Parents of American hostage speak out after Hamas release video showing son
Rachel Goldberg and Jon Polin, parents of Israeli-American hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin, respond to the new propaganda video released by Hamas that appears to show proof that their son is alive.
Subscribe to ABC News on KZhead: abcnews.visitlink.me/59aJ1G
Watch 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events on ABC News Live: • LIVE: Latest News Head...
Watch full episodes of World News Tonight with David Muir here: • ABC World News Tonight...
Read ABC News reports online: abcnews.go.com
ABC News Digital is your daily source of breaking national and world news, exclusive interviews and 24/7 live streaming coverage. ABC News is the home to the #1 evening newscast “World News Tonight” with David Muir, “Good Morning America,” “20/20,” “Nightline,” “This Week” with George Stephanopoulos, “ABC News Live Prime” with Linsey Davis, plus the daily news podcast “Start Here.”
---
Connect with ABC News on social media:
Facebook: / abcnews
Instagram: / abcnews
TikTok: / abcnews
X: / abc
Threads: www.threads.net/@abcnews
LinkedIn: / abcnews
What about Palestinian people are nt they human beings. Why don’t you interview them too and ask how they feel loosing their kids for no fault of them. They can’t be held responsible for hamas same way how these people can’t be held responsible for IDF and their atrocities.
If you are real human. Cry for all victims. Don't cry for one side
Then there are many non-humans protesting spreading hate.
They're snakes in disguise
@@KitKatToeBeans you mean a whole pariah state committing genocide ?
WOW, imagine talking about 130 hostages and ignoring 34000 massacred.
Around 600,000 German civilians died under nazi rule, does that make the nazis right? Casualties of war are hard to stomach. But it was hamas who gamed israel (which i dont agree with their heavy handedness personally, it was too reactive), but they did pull them into this massacre and are probably happy in their qatar condos watching it unfold because they don't care about the people, they are expendable - they care about the furthering of their ideology and that is to destroy the jewish state and work towards their goal of the muslim brotherhood. NObody was yelling "free palestine" and "save gazans" on oct 7. They were yelling "god is great". I don't know how people cannot accept this.
How about the ignoring of Oct 7 What came first the chicken or the egg ?
@@ralex3697 how about the 76 years of occupation, murdering, torturing and stealing lands.
Imagine the 34000 plus of families who are all dead and can not even see their loved ones. It is sad we still support government who are committing this atrocities!
Sad thatHamas started this war and murdered 1200 people including raping women and burning babies. Sad that you support Hamas and what they did on 10/7. Any Palestinian deaths is on Hamas and on the Palestinian people since more than 80% support Hamas and what they did on 10/7. Israel goes out of their way to spare civilian's, while Hamas uses them as shields. And you support Hamas. Sick.
If you believe those numbers
Imagine the Palestinians are facing past 75+ years
kzhead.info/sun/qqV_dK1uaqusgYk/bejne.htmlfeature=shared
kzhead.info/sun/qqV_dK1uaqusgYk/bejne.htmlfeature=shared
Imagine Palestinians were accepting the partition plan in 1947, not attacking Israel and losing and then playing the victims for 75 years while terrorizing civilians. Imagine they could move on like other people who's nations lost wars and not walk around pathetically with keys I can buy in the flea market. Imagine they wouldn't cling to refugee status and invest in welfare instead of weapons. Just imagine this.
@@yoezra Wow ,imagine I will come to your home as guest then ask you to get out this is mine god has promised me this then UN like someone will say you have to give him half of your home will you accept that ...NO..you call your neighbours and everybody around for help.
@@yoezra And don't lie you and I both know what has been happening their already ,palestinians were killed by these terr*rist forces everyday it didn't started in oct
So sad! This is what Palestinian families feel when their kids are kidnapped and detained by Israel without even knowing where they are and when they will be released
Hi soldier here, that Doesn’t happen.
Did all the Palestinians parents know their children were in mass graves? Tell us , soldier there , how do mass graves happen ?
@@alizaamiel144 Ha ha ha. It happens all the time. You have been captured by propaganda. Oct 7 didn't happen in a vacuum. It was a reaction to decades of oppression and abuse.
@@alizaamiel144 How come? Both israeli soldiers and palestinians filmed bunch of those kidnapping videos, you cannot unsee them.. you provided us with evidence and now denying?
@@alizaamiel144 soldier my A$$.
No one is talking about the thousands of Palestinian hostages that have been held longer than October 7th in Israeli jails. What about them! They’re human and their lives matter too!
This is the fault of Muslim Nations especially the leader Saudi Arabia that no-one take the Palestinian hostages into consideration
You mean prisoners with blood on their hands?
kzhead.info/sun/qqV_dK1uaqusgYk/bejne.htmlfeature=shared
@@esti445 lies 😂
They were suicide bombers
Aaron Bushnells last post stated: “Many of us like to ask ourselves, 'What would I do if I was alive during slavery? Or the Jim Crow South? Or apartheid? What would I do if my country was committing genocide?' The answer is, you’re doing it. Right now,
The only genocide occurred on oct 7th by hamas and its accomplices upon the people of Israel. Hamas and its allies /irans proxies in the Middle East and hamas apologists in ivy league schools- call for the mass massacre of Jews over and over again . What you are doing, is spreading hate and misinformation on the same platform that a mother and a father plead for their sons life ,Mehta only “crime” was to go to a party while being Jewish. That is abhorrent. When your actions are being applauded by and Islamic fundementalist autocratic , misogynistic , homophobic , antiemetic regime such as Iran and its proxy- Hamas, you KNOW you’re on the wrong side of History
Who is committing genocide? These parents? Their son who’s a hostage. What are you doing? Supporting terrorists. Hamas started this war on 10/7.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
I just hope you have as much empathy for the Palestinians too.
No I do not because Hamas started this whole mess!
@@Carol-rl8xt How many children must die, in your self-righteous opinion?
What the Pals that encourage and push their children into the same extreme evil ideology beliefs that think it is a honour to be a suicide bomber, hamas terrorist, a martyr, yet adore the status and respect of the like minded community of neighbours, relatives and friends that think it is wonderful and celebrate a parents flesh and blood dying and yet causing others innocent unknown people to suffer such deaths or injuries. It is about time those that follow such a sick religious cult value the lives of their children first and the lives of others instead of supplementing one child for many other births.
@@Carol-rl8xt Hamas started? 😂😂😂 What abt; Haifa massacre 1937 Jerusalem massacre 1937 Haifa massacre 1938 Balad Al-sheikh massacre 1939 Haifa massacre 1939 Haifa massacre 1947 Abbasiya massacre 1947 Al-khisas massacre 1947 Bab Al-mud massacre 1947 Jerusalem massacre 1947 Sheikh bureik massacre 1947 Jaffa massacre 1948 Jerusalem massacre 1967 and many more. Who did it?! Why ur brain just remember October 7 only does ur brain doesn't enough space to remember abt tragedy in 75years abt Palestine?
She does. I’ve watched many videos of Rachel Goldberg and she empathizes with the mothers in Gaza. She is a good human.
No mention of the thousands of Gaza children that were massacred, but those "130 people are humans". Ruthless, simple ruthless and selfish.
Is that the massacred children the parents beat and abuse to put through militant training to become terrorists and martyrs for the extreme ideology beliefs the parents, schools,mosques, family believe in so once they die the community can give the family a higher status of respect for the sick deeds taken place all for the sake of a sick cult.
Do you mean the criminals in Jails? Stop with the lies and gaslighting.
Hi truth, do you remember who started this war?
@@judith2139 Sure, it was Zionism that started the war. Look up Balfour declaration. Then it escalated in 1948. Have you been living in some hole all this time?
i have watched tons of interviews with this mother and she mentions the palestinians in gaza suffering often. but of course you already have an image of her in your head. she is very sympathetic and empathetic.
Poor guy will never look at US or Israel the same way. Abandoned. Left to rot.
He will be freed. Don’t lose hope . Even with his injury he has survived this far
He will be freed and us and isreal are the only once helping you pos.
@supernova7848 they had to run from bombs while Netanayhu used them as pawns to stay out if jail.
Palestine will be free , you inhuman illegal occupier of original inhabitants.
He will be ok, when he is released, he will be smart and he will never see Isreal the same and I hope his parents open there eyes and open there mind listen to his experience he is the one who really knows, the mom sounds angry I would be to but she should see that her son is ok and not look for something that is not there do not feed the problem
I feel sorry for this Family and kid, I feel sorry for all Palestine children and mothers loosing there lives for WHAT 💔🙏🏻
what about the 7000 plus Palestine hostages?
Many of them held without charge for an unspecified period of time. Also many Palestinian children are imprisoned in Israel. So much for the "only democracy in the Middle East".
Do you mean the criminals in Jails? Stop with the lies and gaslighting.
@@fulanichild3138Are you talking about the “innocent children” who participated in the attack on October 7?
201 days and he still alive his parents probably concerns bout his health but look at the reality! City are collapses, food medicine and water are limits cuz Israel not allows food medicine or even UN staffs go in to Gaza Do u think Palestinian kids are living good life with buffets with their families at their cozy home out there?
Maybe HamaSS shouldn't use them as a human shield.
Untrue. Tons of aid has been sent. HamaSSs confiscates it & keeps it from the people.
That's untrue
@@yoezra Where's your evidence of such? Google the 'Neighbor Procedure' Israel has an established protocol of using Palestinians as human shields for DECADES as reported by multiple human rights agencies AND the U.N.. You cant believe everything you see on MSM. You have to demand EVIDENCE.
Precisely. Gazan children are dying of famine and these ingrates don't even recognize what it has taken to keep their son alive in spite of Israeli efforts to wipe him out.
I can’t imagine my only child going through this, I’m still praying for their release.
And the thousands of dead children on the other side, are you praying for them too?
Yes thank you for praying for the Palestinian kids who were murderd god bless Palestine
@@twilajohnson2313No one cares .
@@twilajohnson2313 Children that didn’t need to die, Hamas is their cause of death bringing war and using hospitals and schools and children for human shields!!! Shame on Hamas!
@@kennymorrison7227we know that 🤡
5:26 same goes to every each palestinians 🎉🎉🎉🎉 they are humans you know!!!
To Zionists they are just "goyim." In fact, so aren't all white people who aren't one of them. They hate us and they hate the truly devout Jews, too.
Pray this conflict gets resolved soon. Pls remember that every person caught in this conflict has dreams. Over 40,000 Palestinians got their lives, families, loved ones, dreams, hopes, health, education, homes,.... taken away from them. It needs to stop for the sake of everyone.
It's a tragedy... it hurts my heart.
Yes Palestinian kids dead is so sad I know
@@BayAreaBadBoy1No one cares about Palestinian terrorists
@@BayAreaBadBoy1No one cares about Palestinian terrorists.
@@BayAreaBadBoy1 Palestinian kids would be ALIVE if not for October 7th! Hamas brought war and war results In collateral damage!!! Hamas hides behind those kids, THIS IS SAD!
@@BayAreaBadBoy1Stop it. Just stop. Every civilian death from BOTH sides of this conflict is equally tragic. Until people understand that simple truth, our world will never know peace. No child should have to violently die in wars created by the corrupted rich and powerful men of our world; but they perpetuate the us vs. them dynamic and you just lop it up. Stop.
God bless you and your son! So very painful
They just talked about 133 hostages but never mentioned anything about 8k Palestinian prisoners who even never even spoke for themselves. And never stood before a judge??
This amazed me overall these are the people who cries crocodile tear.
Our hearts must feel for all humans. Not just picking and choosing who we pour our hearts for. All lives matter when injustice to those lives are in effect. May God bring this boy back to his family safe and well.
Hersh's parents are amazing and I hope they will be reunited with him soon.
Eu desejo que demore uns 20 anos 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.
that’s so scary
I pray for this family may his son come home safe ❤
Kathryn from HASBARA sever playbook of Zionism.
George when are you going to be so concerned about the Palestinian children or the Palestinian people? Have you done a single show even a 5 minute bit to show the American people what's happening to the Arabs and Palestinians? How do you think about things how do you differentiate?? Also your attitude looks fake clearly on the TV. It looks like a joke
Thank goodness he is alive! I am hoping with all my heart he will be freed. I really feel for his family. So horrible for all the hostages and their families. The cruelty people re capable off boggles the mind. Our civilisation is paper thin.
Happy he is alive too and my heart goes out to his family. My heart also goes out to the families of the 20,000 newly made orphans in Gaza, to the families of the 1000+ children in Gaza who had amputations, and my heart goes out to the 13,000 children killed in Gaza. Every university in Gaza has been bombed. About 70% of residential homes have been bombed. How cruel of the IDF. I see humans, but no humanity. Source: Human Rights Watch, United Nations, Amnesty International
@@HaseenaReflects IDF do what it suppose to: protect civilians.
I constantly send prayers and energy for protection to them all. Seeing this I totally have to keep the faith and believe it's helping.
Are you also praying for the thousands of children that Israel has killed?
🙏💙🎗
What’s needed is that weapons stop being sent by this government that’s in the pocket of Zionists…. You’re energy ain’t going nowhere for right now
So horrible and sad for a parent to have to endure this 🙏🏽
What about palastinian parents....?once think about it ...
@@mohammadabid3018 they wouldn’t exacted Hamas and definitely not use their own children as shields
@@user-xq5js9ef8v Mind Controlled Moron
Yeah and yet all governments have managed to still just make it all about themselves
@@user-xq5js9ef8vyou are moron
May he come home soon, looks like his injury has healed well. How is it possible that he didn't get an infection in Gaza
His home is not America Real Americans are not dual citizens
The terror they are experiencing is just awful. Jesus PLEASE HELP!
October 7th was baited.. Go read a book.
pray for israel amen
@@72marshflower15jackass
@@72marshflower15stupid jackasd
@@72marshflower15read that book jackass
But no mention of the thousand of innocent Palestinians dead. The parents have no empathy at all. You talk about the hostages but didn't utter a word of the thousand of dead people and the ethnic cleansing of your own govt
Yes they did. Maybe not in this little clip but I heard in another one.
I don't blame the parents. I'm sure anyone who had their child taken from them would be focused on their child alone.
Have you any empathy for the hostages or for these poor parents? Because it sure doesn't seem like you do.
They “empathy” can be heard in the words “ for the region “ & “ in the area” … if they do have opinions towards what’s happening to the local population then they aren’t really saying it either if way. Their priority is to retrieve their child , If it takes obliterating the local population and all their infrastructure to free their son then that’s what they will have to contend with, Although if you listen carefully they are hinting more at negotiation than obliterations .
No empathy for Hamas they brought this on themselves
Every word she used to describe the hostages! Same words are used about Palestinians! When will we world see each other as equals ?
Why aren't they showing what he was saying in the video? Israel has rules for American journalism and what they are allowed to say and not say on air. Israel had the video censored so we don't know what the young man was saying.
He is saying similar content to other hostages videos that were released which is anger towards Israel’s government. That’s what Hamas tells them to say…
@@maleyalove3447 you can fake that genuine emotion.
@@yorksfolly1255 I honestly don’t think that you need to fake anger when being in this situation… it is most probably one of the natural emotions to feel in that horrible state, and it can be linked to that matter. But I’m sure that if Hamas told the hostage: we are making a video of you as a life sign, say what ever you want” then probably this content of blaming the government wouldn’t be the main issue to talk about… Especially when all hostages say the same thing in the same style. So sick that so many people actually support these psychopaths calling them legitimate freedom fighters. Prayers to this beautiful boy 🙏🏽 waiting so much to see the hostages out!
He basically says that this is netanyahu's fault, and calls on him to resign. He also says that so far 70 hostages have been unalived due to the IDF boming them. He also says that netanyahu rejected all the hostage deals that were offered so far, and says shame on him for that. He ends the video by telling his parents that he loves them, and hopes to see them soon.
@@maleyalove3447 psychoanalysing the Hostage and labelling Hamas phsycopaths....are you a qualified psychologist?
Prayers ❤ For Hersh and for the other hostages. 🙌🏽🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
In JESUS name, Amen!
While you are praying pray for the Palestinians too, they do not have souls in your eyes. What hypocrisy of human!
@@protruthforgaza We pray for their salvation, they need to accept JESUS CHRIST as their Lord and savior like everyone else.
The Palestinians are human beings also.
I just can't Imagine. Even I noticed that he doesn't look healthy. He's alive though. My family and Church has been praying and praying for him and a few others who stories have touched us. We jumped and praised God for joy when we saw this video. Thank God bc it's all him. He decides.... Not Hamas, not Israel. This needs to end . They all need to come HOME!!!
Very true
It takes religion to make good people do bad things.Gods are not real, but religious indoctrination and brainwashing is.
30,000+ lost even then hostages are alive
This is heart breaking! To have your sons faith in the hands of your own government
Imagine the pain of those thousands of palestinians abd their families in Israeli prisons where they are continuously tortured
It's terribly sad. I don't believe any of the people involved want's this. The answer seems very simple that an immediate ceasefire would solve this. After all the invasion is illegal.
Am sure he treated 1000x bettor then palistinians arrested by israel Hersh said he was arrested by them hamas so he is not a hostage
How about demanding for a ceasefire and end to occupation
If we negotiated for the basketball girl in Russia why cant we please negotiate for this American hostage please look at his hand and distress , this is our fellow American, please God do a miracle and answer these parents prayers , bring all the hostages home in Jesus mighty name amen 🛐🇮🇱🙏🙇♀️🇺🇸❤️
Well said. Especially considering the basketball girl was guilty of importing drugs into russia whereas Hersh Goldberg Polin is a completely innocent hostage.
Stay home , stay safe ......
@@annaharris1127 ~ *captive. Because “hostage” implies short term and its usage is meant to derive a slanted response from people.
@@72marshflower15 interesting comment. As far as I know even Israel refers to them as hostages not captives. What bohters me more is seeing the mainstream media in Canada refer to "hamas militabts" when they should be called hamas terrorists.
@@annaharris1127 ~ you do realize who created and funded that group through 2019, no? Also, it appears that you’re unaware of who instigated both world wars to begin with..
I hope they get their son back but i also hope she feels compassion for the 40,000+ people killed in gaza. They are not just number either and they had hopes ans dreams. Herch is a victim just like the children of Gaza. STOP THE GENOCIDE!
She has no obligation. Go talk to Hamas your friends about empathy.
@@channahnoyb4803I don't support hamas, I just don't believe in genocide and stealing land. I guess thats all you can do because you are either a bot in a bot farm or an uninformed dum dum lacking humanity. Get a new script.
@@channahnoyb4803 ok bot.
They are writing their own history by siding with Hamas
Where do you get these inflated numbers from? Hamas Ministry of health? What a joke!
Imagine the anguish, the starvation, the torture that the Palestinian children have been enduring not only for seven months but for generations. Tens of thousands of Palestinian have been detained in the worst conditions but no one ever cared to utter a word of support or help. What an unjust world are we living in. The tens of thousands of children that have ben amputated or exterminated by he most brutal killing machine have never had a chance to even to see a post or interview in their favor. We hope that no child has to suffer what they suffer no matter on which side they are
I have sympathy for these parents since their son was not combatant (unlike IDF soldiers who Hamas captured are prisoners of war and not hostages). BTW, there are thousands of Palestinians in Israeli jails for no charges or were convicted for acts of resistance.)
The hypocrisy and the double standard is beyond comprehension 👺👺🤡🤡🤡😈🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
These parents are so strong. Let’s pray for the hostages to get released 🙏🏼
So now they are American?
There were Americans visiting there that were taken.
@@thisissparta8884 Are you sure they are not settlers?
Yep. The devils
most israeli jews are born and raised there. the vast majority dont have dual citizenships or second passports. some of the hostages have ties to other countries like usa in this families case. you seem to have no sympathy at all for this family
@@maddssmithy they are settlers.
it is outrageous the hostages have not yet been released. im very sorry for this. and i wish there was more advocacy from all sides to release hostages and ceasefire now. i am concerned about the number of hostages who were bombed by the IDF. they were supposed to be rescuing the hostages, not bombing them 💔
Looks like he is being treated well. Imagine the pain and suffering of millions of Palestinian parents.
Get Netenyahu out of office!
This is so heartbreaking 💔 and barbaric..let’s be rational and blame it on Hamas.
@@MultiDoer thats you being rational ?
@@nadiaennab8896 I am just saying, how would anyone feel if their loved one were withheld captive; that’s irrational.
@@MultiDoer I would blame the man with all the power to stop this . the same man that propped those same people that "kidnapped" my child .
@@nadiaennab8896absolutely he that has the power is somehow taking the wrong approach but the ideology behind the kidnapping is inhuman, uncivilized, and barbaric..may God grant the victim’s family their heart desires🙏🏿.
A terrible situation for these parents. But are these people settlers in Israel. They don’t know how many of the hostages Nethanyu has killed with his indiscriminate bombing. He cares less about the hostages.
💯
Isn’t it hard to be separated from loved one? Imagine now all those innocent Palestinian kids
As bad as it is for these parents and the suffering caused to their son , let us also mention that there are thousands of Palestinian yound people in Jewish prison . Many are imprisoned for up to 10 years for throwing stones at Jewish soldiers !!! All convicted by military Courts without the assistance of a lawyer !! All Palestinians have felt this pain and humiliation for more than 70 years . 35 000 dead and 70 000 injured ,(2023-2024) including thousands of woman and children with ambutted limbs . I hope the best for this young man and may hé come home safely !!!
Aub stop met leugens verspreiden,
Lets also not leave out the many also trialled before the jury for murder, having weapons, terrorists. Hence why Israelis are reluctant to release these evil lot back out into the world.
Colonial racism has to come to an end. The game is already over, they just you don't know it yet
Imagine all Gaza feeling same feeling ur son have if not worse
Hypocrite. Your leaders are in Qatar marrying women 20 years younger and living a high life.
Go educate yourself, you inhumane puppet.
Bullshit
Maybe they shouldn't vote for Hamas and cheer when they saw the body of a young woman on a track.
So great parents, they're so strong. Hersh will come home soon along with the other hostages!
And the dead Palestinians. Can you bring them home.
Bring all the Palestinians home
@@leemanfatima3615 I pity all civilian victims of this war who are innocent, the same as Rachel Goldberg, the mother of Hersh Golberg-Polin!
@@Athome452 I pity all civilian victims of this war who are innocent, the same as Rachel Goldberg, the mother of Hersh Golberg-Polin!
I'm reminded of Jeremiah 31:15-17, "Rachel is weeping for her children...and they shall come back from the land of the enemy. There is hope for your future, declares the LORD". As Hirsch's mother, Rachel, says, "Hope is mandatory". 💞
What is this world we live in!!! The occupation killed more than 34,000 Palestinians, including more than 15,000 children. Imagine the number of mothers who suffer because of the loss of their children.... More than 18,000 children became orphans and have no relatives because the occupation killed them all
The look on that poor boys face its heart breaking. 😢
Our God Yahweh will help us.Pray to Him every day.
That God is a vicious murderer by all accounts.
You would know you can tell your an intellectual thinker it's obvious as it's burned off your hair from your forehead to the crown 😅
Palestinians are praying to the same god, asking for the same.
Who sad that? Torah ours book. Koran fake.
@@JacobSteinberg75 No one cares about Palestinian terrorists ya clown 🤣
This is sad for the family. Hope he gets to go home to his family. This war needs to stop on both sides.
We are praying for your dear son and Israel every day! Love and blessings from Canada 🤍💙🤍
I am amazed by this lady while she talks about 133 but doesn't talks about 34000 this shows how much empathy she does have. Actually it's not selfish but few people are built like this.
This couple is so highly respectable and you can feel their goodness. I wish they got Hersh home soon.
Watching her speak at the UN was incredible
Makes me sick to my stomach. These poor parents.
My mind cannot imagine the pain of a mother watching her child die slowly due to hunger and being unable to do anything... This happens every moment in Gaza, especially in the north, because the occupation is starving them and preventing the entry of aid
Even if he is freed, he will never be the same again. Not physically (he lost his arm) and not mentally. The mental scars will be the worst. Pray for him. Pray for all the hostages. Pray for the families who are enduring this hell.
What about the Palestine hostages. Are they humans
No such thing. They are criminals. Stop the lies and gaslighting.
Pray for Palestinian 😢
Moron
Moron
It’s not about that you imbecile. No empathy is a reflection of your lack of intelligence
No empathy is a reflection of your lack of intelligence
Sending prayers that all get released and come home quick. To the ones held Don't give up Keep Hope and know we care in USA
Pray for all the Palestinians as well It is only fair as they are human and their children have been injured or died!!
How many of them are alive?
Do not think very many! Hamas always sidesteps any information about the hostages.
Do not believe too many surviving hostages!
They said about 40 seem to be alive.
It’s not clear. Israel has bombed and killed a lot of them.
So sad
All your Government fault who made you live in others property
Pray for you and all the hostage parents😢
We love you, stay strong, and survive ❤ I say it with you.
Let's talk about the over eight thousand Palestinian prisoners including the kids as young as nine years old, maybe even younger, their lives matter too, we normalize the fact that Israelis and Westerners in general live matter more, but no, all liver should matter EQUALLY. FREE all prisoners from both sides and FREE PALESTINE 💯.
Do you mean the criminals in Jails? Stop with the lies and gaslighting. How can you free Palestine if it was never a state? I wish for peace and to free all the innocents, but this is not the case. Sorrry.
What about 10 000 Palestinians hostages under brutal torture n most are women n children
No sympathy here. My sympathy is for the 40,000 Palestinians, most of them women and children, slaughtered by people like this hostage. And how about the 8,000+ Palestinian hostages languishing in Israeli jails? Not to mention that these people and their son are not indigenous to the land but are American. Sorry, folks, the victim card is out of date and no-one is accepting it anymore.
What about hostages in Israel What about their parents
How could someone do that to a father and mother that's purely satanic.
You don't mention the Palestine lives lost why not. Are they not human
It's called war. All these egotistical men making irrational decisions that affect helpless men, women children and animals. It's disgusting and it will probably never end.
No @@leemanfatima3615
Palestinians are human beings also, aren’t they? Why would Israel have Palestinian children in prison? Just stop it. Let those people go!
Where do you come up with this nonsense
Stop stealing land 🤦♂️
Stop lying
Brother you are really concerned about your son well being .Although you should be really thankful to Almighty Allah for keeping your son Alive and well. Have you ever thought about small Palestinian children,pregnant women and innocent civilians being butchered with no reason and what kind of food and shelter they are getting through IDF soldiersand brutal Israeli government. Pray for them also as we know that if you pray for others wellbeing Almighty will give that favour to you also.
Im praying for this poor boy going through unimaginable pain. Imagine a terrorist blowing off your hand and then kidnapping and holding you hostage. Vile and wicked
Is it only violent vicious when Hamas does it or is it still violent and vicious when Israel is doing it repeatedly?
😢🙏💙🎗
@@twilajohnson2313 -Hamas is a prescribed terrorist organisation. if YOU were there, they would have done the same to YOU. Israel does not kidnap and rape women, or act like a mob, rape, burn, butcher, behead, kill, and kidnap. You views are WICKED.
people who died of covid were also not a number
So sad for a parent to have to endure this. So sad to have thousands of Palestinian parents to have to endure the loss of their children
so what !!!! In the end, they did not go to America and hold him hostage, but rather, he came to their land and was hosted by the occupation
The Whataboutism under this video is unbelievable! Let’s hope Hersh will come home alive and stay safe 🙏🏼!!
Hope you have this heartfelt messages for Palestinians as well, who ironically is murdered to the extent of wiping out entire families, newborns are taken out of the bellies of matryed Mother's! What do you say to those hypocritical IDF? Is my question and the entire world?
Very sad😭
Horrific! 6 months with ZERO confirmation that their son was alive, psychological terror by Hamas! A four year old American girl was orphaned October 7 and held 50 days to be later traded for three violent adult male criminals. Insane!!!
and a 5 yr old Palestnian girl was trying to escape the IDF with her family, and they open fired on the car, while she was on the phone begging for help. They later found pieces of her in the car. Her name was Layan Hamadeh.
@@JacobSteinberg75 If this is your real name, Jacob Steinberg, I salute your comments here as a Jewish man. It's a refreshing change to see/hear. I've been closely involved with American Jewish people for most of my life and yes, even Israelis. However, I've been very conflicted since Oct. and have withdrawn from them. Thank you for a different perspective and Happy Passover.
@@JacobSteinberg75you are right and let’s not just focus on what happened on oct and afterwards but over 75 years and how many children died or lost their parents feeling no hope for the future and every single hostage held has a hope for release but the ones in Israel prison don’t even have hope so we pray for both sides to stop this madness and acquire peace process and vote against these corrupt leaders 👍
@@kellyspano1573 Shalom @kellyspano1573. There are a lot of us. Especially at the protests. thank you
Fake news spread by Netanyahu's Zionists.
No thumbs down. Fair and balanced.
😢
Huge sympathy for these 2 parents, their son, and for the thousands of illegally imprisoned Palestinians in Israeli jails.
I would have to tell my son to pray to Jesus
Tell these parents to go sue this Oct 6 exhibit and tell them to bring our Americans home. America will support you
It's hard to believe just how much the enemy can and will take us by surprise. Coming prepared is different. We survive is what we want.