aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속)' The Performance Stage (Glitter Snowball Ver.)
2021 ж. 7 Ақп.
1 687 832 Рет қаралды
aespa's new single "Forever" is out!
Listen and download on your favorite platform: smarturl.it/aespa_Forever
❄'Forever (약속)' MV: • aespa 에스파 'Forever (약속...
Subscribe to aespa Official KZhead Channel!
kzhead.info?sub_con...
aespa official
/ aespa
/ aespa_official
/ aespa_official
/ aespa_official
/ aespa.official
weibo.com/aespa
#aespa #Forever #Performance #약속 #에스파 #æspa
Even tho Giselle and karina doesn't have a position as a Vocalist they still prove to us that they can sing live and be stable. Well we know SM THING.
*ÆSPA is inspiration! For all if I got 4K subscribers!! mom will definitelyy buy me a mic for my cover songs!! Every help is appreciated GUYS*
what is karinas Position?
@@alissa7731 main rapper
@@skybss7312 no main dancer
@@skybss7312 main dancer
Popular opinion: Everyone agrees that æspa is the main vocalist.
*ÆSPA is inspiration! For all if I got 4K subscribers!! mom will definitelyy buy me a mic for my cover songs!! Every help is appreciated GUYS*
Stop commenting this everywhere
@@sakibkhanshuvo3843 Stob
Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!❤❤❤❤❤
YASH OFC
Still can't move on from Karina's vocal, so addicted
Trueee😭❤
You're right, her voice is really perfect.
me too😭
"im addited" -aespa karina black mamba
Karina is my ultimate goddess. She has an undeniable charisma, beautiful voice, a graceful dancer and has an insane visual. She's the prettiest kpop idol I've seen. Looks so natural. Love her so much.
Put aside all of tht, she the nicest and loving idols i have ever seen. In fact, i have been a keen observer of kpop scene since 2009 and i watched all idols interviews, bts, or anything. So far, karina, yeji, kim minju, seohyun, jiho (jisoo, arin, victoria, and some more) have a top notch personality. Just my perspective. Because all of them are softie, gentle, and can't even fight back if ppl did smtg to them (they easily mistreat). even through their mannerism u can tell.
Black Mamba:ALL MEMBERS MAIN DANCER Forever:ALL MEMBERS MAIN VOCALIST Next Comeback:ALL MEMBERS MAIN RAPPER???
Misfit NCT 😂😂😂
@@efrynnn4817 WE NEED MISFIT FEMALE VERSION SM !!!! DO YOU HEAR ME ???
YES YES I WANT TO SEE THAT
Imagineee
YESSS
I don't know why everyone surprised that Giselle can sing well when she literally used to join choir before. [EDIT] STAN GISELLE!
Yes,my friend who's new to aespa her bias is giselle and she cant believe that giselle is one of the underatted member,just sayin'
Karina also joined choir before. They're so talented😭😭😭
@@imyoona2011 yes! all of them can sing so well!!! ㅠㅠ
@@nicoledemata4625 sad huhu
I think it’s because she naturally has a deeper vocal tone and she’s listed as main rapper. Typically main rapper is viewed at the weakest vocally but it’s SM... they feed their trainees the CDs of their sunbaes 👀
winter's way of singing is very polite to the ears, karina is also nice and looks elegant here 😍😍
Winter, a perfect main vocal quality and outstanding dancer with the best visual and strong stage presence. How can she blessed with such talent for a baby chick?
Ningning's short hair and Giselle's black hair is a mood. They look much better with that style.
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help
I agree with you
50% Christmas vibe 50% valentine vibe 100000000% talent
100% agree
aespa comeback 10 NOV 2023 DRAMA 2PM KST
Winter has such a sweet, clear voice I’m addicted! Plus her visual is out of this world :)
SM's rappers, main dancers can sing flawlessly. Well, THAT'S SM Things.
Karina, winter, giselle and ningning are just pure ace and that's fact 💅
*ÆSPA is inspiration! For all if I got 4K subscribers!! mom will definitelyy buy me a mic for my cover songs!! Every help is appreciated GUYS*
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help
Winter is more than just a visual. She keeps surprising me everyday with her talent, personality and beauty. She's just too good to be true.
Ikr! She's getting better day by day 💘
Ikr!! I love her so much
she's hold title as lead vocalist for reasons
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html My cover dance BTS "ON"
I love her so mach⭐💕
Karina, you are more than a visual. You also have an amazing vocals.
Karina is very stunning with her body proportion..
Winter’s vocals are ✨glowing✨
And her visual too 💘
Winter reminds me TAEYEON
Yeah for me she is among the prettiest idol in 4th gen.but i think she’s kinda similar to BoA or jessica.karina is similar to taeyeon than winter i think.
Her vocals is amazing.her sweet and angelic voice are melting ke
Winter in a snow globe concept reminds me of Jessica Jung. Her facial expression and that cold yet sweet voice. Damn. She really has the resemblance of Jessica when it comes to vocal technique.
💘
Of course, she's daughter of Jessica and Taeyeon.😌
I think you need to wear glasses...
@@monroedoc6729That cold aura and vocal technique lmao
kzhead.info/sun/hbmrY5upeHehdqM/bejne.html
에스파는 정말 완벽한 그룹.
No
에스파는 완벽함 그자체
Am I the only one who loves Giselle's proportions like😶😶
Nobody talking about Ningnings short hair. SHE LOOKS SO Gorgeous.
same i agree
PERIODDDD
YEEESSS
Ikr 🥺 she looks so cute 🧡
YEAH SHE IS!!
im obsessed with karina's vocal - it sounds kinda deeper than others but still soft it is so so pretty and attractive
Yesss, her voice is so unique yet powerful
me too!! i love her tone, im addicted yk;)
Me too
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html . My cover dance BTS "ON"
main vocalist: ningning lead vocalists: winter giselle karina there's nothing bad with others saying that 'aespa the main vocalist' we are all whipped for their vocals. but me, i dont feel comfortable. idk hahaha. i wanna highlight everytime that our maknae ning is leading this heavenly vocal roster of aespa. she deserves so much recognition. dont take this badly, i love four of them.
that's not an official member positions, thats just me and my aespa-vocal-besotted heart.
Ningning is the main vocalist, and Winter is the lead vocalist. But they are all very good vocalists. Winter could have definitely been a main vocalist in another group 💜
yes you can definitely say it louder
Might be my favorite ballad in kpop, truly mesmerizing vocals from all members!!!!
Winter's vocals just melts my heart
Her voice is always so sweet 💘
Yeah her voice is so sweet
Her voice is making everyone melts actually
if you listen to both versions side by side, you would notice that winter and karina sounded almost the same in both versions, while giselle and ningning sounded even better in this version. this just proved that their vocals are consistent (top-notch) and would just get better and better. cant wait to see how they bloom in the future.
Karina why she so prettyyyy
WINTER! YOU GO GIRL! those vocals are amazing🤯🥰
I will never shut up about KARINA’s body proportions and beauty. This girl got it all no wonder a lot of people turn their jealousy into hate.
Sameee
Her vocals too. She's so good 💙
Her vocal is good tho
*Karina is bully like irene, don't support such untalented ugly girl, stan ITZY instead of aespa*
@@vc5831 honey u okay? Im not a fan of aespa or itzy, im just your typical music lover & l casually listen to kpop and enjoy it but i personally think it's rude to put down other artists like tht. These women work hard and endure so much to be singers considering how harsh the industry is. I just hope tht we all can respect their hard works, and if their music doesnt suit your taste, just leave them alone. Spread love and positivity in kpop~
Popular opinion:Everyone agrees that all aespa member is vocalist.
kzhead.info/sun/hbmrY5upeHehdqM/bejne.html
copied comment
*aespa can't sing, no autotune can save their horrible voice*
@@vc5831 just watch the video hun, it’s a slap on your face
@@vc5831 You have hearing problems for sure. Please go to hospital ASAP
How i wish i can have a 30% of Ning's vocals, 40% of Karina's body shape, 20% of Giselle's rap talent, and 50% of Winter's personality. I so love this beautiful girls.
Karina voice is so beautiful and unique
Karina is definition of perfection. I can’t let my eyes off her. She is gorgeous and talented. Love her voice too.
sorry but can you tell me who is her pls?
@@suneaterbuu8223 the one who's singing at 1:05 !!
Where's the lie tho
i agree i love her too
@maivănĐinh agree😭❤ she's very charming.💫
their vocals, their visuals, it's all on point, now I'm wondering why ant!s exist? this group is literally a whole package.
*ÆSPA is inspiration! For all if I got 4K subscribers!! mom will definitelyy buy me a mic for my cover songs!! Every help is appreciated GUYS*
Theyre jealous 💀✋
haters are needed just to be a proof that aespa has been bigger in 3 months old
kzhead.info/sun/hbmrY5upeHehdqM/bejne.html
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help
Ning can’t reach the chair at the back so she just stand up ksksksks
Good eye lmaoooo
@@bumbumreideu8164 well hahaha
cause she's just 163-164cm tall
😂cute
OMG HAHAHAHA CUTE
I really love the dance break and karina kills it so smooth! And ningning's voice and her hair luv it and giselle 's black hair shes so pretty and winter's visual omg aespa is the best stan aespa💙💙
Popular Opinion: Every member of Aespa can be main vocalist
main*
I think giselle and karina can only be lead vocalists
@@imjustthin4698 same, unless they train for a while for it, i think the best they can be are average, maybe slightly above average lead vocals
kzhead.info/sun/hbmrY5upeHehdqM/bejne.html
@@justcupcakeaka yeag
can we start acknowledging karina's talents instead of her visual or body proportions, i know she has both but lets appreciate her talents more
She really have unique yet powerful voice 🤧💙
I love her voice so much, it's so powerful and beautiful
So agree let's appreciate her graceful dance, a dancer said she's probably had a ballet training before.
*can we appreciate her bully skills and her ugly visuals*
@@vc5831 The audacity of this person. You're just a troll. Lol. Stay pressed 🤣
we agree that aespa consisting of beautiful girls but damn karina is being extra stunning here?????
The perfect all-rounder artist, beautiful girl inside and out with lovable personality, and a sweetheart. The best leader, best girl, no one else but Karina.
Ningning haven't showed her POWER MAIN VOCALIST Title yet, so they're arguably all main vocals as of the moment, but let's wait till Ningning won't holdback her skills!
*aespa untalented ugly flops, pre recorded vocals, ugly visuals, ITZY can't relate*
@@vc5831 sher mo lang
@@vc5831 maobah, bagon ulo mo ron
@@vc5831 you’re talking to yourself? poor u, may God bless u
@@vc5831 Please don't drag ITZY here. Just stfu and leave if you just wanted to hate aespa.
Everyone: commenting on each member and their vocals Me: Still surprised as to how this also has a mini choreo.
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html My cover dance BTS "ON"
@frozenbananas for me too
@frozenbananas I've thought so as well since the first stage! This reminds of OOTN stages and vibes.
karina so pretty omg
I like Winter's voice the most
Ok but Ningning on her new short hair is like an innocent princess
Ikr!!! She's so pretty!!
She’s baby princess
Karina has everything like wow. She also wants to songwrite and produce too, literally the ultimate ace of kpop ggs.
Agree.. agree..
ikrr she's a hardworker, in highschool or maybe middleschool i forgot. she keep joining many addcourse she study english, math, chinesse, sing, she also have time to joining school festival or idk what's that to dance. omg she's ACE
jisoo blackpink
Jisoo? Is that you?😂😂😂😂
The biggest visual Kim jisoo is talking about our gorgeous visual Karina imagine these two standing together a blast of visuals
WINTER SO GORGEOUS
Winter is such an angel
Winter is so stunning with mellow and sweet tone 😭
Our fairy goddess 💘
i love Karina's vocals i didn't know that she's a really good vocalist
She used to go vocal academy before joining SM
Sm makes sure all their idols can sing.
*she can't sing like the rest of aespa, she is bully and even Kai don't like her, aespa untalented flops*
@@vc5831 Kai told you that??
@@vc5831 Kai don't like you at all. You're a toxic fans. Saying Karina is not talented.Lol. Jealous too much? 😂
Why nobody is talking about Giselle's vocals, Hello she snapped!
Aespa and SM really slapping the haters in their faces that *SM is a vocal powerhouse*
This vocals...This visuals...are insane
ningning her voice,her face,her hair, her everything is perfect she is queen
i love her
Perfect
She's perfect 💙
@@ameerafaras2762 me tooo
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html . My cover dance BTS "ON"
KARINA THE ACE OF AESPA
I love this style of song. It's so elegant and beautiful. I'm so glad they did this. They can really showcase their vocals without all the bells and whistles.
Winter's voice is so soothing, I love it so much.
ningning's short hair is killing me!! shes so cuuute
Agreed ✅
I agree 2!
It looks even better than before
Yeah that's awesome
she is maaad beautiful!
the way ningning made a mistake at 4:23 then she glared at karina. THIS IS SO CUTE
Karina bodygoals banget, suara gisele suka banget, winter cantik, ningning so cute..
Winter vocals are so good.She could be the main vocal in another group
I think all of them can be main vocal in other group
SM thing💅
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help
SM lead vocalists are standard main vocals for other groups
Can we stop with the main vocal in other group thing? Well, they're not in another group, they're in aespa. I know it's a great compliment, but it's kind of offensive to other main vocals of the other groups. It's like you're saying this person can out match you all. It may be true, but still.
For a long time watching WINTER, if you guys would agree. She resembles TAEYEON and JESSICA. She’s like TAEYEON AND JESSICA in one body. She’s like the combination of the two.
she iss!!! omg
YESS
nahhhh
I think it to bro
Kirain gw doang yg mkir gni
네 명 다 음색 미쳤네...진짜 스엠의 역대급 걸그룹인 것 같다. 비쥬얼, 실력, 매력 최고😘
Ningning's likeness to Bada's vocals is even more apparent with this kind of song
The stage, the vocals, the girls, their visuals, the background, the mics, the outfits, the lighting, the camera angles, the make up, and yeah everything is perfect.
Karina's visual is just WOW. Like every angle looks amazing. I bet the camera man is having an easy job handling Karina's shoot.
Hmmm....is not easy for his heart then xD
You can't take your eyes off of Karina.
she reminds me of Jessica, Krystal & Joy ❤️that one member beside the main visual & center (beside Yoona, Sulli, Irene & Winter) that you cant take your eyes of
True
@@SoAnneDiary I'm sorry to tell you but winter ranking in every visual list never goes higher than karina. Even in recent discussion on pann, when ppl were choosing big3 visual representative, it is yoona, irene and karina (krystal and sulli too). So i wonder wheres these ifans refer to when they said winter is the visual. As far as i knew, thts not official and even i cant find it in any korean articles site in naver, namu tht stated it. Even winter is the visual, knetz never have high praise abt tht compared to how they praise karina.
@@artsistic_2273 yes sm never confirmed winter is their official visual and Karina fit 90% k beauty standards while winter fit 80% fit and also Karina is just like Jennie she get that Korean visual and western beauty mix.
Who loves Ningning? 💕
Me
Meeeeee
I’m really happy on the amount of effort that sm put into aespa’s stages.
AESPA CAN LITERALLY KILL ME WITH THOSE VOCALS
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help.
Giselle is so pretty and talented, I like her 1st verse the best. Aslo, black hair highlights her beauty further ✨
She really is 🤗
All rounders everywhere aespa are powerful
You know when a group is that great when EVERYONE IS VOCALLY GIFTED
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa album at 2k pls help
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html . My cover dance BTS "ON"
i love the beat and overall vibe of the song. AND THEN THOSE VOCALS!
kzhead.info/sun/hbmrY5upeHehdqM/bejne.html
*aespa queen of lip sync and no talent, ITZY sub vocal out singed their main vocal*
@Cloud bby *the only bad thing here is aespa's voices and face*
good to see another Hawaiian 🤙🏻
@@vc5831 even itzy voice kinda ugly maybe just Lia can singing but others?? No talent for singing 😌
Winter is so beautiful in this stage! I love her voice too!
This song really made me become a fan of them. Their debut song I didn't like so much, but in this one they show all their vocal talent and I really loved it. They are very talented.T-T Winter is so sweet.
welcome to family luvv
Winter has an angel voice 🥺👼🏻
I swear to god winter’s visual is no joke
True...
Ikr!!
Yeah, she's getting prettier everyday 💘
True
Yeah she's always pretty like princess
Each member deserves praise because each of them is very talented🔥 AESPA = ACEPA
The stylists didn't missed on all the forever performances. They look so pretty and adorable, you can focus on their vocals fully and it ties the whole feeling of the song together.
Their vocals are no joke
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa merch at 2k pls help
Indeed!
Winter's voice reminds me of Boa's soft voice
maybe karina
@@mamiwa814 no.winter vocals is more similar to BoA
전 맴버 음색 미쳣구요... 갓스파~~
WINTER MY QUEEN, MY EVERYTHING 😍💖 AESPA I LOVE YOU!
Winter’s vocal is like her name. It’s feels wintry and cold. It’s like a cool breeze blowing while you’re sitting in the beach watching the stars and moon on night sky.
Winter can be a main vocalist if she was in any other group Ningning vocals are no joke Karina and Giselle can also sing so well they would be lead vocalists or also main They are a perfect group
They are Will be a main vocalist if they are in itzy
@@yourfuture5307 don't bring up itzy, we don't want another fanwar
@@yourfuture5307 no they would not. lia and yeji are great vocalist. and at least they have amazing dancers and stage presence 😉
@@yourfuture5307 WTF why are you here? Stop spreading hate and starting fan wars!
@Don't call me Kpopers stop it! You just want to start fanwars! U commented before that karina is prettier than Jisoo, Rose is the most unpopular member in BP! But no one cares! U can love Aesop’s but don’t give hate to other groups! (I seriously don’t get why they can’t just love a group, but they have to start fanwars and hate on other groups 😔)
Lets make this 1M
Omg their vocals are so good im literally crying what??
æspa : WINTER-KARINA-GISELLE-NINGNING★ DANCE✓ VOCALS✓ VISUAL✓ MV✓ PERFORMANCE✓ æspa is the no.1 next generation of KPop! -ningning is cute with short hair..also winter,karina,n giselle are cute tho! THEY'RE AMAZING!! luvv ~ ~
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa merch at 2k pls help
Agree 😌❤
karina small face and big pretty eyes her face is so animated and her body is perfection and her voice is so unique!
She's so perfect ✨
She's a goddess ♡
Yeah she is like a barbie
@@lutfiyaazzah6871Agree
@@lutfiyaazzah6871 right just say she’s really pretty and go
Winter's voice is so pleasant...
slow delicate music + Aespa equals... perfection
Haters will not stop bashing Aespa even when the girls sings in live performances because they are threaten that if they hear their live vocals it will make them more crazier thinking of any kind of hate to throw to these talented girls!
Yesssss
Seriously, I'm tired of reading to their complains like "Aespa is not singing live" or anything. Can't we just appreciate their hardwork?
@@ramirezjovelyn3583 yes I agree like they're just rookies and let the prove themselves and there will always be a room for improvement for all likeeee people what is not understandable there?
Guys I post Aespa edits if you mind my mom will buy me Aespa merch at 2k pls help
@@wade_adams we'll support you!
In the future this group will be a legendary in SM💖
MYs, Let's make this 1M v13ws. æs~fighting! ♡
I literally can't take my eyes off of winter and karina.
Karina’s beauty and proportions aren’t human... and she had a good voice on top of that
That's why antis are so pressed about her
i agree
Agreeeeee
kzhead.info/sun/obqrfppwiXZ-eZE/bejne.html My cover dance BTS "ON"
Yeah 😍😍
looking at karina the whole time she's so perfect, her unique voice and the way she dances
Karina telling us that she's all arounder. I hope in their next comeback Giselle and Karina will rap. Imagine how many fans will be wreck 😂
@CHANYEOL’S FINGERNAILS She’s never done plastic surgery and was popular predebut..
@@viraljisoo ikr. She's an ulzzang ppl really can't accept the truth
@CHANYEOL’S FINGERNAILS stay pressed.....
@CHANYEOL’S FINGERNAILS Yes, I've seen it all. She's still so pretty. What are you talking about she got. Do you have proof? Please, let's us see it first. Clearly you're just jealous 😂
1M where are you??
Those visuals and vocals are beyond. Stan aespa. Forever.