0:00 Intro
1:14 Tier 1
2:11 Tier 2
3:32 Tier 3
5:24 Tier 4
8:49 Tier 5
10:00 Conclusion
Special thanks to Headyyyyyyy for helping me out and for giving me permission to use their iceberg. Link to their iceberg: / mcsm_iceberg
Sources I mentioned
Unused Alafair model • HIDDEN CHARACTER for t...
Unused Radar lines stirpicus.tumblr.com/search/R...
Minecraft Story Mode idea wiki ideas.fandom.com/wiki/Minecra...
#Potato451 Theories community.telltale.com/discus...
Let me know if you spotted any error/stuff I missed
There's also the theory that Soren is an Old Builder, and also how nobody in Champion City actually died when Romeo exploded it.
Yes I actually also thought of Soren being an old builder as Jesse had found and read many books that were written by him, with one of them being about the Redstone Heart. Soren seems kinda knowledgeable too. Due to his sudden disappearance near the end of episode four, I even went as far as to think he is also the admin (Romeo). Now I don’t think he is the admin, and I don’t know how I arrived to that conclusion lol
@@whale9796 Lol
oh yeah I saw that champion city theory video too
@@IDKTBH209 From @MCSM Fangirl Productions? Pretty smart, huh?
I actually prefer the townspeople from Champion City dying. It would make Romeo seem like an even bigger threat
I guess you missed something. Jesse uses every sword variant. Wood, Stone, Iron, Gold, Diamond. And since The 6th one didn’t exists back then. It makes sense to say he experienced every sword.
its nice to see the mcsm community is still alive
I hope maybe they’ll change their minds and make a season 3! Not to mention the mini series on how Jack and Nurm met? I’ve been wondering how they met and how Jack even started adventuring so I think I would’ve loved for them to release the mini series! I hope I never forget this game, it’s the only one that I’ve never gotten bored of. I’ve played both season at least over 14 times 😅 it’s one of the biggest (and probably most important) parts of my childhood! ^^
Sadly, Telltale Games went Bankrupt and can't make any more games. Mojang inherited the lisence for the series, but gave it up and stopped supporting it. The game is now no longer produced for consoles or PCs and can only be bought as used copies on disks or hard drives. Even if they were planning on a season 3, they couldn't make it. Super dissapointing :(
I loved this game too
It will sadly never, not only did they lose the rights, but they also don't have enough money (even with their new company they founded and as they stated they need the original people or new people hired, they just can't replicate the old style as they stated.)and making another season is bassicly another gamble.
I think there was a scene in mcsm S2 where when you look at a bookshelf, Jesse says they used to read a lot butnow they don't have much time for it
it was in the cabin im pretty sure
Ye, he said it in the video
minecraft story mode is still absolutely amazing imo, i still play the netflix version and watch the playthroughs every now and then
Im glad I qm not the only one! This game is nostalgia!
yeah i agree, still have some faith for season three, even if it most likely not be released
Sadly telltale went bankrupt 😭
@@mrpath3406 Mojang also has to endorse the idea and give the devs the permission to continue the adventure. Until then we,fans of jesse we can like share and have a little conversation here:) LIKE WHO ELSE CRYED DURING REUBENS DEATH😭
@@technobladeneverdies8570 it was the saddest part of the whole thing 😔 of course i cried
I’ve been sad since Ruben’s death since I beat the wither storm, it kinda made me feel lonely, since I witnessed Ruben’s death, 2 days after my dog died, coincidence or not, I’m just very sad.
Even on Eric Stirpe's tumblr he's just like "there's no way mojang is gonna give telltale the rights again, they pretend the game never even existed in the first place"
@@MushroomStew look at the cast of Minecraft movie 👀
am i the only one who liked Minecraft story mode? it had nice graphics and was kind of nifty.
@@MushroomStew fr
No you most definitely are not.
Don't worry you're not alone! I'm even writing fanfiction and drawing fanart for it!
One thing that should've been included but wasn't is how Lukas can act if you choose to be rude to him for half of the first series. If you choose the most rude decisions to Lukas through episodes 1-4, I'm pretty sure he doesn't help with killing the wither storm (not sure on this part). What I am sure of though is that during the New Order of the Stone Assembly part at the end of episode 4, Lukas will not even be on the podium with you glaring at you with anger written all over his face.
@@MushroomStew Yeah, I just really don't like how they treated Lukas in the Portal arc in general. Witherstorm arc Lukas was great; he had a few great flaws, excellent character development and was overall a really fleshed out character. If he hadn't been in the Portal arc at all he'd probably be one of my favourites, because he was ultimately flanderised and was pretty much perfect. I could go on, but I'm sure you don't want to read a whole essay about Lukas, haha. But hey, at least there's other characters that I'm a big fan of, such as Petra, Ivor and Radar, that help numb the pain 😂
nothing hits as much as the story mode music thats for sure
There needs to be a theory about the fact that jesse and the gang arent players but actual people in the game, and also that there are youtubers outside of the minecraft reality that can join worlds and maps. Like seen in episode 6.
Okay but are we not going to talk about how Jesse’s underwater helmet had no glass unlike the others? Still makes me wonder if it was an animation mistake or not
Probably just animation mistake lol. There's a lot to keep track of after all.
Great video, I absolutely loved it, let's hope that there is a slight possibility of MCSM S3...
No because telltale games shut down
@@tazinboor3913 Mojang has full rights to the game now, so that means mojang could actually make Minecraft Story Mode season 3. There is still hope, us fan base could convince them to make a season 3 If we tried.
@@tazinboor3913 Mojang has full rights to the game.
@@josh46464 that and telltale games also came back but they’re currently focused on other projects but every time someone asks for them to bring back Minecraft storymode they do say to bring it up to Mojang and even telltale does seem interested to come back to the project again so it’s literally all on mojang for the project to come back
If they said that they were going to make a season 3 I would literally die of joy
Just an update; the actor for ivor, paul ruebens, had sadly passed away.
I have a theory about the white pumpkin aka cassie rose. So cassie probably built up to the surface and went to jesses world plotting revenge
I searched up deep meaning of 451 in #potato451, it adds up in the accomplishment and achievement part for defeating Romeo.
I don't think she was an old builder however, I have a theory that she was one of the greatest competitiors in the games who kept cheating using the white pumpkin mask to scare off people, the old builders (annoyed with her constant creepy cheating) kicked her out of the games and used the atlas to send her to a random portal . and I believe cassie is still alive and probably escaped the endermites probably lying about the no ender pearls and probably rested in her real home, until years later (since season 2 takes a few years after season 1) cassie finally gets revenge on jesse and she probably goes back to the old builder games palace and threatens otto and asks him "where is jesse!? WHERE IS THE PORTAL TO HIS CITY!" and then finds his place and if sometime mojang does do season 3, cassie would be the villain (the reason it's obvious she survived is because at the end of season 2 episode 5 if you stay at beacontown, radar says "also you have a cryptic note from WP which says 'look out' Strange" . WP? WHITE PUMPKIN
Oh my... YOU MAY BE ON TO SOMETHING WITH THE "Cassie alive" theory, but sadly season 3 will probably not happen. Till then we just hope it happens until- Yea lets hope for the best. RIP Minecraft: Story Mode...
You know, on the topic of "age doesn't exist" part, I'm really confused about how anything works in MCSM world if there's no concept of age or family ever touched in the series. Even the gender roles seem to be completely equal, so almost nothing would change if they made the cast all-male or all-female. I mean, if nobody ages or reproduces in this world, are they eventually going to go extinct? And where do the undead mobs that are not zombie villagers come from?
Command blocks bro..
they come from somewhere but that is a full Minecraft question, not just the storymode question
They kinda just spawn in one day but don’t physically age and can only die of sickness or injury. They still get older, but they don’t… get older.
Simple the admins, they made mobs like that just cause they wanted to
@@Raddish-IS-Radd But now that all admins have been depowered...
I was lucky to snatch these two seasons before they weren't available anymore. I really hope they revive the game. I NEED TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS NEXT :((((
I never forget minecraft story mode its really good
Okay, I have a theory well not a theory. Cassie she was part of The Old Builder, but mainly I think she was forgotten because of the crimes she has done. She has been known as a serial killer in the episode called “A Portal To Mystery.” But she was mentioned in the episode called “A Journey’s End?” If you show the Old Builders the White Pumpkin head. Otto mentions(and this is optional) “I haven’t seen that since Cassie left.” Which did give me something that Cassie was apart of The Old Builders but mainly forgotten until she’d left
Nah, I never forgot this game! It will live with me forever!
We need a season 3 where Steve forms an empire, Marries Alex, Finds a new ore called "Netherrite", Changes his empire's name to "The Netherrite empire" Arms his empire with netherrite, Goes in creative mode and declares war on the rest of the world and steve has to steve the rest of the world from him
@@MushroomStew Jesse and his squad saves the rest of the world from Steve's tyranny
Reuben theory scared me the most. It would be cool but creepy if for example we saw jesse seeing a different timeline seeing himself dying and seeing Reuben live instead.
So the Ruben from a different timeline thing. I don't know if this is 100 percent accurate or not but I remember hearing a plotline where they meet Ruben from an alternate timeline where Jesse died instead and the witherstorm won. Which honestly I would love to see. It would be so cool seeing a post apocalyptic witherstorm world.
There's umm Umm Uuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhhh Funny typo Extra o I can hardly-
@@goddessdeedeebubblesofimag7789 what
@@parallaxladder256 the original comment I can't even-- I can't-- It It said I c-- I can't say it without-- without-- Laughing I-- It said-- *"wotherstorm"* Instead of-- you know--
@@goddessdeedeebubblesofimag7789 oh
Technically at any point that Jesse dies the wither storm wins. I mean it even tried to kill him when it pretended to be dead just so it could drag him in. And if Jesse lost at the end I can just imagine the wither strom laughing to itself mocking the others like HAHAHA THERE GOES YOUR FINAL HOPE NOW THIS WORLD IS MINE. Anyway yeah it's cool to think about like what would happen since then there would be no one to stop P.A.M.A so Harper would have failed. And also the admin what is he going to do? 💀 Will he just kill it or leave it to fester you know? But yeah most likely everyone else dies shortly after and then the wither storm would make it's life goal to kill everyone and destroy every block down to bedrock. Also what would the people under the bedrock think after hearing roars from above 💀
Oh my God Aiden wanted to redeem himself and they had RADAR say it straight to his face.
@@MushroomStew 😐
This game was such a huge part of my childhood, and i'm thankful that it existed
Imagine a reboot of Minecraft Story Mode with wardens and the arch-illager. Would be cool if there was herobrine, like with the fanfiction. But they could use the opportunity to fix it, and add more open-ended content and mechanics.
I miss this series lmao
Man I miss this it was my child hood I can’t believe it died away. 😢
Lukas is a realistic character because I’ve been called too trusting as well.
As a guy who used to play Minecraft story mode, I still love it but has many problems
@Hypothermic Dysrhythmia Well, Eric Stirpe said two things about that: 1. Axel and Olivia were cut because they weren't very popular (he said he didn't want to remove them but the people above him said so or smth), and 2. He confirmed that in Season 2, Jesse's best friend is Petra (and his second best friend is Lukas), not Olivia.
@@MushroomStew Was the last time you checked recently, or five years ago when the episode was being made?
@Hypothermic Dysrhythmia Yeah, Jesse's best friend in Season 1 (in the Witherstorm arc at least, idk about the portal arc) was definitely Olivia, but that changed in Season 2. There's actually a dialogue choice in S2 Ep2 when Jesse says to Petra "You're the best friend I've ever had, Petra.".
I loved mcsm. In fact, a part of my username comes from it. I hope it gets a season 3 even though its most likely not gonna happen. I'm also trying to get MCSM season 1, 2 or both for my switch bc they're available on Amazon
Is it 451?
@@SpeedySonic_YT yes
@@Evening451 Nice
I just found out of about Cassidy Rose. I can’t be the only one that think this isn’t a coincidence. She looks similar and has pretty much the same name as a companion in Fallout New Vegas. Maybe there was a huge fan of the game in the Telltale dev team?
cried during season 2 ending, i wanna see the adventures of Petra, Jesse, and Lluna.
We all do
I feel like the warden's design from season 2 is very similar to the skin that a player named pyrobite used. Pyrobite is a famous 2b2t minecraft player( he was even consider as the king of 2b2t) who was famous for greefing bases and a hole bunch of stuff. Seriously its kinda weird but i feel like the devs might added the warden to an homage to pyrobite. I have 2 theoris. 1- the warden is suppose to keep order in prison. Pyrobite played on 2b2t an anarchy server where their is no rule. Maybe the devs wanted to make like a duality between the warden and pyrobite. Theory 2(i think that one better and makes more sense) since 2b2t us an anarcht server and the admin from season 2 is in a way tryng to create anarchy the warden might just be a reference or easter egg to pyrobite. (Bonus idea, maybe the thunder we see in the first world is a reference to lightning on 2b2t + the first world look very similar to 2b2t spawn. Lava cobblestone...etc.) And guess what. Minecraft story mode season 2 came out in 2016 the year were 2b2t had its peek of popularity (hype age).
No
Ah yes, Technoblade never dies! And may he Rest In Peace, and let him fly high
@@raianabo8158 Rest In Peace King. You will forever rule on your kingdom that is righfully yours. Support to his parents andthe rest of his family❤
@@technobladeneverdies8570 yes, let him defeat the King of Heaven like he’d promised us
@@technobladeneverdies8570 yes 👍
Regarding age in the Minecraft/Story Mode Universe, I do infact believe that it exists somewhat. There's just so many evidence. For starters, baby mobs exists in both games, in Minecraft baby mobs are known to grow up within a few in game days to be adults. I don't see why this wouldn't apply to Story Mode. Second, there are multiple characters that appear to be slightly older than the main cast because they can be seen with facial hair as long as beards, and multiple wrinkles throughout their skin suggesting that there can be older characters in the universe. Lastly this is a bit of a stretch, but we can use behavior to figure out what age range the characters are. The main cast seems to be in their late teens, young adults at most. The main cast likes to hang out in a tree house of all locations. Yes that doesn't mean that they are necessary children, but wiu would you think that grown-ups would hang out in a tree house of all places???
@@MushroomStew age may not exist, and it has been confirmed that it doesn't exist yes, but there's soo much weirdness and conflicting evidence but whatever he says goes I guess...
There’s kinda another layer to it. The executives above Eric Stirpe made a rule that they weren’t allowed to reference ages because they wanted to open the possibility of all the characters being players in a big Minecraft server. But, like another rule they had, they only _mostly_ followed it. Plus we’re allowed to headcanon ages for them.
Jesse said he/she loved to read in season 2 below the bedrock
For You playing as a different character. I remember seeing a tumblr post with whatshisname saying that you'll play as a different character in season 3 as a student in a hero academy, that's all I remember.
@@MushroomStew I could try
Eric Stirpe? XD
Its no longer on Netflix America
Netflix AMERICA?
Or anywhere
Things hit different when the wither storm's theme started playing Also there was nothing in the iceberg on it? Am I the only one who's thought _this hard_ on it/the regular wither?
I'd hope that season 3 would have lizzie, isa, milo, em, the gladiators, and the redeemed blaze rods move to beacontown
Don't forget Romeo as well. He needs the most redemption for what he did as the admin.
in season 1 ep 3 you get to choose if you wanna set the formidi bomb and if you chose not to what would happen?
it's sad that Jesse lost his pet pig Ruben it's a sad part of Minecraft Storymode
Hopefully one day we will get MCSM
Season 3 sorry! I forgot to type it
You know, I wonder if Soren's Endermen experiments could be tied to Game Theory's Endermen being the remnants of an ancient civilization theory
Probably not actually, given how the Minecraft Story Mode world operates with the Far Lands, Old World, Dimension Portal Hallway, Old Builders, and Admins (Gods?)
you missed the fact that in S1 eppisode 4 the maze scene, jesse says she met Reuben "near a waterfall like this"
I also i have a theory that otto might be a villager
Ill never forget it
I think there was a Deleted Scene before the Dead Enders Encountered the Enchanting Room in The Order of the Stone
With more arrows you had to dodge?
@@stfuyoutube423 no with a Daylight Sensor
I still have the 1st and 2nd seasons on my Xbox. I like to play them time to time.
Wordscapes actually stole that for their background
I'm very surprised he did not add the wither storm
@@MushroomStew they're basically saying "there's nothing on the iceberg about the wither storm?" Which I kinda said in my comment too
Good video! Can you give the link to the last thing you mentioned?
if they did make mcsm season 3 it would only be good to continue the story of jesse and the rest of the order...
The wiki for MCSM does give the characters ages though
Minecraft story mode is on Netflix because Netflix bought it is what I found out
I want to hear deep voiced radar
Radar glow up season 3
Luckly for me i just played it now Little tooo late but this is gold i wish there was season 3 tho..
idk why the thumbnail killed me 💀
2:18 this may be a reference to a animation parody called minecraft story mode: funny animation parody where in the first episode you can find Jesse reading a book. This may have lead to a misconception about Jesse likening books kzhead.info/sun/ZtSifdKph4Fvn58/bejne.html
Tumblr added another layer to this iceberg. Just found a fucking *Pinup Lukas*
You know if you stay In beacon town it will be a broken heartbreak of Jesse and Petra, or if you go with Petra for adventuring then it will be a un-broken heartbreak for Jesse and Petra!!!!
I use to binge a lot of Minecraft story mode tubers big b stats dantdm and others
Guys I bought MCSM the complete adventure for Xbox 360 because it has all 8 episodes on it and I don’t have to download anything but when I buy MCSM season 2 since it doesn’t have a a complete adventure disc and only has a season pass many say it works and some say they have problems with it but then it works and some say it doesn’t work so what’s the truth many say it’s a problem on ps4 many say there is a problem on Xbox 360 but not Xbox one so what is it someone answer and please tell me it works can’t really afford a whole new console right now. Some body please reply!!!!!!
I hope the new telltale rereleases will the old seasons
There probably isn’t age because it’s Minecraft, have you ever seen a parent in Minecraft story mode? I think they might just spawn idk
DanTDM
@@therealloganyt237 not what I meant
@@pigwhaleg Ohh I see what you meant now.
@@pigwhaleg and I also realized DanTDM *is* in Minecraft Story Mode, in episode 6, but he wasn't a parent.
@@pigwhaleg and he became a parent (IRL) after episode 6 was released.
bro i still got season one ☠️
My guy sounds like ant venom
I think that you don't understanding ir having a lot of knowledge of MCSM makes you clueless about how to unravel the iceberg which in turn makes a lot of people don't understand it
i love this game
Finally, a game that does not have a mountain of creep pasta
@@MushroomStew damn it Edit: oh I checked the link, good thing I don't like to read lol
Bro i still play it
Bro said he didn’t understand the Jesse loves to read part then shows a clip of it like 2 seconds later
@@MushroomStew relax homie I’m jp
@@MushroomStew bro mad now
@@MushroomStew na homie it’s jus like I didn’t actually expect u to respond but when I did see the vid I was trippin for a sec I actually really liked it tho homie
@@MushroomStew na bro don’t even worry lmao
Minecraft story mode It was actually pretty ok ngl
Some of the character designs popped so hard for the game
@@GayBrain Petra
@@tallic967 The first mainline characters had such great designs as well!
I first played Storymode back in middle school and I loved it to death. I now have Seasons 1&2 on my Switch and my Switch’s album is completely FULL of screenshots from Season 1 & 2 combined. While I love it to death, I will also criticize it to death. The writing for the dialogue could have been better, Season 1 is better than Season 2, I don’t like (but understand) Olivia’s VA change in S2, and I have a few head-cannons for the never-going-to-happen Season 3 🥲
You Sound Like NationSquid
Wanted to forget??? Why???
Player playing mcsm Console: 😭😭😭😭 Pc/computer: 🙂🙂🙂 Tv: 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
? Console players got The Complete Adventure, the most accessible way to play MC:SM
@@Star.6739might have meant how the game performs with tv version (netflix) being the best running with cinematic elements, although it is the worst since there were only 5 episodes and most of choices were remove along with no quick time events
kumalala kumalala kumala savesta
What hapoened ti the netflix show?
It got taken off
Therory mcsm still in netflix reply
Mattishere going to play mcsm first agust 26 episode 1 and september 5 episode 2 september 12 episode 3 september 19 episode 4 setptamber 26 episode 5 october 5 episode 6 october 12 episode 7
Hm
Mattishere play mcsm s1 and s2 first november mcsm s1 and january 2023 mcsm s2
Minecraft storymode is one of my favorite games. even though it can be cringey at times
Dude everthing ok with you voice?
I have to admit, a lot of characters annoyed me, most of them were whiny and super immature, my only favorites are Lucas because he actually got really good character development, Ivor because he’s hilarious, and Ruben because he’s Ruben. But I do love this series for all the nolstalgia it gave me, I was about 9 when I played it and when Ruben died I was literally crying same with when Ldshadowlady died in the murder myster episode because she was my favorite KZheadr at the time, and I’m still wondering what happened to Soren at the end
🤓
If you actually played minecraft before you would know you can’t be a kid so in mc age doesn’t exist it’s not a big deal
hey im the one who made it! Awesome work
You saying age doesn't exist in mcsm but there was baby zombies?
@@MushroomStew so ur saying they re god?