In this video, I go through the entire QB class for the 2024 NFL Draft, analyzing their game and ranking them from my lowest grades, all the way to the top guy.
Ranking Every QB in the 2024 NFL Draft
For more film breakdowns follow us here:
atozsports.com/all-nfl-film-r...
NFL Draft Board: atozsports.com/nfl-draft/2024...
Instagram: / atozsportsfilmroom
TikTok: / atozfilmroom
Twitter: / noflagsfilm
Facebook: / nflfansatoz
#NFLDraft #NFLFootball #FilmRoom
All film used is courtesy of NFL+ and the All-22 broadcasts associated with that service and subscription. No copyright is intended.
2024 NFL Draft Big Board: atozsports.com/nfl-draft/2024-nfl-draft-big-board-top-prospects/
Like your breakdowns brotha! Very objective and informational. Always learn allot from your videos about prospects. I don’t see it with McCarthy either he’s going to be drafted to high and expected to come in and be a savior when he’s not ready. Are u doing every position? Keep up the Good work.
Been a fan of Maye since last year, I’ve stood by the fact that I think he’s QB1 in the class but all three of the top QBs seem like starting caliber players for a lot of teams
Drake Maye passing grade since 2022 w/ class rank: from clean pocket: 2nd throwing beyond sticks: 1st no play action: 1st straight dropback: 1st
W
Great vid 👍
Caleb Williams definitely doesn’t have a slight build. He looked like a mini tank on his pro day
I truly don’t see it with Drake Maye. I think maybe I’m crazy at this point but he’s got a long release, he’s erratic throwing the ball, he looks unsure if he wants to throw the ball or not on a lot of his throws. I truly don’t see it or understand it. I get it with Caleb Williams i really do. His accuracy is truly elite and he’s consistent with it. Drake Maye is way too hit or miss with his accuracy amongst other things. Idk…we shall see i guess.
Caleb Williams meat rider
His feet work is atrocious, biggest red flag
This is basically everything Chris simms says
Cmon bro u watch all that film and drake maye was the guy
😂
Drake Maye is my 1a too, but you can’t go wrong with either of these guys. I think people need to check the 2022 Maye tape when he had a receiver who could actually bet man coverage. Yes, he wasn’t great in 2023 against Man, but not many QBs are when their receivers cannot get open.
What website are you using to compile all of these analytics?
Pff analytics
You’re falling in love with the arm talent only w Maye. Don’t be fooled.
And iq
jason bean the gem of the draft
Great insight on the later round guys, I wonder who is going to exceed his draft position years from now? Smart move on picking Drake over Caleb as everyone is saying caleb is 1, if he’s misses and drake hits, you look like a million bucks!
I think Austin reed should be a tiny bit higher because if you look at the stats you can see that he had (31 tds and 11 ints) this year and (40 tds and 11 ints) last year
He also lead collage in passing yards last year to
Reed super underrated heard he added more arm strength working with coaching
Great stuff... Question ❓ Brock Purdy... Did you see this when he was in college ❓Is it possible for a guy like Sam Hartman ❓Is it the coaching, the team, the system, an attitude... Because when I looked at Dak Prescott college tape I couldn't see Dallas Dak Prescott. What can analytics tell you about these QBs, that makes it possible for a Jalen Hurts... I'm a Giants fan... There is something missing here in all analytics that can't justify these QB's like Tom Brady vs a Peyton Manning from college. Is it Heart... Desire... An upbringing... Because Patrick Mahomes has that thing Brady has... Desire... Or maybe I'm just missing it... I like Penix, but Bo Nix seems better... I'm interested in what you think 🤔.Who would fit the Giants the best❓
Interesting rankings. You stated your reasons, now we'll wait.
I would have to partially disagree with you on Caleb playing hero ball. USC had such a bad defense giving up so many points, Caleb needed to take more risks which makes his stats lower.
Joe Milton is Anthony Richardson lite. Insane value on day 3
Physically he's a lot closer to Josh Allen. Also don't know about the value. Talented but spent 6 years in college and is still raw? at 24? Him succeeding at QB doesn't seem likely atp. He does have the talent to switch to TE but his talent is really at QB.
@@whoopiebob8782 honestly Joe Milton should have transferred to a pro style college school 2 years ago he would have been a top 5 pick. He stayed at Tennessee where they run an offense that is all half reads and go routes so he never got reps to develop the skills needed for the league. He needs to sit for 2 years under a great offensive coach and sky’s the limit.
@@bredmitch737 yeah he should of but he definitely wouldn’t of been a top 5 pick. He’s shown a significant lack of development regardless of the situation. Tennessee definitely isn’t a system to get you ready for the NFL but Hendon Hooker showed significantly better tape as a QB than Milton(Hooker had better weapons but even still). I tried to give him a pass after Michigan but the guy is just raw. It’d be 1 thing if it was just the ability to read coverages. But it’s also a significant lack of accuracy and that’s something scheme doesn’t restrict. He might just not be a QB and that’s ok but it’s hard to blame the scheme when we seen a Tennessee QB last year and a Michigan QB this year who are worlds above him as a QB. He’s probably the next Tyree Jackson.
He’s Anthony Richardson if Anthony Richardson was one of the worst college sack avoiders in the last 10 years instead of one of the best
@@whoopiebob8782 you are right am just a fan of him but you are absolutely right his accuracy is why I would have him on the bench for 2 years and if it doesn’t improve release him
I feel like the age and the auburn years for Bo Nix didnt get taken into account. Nix is very old and also didnt look good under auburns more pro style offense. Plus at 24 thats very old for a qb prospect.
I usually take your word as football gospel I just don’t agree with Caleb under drake but we shall see. Great video and thanks for the continuous top quality content
Idk, for me personally going into this video from watching and listening about QB’s, Drake I feel is the more NFL ready QB, yes he has a lower floor then Caleb but I like Drake a lot, more well rounded Edit: I meant higher floor for Drake mate, Williams has the higher cieling
You Caleb Williams meat rider
@@tommyp5498 I seen that sit down drake had with Rick spielman and said how he is in close contact with Philip rivers and has been mentored by him the past year. So you are right he is more nfl ready per se but I honestly see him as a more athletic and polished Jake locker . I have doubts about his leadership and accuracy. Also has a B+ arm talent nothing special
@@tommyp5498being more NFL with a lower floor doesn't add up. It's either 1 or the other.
@@bredmitch737 who is Jake locker 😂
Wasn’t Jaxson Dart the QB at Ole Miss?
Ye
Next year draft class
Really hoping maye falls to the pats. I like him a lot as well I’m a big fan of the tradition style QB
Top 5: 14:29
Drake Maye is no where near C Williams or J Daniels!
Rattler Stafford 2.0 Milton flacco 2.0
Drake Maye huh? Hmmmm
Caleb has more strengths but is graded lower? Im sorry but Caleb is easily QB1 of the class despite him being a little weird off the field
You are a joke meat riding that joke of a Caleb Williams
Drake has less leadership concerns, much better size and a tick more arm strength. BUT Caleb might have the most talent I’ve ever seen at the position.
@@chriswaughrealestate HUh ??? I wouldn’t say the MOST EVER just easily the most in THIS draft or the past few
@@zendariuskincaid5205who’s the most talented for you in cfb history coming out the draft
I would take Drake of Caleb just cause of the size. Caleb is listed at 6’1 realistically he’s 5’10-5’11
Caleb and Daniel’s are the best
Let bro have an opinion and we’ll see how it turns out
Running backs
You’re putting your reputation on Maye, especially with a chance he goes to Patriots…too risky. Good luck
No
Ain’t no way ur tryna tell me drake maye is the best QB in draft
He is very underrated by many people. I hope he doesn’t go to NE
You suck
Drake is going to be a bust!
Maye ranked so high onna really overhyped QB draft class, for me only Williams is a lock, Maye and Milton are really good prospects but raw, and Nix can make it on a good system, all others.... Now about Drake ranking he is the most unaccurate QB of the top 6, dropping from 65% comp to 63% comp and having regresion from one year to another, he is also the lowest under 50% on 20+ yard passes, how can be graded so high on such unaccuracy and lack of ball placement, also how can you get high value on low read calacity, watch the tape he goes 1-2 then 1 again then 3 man is irritating, I do not see him better than Caleb and his Pisical attributes are bailing on him, if he was 6'2" he would be ranked bellow 8 or 9 so nice to have good genetics but he is more Daniel Jones than Justin Herbert
I agree with everything you said, except Drake man... drake is inaccurate, like really quite bad inaccurate. I can't fathem why or how you have him ranked higher than Caleb who is clearly way better imo. I think you might be falling in love with what could be (arm talent, size, athleticism) and overlooking his issues. Concencus has Maye as QB 3 right now, and I can't see it getting better from here. Boom or bust shouldn't go nombre one overall in a class with Jaden, Caleb and even Bo Nix
I don't see it with Drake Maye tbh. He's okay but he's not elite imo
Drake maye is a 2nd or 3rd rounder
Me when I lie
This is silly. The 3 guys who didn’t win, and didn’t make the plays are the top 3? McCarthy, Penix, & Nix were all better than these three. no wonder NFL scouts r wrong 90% of the time.
“Jj doesn’t have experience” is such a washed narrative. Who of any of these QBs have ever won ANYTHING besides an individual award? Who played the most games this season? Who left the games early bc they were already up 30 points? Look at the most 1st half throw % out of the whole class. Jj is borderline qb2
@@GamerBro22299 maye is a project but higher ceiling. Daniel’s carried by 2 nfl WRs and couldn’t beat a defense in the top 50 of total scoring. JJ has experience in a pro style offense while every single other qb sat shotgun with a motion player every single play. Come back to this.
@@joshcashin563 Most you can do is mute me. Go on
I mean, he has some experience? The whole talk about him being borderline QB2, well idk if I want to agree with you on that but I’m not going to blast you for thinking about JJ that way. I definitely see your point man but again, I’m not too high on him
I'm with ya on JJ. People are really hating on this kid, calling him a bust. I think a good many are U-M haters in general. I'm gonna love coming back in a 2 or 3 years and saying I told u so 1000 times. I'm taking JJ in a heartbeat. I'd love for NYG to get him at 6, but if not, I hope he goes to a team where he's able to sit the 1st year and just learn... kinda like Mahomes did. To me, Maye and Nix have bust written all over them.. same for Penix. Honestly, I'm 50/50 on Daniels. Caleb amd JJ are the only 2 I'd take with complete confidence.
He completed 10 whole passes in the national championship game!
Basically all bro said is if you don’t look at Jayden Daniel’s tape against other nfl talent he’s actually a lot better. Said the same thing about Maye. Well I’d hope my nfl qb can beat future car salesmen
Said that Spencer rattler is too short at 6 foot to see over pass rush yet Caleb Williams at a whopping 6’1 should be fine
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Drake maye the highest rated QB 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 yikes id take 5ish Qb’s now who will be better pros
Name them
@@gregorylightbody255 Williams Bo nix Rattler Daniels
@@zendariuskincaid5205 lmao rattler and nix you lost credibility