Why Pakistan Imploded | From Economic 'Role Model' to Terror 'Safe Haven' | Akash Banerjee & Adwaith
In the 1960's Pakistan was the poster-boy for development ... her GDP was growing at a faster trot than India, Pakistan's per-capita income for a long time was almost the same as of India - sometimes even more... what then led to the virtual implosion of a nation that was once compared to South Korea? This is the story of the Asian 'role model' state and how in a short time it transformed into a politically unstable, economically bankrupt, terror safe haven. We unearth the core reasons and lessons that this country's spectacular fall has for others.
⛔️ BECOME A DESHBHAKT MEMBER - www.patreon.com/thedeshbhakt ⛔️
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
OR
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thedeshbhakt
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕 kadakmerch.com/thedeshbhakt
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact@thedeshbhakt.in 📧
Credits :
Script - Adwaith
Thumbnail : Khursheed
Graphics : Mehul & Ritam
Editor : Khursheed & Ritam
Producer : Sahil
#pakistan #jinnah #bangladesh
Being a Pakistani if you ask me our Army is the main culprit who never let any of the institution to thrive and corrupted the whole system from top to bottom to serve them and never ask about their rights.
to an extent, ur ryt. ur politicians n beurocrats r also equally responsible.
Religious radicalism since formation is the main reason even the army is religiously radicalised
India have UPSC officials and politicians too but they are ahead of us. Army is number 1 factor for our destruction, second comes religion..
Stop watching content from India
Thik bro.
This is why I am against language imposition and excessive show off of religion in India. India must never do what Pakistan does. Any step Pakistan takes is always the wrong step.
Religion Islam wasn’t the problem rather trying to use it for own worldly benefit caused the destruction. If Islam was the problem saudi arabia would have fallen long ago.
wht? every step is wrong>?
@@punarbasunath7730 iran Isn't islamic. they used Islam to get power. they are selfish rulers
Agree go protest against new masjid in ayodhya
I highly agree with you on the last line lol
Pakistan was secular biggest joke of the century 🤣🤣
I'm from Gilgit Baltistan Pakistan the so called PoK and the points you raised in this video are 100% factual Still I think that one day everything will be fine We never loss hope
How many good hospital do you have in GB be honest I just want know as my online friend say
@@FRieza207 Their might be lesser hospitals in some areas of Pakistan than others, talking specifically, the people of gilgit baltistan don't have to pay taxes, also they get cheaper commodities because of bhutto's reforms, they get more seats in government jobs than thier population ratio. You must know all of this. Thier gdp is low because it is mostly mountainous area with very low population density, which makes it unsuitable for big industry, still the government is trying to set up many small industries like furniture etc. to make better provisions there.
I am from azad jammu Kashmir and I think that there is a chance that we move towards betterment inshallah one day
one day everything will be fine when you become Indian and the land your standing will be Indian sovernity
@@ahmedafraz275 betterment will itself come to you wait when pakistan collapse the land your standing will be indian sovernity
I'm from Pakistan. Some good history points made in your video. The content was not biased and the end lesson is for all the world that never suppress dissent as being anti-nationalist. The society should be kept free to speak their mind and economic model should be inclusive.
Panjabees always think that they are the god for Bangali people. They can do whatever they want to with Bangalies. They didn’t gave business licence, government jobs, government authorities, money for make the fundamental structure for the people of bangle. They also try to brought new people from india in bangle after the partition of india. That's also was a ecological threat for Bangali Muslims. That's why Bangali muslims said " enough is enough ", Let's kick the outsiders from our land.
Hasan bhai, I feel pity for you that you have to live in Pakistan. Come to India and we will serve a talent like yours well
@@pranitgandhi6832 Thanks a lot for your concern. I wish you all the best for your future and all the Indians and India as a country. I will fight for the betterment of my country and people in my little capacity. Hopefully we will become developed countries and good neighbours.
Good👍
Fundamentalism dangerous for any country...thank god..that time modi was not our pm..thanx to nehru
As a Bangladeshi, thank you so much for your honest research. You have put a good effort.
Why Bangladesh should not hate Indian govt and boycott Indian products? Indian govt does everything using RAW to keep a faciest government in power. Bangladesh is massively boycotting Indian products as way to bring back democracy. No neighbor countries of India, like Indian foreign policy, if you notice. It will impact negatively on India for long-term ❤ 🇧🇩 ❤
Bro I don't understand that why BNP ( the main opposition party of Bangladesh is being anti Indian ,( I'm a secularist and don't support communialism) are they have no other issue like development, economic growth, agriculture department.
@@chaitalisaha2885 Your answer is in your question You're secularist but the actions of Indian govt. doesn't seems very much secularist in today's date.
@chaitalisaha2885 How BNP is being anti Indian, they tried to make good relationship with India for 15 years. Pro Indian does not mean you can stay in power illegally. Is Indian govt pro Bangladeshi democracy or anti, if anti, than how you expect Bangladesh to be your friendly country. 🇧🇩
Bangladeshis dont want just because india helped BD to gain freedom in 1971 that we will be a docile doormat to india forever. We do want Pakistani feudalism nor any vassal-state of India.
'NANA BHASHA, NANA MAT, NANA PORIDHAN, BIBIDHER MAJHE DEKHO MILONO MOHAN.' Countries that fail to keep this promise are torn into pieces. From this case study, it's also very clear how difficult a journey the leaders of our country underwent at that time to keep this large, diverse country united amidst all the vulnerabilities such as high poverty, famine, food-shortage and low literacy rate. We must always remember that diversity is our biggest strength. We must always respect and be proud of the diversity of our country. ❤
Ekdom sotti kotha this is the soul on which a country can run
I Watch lot of videos of different experts which are related to commonly known historical events. You have covered a topic and researched which not many have addressed. Thanks for adding knowledge.
5 lakh! seriously? Its about 30 lakh people died in the Liberation war of Bangladesh in 1971.I am a Bangladeshi and its really sad to hear this
My God! That's a huge number!😢
Thats the official number which he is quoting. Nobody knows the ground level talks and facts, everybody goes to official numbers while researching
He projects himself an erudite person but actually he is a fool.
Never forgot India's help during those time
It's actually estimated 3 lakh but mistakenly made 3 million by Sheikh mujib.... You can find the interview of Sirajul Islam khan who informed Mujib the number
Pakistan is a text book for us the Indians. The title of that text book would 'How not to run a country'
India have never seen a single military takeover and Pakistan have never seen a single full time pm. India Don't need to learn from Pakistan
Wish these bhakts realise.
@@cynthiaalvares3994 hmm did u realise ? 😂
@@cynthiaalvares3994they have realised andhnamazi don’t
The name of that book should be how to be a successful beggar 🤣🤣
I am a pakistani and i watch your videos regularly....you are a person who deserves followers....lots of love❤🇵🇰
😂😂 bro why do you watch regularly?
So that he can spit his venom here
Sir,I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩This video is a true intellectual explanation .❤
Spot on!! Keep producing such content. There are lessons for India.
agree bro and one more thing India should learn that peaceful community always produces violence like in Israel hamas war, forceful conversion of Hindus in Bangladesh, Genocide of Hindus in Pakistan and always perturbing middle east. so India should be aware that their number should not exceed 28%.
Thank for your unbiased video Mr. Akash Banerjee.Your content won my heart. Your are the person I always trust. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Wo b bangladesi hai tumara bhai akash 😂😂😂
He is congress supporter, not unbiased
@@icecreams214bruh his videos has more viewership from bangladesh and Pakistan 😂
@@prodigalfraudaddy We used see his contents which are related to Bangladesh. We have no interest on his other topics.Try to grow up.
@@icecreams214 You go to ****
History of Pakistan, Iran, Turkey all have set examples as to what happens when we stop appreciating diversity , confuse religion with culture and do not keep religion personal separate from politics and country.
One more reason to be proud of being born in India, we started at the same note and we have come so far.
No you did not start at the same note. Dont distort history. There was asymmetrical distribution of wealth.
@@BITTERYETTRUE Then how come before 1970s and 80s, even after 1947 Pakistan was in better economic conditions than India?? Please don't distort history India has come so far.
@@swathyl8542 Whereas geographically and numerically you are bigger than us, our hearts are way too bigger than yours. We acknowledge and admire your progress and indeginization efforts. Re reread my text above and reconcile. Once it comes to open heartedness Indians are no match to Pakistanis. Stay blessed. Wishing you a shining india.
no you did not start at the same note. India took most of the industries and military arsenal. Also you took many Muslim majority lands and claim them to be India's part stating that their leader decided to join India where as you did quite the opposite for Kashmir.
@@muhammadmazahirali2120 yeah we had industries, but all the lands that produced raw materials went to u. We had nothing to produce in order to put in those industries man
This is the first time I've come across this channel and have to say, the summary of your presentation is very concise and largely accurate. The Pakistan story is a sad one for any Pakistani citizen. I think the main problem with the experiment of Pakistan was its original idea of creation based on religion. This flaw influenced the course of its history as you explained well. India, despite its diversity and Hindu majority, was founded on secular principles. This is THE MAIN difference why the two countries find themselves on different trajectories today. Religion should never be allowed to be the ruling force, as we've all learnt from the history of Europe and how they progressed only once they got rid of the clergy from the governance. The age of enlightenment followed and is for all to witness today. I admire a prosperous India and its journey. Its beauty is in its diversity of languages, cultures and religions. What a wonderful way to respect and learn from each other's differences by living together. I wish my old homeland Pakistan had been a safe place for all minorities and a merit-based country. I wish !
You are from Bangladesh,if yes sorry bro
@@MariaKhan-mh9zf Mariaji you don't feel sorry it is politicians who do injustice and some stupid people follow it. Indians, Pakistani and Bangladeshi middle-class people are good.
I really want ke mere Kisi Indian lardki SE dosti hoooo I want to know about their perspective
@@MariaKhan-mh9zf There are different perspectives. I am liberal Indian staying in Mumbai worked in media for 25 years met people across different nationalities. Majority of Indians feel injustice is done on them. Decline in Hindu population in Pakistan has created more hatred in India. POK if given to India can solve 80% of problem between two nation Culture is same in both the countries so Gazals, Movies and Cricket match can easily take place.
@@sandeepnerurkar4918 I am a media student my mam used to say my sister is having Hindu neighbours I am having Hindu friends pata Nahi bahir ye thek hote hai yahan he onhooone Hindu musalman Karna hota hai
*“History clearly teaches us about what to do and what not to, those people who don't learn from it will face the same consequences that they've faced in the past.”* - a wise man
Throw left behind chuslism to Pakistan
When religion,language,communal controversies are used to give false answers for serious allegations we should understand that the governance is bogus
Hindutva approach is protecting cultural identity and history of india. its nothing like islamism. its an anti-dote to casteism and wokeism.
@@drpimple1753first handle your lindu in Pakistan.
@@paki_munda what wrong they did?? i never heard any terriorism act done by them.
I can only imagine, the kind of efforts and hours you have put in. Great content man🎉
Democracy in Pakistan= by the Army, from the Army and for the Army.
Being a Pakistani i agree with you 100% on every point you raised. Pakistan's biggest enemy is none other than Pakistan Army itself 🙏🤞
Agreed from Karachi
You people must shun terrorism and religious extremism. Take your religion to the four corners of your house. Your country will bounce back.
@@pucheousame to you $anghis 😙🤗
@@SkyMonkeyLing Sanghis dont' wear suicide vests and after 72 hoors. Clean your house first. it's very important.
@@pucheou clean your Country first 🥱 ~ chad Maldives 🗿
Akash, I'm from Pakistan. I take you criticism positively, yes we are in a state of crisis since the creation of pakistan. We should learn from past mistakes to overcome and yes you are absolutely right we should make policies which is in favor of diversity. I believe in this phrase "unity in diversity", thanks for highlighting core issues which should be resolve. I may not agree with your all points. But majorly you are saying right things.
Yes bro I'm with you
U r in crisis from 7th century. 🤣
Your nation was built on the roots of disunity in diversity 😂😂. How can you talk about unity in diversity
@surojeetchatterji9966 - you have always been in crisis.
@sumitgidwani7382 - which is same place you are going now
Great effort very informative episode 👍, nicely explained downfall of Pakistan and creation of Bangladesh.Happy new year 2024 to Team Deshbhakt.
Good research on the topic and well presented.
As a PAKISTANI, I must say with heartfelt feelings.. this guy is absolutely right..... My grandfather migrated from JAIPUR,,, hamara to koi qasoor hi nhi 😶
Maza tho araha ha hoga pakistan me😂
is this a joke for you ??? o i see, you are also 100% similiar to our Pakistan's radicals....@@themysteriouschannel9991
Acha hua chale gaye jaipur se kam se kam ek pakistani toh gaya jaipur se
@@tunaktun3379 😂😂😂 Itni nafrat. . . . . . . # . # # # # 7 Jan 2024 @ 10:51 PM
@@comparativereligiondailynews Yeh sab kya hai?? Hein aur itni nafrat tm musalman hindu se kitni nafrat karte ho Yeh batana shuru karu kya mai
As a Pakistani I think not only Army, Civil Bureaucracy, Judges and Crony Capitalist but also the Public is responsible Pakistani Public always thinks that democratic Politicians are only culprits but they never protest against Army, Civil Bureaucracy, Judges and Crony Capitalist
Atta ki bore; Motorcycle ; cash for votes : Public too sell their votes. Imran khan was blind ? J Tareen aircraft free fuel : Aleem Khan PTI ATM was free? oh please who you try to fool. Bajwa extension for what! Did Angel came into dream to extend? oh please “ can not fool ALL the people ALL the time.
I am Pakistani but it's sad to say everything in this video is 110% Ture 😢
Parallels drawn in an excellent manner !! Bravo, Akash !! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 ❤❤❤❤ From responses which I have read after posting this, I see that you have a fan following in the neighbouring countries too, which makes me feel very happy and hopeful. Happy and hopeful to know that there are other people out there who think that all is not quite hunky dory with the world, and that there is urgent need (and scope) for improvement.
I do not expect Pakistan to change if the people does not wake up in mass, and do not expect others to learn till they face the same consequences. Human nature.
They all get together for Palestine which is thousands of miles away But not for themselves 😂 Wow good 👍
@@themysteriouschannel9991 for once in your life don't be a brainless troll
@@Morphysince94palestine is history now. Dont get so touchy 😂
@@MohammedAli-ng7rmPalestine is still there as it was before war but I can't understand one of the most advanced Israel Military is struggling to defeat them, more than 3 month since the war begin bruh
FOR PAKISTAN "Democracy is a government of the ARMY, by the ARMY, and for the ARMY"
Do you believe that the Bengal genocide would've happened if Pakistan were based on Shariah over the fake idea of democracy?
Best definition of democracy 😂😂😂😂
Army officials loot money,they are most rich people there and then settle abroad after retirement
pak army is not army its simply moderen version of east india company
& imran Khan is new Sheikh Mujibur Rahman fighting against army.....
Soo true. Really appreciated
Excellent analysis and great flawless presentation!!
I am feeling sorry for myself but I have to accept as pakistani that I can't deny any of these facts
Military and government is the problem, they loot money and common citizens don't get anything
Aapni galti ko accept karna aur usse sabak lekar sudharne ke kaushish hi insaaniet hey..
Pakistan too can come out of this and Inshallah the people should also prosper. After all we all did belong to one great nation until unfortunately history did us part.
@hardfact907who is saitan?😂😂
@AshrafKhan-sd7sfwho is saita!
I am a Pakistani and watch your videos regularly. Points which are raised by you are 99% True. The main reason behind our downfall is not Religious fundamentalism but its Pakistan Army. We do not want war with India but If this war with India and fundamentalism narrative ends there will be no need for such a huge Army and all the generals and other senior army officers (majority from Punjab) will lose their " Ayashi Program/Protocol".
This is the sad reality bhai. Someone else is culprit, but the common innocent citizen is suffering . 😢
Bro you're from karachi ?
This story sounds familiar…. Looks like a Déjà vu!
Exactly Bhai , 76 years se lad rahe hai , aur bombing kar rahe hai India pe , bas Bhai aur nahi chahiye asise , mei toh bas yeh dua karta hu ki , Pakistan, india aur Bangladesh phirse ek hojaye , 😭
Religious fundamentalism is the second reason. In india APJ Kalams are scientists, in your country they are maulavis.
Smart episode and well timed!!
I am super glad to watch this video , for 2 reasons 1- as usual , your content is awesome, informative and near perfect 2 - felt a sigh of relief to see your video after almost 2 weeks , it got me worried as to why you didn’t post videos for such a long time . Super glad to know all is well … Great work #deshbhakt , god bless !
Samjhdaar ko ishara kafi hai 😊 Through this history of Pakistan, there is a teaching for India Wow!! Well played Deshbhakt ❤❤ love your content and intelligence
your comment made it so obvious.
Elections agye hain na😅
Dont worry we don't have Quran to go in that way
Well they just reconstructed the temples that were demolished in the past, I don't see anything wrong here
@@sashisingh8348but we have andhbhakts
To those comparing Pakistan's past with India, you need to know that India has always had Hindu majority, which welcomed people from all spheres. There had been times that even jews who were chased out from EU, were allowed shelter, which the British rule had denied them during pre-ind. Religion hiccups and quarrels were there too but that didn't stop India from attracting the persecuted which includes Persians, Arab Christians, Muslim Sailors, Jews, Yazids etc. Ask yourself if people from your religion can simultaneously visit or pray in a church, mosque, temple, shrine, gurudwara etc without any hesitation? THE MAJORITY IN INDIA DOES THAT!
But it will not suit this jokers and his audience mind
It was made possible due to British raj they were inclusive and first to gave rights to minorities and lower classes.Hindus practiced caste system throughout history they used to discriminate with their own ppl which resulted in rapid conversion when muslims arrived. Stop glorifying ppl who used to burn women with their husbands.read history and stop watching akshay kumar movies.
@@LoneWolf.1990i think he forgot about the divide and rule policy
I hope indian politicians understand this and not ruin our country
KATWAPANTI SUCKS
If BJP is there then don't worry
Modi hai tho mumkin hai don't worry
Jaa yeh jaake Raghuram ko samjha
I hope Converted Christians will understand the importance of Our own Religion & Culture And will Revert to Sanatan Dharma
Thanks for a very informative episode, that we Indians need to understand at a deeper level. Afterall, “Those who don't know history are destined to repeat it.”
Excellent, Bravo , keep it up bro
Very good episode by Mr. Akash. There is a plenty of learning for India.
Great episode Aakash India has a lot to learn from the mistakes Pakistan committed and not to toe their line.
INDIA IS MAKING THE SAME MISTAKES LIKE PAKISTAN DID
India also has to learn from China because until 1990 the GDP of India and China were similar
@@hiteshrohra2991and also we should take back our lands like China 😂
Hinduism has nothing in common with Islam. So...such fears are baseless.
An excellent episode! The danger is written loud and clear for us in this study from history. Only, are we keeping our eyes and ears open?
. A good dose of awareness n alert for every citizen around the world. ..
Great slick presentation. “ Tum hamarey jaisey Mat nikal jana “ ( modified line of Fahmida ji’s poem)
TWENTY LONG YEARs and Billions of dollars -Nato and United States of America could not change - Taliban and Pakistan. This Mr Akash : knows ALL. . 200 years British rule ; 90 years absolute rule. KP culture; Baloch habits; Sind way of life; Punjab mind: Did change? Tomorrow adopt dollar as currency; Indian flag : United Kingdom constitution and change name Greater Khalistan? Milk n honey start to flow. Do you live Ali Baba Wonder land or still fly on carpet?
As a Pakistani it is heartbreaking to see how religios extremism, dictatorship, injustice and corruption destroy my country especially Pakistani minorities hindus and christians still facing threats and attacks , India should focus to preserve its democracy and secularism and i support CAA, thanks to indian government ❤
@Amber-mt3nvno hindu or Sikh is more persecuted than rohingya muslims. I support CAA for everyone except hindus.
ramu became Pakistani today 😂😂😂
@@YakrifZee itni nafrat 😶 Hindus seh Kia hogia hai
@@YakrifZee educate karo khud ko aur history parhoo yeh extremism aur nafratoo seh Kuch NAHI milta
@@YakrifZee , but Rohingyas are from Myanmar aren't they and they could be placed in Bangladesh. But Hindus and Sikhs can not be.
Great episode on Pakistan's Economical history, But I saw you missed the major contribution of East Pakistan's resources that helped in Pakistan's economic growth in 50s & 60s
As a Pakistan agreed.
Yes .
Love the knowledge you provide by your videos
❤Bohat hi Achi Research ke hai Aap aur Aap ke Team Very good
Brilliant analysis of the unfortunate history of the Pakistani state. It is sad how common people get crushed by vested interests and propaganda of the powerful. A deep lesson for us Indians to reflect upon.
🔴 Correction ✅ 30 lakhs of Bangladeshi people were murdered during the Liberation war of Bangladesh in 1971 by Pakistani military oppressors. ❌Not 5 lakhs
no no it was 5 lakh but it was wrong i'm totally against my country on this point
@@abdulrehmankk61155 lakh directly 30 lakh indirectly due to war, famine, border crossing
@@abdulrehmankk6115your Pakistani pappa told you this number 5,00,000…?..... 3 million[3,000,000] lives were lost in 71
isko isi se paise milte hai
Correction it was 70 lakhs, around 95 percent were hindus
Loved this episode. May I ask for your opinion on Hindi imposition in non-hindi spoken states in India? Can we have an episode from you on this topic?
Truly an amazing vlog .. We Pakistanis should consider the points of this gentleman, raising.
Your content is spot on; please continue producing such valuable insights. There are valuable lessons for India embedded in the depth of your content, offering guidance and perspectives worth considering for the country's development and progress.
Akash not 5 lakh people died in 1971 the actual number was 30 lakh😢 I'm from Bangladesh. I know Pakistan growed their economy that time because they use Bangladesh for their income source 😢 end of the we are now stable than them❤
Not 30 lakh + tha
5lakh were Muslims and 25 lakh were hindus
Bangladesh came into being in 1971 but Pakistan's dowfalling started from 2005 not 1971. Dont blame all Pakistan for what Pak army did to bangalis.
@@ahmadhussain-Fitnessyes Pakistan looted so much from Bangladesh that it lasted till 2005!!!
Please take back Chakmas and Hajong to your country. They are becoming nuisance to our state.
This is the kind of KZhead channel that you love it❤
Good video ,well explained
Thank you sir for showing our political history
I hope India does not fall prey to the same situation. Thank you for a wonderful explainer.
Your hopes will be dashed brother. Being a sanatan dharma follower I can say for sure that all the slogans of one religion one nation one language one this one that is purely foolishness. It's just like one weather or one food or one cloth. Muslims Sikhs Christians Buddhist Jews Parsi are very important and very much required. Unity in diversity is old concept. New concept is diversity in unity. India will never accept itself to be a Hindu country.
@@AshishTiwari-sl4juApart from Muslims everyone is important bro! Every religion is nice but not Islam! Definitely not Islam!
@@mihirjoshi8934 let us not be against any religion just because of few bad people. Good and bad people are everywhere
@@AshishTiwari-sl4juWell you have no clue about islam ....and interestingly India is growing faster due to its policies not because of its ideology....
Every Indian is equally important regardless of religion. Stereotyping mindlessly will lead to a halt in progress.
V informative ❤
This story sounds familiar…. Looks like a Déjà vu! One nation…One language…one religion…. Rather too much of talks around religion…One everything…killing diversity Thanks Deshbhakt for bringing this to the fore ❤ 🇮🇳
In india the line is one nation one election we never said one religion first learn all parts & we are building masjid too near ram mandir
@@lisabunny127 Who is this ‘we’? Can you please shed light on this? Are you a part of this ‘we,’ holding a position of authority and assuming a higher ground, as if others, like us, are small fries? Did you understand the intended sense of using the word ‘one’ here? If your answer is ‘no’ to any of the above, then kindly keep your advice to yourself because you cannot differentiate between the figurative and literal meanings of an expression. These are the follies resulting from the availability of cheap internet and inexpensive phones-almost anyone illiterate can get up and write garbage on social media.
Learnt many new things about history of Pakistan today and how it can repeat if we don’t learn from the mistakes committed in past. Thanks Aakash
Love your sarcasm! A very beautiful msg and a warning given too for people to understand by themselves. "Boldiya Jo bolna tha aur naam bhi nahi liya" !! Amazing 👏👏👏
Hello sir I am very impressed from the information and knowledge you shared with us.And It is very impressive of you to point out the deep rooted problems in pakistan.
Good honest research.
A very well put satirical video to help everyone in India reflect and understand which path the hindutva approach can take for India and its government
And which path are we going, what do you mean by hindutva approach exactly. I cam see extremism growing in every relegion in India than why Hindu will take all the blame. Is shouting sir tan se juda and actually doing it is hindutya approach, 15min ke liye police hata lo, humari sarakr aayegi to ayodhya me mandir gira denge, is that all hindutya approach.....let me tell you the difference, call extremism when one relegion want every relegion to go out like what happened in pakistan, in India no sikh is on target, parsi, jews, buddhist all are safe. If there is shouting against one relegion than there must be something wrong and not in India but this is a world wide phenomenon, all relegion world wide stopped tolerating non sense of one community and you onow who are they. If i go by your theory than Israel, France, Italy, sweden, denmark every country will fall.
@@Ashish02579brother there hundredths of speeches of bjp leader like yogi modi swami subjramanyam raja amit shah etc provoking anti islamic statements
@@HappyandSuccessful-uz1sx i agree but q is still same, is that one sided speech. There are hundreds of speech from other side too....2nd, anti muslim speech is now being raised world wide, weather be it europe or china, everyone wants them out. Can you tell me why is it so that no one wants them or everyone is wrong except muslim, plz answer this q. While answering this q your all doubt will het cleared, try it
@@Ashish02579bas Godi media dekhna band kardo sab kuch thik ho jayega.
@@Ashish02579 1) Actually talk to many Muslims. They are normal people like us. Extremists are there in every religion. 2) Don't listen to godi media. EXTREMELY distorted from real life. Trust me. I've friends in journalism who regret joining these companies because of the level of manipulation and pressure(at least firstpost and NDTV) 3) Don't judge Europe for inclusivity. They are a bunch of "developed" countries, but they have absolutely no tolerance for people slightly different from their culture. Just look at the geography. So much land. Such less number of people and population density. Yet their history has been extremely bloody and war torn with massive cases of genocides across centuries. They are supremely intolerant of other cultures. Only in the past decade have they actually every witnessed people from other places coming there and a lot of their citizens can't handle it only. That's why the right wing conservatives have shot up like nobody's business. 4) Most important - If you are actually proud of Hinduism - I am - read and understand our scriptures like the Vedas and Upanishads (Not manusmriti, because it's a relatively newer text written in a corrupted era where Hinduism and nationalism intertwined). You will find out that there is never a victim mentality in our religion. You keep saying no in your comments - 'Arey... WE are doing This only to protect ourselves because THEY are doing That'. That kind of mentality is some of the most pathetic kind of thinking a human being can have and must be weeded out in childhood itself to have a stable duty bound community structure. Read it. It's explained in both Atharva ved and Chandogya Upanishad. And they are right. As a country, our best successes throughout history have only been in empires which have been cosmopolitan and inclusive in their outlook.
Appreciate you and your team's efforts to be able to create awareness.
Superbly narrated
Thanx for making this video. Every Indian's should watch this to know that we are doing EXACTLY the same things n expecting a different result. May God bless us....
it will not happen. hinduism is different and inclusive. this is all drama by akash banerjee.
hi Akash your subscriber from pakistan. Thanks for the deep analysis of our problems and history. i must say you didn't sugarcoat it, this is why communication is so vital because no matter what problems there are between two countries its only your rival that will tell you the barebone harsh truth that you need to hear this is one of the wonders of youtube and social media. Thanks for showing us the mirror and for diagnosing our problem maybe now we can do something about it or not time will tell. history is very subjective therefore one must take all the perspective in account and akash your perspective is invaluable for us. we are only human and so we make mistakes but we'll get through this and see better days once more i or we have to believe that otherwise whats the point.
Kbhi reform Hoga in islmi desho Ka. Democracy secularism modern Constitution religious freedom equal right women education right. Har chiz ko to mostly islm k khilaf bolte. Khud ye musslman desh Kisi ko citizenship equal right nhi dete viza khtm hote hi Bhaga dete koi shadi kre to mar dete jbki khud ye musslman non Muslim countries m maze se rhte monitory bolke blackmail krte UK USA Canada France Poland Sweden jermany me Jake citizenship lete masjid bna lete Sadi krte democracy secularism ki bate Ulta hamaas k support m rally nikalte real face Nd double standard of islm. Inki kartut dekh k ab Italy Poland France ki govt bhi inki entry ban krne ki Soch rahe. China ne to islm hi ban krdiye .
@@user-ip7lp7zo6x i have a huge list about indias problems too but see thats the thing we are now getting awared of the problem that we were lied to what you are saying we can the same things about you but so what they tell us lies about you and they also tell you lies about us but its not just lies its half lie half truth. and get off the moral high ground you might get cold up there
You are one of the best and most informed youtubers educating everyone today. Love from Pak my friend
Very well explained 👏
Thanks for your videos brother
Dear Deshbhakt outstanding journalism. Some deep insights & great lessons to learn for India from the journey of Pakistan & where it has landed itself today. Truly its the people who are the real pillar of democracy & are the only credible safeguard against violation of demicratic principles & erosion of the power & authority democratic institutions that are vital safeguards in preserving our democratic values & rights
Go to mental hospital😂😂😂,atlist use your mind😂😂😂
The fact the not even 1 om completed a full term and regular coups also matter.
@Akash I love watching your content. Kudos to you and your team. The way you deliver the script is priceless. ❤
This is the reason why I follow deshbhakt ❤❤
Bilkul sahi farmaya aapne
He brought this video to realize us what is happening in our country in present time
Don't worry my friend this will never going to happen in India, he is a congress puppet that's way he I trying to create fears in general public that Modi is doing all these thing in our country which is not right, in indian situation.
Hinduism and Islam are not the same. Hinduism is a peace loving religion. And the more radical a Hindu becomes the more peaceful and orderly this world will be made.
@@RaviSharma-kx5qcthat's what Pakistani also thought
@@bilalmalik4140 You have no idea of Hinduism. So you are not qualified to talk. First learn about Hinduism and then participate in this discussion.
@@RaviSharma-kx5qc I know about Hinduism but not RSS hindutav, just check before 2014 there was not hatered on next level, but look at now how brother is against brother it doesn't matter which religion we follow but we are from Same race, and hatered will only lead civil war
Sir - Not a lengthy episode. It was a purely spell bound very informative content. God bless you for bringing up such good contents.. Waiting for such more episodes .. Regards
The problem with us Indians is that we dont learn from the mistakes of Pakistan and started traversing the same path. "The majoritarian polarised partial democracy".
Very objective episode. Well done.
Nicely researched.
Akshat sir never disappoint us ❤
Indians should really learn from this incident of Pakistan because now a days many of us are also becoming more excremist due to politics !
True salute to such type of indians
It is due to Muslim appeasement politics
@@ainaannasir5426 bhaiya ghr wapsi kb kroge, taki hm religion ko chod kr desh k liye kaam kr ske.
Extremism pehle bhi tha... but Digital media nahi tha toh utna pata nahi chalta tha aur log bhi influence nahi hote the lack of knowledge k baja se
Hindu Rashtra yeh desh 10,000 saal se tha tab koi extremism nahi tha aur aaj Hindu Rashtra ki baat ho rahi hai toh woh extremism hai
Best KZheadr sir aap ne sahi good information real information good. Thank you sir❤
I haven't bought a youtube subscription, but your channel's videos play in the background while watching. How is this possible?
A must watch video. This is what history should be all about, to learn from past mistakes.
Unbiased Reporter ... Love from Pakistan ❤ To be honest if Jinnah lived even five years, Pakistan would have been different but unfortunately he passed away just in 13 months 😢
If jinnah would have been there, it would have more worst than present because he had no vision or road map. Other wise nation would not have divided in two
@@deshbhakt2779 Pardon me, I think Jinnah was more secular, enlightened, and well aware of modern world than Gandhi ji (I myself am a staunch Gandhian). Once he was the most modern leader of Congress and Subcontinent, and left Congress because of Gandhi's mixing of social, religious, and Cultural phenomena with political and economic stratum. He envisioned a modern secular, and liberal Islamic country which would have economic muscles. His last speech which was delivered on inauguration of State Bank of Pakistan reveals how much he was well aware of the economic power, which he espoused from Pakistan. But his untimely death erased each and everything with him.
@@thought605 neh, you are in some delululu. I agree that Jinnah was influenced by Attaturk to some degree in initial years, but later he became mad, like an Indian fellow named Savarkar. Both demanded religious nations though both were quite non-religious
@@blastergoon4185 I agree with your argument about the later years of Jinnah, and its comparison with Savarkar..
@@thought605You thought you'd use secular and Islamic together and get away with it. A state based on religion can never be secular. Jinnah was a power hungry political leader who created the idea of a Muslim nation solely because he knew that's the only place he'll be able to rule over.
Unbiased analysis 👍
We should learn our lessons from them. Seem to be walking in their footsteps.
As always ur views were informative and upto the point. P.s: Akash We need atleast 2 videos every week! More power to u brother
Great episode to start the year! You and team are doing a great job! Really good content, good questions and points discussions 🎉🎉🎉
Aapke har episode ke baad aapke liy mere Dil me izzat barh jati hai, Salute to u Akash sir, u r really a gem
Absolutely true... Could u make one episode on kashmir riots and how India occupied Kashmir and Y
A major reason might be the initially tilt towards Capitalist Economic System that helps only the elites to grow. GDP growth can be very misleading.
India is making the same mistakes from 1993 onwards. Inequality is extreme and not many people are getting good jobs. Those who are qualified as school teachers are now working as labourers.
@@dipakbose2677Experienced and capable teachers are doing very well for themselves in Delhi-NCR.
@@dipakbose2677agaya socialist ka 14 Ohhh you are a bengali.... sob thik cholche to wb te? Economic boom dekha diyeche shunlam wb e😂😂 Ar btw aajkal lal potaka dekha jacche na road er pase? Ki holo? Tmc er gunda gulo g mere rekhe diyeche naki? 😂
@@dipakbose2677 jyoti basu ne bengal ko jaise economic powerhouse bana diya tha 1993 se pehele
@@saptarsi7868bhai please English Mein bol tune kya bola
I have seen Pakistanis, especially the youths fighting against fundamentalism and corruption in their country... but sadly they are silenced by their Army.
এই এপিসোডটা বাংলাতেও চাই ৷ অনেক দর্শক শ্রোতা এমন বিশ্লেষণমূলক ভিডিও দেখলে পাগোল হয়ে যাবে ৷ অনেক বাংলাদেশীরাও ৷ অনুরোধটা রাখুন ভাই ৷ ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
এই ভিডিওতে বাংলাদেশের ম্যাপকে কেন কেটে দেখানো হয়েছে তা কি বলতে পারবেন?
बहुत ही उत्तम एपिसोड।
I have seen people around me making a mockery of Pakistan whenever it comes up during any conversation... what is unfortunate is that we comfortably turn a blind eye or try to justify when we find our own country to be heading in similar path... tragic...🤷🏽
🤣😅😅😅😂😂Because of uttar pradesh and Bihar 5 kg ration people we are slowly progressing on road of destruction
Mostly islmi desho Ka yahi hal h. Democracy secularism different religions ki respect nhi. Khud ye musslman desh Kisi ko citizenship equal right nhi dete viza khtm hote hi Bhaga dete koi shadi kre to mar dete jbki khud ye musslman non Muslim countries m maze se rhte monitory bolke blackmail krte UK Canada and Australia France Italy Poland me Jake citizenship lete masjid bna lete Sadi krte democracy secularism ki bate krte real face Nd double standard of islm. India me Jo sabse Jada democracy secularism samvidhan samvidhan bate krte wahi log social media m Taliban ko support krte jisne democracy govt zabardsti khtm krdi dusre religion ban krdiye . Women education ban krdi. Burka complusory krdiye. India me ESA kbhi nhi Hoga. India me Hindu religion hi multiple cultural he Yaha hmssa dusre religion ki respect hoti rahi. Iran k parsi rahte. Sikh bodh Christian Jain religion k log he. India m Kashmir Yaha majority musslman ki h waha koi dusra religion nhi. Desh m Yaha bhi musslman Jada h waha koi rahna passnd nhi krta. Congress ho ya bjo ya others party musslman dange fasad krte rahe he. Pakistan ko bnane wale desh m khilafat movement chalaye wale bhi India k hi musslman the. Aligarh university me recently hamaas k support m rally nikalte. Jb Pakistan afghanista m masjid m bomb blast hote uspe chup rhte. Hmesa Muslim brotherhood k nam.ek hoke dusre religion desh ko jhukate. Khud ki kartut per chup rhte. Pakistan ne bluchistahn ko ghulm bna rkha. Rohingya refugees mullo ko Kisi islmi desh ne nhi rkha. Vese Palestine k liy rally nikalte isarel k against me.
😂😂 just because pakistan story you heard; you connected it with india?
How do think our nation is going towards pakistan problem.
@@tunaktun3379 because of अंध भक्त 🐷 😍