Which instrument is better? [DEBATE] Flute vs Violin
2024 ж. 17 Мам.
196 318 Рет қаралды
Want to stay motivated while you practice music while reducing performance anxiety? Download Tonic: downloadtonic.com/today and join the practice community for free!
So who do you think won between Jasmine Choi and Ray Chen? We may have to continue the battle in another video on @JasmineChoi's channel!
Thank you @RayChenViolinist for dropping in as our guest!
0:00 - Intro
0:34 - Round 1 "Price"
1:11 - Round 2 "Range"
Best way to improve and stay inspired in your music practice is to join a community: downloadtonic.com/today 🙌🏼
Neither instrument, the organ has both sound in one instrument, and many others as well.
0:11 0:11 😊😊
Thank you, I just got it
Team Flute! 🪈 ❤
Nooooooo violin is better
Fluteee 🪈
Team flute! 🪈 🎵 I tried the violin and I agree with Jasmine that the flute was easier to learn. I still have my poor violin tucked in a closet for years 🎻 😢
I agree with you that flute is easier to learn at least in the beginning. But some music you can only make on the violin, so for me I can't decide which instrument😊
I play flute that’s why I’m on this side
Don’t waste it, practice bro
As an oboist, I will lose to violin 100% no one writes for me ;v;…My range is only like 2 and a half octaves 😂 at most and it isn’t accessible either it was so hard to find the model I wanted XD (Oh and since I am the only oboist ofc I’m supporting my flute besties on this side)
That’s sad. Violin is ridiculously hard but I think it helps to develop a deeper love for the instrument. The flute is beautiful, and bach badinerie is like my fave song, but I love my violin and wish more people could experience playing it. ❤️
As someone who plays both instruments it's hard to pick one side! It's so cool that my favourite flautist and my favourite violinist are such good friends!
i bet they have the same video editor and they definitely have been in touch with each other for a while
I have also got both so won't pick a side either.
yay flute and violin team!!!!!
@@bobatealover14 yay english horn and vibraphone team!!!!!
As someone who cannot play any of them, it is still hard to pick one side :)
@Ray and @Jasmine, please make a video about Ray learning the flute in one hour or Ray teaching Jasmine because she has played before. Would be very interesting to see what both of you find challenging about the other instrument. 🤔
lols agreed idle
Who’s with me on violin gang? 🎻
I love both❤
I'm in the violin gang!! And also on Tonic! 🎉 🎻
I play violin and flute
So I’m both
Let's go violin gang!
I think if you look beyond the type of flute that Jasmine plays and go into drone flutes and bamboo flutes and the many other types of flutes I believe the recognizability and repertoire increase exponentially.
Flute gang for ever 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Im on violin gang!!!❤
Same 💪
Let's gooo!🎻🎻
Sup
Well I play viola but orchestra gang 🙃
I play oboe but im on small cello side 😈
What an amazing video thank you so much!!!😅
thanks so much, love both of you who make playing instruments with so much fun~ look forward to next episode about virtuosity~
Really cool episode! 😎😎 Thank you both, Jasmine & Ray! 🤩🤩 This was fun & informative too. 👍🏽👍🏽 Please stay healthy and take care. 🫂💕💯
What a great convo between two wonderful individuals!
What an amazing video! Thank you! I’d totally love to hear you duetting to showing the strengths of the two instruments (that kind of represent the (bowed) string instruments and the wind instruments) ❤
Regarding career opportunities, I definitely think it's more difficult for flutists. Even my flute teacher told me NOT to study flute and choose flute as a career and she ended up losing her job as a flute teacher because there were too little students. She studied in Paris and spend her whole life playing the flute, so it's really sad she struggled.
Really nice collaboration~ Thank you for this video, it’s so useful! And I’d love to hear Ray Chen playing “Chant de Linos”😅, I’m very interested how it will sound))
I play both! I lean towards violin though. So glad someone made a comparison video!
I will be waiting for the another video❤
So much fun watching this video of two very gifted, hard working and beautiful people.
I was a music major. And this was soooo fun to watch!!! Great episode!! Can we see more videos with different instruments?
I play both flute and violin in our community orchestra, and love them both!
Would love to hear Ray play Voliere or the last movement of Liebermann Concerto 😎
I like this idea of comparing instruments! I want to hear the comparison of Prokofiev D Major sonata and Franck Sonata by both instruments.
This one is tough! Ray motivated me to play violin again after 13 years (apparently with his Tonic app) but now I want to learn the flute because of Jasmine!😂
You two are a riot. :) I am a classically-trained reasonably competent amateur flutist (I never played a flaut in my life, thankyouverymuch). My grandfather, my uncle, my cousin and my sister all played violin, and I took it up in the 4th grade (for about 5 minutes). I wasn't interested in continuing. I had always wanted to try flute because I liked that it came in a small case. My sister's violin teacher actually sent a flute home with me once; I might have been 7 or 8 years old. I figured out how to put it together, blew on it like it was a bottle, and discovered that the only keys I could use to change the note were the trill keys. Fast forward to when I was 12. My grandmother offered to pay for lessons and of course I picked the flute. High school and college concert bands followed. In college I decided I was not going to pursue a professional career. So I just play here and there for fun.
Beatbox flute and violin is sendingggggg me Also Jasmine looks so beautiful here as per usual!! 언니 오늘도 너무 아름다우시네요~~❤
❤❤❤
Fun video. I play both and can't decide which instrument I like better😊
Casually dropping a video for the first time in over a year and I’m here for it 🎻
How about Jasmine and Ray doing side-by-side comparisons of something flashy from The Four Seasons (Moe Koffman did a wicked jazz flute recording of the sonatas back in the 80s), then side-by-sides of Debussy's Syrinx, originally written for solo flute.
I love this!!! Great content and video-we play both!!! Educational and entertaining!!
And I love the section about group playing and lessons-we offer that to our students too and find it so valiant!
(I meant to say valuable, not valiant! 😊 but maybe that too)
First time I hear from Jasmine Choi. She sounds like such a great person!
Trust me, beginner flutes sound waayyy worse than Jasmine made it sound lol.
Lol I know right especially with the higher notes
Both instruments sound great and beautifully complement each other!🎻🪈❤
I am learning both....I like both....Each are uniquely beautiful
I would love to hear Ray play great train race on violin
Waiting for the challenge 👍👍👍
lololol some of the graphics are so funny! thanks for the video
Really great meeting you all. Such a lovely experience sharing. But I think one the tone color or quality of sound flute would be more recognizable than violin. Violin most the time sound like many other instruments when played as a single instrument, yh. My opinion tho
Flute technique is easy to begin with but really, really hard to master. If you want perfect tone you need to practice hundreds of hours. The low notes are easier, but the highest notes are impossible, and to maintain perfect tone fluidly throughout the registers is like learning to play the instrument while walking blindfolded on a tightrope. You see even this highly trained womam doesn't sound good at D4. But it can actually sound beautiful and sweet. And there's also breath-control, which overlaps with tone as you play.
I really enjoyed this viedo. Played both instruments.
Waiting here🎉🎻❤
Violin can sound like a flute with harmonics.
Yep. Also, a flute can't play more than two notes at once. A violin can do double, triple and quadruple stops
@@whocares_bearflute and other instruments can it’s just the notes are super flat so it’s not common.
@@whocares_bear multiphonics are a thing? Lol
@@whocares_bearflute can play more than two notes at once
@@zgart Yeah, and they sound like 💩 when they do that. Can't compare that to the triple stop at the beginning of Eine Kleine Nachtmusik
I just love both it's really good to hear both violin and flute so I in both ❤
would love to hear Ray try a flute piece on the violin! maybe Dance of the Blessed Spirits by Gluck?
*_I would like to see a video devoted to playing one instrument in the style of a different instrument._* That was done a couple of times in this video, and it was wonderful. I can play, for example, a handpan, or a kinnor, or a shakuhachi, or a 5-strng banjo. Then when I get back to my concert flute, I have a plethora of fresh ideas. I find that the best way to develop flute expression is to listen to tenor saxophonists. I do not have the experience to say what it would take to make a classical violinist into a really good fiddler.
이렇게 훌륭하신 연주자분들을 만나뵐수 있어 영광입니다~^^😍
Violins get more colour changes and can reasonably play 2 notes at once which is nice. Easy to start, portable, affordable though are really big categories.
Violinist and flutis arguing about portability Cellists meanwhile: 😭
When I was in highschool a decade ago we had exactly 0 violins. Flutes however, we had two full rows of them, probably 20-26 flutists. Still to this day I don't think I've even seen a violin in person and I enjoy visiting music shops
Wow Tonic finally uploaded
I started playing violin and flute because my music preferences progressed so much that I could only enjoy jazz & bossa nova and more progressive music, which I couldn't play like I wanted to on the Piano. So I was so glad to play violin and flute where we only have to play one note at a time xD and let others do the hard work xD. Learning the proper techniques was actually fun & challenging a bit. But I felt that was more motorics rather than difficulty in a knowledge sense. Piano is definitely more difficult (for me).
This is always an interesting debate :D
flute 🩷🪷 & Jasmine 💅🏻 I wanna hear Ray trying to play The Great Train Race by Ian Clarke (the piece she was playing while demonstrating multiphonics as a chord alternative)
I just downloaded the app, thanks for putting this out :)
This video was pretty funny to me since I play the flute and my sibling plays violin!😁
I play the flute coz I find strings instrument difficult but I prefer to listen to violin music. Which team should I be on? 😅
Strings instruments r tricky but u play Flute. Real tricky question you got. Whichever instrument is ur favorite u choose do pros and cons of the flute and violin that's how I decide
I'm learning Flute. Though, I do have my sister's old Violin. ❤
Help i play both and LOVE THEM EQUALLY
Fun contest between two superb musicians
for the flute gang: Jethro Tull a rock blues/jazz fusion band
I LOVE YOU BOTH~!
Compare also: Ergonomics: Flute wins. Violinists shove the thing into their necks, often scarring their chins and necks. On a violin, most of the skill and hard work is on the left (poorer) hand,. Violinists strain their left wrists and finger joints, and can cut their skin with the nasty e-string. The violin is the second most uncomfortable instrument. Violas are of course the very worst. Discomfort of listeners hearing a typical player: Flute wins. A flautist who plays for an hour per day can be in a respectable orchestra after a year. A typical violinist after 3 years of 2 hours per day still causes real pain to the listener Adaptability to instruments in the same family: A flautist can pick up a piccolo and start playing. A violinist is a total beginner on a 'cello. Flute wins. Natural connection to the body: Flautists use breath rather like a singer. That makes way for a much more natural ability to express phrasing and feelings. Again flute wins. So, 4 more points for the flute. Having said that, there is no doubt that the violin is the most musical of all instruments.
I experience more pain playing the flute than the violin to be honest... But maybe that's just my body.
Let's do the battle!!!
💜💜💜
The legend has arrived
I play both flute(since 11 years old) and violin (9 years old) love this video!
This was fun 😄
What about bansuri on the app? Is it exclusive to western classical flutes?
Like. The sound of flute 🪈 is more beautiful like a fairy tale here. I'd love too ❤. Greetings from Paris 🎉
LOL I‘m playing both 😊 love them!
Im really impressed on the beat box flute tho ❤
In my opinion these two are the most versatile musical instruments ever which can be used for awesome melody, and as heartmelting tune and as terrific theme music and as horror music
I'm neither. I have got both. When I was at my first lesson on the flute my teacher asked me how many years have you played it and I replied "what do you mean? I only got given it last week." She asked me how did you get a sound out of it? I replied if you can get a sound out of a narrow neck bottle you can get a sound out of a flute. I would experiment with bottles and pitches by putting water in the bottles.
Sweet
Daaamn shi soo beautiful..... 😍😍
Jajaja para esto es que pago internet! Quiero agregar que este tipo de videos aunque son muy divertidos, lo cierto es que cada instrumento tiene su luz propia, su belleza, su singularidad, empezando por las diferencias sonoras. Sin embargo gracias por este tipo de contenido🎉 es muy divertido.
13:55 isn't that made with alternate fingering? Afai you can't consistently blow air between two harmonics with normal fingering.
Como clarinetista, devo dizer que o melhor instrumento é o piano
Storytime: in the 3rd grade, my best friend and I were both signed up to play an instrument by our families. I got stuck playing the flute and she got stuck with the violin. I hated playing the flute and she hated playing the violin. Fast forward to 7th grade, we had both dropped playing our respective instruments at this point. I brought up how I always wanted to play violin and she laughed and said "I wanted to play the flute!" Somehow the communication between my grandma who raised me and her mom got fumbled because we ended up playing each other's instruments!
LOL
I love both.
These are the two best instruments.
i’m a fluteist and now i’m learning violin!!
Amazing flute sure instantly change the atmosfer😮😮
I loveeeeer violin. Hoping one day I will learn to play it😌🤞💗🫀
Oh yay, both my favourite instruments.
Jasmine is amazing on the flute; as to which instrument is better it is totally subjective , it depends whose hands they’re in. Ray made the violin sound amazing too!
Both
wn ray chen said : Only u win this one 😆 😆
Both are equally beautiful.
Topic: Portability Me being a pianist: 😑😓
Hey there btw in versatility the Chinese version of flute is dizi
At 10:17 what melody she was playing. If anyone know please reply.
It’s called “Arirang” Korean traditional song
Im a flutist and a violinist and its really hard to debate which one is better because i love both my instruments.
I just wish that the orchestral world would remember there is a whole world of bands, marching bands, and military bands that have no violins whatsoever.
I would like to see you both try each other's instrument. Like, the flutist tries playing a violin and the violonist tries playing the flute... (Also, sorry if I don't know your names... I just found this channel. This is the first video from this channel, that I've watched so far.)
do the Prokofiev flute/violin sonata
Play violin I am young ( not even a teen). Violin best!!! And I would love the second part
As a professional musician who has played every instrument and taught every instrument, I can easily say violin is the better of two by a long shot, especially when it comes to emotion. There is only so much a person can do on a wind instrument. The instrument is limited by its ergonomics and construction. The violin however has more opportunities to sculpt the sound with texture and glissandos and more very similar to the human voice.
I love Jasmine and I'm a flute/wind player myself, but she really swindled you here Ray. She passed off things that are only used in practice exercises (harmonics) or things that only 1% of players can actually do (circular breathing, multiphonics, super high notes) to counter you presenting aspects of the violin that are standard. Flute sounds beautiful, but violin has better range, dynamics and sustain and an awesome endless repertoire that was written by people who actually played the instrument at a high level. Violin wins.
How long does it take to learn violin?
Ray is right about cats scratching. As a boy, I had a
Being a flute player for well over 40 years, I have to say flute is best. But a well played violin sounds amazing too.