The plaintiff brings his niece to court. He says the defendant got mad at him and attacked his car with an umbrella. He’s suing for damages. The defendant argues she never touched his truck and he’s just being vindictive.
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv
Case # 28-444
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court
I don’t know why she’s taking out her anger on her uncle for grandma not eating when she could’ve gone past and fed her grandma if she loves her grandma that much
Can't believe the whole family left the grandmother alone on Thanksgiving Day. No one visited until close to midnight??
If they know the uncle is in the hospital, why wouldn’t any of them go help the grandmother?
The entire family failed the grandmother. The guy was in the hospital for 10 days, he was worse off than the grandmother, cut him some slack. She clearly damaged the vehicle.
Why was she mad that the grandmother hadn't eaten yet? Shouldn't she and her mother shoulder some of that responsibility when her uncle is in the hospital for ten days?
What a bunch of weirdos, why wait until midnight to go visit grandma, the kids had all day to visit and bring her some food.
And it was Thanksgiving! No one could come get her??
I don’t know why nobody could bring grandma a plate earlier in the day. Minus the plaintiff bc he needed help as well
I'm more concerned about the grandmother not eating.
It makes me scared to get old and needing caretakers. People will treat you any which way especially when no one is looking. I wish humans weren’t trash lol
We don’t know the situation. The grandmother could have had dementia. They tend to think they have missed meals
I agree
I realize now I have an awesome family, and I miss them. Time for a rd trip
@roxane7432 you're one of the lucky ones when it comes to family. Both sides of my families (mom) (dad) are dysfunctional.
Why are so many people blaming him when he was in the hospital all day. The niece shoilse have visited grandma before where ever she went.
Because of his attitude. Didn't seem like he really cared.
And where was the defendant's mother, who I believe is the old woman's daughter? Don't the other relatives have responsibility when the primary caretaker has a medical emergency?
Because he should’ve made arrangements
@@EduardoGonzalez-qm2uk People don't tend to plan their heart attacks... I'm not saying he sounds like the nicest guy, but being hospitalized for a heart issue sort of forces you to prioritize your own health. The rest of the family should have stepped up.
@@amandadonaldson8748yes he said his adult daughter and adult son were supposed to be taking care of the grandmother while he was in the hospital. I would think that they would contact the cousins if they couldn’t do it. His son and daughter dropped the ball.
Why are people blaming him for his mother not eating when he was in the hospital recovering from a heart attack? What about the rest if family? Why didnt the neiece and her mother take food to her or take grandma to eat thanksgiving dinner with them? He clearly states he was mad they didnt take better care for her and yet ppl are blaming him 😂😂😂😂😂
Paying her respects to Grandma makes it sound like Grandma is dead.
Making sure she pretends to care so she’s in the will sounds like. 🤷♂️I know the type well my family is filled with those leeches and it’s gross
Sounds like she doesn't visit much.
She totally did it, I'm a parent of 7 grown children and I can tell a liar in a youngster. 😂😂
her evading the q and a gives her away
You can tell every time they open their mouths
@@stevelozano9523 a famous quote from Judge Judy,lol
That smirk totally gave her away! Her mother must be so proud of her. Sheesh 🙄
Defendant with her eyes darting around and looking down, clear mark of a liar.
Judge Judy would of said look me in the eyes and not down there,lol
The plaintiff had a fricken heart attack & in the hospital for 10 days & what was his niece & sister doing to help out? Sister hasnt been there for 6 yrs & cray niece trashes his vehicle! Time for grandma to go to the nursing home where she can be fed, cared for & get away from this Dysfunctional chaos for reals!
Also, why is a elderly person living on the 6th floor of a apartment complex? 🙄
@@angelawhite7140it’s NYC. Presumably there’s an elevator.
@@mikesteele05 and if its broken,how then,
@@angelawhite7140 very good q that,the best q I have seen in all the comments
Its not like she helped Grandma while he was in the hospital
She got arrested and still says she didn’t do anything. Lol
All I can say is, POOR GRANDMA 😞
If they brush off the fact that their 86 yr old grandmother hasn't eaten all day and nearly all night I can imagine what other horrors that she goes thru. There's a special place in Hell for those that abuse the old and the very young. Shame on them.
Did you listen? That’s not what happened.
@@jayburris6252 its far more concerning to me about granny then her dinging his car. And he was running some BS about the situation You could flat out tell.
@intheredcold9216 so you didn't actually watch & comprehend what actually happened.
@@aerotaken5357 Lol oh great comment oracle plz enlighten my ignorant ears.
The truth is probably in the middle, so more like grandma was upset that on thanksgiving she was stuck with no big meal, no family, just by herself and eating cereal or something lame like that. I doubt she was outright starving or she would’ve called somebody surely.
I wish this episode would be longer. There is a lot to unpack.
I'm already so disgusted with whole family for grandma's treatment I can't watch anymore.
The whole family, except for the plaintiff. I think it would be difficult to expect him to be able to immediately jump back in to handling things after being in the hospital for 10 days.
The plaintiff was hospitalized for 10 days. He shouldn't be mixed with the others.
The plaintiff's family is a disgrace, the man was in the hospital with a serious medical condition, and they couldn't be bothered to care for grandma?! Then, had the nerve to vandalize his vehicle?! Wow🤦♀️
Other family members should have checked in everyday!!! Buy food. Buy T.P. & whatever else is needed. It isn't hard to feed an old lady. They don't eat much.
Agreed! Especially when they all look mobile and healthy themselves (minus the heart attack) but he still made it to the house!
Someone should call Adult Protective Services for Grandma.
She did it she is a brat
Staying up all night could be part of dementia/senility, but older people sleep less as well. She's definitely guilty of damaging the car. I kinda believe the niece about her not eating all day. When he was asked 'who feeds her', he says, 'I take care of her a lot'. That doesn't address who feeds her. If she needs to be fed, it makes me question whether she's truly able to make food for herself. However, senility makes people say things that aren't true. She has to pay, but I wish I felt better about Grandma 🤔 I dunno, lol. I'm a Hospice RN now after years in the ER, so I see/hear things differently than other people. I could just be reading too much into it 🤷 My gut says no.
You're not. I got the same vibe. It's disgusting. If they feed her only when they think about it, I doubt that they keep her company or offer companionship. People are really evil sometimes.
That’s a very well measured response. I agree with you about being concerned for grandma, but we also have to take things senile people say with a grain of salt. I care for my 98 year old grandma and it’s always an adventure 😂 The care for this grandma seemed a little loosey-goosey, but who knows what’s really going on.
@@SarahParker-bo9uz yes, I agree. At the end of the day, you're right. But, another thing... When he was asked who feeds her, etc, he also said his daughter was taking care of her while he was in the hospital. Daughter said she didn't arrive that day until 11:30pm, in the middle of the argument with the niece. Who was with her during the day? I dunno. It just doesn't seem right. Edited to add Thank You for the 'well measured response', response 😂. I really try to he objective. But, 18 years in the medical field can leave you jaded, but also experienced and wiser about what people are trying to sell as a believable story. Also, God bless you for taking care of your family ♥️😘🌹
You're right. Dementia will lead to insomnia symptoms. It's the racing thoughts, the psychosis.
Same vibe
Yikes. Some "family".
Seems Grandma did a fantastic job with her entire lot of relatives. All stellar people.
You had the weakest denial 🤣🤣🤣 #teamdoug for life
Thanks Giving, probably the biggest day on the American calendar and everyone left grandma on her own for the entire day, you would think someone in the family would have gone and picked her up for the day. Can understand the son was in hospitable, but what about the daughter or another sibling if there are any? My father is 87 years old and we would never leave him home alone on Christmas Day. Sadly far to many people ignore the elderly until they are on their death bed and all the family can think about is the will. I have 3 sisters in Brisbane Australia who come to Melbourne (1700 kms) 2 or 3 times a year and stay with my father nearly every time. They even have a weekend away with him and my other 2 sisters.
All of those people there and no one thought to see if grandma ate … wow
She has ago at the man that was in hospital. But says nothing to her own mother for not helping her grandma. Or doing something herself 🤔😞
That guy asking "Did you do it or not"? I'm laughing 😂 around the world the way he said that.. Dude 🤪 crzy!
Anger management!
I PRAY SOMEONE IS TAKING CARE OF GRANDMA NOW, WHO COMES AND VISIT GRANDMA AT 11:30 AT NIGHT ON THANKSGIVING DAY, ALL OF THEM NEED TO BE ASHAMED FOR ELDERLY ABUSE 😢😢😢😢😢
and I get perturbed when family wants to have Thanksgiving at 6 or 7 at night...guess I should be happy they don't have it at 11 or 11:30 pm
The defendants mother is just as miserable as she! 😮
“yes he had a heart attack” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ewww The niece did it for sure
So the guy who was in the hospital for 10 days was responsible for feeding grandma? Wow! Toxic family members. I hope the guy is doing better and stays away from the toxic family members.
Visiting grandma at 11pm on Thanksgiving?? Sad!!! Very disturbing family!!
The brother and sister don't talk so of course that will affect their children. BUT...someone should either be with or checking on grandma every single day...he was in the hospital and the rest of the family should've been on top of that.
So nobody thought to check on granny that morning to make sure she had food??? Cause I don’t know about yall but on holidays my granny eats EARLY. That should’ve been the first stop before anyone went anywhere else
The niece was probably mad that there was no dinner for her!! Where was the girls mom!!!!
"Oh never mind."🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
WTH why is no one taking care of gramma 😠 “We all end up eating” OMG they should all be ashamed
So the guy that usually takes care of GMA was in the hospital and no other family member thinks it’s a good idea to step up?
PRAISE GOD I’M THE ONLY CHILD!! Thank you Mom and Dad!!
the mother is as bad as the daughter
He was in the hospital why didn't someone else take care of this?? Ridiculous
When she said, “the defendant’s your niece WOW!”
Grandma is clearly the instigator of these problems. She always delights in pitting family members against each other.
What a dumb comment.
The defendant is clearly lying and it's pretty sad. Sister and brother haven spoken in 6-years!
I feel the nieces outrage! Their neglecting the grandmother is shameful. Again, Justice according to law doesn’t seem to cover moral Justice where he should not benefit from his bad behavior where he instigated it by neglect, name calling his niece and ultimately locking her out of the house
Someone should've been staying with the grandma 24/7. It sounds like no one is really looking after the grandma.
I think he is but he was quite literally hospitalized at the time
To answer Harvey's question...Yes! I would sue anyone but my mother. Any other family member can get it🤣 I don't see that as something so horrible because when there is a dispute you need an arbitrator or mediator and that's what the judge does in court. So, court is a way of settling a dispute without violence and/ or grudges. Especially those folks on the People's Court because the show pays the judgement so there is no harm. However, it depends on the amount and principal as to whether I would take a family member to regular court. I don't think it is wrong to hold someone accountable, and it doesn't matter who it is. I watched my brother go into debt because he cosigned for a car for our brother. He has been struggling ever since, my other brother totaled the car and left him with a car note. Now he's in debt and our brother isn't going to help him and he refuses to take him to court. Couldn't be me...I cannot! Like I said the only person getting a pass from me is my mama.
Grandma must have money. That would explain the late visits.
I was just thinking the same thing. The niece was probably looking for cash or something to pawn and was pissed to find her uncle there.
He did say something about being up six stories and looking out the window! And if this was at around 8 to midnight I don’t think he could’ve seen her do that!
Definitely a lot of stuff going on with the uncle and niece/nieces mom, the mom hasn’t spoken to him in 6 years and the neice so happens to be so angry over this that she damages his car
Niece is a tweaker.
I can't believe he can fix his truck for that amount...how isn't it thousands of dollars? Judge Judy probably would have made her pay the deductible unless she was generous that day.
If they all knew he was in the hospital, why the hell didn't any of them go help her during the day. Sounds like a bunch of whiny, ungrateful brats. 🙄
I know they are family but, Bloody hell, they all look soo alike.
You can choose your friends but not your family
These old men are something else. They are on the judge's side for sure, whether truee or not😂😂😂😂😂
The defendant sounds and acts like she is the type to build your cat when you are not around. She's coming across as having taken some kind of tranquilizer to hide her crazy.
He was in the hospital and it was supposed to only be his kids to feed her! WTF WAS WRONG WITH HER AND HER MOTHER
A lot is my guess
How can it sound to your trained eye? Shouldn't it be how it sounds to your trained ear? 😂
Harvey, how much money would it take to buy a dog instead of taking a stray……10k…..20k….. If that dog turned into a person, would it be a better tenant or landlord?
What a crew
In my world family is the most beautiful thing family first nothing second family is all I got
The son and his kids aint take care of grandma Either way the niece aint any better by blaming everything on them Grandma supposed to be watched over by everyone in family take a schedule visit so she wont be alone
The niece is lying like hell. She definitely said that crap and damaged his car. He was he in the damn hospital so why didn’t other family members feed grandma? The niece has a very dull vacant look in her eyes. Lol
That young woman has a real anger problem. Not only is she hurting others, the person she’s hurting the most at the end of the day, is herself. Too dumb (yet) to figure that one out.
Poor Mom has to deal with two of her children not speaking to each other, a granddaughter who wants to fight her uncle, and all of the drama with her son. My mom is 86. She lives with my sister. While my sister is at work, my mom pretty much takes care of herself. She still makes the beds, does all the laundry, feeds the cats, etc... We are lucky she is as well as she is. I can't imagine her being alone and not eating. I am grateful to my sister for her care. I live in another state so don't get to see her as much as I would like to, but we talk almost every day on the phone.
Doug said he didn't say anything like that in the trial. What the heck is wrong with him? Yeah, he actually did.
He may have won his case, but like the defendant said, he left his mother with no food because he was in hospital but his daughter neglected the needs of the grandmother too, so they really are quite a horrible family, no wonder his niece was so angry with him...
She had to use a calculator to deduct $300? 👀 9:30
If the niece felt like retaliation was smarter than feeding grandma herself, why didn't she take it out on the cousins instead? I would've been upset with whoever was supposed to be taking care of grandma in uncles absence. Just a lil strange she targeted him. Uncle was also not happy his mother wasn't fed yet, and is trying to arrange a meal while being newly discharged from the hospital.... talk about stressful.
The defendant's Mom is a Karen as well as the daughter. This kind of people in the family are the first one to sue for Grandma's assets when she passes away. Give the plaintiff a break, he was in the hospital for 10 days while his sister is not bothering to check on their Mom.
Doug always there to rub the salt into the wound ....
Stood up there and told that lie. She was louder than that telling her story. Their story must've been pretty bad because JM, the edited version, didn't show her digging into the drama like she normally does.
That would have never happened to my grandma if she was living.
There is a lot going on here that they are not saying!! Hes just got out of the hospital from a heart attack 3 hours ago, but he is supposed to take care of grandmother? Why are all these people going to this ladies home at 11:00 at night! Dysfunctional family all around!!!!
The niece has a bad attitude! That man was in hospital for 10 days so other family members like the sister should’ve been seeing to her mother! The defendant most definitely scratched his truck up! She is one of the most despisable defendants I’ve ever seen on tv court show ever!!
So why couldn't she go and help grandma for a bit while he was in hospital?? Didn't it cross her mind at all in the slightest??
So why is grandma left alone on Thanksgiving????? They’re all kinda shady.
The nice is a liar!!! She will pay for sure!!!
He can't see from six stories up and three blocks down... she knew where his car was. Mom implanted her hate for her brother in the daughter.
Why wasn’t the sister helping out with grandma?!
Mom and daughter are banging on her uncle and mom’s bother that was in the hospital with a heart ailment, and they are blaming him for not taking care of her grandmother, her mother. Where the heck were they at? There’s family and there are relatives, which one are you?
Poor Grandma 😢
She so guilty
I haven't spoken to him in 6 years 😮
She pulled a Brittany Spears on her uncle. 😅
That’s crazy he just got a free 6k
That woman has an attitude. Obvious.
Something else going on here. I hope the young lady is ok.
Where was the daughter (his sister) during the whole day? He was expected to feed his mother from the hospital, where he had a heart attack? 🤔
The whole family, other than the plaintiff, chose to ignore grandma and do their own things. None of them have the right to blame anyone else for her neglect, especially the guy who'd just come out of the hospital.
I’m concerned no one is helping him with the grandmother while he in the hospital!! We’re was the sinister?
Defendants blouse is cute
I thought the defendant was in her 40s. Such a sad family.