KZhead
Ойын-сауық

國外聲樂老師對比《青藏高原》舞台 Vocal Coach Reaction to The Qing-Zang/Tibetan Plateau

CZ Media
2024 ж. 23 Мам.
216 831 Рет қаралды
Жүктеу

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZhead: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
Chapters:
00:00 龚琳娜
06:20 张惠妹
13:36 韩红
19:16 茜拉
23:16 阿兰
28:58 总结
29:43 声乐小课堂
30:16 預告《没离开过》舞台对比
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #龚琳娜 #韩红 #张惠妹 #阿兰 #shilaamzah #茜拉

Пікірлер

  • 不好意思，这首歌肯定无数人唱过不可能全都拿来对比。作为一名听流行音乐为主的海外友人我并不清楚原唱是谁，对舞台素材的搜索基本上是根据油管推荐或热门视频来的，印象中一直错以为韩红是原唱。据了解，原唱是李娜，但看了一下也没有找到适合对比的，有明显Live特征的舞台。谭晶会有自己的系列啦。

    @ClubZeroMedia@ClubZeroMedia8 ай бұрын

    • 其实在后面放一个彩蛋就更好了 ，就是周深清唱了一小段。谢谢你做了这么好的视频分享给我们。

      @user-om2ru5ir5x@user-om2ru5ir5x8 ай бұрын

    • 希望也能有張惠妹的完整系列 謝謝🙏

      @TheA5050222@TheA50502228 ай бұрын

    • 没有李娜版本的，太遗憾了，至少是这首歌的巅峰

      @user-cd8qu2kj7c@user-cd8qu2kj7c8 ай бұрын

    • 我也以为李娜在最后 不过没关系啦 韩红够给力了 毕竟是藏族风格民歌

      @evenbenjamin@evenbenjamin8 ай бұрын

    • 李娜 kzhead.info/sun/dM2Ed6plhKyjjYE/bejne.htmlsi=LrkUZjepZSbz6VDy 云朵 kzhead.info/sun/d5uGecyxp5GJqok/bejne.htmlsi=4twLL4BW4HaqMBbu

      @user-cd8qu2kj7c@user-cd8qu2kj7c8 ай бұрын

  • 因为张惠妹没有按照藏族方言的发音点唱，所以听起来不是青藏地区的歌，更像台湾高山族那种味道。 方言音能带出那种原始感

    @miracleangel6094@miracleangel60946 күн бұрын

    • Well said

      @andrugung5110@andrugung5110Күн бұрын

  • 那么多人要求向老师解释藏族民歌唱法的，我反而觉得不解释才有惊喜。老师的知识库里没有藏族民歌唱法这个知识点，她才找了她所理解的最接近的yodel唱法来做诠释。是的，因为她没有这个知识储备，所以理解不太“正确”，可是，正因为这个不太“正确”的说法，却让我眼前一亮。对哟，阿尔卑斯山区跟藏区都是高山区，牧民在呼唤牲口的时候都需要有能够穿透远距离的嘹亮的声音，衍生出来的唱法和发出声音的质量就算不完全一样，也有很高的相似之处，唱法也许也有些许相似？ 很多人也许跟我一样，之前没意识到把藏族民歌和yodel唱法做类比，现在因为老师这么一说，突然之间有打通了任督二脉的感觉，这不是最好的文化碰撞吗？

    @dwmobusa@dwmobusa8 ай бұрын

    • 我贊同您的說法🎉文化碰撞的驚喜❤ 我認為音樂是無遠弗屆，並非哪一種特殊的唱腔、唱法就只屬於某一個國度或專屬某一個人，流行文化及音樂也可以隨著人文的流動去到世界上的任何一個角落，為何要受到侷限？ 真心覺得在聆聽音樂的人們能把眼界耳界放開接納更多的花火！ 一首歌，就算不了解詞意也可以因為曲調及傳唱人的感情傳達讓聽的人產生共鳴。

      @aprotidechung@aprotidechung8 ай бұрын

    • Can't agree more

      @adriannelcy710@adriannelcy7108 ай бұрын

    • 你说的真的太对了，我在bilibili看到很多这种评论，他们觉得很生气，可我反而觉得由此引发出的关于藏民族唱法和yodel为什么如此相似的问题是更加有趣和值得讨论的。没必要总用对立的视角看问题

      @KatnissL@KatnissL5 ай бұрын

    • Really feel like打通任督二脈

      @lones7660@lones76604 ай бұрын

    • 完全同意

      @chloehsu3294@chloehsu32943 ай бұрын

  • 張惠妹必須自己一集！！！

    @ashin1019@ashin10198 ай бұрын

    • 希望可以讓老師看阿妹歷年表演

      @elmushx1768@elmushx17687 ай бұрын

    • @@user-zj7cr2pg7c 浪費的只有你的時間 ㄏㄏ

      @KoTube-co5eo@KoTube-co5eo6 ай бұрын

    • @@user-zj7cr2pg7c 沒水準的快滾回家

      @boweichen2025@boweichen20256 ай бұрын

    • 是啊悅耳的音色，真摯的情感，專業的技巧！！女阿妹男eason

      @arielyu3535@arielyu35353 ай бұрын

    • 而且要分早中近期，因為阿妹早期的歌聲真的超讚❤

      @user-eu1hj1nj2i@user-eu1hj1nj2iАй бұрын

  • 這老師從沒聽過藏族風的音樂 卻能精準抓到技巧特色 且能模仿七八分 真的非常厲害

    @bonly4806@bonly48066 күн бұрын

  • 老师的解说太出色了。她的耳朵太灵敏，而且可以立刻捕捉到每个歌者的不同特点。字母用词也非常到位。谢谢你们的出色工作，帮助我们提高鉴赏力！！！

    @linalin2396@linalin23963 күн бұрын

  • 每個民族的文化都不同，阿妹是台東人，台灣卑南族的原住民，後面那段就是台灣的原住民語，他選擇用更貼近他生長環境的狀態與方式去唱這首青藏高原，台東的高山、溪谷美得驚人，老師真的很厲害一聽把歌手表演的心思都說出來了😍

    @user-ji3lx4mb4b@user-ji3lx4mb4b8 ай бұрын

    • 对对，闭上眼睛就是带去台湾高山的感觉，不是西藏。因为阿妹没有用到藏族那种方言发音，所以是台湾味道的。也很好听。

      @miracleangel6094@miracleangel60946 күн бұрын

    • A-Mei 跟 Andrea Bocelli有合作過哦！

      @user-ty4md4fo1d@user-ty4md4fo1d4 күн бұрын

    • 但是她退步了

      @jzw8339@jzw83393 күн бұрын

    • @@jzw8339她的聲音很早就壞了

      @YanXiLiu815@YanXiLiu81519 сағат бұрын

  • I admire this coach very much.

    @-isaid@-isaid5 ай бұрын

  • 這個老師好有魅力

    @thewhisperofsoul2182@thewhisperofsoul21827 ай бұрын

  • 五位都是超級厲害歌手🎉🎉精彩的視頻。

    @user-fx7yl9fi5l@user-fx7yl9fi5l7 ай бұрын

  • 終於又有阿妹了

    @fixedouble@fixedouble8 ай бұрын

  • 竟然暗示韓紅是在對嘴，我愛死這老師了😂😂😂

    @user-il8ep2vb8j@user-il8ep2vb8j7 күн бұрын

    • 很有可能 或者早期影片上傳後都大修音過

      @TheWalt31509@TheWalt315095 күн бұрын

    • @@TheWalt31509韩红参加的这个“歌声飞过39年”纪念改革开放的节目，全都是假唱，无一例外。

      @wuaaron808@wuaaron8083 күн бұрын

  • 非常精彩的视频！专业的角度，老师讲到韩红的约德尔调太可爱啦😂可能山歌都有共同之处吧🎉🎉🎉

    @tiequanliu2938@tiequanliu29386 ай бұрын

  • 其实更值得赞扬的是老师旁边没有露面的那位华人，是他用自己的对华人音乐的深刻理解把中华文化推荐传播到世界各地。谢谢🙏

    @pengjunsun3683@pengjunsun36837 ай бұрын

    • 也是我一直想说的话，他很赞！谢谢他🙏！

      @hguo7931@hguo79314 ай бұрын

    • 尤其是很会翻译，超级准确。

      @athomenotavailable@athomenotavailableАй бұрын

    • 謝謝華人小哥，你拉近了東西方文化的距離

      @shiang-weihuang4533@shiang-weihuang4533Ай бұрын

    • 之前以为是西人助手。才知道是华人

      @user-ff6hq6sd8t@user-ff6hq6sd8t7 күн бұрын

    • 广东小弟

      @user-ld7nk9ru6g@user-ld7nk9ru6g7 күн бұрын

  • Amei真的很需要一期

    @holiday000@holiday0008 ай бұрын

  • 這集每位歌手都有本身民族性色彩，各領風騷。

    @lairicky0427@lairicky04278 ай бұрын

  • 我的天啊 老師一直在示範跟說明唱腔共鳴，真的好想聽看老師來演繹這首作品❤

    @a5130463@a51304638 ай бұрын

  • Coach Rozetta, you are always such a professional master. I am really amazed to every analysis and comment you made. Thumps up❤

    @ChenChan-pe5hs@ChenChan-pe5hs8 ай бұрын

  • Amei!Amei!Amei!❤

    @shantylee2415@shantylee24158 ай бұрын

  • 唢呐真的是一件非常有趣的乐器！我认为它是最接近人声的木管乐。穿透力和气质都如此特别。

    @botreepri@botreepri4 ай бұрын

  • Bravo to your reaction. You are the best vocal coach on KZhead. Your music knowledge and expertise are so impressive when you react to music you are not familiar at all. Your instinc is so precise and it makes you get to the point quickly and naturally. Two thumbs up!

    @hunterornot@hunterornot21 күн бұрын

  • 都是厲害的歌手，等不及想看老師的評語，還要等待的時間真久

    @user-ez7ds6lr6c@user-ez7ds6lr6c8 ай бұрын

  • 張惠妹必須好好介紹！！

    @lucky094147@lucky0941478 ай бұрын

  • 比起眾歌手的演繹，我更對這位老師能夠模仿出不同的唱法感到驚嘆

    @KoTube-co5eo@KoTube-co5eo6 ай бұрын

  • 老師的阿妹初體驗~~能唱好這一首歌的,都不是一般人啊~~

    @cedrichsu5228@cedrichsu52288 ай бұрын

  • 敲碗~張惠妹

    @user-it6zm8bv1z@user-it6zm8bv1z8 ай бұрын

  • 期待一整集阿妹的！

    @user-di8ml1se8c@user-di8ml1se8c7 ай бұрын

  • 听到老师对shila的讲评非常高兴，毕竟对于中文还属于不怎么好的情况下，可以唱出个人的味道，是👍的，绝对值得鼓励

    @yorklimchuah8355@yorklimchuah83557 ай бұрын

  • 最愛是索朗旺姆版本 超強力量，魔王級 希望可以讓老師看一下 另外也有vitas的版本， 很搞笑

    @despairingleonardo@despairingleonardo8 ай бұрын

  • 該做張惠妹Amei特輯了吧!!!敲碗!!

    @nono5557@nono55578 ай бұрын

  • 這次視頻聽的我開心死了~~哈哈哈哈！

    @user-hr7yy1vv3y@user-hr7yy1vv3y8 ай бұрын

  • 很喜愛韓紅的温暖歌聲， 剛中帶柔，聽的讓人舒服。

    @kevinlai3861@kevinlai38617 ай бұрын

  • 張惠妹真的要ㄧ集😊

    @viviennechen1489@viviennechen14898 ай бұрын

  • 好期待，一直更新雖然明知不會更早看到。 雖然很愛老龔，但這片中最欣賞韓紅的版本。其他也不錯。 老師跟大大繼續加油！！現在多了你們的互動更有趣，真期待每次影片的互動跟表情！！好喜歡！！

    @adriannelcy710@adriannelcy7108 ай бұрын

  • 許願也許明天這首歌出一集 阿妹、姚貝娜、叮噹、李佳薇等等版本都好好聽❤️❤️

    @hong72@hong728 ай бұрын

  • 第一次觉得声乐是这么复杂和有技巧的事情。她的耳朵怎么这么厉害，专业就是专业！我啥都听不出来，就是觉得她点评的好厉害！

    @snowampl@snowampl6 күн бұрын

  • I like shila's version the most too, I've brought up about shila before. I am so happy that you brought her video up for Rozette, and I really look forward to more reaction on Shila. As Rozette is so in love with "personal style" kind of singer, I believe she'll like Shila as she sang every song to become her own version. Unforturnately shila had fade out from china entertainment industry. You might want to tell Rozette that chinese is not her first language and it's very very challenging for her to learn a new chinese song every 1-2 weeks for multiple shows that she've participated in China.

    @xddd0909@xddd09098 ай бұрын

  • Proud of our Malaysian Malay singer Shila Amzah. Doing well although not a Chinese.

    @raymondng18@raymondng187 ай бұрын

  • 期待張惠妹的整集reaction 老師拜託了🥹😍🙏

    @TheA5050222@TheA50502228 ай бұрын

  • 期待張惠妹特輯⋯我心中的天后！沒有之一

    @q0930546753@q09305467536 күн бұрын

  • 千年琵琶万年铮，唢呐一出全剧终。唢呐，中国传统乐器之王，值得了解一下

    @user-fl3jz6lp3y@user-fl3jz6lp3y8 ай бұрын

  • coach should listen to 4th singer who sang beyonce song as well...she is singer from malaysia..she is malay..it's really hard for malays to sing chinese song that well..glad u like it❤

    @nikkonick1@nikkonick18 ай бұрын

  • 張惠妹要特別一集🎉🎉🎉

    @user-wv6ms8vr9z@user-wv6ms8vr9z7 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹把藏族風格歌曲轉變成台灣原住民族音樂風格很特別

    @user-tv5jt9lm2v@user-tv5jt9lm2v3 күн бұрын

  • 可以拍一個阿妹年輕到老的特輯，就像陶喆那集一樣。

    @DaYiLe@DaYiLe8 ай бұрын

  • 茜拉的青藏高原真的超级好听，听到老师的点评快感动得哭了

    @ahfoong2502@ahfoong25028 ай бұрын

    • 22：11走音

      @1105drum@1105drum2 ай бұрын

    • 比較像唱聲樂

      @user-qf3ml8fq5s@user-qf3ml8fq5s21 күн бұрын

  • JJ正在北京開concert，聽說邀請了周深，韓紅做嘉賓，都是Rozette的最愛，好期待你們react他們的合作

    @bluem3zs@bluem3zs8 ай бұрын

    • 吃瓜不信瓜❤

      @user-ce5ym5pi6o@user-ce5ym5pi6o8 ай бұрын

    • ​@@user-ce5ym5pi6o是真的啦。我已经看到很多饭拍他俩当晚的合唱了。

      @sunnyding298@sunnyding2988 ай бұрын

  • 這期很棒，但是每次看留言一堆點名周深的，我們也想多聽聽老師對別的歌手的點評好嗎？

    @user-ne4rd1yq8g@user-ne4rd1yq8g8 ай бұрын

  • 唱高音时声音更聚焦而不是把嘴型弄圆，使声音更圆润，正是民歌唱法和西洋声乐唱法的不同之处。

    @koolaid2028@koolaid20288 ай бұрын

  • 真心贊同阿妹 要獨立一集 值得老師大量關注

    @user-no1eb5lf7t@user-no1eb5lf7t8 ай бұрын

    • 阿妹唱这首歌是实力已经没法跟以前比了

      @tianyuxing3096@tianyuxing30968 ай бұрын

    • 我也想聽丫妹的歌評

      @tommyng2708@tommyng27088 ай бұрын

    • 阿妹 直接拿這次巡演來當素材吧！這次質量太高了

      @JuzSayWooo@JuzSayWooo8 ай бұрын

    • 期待❤

      @user-bv4ee2ne5k@user-bv4ee2ne5k7 ай бұрын

    • 阿妹每個時期的聲音不同，這首過後的幾年，他又換了習慣的共鳴

      @5566740293@55667402936 ай бұрын

  • i think you should react more to Shila Amzah songs. She is a great siger from Malaysia.

    @letitbe4732@letitbe47327 ай бұрын

  • Thanks for reviewing Shila Amzah!! She's a Malaysian Singer!!!

    @dennislim.official@dennislim.official3 күн бұрын

  • 这个老师太厉害了，一听就知道是对嘴

    @yizaijeremy8330@yizaijeremy83306 ай бұрын

  • Amei love you always!❤

    @juniec.1261@juniec.1261Ай бұрын

  • 個人最喜歡韓紅與阿蘭的版本 有高原的味道

    @lisawinston1548@lisawinston15488 ай бұрын

    • 你听听李娜的版本，我更喜欢李娜。并非先入为主，李娜版本更有藏族民歌的风格。

      @Zhizunbao0508@Zhizunbao05086 ай бұрын

  • Never heard of 4th singer before... Looking at video title, I think her name is Shilaamazah? Her Mandarin pronunciation is not bad - bonus points for her to sing a Mandarin song so well!! However, I think for this type of song, I still prefer the "traditional" style (e.g. 1st / 3rd singer).... They are all great singers though. 🥰🥰

    @skyloft1111@skyloft11118 ай бұрын

  • The lady with the scarf was Shila, a Malaysia singer, and she sang a lot of English songs too, look forward for teacher to comment on her performance more

    @brandonapple942@brandonapple9428 ай бұрын

    • the pronunciation of the Mandarin song she sang, for me is the most accurate.. she did not know Mandarin.. and yet she challenged herself to I am a Singer, in China.. amazing..

      @sarahregine4184@sarahregine41842 күн бұрын

  • Amei amei amei ❤❤❤

    @amei99@amei998 ай бұрын

  • 龚丽娜老师是清唱的， 所以和其他选手做整体艺术对比会吃亏。 韩红的版本更有民族感地域感， 给人一种想去高原看看的感觉。

    @chongliu1715@chongliu171523 күн бұрын

  • Sheila的listen堪稱一絕

    @bonohsiang9913@bonohsiang99138 ай бұрын

  • 这么多人推荐，怀着朝圣的心情看了李娜的版本。第一感受就是这绝对是老歌，有很多那个年代的风格，其次是歌手的表情有种认真执行任务或必须完成任务的感觉。老歌听了不少，除了特殊场合演出，带来任务感高于艺术感或愉悦感的真的不多。我见识浅薄，并没有听出李娜唱出多少高原感或西藏感，倒是更像汉人的流行歌曲+炫技。倒是一些西藏素人随意唱首当地民谣更优美，技术不多，但情真意切不输腾大爷的‘天堂’。天堂每听必哭，李娜的青藏只觉大器大气大器大气…

    @vilyaelrond1586@vilyaelrond15868 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹超好聽

    @user-gi8rx2qw9f@user-gi8rx2qw9f7 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹和韩红的音色绝美! 期待下一期😂😂😂

    @user-jf6tg5kq3u@user-jf6tg5kq3u8 ай бұрын

  • 最愛阿妹。

    @kellyhsieh9239@kellyhsieh92398 ай бұрын

  • 這1~2天看了老師大約7~80支影片，很喜歡也很敬佩老師的講評，但在這支影片裡，我似乎感受到老師對華語高原傳統吟唱歌曲的理解有限，似乎這不在老師現代歌曲背景的認知範疇內，雖然音樂不分國界，音樂都是相通的，但畢竟幾千年的華語傳統歌曲的曲風曲調太過深奧了，轉音複雜變化多，尤其是這種吟唱式的高原歌曲…，不過仍然很喜歡老師這種很真實的講評。

    @chen88hi@chen88hiКүн бұрын

  • 这个很棒，但最喜欢李娜版的，在西藏的时候每天脑袋里都回响着这样的旋律，苍茫、庄严、充满野性又十分宁静，像车窗外裸露着的连绵起伏的高原群山，歌声中对磅礴群山的热爱令人落泪。

    @user-oo4rf3wq1p@user-oo4rf3wq1p3 ай бұрын

    • ❤李娜在我心中也是最好的詮釋者

      @xumingfan1415@xumingfan1415Күн бұрын

  • 韩红的版本听起来最自然。不愧是高原上长大的。

    @LiLi-ij5uk@LiLi-ij5ukАй бұрын

  • 最有意思的就是看老师现场示范，一张嘴就是音准音色音质俱佳的高仿，好牛。

    @kaleege@kaleege7 ай бұрын

    • 人家专业的音乐老师

      @user-ld7nk9ru6g@user-ld7nk9ru6g7 күн бұрын

  • This song “Tibetan Plateau”interestingly here we got several singers with different ethnicity folk music styles backgrounds. 1st singer Gong Linna (Chinese says the last name first) is a great singer with a strong old centuries Chinese Opera background, which she brings in a lots of opera style singing, gestures, down to the way she looks at the camera or every steps she walk, is screaming Chinese opera. Which is very technical and great when she does opera but Linna does that to every single performance. honestly makes 90% of her pop music performances extremely awkward. Tho this time it works quite well in this folks song. 2nd A-Mei aka Kulilay Amit, a Native Taiwanese indigenous people( it’s like Native Indian but Taiwan). She is one of if not the best selling female artist in the Chinese Music industry, she recognized as having the influence and cultural impact in Asia equivalent to artists such as Madonna in Western music and popular culture. There she is at a variety show which they randomly pick a song she has only about 30mins to converted it into a complete different music style which she decided to convert it into more modern rock style mixing in with a old Taiwan indigenous folk song. Honestly I have seen her perform this song better in the normal version but I think it’s refreshing to listen to a modernize version, given she only has such a short period of time to change I think she did a wonderful job. 3rd Han Hong, half Tibetan/ half Chinese, She is most known for this song, so definitely most classic version we got here. Everybody think it’s her song. This performance is actually newer than you would expect, from stage n audience it’s obvious that she performing in front of China government official, so I won’t be surprised if it’s lip-synch, actually it’s a pretty normal thing to do when the government official has zero tolerance on mistakes and time control. 4th is Shila Amzah a Malaysian singer, Malaysia entertainment industry isn’t as big as Chinese entertainment so lots of the best artists also branched into Chinese music industry. She is used to singing western songs so yes her singing technique is obviously most western here. This is also the only version with pronunciation issues. the last singer 阿蘭aka Alan Dawa Dolma is Tibetan singer as she sing in both Tibetan and Chinese languages it’s a traditional Tibetan folk songs influenced song. which Tibetan language n style of singing naturally matches and works with the song the best. Tibetan traditionally communicate with songs, before cell phone exists there simply isn’t any other method of communication between the mountains shepherd. Till now still the most effective way of communication between mountains since no signal issues. Their folks song obviously is designed for communication through distance. People from high elevation need a very strong respiratory system to be able to breathe, exercise, n sing. So it’s live alright it’s super easy for high elevation people born with such strong to be able to do such, and yes she is very contained and in control because here it’s indoor singing to a microphone not between mountains.

    @jennifertu4428@jennifertu44288 ай бұрын

    • Very punctual comment I appreciate it.

      @johnbellcon@johnbellcon7 ай бұрын

    • only Gong Linna and Shila Amzah has the best voice, their vocal is very powerful yet very characteristic and memorable in their own special way...others are just meh and boring

      @markzzzzberg1312@markzzzzberg1312Ай бұрын

  • 不得不说，龚琳娜是学院派，技术大拿。阿妹是残酷市场里拼杀出来的歌后，技术已经是top，但是跟学院派还是有区别。而且商演也多，作息不规律，嗓子消耗肯定更大，倒嗓相较巅峰期严重的明显

    @changyoyo2609@changyoyo260919 күн бұрын

  • Amei!

    @Nearn89@Nearn898 ай бұрын

  • 我的最愛張惠妹❤

    @kannkahann5367@kannkahann53678 ай бұрын

    • 其實她唱的最爛

      @user-qf3ml8fq5s@user-qf3ml8fq5s21 күн бұрын

    • 这集中，最尴尬的就是阿妹

      @user-ld7nk9ru6g@user-ld7nk9ru6g7 күн бұрын

    • @@user-ld7nk9ru6g 那是你家的事。

      @kannkahann5367@kannkahann53677 күн бұрын

    • ​@@kannkahann5367😂😂👍

      @Mimi-tn6gq@Mimi-tn6gq3 күн бұрын

  • it will be so interesting to let Rozette see Shila do Beyonce's Listen

    @JoeChanTV@JoeChanTV8 ай бұрын

    • Yeah Shila got great vocals

      @rockerteers2@rockerteers28 ай бұрын

    • More like xiang ni de ye or her time in asian wave.

      @akane8615@akane86158 ай бұрын

  • 不错不错great

    @user-gl7vz8gi6s@user-gl7vz8gi6s8 ай бұрын

  • 刚才还在想老师做一起阿妹的曲子，结果就看到这期。😂😂推荐老师点评下阿妹的 哭砂。

    @danCC12345@danCC123458 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹真強，演唱會那麼多且高強度唱了快三十年，還是保持高水準。 張惠妹20幾年前的現場，演唱惠姨的I Will Always Love You kzhead.info/sun/jMOThKqMiINmloE/bejne.html 很多實力派女歌手應該都有挑戰過，也適合一集對比。

    @vincewu2643@vincewu26438 ай бұрын

    • 如果是別人來評的話就另當別論，可是如果是這位老師來評的話，因為她本身是歌唱老師，再加上是外國人，因此會比較focus在歌唱技巧的展現，但阿妹雖然有唱功在，而且有很好的感染力，但畢竟不是那種塞滿各種歌唱技巧的唱法，在以歌唱技巧為主的點評觀點下且與一些科班出身的人一起比的話她可能對阿妹的表演比較沒感覺。

      @guesswhat2446@guesswhat24466 ай бұрын

  • 这位老师真的非常专业。对这几位歌手最核心的技术特征、风格特征的点评，全都是一语中的，非常非常准确。由于西方流行音乐已经渗透进全世界的文化，现代中国人的音乐审美，也存在传统与现代的巨大鸿沟。但我第一次听到一个外国人能够如此准确地捕捉到这种差异，而且她能清楚地感知到我们的传统演唱风格里那些最精华的韵味，虽然那些并不是她最喜欢的。不过，别说她一个老外，就连我们中国人自己的耳朵其实都在慢慢远离这些审美。

    @georgelin9028@georgelin90288 ай бұрын

    • 確實專業! 理解完還能馬上示範... 真的很猛!

      @1eea959@1eea9598 ай бұрын

    • 這位老師能唱聲樂，又是音樂老師，很厲害

      @user-qf3ml8fq5s@user-qf3ml8fq5s21 күн бұрын

  • 老师一直对唢呐有兴趣😂

    @user-ye1or2tx7t@user-ye1or2tx7t5 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹的唱法是將台灣原住民的調加在這首歌內

    @ananfan6051@ananfan60517 ай бұрын

  • 歌手在准备飚高音时都有较明显停顿和集气的表现， 但茜拉整首歌唱下来很稳，完整衔接而且有爆发力 当老师对茜拉做出高评价并说是她的最爱时，旁边男的就开声了（老师赞美前面歌手时他都没开声）几乎企图改变老师的决定…… 不知道其他人发现没 要比就不要怕输， 庆幸老师坚持自己的专业和评价

    @steveng9691@steveng96917 ай бұрын

    • 確實要比就不要怕輸，閣下仔細聽，茜拉在22：11已走音！

      @1105drum@1105drum2 ай бұрын

  • 起风了comparison ❤

    @carinechua8316@carinechua83168 ай бұрын

    • 需要更多人点赞👍！！

      @angieplayz4380@angieplayz43808 ай бұрын

    • 有老师喜欢的JJ n 深深

      @carinechua8316@carinechua83168 ай бұрын

    • 是啊，几时轮到吴青峰啊！

      @xddd0909@xddd09098 ай бұрын

  • 我本人來說喜歡韓紅的演繹最有感 像帶我看到高山大草原的意境😊

    @crazypig4212@crazypig4212Ай бұрын

    • Same here. 她的声音有空灵感，另外几位歌手没有。

      @lynnj7693@lynnj769315 сағат бұрын

  • 这位老师也是神人。随口就来。

    @tuesdae666@tuesdae6668 ай бұрын

    • 关键多数都在胡说八道，韩红我现场听过至少五次，现场的效果真的比视频震撼十倍，她张嘴就说韩红是假唱，这样的我是无法想象的。把加拿大的音乐高度等同于全世界的高度，把自己几十吨的小破船当做全球第一巨舰，还自以为自己的专业性无可挑剔，今天是21世纪了，不是19世纪了

      @alading3561@alading35618 ай бұрын

  • 老师的点评棒极了！🎉

    @cozylifeinmunich6403@cozylifeinmunich64038 ай бұрын

  • They face mountain and waters and grassland, vast space!

    @yingzhang7637@yingzhang76377 ай бұрын

  • 阿妹，是台灣歌后，No.1

    @wensonhsu7519@wensonhsu75197 ай бұрын

  • 從昨天連續看了n個影片到今天，老師對阿妹猜測，，，大落馬。😂

    @qqchen3070@qqchen30706 ай бұрын

  • Ms Rozette, would you mind react to Ivy Lee李艾薇 singing performance too? She's a very, very talents & experiences Singer from Malaysia who won the champion title in [Jungle Voice Season 2] in Taiwan few years ago so I think you might find her interesting to hear out her voice in those stage performances too, thanks!!🎤👍👍🙏🙏🙏

    @Migryl@Migryl7 ай бұрын

  • 明明老師個人最讚賞的是馬來西亞歌手西拉，從評價上看她最不感驚艷的是張惠妹，留言板裡面卻一大推阿妹第一，台灣人的心態真的輸不起...

    @callas60@callas604 күн бұрын

  • 茜拉真的很强！我觉得她的版本是没什么修音过的！🤣 可是真的唱得很好 真的很喜欢她的版本 身为马来西亚人真的很骄傲😍🥰🥰

    @jaysb87@jaysb878 ай бұрын

    • 茜拉真的很强 可惜普通话还有这个曲风不是她最擅长的 如果能让老师听一下她的拿手歌就好了

      @Mika-vc8xx@Mika-vc8xx8 ай бұрын

    • 真的很好听

      @ahfoong2502@ahfoong25028 ай бұрын

    • 兼顾了 老派的硬唱法跟跟现代流行的唱法

      @2633309@26333098 ай бұрын

    • 22：11走音了

      @1105drum@1105drum2 ай бұрын

    • 感覺她是用聲樂基底下去唱的😂

      @user-qf3ml8fq5s@user-qf3ml8fq5s21 күн бұрын

  • Beyond

    @xindai9949@xindai99498 ай бұрын

  • I like singer 4. I could be biased as I’m Malaysian, too (same as the singer).

    @serenepoh5606@serenepoh560623 күн бұрын

  • 很高兴老师喜欢sheila的演绎❤

    @yiningtan2218@yiningtan22183 күн бұрын

  • 老師說的約德，其實是藏族在唱山歌的曲調，許多藏族人唱歌都是這樣唱，比較類似山歌

    @mikelucky77@mikelucky7727 күн бұрын

  • interesting comments indeed!

    @KaiSun-tq7nl@KaiSun-tq7nl5 күн бұрын

  • 希望可以聽到阿妹的一整期❤

    @harry_AJ@harry_AJ8 ай бұрын

  • 老师实在是太可爱了 还性感

    @youcan1212@youcan12123 күн бұрын

  • 我覺得老師隨口的示範與跟唱贏了👍我們以為這首歌對女歌手困難的高潮處，老師很輕鬆的唱出來了......難怪她常常疑惑為甚麼有些歌手高音要用假音，不用力衝上去，因為老師都做得到😆

    @jason3tai@jason3tai8 ай бұрын

    • 是的，她惊讶老龚的处理是因为她相信以老龚的实力可以冲上去 >_

      @dwmobusa@dwmobusa8 ай бұрын

    • 但可惜老師比較不熟民樂山歌的系統和發聲方式，用那麼多類似yodel的技法就是要不斷運用轉腔體發音。要求壓縮、尖、亮，穿透性強的聲線，才能真正在山嶺間互唱應和。龔和韓算是這幾位中最保有傳統唱法的大師，要直接強混某幾個音衝上去不是不行，只是相對就更現代流行的唱法，他們的考慮點不一樣。

      @mercurylee8004@mercurylee80048 ай бұрын

    • @@mercurylee8004 不会啊，你去听听李娜和索朗旺姆的版本，都是传统唱法，都冲上去了，感觉老龚这里可能确实打安全牌了，她有这个实力的

      @dwmobusa@dwmobusa8 ай бұрын

    • @@dwmobusa 我是覺得老龔在唱這首歌的時候, 狀態不是很好。只是大神降級還是個小仙, 在凡間壓場子是絕對沒問題的。

      @cwhkg@cwhkg8 ай бұрын

    • @@cwhkg 也可能因为状态不好所以这一场打安全牌了，不冲突啊，说不定换一次唱就能冲上去呢

      @dwmobusa@dwmobusa8 ай бұрын

  • 个人最喜欢阿兰的版本

    @xingw9358@xingw93588 ай бұрын

  • 有个推荐，把黄绮珊最早在重庆一个晚会的《只有你》搬出来，每次听这首歌都让我感到无比震撼！

    @Lidao666@Lidao6668 ай бұрын
KZhead