LIVE! Real Lawyer Reacts: Depp v. Heard Netflix Series Initial Reactions + Unsealed Side Bars
#johnnydepp #amberheard #lyk
🔴 Do you or someone you know need to speak to a real lawyer about a case? Or do you find yourself needing legal advice? Please reach out to our firm and we will make sure to answer your questions or find someone who can. Our consultations are always free and confidential. You can call our firm at (727) 441-9030 or email us at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com.
✅ For business inquiries contact me at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com
✅ Let's connect: www.tragoslaw.com/
Twitter - @tragoslaw
Instagram - /tragoslaw
Facebook - /tragoslaw
TikTok - /tragoslaw
✅ Join our email list here - bit.ly/33lV3Mb
✅ Get your Lawyer You Know merch here - bit.ly/LYKMerch
✅ Become a LYK Channel Member Here - bit.ly/3OecDDD
SUPERCHATS & DISCLAIMER - 1. Superchats read out are not to be taken as my opinion nor endorsed by me. 2. Questions are answered on best efforts based on my knowledge and jurisdiction.
🔴 NOT LEGAL ADVICE
Intro Music: WNAQ9M6UJF
Outro Music: 7RELUAQ9VY
My biggest issue with the series is not only did they not have permission to use a lot of the clips, but they copyright claimed popcorn planet on popcorn planet's own clips
The list of reasons I dropped Netflix gets longer and longer. They use "Documentary" or docu series to push a narrative. These are the people who gave five episodes to Meghan and Harry. To... what? Now there are questions about Making a Murderer... But I had it by the time "Cuties" was there.
The real hero of the sidebars is clearly Judge A and how she kept her patience with Elaine 🤣
Between her and judge Dorow, they could share the award as most patient judges.
I’d be like Emily D Baker shouting ELAAAAINE all the time if I was the judge 😂
@@bibimbnap3105 🤣🤣🤣 true story!
I have the utmost respect for judge A
@@rockulikeahurricane MEEEE TOOO!!! Judge A and her patience was admirable to say the least!!! 🏆
I’m a family lawyer in the U.K. and over the last 34 years have dealt with many victims of abuse - Jonny Depp was the victim, without a shadow of a doubt. The myth of mutual abuse was peddled in this case and it’s a myth. Abuse is about two things. Power and Control. That’s it ! If an abused person stands up for themselves- during abuse- this is NOT mutual abuse! Liveabusefree has done some fantastic videos on this case and she absolutely nails abuse. My heart broke for Jonny Depp in this trial. I’d followed the story for years before it came to trial and he was abused over again by Heard and her lawyers during this trial, it made me sick to my stomach to watch it. I’m so glad Jonny was vindicated by his amazing team of lawyers and you could tell they absolutely felt it for him. There was raw emotion. Camille Vasquez cross was stunning. Not watched Netflix series but will do now.
I totally agree with you. I am in France and I followed the whole trial (I know enough about battered women). All these allegations that made J. Depp’s career destroyed and his health was shaken were a scandal! In 2016, in a French magazine "Paris Match", A. Heard appeared with his "blue" cheek, and it made me laugh, so much I did not believe and I already found it ridiculous... but "the machine got carried away". This unbalanced woman, sought to avenge Johnny Depp with this announcement of divorce, since he had announced to her that he was going to divorce. After pocketing the $7 million, she did not hesitate to betray him in 2018, with the complicity of the tabloid "The Sun". J. Depp was remarkable in courage. What fights he fought! He did not have the legal means to shed light on the London trial. But, fortunately, the Fairfax trial was exemplary, Judge Azcarate of undeniable professional rigor and competence. Johnny Depp’s legal team, too. Many consider that lawyer of A. Heard, Elaine x.., was not good; I would say that A. Heard had so many lies to her " credit" that any lawyer would have been bad...
“Live abuse free” is amazing!
@@jankasza5538came here to say the same! She is spot on in her videos. 😊
I totally agree with you, however I refuse to give AH and her PR team any light so will not be watching it. It's infuriating that Netflix would irresponsibly put together such a lame depiction (from what I've heard) of the entire trial. No way this documentary won't have some sort of slant in her direction as being the victim. It pisses me off actually that they could do this without being more thorough. Based on the popularity of the trial, it seems like a netflix scramble money grab. I watched the entire trial...JD was so clearly the victim, it's laughable that this is still being disputed. I simply won't allow Netflix to twist the story, leave out major facts etc...nope. Sadly, a lot of people who did not watch the trial will watch this "cliff notes" version (of a 6 week long trial) and come to an uneducated belief on who was the victim. Lame. People will forever need her, a woman, to be the victim. I am NOT a crazed JD fan either, just saw clearly through the BS that is AH, and her team.
the Netflix documentary was worst than AH's Layers and fabricated case
I reluctantly watched the Netflix documentary and thought it was pathetic. They did infer that JD won bc of his popularity. Also, because he was the better actor. And finally, because evidence supporting Amber's case was not admitted. Like Depp didn't have any evidence disallowed? The court case was detailed, fair, and stands on its own.
I found Emily D Baker. I decided to dye my hair purple if Johnny won. A year later, I'm still doing it! I found many commentators, and it was nice to see them all together on the Netflix special. However, I agree, the coddling to the woman is really sickening.
Elaine was as untruthful as AH when she said to the jury that AH paid for the trial when she knew that her insurance was paying. She tried so many ways to twist the rules and the truth.
I watched every minute of the live trial. Went in with one opinion and came away with another. I have seen how msm spun the narrative and worked to make me doubt my eyes and intelligence. I have zero desire to watch the Netflix series. Thank you for covering the sidebars.
I believe NOTHING that MSM says!!! Whatever happened to just reporting the news? I’m so freaking sick and tired of them trying to cram their narratives down people’s throat. We watched the trial. She lied. The jury agreed she lied. Johnny won. Get over it!!!
Exactly same here.
I went in with absolute certainty that J. Depp was an abusive monster and watched it with EDB. Came out thinking JD was lucky to escape that psychopath. I am so disgusted with the MSM & stopped watching it for the most part seeing how they are constantly trying to twist the narrative with this.
It's been useful in a lot of ways. And odd. As a lefty used to seeing the right wing media misdirecting readers but this whole process opened my eyes to how much the leftwing do it as well. It's good to know, however disappointing x
@@MsMumei I believe one of the reasons msm and lefties went so hard on Amber’s side is bc the hard core right went so hard against her. The trial brought out some of the worst all around.
Netflixbhas even broken copyright laws, by using Popcorned Planet's videos without oermission, and putting their own copyright on his videos and then had him struck on KZhead! It is so maddening to me!
@@yvonnemurray1253 Yeah, I'm gonna binge Black Mirror today and then drop them as well.
It's extremely wrong they take advantage of the little independent creators not just popcorn planet but all the others as well! I seen Annie Cushing try to fair use the big guys and even she was well within her legal rights but then couldn't they know these independent creators don't have the muscle and their own lawfirm on stand by while some creators and just happen to reach a few thousand subs !
Heard wasn’t allowed to present the evidence from her psychologist/psychiatrist because it was hearsay. There was no hard evidence. You can say anything you like to your psych - doesn’t mean it happened.
Accused of being SA'd by a bottle with a wax seal where are the texts or emails corresponding such claims or MEDICAL proof? Notice Rottenbourne dropped SA claims in closing (as it was too far fetched)
Exactly. And exactly what she did! She played everyone!
Yeah, Amber claimed after the trial that she had loads of "medical" records that werent allowed in. I believe she was referring to her therapist sessions, things she told her therpist cant be substantiated. Not true medical records.
And the psychiatrist could have testified to it.
I watched 2 episodes. And I REALLY did get the feeling that Netflix was making it more out that AH lost because of social media, and not because no one believed her.
If social media had an impact on the jury then her legal team is largely to blame, because they were the ones who opened the door for negative Twitter hashtags towards Amber to be acknowledged in court and read out.
I totally agree. In my opinion this is a hot piece from AH
It was because of social media. Even depps lawyer said how important the appearance was. Crazy show of hugs, no facts.
Thanks, I will save myself some time from watching it! 💜
The jury wasn’t watching social media and one person was dismissed for just seeing it so i don’t think so. Most jurors take it pretty seriously although it was harder to not see this case. But I’m pretty sure they were like the rest of us and just didn’t believe her testimony and the fake photos were probably the nail in the coffin. I mean they would be for me. Along with no drs records at all and even her own witnesses admitting they had seen no physical abuse except her sister (whose story had changed 3 times).
I listened to Popcorn Planet’s complaint that Netflix used 12 out-takes from his interviews without his permission. They sent a letter asking him for permission, but sent another letter telling him they decided to give him credit at the end and used his work for the documentary. He’s furious!
And they copyrighted his videos as their own!! Criminal!!
@@Jess-ce5urif they did… sounds like they have a lawsuit on their hands! But Netflix elites vs a common KZheadr…. Might be hard to fight. So frustrating either way 😤
@@xx.hannahrose the absolutly did use his footage including the footage of when he got to meet Johnny after a concert that was filmed by Andy himself.
I cancelled Netflix,
Netflix stole his content without permission and then copyrighted it so he can’t even use his own content. Then tried to spin the footage like it was setup. Netflix are evil, and Andy already has legal advice telling him to sue.
I think the thing that convinced me (and possibly most other people) were the lack of medical records and pictures of injuries. Amber and her team really expected us to believe she was severely injured when there are pictures to prove she wasn't. And as a person who loves makeup and took some makeup classes in college I can tell you with confidence that there is no way you can cover swelling with makeup. The text messages made little difference to me. I wanted to believe her but she really expected us to believe she was that badly hurt and she just covered that shit with a little color corrector and foundation. Thats fucking ridiculous. I feel so bad for Johnny in all of this and now its all coming back up when I'm sure he just wants to forget it ever happened. Thanks for covering this.
This trial was a huge eye opener for me about the media. I watched the trial everyday, along with watching lawtube. Then saw how main stream media consistently made it look like heard was unfairly treated by social media or that the evidence was showing things differently, that she was the victim, that her loss hurt metoo…blah blah blah…This was so frustrating, knowing that anyone that didn’t follow the trial or lawtube would just believe this, and I also probably would have as well. Now I really don’t believe anything they say
I no longer trust anything that the MSM says. After the documentary of Prince Harry stuff I no longer believe them either. I don't know why I thought that if it had documentary in the name they HAD to tell the truth. I thought that about the MSM also. Now I know they spin things to say what they want them to weather they are true of not.
I wish shows like this, by Netflix, could be prevented. The public gets the wrong impression. This trial was so nuanced you really had to tune in every day to see justice (IMO) unfold. To leave the audienece with the impression that Amber was treated unfairly at trial is disgraceful to the judge and jury. Net flix should knock it off
I don’t know how producers get away with this. Not giving the full picture it’s infuriating.
I just hate that it's a platform we can't rate or review. I'd just love to point out that they admonish You Tubers for making millions off the trial, but have nothing to say about Netflix and the documentarians for the money they made. It's legitimate content for them, but not others, such a double standard.
Agree completely
I don't think censorship is the answer. On the contrary. Let them tell their lies, so that they can be exposed, and then we know who the liers are, and what are their "arguments". One of the "side benefits" of this trial, I think, was the ability to see, in real time, how mainstream media outlets distort the truth and cling to their narratives and biases. The trial was there for all of us to see, and almost every single person who watched the entire trial came out with the conclusion that AH was lying. Yet mainstream media outlets kept trying to sell their snake oil narrative that she's actually the victim. During and after the trial, Hoeg from Hoeg's Law YT channel kept dissecting article after article, carefully breaking apart their narratives and clearly showcasing all the spins, manipulations and distortions. I think this was highly educational to anyone who still believes that "news outlets" actually tell us the truth. As is videos such as this one, that open our eyes about "documentary" shows, and all the ways they try so spin a narrative rather then document the truth. So I say "bring it on!". The more they lie, the more we get to expose them. They're digging their own grave.
I was so embarrassed by Netflix wanting this type documentary instead of the truth! Those that put these lies together versus letting the truth come to light are terrible people! I wasn’t for either side until I accidentally saw AH testify! She’s so nasty and deceitful on the stand !
Netflix are stealing contentproviders content?! They are a billion dollar company _stealing_ fr small youtubers??!! Sounds like a… class act suit?
It should be!!! They are hiring someone to strike copyright notices on people who have clips and using content ID to find it. They mentioned using all social media channels. They are so quick to strike so I hope the creators ask for their due or get their part removed.
Yes and not only stealing content, but claiming they have ownership of it.
10 minutes into the first episode, they play recorded audio. The audio they play is frankensteined to make Johnny look horrible. They don’t say it was multiple clips, they wanted you to think he was screaming at her all at one time but it’s actually clips from several different recordings.
I turned it off that point. Can’t watch the rest cuz I know it’s gonna piss me off.
Wonder if they can be sued for defamation?
I watched the trial... then came here, plus Emily D Baker and Lost Beyond Pluto ... (Australia, and she started when the TMZ photo 1st hit the public, she analysed and predicted UK loss, US win... and explained WHY...) I enjoyed hearing each post court-day analysis from 3 different perspectives... I dont have netflix but was pretty disgusted by 60 Min Australia,s hit piece on Depp... These hit pieces will continue while the bitter and twisted Heard doesnt accept globally that "we saw her..." The trial was nothing to do with social media, that was just the vehicle by which we could observe court proceedings We saw her lie, we saw her try to manipulate evidence, we saw her desperation to connect to JD, we saw her lover EB commit Contempt of Court-twice, we watched her sister lie, her ex friends lie, we heard her voice from the recordings, we saw her act to the jury.... We saw her... in her entirety, in the courtroom, on the stand... She is a horrid human, its a wonder that man is still alive after what she did... Imho...
Amen! I was horrified when I saw the 60 minutes segment, I was yelling at the TV about all the facts they got wrong and my husband goes you’re just to involved in this case. I was so angry🤬, as he knew I love lawtube and watch a lot of trial coverage and I wanted the coverage to be true to the fact in court. Love from Melbourne ♥️
@@swedishlina Right back at ya from Kiwiland lol...
Right? We watched it happen, yet they keep pretending we didn't. I didn't care for all the social media stuff, since I don't really social media, but I DID watch the trial, and I know I agreed with the verdict, for the most part. It was the same with Rittenhouse. The media outright lied. I know, again, I watched it live and in living color, so I didn't need their opinions and biases; I had already formed my own.
Social media was just a response to what we saw, not a setup or bots or whatever heard wants to claim. We saw her lie! We saw her friends lie! We aren’t dumb. The media is just pissed we aren’t sheep who followed THEIR narrative
I watched it. It left soooo much out. There were so many things that were not covered. Also so many KZheadrs, such as that umbrella guy, or incredibly average, that were not even mentioned. It feels like there needs to be like 11 more episodes of all the things that was just not covered at all. Even weirder, I don’t really know (after watching it twice) what it’s thesis really was. Like what was the point, except just to report to someone who didn’t watch the trial or follow social media, about 26% of the story.
They just wanted to let out stephen deuters texts (which were edited by amber) in a biiiig platform as her incompetent lawyers FAILED to bring any witnesses or deuters ON the stand...its to prove somehow that deuters TOLD amber that he TOLD Johnny what amber TOLD dueters (JD kicked her in plane infront of people) and that JD cried..HEARSAY....threre is a reason why amber REFUSED to call stephen on the stand and tampered with his wife Gina deuters with the help of fraud eve fartlow.
Thank you Peter! AH presents as if she was treated unfairly with her “mountain of evidence”. There were legal reasons why they didn’t come in. Brutal how this is still being questioned 🤯
Yes agree. And much of the mountain of evidence could not be authenticated
@@risingphoenix8072 The Best of the trial are the side bar's which came out a few weeks's ago and showed that the AH team KNEW Eve Barlow was sitting in the court with her laptop and other dirty, dishonest things. They knew they had no case that's why this redicolous AH PR hit piece against JD came out. But Netflix has all movies he played in in their database- hypocrites!!
No medical records tho self reported therapy notes aren't admissible and thinking you were abused and being abused 2 very different things, why didn't she file criminal charges for the "abuse"?
@@aleccampbell7707 Exactly. Not even the 4 cops found anything
Remember the hundreds of photos which were of the place Johnny rented for them in Australia. Photo's of flowers 🌺kangaroos and lots of other bs just to make this mountain of evidence looked like she really did have alot. But then only 1 sided txts MSG's the whole time. So infuriating. Then that TMZ photo she sent them during the weeks break. Her girlfriend pretending to be on the legal team to go on social media and pass notes to rottenborn. She played dirty from the get go, and I honestly think she was trying to get the whole court case rejected because knew it wasn't going to work for her. Elaine did so many underhand things to try get things in, she was exhausting. You could see her and Camille's patience running out having to go over things over and over again because she tried getting evidence in that was told NO to constantly
i’m getting angry just reading along with the sidebars: there’s no way i would be able to get through this ridiculous docuseries. i’ll take it one step further, i’ve been thinking about dropping netflix for a while and they just gave me a reason.
My curiosity got the best of me and I wasted 3 hours. You're not missing anything. 😂
I just dropped them, I'm a fan of no one, just a victim of DV..They're calling us fans,so we're blinded
The mainstream media completely failed on this case.
I agree 100%! MSM is so pathetic.
THAT'S FOR SURE!!!!! 😡
I have seen some of the sidebars already, and some of them really highlight how under-handed Elaine was in trying to slip in stuff over and over again around Judge A and the rules of evidence. She either has very little trial experience or plays dumb. When first watched the trial thought that she didnt know about hearsay rules, but then in sidebars, she gives the judge a brief on what she thinks would be objected to as hearsay and why it should be let in at the beginning of the day. Why almost each question there was a sidebar esp during AH testimony. She then tells Judge, well Im going to ask and see what happens so that she can get the question in front of the jury even knowing it was hearsay. I dont know why you would do that except AH may have been insisting. It was a waste of time, made her look dumb and unlikable, and tried Judges patience almost to the point of contempt IMO. The mountain of evidence they wanted in was all hearsay.
It was most unethical shit I've ever seen
Yes Elaine is horrible. She didn’t try to play true. Rottenborn did his best to hurt JD’s team too and they lost because JD told the truth. Elaine knew what she was doing. She was playing dumb and trying her best to get things by Judge A. She’s a dog for that I believe
Where can I find these transcripts? Interested to see more of these sidebars.
Nnn mn
I think Elaine was all about playing dumb. It was embarrassing.
Sidebars make it seem very much like Elaine should have taken 'trial lawyering refreshers for dummies' at the very beginning of trial preparation.
🎯
I watched the actual trial, so it will only frustrate me if there is any spin 🤷🏼♀️
💯💯💯
Same
I was watching Andy on popcorn planet live. He played HIS own footage that Netflix emailed and asked him to give copy right to. He didn’t respond. Then then emailed and said we are using your footage, we’re just letting you know. He still never responded. Then on live, his video was flagged for using footage in the Netflix show that is theirs. He played his own footage. He had Christopher Melcher on and he has a lawsuit against Netflix now. They messed up badly. Multiple creators have lawsuits at this point and they can sue the footage at fair use, but they can’t prevent them from playing and using their own footage and that’s what they are doing.
Yep!! The gaslighting with this case is unlike anything I've ever seen! I'm not going to intentionally sit down and watch something just for it to tell me that what I saw and heard with my own eyes and ears, was wrong!
@@acb1057 yes exactly, I refuse to watch it. I also refuse to watch the little mermaid and Snow White. But that’s another story.
I thought the thing about the ‘kick’ and ‘abuse’ on the plane was that the other people were saying what AH had told them happened, not what they saw/heard themselves.
Netflix stole Andy signores copyrighted content.
And several other people.
@@lynnhoffman247they all should sue Netflix!
...been a Netflix subscriber since 2010. I canceled two (2) Netflix subscriptions today @ $19.99 each & requested the agent note it's because of the Depp vs. Heard Documentary. You know you've been looking for a reason to dump Netflix . Take action, cancel Netflix now & tell Netflix you're canceling because of the Depp vs. Heard documentary. AH, evil personified.
The doco was ridiculous, Johnny is innocent yet they still tried to imply he was guilty
I finally understand the hearsay thing. You can't give your own statements as proof because you could have sent people false statements to create a false record you could use later. I can't text my mother that my sister hit me, and then use that as proof, because there's nothing behind the text. I would have to have someone else's testimony or a picture of the bruises, or video of the hitting. Now I get it. I thought that hearsay had to come from other people.
Same
I wouldn't have watched the Netflix thing if I could have. Nothing can beat watching the actual trial, especially with you explaining the points of law, Peter.
Netflix can be sued because they use footage that Andy Signore from popcorned planet did and he never told them they can us it. Also using footage of Andy meeting JD. Now Netflix says they own the wrights to his footage and now youtube won't let Andy use his footage
I would already have contacted an attorney! What Netflix did was so much BS! They think because they are a big company, a little KZhead creator won’t be able to go up against them. I hope Andy goes after the idiots!
@@lisadearing5960 yeah and how they use footage of Andy meeting JD for the 1st when Andy got tickets for a friend to see the show so Netflix has no wright to say they own all those footage
@@bryonmiles1 Netflix is despicable! Shame on them!
Totally off topic of the video but can i just say, your ability to be a male youtuber and present this content without falling into making degrading comments about women is so appreciated. There are some lawtubers with great content but are so steeped in misogyny it makes watching them unbearable. So, thank you!
My favorite part is when the editing suggested that johnny had wine in his coffee mug during court. They cut to him drinking out of it immediately following the "megapint" section. You know how when a little kid presents a drawing that looks like scribble, but they tell you it's actually a house? This is exactly that, but its Netflix.
I think anyone that watched the trial and saw the evidence can agree that the correct verdict was given. Any social media reaction was based on what was going on during the trial. It was definitely an interesting trial which is why so many people followed it! I also felt the judge and jury took this case very seriously and followed the law. Personally I think having it aired helped viewers see for their own eyes what was going on rather listening to media which can be biased at times.
I watched less than 10 minutes and I already got the idea of what they’re trying to do. They have the tense to always defend criminals and those in the wrong.
I started watching you during Depp trial
The fact that Emma Cooper & Netflix aren’t familiar with the AMERICAN LAW Blows my mind!!! WTH… AH LIED, PERIOD!!
I saw the whole Netflix series today. I saw a glimpse of you without audio and all the other KZhead channels that covered it in the series. I felt like it was clearly biased for AH. It seemed like they wanted to put the blame on social media. Thanks for all the content you create. Out of all the channels that were represented in the series I only watched yours!
Yes just like AH used Christopher Bousy to claim a false narrative, along with mainstream media, who during interviews with Elaine made it appear the trial was biased. Here now Netflix was sued to tout a false narrative.
I have a feeling that this will keep happening cause she is going to try and make a come back, and she will use her connections, she’s too greedy and narcissistic not to. I’m shocked that Netflix crap came out so soon tbh. I think it’s gonna happen like yearly until she thinks ppl forgot and it’s “safe” to come back , maybe not even to Hollywood but perhaps in Spain where she is😒 just my opinion.
@@FabiolaMacabre She's finished.
I just dropped Netflix, real victims we're watching the trial comparing notes..To say wer blinded to the truth..One punch to the face makeup won't cover..No one saw a beaten face..
@@yvonnemurray1253 The things she accused Johnny of doing repeatedly for years; she would've been physically deformed by now.
She lost the trial because the jury didn't like her performance on the witness stand. It did seem like she was lying when asked about the leaking of the video to TMZ.
Was THAT IT FOR YOU?😂😂. It was quite obvious she was lying about FAR more than TMZ. She lied about virtually EVERYTHING.
She lied so many times I couldn't count.
She lost because her lies could not override the facts. She lost because she was guilty of being abusive and her own audio proved he was trying to get away from her abuse and she wasn’t having it. She guaranteed him, if he didn’t stay and fight with her, he would only make it worse for himself .. she lost because Johnny was innocent and proved it.
It’s over. The 3 part Netflix show was already shown in the U.K. back in May. Netflix bought the rights to it from Channel 4. They used a lot of a KZheadrs stuff without his permission in a skewed way & they claimed copyright (illegal). Popcorned Planet now can’t use their own videos & got demonetised & their stream shut down. It’s shocking.
I found you during the Depp v Heard trial and you quickly became a favorite!! God bless you Peter!!
This is crazy!! She was lying & u could tell. Was even caught several times. She just won’t give up & is money hungry!! Sickening!😢
Yep
You can't believe any words that come from Amber Turd 😂💩
Don't worry! Since the last day Johnny has been living his best life. She, on the other hand is hateful & vindictive & can live alone in her misery! Karma!
You go you Depp crazed fan. Just totally ignore all his crazed alcohol/drug rages .
@@Morticia1313, living his alcohol/drug induced "best" life huh???? How blind you Depp whacko fans are....
I’ve never heard or seen anyone talk about her child. Turd on the other hand is another story. SHE DESERVES EVERY LITTLE CRITICISM SHE GOT BECAUSE OF THE LIES SHE SPEWED TO DESTROY HIS CAREER. NO ONE DESERVES THAT
The documentary was so biased to make Amber out to be a victim. It was very obvious
I watched the entire trial live and watched Emily D Baker and Andrea Burkhardt videos on the unsealed documents. I would not have the patience to read them on my own. I won't be watching the Netflix series, I don't need to. I'm not interesting in the Netflix spin. Amber Heard was vilified because she's a terrible person!! I'm not a Johnny Depp FAN.. he's a great actor but I don't care enough to side with him just because he's Johnny Depp. I didn't even know he was in a band until the trial.. that's how uninterested I was in his life/career. I vaguely remember seeing he married a younger blonde at some point but couldn't pick Amber Heard out of a crowd so my opinions of Amber are based on HER actions not out of loyalty to Johnny Depp!! Now that the trial is over, I'm happy he is away from her and that his reputation is restored BUT I would feel that way about any man who had to deal with her or anyone like her. Anywho, thanks for covering this! I enjoy your videos and you have great hair 😂
Totally agree! I didn’t even know about the Netflix series. Definitely not going to waste my time. I watched the entire trial, my opinion is based solely on the on what I saw/heard. The trial only captured my attention because my daughter mentioned it. I knew who Depp was from years ago, but his movies didn’t interest me and I had no idea who AH was. I also listened Emily and Andrea. I do enjoy LYK, Peter and his father are unbiased.
Insulting content creators (while stealing their content) instead of covering the trial was weak. That’s not the story, the story was the transgression of Metoo, a woman claiming to be a victim actually being the aggressor. But the truth isn’t important to the mainstream anymore.
D v H is what brought me to your channel. I stuck around and feel I learn so much about the whole legal process. 😊
I thought the Netflix series was ridiculous on trying to blame social media for Heard losing. I love how they introduced her crapping in the bed, lieing about her makeup and that horrible acting on the stand. There were many things I had forgotten about during the trial. I watched the trial and will never forget the recording of Heard freaking out about Depp visiting his daughter at the house. That was scary and I feel horrible for her infant daughter to be in her custody in Spain.
I saw a little bit of the documentary, and it seemed to me like they wanted to blame the lawyers on you tube for Amber losing. I would love to hear more of the side bars. Thanks
Not watching because I don’t care lol. Watched the entire trial and learned a lot.
Same
Hi Peter, I have been with you pretty much from the beginning of the Depp Heard trial. I really appreciate this video because the sidebars were very enlightening and helpful after having watched the trial live every day for its entirety. My opinion of Elaine as a lawyer was pretty low during the trial and, now that I know her arguments at the bench, I sort of wonder about her intelligence. I don't have Netflix so didn't watch it and there is not a lot on Netflix that I would want to watch.
The frustrating part with ELAINE!! ... she is an attorney. She is supposed to know these rules. She just kept making the same mistake over and over.
She and rottenborn were horrible lawyers
Yes! I would love to hear more on the sidebars! PLEASE 😊😊😊
Cheap Sheets and DUI Guy go through most of the sidebars on each day of the trial.
the social media that reflected bad against Team AH, was more about wimpy evidence and lies she provided during the trial. Fans of JD hoping he would win, had nothing to do with in-court jury interpretation.
After hearing a lot of these sidebars, it seems Elaine doesn’t have a grasp on some of the rules of procedure. She can’t seem to grasp what present sense impression and hearsay mean. 🤣🤣🤣 I’m not an attorney, but even I can understand that. 🤣🤣🤣
Omg so true!! Elaine sucked!!!
Emily D Baker specifically said she was avoiding social media while watching the case unfold and commented on it. As best she could. Her mind made itself up as the case unfolded. I specifically recall that because I was absolutely ready to call AH a liar when evidence of damage at the penthouse was found AFTER the first police call, not BEFORE.
Johnny Depp seems to have just put down his guard and, talked and opened up about the whole thing. Much more down to earth then I thought it would be.
If they wanted mega views (yes, that's a joke on the "megapint"), they could have literally just shown all of Johnny's testimonies. He was so funny 😂 Now that, I'd watch (again).
I agree!! JD was a hoot to watch on the stand.
Johnny Depp was also believable. I'm a feminist and domestic violence survivor and I know Amber Heard is a liar.
@@ileanahernandez1709Once you see it,you can't unsee it, and you can mostly tell who the true liar or true victim is immediately.
I started watching your videos during Depp v Heard. And now I'm a member. 😊
I feel like this video needs to be sent to anyone who watches the Netflix documentary.
Not going to watch Netflix. Saw most of the trial plus 3 lawyers talking about the trial. You, EDB and Law and Lumber. Got hooked on all 3 of you!
Hey Peter, I love your show. You do an amazing job of telling us the legalese of these cases
Thank you for clarifying “self serving hearsay.”
The BPD diagnosis Dr. Curry was spot on imo. I dated someone with BPD and she acted just like Amber. In fact as the trial unfolded I called it before it was ever testified to.
Yeah, me too. Heard's speech patterns and non-arguments that she kept returning to "Oh, If I had wanted to ____, I could have done way more." was like a daily gut punch. And obviously prejudiced me against her, to be fair, but if it shares a large number of traits with a duck...
Hey Peter I’m on rewatch and because the general media did such a poor job as has discovery plus etc on telling this story, I have no intention whatsoever to watch this. I have already heard it’s negative and it’s their own ignorance bc I watched you and EDB and others who ARE lawyers who know what they’re talking about.
How could Elaine pass the bar and not comprehend hearsay? B.S.
She feign ignorance consistently
I think she was just trying so hard to see if anything sticks 😂
People said Elaine was considered a notable lawyer bc she was good at negotiating. I can totally see that, bc she is relentless whether she’s right OR WRONG. I’m sure the other side just gave in at some point bc she’s so annoying. In court that skill has definite limits. Now she’s not across the table from an equal but a judge who can shut her down point blank. I don’t think it was so much Elaine didn’t know the rules as she just doesn’t care what they are.
I havent seen it yet, but I hope they dont try to make it seem like Judge Azcarate was biased because, if anything, it seemed like she was genuinely and legitimately annoyed during at least one of the sidebars and she did not reflect that annoyance in open court. Judge A seemed like she was trying to be fair and just being factual. Elaines lawyers struggled because a lot of their evidence was AH telling her therapist that something happened rather than it being medical evidence of injury. Anybody can say anything, and that was kind of the point of the trial. She made statements and didnt have the proof the jury believed that her statements were factual.
Yes agree, and one example of medical evidence of injury would be a photo that looked like the actual injuries she described. And I’ve wondered why none of her many treating psychologists testified. Dr Hughes could testify about what was in the therapists notes, but could not testify as to whether the therapists actually believed everything they were told. Or why they did not report such brutal evidence of abuse.
I've watched a decent bit of analysis of the trial and why Depp won. One of the points made was how well Vasquez knew court rules and procedures and how useful that knowledge is at trial. It's as if every time Elaine thought she was clear to make an easy lay-up, Vasquez was right there with the block - no penalty, no foul. Vasquez is a phenomenal attorney. She rightfully earned her partnership with her law firm and her sweet TV gig. If I were 30+ years younger, I might want to be her when I grow up.
❤What If Any❤️ 😂 Elaine‘s favorite phrase! Even Camille used it seeing how it worked on Judge A. 😂
I dont have Netflix right now. During the trial I watched psychology in Seattle. Started getting more into lawyers after the behavior panel featured Lori daybell
My Netflix Take Aways: 1) It did a decent job of trying to be--or, maybe more accurately, look--balanced until the last episode, but left off one of the biggest facts that swayed me: the photos that Depp's team proved were edited to make shadows look like bruises and the pictures of Amber in the days following incidents that showed she didn't have any of the injuries she described. 2) They slammed social media for making millions covering the trial, but were silent about traditional media or, I don't know, maybe Netflix using it for content. Also showed a clip about You Tubers having just a few hundred views on videos with random topics who were now blowing up, then cut to EBD, except she was already covering law and had videos with tens or hundreds of thousands of views well before this trial. I cry foul! 3) It really tried to end with allegation that Depp support on social media was just bots and that people are no longer supporting Depp after the sealed documents were unsealed (the Boston plane texts between Deuters and Heard).
Weil it did sway me a little towards the middle - Depp was no saint and clearly Deuters knew something happened, after reading his depositions, he tried to lie himself out of these texts, saying he don’t remember what exactly they were about, then together with Depp lawyers tried to say they were doctored. These texts would change everything if they were presented, the problem was no one had originals apart from an iphone backup
I miss this live.. thank you to the kind person gifting me a membership ❤
I watched every minute of the actual trial - and I watched the Netflix documentary... IMO Netflix seemed to be trying to blame Social Media and KZheadrs, TikTok for the results of the trial. They left out so much of the crap Amber did if someone only watched the Netflix doc and not the whole trial (or at minimum most of the trial) they would think it was decided because Johnny was the bigger star and beloved by all for playing Jack Sparrow..
Your coverage is great Peter. I’d love to see you bring back the JD intro for the JD AH coverage. I started watching you just before the trial. ❤ I won’t be watching the documentary. I saw the trial all the way through, so don’t need to & the media is trying to make Ah out to be truthful which as we saw she is not. The truth is important & as a survivor it disgusts me that they are trying to spin all of this differently. Also watching other creators get copyright strikes for their own content that they didn’t give permission for, is another reason that would stop me watching. It’s wrong. She knowingly lied & she abused JD & she hasn’t had any consequences for it. All that should matter is the Truth.
So frustrating Peter…the evidence was SO against her..I have no interest in watching the Netflix show…very interesting sidebars…all goes to the truth😊 thanks so much for this video Peter 🙏😊
I think that a lot of people should cancel their Netflix account and a lot have already
Came here from JD/AH and never left
I was left wondering if Elaine doesn’t go to trial very often, reaching a settlement before hand, which would explain her poor (for a trial lawyer) of the rules of evidence and the many here say exceptions. But then and email came out where Ben Chew is saying (to Elaine) that he’d been warned about her, and he hadn’t given it much credence, until then. This was during the discovery and pre-trial motions.
I don’t think I am going to watch it because I’m over the trial haha. It was long and more entertaining as it was happening vs now we know the outcome I am satisfied enough with that 🎉
Side bars please!
I agree with you that it really fell flat. I fast forwarded through a lot of it. It was nice to see the testimony side by side, but I’ve heard some creators talk about the content Netflix used from their page getting copyright strikes.
I watched the live trial, listened to many YT commentators and have started the Netflix series. So far I’ve found in interesting and unbiased. There’s no interviews in the Netflix series, it’s truly just showing what happened at the trial and how it was covered by social media.
I just started, but you asked us to comment on whether we want more Sidebars or not. The answer is- YES! YES PLEASE! I've read them and they are FASCINATING. Not even for the "Depp v Heard" of it. It was fascinating to see what was going on behind the scenes between the 2 sides & Judge A. I would love to hear what a real lawyer sees when reading them!
Where can I find these transcripts? Interested to see more of these sidebars
What about the unauthorized use of a bunch of the Lawtube content? And the Popcorn Planet guy's footage?
This series was released in May in UK as a Channel 4 doc, now sold to Netflix, so the sidebars etc hadn't been released then. Haven't watched. It's still available for us in UK on Channel 4.
I came here in the Petito case. I stayed for your covering of Depp v Heard. I think the Netflix was sensationalized and bent toward Heard. Esp at the end! Yes I watched it.
You were the first lawyer i watched on youtube and I came in during the Johnny Depp trial. I now follow a few more but you're my favorite. It's exciting to see your channel grow.
I always appreciate your coverage and take on everything! 😊 Found you during Depp V Heard but have stayed and hung out since
I watched almost the whole trial live (I missed opening arguments). I recently re-watched the trial from JD’s testimony. It was nice to be able to watch the video depo’s on 2X speed……Peter, you nailed Morgen Knight’s clap back at Elaine 🤣🤣🤣!!…….I’m super glad I re-watched the trial now that these side bars are released. 💕💕
It was Morgan Tremaine. Morgan Night was the manager who saw Amber abusing Johnny
Thanks@@Venvaneless
I'm a fan of judge AJ. Such an intelligent, cleverly, fair woman!
I watched it all yesterday. Initially, I didn't want to because I wanted to show no support for Amber, and had heard it was slanted her way.... and yes, I think it was in a way but she still came across so creepy - argumentative, snarky, aggressive- that I still felt zero sympathy for her. It just make me more sure that no victim I ever knew had that aggression when near their abuser. She just came across as such a narcissist than anything else. I also feel it feel flat, and did expect more from it. Frankly, it brought back some of my favorite parts of the trial, which is why I did ENJOY watching it, it was almost like a highlight reel!
I agree. She came off as unbelievable and overly dramatic. I wonder if she'll ever get another job because her acting was B A A A A D.
I hope I’m not overstepping by expressing my “confusion”. The “industry” has really tried over and over to help AH “clear” her name to regain her career. Why?? Does she have “knowledge” of certain famous people’s indiscreet actions? I just don’t understand the insistence with her specifically.🤷🏻♀️
I totally think she does. Wasn’t she referred to as the blackmail queen?
I'm quitting Netflix after this. What an insult to your customers.
I watched it, was angry because they made Lawtube out as being only in it for the money. I believe based on the commentary during the trial everyone was fair in your opinions. As is typical with abusive people, it's never their fault, it is always someone else's fault. The jurors have been accused of not taking their oath seriously. That is despicable on AH and her attorney behalf.
Was the Netflix series sort of a rehashing of what we already learned from you?💕I haven’t watched it and don’t plan to -I had to cut an expense when I signed up for SLING. Oh no. Is it sympathetic to AH referring to this mountain of evidence -that she’s 😂been denied her a fair trial. Oh that’s so irresponsible of Netflix if that’s the case
Yep they are framing it as Johnny won bc of lawtube & social media. I stopped after episode 1
@@anastasiaabrahim9096 I can’t stand that whole scam that AH loves to dissolve into tears about (minus the tears) that she’s been pulled into this position so unfairly when all she wanted was to move on. She’s the attacker who won’t let go. Does she really think anyone’s buying this abused little victim role when she fluctuates between this and back to the screaming shrew when the meek vulnerable ploy stops working. 😡
Thanks Peter. Started following you with this trial. Been in rewatch crew since.
My God...As if we didn't think Elaine was a jerk before!!! 😂😂😂. WOW. That woman. Just WOW
Dang it, I missed the live😢 Rewatch crew!!
Great recap and analysis of the side bars, Peter! The Netflix series did a good job encapsulating the entire 6-week trial in Parts 1 and 2. However, Part 3 dealt with the influence of KZheadrs and other social media on the outcome of the trial. I think that's so unfair. Yes, there was a lot of love for Depp, but Heard proved to me that she's a lying liar that lies. I watched the entire trial, and I'm sure the jurors deliberated and arrived at their verdict based on the testimony and evidence as instructed by Judge Azcarate. Elaine seemed rattled, especially when she introduced her client to the jury as Laura Amber Heard. The debacle with the make-up compact didn't help the case when the defense discovered that it hadn't yet been on the market when Heard claimed to have used it to "cover up her bruises". It must be difficult dealing with a client that lies to you and having no medical evidence of her ever suffering injuries at the hand of Depp. If you really want to understand all the nuances of the trial, skip the Netflix series and go back and watch Peter's coverage. He's one of the best in the business!
You do such an excellent job of explaining the why behind these sidebars: Why they happen and why or why not the objections get sustained. I'm really enjoying these followup videos on the JDvAH trial. So much happened over the 6 weeks of trial that we never got to see and understand, and now that we have the sidebar transcripts, we can understand! I'm not planning on watching the Netflix documentary because the mainstream media has done such an awful job of reporting on this case. Over and over again, they reveal an agenda to paint women as victims and men as abusers regardless of the evidence, and this case was as clear as you could get that she was lying and manufacturing evidence. I don't know why the media wants this narrative out there, but it's getting pretty disgusting to see it so much. Unless people start saying that they did a really good balance job of reporting the facts of the case, then I'm not giving it the time of day.
Came here for depp v heard and your the only one I still listen to
Have missed your videos on the JD & AH case. Thanks for diving back in.