The most interesting thing to me about Lynch's Dune is how he really made an effort to give voice to Paul's thoughts. That's one thing that stuck out in the book, is how much of the narrative is comprised of each character's internal thoughts
@dannyt466311 ай бұрын
Yes the older film has good content that the newer one doesn't. But I have to favour Denis Villeneuve's newest remake as it's a great visual masterpiece with a great sound, without much special effects either and a real made dummy ornithopter! For a film in whole that's not easy to portray to the book. Just a shame about missing some scenes in the first part with the conservatory and the party.
@StoreyR8 ай бұрын
Nah. Paul's internal thoughts are ventured enough by artistic visions that actually mean something to the narrative. Villeneuve in EVERY DAMN WAY
@empyrean-jamelgreaves80344 ай бұрын
@@empyrean-jamelgreaves8034The studios in 1984 wouldn't let him make a movie longer than 2hr20. If Lynch was allowed to make a 5 hour version it would be a much different movie.
@bearstromwanderer47733 ай бұрын
It was an impossible task but you gotta hand it to David for trying, I’m glad this version exists and to use an internet idiom: Lynch’s Dune walked so Villenuve’s Dune could run
@SuPeRNinJaRed3 ай бұрын
@@empyrean-jamelgreaves8034 David: *Uses shonen anime-esque voice-overs to voice Paul’s thoughts* Denis: Voice-overs are for pussies
@mackielunkey22052 ай бұрын
I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.
@Crosmando5 жыл бұрын
La petite mort (the little death) is an expression which means "the brief loss or weakening of consciousness" and in modern usage refers specifically to "the sensation of post orgasm as likened to death." It's like he had to fist fuck that old bitch without jizzing in his pants to prove himself. A task many of us have failed in life.
@Thallod4 жыл бұрын
@@Thallod yes. But no.
@shithoagie3 жыл бұрын
Im not a big fan like yall i just started reading the book but through you guys enthusiasm abt this series it looks like u guys really appreciate the wolrd
@registeredsexoffende2 жыл бұрын
One of the best passages I've ever read in a book. It's honestly so fucking inspiring haha
@joefriedman98437 ай бұрын
When you get the Covid test in your nose
@OfficialRibbitNixon3 жыл бұрын
Idk how any of you niggas put up with that lmao
@traviousandrews10152 жыл бұрын
jesus this is so accurate lmfao
@volpemarroneveloce59282 жыл бұрын
the pain!!!!
@z_man19002 жыл бұрын
it really do be uncomfortable tho
@micanikko2 жыл бұрын
“I hold at your neck the Pfizer”
@smartstudyingdoggo90312 жыл бұрын
"I remember your Gom Jabbar. Now you'll remember mine"
@WORMRIDERfedaykin5 жыл бұрын
S I L E N C E ! ! !
@tStevester833 жыл бұрын
I can kill with a word!
@matthewcooper42482 жыл бұрын
And how could this be!!?? Because he is the kwizats haddirack!!
@StoreyR10 ай бұрын
*unzips pants*
@Gymkage-ku8wk2 ай бұрын
@@Gymkage-ku8wk Pulls it out
@stellviahohenheim2 ай бұрын
THE PAIIIINNNNN!
@solgoode17 жыл бұрын
I love you ! Made my day
@elisedonelson11277 жыл бұрын
ha ha thanks : )
@solgoode17 жыл бұрын
@Reee Monro oh god, not those!
@shithoagie3 жыл бұрын
Tommy gun!!
@GDD12312 жыл бұрын
lolol 🤣 I can't ...
@claretheworm2 жыл бұрын
And the next day, Child Protective Services came and took Paul away.
@robertmiles99423 жыл бұрын
And put him in foster care where his circumstance got much worse.
@sourcandy3042 ай бұрын
to live with his grandfather
@enriquepelenato4956Ай бұрын
"They tried and failed?" "They tried and died." That is an underrated line.
@MatthewChenault3 жыл бұрын
yeam man when i read that line i was like 😱
@registeredsexoffende2 жыл бұрын
It rhymes!
@DoctorFurioso2 жыл бұрын
Explain why it's good. . It's sad brah
@plasmapanasonic4741 Жыл бұрын
"You'll die If you try!" -Pennywise.
@thrustinjustin51152 ай бұрын
@@thrustinjustin5115 "We all float in beer!" -Poundfoolish
@Nefylym2 ай бұрын
Beer is the mind killer. Beer is the little death that brings total obliteration.
@URProductions2 жыл бұрын
Total intoxication
@Pyrus4252 жыл бұрын
Total inebriation
@henlolimbo50882 жыл бұрын
Total inebri…(hic) ation.
@sandywaddell43039 ай бұрын
_Cerveza Cristal!_ 🎵🎶💪
@Brandon.S.Brooker2 ай бұрын
They tried and died? Worse. They went bankrupt.
@WieldingEminatorАй бұрын
Why on earth are people acting like this is even close to the book? Did yall notice she used the voice and he straight up said no.
@garretthaslam38692 жыл бұрын
I noticed that years ago. I like the movie but it wasn't that faithful. But I give credit
@IDKeffect822 ай бұрын
Lynch did the absolute best that he could. He got wholeheartedly screwed by this movie, it’s production, and more importantly: the studio. There isn’t a single director on earth who could’ve made 1984 Dune good. In fact, I think this is the absolute best we could’ve gotten from anyone at all in 1984. As dated as it look now? For ‘84? This was way ahead of its time. The issue starts with the fact that Dune is easily the single most unadaptable piece of sci-fi history ever written. The first book is written in such a way that trying to cram all of that world building, lore, character development into one movie and keeping it interesting/well paced the whole way through is literally not even a probable task to accomplish. It’s why Denis only tackled Book 1 of the first book for the 2021 movie, and left books 2 & 3 from Dune 1 for the sequel movie that just came out this year. As far as I know, Lynch intended to do something similar. Or to at least make the movie longer to allow better implementation of all the stuff he wanted in. The studio allowed him neither. They told him “get it done in one movie, and don’t let it linger for any longer than 2 hours and 30 minutes.” Soooo yea, Lynch got screwed. Now facing the daunting task of adapting the one franchise that by now is easily the single most non-conducive to live action adaptations. AND he had to do it in ONE movie. With ONLY 2 hours and 30 mins of run time. All while trying to pull off 230th century technology/visuals with 1984 cinema technology 😂 Yea, have fun making a good movie out of /that/ particular list of ingredients 😂
@antonradke59432 ай бұрын
@@antonradke5943 Denis Villenueve was crafting together the real made Ornithopter in 2018, he had the baron put on make up that taken 7 hours to get dressed, he had over 200 costume clothing designs. He had all the money thrown at his film to make sure he got his audience.
@StoreyR2 ай бұрын
@antonradke5943 I love Lynch's work on this. I consider it a gift, a "possible future," along with the new amazing Dune films. Lynch did the impossible, and it's burned into my memory in a good way.
@kwisatzhaderach14582 ай бұрын
He was able to Partially resist because He Too Had Bene Geiseret powers......Not Fully Developed and still in it's early stages. You heard the Reverend mother Acknowledge that he was strong, but resistance was Futile in the end.
@Sidewinder5282 ай бұрын
Lynch crawled on his knees so Villeneuve could fly. This is what Villeneuve watched in order to see what did and didn't work. Very useful to have it there as a warning. Like LA Takedown for Michael Mann's Heat.
@thesprawl23612 ай бұрын
yet way more memorable this one than Villeneuve's
@francescomalagoli24672 ай бұрын
@@francescomalagoli2467cap
@ucihasasuke-oo2ti2 ай бұрын
Omg stop with this revisionism stuff. It doesn't make you interresting when you say that this version is more "memorable". It is a flawed movie that everyone, including Lynch, barely remembers. We're only talking about it now because of Villeneuve's movies.@@francescomalagoli2467
@Zenthils2 ай бұрын
@@francescomalagoli2467 Maybe, but it's a shite film.
@thesprawl23612 ай бұрын
@@thesprawl2361 i prefer shite than bland
@francescomalagoli24672 ай бұрын
Box: "CLI'CHUNK". Rev Mother: "Put your hand in the box". Audience: "Hell No!". Brilliant how Lynch tapped into the viewer's primal sense of fight or flight to illustrate the concept of the test.
@MrGrizzle3052 жыл бұрын
DV's version of the Reverend Mother Gaius was very brutal, intimidating and frightening.
@margauxmilan2 жыл бұрын
To the uninitiated, perhaps
@ormand30002 жыл бұрын
Exact opposite of the word, “Mother”. That’s an accurate portrayal, of how some children are treated…not respected as human beings, but being threatened into submission. Very sad indeed
@1Kings222 жыл бұрын
They still never got her look right though. The book clearly states she looked like an old witch from a fairytale, dressed in a black hooded robe. In the movies it seems they always insisted on making her look weird/funny instead.
@Slashco2 жыл бұрын
she is the best
@nayrtnartsipacify Жыл бұрын
As she should be. Bene Gesserit have a reputation of "witches". What is less known is that they are experienced fighters as well (which is supported by the fact that they have extended control over their muscles and biochemistry). While it is not impossible to kill a Reverend Mother, someone who is not trained enough (and Paul at this moment has no precognition nor Fremen training, only traditional Atreides training plus bits and pieces that his mother taught) has no chance in single combat. So it's pretty much a "mother" that can break your neck while sipping her tea. Or command you to break your own neck, if you're not strong-willed enough (and even Paul who was aware of the Voice couldn't resist it entirely).
@andrewmelnikov292 Жыл бұрын
I love this film, the new films are incredible. It's like seeing 2 possible futures.
@kwisatzhaderach14582 ай бұрын
The clang of the box opening when she says, "You see this?" Scariest sound. It always made me think there was a spring loaded blade inside.
@radrickdavis2 жыл бұрын
3:10 MCU fans watching a movie without bombastic action and jokes
@qtarokujo36942 жыл бұрын
LMAO
@brianm31602 жыл бұрын
3:10 Snyder fans when a movie Isn't monochrome
@Ale-dd3ek2 жыл бұрын
Nolan fans when they see CGI
@jesuschrystler777 Жыл бұрын
TikTok kids when the movie doesn't have a split screen with minecraft parkour to watch when they lose attention after 20 seconds.
@joshuafischer68410 ай бұрын
HAHAHAHA
@nobodycares67612 ай бұрын
In the Dune novels , in princess Irulan's commentary about this incident, I always remember how she described the Bene Gesserit's huge mistakes & neglect about Paul's test. Even the Reverend Mother noted that no one had ever withstood that level of pain from the Box and lived. The Bene Gesserit were so determined to kill Paul , they had such fear of his potential that they abandonded their detachment to skew the test & hide its results thereafter. If you know the story it became apparent why they feared him.
@subliteral11 ай бұрын
How do they no when to stop the test? Did the rev mother stop the rest earlier for the others?
@wisdomseeker014210 ай бұрын
@wisdomseeker0142 I'm not sure Frank Herbert went into detail about that. Even the mechanism of the pain box itself was a closely guarded secret of the order.
@subliteral10 ай бұрын
She cranked the box up to 11 just for Paul. He got the bonus plan.
@richard499110 ай бұрын
I just finished Dune Messiah. I can now see why they didnt trust him at all 😂
@DivinityAwakened2 ай бұрын
This scene was so creepy in the new version. Came here to compare the two.
@CeruleanFilms2 жыл бұрын
new one gave me goosebumps. Such a powerful scene in the new one
@Megatronacsbb2 жыл бұрын
Ikr I really like the short words conversation in the new one They didn't have to say much and yet you feel the pressure like they mean business!
@ryumii17012 жыл бұрын
@@ryumii1701 Plus the idea of this ghostly figure veiled in black and wielding some eldritch psychic power... took me right back to the Witch King of Angmar in LOTR.
@CeruleanFilms2 жыл бұрын
@@ryumii1701 yeah . Like everything said here , you feel it through the character's stares and expressions
@vedaryan3342 жыл бұрын
Yes
@jessica54972 жыл бұрын
I think both this and the 2021 film emphasize different elements that work to their benefit. I think this does a better job emphasizing the pain and the burning nature of the test, as well as how Paul is exceptional in his performance. On the other hand 2021 does a better job emphasizing Paul rising above his instincts and using his mind to control himself.
@kundlas1002 жыл бұрын
dune 2021 sucked man.
@ReonKad32 жыл бұрын
@@ReonKad3 No.
@Fjgjgjd2 жыл бұрын
@@ReonKad3 Yeah it just didn't suck though did it ? knob
@joshhobson23402 жыл бұрын
THE PAINNNNNNNN
@kaltsssit2 жыл бұрын
Oh dear. I think Dune 2021 did a so much better job than this one. This looks like child's play in comparison.
@Scorpiotide2 жыл бұрын
- They tried and died! - I shall not!!! - Die? - No...try. See ya!
@anibaldk Жыл бұрын
Lynch's Dune may look grotesque in 2024 (especially when compared to Villeneuve's Dune), but I can imagine how mindblowing it was back then.
@RayPall2 ай бұрын
Much of the look of the film comes directly from Frank Herbert who consulted on the sets and costumes. For all of its flaws, Lynch's Dune looks the most like what Herbert saw in his mind when he wrote the book.
@tmage232 ай бұрын
It doesn't look grotesque, it looks unique and fantastic with its baroque influences in set design and costumes. Some of the shots in this film are inspired artistry, the Atreides ships boarding the Guild Heighliner, the Navigator's audience with the Emperor. Yes the special effects are dated, but they still show style and imagination. In a few ways the film surpasses the latest remake.
@mistert8002 ай бұрын
It’s ok. There’s 40 years of cinematography in between. Things evolve and it is good so. Comparing is stupid. Lynch did his job back then and Villenueve did his now
@fabios.35102 ай бұрын
I just realized that most of the dialogue is taken straight out of the book
@fakebroccoli7635 Жыл бұрын
This movie was ahead of its time. Lynch really did great with the available technology and techniques available at the time. This is a masterpiece in its own rights. DV has also created a masterpiece for modern audiences , I cannot wait for part 2 , November can't come fast enough.
@crimsonhakik123410 ай бұрын
it's crazy how they created the shields.
@zohanrock2 ай бұрын
To think the original airdates is in november, we could've gotten it sooner 😭
@andhikap56962 ай бұрын
Usul no longer needs the weirding module
@PerryGomez77713 күн бұрын
The best thing about this movie was Francesca Annis. In the book the lady Jessica was described as having a natural elegance and regal beauty that would allow her to outshine almost all other women around her, even wearing the simplest of clothes and regalia. [she could wear a peasants clothes and still look like lady of the highest rank] …… I was 21 years old watching this in the cinema and I remember being stunned by her elegance and beauty in this movie. As a young man who only had eyes for young women of my age I think that this was the 1st time I realised that an older mature woman could hold such beauty.
@robg52110 ай бұрын
Well said! Hers was a unique type of beauty.
@mrs.chaffee35177 ай бұрын
you would be considered a newbie in today's times
@blueshit1992 ай бұрын
As much as people give this movie hate, its not appreciated enough for what the director was trying to accomplish. He originally want to do 3 movies as well to do the story right. But the studio wouldn't let him.
@ausername74702 ай бұрын
Channel 4 1991 maybe? This film came on and changed my life. Few weeks later The spice must flow by EON came on pirate radio. When he says THE PAIN - for the first time something actually came close to describing the complete and utter black void that was inside me waiting to be released after a terrible loss in the spring of 1990. That feeling never went but on the 17th birthday of my youngest child of four kids, 30 odd years later. Laid out loads of photos on the table and made something that lifted some of the pain out of me. Print out your photos, get them out of your phones. When my wee ones years later would say dad - i'm not in the mood. MOOD? MOOD? would give 'em a sqeeze & pretend i was Gurney. The new films don't deal with the guild navigators true to the book. Many machines on IX. Saw the Dune 2 at the IMAX waterloo last week, best seats in the house. Special effects and sounds were stunning and the final man to man fight scene is a bit more aggressive and realistic than Lynch's film but it cannot beat the feeling you get in the original when Paul uses his voice to crush Feyd!!!! Wish the new film had that. But TOTO's music, Brian Eno's perfection. From start to finish the original film is EPIC and I feel truer to the book with the voiceovers. Highlander, Point Break and then Fifth Element later were my references (so many others too) . What is great is that we all have our own ones for different reasons. Covid stopped me from seeing Dune in march 2020 in Greenwich Picturehouse - David Lynch celebration sadly got cancelled. So many great films are being lost because of streaming & modern attitudes to older special effects cinemas should wake up to the demand that would be out there for big screen showings of 'older' films. Love you Chico & RoRo xx
@PerryGomez77713 күн бұрын
Fear is the Mind Killer!!!!!
@Jazzman-bj9fq6 жыл бұрын
And pain is for slaves and loosers
@comicszoneuniverse2 ай бұрын
This movie looks amazing. I love how both dune movies have their own style and how they tell the story, but they're both get everything so right when it matters
@twitchgiggles2 жыл бұрын
I saw it when I was like 10 years old
@sweetsalvation71432 жыл бұрын
@@cicolas_nage you have no taste, stick to anime
@yyguuyg Жыл бұрын
@@cicolas_nage as mentioned stick to anime or tiktok crap. They suit you better 🖕
@maggs131 Жыл бұрын
@@cicolas_nage the effects do not hold up but the accuracy and also the performances are reasonably good
@lordsathariel438411 ай бұрын
@@cicolas_nage This movie is a cult classic. It came out competing against Star Wars. Wonder what the budget difference was.
@crimsonhakik123410 ай бұрын
I've experienced pain through nerve induction. It can be a side effect of a misaligned transcranial magnetic stimulation device. It doesn't feel like burning, it's a sharp, stabbing pain.
@hlalakar41562 жыл бұрын
It depends on what nerves are being induced... think of how capsaicin produces a burning sensation (but not effect!) and how menthol produces a cooling sense.
@paulbrookfield41332 жыл бұрын
@@paulbrookfield4133 I meant in my specific case.
@hlalakar41562 жыл бұрын
@DeadNinjutsu Oh, when I said a sharp stabbing pain I was just describing the kind of pain, not the intensity. It really didn't hurt very badly. And it was just a slight misalignment of the device. They repositioned it a little bit and the pain stopped. The therapy actually worked very well for me.
@hlalakar41562 жыл бұрын
@DeadNinjutsu Well thank you, I appreciate your concern. I'm actually having it done again right now, as the effects can eventually wear off over the years.
@hlalakar41562 жыл бұрын
This weirdly reminds me of the hand burning scene in Fight Club
@CCGdude093 жыл бұрын
3:10 when I hit my little toe into a door
@jakobatredies11143 жыл бұрын
😂😂😂
@MZ996982 жыл бұрын
"I must not fear the door."
@ozenthelewdable54272 ай бұрын
Best scene in that movie. There were a few other scenes that captured the books essence but the rest of the movie missed the target. I hope the next rendition does a better.
@draweveryday47105 жыл бұрын
Actually I found the movie great and watched it several times. But I still haven't read the book... Would be interesting to see Dune of Denis Villeneuve when it will be released.
@kirillt2565 жыл бұрын
@@kirillt256 agreed.
@draweveryday47105 жыл бұрын
This scene, in particular, was so much more like the book than the mini series version. I think that is one of the reasons that I like it. Then again, the miniseries had Ian McNeice as Baron Harkonnen so there is that in it's favor.
@bromixsr5 жыл бұрын
@@kirillt256 "but I still haven't read the book" dawg what the fuck
@mysticblade354 жыл бұрын
@@kirillt256 I read the book the only really major difference was Paul's rainmaking miracle at the end and the sound guns, which were awesome in their own right.
@gilbertgotfried4 жыл бұрын
Sian Phillips. Amazing performance.
@clungeest2 жыл бұрын
The whole cast was amazing, much better then the new Dunes cast. I really tried to like the new movie, but I just couldn't get over the fact that he glazed over so much detail that this movie went into. and set production in the 84 version to me was so much better.
@ileria32 жыл бұрын
Watch her performance in the Masterpiece Theater series "I, Claudius" as Livia, wife of Augustus.
@caronstout35411 ай бұрын
Lot of thanks for the upload.
@FUZATl9 жыл бұрын
Patrick Stewart's most underrated role
@benmortimer5 ай бұрын
💀
@grzegorzbrzeczyszczykiewic11392 ай бұрын
Lol
@phillawrence51482 ай бұрын
I tried not to think of the words "sear" and "flesh".
@KnightofDuroch6 жыл бұрын
Just saw the new one. Seeing this makes me not want to compare, because the more recent one is pretty damn good
@brandonWilliams-yr4re2 жыл бұрын
I appreciate Lynch's attempt to stay true to the text, but the results range from effective to super clunky in motion
@MichaelFreckelton2 жыл бұрын
I like in DV version Paul actual stares down the Reverend Mother wish Lynch had directed Kyle MacLaghlan to do the same. I do prefer Lynch has Paul deliver the “I must not fear…”
@AtlasShrugged20053 ай бұрын
I like the detailing on the costumes, especially the netting around her wrists and neck. One of the redeeming qualities of the Lynch Dune is that there are some remarkable costumes.
@lordfreerealestate8302 Жыл бұрын
I know Lynch's version gets lambasted but in fairness, it did stick quite rigidly to some of the concepts in the book. I think when you break it down to the basic story and then layer the intricacies of things like the Gom Jabbar and The Voice on top, you are getting somewhat there with Dune. I hope DVs version, while being hugely epic, will at least come back to these smaller moments as often as the book does. But will it be voiceovers?
@joecantdance4943 жыл бұрын
Indeed, I do not understand the criticism. It is somewhat simplified, with some fancy additions, but also some that have gained iconic status since... plus the unique aesthetics... I think that its shortcomings are down to the fact that it was to be pared down to a little over 2 hours, which is simply inadequate. I have cut my own version, spliced in the leftovers and the result is epic... As for David Villeneuve's take... he had promised that it would be something like "Star Wars for adults", and I only hope that by that he did not mean swapping white men for black women... Whatever the result, such forced racist contortions can spoil any masterpiece. "Star Wars" is a bit infantile swashbuckling stunt by George Lucas... and Dune is anything but that.
@martinrapavy98153 жыл бұрын
I reread the book this past year, after first reading it 50 years ago. It is incredibly episodic, as if F. H. were writing for storyboards
@dougr.23982 жыл бұрын
@@dougr.2398 That's a very good point. The structure is very set out, as if he was thinking visually, especially in the earlier chapters. I mean, the story is all there, I see no reason for DV to deviate from it. It's the thing that annoys me most about adaptations of things like The War of the Worlds. The story is "all there", no need to sprinkle it with hollywood moondust
@joecantdance4942 жыл бұрын
@@joecantdance494 thank you, JCD
@dougr.23982 жыл бұрын
The movie looks dated, but this particular scene I found to be much better than the 2021 version
@mrmr46222 жыл бұрын
And Paul took that personally.
@gottesurteil3201Ай бұрын
Love this version. Sian Phillips is magnificent.
@grahamfunnell559010 ай бұрын
One of the best scenes from a beloved film.
@paulwilliamson66602 жыл бұрын
What's in the box maaan, what's in the booox?!
@jasonfenton82506 жыл бұрын
Horatio Nelson literally nothing, they cause a burning sensation not from sticking your hand in, but from her mental SUGGESTION, as she describes your hand slowly but surely burning away. The test is see your willpower and if you recoil back, your neck gets hit with the Gom Jabaar ( *A very powerful poison* ) in question and you die as a beast would as the poison is meant to kill animals.
@boxtank52886 жыл бұрын
@@boxtank5288 it was a reference to the movie 7 also there is probably a lot of complex technologies in the box
@rhorynotmylastname77815 жыл бұрын
@@rhorynotmylastname7781 I know I'm just answering for those who had no idea and I'm about to edit that reply because I'm just now seeing all the time as where Google Voice fucked up. And its Bene Gesserit Mind Fuckery that ensures you FEEL the hand burn even though its effectively a simple box.
@boxtank52885 жыл бұрын
@@boxtank5288 oh okay sry
@rhorynotmylastname77815 жыл бұрын
I love how Villeneuve took the same camera plans for that.
@ikagura2 ай бұрын
I never noticed that because ive never seen the original movie
@MABGaming012 ай бұрын
IMO what makes this scene and movie so powerful is the "gravitas" of the actors. The acting of this Reverend mother is so underrated. Jurgen Pronchow and Patrick Stewart,Jose Ferrer as well. I hope that the actors in this new movie can live up to that.
@Buckwhizzle2 жыл бұрын
Here from the future. They did.
@MrImastinker2 жыл бұрын
@@MrImastinker not really
@votdfak2 жыл бұрын
@@votdfak Oh yes they did. Look, the 1984 film has its moments, but the new film is already a better adaptation.
@MrImastinker2 жыл бұрын
It doesn’t. The cinematography is (somewhat) better but that’s about it.
@bcm39382 жыл бұрын
@@bcm3938 “somewhat better” How’re y’all in such blatant denial 😭
@abhirupan76302 жыл бұрын
This scene made me want to watch the film. My science teacher showed it to us as an example of nerves being used to transmit pain without actual damage and after school i went in search of the film
@Dracojax9 ай бұрын
Jesus, this is very very very the book! I dont understand why people hate that movie as much i heard but to me always seem' very accurated and honest with the original spirit! Great!
@OluapOirevlis4 жыл бұрын
The problem is that the first two thirds of the film are close enough to the book that it makes the discrepancies of the last third (the time skip and the rain are two major ones) very blatant. It's a good film, but one that is severely marred when it's earlier attempts to be close to the book are abandoned due to severe time constraints. It's more a problem with the medium than the people involved, most likely.
@Thomiroth4 жыл бұрын
@Bad Cattitude thoughts on the new trailer
@alejandrorivas45853 жыл бұрын
Except the end. And the “killing word” weirding module thing.
@paynehollis3 жыл бұрын
@@alejandrorivas4585 it looks dark. like, really dark. like the director kept calling the visual design team to say that it wasn't colored dark enough.
@steveairport3 жыл бұрын
the visual design was so impressive though...
@murunbuchstanzangur3 жыл бұрын
More class than the other movies!
@carthainian3 ай бұрын
Hector Salamanca to Mike: " And the Gom Jabbar is yours"
@PiedrasdeSopa762 жыл бұрын
Internal dialogue aside, this scene have more of the important pieces from the conversation that new version omitted.
@AdamMichalMarkowski10 ай бұрын
In I, Claudius, Sian sits in a side room in a palace, and tells Livilla, who steps into the room, frightened and hesitant...”come here” in a creepy voice.
@planetoftheatheists68584 жыл бұрын
I still tell myself, “fear is the mind killer” to this day.
@brianplunkett40022 ай бұрын
Still phenomenal acting after so many years
@dougr.23982 жыл бұрын
Damn the boy was so pretty that even in pain he looked great
@jjax7894Ай бұрын
I wish it was complete. I love the line about "it kills only animals."
@SidneyBroadshead Жыл бұрын
I feel like so much of the success of the remake's version of this scene comes from the Reverend Mother only describing the consequence of failure. It plays into her dark ambitions and the more dim tone of the lighting and wardrobe.
@walpurgisnight72 ай бұрын
THE PAIN!!!!!!
@SmithFilms20094 жыл бұрын
I thoroughly enjoy Kyle MacLachlan's acting
@jasv49Ай бұрын
Fear is the mind killer.
@RICKONORATO11 ай бұрын
Strange. What I got out of this scene is Paul's mother is the damn most beautiful actress I've ever seen. Yeah, there are younger actresses that are hotter but I'm talking timeless, classical beauty.
@kyleklintok77302 жыл бұрын
In both films
@CalvinHikes Жыл бұрын
U would think in 10191 they'd have better dentistry for the bene desert.
@charlesgrimm73822 ай бұрын
*Snaps lights off* "Step into the room." "What's in the room?" "Pain." LEGOOOOOs
@heckinmemes64302 жыл бұрын
What does this scene teach us THAT IT'S ALL IN THE MIND.
@senorital.58062 ай бұрын
The thumbnail is meme material.
@Squishy_Seal2 жыл бұрын
My favorite part was when the reverend mother said “it’s Gom Jabarrin’ time” and the Gom Jabarred all over the place.
@peterslaby97822 ай бұрын
"just a sec my nose itches"...
@D00m0g2 жыл бұрын
Master piece.
@justme1975113 жыл бұрын
All our love to Anne...
@jagoq532 ай бұрын
I just like Lynch's version better than the new one, and I'm not even sure why. It's weirder I guess.
@JasonHauser1252 ай бұрын
That’s always been my feeling, too. There’s just something about the new one that feels too accessible and pedestrian to me- whereas with Lynch’s version I really feel like I’m watching something based in a different time, another culture(s), with gesticulations and ways of speech that are truly of another world. But I think you put it best, “it’s weirder”, and that makes it much more interesting.
@STARLIGHTCANDY4u2 ай бұрын
Doesn't mean its better lol.
@aaron64312 ай бұрын
sheer magic
@rowancoggins96382 жыл бұрын
The captain.
@khai-yuenloh6692 жыл бұрын
Dune 2021 winn
@rodrigomoran57032 жыл бұрын
Non
@tatooetugo3 ай бұрын
Wow
@resurreccion95662 ай бұрын
Круто!
@Mitol01 Жыл бұрын
THE PAIN
@dbldekr2 ай бұрын
The 2021 scene was just so much better
@kidreaper78542 ай бұрын
says who?
@slowswimmer91692 ай бұрын
THE PAIN!
@Luke-db9fc2 ай бұрын
When you accidentally break a window pane with a normal pickaxe instead of the one with Silk Touch: *THE PANE*
@bush_kit2 жыл бұрын
David Lynch's Dune is still my favorite. After all, Dune would be a dark adaptation more so than not. With the way it was written by Frank Herbert. Such an element as "the spice" that makes such things happen, would bring out the worst in human nature to rule, get and control.
@kristophermeharg70482 жыл бұрын
Yes.
@crimsonhakik123410 ай бұрын
1🇺🇲🎴& direct hit...
@khagan13342 жыл бұрын
1:42 ¡CERVEZA CRISTAL!
@HYBRID_BEING2 ай бұрын
Out of all the adaptions, Sian Philips is the best Reverend Mother. And this is my favourite version of the gom jabbar scene. As good as the mini series and latest 2 parter film are and how brilliant both Alec Newman and Timothée Chalamet are in their respective gom jabbar scenes, this one sticks out to me the most., especially this was Kyle MacLachlan's first film role. It's just so tense and brilliant! "They tried and died"....ohh shivers
@shadow_raven19832 ай бұрын
Really. I loved the books and find 2021 to be much better. The casting and costumes look a bit absurd. Their is also too much telling, and seeing what Paul is feeling in the box takes away from the suspense.
@JNB07232 ай бұрын
Agree about Sian Philps. And I didn't know this was Kyle maclachlans first film role. Cool!!
@shelleynoseworthy44842 ай бұрын
I love the fact he didn't submit to the voice at first
@layzac.39052 ай бұрын
It was through this trial of pain that he became the mayor of Portland.
@SuperlunarNim11 ай бұрын
Just a perfect scene. The acting is impecable. Camera movement is superb, the way it changes the axis simbolizing the non returning path of Paul its a true achivment, you can truly say David Lynch´s hand is here. But above all the Siân Phillips (Reverend mother) performance and dialogue makes me breathless. I am starting to think I am the only one who loves this movie. Specially over the Villeneuve´s version which makes me sick.
@blooregart2 ай бұрын
THE PAIIIIINNNN!
@davidnobre56602 жыл бұрын
Thats the oldest 15 years old guy in the history
@IwonaKlich2 ай бұрын
Timothy is older than he was in this film at 26
@nuketar2 ай бұрын
@@nuketar But he looks younger than this actor 😅
@yinloveyang2 ай бұрын
I like Paul being able to resist the voice at first till the reverend mother puts more seriousness/power/whatever into it. That was missing from the Villeneuve version.
@DonnieTNJ Жыл бұрын
Aside from him yelling "the pain" at the end. I really enjoy this depiction of the reverent mother more than the new depiction. She had that same tenderness she had in the book, but also she is still very intimidating.
@pikablu_25 Жыл бұрын
Lmao, the painnnnnn
@LegrochaTV4 жыл бұрын
Absolutely superior version.
@hunam38766 ай бұрын
Nah 2021 blows this outta the water in every way
@lucashubbard59982 ай бұрын
THE PAIN 📢📢📢📢📢📢🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
@christopherwright5762 ай бұрын
Why does Paul look same age as his mum 😂
@amachin62 ай бұрын
WHAT'S IN THE BOAAXX???
@Mj-pf6by2 жыл бұрын
Silence, silence!!!
@MackeyDeez2 жыл бұрын
Classic.
@Croiseeman2 ай бұрын
That thumbnail is the face of a man that fails to eat fibre and chew his food properly
@Balder-gb4eq11 ай бұрын
Got Jom Gabbar yesterday^^
@vladpryshlyak20253 жыл бұрын
what I liked a lot has been that the cast of actors in Dune followed Twin Peaks (as much as this could be realizable). Dune is a reference point in SciFi, pity Lynch did not manage to get it the way it was planned initially. But anyhow, have watched it probably something like 200 times.
@Psevdokranos Жыл бұрын
This actor is so good at looking afraid but not terrified…
This is a Gom Jabbar. It Jabs Goms.
Underrated comment
Gom Jabbar, the jabbar of goms
😂😂😂😂😂my god
This Is a Flammenwerfer, It Werfs Flammen
This is a stuk. It stuks
The most interesting thing to me about Lynch's Dune is how he really made an effort to give voice to Paul's thoughts. That's one thing that stuck out in the book, is how much of the narrative is comprised of each character's internal thoughts
Yes the older film has good content that the newer one doesn't. But I have to favour Denis Villeneuve's newest remake as it's a great visual masterpiece with a great sound, without much special effects either and a real made dummy ornithopter! For a film in whole that's not easy to portray to the book. Just a shame about missing some scenes in the first part with the conservatory and the party.
Nah. Paul's internal thoughts are ventured enough by artistic visions that actually mean something to the narrative. Villeneuve in EVERY DAMN WAY
@@empyrean-jamelgreaves8034The studios in 1984 wouldn't let him make a movie longer than 2hr20. If Lynch was allowed to make a 5 hour version it would be a much different movie.
It was an impossible task but you gotta hand it to David for trying, I’m glad this version exists and to use an internet idiom: Lynch’s Dune walked so Villenuve’s Dune could run
@@empyrean-jamelgreaves8034 David: *Uses shonen anime-esque voice-overs to voice Paul’s thoughts* Denis: Voice-overs are for pussies
I must not fear. Fear is the mind-killer. Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear. I will permit it to pass over me and through me. And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path. Where the fear has gone there will be nothing. Only I will remain.
La petite mort (the little death) is an expression which means "the brief loss or weakening of consciousness" and in modern usage refers specifically to "the sensation of post orgasm as likened to death." It's like he had to fist fuck that old bitch without jizzing in his pants to prove himself. A task many of us have failed in life.
@@Thallod yes. But no.
Im not a big fan like yall i just started reading the book but through you guys enthusiasm abt this series it looks like u guys really appreciate the wolrd
One of the best passages I've ever read in a book. It's honestly so fucking inspiring haha
When you get the Covid test in your nose
Idk how any of you niggas put up with that lmao
jesus this is so accurate lmfao
the pain!!!!
it really do be uncomfortable tho
“I hold at your neck the Pfizer”
"I remember your Gom Jabbar. Now you'll remember mine"
S I L E N C E ! ! !
I can kill with a word!
And how could this be!!?? Because he is the kwizats haddirack!!
*unzips pants*
@@Gymkage-ku8wk Pulls it out
THE PAIIIINNNNN!
I love you ! Made my day
ha ha thanks : )
@Reee Monro oh god, not those!
Tommy gun!!
lolol 🤣 I can't ...
And the next day, Child Protective Services came and took Paul away.
And put him in foster care where his circumstance got much worse.
to live with his grandfather
"They tried and failed?" "They tried and died." That is an underrated line.
yeam man when i read that line i was like 😱
It rhymes!
Explain why it's good. . It's sad brah
"You'll die If you try!" -Pennywise.
@@thrustinjustin5115 "We all float in beer!" -Poundfoolish
Beer is the mind killer. Beer is the little death that brings total obliteration.
Total intoxication
Total inebriation
Total inebri…(hic) ation.
_Cerveza Cristal!_ 🎵🎶💪
They tried and died? Worse. They went bankrupt.
Why on earth are people acting like this is even close to the book? Did yall notice she used the voice and he straight up said no.
I noticed that years ago. I like the movie but it wasn't that faithful. But I give credit
Lynch did the absolute best that he could. He got wholeheartedly screwed by this movie, it’s production, and more importantly: the studio. There isn’t a single director on earth who could’ve made 1984 Dune good. In fact, I think this is the absolute best we could’ve gotten from anyone at all in 1984. As dated as it look now? For ‘84? This was way ahead of its time. The issue starts with the fact that Dune is easily the single most unadaptable piece of sci-fi history ever written. The first book is written in such a way that trying to cram all of that world building, lore, character development into one movie and keeping it interesting/well paced the whole way through is literally not even a probable task to accomplish. It’s why Denis only tackled Book 1 of the first book for the 2021 movie, and left books 2 & 3 from Dune 1 for the sequel movie that just came out this year. As far as I know, Lynch intended to do something similar. Or to at least make the movie longer to allow better implementation of all the stuff he wanted in. The studio allowed him neither. They told him “get it done in one movie, and don’t let it linger for any longer than 2 hours and 30 minutes.” Soooo yea, Lynch got screwed. Now facing the daunting task of adapting the one franchise that by now is easily the single most non-conducive to live action adaptations. AND he had to do it in ONE movie. With ONLY 2 hours and 30 mins of run time. All while trying to pull off 230th century technology/visuals with 1984 cinema technology 😂 Yea, have fun making a good movie out of /that/ particular list of ingredients 😂
@@antonradke5943 Denis Villenueve was crafting together the real made Ornithopter in 2018, he had the baron put on make up that taken 7 hours to get dressed, he had over 200 costume clothing designs. He had all the money thrown at his film to make sure he got his audience.
@antonradke5943 I love Lynch's work on this. I consider it a gift, a "possible future," along with the new amazing Dune films. Lynch did the impossible, and it's burned into my memory in a good way.
He was able to Partially resist because He Too Had Bene Geiseret powers......Not Fully Developed and still in it's early stages. You heard the Reverend mother Acknowledge that he was strong, but resistance was Futile in the end.
Lynch crawled on his knees so Villeneuve could fly. This is what Villeneuve watched in order to see what did and didn't work. Very useful to have it there as a warning. Like LA Takedown for Michael Mann's Heat.
yet way more memorable this one than Villeneuve's
@@francescomalagoli2467cap
Omg stop with this revisionism stuff. It doesn't make you interresting when you say that this version is more "memorable". It is a flawed movie that everyone, including Lynch, barely remembers. We're only talking about it now because of Villeneuve's movies.@@francescomalagoli2467
@@francescomalagoli2467 Maybe, but it's a shite film.
@@thesprawl2361 i prefer shite than bland
Box: "CLI'CHUNK". Rev Mother: "Put your hand in the box". Audience: "Hell No!". Brilliant how Lynch tapped into the viewer's primal sense of fight or flight to illustrate the concept of the test.
DV's version of the Reverend Mother Gaius was very brutal, intimidating and frightening.
To the uninitiated, perhaps
Exact opposite of the word, “Mother”. That’s an accurate portrayal, of how some children are treated…not respected as human beings, but being threatened into submission. Very sad indeed
They still never got her look right though. The book clearly states she looked like an old witch from a fairytale, dressed in a black hooded robe. In the movies it seems they always insisted on making her look weird/funny instead.
she is the best
As she should be. Bene Gesserit have a reputation of "witches". What is less known is that they are experienced fighters as well (which is supported by the fact that they have extended control over their muscles and biochemistry). While it is not impossible to kill a Reverend Mother, someone who is not trained enough (and Paul at this moment has no precognition nor Fremen training, only traditional Atreides training plus bits and pieces that his mother taught) has no chance in single combat. So it's pretty much a "mother" that can break your neck while sipping her tea. Or command you to break your own neck, if you're not strong-willed enough (and even Paul who was aware of the Voice couldn't resist it entirely).
I love this film, the new films are incredible. It's like seeing 2 possible futures.
The clang of the box opening when she says, "You see this?" Scariest sound. It always made me think there was a spring loaded blade inside.
3:10 MCU fans watching a movie without bombastic action and jokes
LMAO
3:10 Snyder fans when a movie Isn't monochrome
Nolan fans when they see CGI
TikTok kids when the movie doesn't have a split screen with minecraft parkour to watch when they lose attention after 20 seconds.
HAHAHAHA
In the Dune novels , in princess Irulan's commentary about this incident, I always remember how she described the Bene Gesserit's huge mistakes & neglect about Paul's test. Even the Reverend Mother noted that no one had ever withstood that level of pain from the Box and lived. The Bene Gesserit were so determined to kill Paul , they had such fear of his potential that they abandonded their detachment to skew the test & hide its results thereafter. If you know the story it became apparent why they feared him.
How do they no when to stop the test? Did the rev mother stop the rest earlier for the others?
@wisdomseeker0142 I'm not sure Frank Herbert went into detail about that. Even the mechanism of the pain box itself was a closely guarded secret of the order.
She cranked the box up to 11 just for Paul. He got the bonus plan.
I just finished Dune Messiah. I can now see why they didnt trust him at all 😂
This scene was so creepy in the new version. Came here to compare the two.
new one gave me goosebumps. Such a powerful scene in the new one
Ikr I really like the short words conversation in the new one They didn't have to say much and yet you feel the pressure like they mean business!
@@ryumii1701 Plus the idea of this ghostly figure veiled in black and wielding some eldritch psychic power... took me right back to the Witch King of Angmar in LOTR.
@@ryumii1701 yeah . Like everything said here , you feel it through the character's stares and expressions
Yes
I think both this and the 2021 film emphasize different elements that work to their benefit. I think this does a better job emphasizing the pain and the burning nature of the test, as well as how Paul is exceptional in his performance. On the other hand 2021 does a better job emphasizing Paul rising above his instincts and using his mind to control himself.
dune 2021 sucked man.
@@ReonKad3 No.
@@ReonKad3 Yeah it just didn't suck though did it ? knob
THE PAINNNNNNNN
Oh dear. I think Dune 2021 did a so much better job than this one. This looks like child's play in comparison.
- They tried and died! - I shall not!!! - Die? - No...try. See ya!
Lynch's Dune may look grotesque in 2024 (especially when compared to Villeneuve's Dune), but I can imagine how mindblowing it was back then.
Much of the look of the film comes directly from Frank Herbert who consulted on the sets and costumes. For all of its flaws, Lynch's Dune looks the most like what Herbert saw in his mind when he wrote the book.
It doesn't look grotesque, it looks unique and fantastic with its baroque influences in set design and costumes. Some of the shots in this film are inspired artistry, the Atreides ships boarding the Guild Heighliner, the Navigator's audience with the Emperor. Yes the special effects are dated, but they still show style and imagination. In a few ways the film surpasses the latest remake.
It’s ok. There’s 40 years of cinematography in between. Things evolve and it is good so. Comparing is stupid. Lynch did his job back then and Villenueve did his now
I just realized that most of the dialogue is taken straight out of the book
This movie was ahead of its time. Lynch really did great with the available technology and techniques available at the time. This is a masterpiece in its own rights. DV has also created a masterpiece for modern audiences , I cannot wait for part 2 , November can't come fast enough.
it's crazy how they created the shields.
To think the original airdates is in november, we could've gotten it sooner 😭
Usul no longer needs the weirding module
The best thing about this movie was Francesca Annis. In the book the lady Jessica was described as having a natural elegance and regal beauty that would allow her to outshine almost all other women around her, even wearing the simplest of clothes and regalia. [she could wear a peasants clothes and still look like lady of the highest rank] …… I was 21 years old watching this in the cinema and I remember being stunned by her elegance and beauty in this movie. As a young man who only had eyes for young women of my age I think that this was the 1st time I realised that an older mature woman could hold such beauty.
Well said! Hers was a unique type of beauty.
you would be considered a newbie in today's times
As much as people give this movie hate, its not appreciated enough for what the director was trying to accomplish. He originally want to do 3 movies as well to do the story right. But the studio wouldn't let him.
Channel 4 1991 maybe? This film came on and changed my life. Few weeks later The spice must flow by EON came on pirate radio. When he says THE PAIN - for the first time something actually came close to describing the complete and utter black void that was inside me waiting to be released after a terrible loss in the spring of 1990. That feeling never went but on the 17th birthday of my youngest child of four kids, 30 odd years later. Laid out loads of photos on the table and made something that lifted some of the pain out of me. Print out your photos, get them out of your phones. When my wee ones years later would say dad - i'm not in the mood. MOOD? MOOD? would give 'em a sqeeze & pretend i was Gurney. The new films don't deal with the guild navigators true to the book. Many machines on IX. Saw the Dune 2 at the IMAX waterloo last week, best seats in the house. Special effects and sounds were stunning and the final man to man fight scene is a bit more aggressive and realistic than Lynch's film but it cannot beat the feeling you get in the original when Paul uses his voice to crush Feyd!!!! Wish the new film had that. But TOTO's music, Brian Eno's perfection. From start to finish the original film is EPIC and I feel truer to the book with the voiceovers. Highlander, Point Break and then Fifth Element later were my references (so many others too) . What is great is that we all have our own ones for different reasons. Covid stopped me from seeing Dune in march 2020 in Greenwich Picturehouse - David Lynch celebration sadly got cancelled. So many great films are being lost because of streaming & modern attitudes to older special effects cinemas should wake up to the demand that would be out there for big screen showings of 'older' films. Love you Chico & RoRo xx
Fear is the Mind Killer!!!!!
And pain is for slaves and loosers
This movie looks amazing. I love how both dune movies have their own style and how they tell the story, but they're both get everything so right when it matters
I saw it when I was like 10 years old
@@cicolas_nage you have no taste, stick to anime
@@cicolas_nage as mentioned stick to anime or tiktok crap. They suit you better 🖕
@@cicolas_nage the effects do not hold up but the accuracy and also the performances are reasonably good
@@cicolas_nage This movie is a cult classic. It came out competing against Star Wars. Wonder what the budget difference was.
I've experienced pain through nerve induction. It can be a side effect of a misaligned transcranial magnetic stimulation device. It doesn't feel like burning, it's a sharp, stabbing pain.
It depends on what nerves are being induced... think of how capsaicin produces a burning sensation (but not effect!) and how menthol produces a cooling sense.
@@paulbrookfield4133 I meant in my specific case.
@DeadNinjutsu Oh, when I said a sharp stabbing pain I was just describing the kind of pain, not the intensity. It really didn't hurt very badly. And it was just a slight misalignment of the device. They repositioned it a little bit and the pain stopped. The therapy actually worked very well for me.
@DeadNinjutsu Well thank you, I appreciate your concern. I'm actually having it done again right now, as the effects can eventually wear off over the years.
This weirdly reminds me of the hand burning scene in Fight Club
3:10 when I hit my little toe into a door
😂😂😂
"I must not fear the door."
Best scene in that movie. There were a few other scenes that captured the books essence but the rest of the movie missed the target. I hope the next rendition does a better.
Actually I found the movie great and watched it several times. But I still haven't read the book... Would be interesting to see Dune of Denis Villeneuve when it will be released.
@@kirillt256 agreed.
This scene, in particular, was so much more like the book than the mini series version. I think that is one of the reasons that I like it. Then again, the miniseries had Ian McNeice as Baron Harkonnen so there is that in it's favor.
@@kirillt256 "but I still haven't read the book" dawg what the fuck
@@kirillt256 I read the book the only really major difference was Paul's rainmaking miracle at the end and the sound guns, which were awesome in their own right.
Sian Phillips. Amazing performance.
The whole cast was amazing, much better then the new Dunes cast. I really tried to like the new movie, but I just couldn't get over the fact that he glazed over so much detail that this movie went into. and set production in the 84 version to me was so much better.
Watch her performance in the Masterpiece Theater series "I, Claudius" as Livia, wife of Augustus.
Lot of thanks for the upload.
Patrick Stewart's most underrated role
💀
Lol
I tried not to think of the words "sear" and "flesh".
Just saw the new one. Seeing this makes me not want to compare, because the more recent one is pretty damn good
I appreciate Lynch's attempt to stay true to the text, but the results range from effective to super clunky in motion
I like in DV version Paul actual stares down the Reverend Mother wish Lynch had directed Kyle MacLaghlan to do the same. I do prefer Lynch has Paul deliver the “I must not fear…”
I like the detailing on the costumes, especially the netting around her wrists and neck. One of the redeeming qualities of the Lynch Dune is that there are some remarkable costumes.
I know Lynch's version gets lambasted but in fairness, it did stick quite rigidly to some of the concepts in the book. I think when you break it down to the basic story and then layer the intricacies of things like the Gom Jabbar and The Voice on top, you are getting somewhat there with Dune. I hope DVs version, while being hugely epic, will at least come back to these smaller moments as often as the book does. But will it be voiceovers?
Indeed, I do not understand the criticism. It is somewhat simplified, with some fancy additions, but also some that have gained iconic status since... plus the unique aesthetics... I think that its shortcomings are down to the fact that it was to be pared down to a little over 2 hours, which is simply inadequate. I have cut my own version, spliced in the leftovers and the result is epic... As for David Villeneuve's take... he had promised that it would be something like "Star Wars for adults", and I only hope that by that he did not mean swapping white men for black women... Whatever the result, such forced racist contortions can spoil any masterpiece. "Star Wars" is a bit infantile swashbuckling stunt by George Lucas... and Dune is anything but that.
I reread the book this past year, after first reading it 50 years ago. It is incredibly episodic, as if F. H. were writing for storyboards
@@dougr.2398 That's a very good point. The structure is very set out, as if he was thinking visually, especially in the earlier chapters. I mean, the story is all there, I see no reason for DV to deviate from it. It's the thing that annoys me most about adaptations of things like The War of the Worlds. The story is "all there", no need to sprinkle it with hollywood moondust
@@joecantdance494 thank you, JCD
The movie looks dated, but this particular scene I found to be much better than the 2021 version
And Paul took that personally.
Love this version. Sian Phillips is magnificent.
One of the best scenes from a beloved film.
What's in the box maaan, what's in the booox?!
Horatio Nelson literally nothing, they cause a burning sensation not from sticking your hand in, but from her mental SUGGESTION, as she describes your hand slowly but surely burning away. The test is see your willpower and if you recoil back, your neck gets hit with the Gom Jabaar ( *A very powerful poison* ) in question and you die as a beast would as the poison is meant to kill animals.
@@boxtank5288 it was a reference to the movie 7 also there is probably a lot of complex technologies in the box
@@rhorynotmylastname7781 I know I'm just answering for those who had no idea and I'm about to edit that reply because I'm just now seeing all the time as where Google Voice fucked up. And its Bene Gesserit Mind Fuckery that ensures you FEEL the hand burn even though its effectively a simple box.
@@boxtank5288 oh okay sry
I love how Villeneuve took the same camera plans for that.
I never noticed that because ive never seen the original movie
IMO what makes this scene and movie so powerful is the "gravitas" of the actors. The acting of this Reverend mother is so underrated. Jurgen Pronchow and Patrick Stewart,Jose Ferrer as well. I hope that the actors in this new movie can live up to that.
Here from the future. They did.
@@MrImastinker not really
@@votdfak Oh yes they did. Look, the 1984 film has its moments, but the new film is already a better adaptation.
It doesn’t. The cinematography is (somewhat) better but that’s about it.
@@bcm3938 “somewhat better” How’re y’all in such blatant denial 😭
This scene made me want to watch the film. My science teacher showed it to us as an example of nerves being used to transmit pain without actual damage and after school i went in search of the film
Jesus, this is very very very the book! I dont understand why people hate that movie as much i heard but to me always seem' very accurated and honest with the original spirit! Great!
The problem is that the first two thirds of the film are close enough to the book that it makes the discrepancies of the last third (the time skip and the rain are two major ones) very blatant. It's a good film, but one that is severely marred when it's earlier attempts to be close to the book are abandoned due to severe time constraints. It's more a problem with the medium than the people involved, most likely.
@Bad Cattitude thoughts on the new trailer
Except the end. And the “killing word” weirding module thing.
@@alejandrorivas4585 it looks dark. like, really dark. like the director kept calling the visual design team to say that it wasn't colored dark enough.
the visual design was so impressive though...
More class than the other movies!
Hector Salamanca to Mike: " And the Gom Jabbar is yours"
Internal dialogue aside, this scene have more of the important pieces from the conversation that new version omitted.
In I, Claudius, Sian sits in a side room in a palace, and tells Livilla, who steps into the room, frightened and hesitant...”come here” in a creepy voice.
I still tell myself, “fear is the mind killer” to this day.
Still phenomenal acting after so many years
Damn the boy was so pretty that even in pain he looked great
I wish it was complete. I love the line about "it kills only animals."
I feel like so much of the success of the remake's version of this scene comes from the Reverend Mother only describing the consequence of failure. It plays into her dark ambitions and the more dim tone of the lighting and wardrobe.
THE PAIN!!!!!!
I thoroughly enjoy Kyle MacLachlan's acting
Fear is the mind killer.
Strange. What I got out of this scene is Paul's mother is the damn most beautiful actress I've ever seen. Yeah, there are younger actresses that are hotter but I'm talking timeless, classical beauty.
In both films
U would think in 10191 they'd have better dentistry for the bene desert.
*Snaps lights off* "Step into the room." "What's in the room?" "Pain." LEGOOOOOs
What does this scene teach us THAT IT'S ALL IN THE MIND.
The thumbnail is meme material.
My favorite part was when the reverend mother said “it’s Gom Jabarrin’ time” and the Gom Jabarred all over the place.
"just a sec my nose itches"...
Master piece.
All our love to Anne...
I just like Lynch's version better than the new one, and I'm not even sure why. It's weirder I guess.
That’s always been my feeling, too. There’s just something about the new one that feels too accessible and pedestrian to me- whereas with Lynch’s version I really feel like I’m watching something based in a different time, another culture(s), with gesticulations and ways of speech that are truly of another world. But I think you put it best, “it’s weirder”, and that makes it much more interesting.
Doesn't mean its better lol.
sheer magic
The captain.
Dune 2021 winn
Non
Wow
Круто!
THE PAIN
The 2021 scene was just so much better
says who?
THE PAIN!
When you accidentally break a window pane with a normal pickaxe instead of the one with Silk Touch: *THE PANE*
David Lynch's Dune is still my favorite. After all, Dune would be a dark adaptation more so than not. With the way it was written by Frank Herbert. Such an element as "the spice" that makes such things happen, would bring out the worst in human nature to rule, get and control.
Yes.
1🇺🇲🎴& direct hit...
1:42 ¡CERVEZA CRISTAL!
Out of all the adaptions, Sian Philips is the best Reverend Mother. And this is my favourite version of the gom jabbar scene. As good as the mini series and latest 2 parter film are and how brilliant both Alec Newman and Timothée Chalamet are in their respective gom jabbar scenes, this one sticks out to me the most., especially this was Kyle MacLachlan's first film role. It's just so tense and brilliant! "They tried and died"....ohh shivers
Really. I loved the books and find 2021 to be much better. The casting and costumes look a bit absurd. Their is also too much telling, and seeing what Paul is feeling in the box takes away from the suspense.
Agree about Sian Philps. And I didn't know this was Kyle maclachlans first film role. Cool!!
I love the fact he didn't submit to the voice at first
It was through this trial of pain that he became the mayor of Portland.
Just a perfect scene. The acting is impecable. Camera movement is superb, the way it changes the axis simbolizing the non returning path of Paul its a true achivment, you can truly say David Lynch´s hand is here. But above all the Siân Phillips (Reverend mother) performance and dialogue makes me breathless. I am starting to think I am the only one who loves this movie. Specially over the Villeneuve´s version which makes me sick.
THE PAIIIIINNNN!
Thats the oldest 15 years old guy in the history
Timothy is older than he was in this film at 26
@@nuketar But he looks younger than this actor 😅
I like Paul being able to resist the voice at first till the reverend mother puts more seriousness/power/whatever into it. That was missing from the Villeneuve version.
Aside from him yelling "the pain" at the end. I really enjoy this depiction of the reverent mother more than the new depiction. She had that same tenderness she had in the book, but also she is still very intimidating.
Lmao, the painnnnnn
Absolutely superior version.
Nah 2021 blows this outta the water in every way
THE PAIN 📢📢📢📢📢📢🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Why does Paul look same age as his mum 😂
WHAT'S IN THE BOAAXX???
Silence, silence!!!
Classic.
That thumbnail is the face of a man that fails to eat fibre and chew his food properly
Got Jom Gabbar yesterday^^
what I liked a lot has been that the cast of actors in Dune followed Twin Peaks (as much as this could be realizable). Dune is a reference point in SciFi, pity Lynch did not manage to get it the way it was planned initially. But anyhow, have watched it probably something like 200 times.
This actor is so good at looking afraid but not terrified…