I've got two old lathes, both about 80 years old. They have acquired excessive backlash over their lifetimes (rather than having it factory-fitted) but I think I'll try your fix. At worst I can put the original parts back on and I'll have learnt something. Thanks for posting this.
@nicholashacking381 Жыл бұрын
@sourand jaded thanks, I'll try that.
@nicholashacking381 Жыл бұрын
The lathe bed will also wear most near the chuck......
@milojanis4901 Жыл бұрын
Well done, sir. Setting aside the discussion over anti-backlash nuts, the bigger impact of this vid is showing how you can make quality parts with inexpensive hobbyist machinery. Lots of great work holding and tool holding tips in your vids. I'm a big fan.
@vandalsgarage Жыл бұрын
absolutely agree! The actual replacement nut's design way a bit beyond me, but I learned so much about how the lathe can be used as a mill...really useful as a hobbyist who barely has place for a lathe :)
@raelkoping5675 Жыл бұрын
So good I thought you are a small fan,but you tell
@ateefehterminatour8685 Жыл бұрын
It's really satisfying watching something transform on the lathe when others would have used a mill.
@nefariousyawn Жыл бұрын
Very nice work being done in your videos. Good job.
@GlennNowOnYouTube Жыл бұрын
I've seen so many machining videos that it would make your head spin, but this video is absolutely incredible. Really well done!
@Rubbernecker Жыл бұрын
I have as well and whole heartedly agree. The machining creativity is spectacular.
@alleninventions8315 Жыл бұрын
Agree! Great video, great skill, and imagination! I also saw a video on the " we can do that better " channel, and he made an anti-backlash nut that was really great.
@Bob_Adkins Жыл бұрын
Очень хорошо ❤
@necattornac77744 ай бұрын
Brilliantly done, all on the lathe. Very impressive and works a treat!! Thanks for sharing this with us!!
@pjhalchemy Жыл бұрын
Some pretty crazy positioning and machining on the lathe! Thank you sir, great work!
@miyanohm Жыл бұрын
Turned out excellent. I did a similar project to my Grizzly gunsmithing lathe about a decade ago. I simply bought a replacement nut and then cut it in half and inserted a spring of sufficient strength in between the two halves. The spring was held sandwiched in between the two halves of my new lead-screw-nut by four long-enough screws in each corner of the lead-screw nut. It too was adjustable but, my method was way harder to adjust than your design. I did it that way because I knew I could finish it in a day or less. It worked well for me though. I just couldn't afford to have my lathe down for any length of time.
@timmontano87924 ай бұрын
It makes more sense to split the nut lengthwise. Attach one half to the crosslide and spring load the other half laterally. Because of the acme thread, provided there is tip clearance, this is like holding the half nuts closed with a spring force on a screwcutting lathe. This is how I got the idea: i noticed that my instrument lathe, which has a graduated dial on the screwcutting leadscrew handwheel, had no backlash on this (z) axis. (The halfnuts are held closed by a spring). Not much spring force is required because the Acme flanks are very steep (less than 15 degrees from square thread) which is less than the angle of friction. In the same way that a ladder will not slide regardless of weight if the angle is 15 degrees, the nuts will not open regardless of axial force.
@Gottenhimfella3 ай бұрын
Chamfering a square block in the 4 jaw 👌 salute you there sir, love seeing a new trick
@bullyproof5707 Жыл бұрын
Those were done pretty inventive setups there my man.... I loved the chamfers
@jonathonwood4088 Жыл бұрын
Nice work. I'll have to see if I can apply this to my old Logan. Thanks for sharing.
@sky173 Жыл бұрын
Very nice - and a wonderful example of how to use a lathe as a milling machine!
@gheumann Жыл бұрын
Main take away here is how well you used what little you had, most people think you need machining equipment 100 times larger than what you have to make anything what we see you make in this video.
@ToreDL874 ай бұрын
Like many here i absorb shit loads of shop & turning videos but I love lathe improvement, attachments, and upgrades the best. This project really shines because who the hell wouldn't love to reduce backlash to an absolute minimum? It's truly a rhetorical question. I'm going to investigate if I can adapt your excellent design to my old SB-H10 and Logan 920. Thanks for the very enjoyable and well done video. You did it with no monologue, yet the vid is clear enough to not suffer from its absence. Thanks! Wakodahatchee Chris
@cdrive5757 Жыл бұрын
Really well executed! Super project. Haven't seen this way of making an adjustable nut yet. I definitely keep this in mind. Thanks for sharing!
@WeCanDoThatBetter Жыл бұрын
Thank you!
@hammerland4028 Жыл бұрын
thanks again mister.
@Pushyhog5 ай бұрын
Excellent work on the part and the video, thank you!
@jimsvideos7201 Жыл бұрын
I've never seen this design, but I liked it a lot, thanks for sharing
@anglkrd3243 Жыл бұрын
Skill is the great equalizer. Congratulations to you sir.
@robertburns2415 Жыл бұрын
It’s people like you that make people like me, just like you. This is an awesome mod, specially for the Mini-lathe. Though, I would think with a bit of measuring it can be modified to fit any lathe that needed this. Great job.
@eddietowers55957 ай бұрын
Interesting design. I've been able to remove almost all the backlash in my mini-lathe by cutting a slot longways on the underside of the nut and squeezing it slightly in the vice. (Similar to the approach in Taig mill). But eventually this will wear, at which point I may try something like this.
@anthonykosky6495 Жыл бұрын
add a screw and you can adjust it! its a nasty fix without longevity, but it sure works for a cheap operation like mine!
@simonschneider59134 ай бұрын
All done on a lathe. Who needs a mill when you have determination. Well done.
@paulhamilton5634 Жыл бұрын
A good way to machine a complicated part if you don't have a milling machine. The nut appears to work very well.
@ellieprice3396 Жыл бұрын
Ten years ago I changed my minilathe to a brand new Chinese lathe with 255kg and 1,3 kw after I improved everything you could and It became a quite precise minilathe I sold it to a professional Vespa restaurator and he uses it to improve the cylinder and other parts of the italian motorbikes . I also changed the Nut into a sliced Nut with screws you could get the backlash down to a minimum...
@wolfitirol8347 Жыл бұрын
Wow just fantastic workmanship
@scottsoats2152 Жыл бұрын
Great job. I have one suggestion, and that is to spring load the 4 outward facing screws. It might make the final slack adjustment easier.
@bbigboy01 Жыл бұрын
I would do it so too. That way the central rotating part can be done in one piece with outside plate. There are "wavy" washers, which are ideal for this purpose.
@aleks1970nbg Жыл бұрын
Very nice work on the parts.
@wk70602 ай бұрын
Interesting way to do an adjustable backlash nut. I normally make a nut and bolt with a dowel an end plate on it then cut the thread. Then after this just take out the backlash with a shim and or grind. The problem with a rotating adjustment is it could move and lock it up. Its only a little lathe so it should be ok.
@dazaspc Жыл бұрын
Incredible good work, I have a similar lathe but by far not your skills! I had to mount a caliper... Congratulations!
@p4co781 Жыл бұрын
Great project very well presented would love more detail so i could use for my 12 x 36 lathe Thankyou
@metalshopwithtroy5755 Жыл бұрын
really good solution. had fun watching
@TechTomVideo Жыл бұрын
Great job. Thanks for sharing.
@greattechnical_AH Жыл бұрын
Excellent and innovative.
@bostedtap8399 Жыл бұрын
A great video showing lots of interesting techniques 😯 ( whether you want backlash reduced or not 🤞) K
@khrystree92338 ай бұрын
Impressive work, keep it up
@billyking8695 Жыл бұрын
It's about time someone came up with an answer to backlash. Instead of just living with it or recutting new threads.
@Landrew0 Жыл бұрын
As usual you do really nice work. You got the backlash down to less than 0.001". Of course short of going to a ball screw, no one can eliminate backlash 100%, but instead only come close. It's why we always approach our work in such a way as to remove the backlash first. Even the most precise CNC operations are programmed to approach the work in such a way as to remove backlash.
@fredflintstone8048 Жыл бұрын
Chinese mini-lathes like this one are metric, so double that assessment. ( I need to do this and more.. they are chatter machines after working steel for a while).
@tsclly2377 Жыл бұрын
@@tsclly2377 Mostly due to a lack of mass but there is also the approach to machining required to minimize chatter. Very involved CNC machines will vary RPM on the fly for example to try and minimize chatter. Once chatter starts when machining a part you will of course have variations in the cut that are synchronized with the vibration requiring a change in RPM, and often taking a more aggressive cut for a short time to cut through those undulations in the material.
@fredflintstone8048 Жыл бұрын
Chinese machinery is compromised in lots of ways. It's what makes them cheap. A waste of money if you ask me. I'd rather wait, save up and buy a decent used machine.
@rollinrat4850 Жыл бұрын
@@rollinrat4850 I've come to the same conclusion in hindsight. At some point I'll upgrade. I decided to spent a little more and buy a better milling machine than the Chinese offerings. I bought an A-head Bridgeport mill made in 1960. Loving it.
@fredflintstone8048 Жыл бұрын
I've done lots of work on Bridgeports and big Cincinnati horizontals. My favorite lathes are Hardringe tool room lathes. Glorious, super accurate machines. I did some of my most accurate work on those, Vlieg horizontal boring mills and a big Cincinnati CNC boring/milling center. This milling machine had a programmable touch probe that allowed it to inspect its own work. Really cool! It was also laser calibrated every other month for highly accurate aircraft maintenance work. I actually enjoy using Matsuura mills the most out of all the CNCs I've used. Very heavy duty and long lasting. I really dig lots of Japanese made products. Especially bicycle stuff, fishing gear and Toyota 4wds. I actually enjoy manual machining the most, but CNC work was the most productive and payed the bills. I'm sorta retired now and build custom bicycles and wheels for fun and extra cash. That's my real lifelong passion. That and designing/machining my own bike junk to get exactly what I want.
@rollinrat4850 Жыл бұрын
You could also have taken the existing spindle nut, drilled two holes axially for hard pins (3 mm?) and then cut the nut in half so that you have two short nuts. Mill off both parting surfaces at 5 degrees and make a wedge at 10 degrees with a hole in the middle that is several millimetres larger than the spindle. If you then make a thread on the slide between the two holes for fastening the threaded nut so that you can press on the wedge with a worm screw, you could also eliminate the thread play in this way.
@peterpan79038 ай бұрын
Need to add a Belleville disc spring between the backlash screw and the body...
@renaissanceman5847 Жыл бұрын
I can't begin to do precision work like the cuts you make. I have a cheap Jet lathe which has some kind of play which can make cutting tools dig in even on pretty small cuts.
@flyer6173 ай бұрын
7:05 well identified! the parting issue of the mini lathe. Seems like you've done quite a bit work with it to fix it that way. In general I'd rather install a ballscrew than this one, and make a new crossslide.
@mrechbreger Жыл бұрын
Nice! Thanks for sharing, Cheers
@rickpalechuk4411 Жыл бұрын
Quedo muy bien la Tuerca Cuadrada, Medio Decimo y lo vas Registrando !!
@oscardavidbenedetto437411 ай бұрын
Continue making Chinese lathe upgrade videos . I have also similar lathe
@jw200 Жыл бұрын
Top-Job, Sir💪👌
@adriankohli4870 Жыл бұрын
Great job
@rotating-alfadiq Жыл бұрын
Nice job!
@kevincunningham5124 Жыл бұрын
nice job did you lose any cross slid travel ? with the longer nut ? its open on the one end and from the look of the org. the mounting bolt hole to the front end looks about the same so ?
@chrisjarvis4449 Жыл бұрын
I keep thinking there should be a way to make the Acme cross slide nut like an ER32 collet and holder, with a tension ring just behind the handwheel and dial. You could just turn it by hand to remove backlash.
@Bob_Adkins Жыл бұрын
You perform as much mill work on the lathe as you do lathe work. Impressive.
@wk70602 ай бұрын
I know you most hear this a lot, but you are fkn AWESOME!!!
@johnlocke9609 Жыл бұрын
You are so amazing 👍
@uniqko Жыл бұрын
Can you tell me what size is the mandrel used for the grinding/cutting discs and where you got it if possible. Thanks
@deepwinter77 Жыл бұрын
The nut on the cross slide has backlash adjustment built in, using the set screw between the 2 attachment screws you can take out the backlash by snugging up one end and turning the set screw in until the backlash is gone, then tightening the attachment screws
@sassmastersq Жыл бұрын
I think having minumum backlash is important especially on small machine or heavy cuts or turning square and etc.Would resist the tool getting pulled in especiallly your machine tool does not have sufficient gib lock or you are using that one axis for cutting.
@woozhi92187 ай бұрын
Well done, brilliant, better than mine, will copy, cheers
@stevohdee81185 ай бұрын
I dunnoI watched this entire video and I still don't know what an Anti-backlash nut Chinese guy looks like! Humm, maybe I missed something. I enjoyed the video. Thank you, Sir!
@billwessels207 Жыл бұрын
really nice work, great is this ProCraft VMM800?
@marinajackson2363 Жыл бұрын
Nice video shot, thanks for sharing it :)
@Bianchi7710 ай бұрын
You're a lathe master :)
@technoshamanarchist4 ай бұрын
Wonderful, veri nice Brainstorming, very good Job.
@siggibohlenbrecher14034 ай бұрын
Although, wonderfully machine and a clever design.. it appears to me, that it is more of a slipper clutch or break-over friction clutch then a system that is designed to control lash gap in a controllable measure? Perhaps, maybe I missed something. But, yes, modifying this dinky little machines is so much fun, and affordable. I enjoy your content.
@drubradley8821 Жыл бұрын
Nice design.
@RRINTHESHOP Жыл бұрын
other than the joy of 'doing it yourself', is there any disadvantage in using an acme tap and die? Nice job, BTW
@en2oh Жыл бұрын
Respekt! Tolle Arbeit
@hoernst2762 Жыл бұрын
Would it also work with a spring that pushes the cariage towards the handle ? Hmm I guess not because you could only cut properly in one durection.
@BrainHurricanes Жыл бұрын
Excellent, the part I don't understand is how you can do all this work and not get your hands soiled? 'just saying'
@egdiryellam68 Жыл бұрын
wspaniale robota wykonana znakomicie jestem pełen podziwu dla ciebie 👍👍
@mrohny762 ай бұрын
Ultimately the screw will wear more in the region of the most frequent travel and then you have to leave some backlash anyway, otherwise the screw will bind up at either end. You must still develop the habit of making the last adjustment of the cross slide against the reactive force of the tool pressure.
@HuFlungDung2 Жыл бұрын
Indeed. If I was going to this much trouble I would make a self adjusting nut which tightens wherever the feedscrew is worn and loosens where it is not. There are plenty of complicated ways this is done (eg on manual milling machines of high standard) but a very simple way is to use the geometry of the acme thread to your advantage. If the nut is split lengthwise (ie the split plane includes the rotation axis) the two halves can be spring loaded together. Because the spring (and adjustment movement) is orthogonal to the translation axis, the spring is not exposed to feed forces, so it need not be so tight as to promote undue friction and wear. I got this idea because my Myford lathe has a graduated handwheel on the leadscrew for precise moves of the carriage, and I noticed that if I applied a small downforce to the lever which closes the half nuts for screwcutting, and adjusted the stop which normally prevents the half nuts closing fully, the backlash is eliminated altogether. It is important when applying this idea to cut the nuts with generous clearance at both root and tip, so the the nuts close only on the flanks of the screw. I guess it is the lack of this clearance on most half nuts (at least, once they are worn) which prevents more people noticing the possibilities of this remarkably simple solution.
@Gottenhimfella Жыл бұрын
@@Gottenhimfella - seems valid, however an Acme thread is not a square thread. The flanks of the thread are indeed angled, and any pressure on the thread's axis will tend to open up a "spring closed" split nut. So, backlash can certainly be eliminated during no-load conditions using a spring, however as soon as force is applied to the tool, the cross slide/carriage would literally become rubber mounted and jump all over the place. It would take careful consideration anout the strength of spring required to be stable enough to cope with considerable and often intermittent loads from cutting tools. There is a certainly a mechanical advantage from the narrow 29° thread angle, but there would still need to be quite a lot of preload needed for the spring to cope with axial thread forces. That preload also applies at all times, whether the thread is loaded or not, so it might well be that the leadscrew becomes worn significantly more quickly by that continual abrasion.
@johncoops6897 Жыл бұрын
@@johncoops6897 You're right in perfect (geometric) theory. A trapezoidal thread is not strictly orthogonal in the way that I (to keep the explanation simple) pretended. That would imply a square thread. However, real life materials, for once, come to the rescue, in practice, of something which should not work in theory. Geometric theory would tell the whole story if the split nut (and its guideways) were made of something as slippery as (say) wet ice. In the same way, a ladder made of wet ice would invariably skid out (particularly on a wet ice floor) at an angle of 15 degrees to the wall (which is about the angle, per side, of an acme thread). This "angle of friction" is exploited in mechanisms like Torsen diffs and Duff Norton jacks, to act a bit like a diode or a check valve. And that's what I'm doing here. It has to be a trapezoidal, rather than square, thread, or my proposal would not take up the backlash. But 15 degrees per side is about perfect (as I intuited from the fact that lathe half nuts do not try to open even when the carriage runs into the headstock)
@Gottenhimfella Жыл бұрын
It occurs to me that Myford lathes offer another example of this principle in action. I have an ML7 I inherited from my dad, and a Super 7 acquired decades later (when they finally became affordable). On the ML7, the tailstock barrel stays where you put it. On the Super 7, axial force can under some circumstances cause the barrel to retract if the clamp is not tightened. The reason is that the helix angle for the ML7 is well below the angle of friction. The Super 7 has a smaller diameter, three start thread, with a much higher helix angle, maybe four times as much. This is fantastic for drilling, being both quicker for withdrawing to clear chips and apply fresh fluid, and offering far better feel (important, for instance, with very small drills or reamers).
@Gottenhimfella Жыл бұрын
Good job👍👍
@samirzeghloul973711 ай бұрын
It was enough to make a pressure on the side of the guide to prevent the knife from being pulled in when cutting
@Lechoslowianin Жыл бұрын
Bravo........a ball screw......cheers
@mattharvey8712 Жыл бұрын
Wonder full job
@aniljadav2743 Жыл бұрын
Vert clever design. I like it.
@chrisjh777 Жыл бұрын
instant sub. but also, perhaps a spring system might have been better? that way you'd be able to use less pressure (less wear on the nut), it wouldn't come loose with vibrations, and it would work for a lot longer without maintenance because as the nut would get pushed forward as it wears.
@Tristoo Жыл бұрын
And what happens if force is applied in the direction of the spring? backlash
@heybabycometobutthead Жыл бұрын
Tris T, The solution you propose would be more interesting if you do it and show it to us in a video of yours.
@CarlosSilva-gc8ny Жыл бұрын
@@heybabycometobutthead this might blow your mind, but springs of appropriate stiffness are real
@Tristoo Жыл бұрын
@@Tristoo This might blow your mind, it won't work, that's why nobody has ever done it.
@heybabycometobutthead Жыл бұрын
@@CarlosSilva-gc8ny I don't get why you guys are being so defensive about it, it's simple feedback, a possible improvement on an already great job. And if I even had a lathe I would have already done it bud, and then I wouldn't be suggesting anything.
@Tristoo Жыл бұрын
Do you have a video on how to turn short round stock ? Like very short, 1/2 inch short, diameter fits inside the jaws
@tonycstech Жыл бұрын
Awesome fix, would you sell that nut?
@jl3415 Жыл бұрын
Very Good
@yeeli4840 Жыл бұрын
excelente trabalho, parabens
@joelhaukhauk7330 Жыл бұрын
so how much would you sell that part to stores for? $$$
@jmcg2518 Жыл бұрын
Гарна робота !!!Респект!!!!!
@kabovasya Жыл бұрын
Should you not have machined the parts before throwing away the follower nut? ;-}
@Tensquaremetreworkshop Жыл бұрын
Do you sell these? i would love to buy one
@mikew-vj6yu Жыл бұрын
Sehr schön gemacht. Das Umkehrspiel ist immer ein Problem, weil der Drehstahl oder der Fräser ich auch in die Maschine hineinziehen kann. Sie wissen nie wann und wieviel das Werkzeug gezogen wird. An der Drehmaschine tragen sie dadurch schnell zuviel ab, bei der Fräsmaschine zerbrechen sie das Werkzeug und mehr. Einstellbare Spindelmuttern mit Federn lösen dieses Problem nicht. Es muss ein fest einstellbare Spindelmutter sein, deren Gewindeflanken auf beiden Seiten tragen.
@Anrufbeantworter Жыл бұрын
Nice project! But on a manually operated machine backlash is not really a problem as you compensate for it by always feeding in one direction and make sure to take up any backlash before making a cut. And a anti backlash nut will just wear faster until it has just as much backlash again as the old one.
@titter3648 Жыл бұрын
The anti-backlash nut is adjustable, so you just adjust it when it wears. Sheesh! The gibs on the lathe are adjustable. Do you leave them loose, because if you adjust them tighter they might wear so you'd have to adjust them? Do you not tighten your shoe laces because that would make them loose so you would have to re-tie them?
@johncoops6897 Жыл бұрын
@@johncoops6897 Still backlash is not a problem on a manual lathe. Because you can feel the backlash and compensate for it by only dialing in one direction, or take out all of the backlash when changing the direction.
@titter3648 Жыл бұрын
@@titter3648 - you are correct, that backlash is more of an annoyance than a serious problem. However less backlash and slop makes the machine feel a lot nicer to use... more "precise" even though is isn't really. My original comment is about the statements made in your first post. I am not saying whether such a modification is a good idea.
@johncoops6897 Жыл бұрын
Agreed.
@EricTViking Жыл бұрын
@@johncoops6897 You are assuming all the wear is on the nut. However the problematic wear is to the feedscrew, because it always wears more in the middle than at the ends.The nut cannot be tightened to compensate, because it will bind at the ends.
@Gottenhimfella Жыл бұрын
Are you making these to sell?
@tonyhddodge4282 Жыл бұрын
Отличная идея, скоро себе сварганю такую гайку, прижимные планки для продольной подачи уже сделал работают отлично, у меня вопрос по рпижимным планкам с клиньями, тебе не приходилось шлифовать станину снизу где скользят клинья или мне так повезло с моим *джетом 7*? Или эти станки все с одинаковыми болячками?
@user-ov9kp8ho5q Жыл бұрын
У меня там все кривое, пока не придумал как просто выровнять те поверхности, но они особо не напрягают пока
@hammerland4028 Жыл бұрын
@@hammerland4028 я вот думаю попробовать гравёром, закрепить на спорт и отшлифовать, но пока не придумал как подавать образив, глубину за проход.
@user-ov9kp8ho5q Жыл бұрын
Great work, but why remove backlash on conventional lathe ? I work with lathes and mills (conventoional) and backlash is never a problem.
@pierredupre3716 Жыл бұрын
On large machines, play in the cross feed is not a problem due to the large weight.
@hammerland4028 Жыл бұрын
Nicely done, btw your lathe is so shiny do you wipe it every day 😇
@SkillfulMan Жыл бұрын
What stops the sleeve with the two tapers from screwing toward the main nut, undoing the "anti backlash" you achieved by "unscrewing" the sleeve away from the nut?
@eatonasher3398 Жыл бұрын
Interesante el video, me gusto.
@fredevindoortega1233 Жыл бұрын
Great approach for minimizing backlash on a mini lathe! It looks like you've already addressed the leadscrew floating where it attaches to the handle, I removed 0.012 backlash at the nut and another 0.008" movement of the leadscrew. Scraping the dovetails took a 0.009" bow of it. Still need to do the x axis, thats going to be an incredibly long a boring job as I don't own a surface grinder. Over 0.030" to remove! Almost not worth it.
@jefflyon100 Жыл бұрын
almost worth buying another.. so you can send it out.. maybe worth it if you are going to cnc part of it to use in serial production
@tsclly2377 Жыл бұрын
It was much easier, just give the existing nut a saw slot through the screw thread and then press with a screw that opens the saw slot, you have made a perfect backlash free nut that you can adjust. Costs you nothing and 10 minutes of work.
@JaapGrootveld Жыл бұрын
I agree your its a much simple system I do not know if its worth all the precision engineering on a cheap Chinese lathe!!!!!!
@johnhili8664 Жыл бұрын
@@johnhili8664 Well, it's not about being economical, but learning. It's all good exercise.
@Exgrmbl Жыл бұрын
I'm surprised if you take all the backlash out of the nut that it will even let you turn the handle at all without a lot of torque. It will not take long to wear it till you have backlash again.
@gvet47 Жыл бұрын
That is why the nut is adjustable. When it wears, you adjust it. DOH
@johncoops6897 Жыл бұрын
I agree, I use the slide lock and measure the backlash, and re-set the dials, never found backlash a problem, except on milling machines
@andrewwilson6085 Жыл бұрын
@@andrewwilson6085 - backlash is an annoyance, both on lathes and in vices, as well as anything else (eg: adjustable wrenches) where it means you can only sneak up from one direction. Minimising backlash makes all tools far nicer to use. It's unreasonable to expect to eliminate it entirely, however removing most of it just makes tool operation so much more pleasant.
@johncoops6897 Жыл бұрын
How much would you charge me to make this exact same thing? I’ll pay for the material, labor, and shipping up front friend….
@anthonyflores9846 Жыл бұрын
хорошая гайка👍 только вот если ещё масленку туда приспособить, то она будет жить и жить✌
@user-lq6lp4yu1q Жыл бұрын
Çok güzel bir paylaşım olmuş 👍🤝🇹🇷
@weldingbilgin Жыл бұрын
Was the nut made from brass or some bronze alloy?
@berntd Жыл бұрын
Bronze alloy
@hammerland4028 Жыл бұрын
10:10 you should have used copper or aluminum shims
@stingable7 ай бұрын
Impressive. Most impressive. Darth Vader.
@opieshomeshop Жыл бұрын
Next project should be some soft jaws.
@cozf8109 Жыл бұрын
👍👍👍💪
@Freser-qp5zc Жыл бұрын
You should really use zero raked tools on brass, it makes a huge difference, backlash isn't much of a problem as your tooling does dive into the backlash anymore.
I've got two old lathes, both about 80 years old. They have acquired excessive backlash over their lifetimes (rather than having it factory-fitted) but I think I'll try your fix. At worst I can put the original parts back on and I'll have learnt something. Thanks for posting this.
@sourand jaded thanks, I'll try that.
The lathe bed will also wear most near the chuck......
Well done, sir. Setting aside the discussion over anti-backlash nuts, the bigger impact of this vid is showing how you can make quality parts with inexpensive hobbyist machinery. Lots of great work holding and tool holding tips in your vids. I'm a big fan.
absolutely agree! The actual replacement nut's design way a bit beyond me, but I learned so much about how the lathe can be used as a mill...really useful as a hobbyist who barely has place for a lathe :)
So good I thought you are a small fan,but you tell
It's really satisfying watching something transform on the lathe when others would have used a mill.
Very nice work being done in your videos. Good job.
I've seen so many machining videos that it would make your head spin, but this video is absolutely incredible. Really well done!
I have as well and whole heartedly agree. The machining creativity is spectacular.
Agree! Great video, great skill, and imagination! I also saw a video on the " we can do that better " channel, and he made an anti-backlash nut that was really great.
Очень хорошо ❤
Brilliantly done, all on the lathe. Very impressive and works a treat!! Thanks for sharing this with us!!
Some pretty crazy positioning and machining on the lathe! Thank you sir, great work!
Turned out excellent. I did a similar project to my Grizzly gunsmithing lathe about a decade ago. I simply bought a replacement nut and then cut it in half and inserted a spring of sufficient strength in between the two halves. The spring was held sandwiched in between the two halves of my new lead-screw-nut by four long-enough screws in each corner of the lead-screw nut. It too was adjustable but, my method was way harder to adjust than your design. I did it that way because I knew I could finish it in a day or less. It worked well for me though. I just couldn't afford to have my lathe down for any length of time.
It makes more sense to split the nut lengthwise. Attach one half to the crosslide and spring load the other half laterally. Because of the acme thread, provided there is tip clearance, this is like holding the half nuts closed with a spring force on a screwcutting lathe. This is how I got the idea: i noticed that my instrument lathe, which has a graduated dial on the screwcutting leadscrew handwheel, had no backlash on this (z) axis. (The halfnuts are held closed by a spring). Not much spring force is required because the Acme flanks are very steep (less than 15 degrees from square thread) which is less than the angle of friction. In the same way that a ladder will not slide regardless of weight if the angle is 15 degrees, the nuts will not open regardless of axial force.
Chamfering a square block in the 4 jaw 👌 salute you there sir, love seeing a new trick
Those were done pretty inventive setups there my man.... I loved the chamfers
Nice work. I'll have to see if I can apply this to my old Logan. Thanks for sharing.
Very nice - and a wonderful example of how to use a lathe as a milling machine!
Main take away here is how well you used what little you had, most people think you need machining equipment 100 times larger than what you have to make anything what we see you make in this video.
Like many here i absorb shit loads of shop & turning videos but I love lathe improvement, attachments, and upgrades the best. This project really shines because who the hell wouldn't love to reduce backlash to an absolute minimum? It's truly a rhetorical question. I'm going to investigate if I can adapt your excellent design to my old SB-H10 and Logan 920. Thanks for the very enjoyable and well done video. You did it with no monologue, yet the vid is clear enough to not suffer from its absence. Thanks! Wakodahatchee Chris
Really well executed! Super project. Haven't seen this way of making an adjustable nut yet. I definitely keep this in mind. Thanks for sharing!
Thank you!
thanks again mister.
Excellent work on the part and the video, thank you!
I've never seen this design, but I liked it a lot, thanks for sharing
Skill is the great equalizer. Congratulations to you sir.
It’s people like you that make people like me, just like you. This is an awesome mod, specially for the Mini-lathe. Though, I would think with a bit of measuring it can be modified to fit any lathe that needed this. Great job.
Interesting design. I've been able to remove almost all the backlash in my mini-lathe by cutting a slot longways on the underside of the nut and squeezing it slightly in the vice. (Similar to the approach in Taig mill). But eventually this will wear, at which point I may try something like this.
add a screw and you can adjust it! its a nasty fix without longevity, but it sure works for a cheap operation like mine!
All done on a lathe. Who needs a mill when you have determination. Well done.
A good way to machine a complicated part if you don't have a milling machine. The nut appears to work very well.
Ten years ago I changed my minilathe to a brand new Chinese lathe with 255kg and 1,3 kw after I improved everything you could and It became a quite precise minilathe I sold it to a professional Vespa restaurator and he uses it to improve the cylinder and other parts of the italian motorbikes . I also changed the Nut into a sliced Nut with screws you could get the backlash down to a minimum...
Wow just fantastic workmanship
Great job. I have one suggestion, and that is to spring load the 4 outward facing screws. It might make the final slack adjustment easier.
I would do it so too. That way the central rotating part can be done in one piece with outside plate. There are "wavy" washers, which are ideal for this purpose.
Very nice work on the parts.
Interesting way to do an adjustable backlash nut. I normally make a nut and bolt with a dowel an end plate on it then cut the thread. Then after this just take out the backlash with a shim and or grind. The problem with a rotating adjustment is it could move and lock it up. Its only a little lathe so it should be ok.
Incredible good work, I have a similar lathe but by far not your skills! I had to mount a caliper... Congratulations!
Great project very well presented would love more detail so i could use for my 12 x 36 lathe Thankyou
really good solution. had fun watching
Great job. Thanks for sharing.
Excellent and innovative.
A great video showing lots of interesting techniques 😯 ( whether you want backlash reduced or not 🤞) K
Impressive work, keep it up
It's about time someone came up with an answer to backlash. Instead of just living with it or recutting new threads.
As usual you do really nice work. You got the backlash down to less than 0.001". Of course short of going to a ball screw, no one can eliminate backlash 100%, but instead only come close. It's why we always approach our work in such a way as to remove the backlash first. Even the most precise CNC operations are programmed to approach the work in such a way as to remove backlash.
Chinese mini-lathes like this one are metric, so double that assessment. ( I need to do this and more.. they are chatter machines after working steel for a while).
@@tsclly2377 Mostly due to a lack of mass but there is also the approach to machining required to minimize chatter. Very involved CNC machines will vary RPM on the fly for example to try and minimize chatter. Once chatter starts when machining a part you will of course have variations in the cut that are synchronized with the vibration requiring a change in RPM, and often taking a more aggressive cut for a short time to cut through those undulations in the material.
Chinese machinery is compromised in lots of ways. It's what makes them cheap. A waste of money if you ask me. I'd rather wait, save up and buy a decent used machine.
@@rollinrat4850 I've come to the same conclusion in hindsight. At some point I'll upgrade. I decided to spent a little more and buy a better milling machine than the Chinese offerings. I bought an A-head Bridgeport mill made in 1960. Loving it.
I've done lots of work on Bridgeports and big Cincinnati horizontals. My favorite lathes are Hardringe tool room lathes. Glorious, super accurate machines. I did some of my most accurate work on those, Vlieg horizontal boring mills and a big Cincinnati CNC boring/milling center. This milling machine had a programmable touch probe that allowed it to inspect its own work. Really cool! It was also laser calibrated every other month for highly accurate aircraft maintenance work. I actually enjoy using Matsuura mills the most out of all the CNCs I've used. Very heavy duty and long lasting. I really dig lots of Japanese made products. Especially bicycle stuff, fishing gear and Toyota 4wds. I actually enjoy manual machining the most, but CNC work was the most productive and payed the bills. I'm sorta retired now and build custom bicycles and wheels for fun and extra cash. That's my real lifelong passion. That and designing/machining my own bike junk to get exactly what I want.
You could also have taken the existing spindle nut, drilled two holes axially for hard pins (3 mm?) and then cut the nut in half so that you have two short nuts. Mill off both parting surfaces at 5 degrees and make a wedge at 10 degrees with a hole in the middle that is several millimetres larger than the spindle. If you then make a thread on the slide between the two holes for fastening the threaded nut so that you can press on the wedge with a worm screw, you could also eliminate the thread play in this way.
Need to add a Belleville disc spring between the backlash screw and the body...
I can't begin to do precision work like the cuts you make. I have a cheap Jet lathe which has some kind of play which can make cutting tools dig in even on pretty small cuts.
7:05 well identified! the parting issue of the mini lathe. Seems like you've done quite a bit work with it to fix it that way. In general I'd rather install a ballscrew than this one, and make a new crossslide.
Nice! Thanks for sharing, Cheers
Quedo muy bien la Tuerca Cuadrada, Medio Decimo y lo vas Registrando !!
Continue making Chinese lathe upgrade videos . I have also similar lathe
Top-Job, Sir💪👌
Great job
Nice job!
nice job did you lose any cross slid travel ? with the longer nut ? its open on the one end and from the look of the org. the mounting bolt hole to the front end looks about the same so ?
I keep thinking there should be a way to make the Acme cross slide nut like an ER32 collet and holder, with a tension ring just behind the handwheel and dial. You could just turn it by hand to remove backlash.
You perform as much mill work on the lathe as you do lathe work. Impressive.
I know you most hear this a lot, but you are fkn AWESOME!!!
You are so amazing 👍
Can you tell me what size is the mandrel used for the grinding/cutting discs and where you got it if possible. Thanks
The nut on the cross slide has backlash adjustment built in, using the set screw between the 2 attachment screws you can take out the backlash by snugging up one end and turning the set screw in until the backlash is gone, then tightening the attachment screws
I think having minumum backlash is important especially on small machine or heavy cuts or turning square and etc.Would resist the tool getting pulled in especiallly your machine tool does not have sufficient gib lock or you are using that one axis for cutting.
Well done, brilliant, better than mine, will copy, cheers
I dunnoI watched this entire video and I still don't know what an Anti-backlash nut Chinese guy looks like! Humm, maybe I missed something. I enjoyed the video. Thank you, Sir!
really nice work, great is this ProCraft VMM800?
Nice video shot, thanks for sharing it :)
You're a lathe master :)
Wonderful, veri nice Brainstorming, very good Job.
Although, wonderfully machine and a clever design.. it appears to me, that it is more of a slipper clutch or break-over friction clutch then a system that is designed to control lash gap in a controllable measure? Perhaps, maybe I missed something. But, yes, modifying this dinky little machines is so much fun, and affordable. I enjoy your content.
Nice design.
other than the joy of 'doing it yourself', is there any disadvantage in using an acme tap and die? Nice job, BTW
Respekt! Tolle Arbeit
Would it also work with a spring that pushes the cariage towards the handle ? Hmm I guess not because you could only cut properly in one durection.
Excellent, the part I don't understand is how you can do all this work and not get your hands soiled? 'just saying'
wspaniale robota wykonana znakomicie jestem pełen podziwu dla ciebie 👍👍
Ultimately the screw will wear more in the region of the most frequent travel and then you have to leave some backlash anyway, otherwise the screw will bind up at either end. You must still develop the habit of making the last adjustment of the cross slide against the reactive force of the tool pressure.
Indeed. If I was going to this much trouble I would make a self adjusting nut which tightens wherever the feedscrew is worn and loosens where it is not. There are plenty of complicated ways this is done (eg on manual milling machines of high standard) but a very simple way is to use the geometry of the acme thread to your advantage. If the nut is split lengthwise (ie the split plane includes the rotation axis) the two halves can be spring loaded together. Because the spring (and adjustment movement) is orthogonal to the translation axis, the spring is not exposed to feed forces, so it need not be so tight as to promote undue friction and wear. I got this idea because my Myford lathe has a graduated handwheel on the leadscrew for precise moves of the carriage, and I noticed that if I applied a small downforce to the lever which closes the half nuts for screwcutting, and adjusted the stop which normally prevents the half nuts closing fully, the backlash is eliminated altogether. It is important when applying this idea to cut the nuts with generous clearance at both root and tip, so the the nuts close only on the flanks of the screw. I guess it is the lack of this clearance on most half nuts (at least, once they are worn) which prevents more people noticing the possibilities of this remarkably simple solution.
@@Gottenhimfella - seems valid, however an Acme thread is not a square thread. The flanks of the thread are indeed angled, and any pressure on the thread's axis will tend to open up a "spring closed" split nut. So, backlash can certainly be eliminated during no-load conditions using a spring, however as soon as force is applied to the tool, the cross slide/carriage would literally become rubber mounted and jump all over the place. It would take careful consideration anout the strength of spring required to be stable enough to cope with considerable and often intermittent loads from cutting tools. There is a certainly a mechanical advantage from the narrow 29° thread angle, but there would still need to be quite a lot of preload needed for the spring to cope with axial thread forces. That preload also applies at all times, whether the thread is loaded or not, so it might well be that the leadscrew becomes worn significantly more quickly by that continual abrasion.
@@johncoops6897 You're right in perfect (geometric) theory. A trapezoidal thread is not strictly orthogonal in the way that I (to keep the explanation simple) pretended. That would imply a square thread. However, real life materials, for once, come to the rescue, in practice, of something which should not work in theory. Geometric theory would tell the whole story if the split nut (and its guideways) were made of something as slippery as (say) wet ice. In the same way, a ladder made of wet ice would invariably skid out (particularly on a wet ice floor) at an angle of 15 degrees to the wall (which is about the angle, per side, of an acme thread). This "angle of friction" is exploited in mechanisms like Torsen diffs and Duff Norton jacks, to act a bit like a diode or a check valve. And that's what I'm doing here. It has to be a trapezoidal, rather than square, thread, or my proposal would not take up the backlash. But 15 degrees per side is about perfect (as I intuited from the fact that lathe half nuts do not try to open even when the carriage runs into the headstock)
It occurs to me that Myford lathes offer another example of this principle in action. I have an ML7 I inherited from my dad, and a Super 7 acquired decades later (when they finally became affordable). On the ML7, the tailstock barrel stays where you put it. On the Super 7, axial force can under some circumstances cause the barrel to retract if the clamp is not tightened. The reason is that the helix angle for the ML7 is well below the angle of friction. The Super 7 has a smaller diameter, three start thread, with a much higher helix angle, maybe four times as much. This is fantastic for drilling, being both quicker for withdrawing to clear chips and apply fresh fluid, and offering far better feel (important, for instance, with very small drills or reamers).
Good job👍👍
It was enough to make a pressure on the side of the guide to prevent the knife from being pulled in when cutting
Bravo........a ball screw......cheers
Wonder full job
Vert clever design. I like it.
instant sub. but also, perhaps a spring system might have been better? that way you'd be able to use less pressure (less wear on the nut), it wouldn't come loose with vibrations, and it would work for a lot longer without maintenance because as the nut would get pushed forward as it wears.
And what happens if force is applied in the direction of the spring? backlash
Tris T, The solution you propose would be more interesting if you do it and show it to us in a video of yours.
@@heybabycometobutthead this might blow your mind, but springs of appropriate stiffness are real
@@Tristoo This might blow your mind, it won't work, that's why nobody has ever done it.
@@CarlosSilva-gc8ny I don't get why you guys are being so defensive about it, it's simple feedback, a possible improvement on an already great job. And if I even had a lathe I would have already done it bud, and then I wouldn't be suggesting anything.
Do you have a video on how to turn short round stock ? Like very short, 1/2 inch short, diameter fits inside the jaws
Awesome fix, would you sell that nut?
Very Good
excelente trabalho, parabens
so how much would you sell that part to stores for? $$$
Гарна робота !!!Респект!!!!!
Should you not have machined the parts before throwing away the follower nut? ;-}
Do you sell these? i would love to buy one
Sehr schön gemacht. Das Umkehrspiel ist immer ein Problem, weil der Drehstahl oder der Fräser ich auch in die Maschine hineinziehen kann. Sie wissen nie wann und wieviel das Werkzeug gezogen wird. An der Drehmaschine tragen sie dadurch schnell zuviel ab, bei der Fräsmaschine zerbrechen sie das Werkzeug und mehr. Einstellbare Spindelmuttern mit Federn lösen dieses Problem nicht. Es muss ein fest einstellbare Spindelmutter sein, deren Gewindeflanken auf beiden Seiten tragen.
Nice project! But on a manually operated machine backlash is not really a problem as you compensate for it by always feeding in one direction and make sure to take up any backlash before making a cut. And a anti backlash nut will just wear faster until it has just as much backlash again as the old one.
The anti-backlash nut is adjustable, so you just adjust it when it wears. Sheesh! The gibs on the lathe are adjustable. Do you leave them loose, because if you adjust them tighter they might wear so you'd have to adjust them? Do you not tighten your shoe laces because that would make them loose so you would have to re-tie them?
@@johncoops6897 Still backlash is not a problem on a manual lathe. Because you can feel the backlash and compensate for it by only dialing in one direction, or take out all of the backlash when changing the direction.
@@titter3648 - you are correct, that backlash is more of an annoyance than a serious problem. However less backlash and slop makes the machine feel a lot nicer to use... more "precise" even though is isn't really. My original comment is about the statements made in your first post. I am not saying whether such a modification is a good idea.
Agreed.
@@johncoops6897 You are assuming all the wear is on the nut. However the problematic wear is to the feedscrew, because it always wears more in the middle than at the ends.The nut cannot be tightened to compensate, because it will bind at the ends.
Are you making these to sell?
Отличная идея, скоро себе сварганю такую гайку, прижимные планки для продольной подачи уже сделал работают отлично, у меня вопрос по рпижимным планкам с клиньями, тебе не приходилось шлифовать станину снизу где скользят клинья или мне так повезло с моим *джетом 7*? Или эти станки все с одинаковыми болячками?
У меня там все кривое, пока не придумал как просто выровнять те поверхности, но они особо не напрягают пока
@@hammerland4028 я вот думаю попробовать гравёром, закрепить на спорт и отшлифовать, но пока не придумал как подавать образив, глубину за проход.
Great work, but why remove backlash on conventional lathe ? I work with lathes and mills (conventoional) and backlash is never a problem.
On large machines, play in the cross feed is not a problem due to the large weight.
Nicely done, btw your lathe is so shiny do you wipe it every day 😇
What stops the sleeve with the two tapers from screwing toward the main nut, undoing the "anti backlash" you achieved by "unscrewing" the sleeve away from the nut?
Interesante el video, me gusto.
Great approach for minimizing backlash on a mini lathe! It looks like you've already addressed the leadscrew floating where it attaches to the handle, I removed 0.012 backlash at the nut and another 0.008" movement of the leadscrew. Scraping the dovetails took a 0.009" bow of it. Still need to do the x axis, thats going to be an incredibly long a boring job as I don't own a surface grinder. Over 0.030" to remove! Almost not worth it.
almost worth buying another.. so you can send it out.. maybe worth it if you are going to cnc part of it to use in serial production
It was much easier, just give the existing nut a saw slot through the screw thread and then press with a screw that opens the saw slot, you have made a perfect backlash free nut that you can adjust. Costs you nothing and 10 minutes of work.
I agree your its a much simple system I do not know if its worth all the precision engineering on a cheap Chinese lathe!!!!!!
@@johnhili8664 Well, it's not about being economical, but learning. It's all good exercise.
I'm surprised if you take all the backlash out of the nut that it will even let you turn the handle at all without a lot of torque. It will not take long to wear it till you have backlash again.
That is why the nut is adjustable. When it wears, you adjust it. DOH
I agree, I use the slide lock and measure the backlash, and re-set the dials, never found backlash a problem, except on milling machines
@@andrewwilson6085 - backlash is an annoyance, both on lathes and in vices, as well as anything else (eg: adjustable wrenches) where it means you can only sneak up from one direction. Minimising backlash makes all tools far nicer to use. It's unreasonable to expect to eliminate it entirely, however removing most of it just makes tool operation so much more pleasant.
How much would you charge me to make this exact same thing? I’ll pay for the material, labor, and shipping up front friend….
хорошая гайка👍 только вот если ещё масленку туда приспособить, то она будет жить и жить✌
Çok güzel bir paylaşım olmuş 👍🤝🇹🇷
Was the nut made from brass or some bronze alloy?
Bronze alloy
10:10 you should have used copper or aluminum shims
Impressive. Most impressive. Darth Vader.
Next project should be some soft jaws.
👍👍👍💪
You should really use zero raked tools on brass, it makes a huge difference, backlash isn't much of a problem as your tooling does dive into the backlash anymore.