved Lifshitz account - 'they treated us well' -Yasmin Porat account - 'i.T.f kxilled my husband' Civilians were taken to have swaps for the civilians rotting in prisons without charge on the other side. An excess of ten thousands, all before the seventh UN Human Rights Office (UN OCHA) PA Civilians 2008-2023: 2008 - 2,325 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 1,440. 2012 - 3,992 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 255. 2014 - 17,533 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 1,492. 2018 - 31,259 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 300. 2019 - 15,491 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 138. 2020 - 2,581 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 30. 2021 - 19,183 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 349. 2022 - 10,345 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 191. 2023 up to September - 8,508 Wounded Civilians, Deaths 227. civilian deaths on the other side - 2008: 3 , 2012: 6 , 2014: 73 , 2018: 9 2019: 10 , 2020: 0 , 2021: 9 , 2022: 26 Total; 2008 up to September 2023 - 161,233 PA Civilian Casualties, 1,023 military personnel. Wounded includes: amputees from the deliberate targeting of knees by snipers, white phosphorous third degree body burns, etc The "Costs of War" study by brown in 2021 has these figures for the past 20 years of engagement of US policy: indirect deaths 4.5-4.7 million, direct 905-940,000 ; in other words 6 Million Deaths and 38 million displaced. This is relevant because of the Yinon Plan.
This was the plan from the beginning. They're sickening. Thank you for showing this DW.
It's interesting that both groups are having a same characteristic. They both like to hide their hairs and they both are extreme views and will not bent. They waste the world time and energy for their patty and selfishness right?
No it wasn't. If you know the history of Gaza you ll know that neither Israel nor egypt ever wanted it.
@@lilyannal5159both groups? Who?
well now the key difference is that one group controls a disproportionately massive amount of the planets wealth and resources@@lilyannal5159
who was planning what? Hamas started war and no way to end war with terrorism root still there
That old woman is pure evil, how this allowed to happen that long!!
she just wants to live in gaza, how is that evil?
She’s an ex Gazan, who was forcefully removed from her home in Gaza by the Israeli army
dear lord @@cordisdie8109
you mean like how the Palestinians were evicted from the entirety of Israel?@@nnex
@@cordisdie8109 America, the sole reason her nation exists says no. Is that not enough? Well the American military is used to those that say no. Be they Jihadists or Hasids, our eagle sigil knows no god!
Crazy! Displacing almost 2 million Palestinians to make way for the 8,000 Israelis settlers? Such a wicked and sick lady!
30000 filistinleri zwilleri öldürdüler ondan gurur duyuyorlar yarısı cocuklar
Halal slaughter is even more sick.
When that guy said "Israel is a beacon of peace and democracy" i had to let out a big laugh
Mee too, then i thought, God , that gay actually believes himself
then he looks away as he finishes - body language speaks more than words when you lie
It is if you are not military age 🤣🤣🤣🤣
It makes anyone con-volt but that's Zionism
yeah lol...just like thier good American friends
It is shocking and chilling how satisfied and self-righteous the woman is when she announces that she wants to break international law and have millions of people displaced. Her smile is just evil.
Imagine having such granny in the family? Scary
Verdade.
So entitled😡
Evil
فعلا انها مخيفه وشريرة لكن الذي لا تعرفه انو الفلسطينيين لن يخرجوا من غزة هي واهمة وتحلم
As you grow older you realize more than half the world today are psychopaths
or followers that are brainwashed by psychopaths leaders .
Mostly based on religion... hmmm could there possibly be a correlation? Naaah!😂
Naah mostly nihilist atheist @@alexissvetrev
The so called good guys are.
SO SAD.....HUMANS ARE DOOMED??
"We have a connection to gaza" he says with his Australian accent
😂😂😂 Hahahahaha
It's a South African accent.
😂
And most Palestinians are actually Jordanians lol 😂
@@Kvasiir hahahahhahahahahahahahaha prove it?
You know who else dreams of being able to live in Gaza? Gazans.
If the Western countries don't give UNRWA money more and the Palestinians can not get the old jobs in Israel again, they can not stay in Gaza to be hungry. Even without war, they have no job, no money to feed their children. They will go to the Western countries like the people of Afghanistan, Syrie, Irak, Lebanon, ... Even the people in Egypt want to to Germany too.
i guess they regret oct7 then
@@accomplice7the attack that had so many question than answers behind it, that it seems rather made by israeli's themselves than hamas?
@@baconbeast3209 No the questions are about the failure of israeli inteligence and the idf to prevent the attack. noone in israel believes those 911 conspiracy theories
@@baconbeast3209 noone believes such idiocy the questions are about the failure of the intelligence community and the idf to prevent the attack
Get your land from Germany, the nation that actually wronged you.
Germany, France, Poland, Latvia, Bulgaria, Estonia, Czechia, Norway, Belgium, Greece, Italy , Netherlands.... ect.. each of those countries " let " it happen.
@auyemra1331 lets not forget Britain
@@auyemra1331 So pretty much Europe
@@LexSandy000 Most of the today's jewry is an assimilated/converted "jewry" originally from central Europe...
If we'll say that we're willing to leave israel but we'll ask for all our assets we had in europe will we get them back?
It's shocking to see how fast one can go from being oppressed to being the oppressor, utilizing the same line of thought utilized by their former oppressors,.
Fanatics!
When you vote for radical extremist zealots . No one is at peace . Now
Israel does not represent the millions of jewis people all around the world. There are jewis pro palestine, organizations to help palestinians, even inside Israel alot of people are against this genocide.
Yup.... Austrian painter is right.....
That’s called psychological patterns.
That is really sick! The genocide victims turn into oppressors.
you have very little information of what's actually happening if you're saying this.
@@Omkuskom what part exactly did he get wrong
@@missf4681 that the genocide victims are being the opressors, which is wrong. the genocide victims legally got their own state and now defending it against cold-blooded terrorists that only want to delete it
@@missf4681 well the people that today live in israel were not direct genocide victims. Maybe this is what he means.
@@dario-viva probably some are ancestors of those tgat where there. I mean they cry about it enough and play the victim card as though they where there so it would be easy enough to make that mistake that they where there. .
all the door mats will read, "There is No Place Like Someone Else's Home."
Okay. While the actual matter is horrendous, this joke in isolation is hilarious. I fell over from laughing. I imagine bender from Futurama having a doormat like that after just straight up taking someone's flat.
When somebody shows you who they really are, believe them.
Like Hamas?
@@kphaxx like you
As in the US also!
@@kphaxxYes. That's why Isreal should fight Hamas not Palestinians
@@kphaxx All I know about Hamas is what the pro-Israeli media tells me. After hearing a few translations of what Bibi says in Hebrew, I'd be willing to give Old Scratch the benefit of the doubt.
This video just raised my blood pressure. I didn't think I could hate anyone until I saw this
If you search through older videos you'll be even more disgusted at how the Israels treat Palestine folk. This is why 7th Oct happened.
@@McCaff62❤
@ Leslie I am with you !!!
And yet you don’t say whom hate.
This is nothing new ,they are known for this
two choices: you can grow old and become wiser, or you can grow old and become this wicked
Her calling northern Gaza no man's land says it all.
The cognitive dissonance between Ukraine-Russia and Israel-Palestine is mind blowing
It's insanity
indeed that people support ukraine yet oppose Israel for reasons, thanks for proving it too.
"We don't want this to happen again, so we are going to continue doing exactly what we did that caused this to happen in the first place."
what caused this in the first place is not totally removing all arabs from the conquered territories. Allowing them to remain has been the biggest mistake Israel has made.
@@pwp8737 remain?? 🤣🤣🤣 your delusional friend your the occupier hence the guest. You’ve stayed long enough the world sees the face behind the mask. Long live the resistance
@@pwp8737 and this is according to what? Who is occupying other people’s land ? Isn’t Israel? Why don’t you read some history? At least wiki
@@pwp8737colonizer psycho says what
@pwp8737 the biggest mistake israel ever made was taking that land instead of taking California. They would have "displaced" all of us to Mexico by now and be the new US.
They just sound like a bunch of bullies, and this kind of content would NEVER play on US media. Thanks DW!
blows my mind how entitled these thieves are
Pure criminals
Can you quote what the Quran says about the spoils of war?
@full__tilt two wrong doesn't make it right. Lunatic!
@@PastequeDuTurFusorry but you know this is human nature this has been going on since the time of the crusades, this gives people purpose like nothing you have seen
well, the Gazan Arabs certainly have behaved, many of them, like criminals and murderers but it does not mean ALL are that way. Instead of the world embracing and supporting Hamas and murder, this movement establishes an example of honorable, civilized living instead of savagry and barbarism.
Then they wonder why they get attacked
Why are there no settlements from Palestinians allowed in Israel? The situation seems absurd. It's like the Spanish moving to Portugal and then claiming that Portugal is now Spain because there are a lot of Spanish people living there.
Verdade.
It's an age old tactic of relocating your citizens to another country and then later came that land for yourself.
Or the Irish and the Welsh turning up with an army and displacing the English population to France and Germany because several thousand years ago waves of tribes invading the west side of the British isles forced the then population further West! Of course it would be laughed at here So why does the world allow the Israelis to do exactly that?!?
putin does the same
The British used that tactic a lot.
it’s will never be a peace . if you try to steal others property
International law is meaningless if they can't enforce it on certain countries
It's been like that always.
The first step would be to stop funding Israel. Israel has run trade deficits almost every year since at least the late 1960s and could not sustain its current standard of living without an influx of cash from overseas. Cut off Israel’s welfare payments would be effective enforcement. Technically, we are not supposed to provide aid to them or trade with them because they have nuclear weapons but have not signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. It get’s a congressional waiver each year (Thanks AIPAC!)
I’d love to see Germany defending Israel on the ICJ over this… Shameful
They have to do what their master the U.S tell them to do.
Germany continues to choose the wrong side. There is lots of historical precedent for this.
They just minority
She say. Israel flee from their homes Because war. Egypt can a give solution to the people from Gaza that flee from their home because of the war you know give them a solution they our enemy. I can't give them a solution .😮
Is it a final solution?
And Germany wants to defend Israel at the IJC...
lol even the US criticized Israel at the ICJ
@@DK-nc9wrThe US judge Joan E. Donoghue, the President of the ICJ and therefore was in charge of this case, but Biden and Blinken do not care about international norms or the once fashionable duty to protect. PS The German ICJ judge, Georg Nolte, was part of the ICJ's majority, but like in the case of the US, his own government ignores his professional expertise.
Psychos. I would not wish such neighbors even to my enemies.
Is unbelievable that this people are doing the same to the Palestinians that was done to their ancestors ...humans never learn !!! 😡
But Palestinian would not get the recognition they got you can’t even say a word before they say anti semi whatnot
I use to think that people who experienced horror would never inflict it on others because they knew the suffering it caused them. I was so wrong. Israel has inflicted the same unto the Palestinians that was inflicted on them ten fold and expect the world to support them in this and give approval on top of that. How freaking hypocritical can you get. The inhumanity, the callousness. No matter what happens, Israel and the U.S. has lost so much more than they have yet to comprehend.
Absurd
Like 99.99% of the current settler movement are too young to have been in the Holocaust. I think the kind of people that do it thrive off of the cruelty of it.
It is absurd! And the way they treated those orthodox offshoots who were peacefully protesting in London (can't remember their name) too!
Maby they never experienced horror ;)
inhumanity?u watched hamas videos or u did not?what you thought would happen,easy to you to make this criticize about country that u don't live at or u don't care about,if it would probably would happen to you or to your country,you will talk diffrently , i am not asking you to support any war,but i am just want you to measure the things you write according to what would you wrote,in a perspective of your own mind that maybe use a sense of what and why it become like this,"inhumanity",if this is how you measure it so probably your country also is "inhuman" country,i don't have to know which country you are from,because almost every country had a inhumanity disaster sometimes...,u are maybe forgot what is the meaning of war,war is not moral in the first place,but if war would not been done,your enemy look at you as a weak country,and nobody like to be weak in this world.
So this is what Germany defends so badly??? it looks like the Germany of today is not so different to the Germany of the 40s... shame!
YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY WRONG.!! YOU ARE NOT FROM GERMANY OR EUROPE COUNTRIES AREN'T YOU ?????
@@stellaeliza5317 you are right there is a difference they went from committing genocide to supporting genocide
@@stellaeliza5317 They went from committing it themselves to supporting it to take place.
@@stellaeliza5317 I think writing in all-caps with exclamation points makes you sound more reasonable.
"how could people who survived the holocaust turn around and do this to others" reminds me of how during a talk about his book MAUS, Art Spiegelman said "suffering doesn't make people good, it just makes them suffer. There is unfortunately no spiritual inoculation against cruelty. the holocaust was not a "teachable moment." a population can experience unimaginable and senseless inhumanity and still inflict it on others. there is nothing morally cleansing about hardship.
When you look at the stories told by the “survivors”, you become skeptical. A woman really swallowed 5 diamonds each day and retrieved them from the latrine for a year and never got sick or suffered internal injuries? She also claimed she was subjected to Dr. Mengele’s experiments. Didn’t he ever wonder why she was always sick or injured? Another woman claimed she was sent to the gas chamber but it ran out of gas and only knew it was a gas chamber because somebody later told her it was? These are not exceptional cases.
They all don't even looks middle eastern LOL. That tells it all from USA, Australia, Canada, Argentina and more.....they all have ONE thing in common "They are all not from Palestine" colonizers.
"AIPAC owns the US Congress" once you can wrap your head around this, the events happening now in Gaza make 100% sense.
😂😂😂
not only US Congress, they are all over also in Europe.
they own Germany to
The main reason for the U.S. support is that wants an attack dog in the Middle East as long as oil is of strategic importance. As oil use declines U.S. support for Israel will decline.
The lizard people too! 😂
The Apartheid must have to be stopped at any cost. Palestinians deserve their own state, with free will and their own army
They have their own state. It's called "Jordan". Look at the Jordanian flag 🙂
Stop launch rockets first.
I’m all for it. Unfortunately who is gonna make sure they become a functioning democracy with security? Last time Gaza got an election they voted for Hamas.
First Israel must be willing to discuss the two State Solution with the international community. The rest there should be a mechanism with the international community to put peace keeping, force in the new Palestinian State with its independent borders. That would be negotiated with Arabs countries that recognizes Israel and others friendly countries to The Palestinians cause.
@@adolfost88adolfos95 What gives you the right to dictate Middle Eastern policy?
This is so disturbing 😭
What is really happening in Palestine since 75 years is horrifying, there are no words to describe it
Maybe that is why the Babylons took over Israel, because they were more evil.
How easily this woman steals their land and house and tells them to go to Egypt.
Speechless to see how inhuman the supposed chosen ones maybe the most shameful children of god. We arw all human beings on this small planet we ought to act as such brother's and sisters above animalistic territorial disputes. Enough is enough
Give them the solution she says...
It is very emotional to displace people and treat them like a herd of animals! Can you imagine dealing with an occupier that see they have the right to occupy and displace you and additional to that you have to be happy with it! Sick
Now, imagine that this happened to the original inhabitants of this continent infinite times over for the past 500 years?
@@anahuactitlantli post colonial trauma for the hole area but after colonial time they name it we bring you democracy
The irony of the museum dude having a british accent, YOU ARENT NATIVE TO THAT REGION.
They probably have forgotten their own history
Our hypocrisy is giving me whiplash between Gaza, Ukraine, and all.
No man, we should somehow stop funding Ukraine, but obviously continue to support Israel unconditionally.
And the the people who suffers the most, are both Palestinians and Ukrainians for other, BIG brothers interests!
stop talking about hypocrisy. West has a right to have own interests, rules and ideas. Additionally all other accusing west are little thieves like erdogan or murders like putin.
@@wallenbergphotoUkraine is fighting for its life. With your logic, Ukraine is more like Palestine.
Really you need Gaza to notice it ? This been going on more then just Ukraine and Gaza.
And there isn’t a genocide? Germany is on the wrong side of history…again.
Long live Israel
@@Peaceful_World130long love Baruch Goldstein, Ben Gvir and Smotrich. These fine gentlemen are the personification of the Israeli state.
@@Peaceful_World130not
@@ahmedvawda1282they are cowards who are nothing without the weapons donated to them. Loll
@@arzoahmadi5821 why not
Mozaics dating back to the Byzantine Age were stolen from Gaza a few years ago and placed in a museum in Jerusalem. Now the host says this mozaic proves they're connection. At the same time, other remaining mozaics also dating back to the Byzantine Age still in the Gaza strip have been bombed by the IDF. Super connection you have there.
Artifacts have been stolen from Gaza and displayed in the Knesset during this war too.
"Never again.. ......to us"
The real terrorists
You Said it!! High 5
yes the arabs.
Yes Arabs
@@user-tv2pn8kr4u it is not the Arabs committing genocide
@@user-wc8lw9km4w The more you exaggerate and use term "genocide" when it is not appropriate, the more you devalue this term, making people more "tolerable" of this term. Death of innocents in this war is a tragedy, Israel didn't started this war, Hamas did with its October 7 terror attack.
Thank you Aya Ibrahim for this report. It must have been hard to talk to so many fanatical people who don't respect other people.
Lol, the funniest part is how evil proclaims itself a victim aloud as it's striking and lashing out 🤣🤣
How can one be so evil!!
Crazy what people who were wronged in the past can get away with
It's a circle of abuse.
Who were wronged in the past? Being wronged by someone before doesn’t mean you get a free pass
Insane that the past wrongdoers keep supporting the crimes of the new perpetrators.
@@sihr07 You are right. Alas, many nations still give Israel free pass because of their ancestors' suffering.
they work extremely hard at making sure we never forget it
Imagine saying you’re gonna take someone else’s land and not even bat an eye. 👁️ 👁️
وكأن الأرض يملكها جدها 😂😂
I have negative emotions towards people who think a book can give them rights over land, which has been inhabited by more ethnicities for millenia. Settlements in the West Bank are absolutely illegal, as simple as that.
I am shocked: this is pure evil.
It is, and it's nothing new
Settlements are like the German lebensraum
Nazism is nothing compared to Judeo-Nazism...
That is sure true !!
Had to look up the word, but correct!
and the way how they act gonna scare you, seriously
"We need civilians in hostile areas to protect our bigger cities. By the way it's the other side that uses human shields, not us!" - Israel, literally.
“We need civilians in hostile areas (that are made hostile due to Israeli far right policies towards the Palestinians) to act as pawns and cannon fodder for the purpose of justifying our far right policies, rinse and repeat”
😂
they are right , if israel leave west bank it will get another gaza in the heart of israel , palestinians can not be trusted
He is still not wrong though...hamas is known for using kids as human shield
@@prasanjeetnayak8253 He didn't say anything about that, only that he intends to use entire civilian populations (including kids) as human shields. How is this "not wrong" in your opinion? Because as a response that is the thing that your "not wrong" refers to,
Evil. And you wonder why palestinan have so much resentment towards them.
Evil. Evil. Evil. And we support them with our taxes 🤬
The unashamedness is astounding.
Big regards to DW for fairly neutral reporting and keeping the comments open 👍👍
I agree 110% you would never get this out of US press.
Tbh, it’s a good report…but it’s sadly not exactly a true neutral report as it doesn’t actually interview any Palestinians regarding the matter. They also don’t tell us about the vibrant community + culture of Gaza btwn 2006- Oct 2023 developed outside of the Hamas narrative. It’s literally completely skipped and so the viewer doesn’t actually have any connection with the Gazan people. I mean it’s DW, a German broadcast so it’s a good start I guess.
@@UsefulRevolution that's because it suits the Palestinian narrative to depict gaza as an open air prison. Suddenly its a ' vibrant place'?
@@UsefulRevolutionindeed. They couldn’t find one Palestinian to interview. I find it really concerning they give so much voice to extremists without listening to the victims.
They are still very biased towards Israel. It’s just that we can all see what’s happening and it would be beyond dishonest and abandoning journalistic integrity to not report any opposing viewpoints. Earlier on, German media and government was sympathetic to the Israelis, yet still fail to amplify the Palestinian voices.
I can’t even begin to describe how disturbing this is. How happy they are at the expense of innocent lives!
Okay so he is basically saying that the settlements in the West Bank protect Tel Aviv… if they were ever to be attacked, would that mean that Tel Aviv uses its own people as “”human shields””
Exactly.
Hilarious that an Australian man is explaining his deep connection to land in Gaza that he wants to steal from people that actually have that connection
Talks about his deep connection to the land, meanwhile people who have lived there for centuries, if not millenia, are to be driven off it.
south african
Germany’s support of Netanyahu is Unconscionable !
Guilt feelings , and lots of pressure coming from somewhere much further up.
Birds of a feather stick together
The German foreign minister had just recently spoken out about the need for a ceasefire in Gaza, and that a two-state solution is the only way for peace. But don't let facts get in the way of your "Germany bad" bias.
@@drsnova7313 I’m fully aware of the diversity within German society, however fact remains Germany as a Government supports Netanyahu, and continues to supply weaponry and support to the Genocide in Gazza 🤷♂️😡
@@drsnova7313 Hmm interesting that he said that as pro-Palestinian demonstrations get banned, Palestinian artists, authors, and thinkers are ostracized from German society. People have had their homes raided for simply flying the Palestinian flag out their window.
This is inhuman . 😢
it is like all the lessons from history are ignored.
If they openly defend to violate the Geneva Conventions which they signed, they should at least be coherent, unsign it and endure the consequences.
what would the consequences be? they will just keep doing what they do
Win the war get the land simply like that, who wil stopped you 😂😂😂😂
@@tonypucheta354 Except that they signed a document saying that it is illegal to get land by winning a war. You might have heard of such a document, it's the Article 2(4) of the United Nations Charter. If there is one conflict that might end up fracturing the UN, it is this one. Israel doesn't seem to give up a damn about it.
@@sur_un_nuage For Israel, none. But if there is one conflict that might end up fracturing the UN, it is this one.
Did Hamas and innocent hamasians follow the Geneva conventions they signed too?
I tip my hat to the brave reporters who took the challenge to bring the true mentally of those people
We just want what was promised to us, you are brain washed
@@IszzrealPromised by whom? 😂 Grow up and wake up! Selectively picking a period in time several millennia ago when the Israelites occupied and conquered (hmm, sounds familiar) the land of the Canaanites is beyond ludicrous! All it shows is a propensity for land grabs that, curiously, still exists today!
@@IszzrealYou forgot to take your medication today 😮
@@Iszzreal Half the land is what you were promised.
Your god says you can have it but my god says you can’t guess we will have tO see who’s god is biggest@@Iszzreal
Palestinians have a right to live there. Their ancestors have been in the area for centuries. To deny that is inhumane.
This is beyond bizarre.
For the first time DW actually did some research and provided us with solid info that explains the status in the middle east
I don't think it's a coincidence that they're doing this now that a few mainstream politicians in the US have now called for a ceasefire. Their was an obvious narrative that was being pushed by western media and DW was a part of it.
By highlighting a fringe settler movement in Israel all of whose members can fit in a small room. Meanwhile, Iran is weaponising its proxies in Gaza. Lebanon and Yemen to attack Western interests in furtherance of its goal of the building a shi'ite empire across the middle east so as to bring about the return of the mahdi
That isn’t fair. DW occasionally reports correctly. Not that they don’t want to, but they are fighting the narrative. At least DW showed both sides of the issue bright to the ICJ.
"Every time anyone says that Israel is our only friend in the Middle East, I can't help but think that before Israel, we had no enemies in the Middle East” -Father John Sheehan
Just unbelievable
sickening.
He says "it will send a message that if they want to be violent etc..." meanwhile leaving out the violence and SA's of the IDF and illegal settlers which makes ppl lash out in the first place. If I'm 5 years old and you beat my parents and imprision them for no proper cause, of course I will hate you for my whole life. Its common sense
Exactly!!!
Why do you think they hate Christ? He called them a brood of vipers.
They are indoctrinated from a young age, no matter what Israel does. So it's normal IDF is no longer concerned about breeding hate, cause the hate exists no matter what.
Exactly, and no one need to teach you in a school to hate the Israelites, daily abuse at check points will do this to you.
You are confusing cause and effect. First the Palestinians commit violence, then they lose territory. It's always been that way.
I always believed that governments were not a reflection of its people. That is to say a government can be currupt and evil but the people of the country just human, loving, kind... Living their lives. But I'm beginning to doubt that understanding when it comes to Israel. The government and most poeple there seem to be the same (consumed by hate and playing the victim card).
true
It's a country which has a decently high democracy index (77/100) and political rights score (34/40) according to Freedom House. One can say that it's safe to say that the Israel's government actions do reflect the will of the majority of Israelis.
@@hitthedeck4115 exactly. Not a healthy mentality.
yeah i used to believe the same thing. Even after watching Abby Martin's interview with Israelis a while back, I thought maybe those were the rare few Extremists and they don't represent the entire government but goddamn watching the interviews on omegle with normal Israelis and normal people interviewing them and hearing the stuff coming out of their mouth :O
Maybe before saying stuff like that you should actually visit the place and research how executive decisions are made. Israelis do not think this way, these are extremists. Settling and Netanyahu are widely protested by Israelis. Statements like these can lead to dangerous actions.
They are openly planning to evict other people from home.Are they thieves or burglars?
Omg greedy people
"They are shooting fish in a barrel and they're annoyed with the splashes"
And you still wonder why you are being attacked?
Sorry, you are trying to explain why Hamas did what it did on October 7th?
Because the Arabs can't conceptualize the fact that they lost the war they started in 1948?
@@davidgaskin5417 yep, the Israelis do evil things and then cry when someone retaliates. They still can't accept that it was Hamas, not the Palestinians who attacked them.
@@davidgaskin5417 Hamas killed once, Israel has been killing children for 100 days. Who is bad?
@@davidgaskin5417because Palestinians knows the Israeli’s always planning to push them out and steal their land. Thats why those 2 nations cannot live together. 🤷♂️
Omg, so evel! So sick!
Pure evil behavior justified by religion.
My heart 💔💔🥲 for the People of Gasa,😢
who could live on top of the dead let alone sleep at night while doing it......
Israelis, lol😂
Americans, Canadians, Australians, and New Zealanders.
They don’t give a s..t, because “god promised them”
@@ingashafranik half of Israelis identify as secular, except when it comes to that promise
@@tyebo2010 exactly. What they forget, is that every time Israel loses its moral compass, God throws them out. They should read their own book.
now we know who are the real villains are😅
And the world wonders why theres extremism in Gaza. What do you expect when they are completely opressed for generations? Extremism are always bad but what happens when people are so opressed? Lots of desperate measures that end up being extreme occurs!
So if Israel got the rights too take the land of palestine, does that mean the red indians can start doing the same in america?
Yes .
So get ready , and not for a bed of roses but a valley of tears.
And Aborigins in Australia.
Not only America all over the world .
Wrong comparison: the Red Indians are in the same position as the Palestinians and Australia's aborigines. Israel is the coccupier
There is a dark irony here playing out that many are afraid to mention for fear of being attacked, but we all can see the comparisons of history.
No one is afraid, its voiced time and time again
They make their own rules regardless what the international law says.
I ask my government, please let us take care of ourselves first. At home, health, food, education, infrastructure, communication, work, development, security, laws, helping our neighbors. God bless the world. Please, I ask my own country's government to stay out of other's business. We can give help when we can help ourselves. So much tax money spent outside of the US and for what? Greed. Shame.
Did he say Israel is a democracy 🤣?
They are professional lier
Yes,democracy can be dictatorship too
Don't most people believe that America is a democracy? Same people, same thought process. 😊
Do not conflate democracy with morally right actions (taken by the nation). A democratic system simply says that the actions of the government reflect the will of the majority of the people.
@@hitthedeck4115 Very accurate statement sir!
did anyone feel surprise?
no they own it so they can have it.
Not at all.
@@user-tv2pn8kr4u yeah yeah yeah. because it is the so call the promised land, right?
@@user-sn1bp8eg8eno ,it more about zionism, NOT the promise land theories
no anymore, I watched many documentaries already
And this is not genocidal talk
This is what they have been doing over past 70+ years now people can see them for what they are. Just how evil they are in giving zero value to life of other humans.
How is that life? It is the right of the conqueror to take what he wants.
they weren't evil and nobody cares about gazans
It is awful seeing these cruel thugs act so jubilantly about occupation and breaching international law.
Germany naturally support the evil side.
Im so curious why there isnt conversation about how folks continue to settle areas that they are not permitted to under law and agreements made. Why do Isrealies think its okay for them to do this? Why do they act like it is an unfathomable event to be removed from a place they forced themselves onto, were not welcomed as such and broke the law? 🤷🏽♀️
I$rael occupies Palestine not the other way around. Occupation is the problem not the resistance. Apartheid was the problem not Nelson Mandela.
Mandela was also classified as a Terrorist by the West and went to jail for 27 years for resistance
So you are justifying apartheid???@@rabbinyirenda2886
Absolutely correct.
Resistance in the form of Terrorism by Hamas is a problem....
You seem to ignore the religious dimension deployed by those you designate as "resistance"