Garmonbozia, the Black and White Lodges, Mike, Bob and the Little Man, Judy, Audrey and Charlie, Season 3's ending... The mystery of Twin Peaks has survived for nearly 30 years... until now. You may have heard some of the ideas in this video before, but never with this amount of depth and supporting evidence. Are you ready to fully KNOW what Twin Peaks was really about? "Watch, and see what Rosseter teaches."
Brazilian Portuguese subtitles by Jonatan Paiva
¬ Support TP! - / twinperfect
¬ Discord - / discord
¬ Twitter - / twin_perfect
¬ Facebook - / twinperfect
Imagine Lynch watching this whole thing all the way through and just saying “no” lol
Lynch would probably rather say "Bullshit!!!" XD
@@shemthecatambassador6576 I think he would've said a little more than that!
@@Gizaalkemy Maybe, but you might know the clips of David, where he is responding to all sorts of theories or claims just with "bullshit". Guess he has a knack for this response :)
Lynch would probably be like...what explanation?
@@djdndi I think that too. He apparently has, but he'd NEVER give it away for sure. It would basically kill him in so many ways.
You’ll probably never read this, but here goes... When I was 17, I had just enrolled at NYU. It was the summer of 1991 and I was walking down 6th Avenue in Greenwich Village, feeling in awe of being in New York City. A little man walked past me and I did a double-take and turn around to catch up with him. “You’re Michael Anderson!” “Have we met?” “No, I’m just a big fan of Twin Peaks!” “You must me a big fan to know MY name. Who played Laura Palmer?” “Sheryl Lee, of course.” “Nobody knows that!” “Can I buy you lunch?” “Sure!” So 17-year old me sat at a table with the Little Man from Another Place and ate BBQ ribs and talked for an hour. He was FASCINATING. Did you know he was the dialog coach for all the dream sequences? He had the ability to just say things in reverse. So he would figure out all the other actors’ lines backwards and then teach them how to pronounce it and they’d shoot the scenes and run the sound backwards. He told me that day that the reason the giant ever even appeared in the show was because he had a scheduling conflict when shooting the scene where Cooper gets shot. He was supposed to be who Cooper saw, but he couldn’t be there. “So they had to get a giant to fill my shoes,” he said with a grin. I also asked him if the finale cliffhanger was Lynch’s way of saying fuck you to ABC, and he replied “oh yeah! David was furious at the network by that point. He wanted to give them an end that didn’t end anything.” Michael was kind and open and incredibly smart. Meeting him that day is one of my most cherished memories.
That's an incredible story!
That’s so awesome! I watched Carnivale because him, Clancy Brown, and Clea DuVall were in it.
HC Iapetus I loved Carnivale! Was so bummed when it ended. Also featured Nick Stahl.
Nathan Freeman - it was definitely one of the best series I’d ever seen. I was bummed when it didn’t come back, but I oddly don’t feel empty about it (if that makes sense). I actually didn’t recognize Nick Stahl at first when I started watching the series. Then it dawned on me that it was the dude from T3 and Disturbing Behavior. Lol. Oh! Have you seen the statements the creator of Carnivale said about what he had planned with the other seasons and how it was going to end?
Damn I wonder what made him hate David and say anti Semitic things on Facebook
Fire Walk With Me is one of the best and most haunting movies I've ever seen. It's insane to me that people back then hated it. Being able to see Laura's other side provided context, Laura had always been the center point of Twin Peaks why would anyone want to move on from the central point of the show?
I love the film too. It is essential viewing for any TP fan. The negative reaction was due to its lack of humor/comic relief that worked so well on the TV show.
I loved that film. And that set me up to expect so much from the new series. But the new series wasn't very good.
@@fraundakelmbrilpondaprost90It was meandering and proof that the TV execs during the original run did the right thing in beating a conclusion out of Lynch
@@omegamanGXE I assume you didn't watch any of the video you're commenting on? 😂
@@omegamanGXE The "meandering" was an essential part of the entire point of Twin Peaks though. Did you watch the video?
It's a travesty that Fire Walk With Me was booed and had mostly negative criticisms. To this day one of the most anxiety and dread inducing movies I've seen and Sheryl Lee was absolutely phenomenal. People were expecting the next episode of Twin Peaks and were mad that it's not what they got. I wish all the people in Cannes would be forced to watch a 5 hour prequel to Fire Walk With Me.
The shot of Laura staring into the fan was incredibly well done. It's way more haunting if you buy into Ross's interpretation of what it means. Laura, the conduit of good, staring up into the zeitgeist and being driven insane the longer she stares.
@@12ealDealOfficial It's an amazing scene but sadly it's from the Missing Pieces. I definitely feel FWWM is inseparable from the Missing Pieces. A lot of the hate for the movie when it came out can be explained by the fact people were missing out on some of the best, most important scenes of the show that were cut out in the admittedly over-brazen and truncated theatrical cut. Take the scene above the Convenience Store, in the full version (Blue Rose cut) it is one of David's best, in the movie it oddly phases in and out of legibility.
"Television is just chewing gum for the eyes." -- Frank Lloyd Wright "That gum you like is going to come back in style." -- David Lynch
Lynch lives in a Frank Lloyd Wright Jr. house.
Holy **** ! And, Invitation to Love was filmed in the FLW Ennis House! See 58:24 where you can clearly see the blockwork
@@MrTee3three HOLY SHIT DUDE
Nice. There's also that line Lynch mentions when directing Laura Dern, "More bubble gum."
My. Mind. Blown.
"What's your party trick?" "Me? I can explain twin peaks lore in under 5 hours."
Barely though.
no you can't mr simpson, no one can
Impossible. Can't be done.
you are gonna get a lot of bitches with that trick
Lol
Dude is really pushing the 10 minute mark with this one
What year is this?
2010@@iknowme
@@iknowmeAHHHHHHHHHHHHHGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
Even if David Lynch would personally say this is all nonsense (and he never would say anything anyway), this is an incredible breakdown with meticulous work. There are some leaps at times but it still fits together very well. Kudos to the dedication to put all this together. It really helps putting everything into a context that seems to make perfect sense.
This is reductive bullshit.
Whoever made this video is so f****** retarded they actually think they're at least a midwit but they're not even that 🤷♂️ I actually SOMEWHAT agree with many of this Jerry's conclusions... I just wish he wouldn't have to say completely retarded s*** on the way to get there... like why does he have to insist THIS is the conclusion Lynch wants us to come away with... and is the "correct" interpretation!?!? ☝️ This video would be 75% less retarded if he didn't say that. Instead he made this retardedness 75% of the video. I don't use the retard word lightly. I was born ¼ retarded and gay on the side so I understand the deep pain that word causes. But facts are facts. Despite the rumors Rosseter isn't an arrogant twat -- he's just literally more retarded than my dog so give him a break for thinking he's galaxy brained okay he can't help himself 😭
You want to know who killed Laura? You did! We all did! -Bobby Briggs.
AMEN!
@J Dee Carter based!?!?!?
@J Dee Carter wtf with the hashtag? Deadass
@@carybeweary7209 he's not wrong.
@@stevendunn5597 uh yeah he is! Ffs!🤦♂️ So many fools to send to the shadow Realm my work is never done
Wow, so the real Twin Peaks truly was the friends we made along the way.
Hahahahahaa
Well yeah, kind of, actually, hahaha
Just like Lost.
I actually have it to thank for my marriage, but still - v funny! :)
The real twin peaks was in our hearts this whole time
There was one missing page from Laura's diary. The person played by Sheryl Lee in the last episode is Carrie Page. The last missing page? If yes, then perhaps that whole ending sequence is a documented dream of Laura who was dreaming she was a different person (Carrie), and even Carrie Page's life in a bad place to is better to her than her own. Dale and Laura share this dream (there is precedent for that), and Coop is dreaming of saving Carrie. But then Carrie remembers Sarah's voice, and her house in Twin Peaks, and wakes up screaming? And it's not the ending but a vignette that takes place in the past?
Dude, this is essentially a video dissertation. The amount of research and effort put into this is worthy of a PhD…and I’m just barely kidding. Kudos.
A Doctoral thesis wouldn't be anywhere as smug and reductive as this horseshit.
Man, I was so nervous to spoil the deep and wonderful meaning this show has always has for me but watching this elaborate and beautifully crafted analysis (which I fully intend on watching multiple times) has made me love it infinitely more. Thank you for the obviously very dedicated effort and enjoyment in doing this. 🥹👏👏
20:23 CATCHING THE BIG FISH 40:51 THE KEY THAT OPENS THE BOX 1:10:31: FIRE IS COMING 1:31:57 GOTTA LIGHT? 1:55:36 THE ONE ARMED MAN 1:58:57 A CIRCLE OF PAIN 2:12:59 GARMONBOZIA 2:21:36 THE MAGICIAN LONGS TO SEE 2:29:46 THE MIND IS A DETECTIVE 2:41:31 PLOT DEVICES 2:51:34 YOU CAN’T GO HOME AGAIN 2:54:12 FEELING THE AIR 3:05:49 THE WHITE HORSE 3:13:49 IDENTITY CRISIS 3:19:03 COINCIDENCE AND FATE 3:25:01 THE ROADHOUSE 3:30:28 RUNNING OUT OF SAND (audrey horne!) 3:41:44 IT IS IN OUR HOUSE NOW 3:49:12 THIS THING OF TWO COOPERS 3:51:01 WHO IS JUDY? 4:16:24 “DIANE…?” 4:25:06 WHAT YEAR IS THIS?
hero.
You the real tp
Mayor Tacoghost thank you! This is going to take multiple viewings
Thanks
Hero!! Thank you!
A buddy and I watched this yesterday. Both of us are huge fans of Lynch, and Twin Peaks. One thing we talked about more than anything was how much work it must have taken to put this whole video together. This is some collegiate doctoral thesis level scholarship. Like how...how did you pull this off? We were talking afterward about the logistics involved in putting this much content together. The amount of watching, re-watching, and note taking that had to have occurred...and then to sit down and present the information in what felt like a completely off the cuff fluid narration even though it must have surely been tightly scripted...I can't underscore how impressive this is enough. Thank you so much for taking the time to put something together like this.
On Reddit he says it took 2 years to make this video "I have been working on this video for two years, writing and researching and editing. I've been reading and watching and listening to every creator interview and AMA, every DVD extra and featurette, every TV special, every fan theory, blog, and podcast - any and all Twin Peaks-related posts I could find - trying to hone and polish my script to be the best I thought it could possibly be. I focus-grouped my video with people, challenging them to poke as many holes in my arguments as they could so that I could better illustrate my ideas. I tried my best to create something others would find of value, something that would add to the ongoing mystery and spark new discussions about my favorite series."
@@matthewholloway4141 2 years? Yeah, with additional 25 years to process some crucial info from S1, S2 & FWWM.
Lynch helped him, this IS Season Four, the Ultimate Closure, the Ultimate Evil, THE END.
I feel like all of these Twin Perfect videos deserves a LOT of credit! I have watched The Real Silent Hill Experince like 20 times. Both because im a HUGE SH-fanboy, but allso just because they are so well made, and its obvious that you put so much work and passion into it...Right now im watching this review of Twin Peaks...A series i havent even seen! Thats credit right there!
@@PenskyMaterial Damn thanks for mentioning this, I had no idea. I had a blast reading an essay on gamefaqs in 1999 that detailed and contextualized a lot of the intent, looking forward to what this video has to say.
16:16 It was booed at Cannes. it was canned in the press. It was depressing for people looking for answers after the show's ending. And the response ended David Lynch's dream of Twin Peaks. Nice one!
wow
BARS
3:54:00 As a Mandarin speaker, I can tell you that the one and only definition of that word is to "explain". You sir, are spot on.
“Will you elaborate on that?” “No I wont.”. Pure gold.
Lynch is the Bill Belichick of Hollywood. Stonewalling reporters and offering only vague answers to detailed questions. Focuses more on the product he creates and avoids giving too much commentary...
@@RustCole01: _Therefore the Master concerns himself_ _with the depths and not the surface,_ _with the fruit and not the flower._ _He has no will of his own._ _He dwells in reality,_ _and lets all illusions go._
Twin Perfect: And that's why Laura Palmer is literally a horse from outer space. Me: I agree in general, but I think that's going a bit too far. Clip of David Lynch speaking to audience: And Laura... Laura is literally a horse from outer space.
lmao we're not horse enough yet to totally get it
Whiteness of an eyeball as a symbol of evil (the black lodge) is a weak representation. Lynch'd rather agree that Laura is an alien from an outer space, than an eyeball. A horse from an outer space is a pure dream metaphor. It is a cloud. So, Laura is a dreamer, she's romantic person, even being possessed by the cruelty of this world. And also TV is not all what Lynch wanted to say. A confrontation between Rockers and Hipsters (the last minutes of the pilot, when Bobby+Mike is fighting friends of James) is a manifestation of what's going on in TP: dreamers vs richs.
Lol that's how it feels huh
Idk where to even begin. This has always been one of my favorite shows, and getting such an in depth explanation not only into the story but the greater context in which it was built around has cemented this show as not only my favorite of all time, but has left a profound philosophical impact on how I view life. Especially when it comes to mystery. Closure brings permanence in a way, and sometimes not knowing all the why’s is for the best
3:53:24 Naido isn't just a weird way of saying Diane backwards. She's played by a japanese actress, and you can break it down to the Japanese words Nai and Doh which mean Inner and Road, or Path. She exists in the unconscious in episode three, and is able to enter twin peaks because Twin Peaks is inside the dream, which she reveals to Cooper later on.
It almost sounds like David Lynch is saying "NATO." And now my brain is trying to find a connection there.
@@CaveyMoth"She's my mother's sister's girl! *puts hand on face*" -Gordon Cole, 1992
@@caringheart34 "What the hell?" -Gordon Cole
@@CaveyMoth Yes. Exactly. Look up the term "apophenia." The more I watch of this video and the more I see people pattern-matching here in the comments, the more I'm convinced that's really all that's going on here. This is Bible Code stuff, hun.
Just waiting for Lynch to watch all of this, wait a few seconds, lean forward, smiling, simply saying "No. :) "
ALL :-)
Problem: this theory is correct.
Next like is "119" youre welcome, whoever you are
Lol
Zuben4 i dont think so but if it is, im very disappointef in the meaning behind it all
To summarize, Twin Peaks is a TV show.
No, watch again.
oh god oh fuck
Cahiers would disagree
Yes, it's a TV show that "knows" it's a TV show. It's a meta creation, that has a conversation with itself and the public. Quite amazing.
Twin Peaks is the remake of the movie Waxwork from 1988, just watch it and see. It has the character Bobby Brigs, who is the exact same in Twin Peaks. The main character , the young detective type craving for coffee. You got the girls, the football players, the mistery in the middle of a small town street. You even got the dwarf and the giant , the giant is a waiter, too, you got the waiting room with the couches... Even the basic ideas about fire are in Waxwork.... Even one eyed jack is in Waxwork, its the torture scene with the girls.
Very, very well put together video. Something to add to this that I don't think was mentioned is the Saturn lamp that's on the table next to Agent Cooper in the red room. This lamp came from the 1939 New York World's Fair and it's when the television was introduced to the mass public.
WOW, BOB, WOW. This adds another layer still.
Thank you very much! Very good observation!
Nice eye. Some might say you have two. Another detail I’ve wondered about; the selection of Odessa location for the last episode and the 8-foot Jackrabbit in that town. Just wondered if there’s any connection. 🧐
Ironically, today's era is a PERECT environment for a meta dark soap opera show like Twin Peaks. Viewers have had enough of the cheap cotton candy content from studios that wre written by straw polls and are hungry for something thought provoking that likes to break the fourth wall. Twin Peaks was written for an era that was thirty years in the making
You're not wrong, however I think you misunderstand the necessity of Twin Peaks. Twin Peaks MADE this media landscape possible.
Work in Progress: 06:53 History of the show 20:31 Catching the Big Fish 27:33 Wizard of Oz/ Blue Velvet 33:45 darkness and light 35:29 Balanced TV 39:47 Heidi late to work 40:55 the key that opens the box 41:25 Gordon Cole/ David Lynch 43:17 Chet Desmond and Sam Stanley 46:47 Bob 49:31 Ronette in the train car 51:09 Laura’s murder 53:41 The Magical Light 56:00 the meeting above the convenient store 58:06 Invitation to love 1:02:11 In Dreams 1:03:26 The Monica Bellucci Dream 1:04:56 Characters know they’re dreaming 1:07:38 the men behind the curtain 1:09:37 Cooper’s Dream 1:10:33 fire is coming 1:14:46 wind/ airwaves kicking up the fire 1:17:58 Zeitgeist 1:19:12 bob/ leland palmer 1:20:50 sarah palmer/ whens there smoke theres fire 1:21:43 Woodsmen/ The Electrician 1:25:07 consumable violence is wearing our tv shows as a mask/ 1956 1:32:03 gotta light? 1:34:46 The Giant/ The Fireman 1:35:56 Non-existence 1:42:15 Oil 1:47:30 Film is balanced 1:50:21 The Arm/ Fire Alarm 1:51:59 God of Light/ God of Darkness 1:55:15 Mike The One Armed Man 1:59:02 A Circle of Pain 2:03:25 The Owl Ring 2:06:49 Owl Symbol 2:10:02 Formica Table 2:11:53 Dirt 2:13:02 Garmonbozia 2:21:38 The Magician Longs to See/ Fire Walk With Me Poem 2:25:42 Masks/ Jumping Man 2:29:49 The Mind is a Detective/ Cooper's intuition 02:34:52 "Don't take the ring Laura" 02:35:50 Cooper in the Monica Bellucci Dream 02:36:48 First scene in Season 3/ Richard and Linda/ two birds with one stone/ 430/ 02:40:44 Major Briggs is Mark Frost 02:41:35 Plot Devices/ Teresa Banks/ 02:43:43 Chet Desmond’s disappearance 02:46:17 Phillip Jeffries 02:51:39 You Can't Go Home Again 02:53:10 Why a Season 3? 02:54:35 Jacoby in the Return 02:59:09 Nadine in the Return 03:00:08 Ed/ Norma 03:05:50 The White Horse/ Doppelgängers 03:12:10 Theme I'm not myself 03:15:38 jerry horne 03:16:57 Dale Cooper waking up 03:19:05 luck 03:23:55 todays tv. A world of truck drivers 03:25:04 the roadhouse 03:26:21 marlon brando the wild one 03:30:29 Cooper’s hotel room key/ Lucy and cellphones/ Doc Hayward Skype call/ Jack Rabbit’s Palace 3:31:53 audrey 03:38:59 ghostwood 03:42:06 corruption of the youth 03:42:33 shelly 03:42:47 richard horne 03:43:11 todays tv audiences/ modern garmonbozia 03:43:42 we’re sarah palmer 03:44:29 side stories/ rotten eggs 03:49:18 multiple coopers 03:51:03 judy/ two birds with one stone 03:59:08 glass box 04:12:53 face overlay/ closure 04:16:25 Diane 04:22:04 crematory/ mausoleum 04:25:14 what year is this?
Thanks for this!
Thanks, that is one well job.
The clock functionality is the best thing developers implemented into KZhead active buttons. Thanks man for sharing the timing in here. 🙏
Thanks for doing this this is such a big help! God Bless You!
Bookmark for later
Rest of youtube: No one's gonna watch my video, it's 20 mins long Twin Perfect: Hold my damn fine cup of coffee...
Grape soda
I'll watch it several times lol.
And it could be the best thing Twin Perfect has ever produced. I couldn't stop watching it until it was over.
Long form content is best content. Especially with timestamp aspies in the comments.
A tulpa is an imaginary friend which is made a real person by magic.
I like the bit where you said people focus on the details too much because it makes the rest of the video very funny.
OMFG exactly
Obviously he meant stuff like background production design
My favorite parts: 3:05:50 The White Horse 3:13:50 Identity Crisis 3:30:30 Running Out of Sand I really appreciate the elaboration regarding Audrey’s story in The Return. When I first watched The Return, her scenes only left me scratching my head, but the meaning you’ve presented makes it incredibly sad and haunting.
Yeah. I would add that she was by far the prettiest one back in the 90s, so her ruin in appereance - which will eventually hit us all - have an extra bitterness
The owl shaped power pylons: "Open Wire Lines. Sometimes called O.W.L"
thank you!
[Head explodes]
or.... Oscillating Wave Lengths?
YES
Oh wow!, how intriguing an anagramatic analogy 🤔👍
It’s too bad that so many people hated Fire Walk With Me. I actually liked it a lot, and rather than just rehashing Laura’s murder, I think it added a necessary level of understanding to Twin Peaks as a whole. You begin to understand Laura better as a person and you realize just how important she actually was.
Back in the day I used to tell people the best way to understand the most about TP was to go to Blockbuster and rent FWWM and the "2 hour series premier". Haven't seen this made for TV movie anywhere even talked about but gave awesome info about the TP world. Should have stolen the VHS tape at the time.
I think FWWM is fine. I’ll probably show it to my friend who I know will never sit down to watch the show.
In fact, after the... bad... parts of season 2, it was the movie that got me excited again for season 3.
Michelle, may I just change the tense in your final sentence please: Laura is important. Take care.
I think it's one of the best movies I've ever seen and I'll never watch it again because it's also one of the most depressing movies I've ever seen
Major but understandable mistake in this analysis. According to Frost. Lynch didn’t own a tv or watch many, if any, movies around and during the production of the first two seasons. Additionally, he doesn’t do speaking tours about violence as entertainment and its consequences. He tours on metaphysics. This whole thing feels like a MAAAAASSIVE reach
Ok lets just take your point and ask, "How incredible is it that a man who allegedly didn't own a tv or watch many movies at the time made one of the most defining TV shows of all time? And many movies which are the greatest of all time?" Mulholland Drive was voted the best movie of the 21st Century because they took like 200 critics top 100s and Mulholland Drive was in so many of their Top 10's it had the highest aggregate score. I don't think Mullholland Drive is my favourite movie, or the best movie, but is it easy to see why people who love CINEMA, love Mullholland Drive? Easily. David Lynch is your favourite Director's favourite Director. And this is why; he is the GOAT. And if the GOAT didn't intend all this, and you can still find it there, that's a huge coincidence and some transcendental shit handed to him by the Jungian collective unconscious.
...And? Lynch doesn't need to own a tv or watch a lot of movies while directing Twin Peaks to have opinions about television and movies. And yes, Lynch is touring around speaking of metaphysics... and during these tours he sometimes speaks about violence as entertainment. So...?
David Lynch didn't even know what this show was about until he saw this video.
Hahah
Honestly, given how he works from intuition (as opposed to rationality), that could be true
@@alphablitz1024 @TacoSteven Following what Lynch once said, im sure it was exclusively Inland Empire modus operandi. Other works are rather well thought out constructs:)
Naw, the narrator is actually a tulpa of lynch....
@@dragonchr15 That sounds about right
I can't get over the fact that every time he reads a quote from Lynch, he's doing his best impression of Gordon Cole. 😂
The chidori 😂
That's actually how Lynch talks lol
YMS
I listened to a Twin Peaks rewatch podcast where the host did the same thing. It’s like you can’t not do it when quoting Lynch.
It’s a really terrible impression that makes me reluctant to show this to other people
I’m watching this for the fifth time in three years, so I am confident saying that answers don’t have to give closure. They can also open us up to more questions that keep us engaged with the mystery.
So true.
If the explanation in this video is the true one, then I think David Lynch should've just done the show he actually wanted to do instead of 18 hours of him rubbing our nose in the carpet.
This video hasn't gotten closer to the answer, because nobody knows positively if the author supposed any answers at all. This is just PR. That's about it. Many caught this fish, that's an explanation of the views number.
@@ItsMcDude Exactly!
@@ItsMcDude It isn't. Lynch and Frost did the show because they wanted to, not because "we" forced it into existence. This is horseshit that is superficially coherent. The conclusion is selected at the beginnning and the "evidence" is retroactively interpreted in its light.
This video was my occasional dinner companion for a month or two, and I finally finished it today. Amazing job, well done, and thank you!
I watch it when i try to sleep, its been for 3 weeks, hopefully, i finish it tonight haha
remember back when youtube wouldn't allow uploads to be longer than 10 minutes
Yeah I miss when people had to be able to articulate an idea in a sensible amount of time.
I do. I also remember when I was randomly selected (on the youtube channel I used at the time, not this one) to be able to upload videos longer than 15 minutes.
Oh yeah ! Nice reminder
Now people can upload 10 hour 1440 videos of just looping sound effects. Can't imagine all the space that will be used in another 10 years.
@@ouackstrax7356 Most likely unsustainable ! And I am not considering the possible artistic qualities of what might be uploaded. This an ecological concern as much as an economical one.
Watching The Return made me feel like I was being punished by David Lynch for a crime that I never committed on the account that I wasn't even alive when Seasons 1, 2, & FWWM happened.
HAHAHAHAHA
I had a somewhat similar experience. I knew the 3rd season was anti-tv. The pace is slow, oh so slow, but that in itself was hilarious in light of the paradox forced onto the viewer.
@@wlewallen I don’t watch tv and I loved it
I know exactly what you mean. I was a literal baby when this show came out on TV. As I grew I was very aware of it, because I fell in love with the Silent Hill series and I knew it took much inspiration from Twin Peaks. I finally watched the show this month, and I can see how season 3 could feel like that. Now that I’ve finished all 3 seasons, and the movie, and the Missing Pieces feature from the movie, I feel a sense of loss. There are always the books I guess. Plus I might actually just start the show again from the beginning anyway because I loved it so damn much.
wlewallen seriously I was getting so frustrated at some scenes that were so intentionally uninteresting and nonproductive... sweeping man, Diane and cooper driving, don’t even get me started at the amount of blank starring at each other smh
This video deserved an award, even if you can disagree with some points the whole string of theories combined is very impressive and respectable. Salute and hope you are doing fine.
Came for Twin Peaks explanation, stayed for your David Lynch impression Also I'm imagining the alternate reality where Twin Peaks goes for four seasons of Laura Palmer investigation. ALSO ALSO I loved the Dougie scenes and I thought they were a lot cooler than watching Mr. C kill another guy.
As a viewer, my modern mind cant accept the fact that this video has ended. I'll wait for a return video 25 years later explaining how this video was a meta-commentary on youtube culture and how everyone needs everything to be explained to them without being confused if their interpretation is right or not. Great video though. 10/10
omg this
@@Shofixi wait, is there something left to explain?
TWIN PERFECT THE RETURN MUST BE 10 HOURS LONG AND I'LL SURELY WATCH IT
Love your wit. Hisham Raphick.
In 25 years we will have descended into the world of Idiocracy and won't even understand exposition on content anymore.
David Lynch: "it's cuz you be on that phone"
@Luigi Nastro *FUCKING TELEPHONE
Best comment so far hands down
Never in a b-trillion years
HAHAHAHHAHAHA
”It really isn’t that difficult to understand”. Proceeds to explain that we need to have a working knowledge of nuclear physics and electricity in order to even get started on understanding anything.
36:53 Pitch is used in baseball. There are a spectrum of pitches, fast, wild-moving, and down the middle. Pitch is also used as part of the tuning of a message over UHF/VHF to combine it with sound. More parts of the cypher. Gotta say - great work. Even now.
Pitch is also a word used to describe a speech made to sell an idea or product. And pitch (the substance) is used for sealing cracks -- as compared with oil, say, which can be used to lubricate.
And one must first pitch an idea for a film or tv show…
This is a doctorate. This changed my perspective on art, story telling, philosophy, and history.
This sort of thinking changed how I watch Christopher Nolan films too. One you realize what inception is REALLY about, it helps you take the moral of TDKR and Interstellar and then use those to decode the bulk of the rest for his films... then *head explode* It's a little disappointing after Interstellar on light of TDKR, but seen just in light of Inception, and the first two dark Knight films... it's quite beautiful. Hrs got a running set of ideas that take shape in different ways in different films and it fits a specific philosophy, similar to Lynch, about art, story telling, how we use narrative to give meaning, and through that meaning, hope and maybe even survival or goodness... but sometimes that lie can disease us (memento) make us the monster. It's pretty cool on one level, but the tesseract talk in Interstellar just makes it all so cynical. It's kind of sad.
Ironically, modern day doctorates have far less (if any) substance. This was far better than a doctorate.
I know right!
What sort of thinking?? How can I apply this to other shows/movies?
@@ravissary79 LMAO
Me: I don't have time to watch this video. Corona Virus: Hold my beer.
same
same here
bruh
For real man lol
Sameeee!!! 12 minutes in& I'm hooked💯
Well done. My goodness. ❤ thanks for taking time to do this, what an amazing job.
46:24 I don't want a 4th season of Twin Peaks because I need answers. I want a 4th season of Twin Peaks because I like Twin Peaks.
thats exactly what i feel!
Same.
I want a 4th season of Twin Peaks because I need more questions, LOL
@Ante Herco Was thinking the same thing. "I don't need anything. I want!"
Exactly, and I want more of anything David Lynch will direct as well.
we deserve college credits for watching this, and you deserve a phd for making it
In this case , David Lynch must be a God
@J Dee Carter noice
Louis Wain!!
@J Dee Carter no straight pride allowed on my comment thanks
I thought just the same! This guy deserves a PhD just for this amazing analysis
ATTENTION: If you truly are a super fan, you should check out Blake Edwards' film Experiment in Terror. It is a movie that greatly influenced David Lynch's Style. In the movie, the lead actress lives in the city of Twin Peaks. There are aspects of the film that Lynch clearly borrowed. The movie is definitely not like most of Blake Edwards films, which were comedies, and this film has little resemblance to the Pink Panther, for which Blake Edwards is most renowned. Henry Mancini also does the score, by the way.
me before watching this video: “this guy’s so cocky- there’s no way he knows what’s ACTUALLY going on” me after quarantine finally gave me enough time to watch this: *HE LITERALLY KNOWS WHY THERE WAS A FISH IN THE PERCOLATOR*
Could you mark the time pls .. when he explain about that fish in the percolator
@@NavinKumar-yp2rf 1:43:00
@@NavinKumar-yp2rf 20:23 CATCHING THE BIG FISH
I doubt you--or anyone who watched this video--can clearly explain why there was a fish in the percolator.
Easy. Josie packard put it there to be a bitch. Lol
i want to live in the alternate timeline where the laura palmer case didn't get solved until the last episode
Twin Peaks is the remake of the movie Waxwork from 1988, just watch it and see. It has the character Bobby Brigs, who is the exact same in Twin Peaks. The main character , the young detective type craving for coffee. You got the girls, the football players, the mistery in the middle of a small town street. You even got the dwarf and the giant , the giant is a waiter, too, you got the waiting room with the couches... Even the basic ideas about fire are in Waxwork....
Chan Jackie wait what
@@chanjackie2299 You've replied the same thing word for word at least 3 times under at least 3 different comments edit: make that 7
@@shen1891 apparently he feels the need to voice his opinion everywhere. An opinion which is obviously utterly wrong. Anyone who's seen both shows knows that. So nobody is giving him attention. Because twin peaks is such an iconic show and people know he's wrong. So he feels the need to write that thing on every comment trying to convince everyone. And almost all of his comments have exactly 3 likes.. Hmm.. Very suspicious. Almost as if he liked his own comments from 3 different accounts. I think he just hates David lynch for some reason. Said something about David copying from another movie too.
And judging by his (chan's) interaction on other reply sections calling others kid, idiot, stupid and other stuffs, trying to pick fights for no reason, i have come to the conclusion that this is an angry kid or teenager in one of his "phase". Anyway. Couldn't help but point this out. So other fans reading his comments do not get the wrong idea about twin peaks. If he is not a kid, i have to say I'm very disappointed that adult people like him exists with that kind of shallow observations and cheap mindset.
I remember getting my first job just when Twin Peaks started airing. There was me and two other people in our office watching it and boy did we 'water cooler' chat the next day after it aired. No one else knew what the hell we were talking about. Yep - we were the 'hip kids' for sure - haha
Thank you for a very thoughtful analysis. After seeing Killers of the Flower Moon (spoilers) I've noticed a parallel in terms of portraying readily-consumptive evil as part of the audience's expectations, although the movie is more commentary on sensationalisation of suffering, in particular the Osage murders
“It was booed at Cannes, it was canned in the press, it was depressing for people looking for answers after the show's ending, and the response ended David Lynch's dream of Twin Peaks.” That's some masterful use of language...
Thats just a sentence listing things, and then saying what those things did in the end. If that is luguistics then i dont see why everyone isnt a writer.
@@unsubme2157 it was booed at CANnes. It was CANned in the PRESS. It was dePRESSing for people [...]
That's poetry, biyatch!
Was it booed at Cannes though?
@@GeorgeCarlinsToothbrush i heard it was. quintin tarantino was supposedly there booing along i heard
"It's not a tea kettle, IT'S a coffee machine" - *proceeds to slap forehead, now it all makes sense.*
@ShoLKAN and twelve rainbow trout in the back of the truck.
@ShoLKAN Now we know, that fish is the key to everything.
@@AlbinovSK fish = ideas. click to that and lots of stuff falls into place.
@@timetravellerregisteredtra850 A RED HERRING.........
And there's a donut on the wall...
I've worked it out: Laura was abused and electrocuted in Twin Peaks. She lost her memory and left the town as a drifter. Richard fell asleep in the motel and somehow connected with Laura in his dream. She gave him details of how to find her and remind her of what really happened. Twin Peaks is just a big shared dream they are having. Odessa is the real world. Judy is just the diner Laura works at but it's important for Coop to know about it in order to find her. At the end Coop thinks he failed because Laura's mom is no longer at that house. But it was a lie by the house owner who knows what they really did to Laura. Finally her mom sees Laura out the window and shouts to her. That makes Laura remember the horror of what was done to her. That is why in the black lodge she says "I am not Laura but i know her. I am dead". That is her old personality talking, before the electric shock that removed all her memory. Likely abused with electricity.
Solving the murder wasn't the issue. The problem was that the writers had no idea where to go from there. The supernatural aspect that more or less provides the frame work for the whole mystery never got explored. Instead season two was just filled with random stuff that had no direction or purpose...and the show never got its stride back from there.
A problem, not THE problem
"It was booed at Cannes, it was canned in the press, depressing for people looking for answers after the shows ending, and it ended David Lynch's dream of Twin Peaks." - woah nice subtle wordplay mixed in
I noticed that too. It actually made me pay more attention than I'd planned to to a four and a half hour video essay.
Hello. I don't understand the meaning of "it was canned by the press" (English is not my first languaje) Thank you.
@@CiroAguilar its not really used properly here so thats perfectly understandable. Getting canned means getting fired so getting canned in the press in this context means it was rejected by the press
Nimish Todi just want to say that’s a clear and succinct explanation for the benefit of our ESL friend. Well done! (But not like a steak.)
barrs!
it takes 4 and a half hours to explain twin peaks. yep.
and even then not really - Twin Peaks season three is about season 2?
It takes 3 seconds to explain Twin Peaks, it takes 4 1/2 hrs to extrapolate the explanation in a satiating manner.
@@LiamPorterFilms Its about the evolving landscape of media consumption.
This was the comment I never knew I needed.
Laura's dad killed her. The end. What mystery is left??
50 min in and I'm already very happy to have started this journey. Thank you kindly for sharing your light with us!
I'm a trial lawyer: I'm paid to assemble facts, weave a theme, convince people. This is masterful. I wish I could be this good in court.
Same
Do you know Saul Goodman?
@@damiencrowley5039 LOL, I'm more of a Vincent "Two Utes" Gambini guy.... more grits than garmonbozia! ;)
You should sue this guy. It would be hilarious.
I think we should all be grateful that we finally got to meet Judy.
Mike Schlickman we’re not going to talk about Judy at all we are going to leave her out of this
Finally David Bowie's dialogue in Fire Walk With Me makes a bit more sense than it did beforehand!
@@adamsmart1075 It's still kind of amazing that we got an answer to that mystery - remember those 25 or so years where everyone thought we'd never hear another peep?
20:23 - Catching the big fish 40:51 - The key that opens the box 1:10:31 - Fire is coming 1:31:57 - Gotta light? 1:55:36 - The One-Armed Man 1:58:57 - A circle of pain 2:12:59 - Garmonbozia 2:21:36 - The magician longs to see 2:29:46 - The mind is a detective 2:41:31 - Plot devices 2:51:34 - You can't go home again 2:54:12 - Feeling the air 3:05:49 - The white horse 3:13:49 - Identity crisis 3:19:03 - Coincidence and fate 3:25:01 - The Roadhouse 3:30:28 - Running out of sand (Audrey Horne!) 3:41:44 - It is in our house now 3:49:12 - This thing of two Coopers 3:51:01 - Who is Judy? 4:16:24 - "Diane...?" 4:25:06 - What year is this?
I have this idea floating in my head, that through the whole Season 3 we are literally inside of Lynch's mind, where he explores his Worlds and Characters, memories and thoughts about the society and surreal reactions of his psyche in visions of horror, comedy and absurd situations and revelations. Therefore, when Cooper escapes in reality at the end he is faced with a bit more bleak normal conditions, without the Lynch's filter. Also the fact that Lynch himself is present in the story the way he is makes me really consider that whole idea.
"It was booed at Cannes, it was canned in the press, it was depressing for people looking for answers[...]" Beautiful. Such carefully chosen words. Do not think any of this goes unnoticed :D
I thought that was very clever also.
Being booed at Cannes is a sign of good health
Twin Peaks is the remake of the movie Waxwork from 1988, just watch it and see. It has the character Bobby Brigs, who is the exact same in Twin Peaks. The main character , the young detective type craving for coffee. You got the girls, the football players, the mistery in the middle of a small town street. You even got the dwarf and the giant , the giant is a waiter, too, you got the waiting room with the couches... Even the basic ideas about fire are in Waxwork.... Even one eyed jack is in Waxwork, its the torture scene with the girls.
@@chanjackie2299 why are people liking your comment?? This is not true at all. There isn’t even a Bobby brigs in that movie
?
i hope david lynch personally invites you to dinner
Or for pie and coffee (?)
@@agukasem of course, what did i expect! :D but honestly, watching this video reminds me of david lynch remembering the invitation he got from stanley kubrik attending dinner with mel brooks. despite twin perfect might be david lynchs personification of judy. i am sure dl is very greatful to be understood finally. as i am greatful to understand finally :D
@@agukasem omg it just hit me, that now david lynch HAS TO implement twin perfects video into his concept for season4! what do spoilers do to tv series. even worse than in-show reveals. off show reveals. O.O
Really? Seems like Lynch would consider this guy to be the complete antithesis of his creative process and his 'bring your own interpretation' stance on movie-making.
sounds like a threat
I hope someone awarded this man his PhD!! This was incredibly complex and detailed. Bravo.
It's incredibly lame that Annie wasn't mentioned once in The Return (as far as I know). I assume it's because she wasn't a creation of Lynch so he had no issue discarding the character. From Cooper's perspective, Annie was his second chance for a meaningful relationship and yet he doesn't spare her a second thought. Regardless of her connection to Cooper there's still Norma who could've offered a single line about her sister's whereabouts.
You forget that Frost also wrote the show. Lynch did not create Windom Earl either but gave him a great send off. Some characters stories where just over.
She is definitely mentioned in The Return.
@@superdupermcgee i'm afraid she's not:(
*slowly rises and gives a standing ovation*
Yes this!
bathroom wut?
"It was booed at Cannes, it was canned in the press, it was depressing for people looking for answers after the show's ending, and the response ended David Lynch's dream of Twin Peaks." Masterfully subtle wordplay there.
It was alright.
^^Doesn't understand the awesome wordplay.^^
@Grumpy Sega Tech: I haven't seen the video yet, my reply is solely based on the original comment and your question. Maybe the OP is referring to this line in the series: "We are like the dreamer who dreams and then lives inside the dream. But who is the dreamer?".
Cannes - canned (the) press - depressing ending - ended
@@Pantano63 How about "It got shat on in the Cannes, the papers wiped their asses with it, people were drowning in a swirl of questions after it got dumped, and all that flushed any hope by Lynch to further plumb the waters and keep his precious log afloat"?
Early on in the show I made the association between the Great Horned Owls and the Horne family. I assume this was a deliberate connection made by Lynch/Frost and although we learn a fair amount about the family, it always feels underdeveloped. Could just be me wanting clear cut answers because they remain significant characters throughout the franchise. Maybe everything the Horne family has to offer is on display but demands more from the viewer to see it all.
I may be late to the party... but this quite frankly has to be one of the best things I have ever watched. The time and dedication expended on it is amazing. It highlights just how much of a genius Lynch actually is in crafting his work. The attention to detail and the ingenious metaphors. This explanation is a work of art in itself and the whole thing kind of leaves me feeling a little lost in the world. I will definitely have to re watch Twin Peaks now with new understanding.
Just watched all of twin peaks, so I guess I'm on the same page
Hello from Russia! Shortly after USSR crashed, we've had a short period of time when our TV people weren't shooting any local TV series and they've started to purchase and show foreign ones. And they chose the good ones - Homicide: Life On The Street, Crime Story, and, of course, Twin Peaks. It was shocking for a young boy, who saw only party-approved TV prior to that, to watch something like Twin Peaks. And I'm not the only one: Twin Peaks is kinda a cult here :) And there's one more reason for me to be grateful to the author. I've re-watched Twin Peaks for a couple of times since then, usually once in a decade (just so I could forget most of the scenes), and finding this explanation became somewhat of an unexpected holiday to me, because I wasn't going to watch Twin Peaks for 7 more years at least, and this video allows me to dive back into the story much earlier. Thank you!
Добрый день, после 3:44:28 у меня пропал перевод субтитров с английского на русской, у вас не было такой проблемы?
@@saton0die488 К сожалению, не могу тут помочь -- я субтитры на английском смотрю. Можно попробовать другой браузер, наверное. Субтитры ведь в принципе не должны исчезать, они же автоматом переводятся.
I'm glad that despite ussr government tried to block every foreign channel during sovjet time for its occupied countries, the northern part of Estonia could see Finnish tv channels starting in 80s and got the glimpse of western culture, US movies and series including TP. I know it gave us the feel of freedom in our minds and also because of that we were treated in ussr as partial western state. So without Finland I've would've not seen the crazy and wonderful world of TP in the first place. Thanks Finland!
Yeah! I'm from Russia too. Where I was growing they never had red curtains in movie theaters, an power lines have different design. So I wouldn't understand the whole red room thing properly without this video, not to mention all the american 50's TV shows.
@@emilgens8895 Your welcome 🙏. Hard to imagine how was life in our neighbor country those days. But glad you was able to see Twin Peaks.
Twin Peaks is all about crew member Frank Silva being seen in a reflection during the Pilot, and David Lynch yelling _"Perfect!"_ The end.
What was it before that?
@@johnp515 the answer is simple: it wasn't.
there is a force unseen that coincidentally made it apparent Frank Silva needed to be Bob in the show. The point.
An evil unknown entity
And as far as the project Ghostwood is concerned ("It's like Ghostwood here" says Audrey Horne in season 3), remember that Mark Frost wrote in his book that the project led to the construction of a prison. She is definitely stuck in the past (the prison)
One hour in and I'm intrigued. Maybe not 100% on board, but you're definitely on to something. Pretty impressive and well thought out. Will continue....
Can I add something to this? Lynch probably chose sycamore trees not only because of how they look, but because of the famous Doris Day song "Birds singing in the sycamore trees, DREAM a little dream of me..."
Julia also if you go in for suggestive names sycamore could read like “sick amore.” The show is about some sick loves.
@@ngazin Now that is brilliant :)
I think the sycamore tree came from the native american lore, many native americans called the sycamore the “ghost of the forest” (ghostwood?) Some of them believed evil spirits inhabited sycamore trees and could bring misfortune. (Perhaps The Arm becoming a tree helps support this too?) Theres a few references to native american heritage in the show so thats how i find it plausible.
@@austinjoiner5968 Good points. And of course there's the log lady and the mill closing down.
He mentions the song
So season 3 should actually be called: TWIN PEAKS: THE REVENGE
Twin Peaks: Revenge of the Judy.
Maybe just: Twin Peaks-ish It was sort of like watching the original, but, everyone from the original show is really just a pod person. They were pod people for a reason, though. They were, indeed, intentional.
Oh my god. This is so tragic and brutal. If this is all true it just makes me feel so bad for Lynch. I don't blame the audience for wanting to know, but this has given me a bit of pause to, instead of want to know to just, enjoy the mystery.
That is the whole journey! To enjoy the storytelling and the mystery! Feels like the average crowd misunderstood Lynch in all possible ways
This video kinda sucks
@@farzanamughal5933Like your attention span.
Ever since I discovered this video, I've gone back and watched it four or five times now in its entirety. I normally would not watch something this long multiple times, but this is absolutely fascinating and incredibly well put-together. There are so many Twin Peaks theory videos on KZhead, but most of them seem like a stretch or jumping to conclusions, but I still can't find a flaw in your interpretations. This is it, KZhead, this is the definitive take on Twin Peaks. I can't begin to imagine how many hours went into making this, but I thank you, thank you, thank you. (Loved your Mulholland Drive video as well!) Amazing work.
doing the same thing for a 4th year in a row, its the best video on youtube for me
I still come back to this year's later. Twin Peaks is the most legendary television show ever made imo.
this is the longest video i've ever watched on youtube, and goddamn it's also the best one. thanks judy
So maybe you need to watch longer videos? :P
It's Judy!
m.kzhead.info/sun/a9KBhpalhnV_hXk/bejne.html
Here's one longer that you must watch front to back cradle to grave lol. kzhead.info/sun/Za1qYLRtq3-Cn4E/bejne.html
@@reverendjimjones1043 dick I slept too this last night instead of white noise. I woke up with a doughnut in my hand. Wtf?
Hello to the guy who was watching this video next to me in metro line 5 in Paris earlier today, thank you for bringing me my daily dose of Twin Peaks when i wasn't expecting it!
To quote Homer "Brilliant, I have absolutly no idea what is going on"
😂
About the Judy thing, I HATE when something is made without an answer because they don't want to give an answer. Make somehting WITH an answer, SO its coherent, and THEN DO NOT give the answer, otherwise you're just writing nothing or something entirely abstract, in which, clues are pointless.
He gave us an answer. Several answers actually but u have to watch again and read Freud
If you mean that JJ Abrams / Damon Lindelof "mystery box" style nonsense is crap because it is often empty mystery for the sake of mystery, then I totally agree. Those writers are just like Mr. C, creating red herrings to keep the audience invested and legitimize its own existence. You're right: Create mysteries that make sense but don't reveal them. The audience always knows when the writers have no cards or "hand" to show.
@@david_arialost and the leftovers are masterpieces and I’ll die on that hill. Jj abrhams is a tool but he had little to do with lost, besides the pilot and original idea. Lindelof had a mental breakdown being left to do lost alone bc abrhams couldn’t be bothered after the show got picked up. And it’s a gem. Does it have its issues? Sure, it was prime time tv with one to two seasons too many and the studio wanted it to go for 10-20 seasons. So there was a lot stretched out and unnecessarily added bc of studio interference. But the overall stories like with life things don’t make sense with the info we are given but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t have a reason and a purpose. There are only a few things on lost that weren’t given enough info to resolve. Most people who tote the idea otherwise either didn’t watch the whole show a few times to pickup on everything or more likely hated the ending and therefore use the “so many things weren’t resolved!” complaint. My dad for instance thinks they were dead the whole time 😑 The leftovers is only 3 seasons and shows lindelofs talent when not overrun by studio execs only wanting to make as much money as possible (which is why we have a million seasons of copy and paste shows like law and order, ncis, csi, etc… I’ll take a show with a few unanswers over shows that spoon feed every little detail with scripted exposition). Anyways. Like I said. I’ll die on this hill. lol ❤
This is the kind of explanation I would expect in heaven where one gets to finally be satisfied with the mysteries that felt unsolvable in life. Bloody brilliant work.
Like zodiac
Read Hegel then
@Aaron Teran right answer lol
Just like a lady in the radiator once sang, “In heaven, everything is fine.”
Mathematician Paul Erdos talked about “The Book” as a book in heaven full of the most perfect proofs anyone could conceive of.
I honestly never in a million years thought I would get an explanation for "theres a fish in the percolator". Incredible.
I always thought it was just basically it's Twin Peaks, weird things happen. I always thought there was something so Silent Hillesque about a fish in a percolater.
It blew my mind too. I feel it's a real weight off my mind that I didn't know I needed.
Can you please explain?
@@Dzztzt I phrased that weirdly, my first watch of Twin Peaks was after I played Silent Hill so I meant that the influence of Twin Peaks had on it was glaring to me.
@@ShinyFlakesShinyFlakes a fish in the percolator represents having an idea in your brain, these ideas fuel the show.
I loved Fire Walk With me. It's my favourite horror movie. By a long shot.
I never liked it.
I dont think its a show about a show knowing its a show but not knowing its a show. Nor do i think its a lynchyian idea about violence of modern tv or cinema. I think its as basic as good vs evil having to reunite for balance. The splitting of the atom literally split an atom, the balance became unbalanced, judy was created in the split, laura was created to balance.
It only takes 4+ hours to explain Twin Peaks.
Considering the whole of TP lasts mor or less 30 hours...
It's surprisingly entertaining though... I mean, Im not bored yet
If the person who made this did a better job he could have done it in 1-2.
It takes 4+ to explain Twin Peaks to people who have already watched the show start to finish.
4 hours to prove it
“the idea has merit” Amazing. The only thing missing was you peeling your face off at the end and revealing Lynch behind.
Oh wow yes, that would be the perfect closure OH WAIT
That would have been amazing.
That is an image I can't unsee
He already has the voice, not too far from actually being Lynch lol
K8
This certainly makes me appreciate the Return more. I was initially quite disappointed with the ending, but it makes a lot more sense now. Thanks for the amazing vid!
Final thought comes to mind. "Twin Peak is a soap opera." The appeal of a soap opera, from Lynch's perspective, may have been an opportunity to have characters live on for decades, as many soap opera do (ie General Hospital, Young and the Restless). The audience of soap's also start to feel a love and kindship with the characters, as if they are real family. Possibly the best fate a creator can hope, for fictional character they have created.
26 minutes in, and I'm not sure how much more of these David Lynch impressions I can handle 🥹
A video so good that, even though it’s 4 and a half hours long, it has 2.6 million views. Just let that sink in.
With no mid rolls, for me at least. Dude could have made BANK on mid rolls with that many views and a four hour video, even with low retention say 25% that’s still one hour of mid rolls.
He should meet David Lynch and then talk about nothing but lawn maintenance.
Arif M M yep
He should meet David Lynch and then talk about nothing but making sure you are careful and slow down to a complete stop at yellow lights
Better: he should meet with David Lynch, film himself asking questions staring into the camera, starting with TP related questions and trending off topic to questions perfectly unrelated to TP while Lynch sweeps a floor in the background for 10 minutes.
Maybe occasionally Lynch stops sweeping to give a cryptic answer.
Holy shit, dude. My only issue with this is that my friends are going to look at me like I'm off my rocker when I recommend a 4+ hour video to them. I love it.
Most likely because you're from the united states of shit
Wow this is such a masterpiece! I can’t even tell how much effort you have put on this video. Thanks so much for your enriching perspective. I just wanna point something about it: it might be just exactly as you say it, or maybe not so much but let me clarify why I think so. As a creative myself, creative minds work in a way that you will throw something so unexpected and unpredictable, that people will eventually start to think that everything you do has a meaning. But often, creative geniuses are just that: people immensely creative. They add so many symbolism that it blow peoples minds and they end up proyecting their own perspective onto it. And who knows? Maybe that’s the intention. As a mystery lover, I can tell that people that are blatantly mysterious, they often seek to confuse people, to intrigue them with symbolism and stuff, just to keep them on their toes, it is almost a lowkey form of arrogance that is close to humbleness, or a bit of both. Yeah it could be that all of those meanings that you found are the truth, and trust me, I think you are a very intelligent person, but I believe that someone who is so invested in creating mystery, and who is so intelligent as Lynch is, can easily create a bunch of confusing stuff that can accidentally lead people to believe it must have a meaning. In semiotics, and in production specially, everything must have a meaning but that does not mean it has to be something super deep, just like a practical meaning. A lot of stuff you mention is undeniable though. I think it is amazing that you got all of these pieces together to make a theory that can make sense like that. Congrats for the amazing work! 👏🏼
And boy I LOVED episode 8. I can't imagine not having felt how compelling and utterly sensible it was
Being that Trent Reznor Atticus Ross and Nine Inch Nails are all in it makes it all the more incredible. "The" Nine Inch Nails rather 😂
@@ericeast8097 yessss "the" 😂 Saying it that way felt very typical and right... That kinda awkward or unusual way of saying things that makes it anachronistic or offbeat. Wonderful use of language
This is the single most thorough and brilliant analysis of anything I've ever seen, at least on KZhead. But I hesitate to even add that qualifier. Far more than just another multi hour TP rabbit hole.
Fusion Space just commented something similar. It’s astonishing.
@@HotStrange Not to be presumptuous, but I believe you misplaced your reply. It is astonishing, though. It feels like the "correct" interpretation, meaning the one intended by Lynch.
Yeah I was fully expecting to laugh and shut this off after 10 minutes. Unbelievable analysis.
This is the sort of stuff PhD's are made of.
yes, this could easily qualify as a PhD thesis in media studies
"Finding love in hell may be a theme in all my movies" - David Lynch.