Why People Hated Windows 8
Play World of Warships here: wo.ws/3jsGOum
Thank you World of Warships for sponsoring this video.
During registration use the code FIRE to get for free:
-200 Doubloons
-1M Credits
-Tier 5 - USS Texas
-20x Restless Fire Camouflage
-7 Days Premium Account
The promo code is only for new players during the registration.
With its release in 2012, Microsoft's latest operating system, Windows 8, ended up becoming one of the most hated and controversial products that they had ever made, but why?
It wasn’t just a matter of some public opinion; the failure of Windows 8 was actually much worse than it looked. Strictly talking numbers, Windows 8 actually did worse than Windows Vista, despite even having the advantage of being released during the holiday season.
Now with several more versions of windows succeeding it, it’s almost as if Windows 8 has become one of those products that Microsoft just doesn’t want you to remember. I mean, its support was cut very short compared to other Windows versions. Windows 8 never happened. But now that this once ambitiously marketed OS has since been kept in the past, it is much easier to look back and see where things went wrong, and doing that involves answering this question: Was Windows 8 really that bad, or was it just another victim of its time? Were these radical changes to the Windows experience justified in any way?
What’s particularly interesting about the story behind Windows 8’s failure is that it oddly reflects the factors which killed Windows Vista. These include the big design changes that Microsoft implemented, the popularity of Windows 7, objectives being focused on the wrong industries and demographics, forced implementation of apps, and lastly, simply the long-term damage of the bad press.
Giving Windows a “new look” was clearly not the right call. It’s easy to say that Microsoft totally screwed up because they just had no idea what they were doing, but an opinion like fails to take into account the technology of the time. In 2012, the direction that computers were going into was uncertain. The future wasn’t bleak. Computers were only going to become more popular and more powerful, but no one was quite sure what they were going to be like. The tablet industry was just starting to grow. Tablets had been around for a while, but with the iPad’s release just two years prior in 2010, it had undergone a complete transformation. All tablets were going to be just like the iPad from then on, and it was now a continuously and rapidly growing market. There was even speculation that tablets would make the computer as we knew it obsolete. The tablet would become the new PC, and everyone was now in on it…except Microsoft. They did have the advantage in the traditional keyboard-and-mouse PC market, but that was about it. With this new growing industry, they were falling a bit behind, and it was time to change that. It seemed that the only way to do that would be to make their most popular product more inclusive to these other platforms. Compromises had to be made. It was time to change Windows into a tablet-friendly OS, even if it’s at the expense of their already iconic setup, and that’s what they did with Windows 8. It wasn’t just the next update for your computer. It was something that would also be bundled with Windows Phone and the brand-new Surface RT, essentially to show off the new Windows’s versatility.
But as you would have probably guessed, touchscreen and non-touchscreen-based computers are very different. If you’re going to appeal to tablets, things have to be bigger and less cluttered. This led to one of the most controversial and hated decisions that Microsoft made to Windows 8: removing the Start Menu. People anticipating a more updated version of Windows wanted something that was more or less, a better version of Windows 7. Instead, they got something so foreign, it was like learning a new language. It was unfamiliar, confusing, and its setup was counterintuitive. Multitasking was now very difficult, something that Windows had been praised for mastering almost 20 years prior. There were third party workarounds for this, programs you could download such as Classic Shell for example that would solve this problem, but that was just extra work, and a lot of everyday people were not aware of these alternatives. People didn’t like Windows 8 because it was confusing, and it didn’t need to be.
Website: www.nationsquid.com/
Forums: www.nationsquid.freeforums.net
Patreon: / nationsquid
Merchandise: teespring.com/stores/squids-s...
Google +: just kidding.
Discord: / discord
Beauty Flow by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.filmmusic.io/song...
License: creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
A special thanks to these patrons:
- Swingadee
- Winolotonolo
- Tommy Sharp
- Sl0rg
- Nathan Inkenbrandt
ENJOY THE PROGRAM.
Play World of Warships here: wo.ws/3jsGOum Thank you World of Warships for sponsoring this video. During registration use the code FIRE to get for free: -200 Doubloons -1M Credits -Tier 5 - USS Texas -20x Restless Fire Camouflage -7 Days Premium Account The promo code is only for new players during the registration.
YAY YOU LISTENED TO ME
Zewurldo
1 million 1000000 social credits 😎😎🤩🤩😲😲😨😲🤯🤯🤯😳😳😳
How did you comment 10 hours ago but video Is 17 minute ago
@@rakhapradana7350 he posted comment while video was getting uploaded its youtubes shit work
Windows 8's backlash could've been avoided by having a checkbox at the start of installation/setup if you were operating on a PC or tablet, with PCs defaulting to the standard desktop and start menu. Problem instantly solved.
If its actually being installed it would be safe to assume its a desktop. Thats why I was so scared when people thought tablets were going to take over. To put it in the word of leister from GTA "locked down restricted access crap"
For me the app-fication of programs (such as the aforementioned Skype, among many others) was the deal-breaker, not the impractical tiled menu by itself.
And they didn't even think of that for 8.1. Suckers.
no,no,no - Sinofsky knew better than you. the PC was just a big tablet.
8.1 solved it. But it took them way too long
The removal of the headphone jack was definitely the wrong move and is still missed today. I don't think people have seen the light, more that they've just accepted that they're not getting it back.
agreed
It's still standard on low-end and mid-range phones, and tbh most people don't need a flagship. I just think the people who buy flagships are able to justify the lack of it with stuff like "it allows the phone to be thinner" or "wireless headphones are fine anyway."
@@kfcnyancat I always wonder who exactly was asking for thinner phones beyond a certain thinness to begin with, but I guess they need to market somehow.
@@charlessnyder9684 For what it's worth, thin isn't as in demand as it was when Apple first removed the headphone jack.
I dunno, i'm seeing more and more heaphone jacked lineups again, three years ago looking for a 3.5mm jack would give me like fifty models of midrange to choose from, nowadays there's a couple hundred.
I was in middle school when Windows 8 rolled out and our school had a program where we were each provided a laptop (rare back then) and did almost all of our work on them. I remember just the constant frustration from both students and teachers because basically nobody knew how to use a computer anymore. A few months later they had everyone leave their laptop at school over the weekend and we came back on Monday with Windows 7 installed.
Had the exact same thing happen at my school. We then just went straight to Windows 10, thank god
Loool this just makes me think, Wow what a stupid school! They couldn't figure out the windows key on the keyboard opens the start menu, and that the windows key+D keyboard shortcut makes it go back to the desktop? Either that or just find the little desktop tile to go to the desktop, and put the mouse cursor in the corner for the start screen. It was so easy. And I loved the new and refreshed design than the old outdated start menu. They got rid of the start menu now anyway in windows 11, so there was literally no reason to bring it back in windows 10
All they should have done in windows 8 is just provide a start button and an all programs button... ...which they did anyway in windows 8.1. So it was sorted after that. I don't know why people kept complaining But yeah, it's amazing that your school couldn't figure this out. Obviously windows was supposed to be usable. So the school was supposed to Google how it was supposed to work if they couldn't figure it out themselves. And then they would have realised that it was easy. Literally no reason to go back to outdated Windows 7
@@marioluigi9599 windows 7 ran out of support why would anyone try to use it for their main pc anyways lol
@@marioluigi9599 windows 10 ends support in 2025 so why not use that
the headphone jack and floppy drives are two completely different things. one was a slow storage device in a time where faster storage was more easily accessible. the other is a way of connecting an audio deivce to another device without needing set up bluetooth any time you want to use it one device, then another and back or worrying about your audio device running out of battery, or it yelling at you for its last hour of battery life that it has "low battery" usually cutting off all audio and at max volume regardless of what volume you have it set to.
Honestly, Modern Apple seems to just be about seeing what they can get away with removing, like the home button. I'm sorry, but the face cam is nowhere near as easy to use as just putting a finger on the home button.
No they're not, just get a dongle if you like cables so much.
Right? It is such a friggen techbro thing to say to be like "No one cares anymore, all the other companies did it and people don't complain"/ People aren't complaining because we have no other choice! Believe me, when i had to replace my phone I hunted down one with a real headphone jack, and I am dreading replacing this one. It's literally just another way to squeeze money from customers.
@ember9361 But the point is that you shouldn't have to get a specialized (especially in the case of Apple with lightning) dongle to use headphones. They didn't replace the aux with anything, they just removed it and said "Look how brave we are". And then samsung followed suit because they realized they could get away with it. Mark my words, with Apple being forced to switch to USB-C, it won't be long before they remove the charging port. Then we'll all be forced to use wireless charging, which can never be as efficient as plug charging.
@@andrewarnold9818true. Most people think these big companies are at their mercy, when in reality it's the opposite. "The customer isn't always right, The customer is just as it is a customer".
I still care about removing the headphone jack... I just prefer wired connections over bluetooth, and the ability to charge your phone in the car and be connected to an aux cord is one of those things you don't consider until you need it and can't use it.
Also having wire means : You don't have to charge your headphones. Your phone can live longer by consuming less battery.
@sol As an Osu player... I can relate.
@sol as a clone hero player I can agree
I'm a sound engineer by trade and a built-in headphone jack is essential for me. I also couldn't count the number of times I've been asked if I have the adaptor for an iPhone.
@@staringcorgi6475 oh i might check that one out, is it good? How do u play it?
The headphone jack is one of the most missed features on flagship cell phones. It needs to be brought back, not accepted as being gone forever.
Nah.. Once you go wireless you never go back to the wired dirtybuds. removing the jack was the right call... that was rather late too.. bt headsets existed since at least 2004, but they never evolved fast because the technology wasn't adopted by the masses. You see phones/pdas all had these 3.5mm ports and people stuck with it because that's what they already knew and it worked, but that was at the cost of poor user experience such as tangled wires, wires frequently breaking, overall annoying setup of having to route the cable under the shirt each time you use the buds, so it wouldn't catch into everything you pass(even that wasn't good enough because that small exposed portion of wire, that coming out the shirt and into the pocket would still occasionally catch into a corner of an object and that was always painful when it happened). when companies finally started to remove jacks, people had no choice but to try the superior alternative or have yet another annoying thing to plug in... most chose the first option and now nearly nobody cares if the jack is gone
@@beardsntools Just because you don't use it doesn't means that headphones jacks should cease to exist.
@@beardsntools "Oh no my headphones' battery is really low! Welp, guess I'll just spend 2 hours waiting for them to charge again!" Get the fuck out of here you fucking troll LMAO
@@beardsntools You know that earbuds are NOT the only use for headphone jacks? I need one to connect my phone to my guitar amp to play backing tracks while I play guitar, and also, you don't have to charge wired headphones + they have no delay
@@beardsntools "Once you go wireless, you never go back to wired" Yeah, no. I have wireless headphones and they're great, but I also have a pair of wired ones. One cannot replace the other for my needs. The wireless ones are great for convenience and it having ANC, but the wired ones just smash it in terms of sound quality.
The worst part was they used the same touch friendly environment for the server version of Windows for no sensible reason. Using charms and crap over vnc or remote desktop, as you usually do for servers, was basically IT hell.
Almost as bad as Unix 😂
@@mrcontrarian1416 ?
@@coolingjam Unix sucks to manage servers with
I was in my first year of uni when windows 8 hit morale like a freight train. After the forced auto update I walked into the cafeteria and multiple people were having emotional breakdowns. I wasn't the only one who had a shit ton of files erased. It was...awful. It wasn't just people who didn't save their work and lost it to the forced shut down.
Apple's removal of the headphone jack pisses me off to this day, as I will always prefer to use a wired connection with headphones
The statement that nobody cares anymore couldn't be more untrue. I'm also pissed as hell you can't get a phone with a jack without making compromises anymore. I love true wireless buds, but the fact that I can't use any of my other headphones with my phone is incredibly annoying.
@@justsomeguy5103 prolonged exposure to bluetooth doesn't seem to be too good for the brain too
Samsung following suit pissed me the fuck off too tbh. Low key out of spite I'm going the Sony Xperia 1 route when my current phone eventually gives in. Besides, the specs that I would ACTUALLY use is present in Xperias.
@@dylanrodrigues9577 koro sensei!
@@stealth1384 ahh, assassination classroom! what a great anime!
The real reason windows versions tend to alternate from good to bad to good again is cause one version tries to fix what isn’t broken and then the next fixes what was broken
And now with windows 11 being a mix of both. The looks in my opinion is way better than 10. The start menu has moved to the middle but there's still an option to revert it back. The decision to replace the right click menu to more simplified one is not a good one. But the new "file explorer tabs" feature is probably one of the best innovation they have made. Now we can stack multiple file windows without overcrowding the desktop
@@alieffauzanrizky7202as someone who dislikes all of those, I am even more pissed that it disconnects the battery when updating on a laptop, causing its own corruption by updating withouth saying anything in the 5 second window of closing my laptop and unplugging it from the wall.
Metro/Modern UI wasnt even the worst thing about Win8. The worst thing was that Microsoft was seriously planning to use that UI style for Windows Server.
Server typically gets the desktop stack that is attached to the build it is based on. The Insider Preview version right now has the Windows 11 UI.
@@soundspark For most people it was exactly the new, and forced, completely unusable UI
@mikaeldk5700 Still, it wasn't because Microsoft planned to use the UI specifically for server, but instead because server and client share most of the same files. Windows Server 2012 is the same build number as Windows 8 and Windows Server 2012 R2 is the same build number as Windows 8.1. Server 2016 and 2019 used the Windows 10 builds of the time, and Server 2022 ended up getting caught in the middle of a preview cycle and had a post-10, pre-11 branch go to stable for that version, carrying the Windows 10 UI because the Windows 11 UI had yet to be unveiled.
You forgot to mention that all the new apps didn't initially had a close button, and there was no Taskbar! it worked like a smartphone where you had to go to the start menu to use another app , except that even in smartphones in that time the navigation bar was always visible 😂
Urmmm there was still a task bar. Just no start button ...but they brought it back in windows 8.1. So it was fine after that. I don't know why people still hated on 8.1.
It was annoying as heck trying to turn off your PC with Windows 8, there's no start button, no indicator how to get to the power off option, so I had to crtl + alt + del to bring up the task manager screen which had the power icon in the button corner to turn off my PC. EVERY. SINGLE. TIME! Once they updated to Windows 8.1 with the task bar back, it wasn't as ANNOYING, but still! The task bar and start button shouldn't have been basically removed in the first place.
@@cocodojo actually there was a power button if you open the pop in menu from the right side and click settings. And even if you didn't find that, you could just sign out to the log in screen and there was another power button there. And if you didn't want to do all that, you could just press the power button on your computer itself and it would shutdown as long as you had it set to that
@@marioluigi9599 That was the first few weeks of me getting Windows 8, there was nothing indicating you could've done any of that at the time, information about the system was basically 0, but ever since then when they finally rolled out the update to make windows 8.1, things have become much more reasonable.
@@cocodojo Yeah everyone was struggling, including me. I remember, I was struggling for the few minutes to get to the desktop lool. But after the first day I worked it all out and I was all good. It wasn't that bad
"Windows 8 was trying to move people over to an environment they just didn't want." And this would define Microsoft's MO for the following ten years: forcing things on users and taking things out of their control.
Like the Xbox One
@@zaneheaston8254 I am amazed that thing sold a single unit after the PR nightmare prerelease. "Never go on vacation again or we'll lock your console! Don't you want one?"
@@zaneheaston8254 you're too right, though. I have one and it was a lovely, lovely present from my fiancée and I've had a hell of a lot of fun on it. But I've had a hell of a lot of headaches with it. They force cloud save storage on you, which on two occasions rather than being a "data safety feature" has actually wiped my saves on two different games. It's still got no opt-out. They force Edge browser on you. Who the hell browses on a console? Not me. But there's no opt-out, so it's uselessly sitting there eating space. At first, you could view your screenshots offline. Now you can't! Gotta be online. No explanation. Updates every single bloody time I go online with it and takes bloody ages (especially in the verification stage - longer than the download and installation stage combined maybe even twice-over!). Why? I've got no bloomin' clue. There's even considerable menu lag now, it's done so much rearranging the furniture. I don't know what was supposed to be so wrong with how it worked before all the updates. It ran games. Games Sony didn't buy out exclusivity for, that is. But plenty of really fun games. It did what it was supposed to do, I just wish that was all it did.
@@Torthrodhel this is the type of stuff that made me swap to linux
@@fiercey425 I am strongly thinking about that. It'd be a big shift but it looks very worth it.
A LOT of people still care about the headphone jack, nearly everyone I talk to. They just can't do anything about it. We had ONE port used for audio and headphones across all devices (ok 2.5 and 3.5mm and some use usb) and everyone got headphones they love for that one port, they can use on any phone, any laptop, tablet, desktop, console, any device at all. And apple cut it to save manufacturing, improve waterproofing and force wireless on people
Aka people who are afraid of change
@@staringcorgi6475 nope, people who likes change, but only if it changes for the better.
@@bennybau123 imagine if there is no micro usb anymore and force everyone to use usb c
@@staringcorgi6475 the USB C is superior, Bluetooth is not, if the replacement is better, I think it is good.
@@bennybau123 or what if usb a gets discontinued to push usb 4/thunderbolt
I switched to Windows 8 at the time because I simply wanted to be up to date. The new Home menu took a lot of getting used to. That's why I was happy when programmes like Classic Shell became available that brought back the familiar Windows look. As I remember, the apps from the Windows Store were vastly inferior to the normal programmes. To this day, I ignore the Windows Store wherever possible. Windows 8 may have gotten better over time. But I quickly switched to Win 10 when it came out. Just as I did from Vista to 7.
Yes the apps where indeed inferior. I remember the app version of skype had quite a few functionalities removed, such as screensharing (and others that I don't remember). Windows 8's UI would have been good in the 90's when multitasking wasn't very common due to technical limitations (computing power and screen sizes). The whole point of "Windows" was to be able to have multiple Windows open side by side. Going fullscreen on every app in 2012 was just dumb.
I still use classic shell on windows 10 & 11 😊. To me, it snakes easier to use
Bro ignored 8.1☠️
@@nobody_023k Not really. I just didn't mention it because it didn't matter much to me.
I still refuse to buy any phone without a headphone jack
16:22 "now people don't really care any more." I care IMMENSELY. _still using the headphone jack on their S7 daily_
right? i still use wired earbuds all the time, i can't afford spending $50 on bluetooth ones
@@Tendo641 I can and I refuse to buy Bluetooth headphones. My ten year old wired ones still sound better than anything I could get for under 200 bucks wireless.
@@Tendo641 there are literally 15$ Ones that Sound decently
Just use an adapter mates
@@riponrip4574 Easy for you to say, you probably already own one. I'm not going out to buy an extra accessory just so I can use my headphones. Also it's annoying to have to plug in _two_ things when I'm going out with my headphones. Suddenly now there's two points that the headphones can pull out of, and what's going to happen if I lose the adapter whilst getting off the bus?
16:23 I still haven't gotten over this. I find it really dumb that mid tier to budget phones are more user friendly than $1000 phones that should have all the features a smartphones have. The fact that if I ever got, say, a Galaxy S21, and I'd have to throw away my perfectly functioning earbuds and buy bluetooth ones is dumb in my eyes.
Just like Mr. Krabs says. “Money!”
@@InfinityBS facts
It's also crazy how my mid tier/budget from 2016 has a better camera than a lot of mid tier/budget phones from 2019. Also doesn't have a notch, has a selfie flash and uses the right aspect ratio.
@@JonatasAdoM nowadays camera quality is more dependent on software
@@JonatasAdoM 2016 Phones don't have better camera's...
Companies need to know that any change in User Interface will likely cause a backlash. I should not constantly keep memorizing new places to find the off button as I keep upgrading my OS to the newest version.
*This argument has been beaten to death but...* Apple removed the headphone jack to promote AirPods _not_ because of aging tech. It's no coincidence that all the other phone manufacturers that remove their headphone jacks also had their own brand of wireless earbuds to promote. In 2023 (a year after this video was made), headphones that use the 3.5 mm jack are still being sold everywhere and new non-flagship phones as well as all laptops still include the jack.
I legit just watched your M.E. video and thought "huh, wonder when he's gonna make a video on Windows 8?" Then like an hour later this dropped lol. Great video!
Holy shit me too
HOLY SHIT ME TOO?
That's because I read your mind! Thanks for watching. :)
Speaking of which, did Windows 8 do worse than Windows ME in terms of a commercial standpoint?
@@NintendoGamer2600 Highly Doubt it
What always bums me out with Win8 is that it was SO GOOD on smart phones for the vast majority of things casual users do, but the failure of that UI translating to desktops and Android and iOS both working on large and small screens killed Windows phone despite just how much dev support it got from the start.
Right, just with Windows Mobile, they had it all in the bag and blew it (Windows Mobile was admittedly a lot more successful than Windows Phone, obviously). Windows Mobile really was the Android of its day, open, extremely customizable and more utilitarian than "user friendly". And then Windows Phone came, which started out as the best of both worlds... Then crashed and burned.
I had the pleasure of experiencing Windows 8 on the original Surface tablet. I loved navigating it!
The failure of the UI didn't kill the Windows Phone. It even got a version of windows 10 phone which was really promising and supported the desktop feature and what not. If they didn't shut it down we could have had it today. The problem with it was the Microsoft didn't know how to handle it properly. They didn't want it to end up like android at the time with tons of unchecked shady apps but they also didn't want to be completely locked centrally controlled ecosystem like iOS so they tried to go somewhere in the middle. Phone developers that wanted to adopt Windows Phone had to check some criteria Microsoft gave them to ensure it will run well and that actually wasn't a bad move but then App developers had to go through some licensing process and had a strict rules for UI design and what not and that was not so smart. App developers didn't want to deal with that for a platform with small market share and people didn't want to buy phone that has no apps and that led to the downfall. Microsoft should have approached it better but they had this dude that also made the Zune disaster and realised all the market opportunities too late and was all straight up incompetent. Check out some of the last windows phone 10 devices, they were really cool. If it continued we could have had another alternative to Google overlord and maybe that desktop in phone feature would be actually useful. Now we just sadly have to wait for the raise of Linux on Phones to do that.
@@MrMozkoZrout WHY MICROSOFT WHY DID YOU DO THAT windows phone is the best phone os ever, killed by lack of apps. I still have a lumia 640lte with windows phone 8.1 as my secondary phone and I love it. Also shame they removed whatsapp. And shut down the ms store.
Highkey, I loved the user interface and design of windows 8. As someone who likes customizing their PC and just things in life in general, I thought it could have been a great customizable option to add some flair to your desktop. The downside I dealt with was not every app was fitted with cool tiles or tiles just didnt function right. I feel like had it had a lil more love, it could have been a great OPTION not the only one.
short answer: the windows menu long answer: the windows menu with examples
Tiles were annoying, and it made the Windows symbol itself ugly, so I'll never forgive it. My dad installed it when I wasn't there, and I suffered through it until 8.1 made it a bit more manageable.
I made the mistake of buying it and installing it. I went back to Windows 7 as soon as I was able. Microsoft was so into the tablet craze that they forgot that full size computers are still a thing.
Just use Linux.
@@nobody-pk8ei Bruh, I believe you mean Ubuntu. And unless you're a programming freak, it's not worth at all.
It couldn't run games for s**t either.
@Rlaziken Nah, it's just Linux.
"People forgot about the headphone jack problem after the iphone" Yeah, that's a load of bull. Bluetooth has come a long way but the noticeable half a second delay in sound AND the still to this day absolutely ATROCIOUS level of battery drain will make sure wired connections will still be more preferred than "futuristic look ma' no wires!" crap the phone makers try to push. It's all so we'd buy their overpriced dongles. Also, no the iphone having no jack is NOT a problem that went away. I worked at an electronics retail chain and EVERY SINGLE DAY someone was asking for an iphone compatible usb-c to headphone adapter.
Well of course they’re gonna ask for one. Someone will get one even if the majority don’t becaude that’s just how people work
that shits actually so annoying i had a broken phone for half a year and when it was fixed i keep trying to plug my headphones in to a nonexistent hole
bro. i notice no delay in everysingle one of my bluetooth headphones, especially my xm4s. dont over exagerate things just to prove a point. the last paragraph would have been fine on its own
Also sound quality is worse on wireless headphones than wired
@@monarchu "Bro i don't have this problem meaning that this problem doesn't exist at all" That's all you contributed to this discussion, i don't have to overexaggerate when i speak from everyday personal experience.
It's weird that Microsoft assumed everyone would switch to tablets, apparently forgetting that a lot of people work office jobs where they're on desktop PCs all day. This is the same company that has a product called Microsoft Office, with programs commonly used in offices.
I loved 8 on a touchscreen computer lol. When you can just touch the thing on the screen it turns out it was rather intuitive. Once they added back the start minue I used it, but honestly preferred to use the touchscreen. I remember being pretty disappointed when I had to update said touchscreen laptop to Windows 10 lol. Definitely planning to get a 2 in 1 at some point to get my touchscreen back lol. Though it turns out after 8 I kinda don't like the start menu lol. It's much smaller and a little harder to find the program I'm looking for.
Ever played with MS Paint and draw with multiple fingers at once?
I was one of those who never updated to 8 because of the backlash. I saw demonstration videos and noped out. I went from 7 right to 10
I did too, I wasn’t interested in a windows that look more like a tablet and when i saw windows 10 returned to the old startmenu
I made my windows 10 look a lot like windows 7 with custom shell and my gosh the move up was easier.
@@Cynderfan35 Same, I tried to use the default start menu in 10 for years but it wasn't doing it for me, so I installed openshell and reverted it back to W7 style and it's been amazing! Am hoping openshell eventually supports W11 too
Same here. Never even tried Windows 8, but my mother had it and just watching her use it discouraged me. I wanted a PC that felt like a PC. Not a damn tablet. Especially on desktop. Windows 11 seems to have a lot of problems too so I may be skipping that for Windows 12 as well. Who knows. Still not as bad as Windows 8 though.
Same
Tbf, as a once-owner of a Windows Phone, the tiles were so amazing there and I still miss them. But Microsoft should have kept them faaaaar away from desktop.
totally agreed. I had a windows phone too and it worked really well....on mobile ONLY
Yeah I would have to agree
Feel like that should exist a win phone themed launcher for android
@@headxplosion there are already some on the Play Store
Titles should have stay away from windows or Microsoft should have put the titles in touchscreen mode where only titles shows and no desktop so is would be user friendly to touchscreen than it would be still in window 8 to 8.1 when did people ask for the start button to be removed so you just added it back in 8.1 Microsoft forgot to remove old Policy on group policy I got a policy stay turn off windows store I did and nothing happened to the store
I was a kid when windows 8 realeased, and being curious as hell, till this day I have nice memories of it because my 9 year old self loved that piece of invencionice. I'm 20 now, and I would hate to use that os again, but at the time it was really important, not only it made me learn how to install and uninstall an os, that was my first ever experience actually learning something about computers, but it made me realise that changing things in the computer its not only a feature but a must to anyone who wants to use the machine at its fullest, well learn that as good as a 9 yo can learn, but for me it was important, created an interest that later grown to be really important in my life, and without windows 8's incoveniences I would have just keept my life going, playing League of Legends and never getting interested in computer science.
Why on earth would tablets replace computers. Has any tried to do anything actually productive on a tablet without a keyboard. Imagine coding or writing an essay with nothing but a touchscreen
Tablets have now become coexistant with laptops since you can get work done on them with an apple pencil for example or a keyboard however for more sophisticated and precise work you need a laptop
I was asking myself the same thing. It doesn't make any sense tablets replacing desktop computers or laptops. I'm a programmer. Did Microsoft want their employees to develop the next version of Windows on tablets?
16:18 I was with you until you started simping for the removal of features because of "muh technology advancement". Speaking as a frequent Bluetooth user, I still refuse to use any device so comfortable in removing connections as ubiquitous and basic as a headphone jack, that's like buying a computer with no USB slots.
Move on into the future, grandpa. We can’t be stuck in the “forgotten days” forever.
@@ToyBoxBrain Ok would you buy a car with motion controls instead of physical because "it's more advanced" or do you want a car that actually works very reliably without needing an internet connection, a bodysuit and a camera with a perfectly unobstructed view of you at all times? Because you're now advocating that everyone be forced to use more expensive temperamental devices that require their own battery supply, can be easier to lose and can have audio delays as opposed to also having the option of using the tried and true ubiquitous technology. You should start advocating for the removal of USB ports while you're at it.
Exactly. Bluetooth is convenient, but I always want the option of using the jack. Like If I'm walking on campus or doing dishes, then yeah, I want bluetooth so I'm not going to get caught on anything. And because I am busy with other stuff, I'm going to be busy while the music is playing so I'm not going to be an audiophile. But when I'm listening for enjoyment or I'm using my phone in a long call, I stick with wired because it is more reliable. Heck, I've even bought into Dankpod's KZ recommendation. It is so nice to be able to swap the headphone drivers themselves between a bluetooth set and wired. So that is even less loss of quality on my end. I want both because I frequently use both!
@@ToyBoxBrain Eh, removing the jack was never really for the advancement of tech. The tech was already there and well-refined. Companies just needed a reason to push a new trend of wireless buds. It's not as simple as floppy drives because CDs were pretty much superior in basically every arena. 3.5mm jacks vs. Bluetooth isn't so clear cut because they each have very clear pros and cons. Bluetooth is convenient but has a latency penalty alongside the typical issues you have with a 2.4GHz wireless connection. The 3.5mm jack can be a bit to faff about because cables but it does allow for mostly latency-free audio and generally allows for a much higher quality assuming it is paired with a stout DAC/amp combination. There's a reason I have wired and wireless headphones. They're both great for their own respective cases but one cannot replace the other because they each have very distinct pros and cons.
The charging port however can be removed. We have MagSafe and also we could use magnetic contacts rather than a hole.
This video gives off "I need to meet that essay's minimum word limit" vibe. But in this case, they are after watch time.
very much agree it seemed the f irst points were repeated for like 5 minutes
20 minutes of "it was confusing"
6:44 emotional damage
I consider myself very computer literate, yet still don't understand Windows 8 and the tiles. I could never find anything, and even in Windows 10 I also cannot find my installed software. I cannot find anything, I have to use search! I still haven't worked out how to get what I WANT to appear in the Windows 10 Start Menu tiles that appear on the right of the programs list. I have no idea why those things are even there, taking up space for no reason.
My initial reaction to Windows 8 was confusion. I thought I'd messed up and bought the wrong version or something since the familiar Windows layout had been replaced with tablet style mystery meat navigation.
That's one of the most subtle UI design burns I've seen in a while. Nicely done! I personally have no problem with 8 or 8.1 besides the fact that my Surface 2 is basically useless now.
Honestly I don't think Microsoft stil hasn't fully learned from the windows 8 disaster. Imo they still haven't recognised the market.
Absolutely
and they're still going head first into W11 with all touch screen nonsense. Like, what's the point of having the start icon in the center? I could, in older times just zip my cursor across the screen, it would lodge into a corner and click and the menu would pop up, among many other changes to the display sizes of elements on screen that are super wasteful.
@@AD_RC It being at the center isn't that big of a deal, since you can change it back to being on the left; it's more of an aesthetical decision, rather than it being linked to the Touch-y UI
@@AD_RC I use 11 now, and i thought i was going to move the start button to the left but now I'm used to it in the centre
@@AD_RC You can move the start icon to the left on W11...
Lemme tell you, I run Windows 8 on my main laptop, and Im STUCK. The laptop BARELY even RUNS on Windows 8, but after EmbeddedReadyPOS 7 ended support in 2021, I had nothing else to run Windows7 with and had to upgrade to something else. Had I known Windows 8 ended support aswell, I wouldve just bought a new laptop. But it was too late for that. Now I was sitting enfornt of… colourful tiles on a purple screen and I DONT EVEN KNOW HOW TO SHUT THE DANG THING OFF. And its sad that my laptop cannot run Win 8.1 or 10. So im practically stuck, because theres a high chance my laptop will break or run poorly If I go to Windows 7. ugh.
17:51 not gonna lie, that wallpaper somehow gives me nostalgia to like 2012/2013. Somehow I wonder why, but when I think about it.. it's been 10 years already, sometimes when I think about like "10 years ago" I'm in the Windows 7 kinda era. Time's going by fast...
People not caring about the headphone jack is not because we "understand" or are fine with it. It's more so a "ffs, they don't listen, why do we still complain" thing. I'd HATE if I got a new phone and suddenly I could no longer use the wired headphones I already have for my PC. Only reason I might forgive it is if they include *very high quality* wireless headphones/earbuds on any phone that dropped the headphone jack.
When my last phone gave up on me I ended up having to choose a weaker phone than something else I could afford while paying a lot more just because I wanted a headphone jack.
Sony includes their premium BT earphones during their Xperia preorders. Which is double hilarious since they actually DO have the headphone jack on said phones.
@@Spearra That’s for making people buy their Xperia phones. The smartphone division of Sony is literally failing without proper press And limited user experience
Unrelated but I love your pfp.. Omori Futaba 💕
Apple or android, smartphones keep going one step forward and ten steps back.
The entire staff had to re learn how to use the computer, however simple Win8 was to use. Many of us had become entrenched in many automatic hand/eye/Brain shortcuts while using Windows 7 that productivity almost ground to a halt when we had to do so many things differently.
9 days left till 2023 and i am still watching this on Windows 7
"people don't care about the removal of the headphone jack" Just about the silliest thing I ever heard. People had no choice unless they wanted to abandon the OS and accounts they where familiar with. Every single person with an apple product I personally know despises the patently obvious "F*CK you" to consumers that it was.
People who dismiss the lack of a headphone jack have never had to deal with a long road trip in a car with no bluetooth support. Or, in my old phone's case, a car that only supports a version of BT my phone's last version of Android dropped support for. If not for my Aux cable, I would have had to use my phone as the worst portable boombox ever.
Aux cords are a life saver for broke people
I grew up in the 90s with corded headphones now I wish wireless was a thing back then I hate corded headphones I love Bluetooth
@@Parappadarappa2 im broke as fuck but I have working Bluetooth headphones and my vehicle radio
@@Parappadarappa2 aren't we all?
My early Prius has bluetooth, but only for calling. Not for general audio play. I rock the cellphone boombox cause I'm not interested in purchasing an adapter. At the least, the speakers are nice and loud.
>apple removing headphone jack >people dont care anymore im sure thats not true for a LOT of people but ok yes thats all i wanted to comment on, bluetooth audio is just NOT as good as wired
This.
100$ Bluetooth Headphone = 30$ Wired Headphone
The Sony Xperia 1 iii sold hella units in China too. Which is a flagship that has the jack. So to say there's no demand for it borderlines as dismissive. (The ladder if which is VEEERY common with die hard BT fans I've noticed. Except in their case, it is outright hostile AND dismissive)
Bluetooth sacrifices mic quality, longevity, and low latency for convenience. I think wireless headphones are nice but the reliability of a cable will probably never be beaten.
I tried it when it first came out. It wasn't terrible, as it was pretty much w7 under the hood, but the duality of having two separate windows shells (UWP and w7) in one was cumbersome, so after a while i returned to w7. Did not try w8.1. BTW w10 still has problems with both UWP stuff (store and what is included with it) getting sometimes crossed over with w7 leftovers. A quick example is the new and old control panels still existing in it or notification tab like you'd have on your tablet/smartphone. w11 is much better in that aspect, but you can still find old leftovers if you dig deep enough, while in w8 it was right there every time you pressed
dude it waa terriblw stfu
Windows 8 came out around the time where SATA SSDs were starting to be in my price range. Given that I had just graduated from college, that wasn't too much. My fondness for Windows 8 is probably more "I can't believe how fast booting is with an SSD" combined with acceptance of the OS after finally getting used to it. It was amazing not having time to do my entire morning routine before the PC booted up like the XP days.
"...unmitigated disaster that could decidedly hurt Microsoft and its future." Who thought a post from 9 years ago could've been so relatable still today
You are windows 7 you are biased
@@LibertyCat100 im a different edition wruo
@@LibertyCat100 your comment translates to at my desk
waddup
Oh my fucking god everytime i comment on a video someone ticks me that i'm windows 7, leave me the fuck alone y'all
I'm still out here fighting for the headphone jack. THE 2016 WAR IS NOT OVER.
I heard its coming back
@@americanShurtugalEntertainment where
Damn y’all are pathetic. Maybe get a better job that will afford you some quality earbuds or headphones.
@@ToyBoxBrain All the best headphones are wired. I have airpods, but I'd much rather use studio headphones. Or, you know, ANY headphones I'd like.
Get a Sony Xperia 1 mk.iii. Sony has a proper, complete flagship on their hands.
This is how it ended a year earlier than windows vista.
As someone who is old, I haven't liked a version of Windows since Windows 7
I was in middle school when I was using Windows 8, and I didn't particularly dislike it. The start menu was confusing though, but I got used to it over time. In some ways I liked the new start menu. It almost made my laptop feel like a game console, especially with the Xbox integration. Windows 10 was a breath of fresh air and was way easier to understand though, and I haven't really gone back since.
🍞
You can go into tablet mode on Windows 10 to get it back
@@Hamox yeah but the start screen in windows 10 is super limited compared to 8.x
I am using windows 11 right now
@@fredericchopin2441 what for? why would you switch from 10?
Never underestimate the staying power of a form factor. PC sales have been growing. This shows that PCs are not under threat. Most PCs just weren't in need of upgrading until recently. PCs are the perfect platform for power. No mobile device can compete on power. Not for any significant length of time.
And they never will. Just by size, if a microprocessor as powerful as a modern computer is ever developed in a size apt for a mobile, a computer will be able to implement ten of those without problem. It will have no trouble with energy input, size or heating
@@staringgasmask Same reason why notebooks are always a compromise between size and power. Even a notebook can use it's size to have better hardware and better heat dissipation than a mobile device.
Not to mention that it doesn't matter how powerful a tablet is, its limitation is always going to be form factor and input methods. You just can't get away from the fact that you still can't get any proper work done without a decent size screen, physical keyboard, and a mouse. I've got a Windows 10 tablet that is plenty powerful on the hardware side of things for what I intended to use it for... except multitasking is horrible and almost non-existent, the virtual keyboard takes up half the screen, and you can't hit small icons or perform more intricate actions with a finger.
hold my cloud gaming with 5g 😂 you don't need power anymore
@@dejazO0 Cloud gaming. LMAO A scam as big as NFTs.
I do miss the windows version for smartphones, it was so ahead of its time
At the time I remember really liking windows 8's start screen and missing it for a time with windows 10. Not sure I'd feel the same nowadays though!
I had such a great experience with Windows 7 that Windows 8 was the one OS I never could use on a permanent basis. I did end up using 8.1, along with a third-party shell replacement. But the Windows 8 experience was just horrific to me. The jarring nature of being thrust either into the Start screen or back to the Desktop made it seem like 2 separate operating systems. I like Windows 10
it does help that in 8.1 you can get Most of your start menu back by Right-clicking the start windows button on the screen. Just gotta train yourself to never actually press the windows key.
Windows 10 with Open Shell.
I still use Windows 7, both in my desktop and laptop. I've had 3 Windows 10 laptops, every single one was stolen. The windows 7 laptop was also stolen, but the battery was so lousy the thief actually returned it. Future versions only got bigger, uglier, and generally less compatible. Win 11 and 10S I refuse; less ability to use programs I want, and too much corporate control or spying. I also would not buy any computer with a tiny hard drive that relies on using a Cloud. Windows 8 did nothing that was good. Windows Defender is NOT Malwarebytes. Having it built into Windows 10 required me to go through a great ordeal to disable it so that I could run programs I wanted without having them deleted.
I remember when it came out people at my school tried to make me a it person with no pay no fuck off it was kinda of weird see people not know how to use 8 when the ui was just a phone and tablet ui but man use 8 buggy trash 8.1 was miles better
@@trashsombra2793 I never really understood the hate for 8. I mean I understand it was a different UI, but most of it seemed to be people violently overreacting to the Start Menu not stuck in the bottom left side of the screen. The Charms bar was actually a step in the right direction (functionally similar to the Mac OS adaptive top menu bar, just about the only thing Apple got right) but the failure of 8 really killed it. So many people were too scared to learn something slightly new or different. I mean the worst thing about 8/8.1 was that it looks like it was designed for a kid's tablet, like Leapfrog or whatever and the bright Start Menu looks genuinely silly in a business environment (which is probably where I used it most, lol. I used a keyboard and mouse, too).
16:32 Strongly disagree. People would have used it, but when you cut support and ability to access to certain product for very long time - people starting to accept to never having it back and forget. Natural death and murder are 2 different things
Yeah I still only buy phones that have phone jacks, I prefer my headphones over uncomfortable ear pieces that can occasionally disconnect and also run out of battery and can compromise audio quality
@@AlineaEuros and fall, i would never trust something that can fall out of my ear and not be linked by cable
I still use Windows 7, both in my desktop and laptop. I've had 3 Windows 10 laptops, every single one was stolen. The windows 7 laptop was also stolen, but the battery was so lousy the thief actually returned it. Future versions only got bigger, uglier, and generally less compatible. Win 11 and 10S I refuse; less ability to use programs I want, and too much corporate control or spying. I also would not buy any computer with a tiny hard drive that relies on using a Cloud. Windows 8 did nothing that was good. Windows Defender is NOT Malwarebytes. Having it built into Windows 10 required me to go through a great ordeal to disable it so that I could run programs I wanted without having them deleted.
Floppy discs were still available on windows computers for years after. Our school still had them when I graduated in 2004. But floppy discs had 1.44mb of space on them. They were becoming pain even by the end of the 90s. By 2001, we were about as likely to try our luck emailing a file to each other than try fitting it on a floppy disc.
@@hjf3022 floppy disk and their successor laserdisk have one thing in common: it was a *physical copy* and not an app or a digital cloud save - meaning no one from digital corporations, microsoft or hackers can take it away, alter your information/content. Over the past there lots of movies, music, videos, animation, games, personal files and software has been accumulated and saved on disks. Pretty sure many of us who posses these would like have access to them.
I feel that the problem with Windows in general, is that the UI was near enough perfected in XP and never really needed to change at all. And with Windows 10, although it was a very welcome return to the familiar style which was never broken, it is not a great feel. It feels like they tried mend the broken vase and couldn't quite fit all the pieces back together properly. Windows 11 is an improvement, but it's blatantly just a reskin of 10. You only have to open the bonnet to see that it's the same engine.
Love that you're video has the Toshiba satellite laptops. I have one of those. But it doesn't work anymore.
I remember being tasked with the job of replacing the computers in computer classes around the campus at the school I worked at at the time. My most common complaint was the lack of the start button, as soon as you told them to use the windows key they went "oh ok" and they were pretty much fine with 8 after that. Personally I liked 8 apart from the visual style. Still, Microsoft definitely should've simply made a different edition for tablets instead of combining everything into one. Or just some kind of setting that allowed you to pick a more tablet friendly UI
I believe if Microsoft just didn't at least hide the Taskbar with a visible Start button while the Start screen is opened, there will be less resistance to Windows 8. Sure people may still complain, but it will be alot less and not as confusing. I think the reason why people get confused is when they login, there is NO Taskbar which is a visual thing about Windows, without it people will get confused how to get around. Start screen basically acts like a Desktop icons anyways, which majority of people use than the Start itself when opening apps. So if the user gets around the Tiles, it's not that bad for them and some may even prefer it for many different reasons (bigger target to open, larger icons and text, Live Tiles giving info, etc) Also All Apps is stupidly hidden ON windows 8, but they addressed it and make it visible on 8.1 just like on Windows Phone 7 which is release way earlier. That one is probably one of the really stupid thing that I don't understand why hide it when Windows Phone 7 had it always visible.
Let me make this even worse. They actually did make a separate version of win8 for tablets. It was used on like 1 or 2 of the budget tier Surface tablets. It couldnt run any native windows programs and wasnt eligible for the win10 upgrade. It is unbelievably terrible compared the normal win8.
I remember getting a laptop with Windows 8 when it was new. My thoughts on it are broadly the same as those outlined as public opinion in this video. It was very clunky for a traditional PC user like me, and as mentioned, I not only had no interest in a tablet, but I didn't and don't like touchscreen interfaces. So many of the changes actively inconvenienced me as a user, and made me wish that I could go back to what's still my favorite Windows- 7. Of course, my family couldn't justify buying the downgrade, so I was stuck with it. I managed, but I wasn't happy about it. I remember when 8.1 was released, and here's my reaction: "Oh well, at least this is marginally usable now." Later, when I got my Dad's old desktop, still running 7, I stubbornly clung to using it until the day its support was discontinued. My experiences with 8 led me to distrust its descendant, Windows 10. I don't mind Windows 10 now that I've used it, but it does still have that layer of mandatory account linking and automated features that irk me. "At least it's not Windows 8."
I remember buying a laptop which had W8 on it, I hated so much that I preferred to lose the warranty for altering the OS rather than staying with such unstable and inefficient OS.
@@ozzcoremidmx8287 I never had a major issue with it being unstable or crashing, but I really didn't care for the UI or usage experience.
Well, good thing there is Linux just in case Microsoft messes up too hard... again. Then again, they do have a record of learning from their mistakes...
@@ozzcoremidmx8287 The OS is actually stable and efficient, waay better Kernel than Windows 7, UI is hot garbage. I also had the bad luck of owning a high end 17.3 inch laptop released in 2012 or 2013 that had Windows 8, fortunately Windows 10 saved it and the Core i7-4700MQ beast that it has inside. Man, Windows 8 sucked so badly by that UI, Windows 10 is light years better.
@@putinpunhere Linux software support is terrible, worse than Mac.
On Windows 8, you did not have to use the big full screen start menu. You could use a sized down start menu that looked almost the same as the windows 7 version.
8.1 had this feature, 8.0 did not.
@@thatradiogeek I see. I first got windows 8, when Version 8.1 already had been published.
My family all used windows 8 while I stuck on 7, I couldnt understand why they liked it. I remember thinking it was annoying that the app icons were so big, you had to move your mouse a lot further just to open another program, compared to the tiny app icons on the desktop.
Call me a strange but I liked the tiles setup since the day windows 8 was launched. Heck I still use tiles setup on my windows 10 PC today. Sure, It takes a bit of getting used to with playing with all the corner feature on PC on the 8, but once I actually followed the tutorial that Microsoft included after installation and get used to it, it's was really futuristic. (Yes the Exit button is still there in the corner, just hidden). I actually missed a lot of corner feature when they removed it on the 8.1 release. I remember taking my newly upgraded laptop to my class presentation in HS. It is certainly a wow factor coming from all the windows 7 installed in my school back then. Every action is sooooo smooth, no trying to precisely click at the X to exit, no small box to tick, just drag my mouse to the corner and it's done. The UI is so neat and uncluttered. But everything is also still there if you need it. Advanced controls, etc. Now look at the Windows 11 mess. Shit I don't need already filled the start menu since installation, and when I need advanced controls it might just tell me to go f- myself.
7:40 Nice work making the desktop icons feel nostalgic. I saw "Poptropica" and felt a stab at my heart.
maybe you should call an ambulance then
My only real exposure to Windows 8 was during my A+ certification training, but I agree that Microsoft made the wrong bet on which way the tech winds were blowing -- after all, even tablets are now becoming more laptop-like, with the fairly common adoption of add-on keyboards, pointing devices, and even Bluetooth game controllers by tablet aficionados.
This may sound weird but I like the way this comment is formatted.
Yes with the missing hyperterminal software ....
I also think Windows 10 works really well for both touch screen input and for keyboard/mouse.
Did anyone notice MGRR at top right in the timestamp of 16:09?
A lot of people have made the comments about the headphone jack line, so I'll take it a step further and say that exact mentality "Ignore criticism, users will get over it eventually" is toxic to tech and it's getting increasingly present in the design philosophies of many companies.
Windows 8 did have a few new features that were really missing in Windows 7. Like the new task manager, or my favourite, the ability to mount .ISO and .VHD files.
This
@@radonulk108 Also the ability to display the task bar on two monitors or more.
I remember buying a laptop that came with Windows 8, and immediately feeling disgusted by it. It was so unintuitive. I got classic shell as soon as I found out about its existence.
I have Windows 8 u guys put problems in everything
@@angelomiguel8482 Good for you. You can pick up your participation trophy on the way out. Have a good one.
Im struggling finding apps turning off it etc. With windows 8 windiws 7 is better ngl
Julio Vargas Good for you. You can pick your participation trophy on the way out. Have a good one.
@@darkigor20 stop copying me!
whoever thought tablets were gonna replace pcs were absolutely trippin, can't believe people actually thought that
thing that i LOVED about launch of Windows 8, was the launch deals of it. back then you could get 30€ legal Windows 8 pro retail keys straight from Microsoft. or if you wanted to save extra 15€ you said that you bought your pc within the last 6 months and you got the key for 15€ this got even better as the same key works on Windows 10 and 11, so not too bad of an investment. and what comes about the Windows 8 itself. it had the new task manager, but it did require 3rd party start menus to become usable. and add tools such as Glass8 on top and you would even get the native aero glass theme with transparency back. after all these changes, it was mostly as if i was just using Windows 7 with the new Windows 8 taskmanager.
What I remember about Windows 8 was how cumbersome it was to do simple things. Like shutting down - I think that option was buried in a side-drawer. If you want to run an application, you had to hunt for it in the Start Screen. I just found it easier to enter a search query whenever I wanted to run something. Windows 8.1 improved upon it a little bit - at least it brought back the Start button, which had a new feature where you can right-click it to access basic functions
I remember back in 2012 and 2013 when my grandma got a new PC with Windows 8, as an 11 year old who knows the basics of using Windows, I was so confused how to use this thing. All I wanted to do was to go to MS Paint and draw, but finding Paint was a big hassle. I was of course very disappointed that my grandma replaced her Windows XP machine with this piece of junk known as Windows 8. Windows XP, Vista and 7 were my childhood, and knowing how to use those OS's were engraved to my brain ever since I learned how to use the start button! :D Windows 8.1 is actually good though, I was talking about the original Windows 8.
Windows 11: released Windows 8: finally a worthy opponment
To be honest, I was always an early adopter, and when 8 came, I bought my first apple!!!! Your video nailed and told all the problems that win 8 had. And “Friend of P” comment (please check the comments to find it) point out what would have be an easy solution for the problem back them. If MS had put the “desktop view option” during the installation it would do wonders for the system… But, that´s history now. Anyway, for pure coincidence, to “make it alive again”, I put my win 8.1. OS copy in an old Dell All in One with touch screen and… It´s perfect. NOW, because the use of tablets is so common, I can understand better the “logic” of the 8.1. system. Sure, there is some points to improve but, overall, NOW, is a good experience. But the support will end in January 23 so… it´s time to say good bay.
When I was way younger, my older sister decided to let me “borrow” her Windows 8 computer to play games. She let me make my own Microsoft account, download any games, and use it whenever I liked. I loved that computer and I remember that version of Windows fondly. It was so different from my mother’s 2008 Mac Leopard or my school’s Windows 7 desktops and my child self found satisfaction in the variety. I thought it was so cool that it looked so modern and futuristic; I loved changing the backgrounds and playing around on the menu. I would play Minion Run or the My Little Pony world builder game avidly; it was amazing to a small child. At some point, my sister did ask for her computer back (I used it so much and constantly kept it with me, it was more like my own) and I received a Windows 10 HP a few years later. Even though it receives a lot of criticism, I’ll always have a special place in my heart for Windows 8. Whenever I hear the Windows 7/8 startup sound, my heart breaks. 💖
Even though I don't have siblings, I can relate to this on such a deep level. Win8 is just pure nostalgia.
@@jdcs._ Strongly disagree. Windows 8 was the very definition of "Inadequate". I understand your sentiment, though. Microsoft like a crazy wife-beater that you have to keep going back to.
windows 8 was my first os and ngl i loved it too lol.. i loved playing around in the start menu, changing the sizes and moving them around
I skipped 8 cause it sucked just that bad and was used to vista and 7. Windows 7 was just that good. Also I turned on the startup sound on my windows 10
youre a child
I've used Windows 8.1 when it came out and i actually liked it It was more snappy, started way faster because of fast startup and it looked better than Windows 7 (or 10 lol) in Desktop mode. The only things I did were using Classic Shell and setting the system to boot on the desktop instead of the tiles. I compared Windows 10, Windows 8.1 and Windows 7 on a Core 2 Duo system and guess what: Windows 8.1 was the fastest
8.1 was a step in the right direction but 8.0 was horrible to work with on a desktop/laptop
Agreed If you REALLY want to cling on to Windows on a Core 2 Duo laptop, go for Windows 8.1, because its not only faster, but the driver support situation is MUCH better than Windows 10. (Also Windows 8.1 on a laptop looks really clean)
@@richard086 Yeah LOL When I bought an Acer Aspire V3 with Windows 8, I was confused for one full week LOL 😂
@@jasimaneesahamed1033 I mean I did the test on a pc but i also had it on my Core 2 Duo Laptop with Geforce graphics and i felt it being way faster than Windows 10 when that came out so i reverted back because Windows 10 had nothing more to offer on that machine
@@abchack2 I see My test Core 2 Duo laptop had a rather weak NVIDIA Quadro GPU (only 256MB of VRAM LOL)
When I remember that old tablet that still launches with windows 8, I get all nostalgic. Windows XP, 7, and 8 give me a strange feeling of comfort and being home, something way more familiar than anything else.
Apple removed the headphone jack in 2016. It's been 6 years and I've not bought an iPhone since and probably never will again. I wouldn't say they're forgiven. (Also I actually liked Windows 8 when it came out.)
I may have been a few of the people who liked using 8 also on a traditional laptop without touchscreens. I just felt like the improvements made to the desktop side were great, and the apps, altough they would get better over time (especially in 8.1), were a bit clunky but offered interesting features.
On the Surface tablet, using it was great! 😁
Same here. I've got new laptop with Win8 shortly after its launch and it was perfectly fine for me. Win8.1 was even better, but 8 was good enough. This start menu finally made me use it properly and keep the desktop clean of shortcuts - they all moved to start menu, where they belong. Maybe I didn't dislike it because I've never used Win7, but jumped to 8 from XP?
The first laptop i got was with windows 8, i loved it and mainly the startup background whitch i still use to this day. I stayed with windows 8 till i somehow managed to delete the desktop button. I had to move over to windows 10 because at that time i didnt know windows 8.1 existed.
Right, Windows 8.1 is going to go down in history as very underrated, just like a fully patched Vista install (which looks beautiful and it's actually comparable to Windows 7 in stability). On that note, Windows 8 really was the Vista of its time. It started out trash, then turned out to be one of the best things they ever made, which evolved into the best overall release to date (Vsita went to Win7, 8.1 to 10).
Windows 8 was underrated. People hated it for things missing that were actually implented but just needed to be enabled... I hated Windows 8.1 though as it caused massive performance issues. Windows 8 was smooth, just needed a couple of days to be accustomed to it. The main issue with Windows 8 though was that a lot of softwares were just incompatible which torped Windows 8.
I installed Windows 8.1 again after years of using Windows 10, as it's still supported and perfectly compatible with modern software. Just because Windows 10's default UI is better suited to traditional PCs at launch doesn't mean that Microsoft hasn't made bad decisions with the feature updates of Windows 10 over the years. Feature updates that are frankly more suited to the mobile market than the PC market (once again). One of these changes that Microsoft made to Windows 10, that infuriates me to no end, was removing Control Panel settings and moving them to their universal Settings app, where they're significantly less in-depth and less intuitive. Another was reverting user changes back to defaults after every major update. So yes, while Microsoft did make the UI more friendly to PC users, the way it has treated the end-user is more reminiscent of how Apple and Google treat their mobile users.
+
Funniest most stupid sht is... The control panel is still there! it's the same as it's been since windows 95! but now windows has this dumbed down version of it on top, right now I make most of the things on the dumbed down version but if you want to make more "advanced" stuff there is this "advanced settings" options somewhere hidden in the win 10/11 config options which when clicked will bring you to... The old control panel! 😂 It's still there! And the deeper you go the more the old windows keep showing! I recently had a problem with my audio settings and it came a point where the thing I needed (the audio mixer) was after a ton of clicking, still the same old little window that has existed since the old days! And that is my complain since windows 8, instead of actually tweaking the ui, they just added a new one on top! You'd guess they would improve it over the years but win 11 came and the good old windows 95 is still there buried under a pretty ui...
I kind of can't stand Windows 10. Windows Defender is NOT Malwarebytes. Having it built into Windows 10 required me to go through a great ordeal to disable it so that I could run programs I wanted without having them deleted.
In 10 just place a control panel icon in the taskbar... problem solved.
The sad thing is, Windows 8/8.1 still had gestures and stuff that 10-11 doesn't. In that way, 8's interface is still best for tablets.
8:28 COIN-SIDED
The most sensible way would have been keeping the start menu and have tiles at the same time. The concept of tiles is not bad, having all your most accessed programs, and stuff right at the front and easy access. But the start menu still contains nearly everything you need to use a pc, from launching programs to device manager can be accessed easily and with familiarity. Combining the two would have been genius, which is exactly what happened in win10. Nowadays, I seldom use start menu and have my most accessed programs in taskbar, when combined as a single icons for multiple instances makes multitasking so much easier. But if i ever need start menu to access some more obscure stuff, I can still use it. Heck, a fully fleshed out windows defender itself is a godsend and win8 should be praised for that alone.
13:55 The *Audacity* of making programs an app!
The only Windows 8 device I wanted to get is those AIO desktops that had a touch screen because that’s the only way to really use the OS lol
I actually really like Windows 8. It didn't start out like that though. I remember Christmas of 2012, opening a brand new Acer Aspire One. I was 13 and practically over the moon with excitement as I booted it up, only to have my hopes dashed with such extreme confusion as Windows 8 began it's setup. I struggled hard to adapt and learn the new UI, but I eventually mastered it. I definitely ignored the app parts of it though haha. I still downloaded everything traditionally from a website. I again feel the same with Windows 10. I hate it. So much. Even though I've been using Windows 10 for years, I still find myself dragging my mouse to the upper rightside trying to bring up the UI.
I genuinely prefer windows 8, dx12 lags a lot for me and 8.1 is just better for me in general.
I did it quite like it from the very beginning. I mean, it's not like the start menu now being in fullscreen makes a major difference since you can still see all your important stuff in it anyway, but it also has some improvements in its file explorer and generally it doesn't look and feel too bad either. Well, in comparison to Windows 7 I still prefer 7 but at least Windows 8 is such a big upgrade over Windows 10 though. I would choose Windows 8 over 10 any day.
Shhh
Shhh
5:18 "tablets would make PC's obsolete" lol as if 😂😂😂
Lol ikr. It didn't happened.
Hi! Thank you for your video! Regarding Apps: Apps have no place in Windows, it should have been normal programs only. What are the benefits of apps in Windows for the user, or in other desktop-OS for that matter? Regarding Win 8: I don´t like to be "told" that I don´t need a start meny. So I never installed any version of Win 8. I stuck with Windows 7. For the same reason I will never install Windows 11, a bloatware OS with the startmeny "forced" to be in the middle of the screen. Or was it the taskbar that couldn’t be moved? I don’t rember. Users simply don´t need to be told where they want the icons or start meny to be. Users know this for them self. The start meny should be able to be put in the middle of the screen if one wished. Without installing/buying third party programs. I also don’t care, at all, about MS Bing, Edge, Onedrive or all the other ”services” I’m being told that I ”need”. I also never listen to marketing from companies when trademark-names or logos are changed, when they claim I "need" their products or that everyone "should" have a pad or a certain TV-size or electric car, Facebook-account or whatever. I just ignore such childish claims. (And, by the way, I still have a phone with 3,5" connector for headset 😅 (Samsung A52). BR
Windows 8 was actually the OS that finally convinced me to switch to Mac, after being a Windows / PC guy since MS-DOS 5 and Windows 3.0. Although, by that time, I also had access to the just-released Windows 10. .... But that was a similarly awful experience. I had already jumped ship and bought a MacBook Pro when I tried 10, and decided to try it in Boot Camp / VMware Fusion. Within an hour of having it installed, Microsoft Office had already broken my Windows user profile to the point I couldn't access the Start menu. So I wiped the partition, installed Windows 7, and eventually relegated it to a VM that I kept running in the background, but only used when I absolutely had to run Windows-specific software. I don't miss any of it. AFAIC, Windows 7 was the end of the line.
What threw me off with Windows 8 was the removal of the Start Menu, and that it booted directly to that fullscreen apps tile list. But I ended on keeping using it because I had no choice and it grew on me. Windows 10 was definitely their saving grace.
Even though I didn't like windows 8, I still like windows 8.1 due to it's interface looking like it's a mix of windows 7 and 10 (Except the start menu)
I used 8 and 8.1 on a laptop and used classicshell (now open shell) to get a proper start menu Still use OpenShell on 10 to this day, I will use the 2 panel start menu until I die
@@CaptainApathetic I'm using 8.1 as my main OS right now, and yeah, it ain't bad at all! Feels like a modern Windows 7. However, instead of OpenShell, in my case I went with StartIsBack+
@@polytelus I phrased that as if I meant windows 8 lol I meant I still use OpenShell. Have 11 installed on a separate drive but it needs a bit of a workaround to get functional but when I use Windows it's usually 10 Linux is my daily driver OS for most stuff
I think if they released 8 RTM with all the features that the 8.1 updates brought, things might have turned out a lot differently. I love the fullscreen side-scrolling apps of the Metro design and wish that it was successful, but I recognize that is very much a minority opinion.
I was little when Windows 8 came out (I'm 16 now) and I remember it not that fondly. We had this Toshiba laptop that had win8 installed and it sucked (both the laptop and the OS) but me being like 5 years old of course didn't care. My mom used it and I just remember playing games on it sometimes. Eventually it was handed down to me and by that time it had upgraded to win10 (which was better) It still has the 8 sticker on the bottom. (We stopped using the laptop years ago. RIP my Toshiba) Other than that my prime memory of Windows 8 is this one time when I tried to watch a Brainpop video and it bluescreened. Side note: I consider Windows 7 my "childhood" OS because the laptop i used most had it. I did use XP as well but only when I was super small. My clearest memory was renaming Internet Explorer to "gemes" because I wanted to play games (but didn't know where to search for them I guess...)
Windows 8.x was misunderstood. It's most likely the fastest version of Windows they ever shipped, and with some work, you can have the positives of Windows 10 with the look and feel of Windows 7.
Windows 8 was horrible, no arguments there But Windows 8.1 is, just like you said, the most polished and refined version of Windows to date. Also, I actually kinda like the Start screen on Windows 8.1.
When I first built my desktop, 8.1 was still a few months away. In the end I decided to just go with Ubuntu because of how much trouble I'd seen with 8 and its lack of start menu especially. As soon as 8.1 dropped, though, I opted to give it a go. Literally all it took to change my mind was that the start menu came back.
16:14 wait a minute, apple removed the headphone jack in 2016?? I could've sworn they removed them in 2019
i remember i used to have an windows phone, it had windows 8 in, and god it was an disaster the limitations were many, the app store was empty, the UX design was so hard to get, like, things were messy i recal seeing my friends getting subway surf on their samsung or iphones, and then when i search for it, nothing they really felt like it was going to be the future, but anyone who had those was frustrated