[4.5] WHO IS THIS KID!? (Debunked but still fun!) - Genshin Impact Lore & Theory
2024 ж. 13 Сәу.
112 853 Рет қаралды
...We may or may not have misinterpreted some lines about Arlecchino...
This is a lot of crack. If it ACTUALLY turns out to be true I'm going to end up questioning everything I know about this game LMAO
[update] - so there was a short animation released like 2 days after I made this that disproved about half of this. RIP short fun theory. You will be missed.
*TIMESTAMPS*
Dude it's 7 minutes.
*CITATIONS & LINKS*
Citations & Attributions - pastebin.com/3Fjg67e2
Creirwy(Keleiwei) Texture Name by Raynie - / 1779067606089048393
/ 1779082749644587310
Black Swan Theory by LaughingMan - • Arlecchino: The Black ...
Arlecchino Speculative Analysis by Ashikai - • [4.5] Arlecchino and t...
Blood and Wine by Ashikai - • [4.5] Eat Gods, Get Go...
**NOTES & CORRECTIONS** Updated notes about the theory in this community post: kzhead.infoUgkxVBJzhWwBTurTRWvgci1wPUErhLchu6S3 - The information about Marcotte's texture name was discovered by Raynie (twitter)! I made this video very quickly and did not track down the original source of the information when I definitely should have. That's on me. Please go check out their twitter threads on this subject and tons of other hidden lore observations!! twitter.com/Rayniegirl_/status/1779067606089048393 twitter.com/Rayniegirl_/status/1779082749644587310
Ash, just saw the animated preview of Arle and I think you were right about the little girl being related to her
The knave could be a demon
Will you make a video on the recent short (that answered who the girl was)?
There has been something in the back of my mind nagging at me for a while. It keeps getting sparked by a lot of people wanting Singora to be resurrected, which I highly doubt will happen. I don't think Venti meant the Tsaritsa when he asked if she "Stole her master's face". What if she was a previous Hexenzirkel members pupil? One who we know to be dead. That if she can change her face, is Dotorre involved with that? I haven't seen this discussed anywhere, and I would love to hear your thoughts on this theory
Maybe the girl could be Clervie?
0:06 "I think I might know who this girl is" My dumba** fried brain on 2hr of sleep: *"It's Yanfei"*
HELP
No Yanfei is the main vampire.
I thought it was Elysia
@@anarchistofwar1971 IM SO GLAD I WASN'T THE ONLY ONE
stop I said that too
Plot Twist, Turns out Arlecchino was just mad that Freminet ate the last of the food at the recent BBQ Dinner.
Double plot twist, Marcotte orginised that BBQ dinner as trap for this while Arlecchino knows it and she is just pranking.
Poor freminet
That's definitely what happened
I don't think that when arlecchino said BBQ she meant the actual BBQ, I think they are eating people
Freminet just forgot to take the chicken out of the freezer for the BBQ dinner 😂
YALL SHE'S COOKING AGAIN
God bless!!!
NO SHE BURNT IT AND LEFT IT ON THE STOVE TO ROT (her theory was debunked before the patch even dropped)
@@trashvalley Its was still really interessing !
Poor Ashikai could not imagine they would debunk her theory before the patch even hit.
Reading html for lore,ah how i've missed you five nights at genshin
FR AUGH
For normal people its annoying. But for me this is THE stuff that keeps me hooked to the game.
welcome back arlecchino fazbear
I'm calling it that the whole Arlecchino attacking the siblings is just a jebait and she's actually testing their integrity to see if they would stand up to her if she went down the wrong path.
Real
Exactly my thought, we clearly see that shes not going all out
Exactly, even in the 4.6 livestream they practically spoiled that they’re just "training" / "sparing" (but with some twists and more than average aggressiveness in it) when they said that phase 1 is just "like any other ordinary training session" implying that even if the whole thing has more to it it at least started as just training.
Yeah, there is zero chance that there is any conflict between Arlecchino and the kids that doesn't get resolved in some convenient and tidy manner. Certainly there will be no lasting damage or change in the status quo.
Oh exactly @@ATMEIDAREYAIDOUBLEDAREYA
so that the reason why arle helped navia to secretly search creirwy on poisson, this would prove what childe voiceline for arle
I cant beleive this video got outdated in 2 days
Back here after the animated trailer teaser, I'm screaming/going crazy seems like this theory is right
She can't keep getting away with it. Ashikai cooks too hard 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥
Hyv just dropped a trailer for a coming animated short for Arle not too long ago and holy moly the lore drop is insane cant wait to see the full version and hear of what you think of it
It was si unexpected because you know genshin could never
as soon I saw the teaser I remembered Ashikai theory😅
When you were talking about vampires I seriously was thinking "please don't say they sparkle"
We all are .
creepy immortal master vampire kid sounds like a wild character design i'm in
She isn't even going all out against her children or us only releasing enough strength that her children can fight back. Unlike Signora who one shot Kojou Sara what's going on in her mind.
U get it, for me it seems like shes protecting them. She will do something that her children will deem to be "evil" but she doesnt mind because she will do it with their best interrest in mind even if it might lead them to hate her
Hey miss Ashikai, just a quick fun fact: In the official Brazilian Portuguese translation of Genshin Impact, Arleccino's is often refered as "A Serva" which translates to, yep, you guessed it: "The Servant". You can even see it in 4.6's website preview if you change its language to PT-BR. I'm very excited to know more about her lore when the patch drops.
I think it’s only in English that her title can be interpreted differently, in Russian her title is clearly says Слуга - Servant
Arlecchino in commedia dell'arte is often portrayed as a servant, hence Arlecchino's subtitle is "the Servant (仆人)". The title "the Knave" is an archaic way to say servant, which is far removed from its modern English definition.
That's true for most languages. English tends to always add a little flair with its translations.
Ashikai needs to make another vid now that the Knave's trailer dropped
Fast forward to today and her name is Clervie and she was Arlecchino's friend in the old HotH. And is the daughter of the prior Harbinger that Arlecchino replaced 3:29 that's......that is exactly what happened though.
I know this theory was born out of somewhat limited information, but I'm curious to see Ashikai's take on the whole thing now that Genshin have released their new animated video as it answers at least a couple of the questions posed here 😊
This is fascinating after watching the "Song Burning in the Embers" short. Even knowing who Clervie is, we still don't know what's up with Freminet's little friend lol
ASHIKAI WAKE UP NEW ANIMATION OF ARLECCHINO JUST DROPPED
After the animated short, I'm starting to think your vampire theory is the right one. "Mother" Update: It's soo OVER for this theory. haha NVM but close enough.
Is that a resident evil reference??
God, I hope this is true! I love love LOVE vampire mythology and the whole "Arlecchino is super vampire-coded" theory is one of my favorites. I would LOVE for this to be true. I also love the whole "vampiric parasite" theory floated in the 4.6 analysis vid... Ugh, there's so many exciting possibilities! Amazing video as always, Ashikai!
"super vampire-coded?" Jesus just say implied
@@jamesvaugh4718 I was quoting Ashikai in the livestream. They were saying Arlecchino is vampire-coded, and saying something is "x-coded" is a pretty common term these days.
@@betterretromess no its not
THEY JUST DROPPED A TEASER FOR A SHORT WITH THE GIRL AND THE AUDIO SAYS "MOTHER" U HAVE BEEN COOOOOKING
Alrechinno in the teaser to her teaser: "Mother"
I’m surprised you didn’t mention that Fontaine’s Local Flower IS LITERALLY A MARCOTTE. A PINK FLOWER WITH A PEARL LIKE-LUSTER!!!
I genuinely question how you guys are so smart. I'm betting 5 dollars this theory is somewhat, if not completely true.
Listen half of our theory always go wrong don't worry
If you throw a dart blind folded at a target enough times with enough hints you eventually hit get a couple hits. @@abhaythakur133
Which means half is right
Or like the real life myth of Creirwy, shes just Arlecchino daughter. Which in return will make Arlecchino Crucabena (Ceridwen) goddess of the moon, witchcraft, death and préservation
Alot of its just paying attention and having lots of background knowledge, searching up terms and such. Don't just take the story as its given to you.
LMAO U COOKED HARD
Wait, this might actually be true... Genshin just dropped a trailer for an Arleccino animated short and it seems she is a child with a character that looks like Marcotte.
Well we know who that girl is now
Is it just me or is this same little girl at the end of the animated short trailer for arleccino that hoyo just dropped?
it is
this little pink-haired girl looks SO much like ELF Elysia from HI3rd i’m going CRAZYY
to me she looks more like senadina
Looks like Firefly but with her colour pallet
She looks interesting but I don't it cause it very likely she'll be an NPC and I doubt they'd use such an important character as reference in this case
@@kri1ndawn440inb4 new kid char
She looks more like yae rin
fascinating
:O (ikr though)
This is mega cooking. Maybe the answer has been in front of us the entire time with the Marcotte flowers we've been collecting around Fontaine... That look like branches...
YOU GUYS, HOYOVERSE JUST DROPPED THE ANIMATED TRAILER VIDEO. IM STARTING TO THINK THAT ASHIKAI WAS COOKING WITH THIS ONE 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
ashikai is simply an insider
5:17 praise people who write and plan out lore for this game. This book came out in like 4.1-4.0......i would've never remembered it if it wasnt for Ashikai xD
So uh....anybody else here after the new video dropped?
And then the new Genshin video posted today, debunks this theory
I hope the animation coming out proves some theories haha
Genshin dropped a new video, and it's actually arlecchino's childhood friend! (For ppl who still haven't watched the video from genshin and are watching this instead)
Wait a fucking minute. Does Ashikai have insider info.
MAYBE????
Seems like you cooked well with this one based on the latest teaser vid Genshin just released
0:36 the funny thing is that my intrusive thought after seeing that just went “Is she a “Daddy” long legs?”😂😂😂😂
I was just watching another of your videos about the timeline of Sumeru. I'm glad I found your channel as it has reignited my love and intrigue for the lore of genshin, thanks!
THRY JUST RELEASED A TEASER FOR THE SHORT AND YOU WERE RIGHT AGAIN?!?!?!
@Ashikai LOOK WHAT THE GENSHIN IMPACT CHANNEL JUST DROPPED!!! ANIMATED SHORT COMING SOON AND WHO DID I JUST SPY THERE?!
The song from this trailer touched something in my soul, can’t stop watching it
Yesterday i watched this video first thing in the morning and my brain was flung i to the outer space with the sheer power of this theory. TODAY THEY'RE DROPPING THE PREVIEW AND THIS PREVIEW SEEMS TO BE HINTING AT THE SAME DIRECTION WHAT. Oh i can't wait to learn more about her ahhhh
HOLY CRAB!!! THE NEW ANNOUNCEMENT FOR THE SHORT ANIME LITERALLY SUPPORT THIS IDEA!!! ASHIKAI COOKED!!!
I think the Arlecchino animated short teaser just confirmed this, wow!
Im way too shocked at how lucky i am to be the first person here! Also, what!? A theory this close to a new patch, you're spoiling us Ashikai!!
Based on time stamps, I'm wrong. I wasn't first, sadge...
So, definitely not crab legs. Spider legs. Given all the threads she stands on, that was a given really. We now have some new information, like a spider funeral and a childhood friend.
I hadn't counted the legs but there are only six meaning is posible that is crab instead of spider
Woah interesting
Crabs have 10 legs..6 is for an insect
@@paulpreston15692 human hands 2 human legs 6 red ones = 10
i don't like the "leg counting" justification for spider/insect/crab because genshin impact has a TERRIBLE track record of accurate leg numbers for arachnids/arthropods anyway. even the real spiders in game only have 6 legs, so do the scorpions in the desert, and i think the crabs are missing 1 pair of legs too. i don't think only have 6 legs/wings crosses out the spider imagery at all lol
@@paulpreston1569 Crabs have only 6 walking legs chef here, they then have two "swim legs" and two "Chela" or Claws.
ASHIKAI WAS RIGHT PogChamp
I know this has nothing to do with Arlecchino but I'm just so surprised no one has talked about this before; Barbatos’ statue in Mondstadt city (in front of the church) has distorted voices near it. Adjust your audio settings with dialogue and music to 0, and you can hear it pretty clearly; although I believe it’s in Mandarin, so I’m not sure what they’re saying. I don't know if this is lore important or not, but I still think people should know...
Another voice that is not the Rukkhadevata's whisper?! How much more there is?
I just did what you said and all I heard was ambient city noises (crowd murmurs and dishes clanking), birds chirping and flapping during the day, and horses neighing at night.
@@Nephriteswordexactly
@@Nephritesword Idk I heard some people murmuring under the statue but I have dialogue turned off completely.
For some reason it only plays during the day (in game). I feel like I’m going crazy but my sister and friend hear it on their accounts too. Right near his feet is the loudest it seems
The harbringers are ranked When nahida said that the top 3 is akin to gods that doesn't mean the 4th or 5th isn't close to that status, maybe not god tier level but like a rank of a lord....a vampire lord
I’m back here after watching the animated short and omg the timing is perfect
If she is a black swan since she was the servant, you can also see a black swans swimming near the shores of Fontaine Institute.
U cooked lol
many people have pointed out the arlecchino swan motifs, but i've always assumed it was more of a stork... since here in poland, storks are said to be where babies come from: they bring them to their parents, carrying a swaddle in their beaks. since, you know, kids and orphanage! and also kind of a rebirth motif, since storks return to europe in spring. but it might be a little far-fetched
Damn calling me out, here I was thinking Arlecchino's Boss wings resembled Crystal Flies...
Ashikai has a talent for convincing me of her theories almost immediately
Watch this just be some random npc that appears in Arlecchino's story quest for a decent portion that we'll never even hear of again and will completely steal the focus away from the arlecchino herself Jk jk they could very well be important it's just crazy how quickly this was brought attention to and that's how almost every story quest has been in the past lol Edit: I didn't get to share this on the special program analysis stream but it's interesting you see arlecchino as very vampire related and not spider, ok of a leak that hard confirms her relation that I will share I'll just double down and say your pov is very interesting
nah I doubt that since dehya story quest they been doing pretty good job in SQ in terms on not focusing too much of npc even the "bad" ones are still pretty decent and more focused on the playable character
If the little girl is the real “master” I wonder if Arlecchino, as the Knave, is fulfilling her betrayal trope by trying to be free of her. And if we’d then get a nod to Colombina as her coconspiator as we’re getting Remuria and Colombina is still linked with singing.
Oooh, nice theory. Funnily enough, what is shown in the special program at least SOMEWHAT supports it. After introducing Arlecchino's story quest, when they talk about the Focus-Experience mode. You can see the SQ name: "When The Hearths-Flame Go Out," and the second title for the quest is "The Child Who Doesn't Exist." I doubt the quest heading and sub-heading would be a red-herring they intentionally created just for the Special Program. Edit: Fixed terminology and Arlecchino's SQ title because my memory is dogshit
this is why i love this game
I'm so excited and PRAYING you do a video about all thr vampire ties also you talking about spawn and vampires made me think of Astarion from Baldur's Gate 3
It’s weird how for how crack this theory is, the one thing she got right was how the child Clervie exhibits a classic vampire behavior of not being able to go into the sunlight.
I’m surprised there wasn’t a Lore-Gasp at Arlecchino’s weapon: Crimson Moon’s Semblance. Sounds very Khaenri’ah.
Exactly and Perinheri
Long story short Arlecchino might be a vampire and Freminet is gonna be trying his best not to get murdered by his own Father also if she's a vampire well Arlecchino vs Alucard from hellsing ultimate anyone
In the words of a certain radio demon: "Ha! No."
Ashikai casually jumpscare us with short arlecchino theory.
Post animated teaser now I wonder if the little girl is the memory of Clervie left in the ley lines and Freminet finds her before Arlecchino who's looking for her...
love to see you playing with the format, feel free to make short or longer videos, hopefully everyone will just be glad to watch your content and the algorithm is kind to your channel
Ashikai the animation THE ANIMATIONNN
A curiosity about Arlecchino being a servant: in the Brazilian Portuguese translation she is literally called "The Servant" (A Serva)
Since Rosaria came out I was waiting and waiting when Genshin decides to touch vampire theme and you know what, Fontaine (France/Britain themed region) is the best for it. Can’t wait to find out what’s really going on with The Knave. Ashikai, you’re a head chef at this point! Thank you
I don't think the title of Knave meaning "servant" should hold as much weight as is being attributed to it. After all, that's the *definition* of the role of the Harlequin in the commedia dell'arte (which all the Harbingers get their title from). So unless we're going to start making the argument that Dottore is the head of the household, Tartaglia is a stuttering statesman, and Pierrot is a sad clown (I am not joking, these are their roles in the commedia), I don't think we should be putting all our eggs in this basket just yet
Yeah. As much as these theories are fun, mhy tends to take the easy way out. Details feel too random at times to really make these details relevant.
Wouldn’t Freminet then be a better replacement for Arlecchino instead of Lyney? Simply because he worked for Marcott despite what Arlecchino wanted? Just spitting out some thoughts but Lyney seemed pretty adamant about not going against arlecchino no matter what (which he will definitely start pulling back from during this quest for the sake of his siblings) I personally, if I was Marcott, would rather Freminet replace the current Knave as MY servant than Lyney. Simply because he was very loyal to me as a person despite all odds against him.
My dumbass was thinking "is that Mary Ann Guillotine?!" but then I remembered that we already finished that side-character story arc with the Narzissenkruz world quest... 😅
tbf the percentage of characters that are mary ann in some shape or form are higher than average 😂
Mary Ann is very likely to be sandrone, as in, Sandrone is a puppet made in her image, by Alain
cooked baked and friee
6:35 Huh. Maybe that's why the head of the house is always referred to as *Father". Interesting.
I took it they mean Father in the patriarchal sense, considering the orphanage is based off a Russian one the person managing the kids would be female and called matushka or in English something like mother. I thought referring to her as father as playing on her nurturing them in a masculine way rather than a motherly empathetic way. The Father thing also might fit with the possibly vampire lore too, it'll be interesting to see how it plays out, would be cool if they could merge the two though.
Arlecchino Black Butler era
So Arlecchino is sharing a "bond of life" with Marcotte... 👀
You are my fav loretuber
So basically Marcotte is Elysia or an ALT of her. The King is a "sa or finality point etc" and They create "herscher" "vampires" and the blood is primordial liquid which makes up all things in the world of Tyvat that wasn't there to begin with. It would also explain the similarities of the "Domes" of Eternity (Raiden) IX (Archon) and with her. Also the "Crab" is consistent with the Sea of Quanta creating Sea like creatures. The Harbingers are messengers of things coming from Outside this world.
ASHIKAI HOW DO YOU FEEL ABOUT THE ARLECCHINO ANIMATED SHORT TEASER 😭 (right at the very end there's a scene with what I think is young arlecchino and princess Marcotte what the heck)
My thoughts on this video: 1) 0:47 This seems like a very strong interpretation. Even though Arlecchino is a Pyro user, she is still from a region heavy with aquatic motifs. 2) 3:35 The way I see it, Arlecchino may have obtained the power to depose the pervious Knave by convinced Marcotte to side with her. 3) 4:15 I find this particular part to be a bit questionable. First of all, all harbingers are only appointed as such by the Tsarista. Second of all, what does Arlecchino's appointment ceremony (in what is clearly Snezhnaya) have to with whether or not she personally killed the pervious Knave? Why would these two things chronological be the same event? 4) 6:58 Let me guess, some of your other theories have to do with the One Winged Angel/Grim Reaper/Masque of the Red Death elements of Arlecchino's design? I know they have certainly grabbed my attention, that's for sure.
You still have time for one more theory
You actually upload videos, yay🎉🎉🎉🎉
Aaaaannndddd Theory debunked. bruh. The name of the girl is almost close though.
Marcotte kinda sounds like Nahida being a branch of Irminsul
@Ashikai I was curious how her name relates to the flower found all over Fontaine " A pink flower with a pearl-like luster and rich scent profile. It is one of the major perfume ingredients. Marcotte is said to represent purity and sincere care. In Fontaine, the first thing a perfumer learns is to extract fragrant substances from Marcotte. On top of that, the plant's honey can be used for making jam and mulled wine, making it an indispensable part of everyday life in Fontaine. " I wonder if she has ties to Emilie who is a mysterious perfumer who is never wrong and also there is your wine reference for yuh
You put a bug in my head. Sun Yu, the Guhua Disciple from Liyue takes a box of his homeland soil to Fontaine. Like a freaking vampire. I just noticed because the daily commission came up. The Guhua clan is fishy in itself (was it not mentioned in your vids that the head took shortcuts in cultivation?).
Mind totally blown! Amazing theory!
crab? shes obviously a spider? considering shes literally walking on threads in air? It also plays into the reference of Other Mother from Coraline being a spider and kind of taking in "orphaned" children
aged like milk
3:35 we now know that's exactly what happened...
Did not expect vampire lore but I'm here for it! I'm skeptical of Marcotte being one though, I feel like she's more a stand in for Alice given all the Alice-in-Wonderland references in Fontaine... perhaps the siblings (the Cheshire Cat/the Mad Hatter/not sure about Freminet's role) are hiding "Alice" from the Red Queen/Knave of Hearts (Arlecchino)?
I was expecting something longer but this still works
Holy frick!! This is such an interesting theory! 👁👁 Now I'm looking forward to see how Arle's story quest plays out
Should the animated short uploaded recently be canon, this theory seems to be false. She seems to have fought the previous Knave herself. It is mentioned she truly does have a curse. Therefore, her being a hilichurl may still be a good possibility. She also seems to have a lot to do with spiders.
She looks like a elysia elf or senadina from hi3