XL bullies: Time for a cull? Feat. Peter Bleksley & Marina Purkiss | Jeremy Vine
2024 ж. 4 Ақп.
4 141 Рет қаралды
Following the death of a grandmother in a reported XL bully attack Jeremy is joined by Peter Bleksley and Marina Purkiss to discuss if the ban goes far enough and if it's time for a cull.
Jeremy Vine on 5 is on television every weekday at 9:15am until 1:30pm on Channel 5.
Subscribe to the channel for more celebrity interviews, hot topics and debates: bit.ly/34DvAv4
Twitter: / jeremyvineon5
Facebook: / jeremyvineon5
Instagram: / jeremyvineon5
#JeremyVine #xlbully #ban
Ive reported it twice a lad walks his dog running wild not on lead police have done nothing
Stop grassing people up ya busy body
It’s about breeding aggression into dogs, poor ownership and basic expectations for having controlled dogs, I’ve had 2 instances now with the same xl bully. Owner had no control, came from one side of the field to the other and me and my dog couldn’t get away from it. Police do nothing. They cba that’s a huge problem too, they wait till it’s too late and someone does get injured
Police can't even catch rapists nevermind unruly dogs
It’s the same old IRRELEVANT 💩💩over and over from these pit bull defenders, “are we going to ban cats because they scratch?” , he says 😆🤦♀️then “I’ve been bitten by Yorkshire Terriers” the woman says 🤡🤦♀️, what EFFING nonsense!!
I wish Angela would answer this question, If YOUR little Shitzu was mauled and killed in front of you, would your opinion be the same ? Because I’m in groups on Facebook for people who have had that happen to them and these peoples lives will never be the same again, they have PTSD, depression, flashbacks, nightmares, and probably will have for the rest of their lives, our dogs are just like babies to us, it’s like lost a child, I wonder if she knows that (around) 300 dogs were injured or killed by them last year 🤔💔, I’ve seen many of them on social media, people have paid thousands in vets bills (still having it to pay when they die the next day because the injuries were too severe) , I’ve seen people who have paid as much as £12,000 , and worse still, the owners always flee the scene to escape prosecution (and vets bills), Angela love, you have no idea the destruction/devastation these dogs have caused for people who have lost their loved ones (people and pets) people need to think about the REAL victims in all of this, people who have had their lives ruined just because people CHOSE to own a dangerous animal, and , I AM one of the biggest animal lovers anyone could meet, not just dogs but ALL animals
Those dogs are not safe
Shitzu’s are not killing people and it does not matter if they are loved, trained, they CAN still attack and they HAVE ATTACK MANY TIMES, I’ve seen it time and time again where they have been loving pets for years and years and have been fine until the day when they turned for no reason and WITHOUT any warning, they have pit bull in them, and it’s not so much their bite force it is their desire to to attack, fight, kill .
16:46 She said Cane Corso. Search for videos of them, they're terrifying! 😱🐶
Seen them, they killed a baby a couple of years ago
Cane corso's are actually lovely dogs
Bite force of a lion 😂
😂😂
no, the bite force of a hyena.
Why would you want to have dogs that fight even each other that badly and have to deal with what Marina had to in the park, why not have two labradors or golden retrievers?
You do realise that you can get bad labs and retreivers, right? You should see the way my neighbour's Labrador goes on. Lots of complaints about it but because it's a Labrador nothing gets done
@@Keeks_x their jaws don't lock though like the bull breeds which means when they fight they can't be separated, which is why Marina had such trouble in the park, and when they bite a child they can kill it cos they don't let go. A Labrador bites then lets go
My bully is nearly 3, he’s been attacked by 5 other dogs he doesn’t try fight back, small dogs snap at him, am actually going to get a camera so the police will see what dog is in the wrong! Am responsible owner my dog is well behaved good with kids and other dogs..
There are a lot more unpredictable and dangerous people!
All dog owners say their dog won’t harm anyone. Even the ones that have dogs that have killed people.
Patrick from Bristol - we haven't, actually, culled any breeds of dog. This makes your question about 'How many breeds of dog do we need to cull before we realise culls don't work?' very odd. Extremely premature. You want us to guess? Maybe, in places like India, there are sporadic culls on feral street dog packs but it's more about controlling numbers and pack size (big packs, singularly intent on finding a vulnerable human to eat, are much more capable of fulfilling their objective than a single environmentally homogenised feral dog) than anything breed specific. Those feral packs in India - they're not a breed. They're what happens when nature and environment take over when humans are no longer interested in engineering breeds. The fact is - we haven't tried breed specific culling. It may be the case that it's an instant improvement. We don't know (we can get a rough idea about the impact of BSL by looking at North America where each state can decide whether to use it or not - but BSL isn't breed specific culling. It's legislation - like the UK 'ban' is BSL.). Personally, I don't want the situation to get serious enough to need to seriously consider a breed specific cull (our government has a hell of a lot to answer for with them letting the genie get so far from the neck of the bottle). I think this whole program set up is deeply antagonistic and maybe that first la la land XLB owner, who phoned in, was cherry picked to exemplify type (if it was purely by accident that she turned out to be utterly detached from logic and reality - oh dear... Not another one.. It would be quite refreshing to encounter one that's not, to some degree, worryingly deranged.).
The lumps phoning up... Not one can see objectively. It's in the interest of the people not to breed a dog that is more likely to attack. Just the name, "bully." It's a combination of the bred aggression in these dogs and the kind of owners this appeals to.
"Just the name bully" is short for Bulldog. You clearly are uneducated on the matter. "It's in the interest of the people, not to breed dogs that are more likely to attack" is a false statement. Contrary to propaganda, Xl Bulldogs, (mixed from American bulldogs, Old English bulldogs, French Bulldog, Pit bull terror (small percentage argued 7 to 15% which is why they can't be dna'd as dangerous)not Pitbulls and Staffies as posted mainstream. They were bred to lower the prey drive and make them a companion dog, similar to a Staffie(The nanny dog) to be tolerant and loyal to children and family's. Please do your research, instead of spewing false information. You try to victim shame an owners who like, and are compatible with this breed. Do you think this about all large dog owners? Ever wondered why there are no problems with this breed in USA? Where they originate.
@slurpeeBeanz Clearly. "Breeders have acknowledged that American Bully dogs can be very dangerous if improperly raised or bred." Get a companion that's not capable of killing a human being if it snsps due to its physicality.
@@pagliacci2942 Clearly ANY dog can be dangerous if not raised properly. That's why licencing and routine tests for people who handle large breeds should be the way to go. Not a blanket ban, which mixes up many breeds in its description. Whilst unable to use your dogs dna to identify it. Absolutely crackers, and it won't stop criminal elements obtaining a loophole, but penalise good responsible owners. Ineffective to say the least. Plenty of dogs large and small are capable of killing a human in the wrong hands. What's your point? Do you just want to mass kill a breed, instead of rightly punish the owner as they've used their dog as a weapon or been grossly irresponsible? Probably. You used the world 'objectively' in your about comment. I suggest you can't 'see the wood for the tree's'. From my short discussion with you, you don't seem knowledgeable on the subject.
@@pagliacci2942 That just proves you're an idiot. Incapable of debate, deleting comments.
Ik heb 2 bullen rot toch op losers en die gast die naast je zit wil ik graag af schieten pak de mensen aan die honden de schuld geven die moeten ze moeten die af gemaakt worden punt😊
Why should I have to walk down the street with my child and have to deal with someone else and there XL Bully. My child shouldn’t have to be anywhere near something which CAN BE so dangerous. Peter is spot on.
Don't ever put your child in a car then... just to be on the safe side 👍
Blimey! Must be grim living in places like Clacton on Sea surrounded by dogs, caravans and deserted rusty theme parks. Interesting to see if the new law is enforced on illegal dog ownership.
Their foundation is the Pit Bull Terrier, and that is also a banned breed in the UK.
So, the Grandmother was 'visiting' the Grandson ? NO. She was asked to go and stay there while the owner went to make a rap video. That is from the owners own mouth when he gave a sob-sob interview. As for 'kill-em-all' Bleksley, The death penalty for humans was abolished because wrongly accused people can't come back to life, and nor can dogs.
Stop being idiotic (the man who rang in) ALL dogs should not be muzzled, all dogs aren’t dangerous 😤
Therapy dog my AxxE 🤓he thinks because his dog is snoring and being normal that it can’t attack/kill, just like THOUSANDS of other people who THOUGHT the same BEFORE it happened
Peter has obviously never owned a dog and has no idea of what a Bully is. If you are going to Cull dogs that are capable of killing a person, that will be any dog over 35kg. Pure insanity. Here is a bit of advice if you can't control your dog then you have the wrong breed, get a breed you can control.
2:36😂👏👏 He aint mucking around
I've been attacked by both pit bulls Mastiffs and a German Pinscher. And a Rottweiler. I remember telling my dad about that when we were going up to see my older sister and her husband and I was telling him about how much I hated Rottweilers or mastiffs and German pinschers and when we got to her place she had a Rottweiler who was bred with a German Pinscher. And the dog was extremely docile very much like a little puppy. But even though I saw how they were with my sister and her husband I could see that they seem to be docile and quite just wanting to be loved and petted and so forth. I still did not put myself into a position where it was just them and myself alone or that they were in a place where they could get to me quite easily where I could get out of there in a given him a moment. I know my sister had said that when she first saw the dog she also was very Weary at the idea of having her. But when her next door neighbors told her that she would do wise to have that dog because of the fact that if the dog would become the kind that would respond to such things as bears and other animals like that there's Bears aren't the most dangerous thing up in the mile zero of Alaska Highway area British Columbia. Moose and other large game like that can be very dangerous to humans. But still no I'd rather have the animal I have with me right now. And that's not somebody I have to take out to go do their business outside. The cat that that I have only two areas that I need to go to clean out the toilet that she uses. She's a lot easier to take care of than somebody who's constantly always needing me or they're going to be barking all day long without me being here.
Disgusting
Can you do a story about if people have gone past the date but want to get there dog excemption done for there dog so they are all legally done please or does anyone know how to do it
Every dog can be dangerous a lot of this is down to bad owners
But it’s not though is it. The woman said it herself, it’s the fact that when they do go, they go off. You can’t stop them.
Yes and no, when dogs are bred with aggression into them they are much more likely to act on that aggression.
I lost my staffy a year ago too and he was always the one being attacked by other dogs. He was too soft. He couldn't even stand up to our female house rabbit. On the other hand there are some snappy staffies (never met one myself) It just depends on the dog, they're all different. Like people.
sorry to here about the loss of your dog they a family members but these people would of looked at your dog as dangerous and want him muzzled i have said before a lot is down to bad owners as a responsible owner you knew how best to keep your dog
Training a dog to be in mi5 lol the point isn't made what kind of abilities do they have to know what kind of dog they are you can have a cross laborador staff that looks big but is basically a loving well balanced dog. There's bad owners that can't be trusted
Totally agree with Peter
I have no idea on what the guy is on about when he criticized people once or more for leaving an apostrophe off but continues to daily give e out a telephone number that consists on numbers and letters. What sort of person would do that if they had the intelligence level above that of a 5 year old?
Whose going to pay for the cull
Just learn the difference between a letter and a number before you spout off on where someone gog an apostrophe wrong and try to infer you are so much smarter than others.Bit of a joke to hear vine rant on about others 5 days week when she/he/it gets is wrong everyday
What a disgusting discussion
I agree. What a cruel and heartless man
Blame the owners not the Dog.
Bullies are bred as family dogs and specifically to take out the aggressive genes - what you have is BAD DOG OWNERS which can happen with any breed especially with breeders that do it for money only. I have a bully that is the sweetest goofiest little thing, I had a mini dachshund rescue before that was viscous because he was abused - the lies are that the dog was breed to attack that’s not true at all do your research!
They don't have a cull of dangerous People! How dare Peter say they should be killed! 😡
Ban them NOW !!!
They ARE banned....🙄
Ban you, you 🤡
KC REGISTERED DOGS ONLY ALLOWED, NO CROSS BREEDS IN THE FUTURE. ALL DOGS TO BE NEUTURED , FROM NOW ON. NO BREEDING AT ALL , ONLY IF KC REGISTERED LICENCED BREEDERS. ANY BREEDING AFTER THIS WILL BE SEEN ILLEGAL, BREEDING/ SELLING. PETS4HOMES TO ONLY ALLOW SELLING OFF KC REGISTERED. AND OTHER SITES MONITORED AND CLOSE ADS NOT KC REGISTERED.