Russia defenceless to Ukrainian drones in major embarrassment for Putin | Michael Clarke
2024 ж. 15 Мам.
154 373 Рет қаралды
Michael Clarke joins Frontline to discuss the future of NATO, Russia's upcoming offensive and the prospect of a Trump presidency.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Shame on Western allies for their weakness and failure to act.
lol the west doesnt care about ukraine. "it may be dangerous to be America's enemy, but to be America's friend is fatal."
Stop begging America You are on your own
I know , I feel like CURCHHILL IN SEPT. 19 1939, FRUSTRATED WITH WISHY WASHY PRESIDENT BIDEN NO MOTIVATIONAL SPEECH TO THE NATION TO BE ARMS ( 29:45 ARSENAL) FACTORY OF DEMOCRACY. YO J.B. JUST USE SAME SPEECH MOST PEOPLE WON'T NOTICE OR CARE. ITS A GREAT "WAR IN EUROPE" SPEECH..... LOOKING GOOD HOSTESS.... JABO.
This war is working well for US MIC corporation profits, in weakening the economies of European countries and opening out the agricultural and mineral resources of what was once the Ukraine to BlackRock, Monsanto and others.
Russia are the good guys. The west is evil
Michael Clarke is a joy to listen to, he's asked a question and he answers without umm's and ah's that many others do.
Mist con men are smooth talkers
@@bryandimery6509fanny
Duh!
Highlights Ukraine’s power grid disaster
@@bryandimery6509 get a life VatBot
Michael Clarke as always points to most important things.
LIke what?
Great Show Kate, per usual, and I'm always eager to hear what Clarke, Sherriff, and Hodges have to say. If they had been running things this bloody war would have been over the end of 2023. Thanks for the update from America.
Yes because people who are ready to tell BS and things you like are getting smaller and smaller- The guy was trained specifically for this sort of situation and your type of people.
@@rouz0 _"The guy"_ was not _"trained specifically for this sort of situation"_ whatever that bizarre collection of words is meant to mean 🙄. He is a renowned and distinguished academic who has studied defence for his entire academic career.
@Muddy283 you were not in academia and don't know how argument from authority is used in such cases. By the way, getting a degree does not make you any more moral and improve your character. I tell it as an academician dealing with hundreds of them
@@rouz0 I was in academia. What has _"argument from authority"_ to do with academic research? Where did you get the notion that I entertain the absurd idea that _"getting a degree"_ makes you any more moral? All these various statements by you are very bizarre indeed.
@Muddy283 So then you should understand that he generally say BS. Not because he does not know but because it is his job to tell those BS. Otherwise, knowing what is going on in Ukraine it is not difficult for those who research it.
Good afternoon Kate, enjoyed this, and listening to Michael Clarke again. One major critique, we're not giving the right response to Putin. Zelensky, Budanov and Syrski have made it quite clear. Ben Hodges, Macron, the tall Dutch guy whose name begins with 'V', Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland are all fully on board. So must we be. There is no discussion until every Russian boot has left Ukrainian territory (or is buried under it- my words), including all the occupied territories including Crimea. So if we are Ukraine's friends, that is what we are helping them to do. Anything less is cowardice, treachery and backstabbing. Do we want to have that against us when the history books are updated.
That’s hilarious , I don’t think your insistence that “there is no discussion” will prove to be relevant given the fact that Russia is winning the conflict and has no reason to “discuss” anything!
if you’re suggesting additional european armies should march on crimea and the donbas, you need to understand that russia would consider this an existential threat and grounds for nuclear retaliation. moreover, none of these european countries except perhaps the baltic states have any interest in spilling their own blood to save ukraine-the poorest and, along with russia and moldova, one of the three most corrupt countries in europe-from losing 20% of its territory. keep in mind the US-backed west has stood idly by while russia has held on to pieces of georgia and moldova, while azerbaijan ethnically cleansed armenians from nagorno-karabakh, and protected Israel from diplomatic consequences for stealing land from its neighbors
He never gets enough time on the mainstream news channels so the questions and his analysis are less comprehensive. Well done for this interview. 30 mins of considered opinion. Great work Times Radio.
EVERYBODY MUST deliver to help Ukraine win this nightmare! History will judge ALL OF US, if we Do not. Personally I am prepared to sacrifice financially . Kind regards from Denmark.
Thank you for your support in Ukraine’s defence of Western Europe
Thanks, times radio, for bringing Michael Clark back ❤always appreciate his insights! P.S. where the orc bots at? No more potatoes ?
The bot is right here! what is your question and what are his lies and fantasies you need me to discuss for you
briandimery is spouting nonsense and ruzzian talking points under most comments as usual, they’re beyond pathetic!
The orcs are keel ling a lot of urks.
Kudos to Kate Gerbeau. As usual, skillful, knowledgeable interview. Keep up the good work!
Micheal Clark is brilliant
He is bias, and misinformed
@@user-ny2mi8kp7pcry harder
He is a clever fool, and you are fooled.
@@graemes52 cry harder
@@user-ny2mi8kp7phow did you make it to troll third class with such poor English skills comrade vatnik?
Brilliant Strategic insight Michael 👏
I really enjoy watching Michael Clark explaining an teaching us everything about the war. Cheers and best of luck to Ukrainians.
Maybe have a watch of Scott Ritter's analysis of this whole thing, to get another opinion? (You know, the ex- US marine intelligence officer and ex- UN weapons inspector) Or Col Doug McGregor (ex US TankForces Commander during Desert Storm) Larry Johnson (ex CIA analysist) Ray MacGovern (ex CIA), You might be surprised by how their analysis differs from the mainstream. All available on YT. I'm sure you'd agree, its good to inform yourself from all sides of an arguement, then make up your own mind?
Kate, Another great show.I wish Michael Clark and Gen. Ben Hodges could get more exposure, especially in American Mass Media, to make the case for the value of the Ukrainian aid package towards American national security. Unfortunately, the general American public is not very well informed in regards to events beyond our borders and have no conception of the ravages for war and the dangers of imperialism or fascism.It's all very abstract and they don't understand how global events affect their daily lives. It's like reliving the 1930's and 40's. ( unfortunately our 'Greatest Generation' who experienced and understood this, has passed). Thanks, to you and your guests, for trying to illuminate the information space.
What average Americans don't hear or see is a sense of danger from europeans, or actions that reflect a sense of urgency after 2 years. I sense - given those things the perception could change. that was seen in WW! and WW2
@@icu17siberia Thanks for the comment.Like WW1&2 we believe the oceans will protect us.Today everything is global;goods,services,finance,culture,information, natural resources,climate change,etc.The younger generations and business community (even farmers) realize this, but our corporate media doesn't seem to be interested in educating ,just entertaining with drama,sensationalism, and celebrity news.( or breathless political controversy). So much so, that I've been forced to rely on European( English Language) news sources of all flavors.
@@icu17siberia--- Yes, but what can be done to make this 'real' to the average American? Right now it seems that only Americans with family/friends in the former Soviet Bloc understand the danger Russia poses.
GAFER BOB, your so right! Most of the younger (18 to 40) Americans have very little or no sense of what's at stake in Ukraine! It's gunna be really hard to vote for Trump for not helping Ukraine, but he's the only game in town!
This has been one of the best discussions of the current state of the Ukraine war so far IMHO. Michael Clarke covers a lot of ground in a very accessible way. Must watch this again...
The German battleship, Bismark, couldn't deal with 'low & slow,' Swordfish torpedo biplanes either... History resonates, for sure!
And one of them made the ship unmanoeuvrable and was doomed to perish.
Highlights Ukraine’s power grid disaster as well
Neither would any English battleship have been able to. The Hood was sunk by an honest artillery shell.
@user-sm3xq5ob5d I partly agree. We used the Swordfish torpedo biplane for that exact reason. The Hood was built during WW1 and launched in 1918. Despite her design flaws and already being out of date, including a real requirement for an essential upgrade in the early-mid thirties, she was a great battlecrusier from the WW1 period and flew the flag and represented our country well, overall. The Bismark was launched in 1939 with all the latest hardware, technology, and 21 years younger - a massive difference. She took a lot of hits and sustained significant damage, but unfortunately, she was hit in the magazine and blew up due to not getting that upgrade, which I mentioned earlier, which would of prevented that and given her move time to close with the enemy. Only three sailors survived. 🙏
@@PutinTerapevtEuropi 🤣🤣
Great interviewer and great interviewed Michael Clarke. It’s so important to hear his opinions. Great questions and commentary also. Thank you.
30 miniutes with Michael clarke's analysis nice!
Michael Clarke speaks with authority and knowledge. His clarity is sensational and I can listen to him for hours. The West needs to get the ammunition to the front immediately.
Raz Clark the DINOSAW
That was such a great interview, thank you.
Professor Michael Clarke is Fabulous💖 🦄 ❤💙💛❤Slava Ukraini❤💙💛❤🦄
Yes if you like to hear some fantasy story
@@rouz0 ...Yes the typical western expert who does know war only from his desk
Terrific show, brilliant guest, love this channel.
Kate, by far the VERY BEST Journalist and Interviewer in the WEST. She is what other persons in her Profession should aspire to. All the Best to you and Times Radio.
Your cheerleading and fawning all over Kate is quite frankly weird and creepy! 🤦🏼♂️
I see Kate as a Real Journalist who deserves a pat on the back given the Garbage Journos out there and the Wannabes. Posing as such. Your comments are VERY WEIRD AND CREEPY-----DO I DETECT SOME ANIMOSITY TOWARDS MEN??
Professor Clarke! Ice to see you again and to hear your perspective!
Really had enough of this Putin fella, looking forward to when Russia has a friendly leader
Profound words
@@lightsout176 I'm like that
Don't hold your breath. Anyone who deposes Putin will bring more of the same revanchist, nationalist and west hating bile to the table.
I feel the Russian mindset/indoctrination is not going to lead to any improvement soon.
@@mickkelly6389 If inflation keeps going up and interest rates, he might get the boot
Where are those one million shells right now? Still sitting in storage gathering dust?
Why can't we do a greater package..... After all Putin plus refer to the UK as the eternal enemy.......more please...
Great interview. Thanks.
Good interview. Concise follow ups. True emotions. We love Ukraine 🇺🇦
Everybody loves some thing you can choose to love the devil not my business
@@atesuapharaoh4164 The devil wears Red last I checked.
Japan knows a stronger Russia will mean a stronger China.
Great interview! Chapeau to Gerbeau!
I could listen to this fella all day .
and politicians should listen to him as well
Pass Ukraine aid now!!
Great talk. Highly informative report about situation and outlook of the war.
I am ashamed of the cowardice of the German government.
All of Europe focuses on quality of life of their own citizens and expect USA to pay for world defense. That's why Russia is so bold.
@@jaytate491 kzhead.info/sun/aJtthrSmbn6EiK8/bejne.html
You could shorten it by saying asha ed of the german government or just ashamed of the germans
@@bryandimery6509it is likely not the German people who are hesitating, it's policymakers.
@tyllerboomgaarden7344 the german people are responsible for the gems running that country.
Thank you.
Micheal Clarke rocking the stacker with graphic equaliser, Show off! Just kidding, great video as usual with Michael.
Looks like my old technics separates system with graphic equaliser, then again I'm old lol
kzhead.info/sun/aJtthrSmbn6EiK8/bejne.html get the real news russia is fumigating europe bit by bit
I had one of those things all stuck together I think 40 watts
@@themcgeachys I've still got mine, technics 100 watt per channel, wires at the back like spaghetti 😬
Kate is the best interviewer, hands down.
Thank you Japan for aiding in Ukraine’s defence of Western Europe
Learn some history
@@spudwesth What part of history do you want a lesson on?
Nothing cheers me up like a video highlighting Russian incompetences.
and burning oil refinaries
Nothing cheers me up like Russian incompetences.
Problem is, they've got millions of incompetents that willingly go and die for mere square meters of land.
Russians do learn fight better. They have done so already and they will improve. Its false narrative that they cant get done anything right. They still take some land and UKR soldiers die every day.
It is fiction!! I hate to disappoint you but santa isnt real either
Brilliant commentary - Michael for advi
Where are the patriot air defence systems for Ukraine?.
Russia destroyed them all
Used up.
I'm Russian and want to know why our air defenses cannot stop Ukraines home made RC planes.
@@IvanChelyabinsk Paradoxically I think it is because they are designed to take down much more sophisticated weapons.
@@IvanChelyabinsk russia is vast and it cannot protect everything? And also I'm not sure this resistance/determination by Ukraine was factored into the decision to invade, possibly, and therefore events happening now weren't expected?
Love Kate… always great questions
I am in the United States and a history major. Historically the odds of Trump winning are really, really against him. However Trump does have a tendency to buck the odds, although I think his luck has run out. I was in the army decades ago. We had a philosophy or maybe it was a saying, decades ago is a very long time ago. "Hope for the best and plan for the worst" It is probably best to hope that Trump doesn't win, but it is a pretty good idea to plan for if he does.
That's a universal term...we use that in the UK too. It's absolutely heartbreaking watching putin's genocide in Ukraine....and America, the so called "Leader of the Free World" doing nothing to help! We know why of course, but in this day and age, it's mind blowing how this is happening! It's making the US look extremely weak, disorganised, divided, and unreliable as a democratic ally! Putin, and the rest of the dictators around the world will be loving this! It's just what they've always wanted for America!
@@Mortthemoose Joe Biden is responsible for this fiasco. If he would only compromise with the GOP and secure our southern border the Ukraine aid package would be released.
@@Mortthemoose America is very good at letting its allies down. When it’s America’s hour of need, it shouldn’t count on those it let down.
if trump wins ukraine has lost, theres no way to prepare for it, if they can’t win without him then….
His chance’s of winning are slim? Are u kidding me. Check every single pole and you will see he is ahead. If he can keep his big mouth shut he will win. Atleast OUR border will be secure again. We shall see.
Some very good and interesting points of view. Europe should just move their air defense systems to Ukraine NOW if not they will only end up using them closer to home in the future.
Double Take Outro Kate! You do great work and cool that you include a blip on the stage. Cheers Kate! 👌👌💕
then why is ukraine losing 💀
Russia's winning is now an embarrassment to Putin, That's quite the Orwellian title if there was ever one😂
Michael 👏👏👏👏
1982 called , they want their stereo back
That ending LOL very professional Kate 😆
🇺🇦🇬🇧
Nice one, Kate!
Informative
Never underestimate the selfishness and incompetence of Joe Biden.
Good point. He's lucky he has Trump to make him look like he's a decisive genius.
As always, excellent interview, Kate.
shame on Trump, shame on Johnson, shame on GOP
Johnson? He has done more than any other Western leader to advance the cause of Ukraine when he was in power.
Very informative
The car is red!. Stay strong and resilient - Ukrainians will prevail!!
Such a fantastical mind, this chap has. He sure seems to enjoy telling his fantastical tales ... rather entertaining
Slava Ukraine ❤
What a great solicitation piece to get more money! Of course, he’s not paying for it. How NATO like.
Good interviewer
Shame shame shame to the Western allies! I really hope Japan steps in if nothing else it's in their best interest to blunt China's advance. I just can't believe they're letting Putin get away with this. Sad world we're living in atm. We never learned from history & past mistakes. 😢
Truth is, nothing was learned. Especially the American terrorist acts of recent decades spread throughout the world
It's ironic that most of the world outside Europe is aware of the situation in Ukraine, but doesn't understand the larger threat to Europe, or for Europes need for assistance in meeting the threat.
Agreed, the West on the whole has done a horrible job with messaging. It's like they're perceived as exaggerating when in reality they're drastically understating the danger.
Most of the world know who the real threat is, ie the west. what did you think we have Alzheimer or something? Oh we know, we always knew so don't expect friends out here, you're on your own, you been making yourself on your own for 400 years.
Michael Clarke should write a book on the disaster that was Brexit, and the ineffective politicians.
Brexit was the UK's lifeboat to a sinking European Titanic. It's costly and will cost us much over the next decade but be in no doubt, Europe is going to fail. You need to study long tern global economic forecasts and then answer the question what is your priority, your future or your children's future?
Mike Johnson, Republican Majority Leader, is losing the Ukraine.
Oh for goodness sake ! Use you OWN land to create a buffer zone !
That's exactly what we are doing, it's our land.
@@alexanderlazarev3570only because you are trying to steal it
Ukraine is our land 🇷🇺 - Putin
@@raftguy1376 putin says they have no borders, he wants Alaska back
According to putin, he has no borders, and he wants Alaska back
Putin should save his embarrassment & just stop - the whole world thinks he is a joke..
Not a funny joke!
You apparently live in a very small world.
@@davidowens4145 you live in a small poisoned (by putler) mind
My observation is that the whole world considers Putin a remarkable and effective leader.
@@larrysherk Then, you're a terrible observer.
There's no reason for Ukraine to settle for anything less than 100% of its Budapest Memorandum-recognized territory, 100% reparations for damage and cost of fighting, and a 200km DMZ inside Russia and Belarus. The only things to negotiate are 1) over what time period are the reparations due and 2) maybe the depth of the DMZ.
Thankyou Michael Clarke for your good work. Can the Ukrainians make their own cheap n nasty, FAB glide bombs? Ukraine has shown ingenuity and is likely to make a better one.
It’s not a embarassement’s it’s a complete failure’s and so they indulge in revenge attacks against civilians and civilian infrastucture…
Where are the F-16's?
The editor went to sleep on that ending.
more bloopers please
Michael Clarke is always informative and clear-eyed, which inspires no matter what the situation. BTW- does anyone else see the resemblance to Michael Caine? Think Miss Congeniality?
Russia will never allow a US military base in Crimea with nuclear weapons. This is the reason for the war 😣😏😣😥🤔
A Times Radio blooper reel might be fun.
not as much fun as a Ruzzian blooper reel. And not as big.
When you are down on your luck you find out who your friends are.
My goodness, if he is not merely fear mongering about Zelensky's position being at such risk, Ukraine might be better off surrendering right now.
Radars are often adjusted to filter out small slow "targets" so their systems aren't cluttered up with birds etc
For every hit of Russian equipment, Ukraine has to put up thousands of drones in the air. Drones are not a panacea, they have their limitations. Russia has excellent electronic warfare jamming capabilities that can knock drones out of the air.
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦❤💪👍
Slava Ukraine
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 just listen to the garbage being dispensed😂😂😂😂😂😂
Go, Russia!!!❤
The glide bombs look more like a copy of the ones delivered earlier to Ukraine by I think the USA than something new? I've seen graphics of bombs that were going to Ukraine quite a long time ago. This is the problem with every weapon. It only ever gives you a battlefield advantage for a limited time, until your enemy imitates it. And then everyone has them, so the ultimate effect is just to increase the number of casualties on future battlefields. You could call it the "post longbow effect" or something.
22:30 does he realize Austria's not even IN NATO?!
F-16s might not be so irrelevant considering they just trained AI to fly them.
I deeply respect Mr Clarke and value his analysis but I have to correct him on one point: Mathis Rust was intercepted by Migs. There is footage of it, the russians and Rust told so. They could have intercepted him, they simply decide not to shoot him down. The rest of his analysis about russias air defense still stands.
Slava ukraini
Kate is always the best
You can always rely on the Americans to do the right thing - after they have tried everything else.
How come we can intercept icbm’s but not fab500’s?
I love this program and try and catch every episode, I would, however, like to respectfully disagree about the Ukrainians needing world support for the morale to keep fight. I have had dozens of Ukrainian friends over the years and competed against Ukrainians at the highest level of sport, and I can tell you, they are not a people that are going to go down without a fight, especially for their country. That does not mean that we should not continue giving as much support as possible, because war malaise is real, if it’s not happening in your front yard. 😅
Mathias Rust flew into Red Square on the 28th of May 1987 not 1972.
The F16 are coming this summer. That will be a game changer.
The volume is way down in level - increase it by 20dB.
The one with The German Kid Landing in Moscow happened in the 80s
What a waste of lives - if Western countries had not followed appeasement policies, like they did in the 1930s, Russia should have been stopped by now.
to be specific...20th century European history repeats itself
26:30 Japan should push Russia for return of the territories Russia occupied in the closing days of WWII. Tell Putin to decide now. Then if Putin says no, boycott him and finance Ukrainian aid even if constitutionally it can't provide military assistance.
Did you compare sizes of Russia and Japan? Any sober assessments re: how much Japan can push? Educate yourself re: how long it took Soviet army to finish Japan's elite kwantung army in August 1945. I am tired from nonsense of poorly educated folks
@@irinajosefson182 I was implying, in order to prevent Japan from joining international sanctions and instead arming Ukraine. Sorry if that wasn't clear. It's not cool to just insult strangers if they're saying something you don't understand.