Who Should We Blame?
2024 ж. 9 Мам.
39 081 Рет қаралды
Gary Answers 5 of Sims Questions about the Media & Politics
UNDERSTAND, SHARE & PUSH BACK
WEBSITE - www.garyseconomics.org
TWITTER - / garyseconomics
FACEBOOK - / garyseconomics
INSTAGRAM - / garyseconomics
TIKTOK - / garyseconomics
KZhead - / garyseconomics
PATREON - / garyseconomics
DISCORD - / discord
SUBSCRIBE, SHARE & START A CONVERSATION
Performed by Gary Stevenson
@garyseconomics
Produced by Simran Mohan
@mohanmedia
You deserve millions of subscribers. Keep spreading the message, and thank you for your integrity.
What we need to do is rise and make a more equal society
Never going to happen mate, we're a nation of brainwashed subservients. Would love to be proved wrong and play a part tho.
For some sense of ‘rise’, some sense of ‘we’ [and some sense of ‘against them’], this is obvious, and has been obvious for centuries. The middle and poorer classes, presenting credible political demands against the billionaires is imo the first step. Escalating as necessary. Look to the chartists. Tax Wealth Now.
Like Wat Tyler's crowd in 1381? He was executed along with many of the crowd. Like the Levellers? They were _thoroughly_ trounced by _both_ other sides in the Civil Wars. Like _'Insulate Britain'?_ You saw what happened to them. And there's _hundreds_ of other examples - rise up, get stamped on - & nowadays the media gets us to stamp on ourselves!
Another issue with this rise and make a difference is how vague this statement really is. Who is we ? What does rise mean - ie, what is the vehicle of the political movement. How do we create a political movement which is effective, enact change which is protected. How do we really enact change without division within our own class systems.
How?
Good video. Keep fighting Gary. Do a video on how the super rich use their money to make more money and how this affects the ordinary people. The average factory worker has not got a clue.
You're right of course, we need to start by financial and economic education in schools, which currently doesn't exist
i think henry ford one quoted, if the ordinary person did understand the banking and monetary system there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning.
I'm 43 and I've been active since I was a teenager and my main thing was always finding an answer to "how do we get the majority of people to see the better world we see is possible?". I took a career in digital marketing and media because of that. I want to help, let's chat. The next step is crafting a solid narrative to bring groups together. I agree with your points 100%, and your channel is finally giving me some hope!
Digital designer of 11 years and former publisher, used to push ads for conservative news media, now in media and publishing. If you need support in this mission I'd like to atone
Working class hero, sadly we haven’t got enough people like you Gary.
So your saying its good to screw and abuse minorities.
Thank you Gary. This desperate situaion is preserved and worsened by the systematiic devaluation of life. We are all complicit in accepting the judgment that vast numbers of people in society are worthless and disposable. Morality extends to keeping people alive at a subsistence level and forcing them to compete for scarce jobs and resources, and failing to value the important stuff that people actually do, and the stuff that they would do if they were resourced to do it. Meanwhile the very rich are self serving on an unimaginably grand scale that warps their experieence of being human to such an extennt that they embrace everything that is systemic and technological whilst rejecting any notion of common humanity, shared experiences, pooling of resources and solving problems together as a society of sentient intelligent beings. A world ruled by elites who meet in boardrooms is a world of stunted growth and disease. This is not good for anyone.
Hi Gary, when you made your appearance on the BBC one of the talking heads said something along the lines of ‘a wealth tax has been tried in many countries and it never works’, I’d love to hear you address that argument, about why you think a wealth tax will work, what it might look like roughly and also why it hasn’t worked in other countries, if that is the case. Thanks! Love your channel ❤
I second this. I'd like to see a kind of 'what we want' video. Presuming the answer to that question is a wealth tax, maybe an outline of possibilities while addressing these kinds of common counter arguments.
Land tax works if implemented in the respect of unable to avoid it.
Do you think Starmer will form alliances between working and middle classes!?
This is a great suggestion. I really like a well thought out analysis of why and how this could work with potential problems and examples from overseas if they exist.
That argument is always used. But the last time anything like this was tried was the 60-70s and many fortunes greatly diminished & estates were sold. Which is exactly what we want. The rich to get poorer & ever one else to get better off. But even this comment length is longer than people looking into the actual consequences of how it was last tried. So people shrug say.. "oh your right!" And we dismiss the measure which is what they want.
When you see a complete media plurality like we did with Corbyn it should be a signal to you he's the right person to shake things up. I won't be excited about another polition in this country until I see the media go into full unhinged, lunatic mode again. That's the sign change could come. Respect from one Gary to another. We're a dying breed we gotta look out for each other.
The Corbyn era failed. So why hold that up as a good example? He wasn't the right person, he didn't shake anything up beyond the commentary. Nothing changed, things got worse. This failure wasn't down to the opposition from the super wealthy, establishment, corporations or media. It was from their failure to have an effective strategy to deal with that opposition and a plan to appeal to an electorate that could put them in government.
They did the same with Farage.
@@DeathWozza What lies?
@@dtz1000 I'm no brexiteer, but the only way brexit could work for the normal people would be for the rich to get MUCH poorer - that wasn't proposed by anyone in the media (apart from maybe Mick Lynch). Brexit was going to make Britain have less stuff overall, so only redistribution could do anything other than make the poor poorer.
@@markysgeeklab8783 Never heard immigrants referred to as "stuff" before. We would have had less "stuff" if Farage was PM but he only had half the answer. We also needed the super rich to be taxed properly but he wasn't the man to do that.
The community need guidance on how to do what you're saying. Not rushed, well thought out and presented with a call to action. Here's one thing you can do today. Here's the one thing you can do this time to help. Slowly those weekly calls will make a difference and if you can plan them well enough you'll already know what doing them will result in.
I've been thinking about how civil disobedience can reach critical mass before things get out of hand. I think strikes will increase in frequency once things get worse, but would be better if we organize now, because there will also be a lot more violence and divisions when things are worse. Global and united strikes are the only way to get the rich to budge.
Yep totally agree Jon. Apart from I know what to do and I’ve inadvertently got myself trapped in the capitalist Hamster 🐹 wheel. People like my Teacher neighbour who would love to change society are too tired and busy to react….. This is a big problem. People feel defeated. Not only do we need to educate people. We need solidarity / mutual aid movements that can bring the tired masses along with us.
@@Syphil23 I think starting weekly discussion groups would be a great way to an easy start, just to get everyone on the same page and build a sense of solidarity, which will go a long way to fight the sense of powerlessness and disenfranchisement.
@@aumioishaat8167 I wish you luck. Where is _your_ weekly discussion group? How many people attend? How many attend more than once?
@@Syphil23 Same here Phil, I think more financial education at a young age is a good start to capturing people and making them think whilst they have the energy. The majority of society are just earning a wage, spending most of their income and time on living so I'm looking to someone like Gary and hopefully other groups to head something that means people in that position can understand and contribute with the small amount of spare time resource they have so the message in numbers gets out there.
Hello Gary Your podcast is very much appreciated by us. Information you present to us should really known by a wider number of people. I think the intension is too keep the masses at a arms length.
You should be able to see it for yourself, it's blindingly obvious how the corporate n right wing media redirect anger away from the guilty towards the symptoms and create phantom enemies like " the wokeraty" and climate activists etc.
Gary, how do we go from words to action? We’ve got the message, but no political party is taxing the wealthy. How do we get this message onto any parties agenda?
Support community efforts for self sufficiency. Food, water, energy and accomodation resources are overwhelmingly owned and supplied by the super wealthy. To stop the transition of wealth further, focus on protecting providing for ourselves
@@TomNook. like cooperatives?
Yes, exactly that, but that is not enough on its own
The big political parties are owned by the "few", the new "international oligarchy" who are richer than nation states have too much power and influence. We cannot (in the short term) change this system and so we need to build our own alternatives, as a means of survival, as an example to others and to create a groundswell of ideas which will, eventually, result in the changes we all need. See also Tom Nook comment.
@@englishsteve1465 you can't just change this by acting individually or locally. Need to act nationally. Ie don't vote tory. Vote for whoever will get them out in your constituency. Also join a party to press for action. Also join union. Also join co-ops. Etc. Both and. If people try and knit their own alternative and ignore national and local politics then sheisters will get in again and things will get worse. Edit. On the other hand I agree in building the world we want through coops and cooperation and exert power rather than asking those already in power to change.
Unfortunately Gary the middle and working classes in this country have been set against each other since before the Chartists. That said, I can’t think of another time when the masses interests have been so aligned. The recent redistribution of wealth from the bottom up has dragged a usually protected middle class into the fight and things cannot carry on as they are. As you’ve said our economic cliff is fast approaching and we have to come together to fight it. Solidarity.
I monitor KZhead comments on the news channels [Im an author its a form of research] the divide tactics are no longer working. Yesterday the Govt announced a crackdown on transgender toilets - I read 100 comments, almost no one was buying it. Everyone knew it was another distraction from the f-uk up the govt has made of the country. " I can’t think of another time when the masses interests have been so aligned". from the govts perspective, they are becoming dangerously aligned.
Great video Gary. As someone who’s coming to the end of my working life after 45 years of work all I can say is that I have watched people’s terms and conditions go in a steady downward spiral. I fear for my two sons and how their lives will be. The big question is how do we reach the millions who are either already too brainwashed or have simply given up? I myself feel helpless and hopeless. The twin threats of climate catastrophe and economic collapse worry the life out of me and all I see is the car accelerating towards the cliff. I admire and applaud your efforts but how do we become an effective movement? It seems to me that there are so many different movements who all share a similar goal (XR, Diem 25, Green Party, WWF, Greenpeace, Naomi Klein, any Charity you can think of) but they’re all divided and battling individually. Why not a unified organisation bringing them all together to fight for a common cause with agreed common goals? Thank you if you read this. Solidarity brother.
I feel pretty much the same.
@@sososoprano1 Thanks for saying that, I am glad I’m not alone in that sense. X
I am also a baby boomer who has recently retired. I think it is important to note that not all baby boomers are selfish and greedy. Since 1994 I have lived a life of voluntary simplicity. I try not to take more than I need and live lightly on the planet.
@@carolyngartner6865 - I think there are more of us like that than younger people acknowledge. After all, when we were young many of us were trying to build alternatives, with our worker co-operatives, including radical bookshops and magazines etc. We were the age of Schumacher’s Small is Beautiful. We failed to expand the bubble sufficiently, but at least we tried and still do. I wish we were given credit for that rather than being despised.
I' be more worried about the "Economic collapse" than a climate catastrophe myself - the latter is a farce. And you've clearly fallen for the brainwashing!
Since I have been watching channels like Gary's, Novara Media (as you mentioned!) And also a channel called Politics Joe, I have found it's a much better group of outlets to watch the media. Just as Gary said, the mainstream media appears to make a lot of people stressed out. Thank you Gary and everyone who helps you and supports your channel. The mainstream media has us all at each other's throats. P.s. there is a great channel called SirSwag that is a worldwide news outlet but with much less content than all the others.
Like you I seek out news and political commentary channels I like Politics Joe and would add Double Down news (Novara's a Marxist talking shop so am less keen on them). I also try to seek out channels that don't align with my core beliefs (i.e. conservative ones). It's tiring but you can get some understanding of where there is commonality. The sad truth is that nothing can change without political power, there is no glorious revolution coming in the UK. To get elected in Britain is difficult and expensive. A successful centre/left party will rely on the votes of people that don't particularly agree, like or trust each other to get into government.
I would definitely buy this man a pint 👍
I *LOVE* a good rant and this is massively reasonable, right and fair. We should be angry, we *MUST* be angry. Long may your videos have plenty of bleeps
Think you missed the point of the video. Dont be angry, it doesn't help. Its dangerous.
We must unite! Amazing content as usual Gary 👍👍👍
I would like you to do a model like the Novara Media lives, talk specifically about news articles you disagree with and argue your point. You are amazing Gary and have opened my eyes, I’m always spreading your message xx 😁
It’s very bad, few people under 40 now even remember what a decent U.K. looks like. We took back the country in a not well publicised bloodless coup after ww2. About 2 million working class trained killers came home from defeating the Wehrmacht & demanded a "country fit for hero’s" it had been talked about in the dark days. When all the working class could do was sacrifice on every front. So they asked - for what?! - and we’re promised a lot. We decided in a rare beautiful moment to hold them to it. They were terrified the country would be taken from them in a day if we wanted too. So they gave. Then people started reading things like ‘The ragged trousered philanthropists’ and we also got a beautiful labour government ( a real one not Starmer ) And the funny thing was, this way of raising up the bottom to almost the lower middle actually economically worked better than anything the short term upper class had done. Everyone had some money. Hobbies, clubs, holidays, new furniture, cars. It was a consumer boom. It lead to the country booming. Lots of middle class and new rich were created. Social mobility was becoming possible. We need to tell the story that not only is the economic theory of the last 40 years bad. It’s idiotic & leads to the eventual demise of the country. We need to tell the story I just told. But better, more interesting and well written. So that people will understand, the only ones who ever have something to lose, from a country that treats us all well,from the working class to the upper middle class - is the very rich! Gary is right. We must not hate someone who is 3 times better off or they despise the poor who is 5 times worse off. No! If we only understood and shifted our gaze to the small groups who are 50,000 times better off and more! Well we would have a vast number of allies and with the middle class so comes the people in general with the ability to write well & talk well & the idea that people want to listen to them. - which lets be honest, we working class never believe of ourselves… All revolutions have succeeded when the middle leads the workers against those with everything. Ours can too. The problem is the media! But I just turned 50 I have to hope that more & more people my age and under are not caring about that stuff and trying to find their own news. Because if they don’t know how it’s wrong. They feel it!. Sorry for the long winded comment haha. 🙏🏻 thanks for reading anyone who did.
Thank you for sharing. Just the knowledge that it has been done before is emboldening. Here in the States, the poor are so overworked, tired and without healthcare.... It's very intimidating to even consider striking or figuring for change. The perfect arrangement for the ultra rich.
I’d love to see more deep-dive videos on HOW to tax the rich in this current system. Or theoretic ways we could in future. Like Gary interviewing a specialist on AI… is it possible to use AI to make tax avoidance and loop holes with stamp duty etc impossible? Or a system with much more extreme devolution (enabled by tech)… would taxing the Rich then become more realistic? My brain wants to start building up a positive vision of how experts could make this happen.
Yes G! Keeping things personal and human! I really liked this one -the sentiments involved and the empowerment. Grassroots!
Hi Gary, I do admire your courage and determination in trying to address these realities. Each of us has two parallel lives, the life we do have and the life we think we have, they are never quite the same all of us suffer from a range of perceptual distortions. We are also severely handicapped by our own emotions, the way we attach our feelings to people and events around us is instinctive and unavoidable, some of us find we can manage to separate ourselves from the delusions of cause and effect, in simple terms being able to understand that feelings provoke awareness and memories provoke feelings, this is a normal biological activity the errors creep in when people start to believe that it is the events and other people that 'cause' the feelings. This sadly leads people down an endless rabbit hole where evidence can be imagined and confirmation found in every crevice, what cannot be found is any direct mechanical connection that is what we normally associate with cause and effect, the most important point being that in actual reality the effect always follows the cause, the mechanisms are consistent and predictable, it is the failure of our feelings to be fully consistent that breaks that chain of logic. This all plays into your main topic which is the ways in which the ideas and concepts that so many people hold dear as 'truth' and certainty are driven by feelings and cannot engage in the style of critical thinking that you recommend. One of the fundamental things that so many people do not understand is that there are many differing styles of regulation, one is directed at punishing offenders one other concentrates more on statutory instruments that make it much harder for people to do things badly. My favourite example of this in action was the type of regulation that the airline industry had to comply with that prevented errors and deaths, that created a level playing field of compliance that made it possible for the cleverest and hardest working in the industry to succeed and lead to the most profitable industry ever created. This system of course is of no use to the get rich quick opportunists that currently rule the roost and one only has to look at what is happening to Boeing now r=to see where that goes. Cheers, Richard.
The anger direction is so spot on Gary. If I may the book Angrynomics - has a great distillation of the macro forces leading up to the election of Trump and Brexit. Worth a read/listen
Agreed its a fabulous book except for one thing. They both agreed that we can't tax the rich, which I think its absurd. I'd really like to get Mark and Eric in an interview and get down to the nitty gritty of "WHY NOT?"
@@tonywilson4713 Eric is a hedge fund manager, and Mark is one of those, great at description, cautious at prescription type.
@@Account.for.Comment Yeah I know both their backgrounds. I loved the book and the talks they gave. I just found their attitude to taxing rich people to be poorly explained. Do I think taxing the rich will be easy? Hell no. They're fundamentally selfish and will fight back, but to just say its too hard to try is kind of poor. There's a report from the American Congressional budget office on family wealth from 1989 to 2019. When you compare the data from 2007 to 2010 you get the effect of the GFC. When you check the data from 2019 back to 2007 you get the recovery. If you want I'll explain the details. In a nutshell - the people who caused the GFC got hit but they got bailed out and have since made OVER $30 Trillion. Meanwhile the people who DID NOT cause the GFC and got smashed harder than anyone else STILL HAVE NOT YET RECOVERED. The Bottom 50% (165 million people) got smashed and have less combined wealth than they did in 2007 with a combined wealth of $2.3 trillion (2019) compared to the 33 million with a combined wealth of over $90 Trillion (2022 estimate) and smart people like Eric and Mark are saying they can't be taxed more. *THAT'S BULLSHlT*
This is so important. Thank you for your great work, Gary! I was wondering something. I' Swedish, and in the news the other day I read that the Swedish opposition leader, Magdalena Andersson, said the inflation was because of Putin's war, oil prices, and all that. It made me wonder: why is she deliberately obtuse about the real reasons for the inflation crisis? She was prime minister after all when the country increased its money supply with, as I've read, 30 % in two years during covid. The fiscal decisions during covid were made in broad political agreement, and similarly throughout the western countries. In short, it shouldn't be political tabu to talk about the actual reasons for the inflation crisis, but it seems it is, and across the political spectrum as well. I guess my question really boils down to: why are politicians trying so hard to make people not understand why the inflation crisis is happening? What are they gaining from blaming it all on the war in Ukraine?
I hear what you are saying and you certainly have a point. One thing I have seen though is when people get some assets or money behind them they change. I've seen people go from kind and pretty reasonable to be penny pinching snobs. Maybe it's part of humanity to look down on others and enjoy doing it. We're all in this together.
I am not condoning it, but I think it's down to the insecurities he was talking about. You suddenly have some but you can see how easy it is to lose it all, and boy you dread going back to the struggles. Such insecurities will do amazing funk to the mind.
@@videomakville good point.
Jealousy is a powerful motivator and we've been trained to think someone getting something easier than we personally got it somehow makes it that person's fault. So people who've struggled and struggled and "made it" then turn around and say "if I had to struggle like that, then you must too", rather than "Jesus, that should not have been that hard. What can we do to make that better?"
@@jezlawrence720 If only! A lot unfortunately pull up the ladder behind them.
@@kimeccleston5586 that's pretty much driven by the same messaging and conditioning. "People should suffer like I had to" is one short step away from "how dare they ask for more, punish them"
Gary… you said you’d answer questions, but I’d also welcome being pointed towards a resource of that saves time! 1) In descriptions of the asset economy, you mention we don’t tax wealth properly. But don’t you have to pay tax on all rental income? Or is it the Increases in value you referred to? 2) For us environmentalists, who see a conflict between incite growth and a finite planet… Why is growth necessary? The answer is always “recession” but that’s just another term to define stunted growth. Why does unemployment and poverty result from a failure to increase output versus the previous year/quarter. Why is maintenance not okay? What are the mechanics?
Well done Gary. Another thing to campaign for is financial education in schools, kids don't even know what a mortgage is, or how currencies work, let alone how govenments and central banks operate. You've only just get to watch any quiz when politics or economics come up, and there's an almighty groan!
I found the part about the disastrous economic consequences of our current direction tied to the importance of unity between everyone, getting the rich on board too, to be incredibly powerful! This may be titled Media Manipulation, but it touched on what the aim is and the motivation for why, and the how of unity, it definitely helped me to join some dots in my mind, thank you!
Another fantastically done video, Gary! Thanks for this - it’s really helping those of us with no further education to better understand the issue. Could you do a video on the types of redistributive policies that could actually work to address these issues in the long-term? Also, using historic taxation (such as the 91% top-level in the USA back in the 60s) might help people to understand that there is clear precedent for this and that it works.
Yep the book Utopie for Realists is good at historical examples like this.
This is the crux of it Gary. Uniting the middle class and the regular Joes and Josepines is a massive problem, especially in such a divided and individualised society. I watch the news with the sound turned down most of the time.
The media tells the very poor to hate the middle class (otherwise known as people with just enough to be comfortable). It tells the working class to blame the poor for being lazy. It's lucky for the ppl who are actually to blame that we are all so stupid, otherwise we would blame the people who have 100 million+ rather than each other.
My main source of news is Private Eye. It's about the only printed media worth buying these days.
How wonderful that such decent people like you and your mother live in this world. It gives me such hope for the future.
If we could just have you on the msm for 10 minutes a week in a primetime slot, that would help so much! But of course, they're not about to allow that, are they?
I saw a lot of unity breakdown during the 80s when those who bought their council places started to think they were better than the council Tennant. Now they were torry voters , voting against them (Me) . You even to this day have separate council meeting one specially for the freehold to meet their wants and one for us that ignores our needs..Its the I am better than you syndrome and believe me I've tried to explained that they are really not. It never works..I just wanna bring some joy to this "Town Called Malice".. Great stuff Gary as usual. Mo..On lovely sunny morning in Olde London Tarn.😃
It surprises me that people don’t really look at what is happening and take what they see at face value and don’t question it. I was told at school to look at the intention behind the intention. It took a long time for me to understand it. Thank you for your channel.
Great video. Thanks, more cross channel pollination is needed of your message. We appreciate your work 👍
Thanks, Gary - my Econ teacher always said you can read the state of the economy and the confidence in it, by the width of men's suit lapels and the expenditure on porn - if these increase, then a crash in on the way - not sure how this fits in with the current geopolitical headwinds - also, Rockerfeller in 1929 knew the stock market crash was imminent when his shoeshine boys outside Grand Central Station were discussing stocks and shares so he was aware of the over-speculation.
I live in the Southampton area (UK) and we're tripping over homeless people here, old, young, some women, mostly white, but a lot of immigrants who the state have abandoned. I've been told I'm an 'insanely talented writer' but my immediate and ongoing challenge is to keep a roof over my head. I won't be homeless again, it's too f*cking scary and there's no help out there. I'll take other measures. Talking of being called an 'insanely talented writer' (it takes humans decades to learn it in whatever genre/subgenre), content and art driven by AI is going to smash through our societies like a freight train at top speed. People have NO IDEA what's coming or how AI is gonna take away their jobs. I know, I'm an Internet technology graduate. I'm not worried because I know how to use AI tools and I can focus on my subgenres which AI can't write yet, so people ahead of the curve and early adopters have one or two years before it catches up, but the overall effect on society is going to be seismic. The problem is that sites like book-upload sites (for self-publishing) are going to be flooded by regurgitated cr*p AI content and readers/customers are going to be swamped for a while, making it harder for us original concept & genre publishers to get seen. My question is, how will the servers cope? Are the big sites going to provide unlimited server space forever?
I’m really worried about AI. My son had just finished a PhD in particle physics and I think his future is very precarious. He had wanted to stay in academia, and that would have suited him, but it has become toxic. I really don’t know what’s going to become of him.
@@sososoprano1 He'll be more than fine.
@@TomNook. - oh I hope so. Must confess I do tend to catastrophise, but for so many the future looks pretty bleak.
Imagine, plan, and finally … act ? I’m a huge fan of Gary’s channel. I particularly like the way that he remains above party politics. By keeping it cleanly about economics, it makes the problem we face much simpler. It is not about taking those traditional sides; of Left party vs. Right party. It is about redesigning a system so that it is fairer and works for, if not absolutely all of us, then at the very least, for the greatest number of us (let’s be realistic). Democracy is in crisis because both Labour and Conservative politicians, far from keeping an effective oppositional ‘check’ on each other, nowadays tend to act in cahoots with each other, both puppets of the billionaire establishment. Yes, they say different things, but if you pay attention to their behaviour then you can see they act the same, delivering the same results, thus removing that critical check so crucial to a progressive democracy. And let’s be clear, the puppet strings all lead to the hands of the billionaires. So we have a sham parliament, full of archaic ceremony, simply going through the motions. Meanwhile, 99% of us get poorer - and 1% get richer. Nice. It’s not just Democracy that is in trouble. The model of Capitalism we have been using for the last 50 years (market capitalism) is also unraveling. It needs urgent reform because it fails to fund the crucial social/health/education ‘safety net’ from which we all emerge every day, to go about our lives, whether we are schoolchildren, working adults or retired pensioners. Gary asked us to leave comments to share ideas about how we can bring about the socioeconomic change that is so desperately needed for our country. The clock is ticking. So here are some thoughts to get discussion going: I’m going to use a learning technique borrowed from the world of counselling to get the ball rolling … so bear with me, as this may sound a bit zen and ‘out there’, but it is a very useful imagination exercise!! So, imagine we could wave a magic wand and make the billionaire elite and all of their corrupt agents (who currently hold the levers of power - the military, the media, the security services, the police and the judiciary) to magically disappear? Just imagine we can magically disappear them all to a limbo-like place, a bit like a ‘green room’ - or into a suspended state, a bit like pressing a pause button on a TV remote? Just imagine that for a second… How would that be? Might it feel a lot better? Probably, for a while. And would that solve all of our problems? Probably not. It would solve them partly. Life would certainly feel less hopeless and more optimistic for most of us. But pretty quickly we would need a new team of people, to run everything more fairly, as a nation. Ordinary people, like you and me, randomly selected like a jury perhaps, every few years, working in a non-corruptible infrastructure, with non-corruptible levers of power. We could pay these people well for their work in office so they never feel the need to defraud the system with huge expenses, or bribery. And it would be more representative, unlike what we have now. The magic wand exercise is helpful here because it shows us that, however attractive it might be to metaphorically ‘cut off the snake’s head’ (some might even think it an intelligent chess move), it isn’t the whole chess match. That ‘win’ - of a fully functioning, truly egalitarian society, needs careful planning too. And, in the absence of a real technological solution even slightly resembling a magic pause button, what process could reasonably and humanely be deployed to redistribute the wealth from these former billionaires and ‘rehabilitate’ them back into society again, as ordinary people? Again, ordinary people - just like the rest of us, who must pay tax, with a wealth ceiling in place that is still generous - but that is the same wealth ceiling attainable by us all, should we want it, in a fairer UK. I’m not a believer in violence or violent political change, so maybe we could develop a process of wealth redistribution that is fair and reasonable. Sure, it will hurt their wallets, but then I would argue you can’t truly own what was never yours to take in the first place. So, what about giving the billionaires this option: 1. Give them the opportunity to spend it all within a set time limit (not on assets) so that the wealth flows back into society and government. Something I know Gary has mentioned before and won’t take 10-20 years to achieve, so all generations benefit pretty quickly. 2. Or … if they refuse this, have all wealth (the actual amount to be determined) confiscated as ill gotten (let’s face it, it was accumulated in a so-called ‘legitimate’ environment with laws made by them, for them - it wasn’t fairly earned by an honest exchange of labour for pay, like the taxable salary of a teacher or nurse (and to be really clear here, like that of a higher earning, higher taxpaying GP, HR Director, IT Consultant, Master Builder or Chartered Accountant)). Unlike the earnings of all these hardworking taxpayers, it was gained through unfair privilege, with little to no taxation levied upon it. 3. Finally, enrol them into a compulsory rehabilitation programme, whereby they have to do work in the community, for the community, e.g. work in hospitals, railways, schools, youth centres, charities, road maintenance, waste, housing, care homes, social work, construction, catering, etc. This work should be aimed at dismantling all the self-serving practices they have previously built as billionaires, and also at creating programmes that help the people of the UK more fairly. I know this all might sound harsh and maybe even punitive to some. Others might not think it harsh enough. I am not up for harming human beings, or discriminating against a certain group - but I think it is ok to prescribe a healthy dose of teaching on this occasion - to educate these people that they are part of society, not above it. There is one more thing that needs to be addressed here. These people didn’t just end up rich for no reason: they are extremely driven and power hungry because they have deeply negative emotional issues. I am going to be ‘therapy joe’ here one more time … but, stick with me. This internal state makes them outwardly seek perfection and superiority. It’s not good for them but, more importantly, it’s really not good for us. In the most extreme cases you get narcissism and sociopathy. Many people in high office, for both public or private sectors, are closet sociopaths or narcissists. They are masters of manipulation and drama. So, whoever deploys the wealth distribution process needs to be aware of this. Therapy usually doesn’t work with these types, because they often don’t recognise or own that they are dysfunctional. So we cannot truly ‘fix’ these people, but we can teach them how to rehabilitate; for our sake, not theirs. Anyway, these are some ideas, to spark discussion. Perhaps someone else can comment on what I’ve said and take this further? How could we bring about the deployment of such a plan? It is challenging but I am optimistic that there is a way. We have so many lessons from history to draw upon which means that we really can develop impressive systems and infrastructure, with non-corruption measures built in. History also shows that the promised land is built on shifting sands and nothing will ever be perfect. But let’s face it, anything is better than what we’ve got now! Is all this too naive? A pipe dream? I hope not. I just think if we can be more honest about our species’ propensity for selfishness and look it squarely in the face, then we stand a good chance of bringing about a better country for us all, whatever our politics.
Thanks Gary for another really powerful message. Is there any chance you could extend your advice to political leaders in South Africa?
Thank you, a Brilliant summary of where we are. I have a concern. KZhead is owned by the people we need to Tax. How can we make sure your voice continues to grow when they must be working against us? E.g. shadowbans on the platform etc?? It would be great to have other media routes as successful as KZhead 👍👍💪💪
Thank you. Your videos stand out with their outstanding analysis and insightful perspectives. Your ability to engage and educate your viewers is truly remarkable.
great and useful sentiment as always Gary! I think a video giving more detailed breakdown on how to reshape the economy according to different models and political ideologies would be good, maybe even if you invited someone on like maybe Aarron Bastani to discuss. Brand used to talk about anarcho-syndicalism quite a lot, one idea within that was an interesting way of restructuring how much workers within a company were paid. where by wages actually get less as you climb the ranks of the company and shares increase so the person at the top is paid nothing and only owns the most shares....
Hi Gary, can you do a video one day explaining how the government is able to spend so much money on military defence - where does this money come from? How does it impact on us and our economy? And how is it possible to maintain & increase this funding even through out all the economic we have been through in the last few decades? Thanks Rx
I really like this subject as a message and often see in fighting. There are those who will discuss their opinion and as a result understand each other and then there's those who out right reject the other opinion which is not a good thing but I hope that others reading the conversation will perhaps learn and that can't be a bad thing.
Billionaires are addicted to wealth accumulation whether they are drug barons or media Barons. The difference is that drug Barons have hundreds of gunmen to threaten their rivals and subjugate people who might want to oppose them. Oil Barons,Arms dealers or mining Companies can send armies to back up their interests. Gary is sending a powerful message out, he’s affectingly saying if we build a mass movement while we still have a democratic process in place then we can reign in the madness of profit before people and exploitation. He’s extremely intelligent he knows this can’t be done unless the working class and middle class wake up which hopefully includes very rich people who can see how this system is going to kill us all in the end .
Gary, when are you going to run for political office. I’m Canadian and we have the exact same problem the UK has…stupid politicians who are disconnected from the reality of the middle and poor class. Love your videos. Thank you for sharing your intelligence.
It's about loving yourself, not hating others 💗🌠 ... then you will be FREE
What about the bills
Thanks for this, Gary. This is your best vid yet. Your mention of the 2 Minutes Hate was brilliant, and how easy it is to shift society's focus of hatred. Also, I think you're right about the direction that our society's going in, but I don't share your optimism on how we can stop it. You just have to listen to the average guy in the street to realise he's been hooked by the mainstream media. I've heard it and it's very depressing. But thanks for your incisive insights. You and others like you rip away the veil of disinformation, the lies of omission that the mainstream media puts out there. They are a fear machine to keep us divided and subdued. I do hope we can build the alliance we need, but I'm not optimistic. Thanks very much and keep going 👍
Brilliantly informative advice Gary . Rapper Tom mc donald makes all these points without bad language .. great info Gary
'We need create an alliance between the poor and middle class to take on the very rich who are taking everything', spot on. Unfortunately the mainstream political parties including Labour and Conservatives will do nothing to redress that balance. We need something new which is neither left/right but stands up for average Joe against the Corporate interests. That'll be a painful transition because the markets will do everything possible to stop that happening.
The middle class work hard, many of the poor don’t work at all, which makes an alliance unlikely.
@@AJ-hi9fd What really prevents an alliance is the middle class accusing the poor of being lazy...
@@AJ-hi9fd showing your ignorance there mate.
Big respect what an inspiration
I really appreciate your message and your work - thank you for giving me a message and ideas I can get behind. Bleak though it is, it is the first hope I have felt in a long time.
Brilliantly explained Gary.Nice to see someone who actually understands what is going on
Thank you so much for your videos. I like the information and the way that you delivered it. Keep be a giving person. :)
Fantastic Work Gary ❤❤❤
You’re spot on !
Another great video Gary. Will be sharing this around 😎👌🏻
Serious question: all money channels on here and tiktok (and google to a certain degree) say that you cant retire on a pension alone. And there's no guarantee that your pension will even be there when you need it. So a lot of "successful" people say "invest in property". Now, your channel makes the same point (but from the otherside). But you both basically say "there's a lot of money in property investing". So my question (sorry for the long comment) is: if pensions won't look after us when we want to retire and property isn't possible or the most ethical way to build wealth. How, in the current system can someone retire comfortably please? What does an average person do to ensure they can stop working at some point? Thank you for reading. And for the great videos 🙏
The psychology of the problem is fascinating as no one looks at the psychological side of things when in fact everything we humans do comes down to psychology… understanding the dark triad of human psychology is a must for anyone who wants to understand politics, the accumulation of wealth and why the world is like it is …
BANG ON , root of the problem .... they rely on differences never being put aside
Thats what I try to do, get a better understanding whats going on.
One of the most important videos you've ever made. Those who are undecided need to seexthis because your right, we will need them onside.
Rates of taxation, income tax bands, VAT, CGT, evasion/avoidance etc. - how the media and even politicians oversimplify tax discourse by not talking about which taxes effect who most
America was looking at a basic 15 percent for everyone and stopping expenses
@@paulmessenger9836 doubt it
Thank you!!!
Loving what you are trying to do... if you want to see something outrageous have a look into price water house cooper getting paid both ways in Australia... selling the gov a consultancy service to re jig the tax system then at the same time selling their clients the inside run on how to avoid the new taxes.. what gets me down is we still think the playing field is fair rather than being two moves away from the end of monopoly game and vacuuming up what’s left
Respect bro. . Very well done
Gary, I really like your channel and I think it adds some good context to what is happening. when you talk about bring people together to make this change, this is issue that is not addressed, noting the traditional route of voting your local politicians and changing parties currently will not work as the vast majority of the politicians are in the rich and wealthy bracket and do not want the change that you identify is required (hence the campaing to redirect the anger). The biggest thing I think your channel can do is identify how we can make this change when the current system will not work. there are others in the comments saying this /offering help.
Love your channel and really hope it gets big so we can actually change the status quo! All I want to do is get a property but that’s not possible with how expensive it is! 31 yo and still having to live with parents because how expensive rent prices are! How can we change this?! I feel hopeless and trapped
Well said.
F*cking brilliant video. Beep-o-meter when off the scale :) Thanks for all you do. What trading platform do you use? (asking for a friend)
Hi Gary. Could you do cover and explain the how our economy has been more rentier and who benefit from a rent based economy. Also keep up the great work your doing.
Solutions! we want practical political and legal solutions...Gary is great at shining a spotlight on the inequalities but completely lacking in what needs to be done....first issue; how do we 'tax' wealth that is tied up in valuable assets and cash reserves? how do we go about liberating that resource and transferring that to the end of the economy that needs it the most?
The simplest thing we can all do is discuss the issues with friends and family. Discuss what you are learning from people like Gary and others. Discuss what it actually means when on the news they say things like Interest rates are rising. Discuss some of the causes of increased bills. Education is the best tool we all have. Even if you as an individual cant make much change if enough get educated we can make a positive difference. At the very least your friends will be a bit more clued up when they go to vote. When discussing these issues its not about you being 100% correct. I will normaly say somthing like "Yeah, bills have been rising, I have been trying to understand why that is. From what I have found so far it appears to be partly down to x,y & z." There have been many instances where my friend has also told me about somthing they have learnt. I have gone away and found they are correct and taught me somthing as well. So just discussing the issues arms us with more knowledge that we can use to make good choices that are within our controle, while also helping us understand things we have no control over.
Any good resources to learn more about wealth taxes/carbon tax etc? Whether books or articles/lectures would be greatly appreciated! Thanks again for the video, great message
I’d be interested to know what you would advise a young person - early 20’s - in employment, regarding the best life/financial strategy’s in todays economic climate. Thank you for the great work you are doing Gary.
Hi Gary, I really like the approach you take in this video: i.e. not about hate. The super rich have most of the main levers of power in their pocket: the lawmakers, the central government, the courts, the police, the military, the media, the energy grid, the transport providers, the major employers, etc. They did this to protect themselves as they have all the wealth and are scared of having it taken away. The clock is ticking and no generation wants to wait 20 years for reforms to eventually bring about the healthy balance we need for a better society in the UK. I think the idea you mentioned about giving them a deadline by which they MUST spend wealth (as opposed to taxes) is the quickest, easiest and fairest way to rectify the imbalance in our country. However, we must get all the best heads together to work out a plan on targeting the levers of power so that they are influenced and infiltrated with more representative members of society, because I think we will need their support, in order to achieve this goal of redressing the balance of wealth. I hope that a non-violent solution is possible. We need some incredibly brave people to start unifying and working on a plan of action, because the clock is ticking. Perhaps a general strike should be the non-violent starting point. Would they dare to make the people work at gunpoint? Probably!! But we need to be more like the French because protest works.
I watch Novara Media like you Gary. I come from a very poor background. I never made a lot of money as a builder, but have a share in a rental property which tops up my pension. I'm 69. Its sad to watch some on Novara bessmirch all landlords as the same. The contradictions of life make you have to do things which would not be your first choice in a better world. But I am a believer in unity of working people, so I will continue to watch and support them. Sometimes our social positions may be different, but hopefully we can come together over economic positions. If not, the elites have won by dividing us.
Thanks for all your amazing content, I have a question: - What are the implications of CBDC’s? Both positive and negative
Great video, great movement.
Thanks! ❤
I want to live in peace and security. I don’t want to be mega rich, I just want enough to pay the bills and have enough to save every month for my next ISA. I am reading your new book Gary THE TRADING GAME it’s brilliant 🤩 Well done and thank you for all you do. I watched a video last night Gerald Celente he is an American Trends Forecaster he says the World economies are going down.
Thank you once again for this, Gary. Please keep on saying it. The rich need to pay their taxes.
Thanks so much for all you're doing Gary. I'm getting a bit worried about how little value my pension will have when I actually get to retirement age due to the growing wealth inequality and devaluing of currency. Is it worth just opting out of the workplace pension to invest the money instead? Sorry for the repost of my same comment from your previous video.
Hi love the content. What taxes should be put in place. Higher income , with a lowering of the bracket say an 11% bracket like in france. Or a lowering of VAT? Or ofc as youve mentioned inheritance tax. Would love a quick covering of what we have now and how to fix. Thanks
Totally. You are a valuable asset for the global citizenry. As Fredr I ck Douglas said: "Power yields nothing without Demand." Regards, Viet vet/Ecologist VFP Great advicw about connecting in communiyy. I love the Grayzone and Revolutionary Black network. 👍 Rock On. And "Qui Bono?" It's not the individuals, it's the Transnational Architechture built on the organic shifts in the Great Acceleration, by the Plutocracy of Oligarchs & their 1% Clerisy (Politicals and Corp. Media). Techno Feudalism of [ "FIRE"& TELECOMS.]
Incredible content as always, thank you! I think I'm the precarious middle class you describe, even though I have no property! Quick question - can someone earn their way out of this? I'm currently aged 40, no assests, a bit of savings (£10-15k). I rent and can't afford a mortgage. I don't live in London! I earn £25k in the public sector but on a pathway which means next year it'll be £35k, 3 years later it'll be £45k, 5 years later £55-80k. If I go into the private sector, I would be earning £100k+. I'm not bragging or anything, because that's 10 years away, so what I'm wondering is; will my increased earnings across the next 10 years only help to maintain an equilibrium, or will I be able to 'out-earn' the economic decline, and actually get to own property and have something for my child? Thank you, Gary!
Gary, do you think you could put aome visuals together to illustrate how the path we're on economically matches the early 20th century? It might help people realise how were putting ourselves into the situation 1930s germany was put into. Or it might show its not much of a danger. I dont know and i wouldn't understand the data well enough to find out but i bet you would. Either way, some honest visuals might help. Im thinking about the one you did around how wealth & money circulates and accumulates - id heard you explain it a bunch but the visuals you did a few months back really helped consolidate my understanding.
The problem Gary with uniting the middle and working classes is generally their political and societal views can be vastly different. Remain vs Leave is just one example. Attitudes towards gender, sexuality, politics. Even their hobbies and interests can be quite different so it can often be difficult to identify with and find common ground between these two socials classes. That frustrates building political alliances with each other and ultimately that does play into the hands of the super rich.
Hi Gary, thank you for doing what you do. Excellent channel, excellent information. I think everyone should stop using credit cards where practical, everytime a credit card is used the credit card company gets a fee for the transaction. Wealth transfer from poor to rich. Use cash where practical and try to reduce expenditure with large blue chip companies.
Hi Gary - Thank you for perserving with enlightening others like me on the issues taking place. I had a question given the latest announcements by Jeremy Hunt on asking DC pensions to invest 5% of assets into start-ups? Organisations signing up using/risking the money of individuals at no risk to the Organisation/Government. - What are your thoughts on this and the document that suggests we 'WILL' all be richer (like its guaranteed).... I'm noting that DB pensions aren't to be included - those of MPs ... funny that...
Hi Gary, great video. I honestly truly admire you. I always worry with channels that create content like yours or London Real where they create content to help the masses, but then they rip their audience off in the future.
I can tell you now, there is a gaping chasm between Gary and that tool from London Real.
As Michael Moore reminds us in Capitalism: A Love Story, after WWII many people became rich and paid taxes of 90% but still they could 'live like Bogey and Bacall'. Those taxes were spent on vital infrastructure. We know what high taxation on the very wealthy can achieve, and yet our politicians are reluctant to implement the level of taxation on the very rich that applied between 1945 and 1979.
If Gary was standing as PM I would definitely vote for him
If someone was hypothetically 23 years old in London and wanted you to spend a few hours with them for solid mentoring advice without actually breaking the bank and just able to absorb what you do, what would usually be the outcome?
Totally agree with you Bought our property 23 years ago and i have to sell it now because i cannot maintain it or the upkeep of bills so i know the capatalist state is to blame
I saw Norman Lamont on a TV clip yesterday. Asking him for his pearls of wisdom. I thought oh dear God, him?!? He crashed with UK economy with Major in the early 1990's! Total cock-up.
Hello Gary! I've always wondered, if you start taxing the rich, how you stop them from offsetting that cost on the public by increasing the prices of products and property for example. Thank you so much for your work, it has been really eye opening!
And i wonder how you will stop tax evasion and tax avoidance!
You cant. The poor are stuffed regardless of what happens. Tax the rich and they will bleed the poor as hard as they can because they own all the credit and the assets.
Then ultimately they'll price themselves out of the market. If a competitor was to come in and undercut the profiteers in the shorter term, they might make more in the long. Then the producers would have to bring their prices down to compete. At least in theory! 😊
@@maxgee1691 What if they're a monopoly?
You can do all of this through regulation. These myths are often rolled out by the stenographers of the status quo along with other boogeyman ideas such as "the rich will all leave". None of it stands up to scrutiny. It will take time but people will start realising that they cannot eat myths.
Most of us are rats trapped in urinal fighting over the yellow detergent cake. Crumbs off the top table. The rich are taking everything and the poor will vote for fascism. I am very pessimistic about your very simple well explained ideas taking hold.
Totally agreed. The current government is killing the middle class, so we will end up with very small percentages of very rich corporation owners controlling the mass. We need a government working for middle class and balance the power of rich and poor.
We don't need to know who to blame - we need to know what we can do to prosper in any environment. That's just simple evolution principles. I'm not blaming in any way content or author - both are gorgeous and profound.
One thing I would love to know. Whenever i hear about people calling to tax the rich there's always the counter argument that those companies and individuals will simply go elsewhere, move their infrastructure and operate in other countries that won't tax so much. In fact many companies that are scooping up freeholds and other companies often are already based elsewhere. Do you not think that by taxing the rich more we would loose a lot of key players in the British economy, key players that would otherwise provide decent benefits and cash flow back to the middle and lowers classes. That's what I'm often told anyway.
Why do we keep getting told the tax take is at an historical high?