The Monster Behind Gender Theory, and the Atrocious Lie He Based It On
Hallow: Try Hallow for 3 months FREE: hallow.com/jordan
Watch the full episode here: Ep. 347 - • Gender Insanity and Pa...
Listen as Dr. Jordan B. Peterson and Dr. Miriam Grossman walk us through the horrific yet true story behind the Reimer twins. The atrocity of their upbringing, branded as a successful experiment by Dr. John Money, was used as the bedrock of gender and identity ideology that has captured the western world today.
Dr Peterson's extensive catalog is available now on DailyWire+: utm.io/ueSFn
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Premium Podcast - jordanbpeterson.supercast.com/
Newsletter: linktr.ee/DrJordanBPeterson
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life: jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Blog: jordanbpeterson.com/blog
Podcast: jordanbpeterson.com/podcast
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
#JordanPeterson #JordanBPeterson #DrJordanPeterson #DrJordanBPeterson #DailyWirePlus #podcast #news #TheJordanBPetersonPodcast
What always stunned me about this is that humans have been castrating male animals for thousands of years and it doesn't turn them into female animals.
Never seen gay boars after castrating them young for softer meat...
Eunuchs were a huge part of many cultures around.
@@robertd2055they were still eunuchs, not women though.
@@Tof235the animals??
steers , geldings fat dogs
As a psychology student in the early 80s I attended a lecture by John Money. He openly bragged about his “success” at gender reassignment and talked extensively about these twins. After the lecture we went to dinner at a local restaurant where I sat directly across from John Money and we had a conversation during which he constantly alluded to sexual acts, genitalia, odd attractions, and fetishes. It made me very uncomfortable as a young student which he seemed to enjoy. I remember it to this day. I am 62 years old. In my opinion this man was truly evil.
The Dark History of Transgenderism... kzhead.info/sun/mLWDddN_naGLjXk/bejne.html
FYI * alluded
He sounds like an evil perverted person
That is horrible.
I'm sure there were less options then just going online and reporting a concern to a school or academic governance board, more people need to stop dismissing & making excuses for 'odd' behavior. Speak up. Do so with caution and respect in case you are wrong. But no one innocent would care and would know you are protecting kids.
This video should be played in schools all over the world. Should be absolutly mandatory. Could prevent an incredible amount of mental illness and so much suicide. This angers me so much
Oh yes, people struggling with their identity will lose all of those feelings and become completely healthy after hearing about the misdeeds of one moron.
the amount of kids getting actual triggered would be overwhelming and cause a chaotic response of distress some even extremely violent and it stem from the very real chance they have been sexually abused for years in silence too. So start at home, make sure the closest people to you are informed and then come together to face the school board because they are following the whole agenda too
The fact that some psychologists "ok" this mental illness and do not claim it as such is so far beyond disgusting!!
Politicians need to watch this too! It should be mandatory
Calm down. Making it mandatory may necessarily not adjust the slide. Humans ought to acknowledge truth with some grace lest the chaos will survive to come around and destroy humans. In the absence of wisdom, madness and chaos dominate.
I’m running out of words to express my utter disgust with all of this madness. It’s heartbreaking and evil.
Absolutely friend.When Jordan PETERSON started using the word "evil" I thought he was exaggerating.I should of known better .Those poor boys and their parents. FUCK.
And just incase it was a once off failure of a good theary, Jazz Jennings. became another experiment
it is a funnel into legalized pedophilia
His brother died of an overdose, he shot himself, his mother attempted suicide, and his father was a hopeless alcoholic. That entire family was destroyed by this. It’s unbelievably sad.
And this family story is considered an outstanding success 😮
This is a reminder to not play with TRUTH. Sooner or later it'll hit you back.
Destroyed just because hugo strange was a very horny person.
Two-time New York Times Bestseller author and outstanding physician Christian Northrup spoke of her early years as an intern in which she had to perform circumcisions , she found herself horrified that we did this to baby boys and refused to take part in it anymore. BTW , she told this story on a YT talk she gave about the cure for the most recent pandemic … She had been super successful , had her own segment on Oprah and then her own show but when she spoke out against the above they destroyed her career. Fortunately she had already done quite well and was ok to retire . But what they did to her name was sickening .
@@lisacolbert5987This is unfortunately all too common
In 1983, this case was presented to my psychology class as a great success... what a disgusting lie. How that poor boy was made to suffer is beyond evil.
Disgusting how the left’s core beliefs are based on lies and intimidation: gender reassignment, abortion, Covid etc.
I have to ask if this was truly an accident or something nefarious and intentional?
@@wjdyr6261 he was a pervert ,
...there is something undefinably wicked about the whole trans movement, or any movement that promotes a lifestyle that does not end in offspring
I don't find people who simply don't want reproduce wicked.
I heard about this story in the 1990s. I was shocked. This story should be aired every day on all the news networks. 24/7
The fact that this lie is not realized more is insane.
My sister saved her son from John Money when her son was born with a condition that kept his penis from forming properly. He pressured her terribly but she refused to let them do a sex assignment surgery. He’s a happy married man now. It’s unreal how far this whole debacle has gone over the past 40 years.
Her angels are with her. God bless her for protecting her family.
And now mentally ill/traumatized people use this as a way to further escape into madness.
" Oh man , my finger has a malformation " " YEAH , LETS CHOP ALL OF YOUR FUCKING HAND SO WE CAN CALL YOU A DIFFERENT THING "
@deborahpruitt2773, Your sister is truly a wise woman for successfully following her instinct to protect her son from harm - ESPECIALLY when pressured by Dr. Money with all the gravitas and prestige of Johns Hopkins backing him up! There are moments in everyone's life when one has to stop and carefully consider if a conclusion is correct, or if an action is truly the best course given the circumstances. During those moments, we must ask ourselves if what is proposed makes sense! Thank God your sister thought carefully and realized that consenting to an irreversible surgery on her baby was not going to solve anything, but would have led them down a path of pain and tremendous regret. Parents are choosing now to WAIT if their son is diagnosed with hypospadia: that there is no harm done to allow their child to remain as he was born, letting him grow and mature so he can decide for himself whether he wants to consider surgery. As long as an infant is peeing adequately, without any obstruction, there is less harm done by waiting until he's older before discussing intervention. This includes decision-making involving some medications as well. If it isn't an emergency, do your research and ask questions. Don't let anyone shame you for asking for as much information as possible before you make a decision. Dr. Money's story is a cautionary tale we can learn from. Remember, "First, do no harm."
Thanks GOD ALMIGHTY for your sister and his son
As a child I never thought about my gender. I was playing, having fun, living. Nowadays we have adults pressuring kids on their gender. “What are you? What do you feel like inside? Nothing can happen until we address this HUGE issue ?!?”
depopulation agenda at work, Covid, gender "swapping", estrogenic chemicals in BPA etc. etc. etc.
Exactly. I was making forts in the hills and playing piano. It’s so weird that this issue has become so front and centre for them. I would have found it overwhelming.
Toddlers cant even define abstract concepts, they identify what they can point at and eventually learn its name because its in front of them. They have no notion of who they are or question it. They're just there and what matters is what they can eat, chew or play with at that age. Their reasoning capability is that of a smart dog.
Nobody is more obsessed with this stuff than you freaks.
"if I knew it earlier it would have been so much better" probably worst way to think, things come naturally, you dont need to be unicorn, everyone struggles growing up, hitting their puberty.
And just two years ago I was sitting in an intro to sociology class at my university and the professor was trying to convince us all that gender is a spectrum and of the validity of trans-sexual surgery. He didn’t bring up this case but it was the same idea. And so many of the students in the room were nodding enthusiastically. I was so disgusted and furious.
And yet, David's whole family became a statistic that sociologist study.
The twins case had zero to do with transsexuals. Educate yourself.
@@angel794one of the premises of this so called gender theory is that it is a social construct. Something we are taught. And yet, all the teaching in the world didn't help that boy's body to become female
@@angel794Apparently, you need to educate yourself. The male who was transitioned after his genital accident was technically a ‘transsexual: ‘Being born one sex but after castration raised, socialized and groomed as the other-for the research benefit of a sick, narcopath psycho definitely qualifies as transexual. Maybe you don’t understand the ‘trans’ component…
@@angel794In which way did they have nothing to do with transsexuals? The boy, David, clearly went through a gender transitioning surgery although certainly in hopes of having him be as least disabled as he could since yes, not having genitals is indeed very much a disability.
Jordan was swallowing his tears, what hell these family lived through each day. May God hold them dear. evil people have no mercy
You are evil if you have no mercy
Or no humility
Or ability to make a break
An ex of mine (a woman I still respect immensely) was going for her doctorate in early childhood psychology around 2013, just before the gender identity crisis really came to life. She left the field entirely during the middle of her doctorate upon finding out just how corrupt and flimsy most psychiatric research is. I was actually sitting in taking some of the courses as an observer as she asked intelligent and probing questions about methodology and ethics , only to be met with eventual stone-walling once it became clear that some number of the sources being used for the doctorate program were utterly manufactured or highly manipulated. Disgusting levels of corruption in psychology.
You're correct. My husband used to be in the counseling/ mental health field. The LACK of research has trouble me for a couple of decades. I don't trust anything from that branch of medicine.
Psychiatry, by and large, is a "profession" that has managed to fabricate "mental illnesses" which they tell the public are caused by brain abnormalities/imbalances for which they have no definitive proof. Any patient who is diagnosed with any kind of deviation from what a psychiatrist sees as "normal" behaviour is likely to be given one or more psychotropic drugs which they will probably become dependent on for the rest of their lives. Psychotropic drugs are neurotoxins (see evidence from Dr. Peter Breggin). This is the most efficacious way to treat people who are only suffering from existential dilemmas and have nowhere else to turn. I am glad that at least some people can see the charade. "It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society." Jiddu Krishnamurti ·
The sad fact of the matter is that research costs money, and the overwhelming majority of funding is given with predetermined expectations. It really soured me on my own experience.
Unfortunately,not in psychology only but many other fields
Psychology is a narrative field, not a scientific one. You don't take in teh concepts and submit to them as object facts or physical laws. The main issue is people want to be told, they want to be seen, they want to be fixed. And so, they are prey. And there will be a predatopr there to mold them as they wish.
The weirdest part about this story is that in sexuality and gender classes they still told this research as if it was successful and evidence of gender as a social construct. I remember learning this in my lecture and thinking…ummm so you just told us a horrible experiment on an innocent person who ended up killing themselves and framed it as a good thing??? This was absolutely a horrifying experiment. They should be using this as an example of extreme malpractice
That's why we call them Demonrats...
I've wondered how it is presented now. That is terrible, but unsurprising, to hear. The entire Reimer family was utterly devastated by John Money's evil. The entire world should condemn both John Money and Alfred Kinsey as the monsters they were.
This is not malpractice, this is child abuse, this is psychological torture, he should've been put in jail. This is just diabolical.
@@yamiletsoler3464 it’s all those things..including medical malpractice. You can add your list of charges without diminishing another.
Someone else on a gender critical group I'm part of said the same thing. Their lecturer had no idea of the actual outcome and they had to be schooled on it from them. They had to put them right.
So sad. My heart goes out to the boy and his family. We must stop this evil. And schools today are normalizing this.
i remember first hearing about this case YEARS ago, it is infuriating. and it is absolutely heartbreaking.
If you are a student, and you’re watching this, PLEASE start speaking out about this when teachers lie about this case. It sucks but it falls to you to stand up and publicly address this in front of other students during class so they don’t get sucked into the lies. What the teachers and schools are doing is not only toxic or negligence-it’s ABUSE. You are being abused!
Oh please calm down. Being lied to isn't abuse.
@@k-lab3824If the lie leads to harm it is abuse. It's mental abuse.
@@americawaters4257 okay victim. If thats what you want to be...
@@k-lab3824 Very mature. Dispute it with facts.
@@americawaters4257 I just did. Victim mentality is a well known psychological disposition.
Thank you for bringing this to more people. The psychological and physical damage being caused by the "trans" movement to our youth is incalculable.
Ironically, this dude wasn’t trans. He was forced into this. And his experience was very similar to that of an actual trans person, minus the abuse. In the sense that he was raised as the wrong gender. That’s how trans people feel. This is why trans people transition. In this case, it was just the other way around.
@@practicalphilosophy301 You seem to be missing the point my guy. The very notion of “trans” people comes from this experiment. If not for Money and this failed experiment, there would be no “trans” anything. There would be what there is now, people suffering from a mental illness, gender dysphoria.
@@practicalphilosophy301 Right, but many people Transitioning now will do so on the basis of Money’s fake research and ideas being fed to them in colleges and clinics. What this video suggests is that the theory is based on a lie.
Behavior of baby boys and girls is different within a few weeks after birth and baby girls look at the mother s lot more than baby boys. This biological difference is in built by nature.
@@practicalphilosophy301 Trans people are not being raised in the wrong gender (unless they transition). Trans people have a psychological problem, not a gender problem. This was not just the other way around.
This is not only sad but atrocious, despicable, appalling, and more. How is this information not sufficient to make changes and STOP the mutilation?! How?! Rethorical.
Because it literally proves you can't brainwash kids into being transgender. If someone feels like a boy, you shouldn't force them to go through life as a girl simply because they don't have a penis. It's not going to work and will only ruin their lives. So how is this information not sufficient to stop transphobia?
“Follow the science” right? So unbelievably sad… and so many victims still to this day.
YEAH it's sad. we should really listen to the children and what they need, and let them decide for themselves.
Scientists can be curel, people were just test subjects for him
No. We should follow science. Science is the way to the future. What this is, is pseudoscience. Bs science from a mad scientist.
There seriously needs to be accountability in mental health field
Tell that to a narcissist who wants to exercise malevolent power over the meek.
Nuremberg trials A child can’t give consent
There is. The inmates run the asylum. That is why I stay in private practice.
@@DieGlobalists they are working hard to make children sexually literate because then they can consent. The courts are captured .
And 'jail ' time
The absolute cruelty of neutering children and the psychopaths doing this is beyond evil!
And there is one side of the political spectrum that supports and encourages this. And REAL Conservatives aren't on that side!!!!
@@blast3613 no one wants to neuter children. That would be crazy 😵💫 or are you talking about ppl wanting acces to hormone therapy pre-puberty? Does that count as neutering?
@@DieFarbeLila88 That's effectively sterilizing children
@@christerjakobsen8107 not so sure. There is no gender-affirming surgery happening and if you stop taking the Hormons you go through a belated cis-puberty. I am not saying that everything will go compleatly back to normal - because I don`t know enough about the topic. But that`s still not a Sterilisation. Organs are still intact, hormone flow goes back to normal.
@@DieFarbeLila88 The so-called "belated cis-puberty" is just cope. You only get one puberty, and to screw with it is to lose it.
When she said earlier that he would spend time alone with the twins I knew then 😢.
😦😭
So sad. And really what a twisted person. I wonder how many of his patients faced the same abuse.
I remember being taught this as if it was gospel when I was in middle school back in the early 80s. My teacher was very belittling to anyone who questioned its legitimacy.
I watched the documentary _Dr Money and the Boy with No Penis_ years ago and I just remember sobbing when the fate of both of the boys was revealed. What astounding evil has to be present in the human heart when we’ve allowed our culture to be overtaken by the most objectionable perversion imaginable.
It's still happening every day. Those that are pushing the agenda and profiting off of confused children and adults are the ultimate evil.
"The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?" Jeremiah 17 Some of the worst advice people give to each other unfortunately is "follow your heart", not realising that following the heart is a one-way road to hell. Instead we should all follow Christ who said "I am the way, the truth and the life" "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life."
@@Ria.ray77257 WELL said!! 👏👏👏
@@Ria.ray77257 - I agree with your comment. In addition, I would replace follow your heart with follow the FACTS.
Where can I find that documentary??
The depths of depravity of these monsters who do this to innocent children is beyond evil. They ALL should be in prison. Parents, teachers, therapists, and especially the doctors.
Incomprehensible, ineffable, unfathomable and unimaginable white hot flames, where the worm dieth not and where the fires are *NEVER* quenched = eternal damnation / perdition is where John Money ended up and ANY who have continued his so beyond words so profoundly wickedly evil. So i agree with you how dumb-founding Marinara Trench deep this moral depravity it is to do this to the innocent precious children... but even more so this is ineffable abomination to our Creator what the Antichrist seduces mankind bit by bit to do as though this is not at all so paramount sick-minded degenerate heinous maleficence , so praise forevermore the authentic austere Scriptural God/Jesus THAT NO ONE ESCAPES His judgment.
If we question anything they assert is true,we face lawsuits&being put in their insane asylums for....."Denying Science!"
You say prison. I say incinerator.
"He who fights with monsters should look to it that he himself does not become a monster. And if you gaze long into an abyss, the abyss also gazes into you."
@@tyraelpl You do not compromise with evil, you destroy it. To allow evil to exist is to be evil oneself.
😢 I am so so so sorry for David and his family. They have been victims of an egotistic, egocentric, manipulative narcisist of a MONSTER. R.I.P❤
I remember learning about this in class. I always thought people were silent because they were obviously horrifed about what happened, looking back its more likely they were silent because they didn't know if they were allowed to feel horrified.
This is horrifying. The worst thing is Money destroyed a family who were in desperate need of help and he was celebrated for doing it
Has there ever been a movie made of this story? It should be done so as to shock the transgender children movement to their very core. But alas, one gets the feeling that some parents with evil, sick minds use their children to gain attention and sympathy. Of course David's parents were innocents, duped by an evil doctor so the above reference does not apply to them.
The doctor who botched the circumsion (something fucking priests manage to do on a daily basis) destroyed the family.
What does that say about the people running our institutions…?
sounds like standard doctor behavior
@@bigol9223 That's not true ,the majority of drs are good ,sick people live in this world 😢
I am a 54 year old male born with hypospadias. I don't know how severe, but at ages 5 and 6 I had reconstructive plastic surgery to correct the opening of the urethra. I remember at age six the catheter being removed after a week in the hospital and the sensation of "peeing razor blades" when I urinated. Through the years I have had numerous urethrosplasties and DVIUs to remove scar tissue and or reconstruct my urethra. This includes grafts of the buccal mucosa. In 2014, I opted for a urothrectomy to route my urine through the perineum. In 2021, I was diagnosed with bladder cancer no doubt due to the numerous surgeries, infections and chronic inflammation. I had a radical cystectomy, prostectomy and urothrectomy last year. I am stage 4 bladder cancer having completed cisplatin/gemzar and now on Opdivo. Last week I was in the ER with deep vein thrombosis and a pulmonary embolism - due in part to the drugs, abdominal surgery and cancer. I hope someone or some parent reads this and considers carefully what costs they may later face when the start cutting on their parts.
I am so sorry.
You are a fighter keep going! Bless you!
Sorry we must fight this crazy in africa
OMGOODNESS prayers for you in earnest 😢
May God grant you speedy recovery and peace of mind ❤
This is disgusting. Ppl should have been sued into oblivion for malpractice. Starting with the ppl who botched the circumcision, to the abomination who came up with this theory. And his estate should still be sued to force this imto widesprrad public knowledge and to force publications to publish recantations of his pApEr. And anyone using this case to try justifying doing this to more kids should be as well. And jailed.
THANK YOU for shedding such much-needed light on the darkness of what’s going on right now. It makes sense now seeing that it is rooted in pure psychopathy.
This woman is brave beyond words, glad she is speaking out.
Why is she brave? Isn’t this pretty common knowledge at this point?
Yes, she is brave. God bless her and keep her safe, in Jesus's name, Amen
This was public knowledge back in the early 2000s when a documentary came out and even Oprah talked about it. Now, few people are willing to talk about this case because of the political blowback.
It was public knowledge back then, but taboo knowledge now...
How is it brave? What’s to be afraid of?
As a teenager I remember watching an Oprah Winfrey talk show episode where she had David Reimer on. That is when I first heard of transgenderism although it wasn't called that back then. I felt so shocked, horrified and sorry for what had happened to David and his parents but then I naively comforted myself with the thought that at least the world knows about this now, and so it won't ever happen again. How wrong I was. What took me by total surprise though, was not just that the world hadn't learned anything from poor David Reimer, but that they actively ignored his huge warning story and all his unnecessary suffering. The world had ignored it, ignored the doctors evil acts and deliberately ignored all the clear negatives and abuse of transing kids. Not just ignored it though, no far worse than that, the transing of kids actually became encouraged to the hilt and those who stood up for kids to not get abused like that are the ones who get demonised. This is the work of Demons to flip such an obvious evil into a perceived good. Trans-ing kids is pure child abuse. It's origin is in powerful pedophile's and pedophile doctors. It is as satanic as it gets.
I saw the Oprah Winfrey segment on KZhead, but had known of the Reimer tragedy previously. The mother had allowed Money to experiment on her sons. Of course, Oprah wanted the scoop of the remaining twin forgiving his tearful mother on her show. What a cringey, outrageous expectation on top of all that poor young man's other problems, but Oprah was there to cash in on it.
I don't think you understand the issue very well.
Yes, I saw that Oprah episode too. I was wondering where I had heard this story. Very tragic. These people are monsters.
What’s weird is apparently Oprah has forgotten this story or pretends so because she seems to support the whole trans ideology. She doesn’t even need the money now.
@@mon_avis2978 what would one search to find said video?
This story is so sad and infuriating. Those poor kids, poor family.
Would it be fair to say that the medical industry regarded this disastrous treatment as being "SAFE AND EFFECTIVE"? For decades
This story was taught in a Human Sexuality course in college that I attended a few months ago. However, the course completely left out the end of this story. When I looked into the story further, I was enraged that the course material blatantly obfuscated the true results of this evil "experiment".
If I recall correctly, both twins killed themselves.
@@lyndseywilliams3618 but Bruce/Brenda/David has a KZhead channel?
@John Nunn it must be fake because they are both dead now
@@lyndseywilliams3618 That is correct.
a few months ago? so we haven't learnt anything? i am increasing holding western science in low regard, it seems too easily corrupted.
The fact that so many boys and girls in developed countries are having trouble with simply being boys and girls is a tragic sign that something has gone horribly wrong with those socities.
* in usa
They are not actually having any problems they are being programmed to think they are having problems gender theory etc marxism etc.
This issue it became like a virus
@@maryanneazzopardi5469 Mind Virus, like with much of everything these days.
“Tragedy” doesn’t go far enough to describe the experience of that family like she said, but “monster” as used in the description of this video also doesn’t go far enough to describe John Money
I'd like to add that I feel that seniors in high school should (with their parents' permission) be shown a film of what a state of the art circumcision process for a newborn baby looks like, to be adequately informed before becoming parents.
I learned about this in a college class. My professor tried to defend this monster and it pissed me off so much
God save us from narcissistic nut-cases posing as professors.
Professors can be biased therefore creating lessons with psuedo-educational services. Just wrong. Agreed.
the whole education system is being wrecked by people like that @@dare3575
I learned about it in Psych 101 back in the late 80's. My professor hated Freud, and he presented John Money truthfully. It was here I first heard of how disgusting Kinsey was.
Most current "Professors" are motivated by money, not facts or science
'The wasp factory'. It's a novel I read in the mid 80's by Ian Banks. It might be inspired by this story. If there are still people out there who read; you want to read this one. Great story, well written, very graphic. I guarantee, you will be blown away.
Read this as well. Books insane
I remember this case, tore me to pieces with sadness. There were findings in Izrael kibbutzim that showed that gender is nor a matter of appointment.
Hi. Interested in these kibbutzim studies. Do you have a reference?
I cried from beginning to end, and now we have parents willingly, "educatedly" putting their children through this hell.
So true. Its like indoctrination.
This guy is satanic, get rid of him, before he does more harm
Disgraceful to allow this
Did you assume the fairy-tale conditioning that all parents (average) are always good? They are not. It’s not realistic for all families to be good., and the corruption inherent in the human flesh makes a portion of families “do bad things to their kids” even if they knew (in their minds) or acknowledge they are good people to their social groups. Male and female genders are not products made by social constructs. If you had to theoretically create a person from scratch, hypothetically, The physical, mental, emotional, and self of the individual , has components that dictate gender. The doctor that the lady is talking about in the video, he was wrong and sinful. Social constructs are built by humans and not the inverse of that idea. People are born while social constructs are sustained prior generations. Lesbians, gays, and transgender people, are naturally born and made that way by god… Attacking them is equivalent to attacking the innocent. Im not attacking you, ThePitaPaz. This is my response to your post and the point of the video. I don’t agree with Mr Jordan views. He’s a Gemini. A majority of them will pretend to do good, but in reality, they will commit sins and deny it 99.9% of the time… i e Mr Trump.
I find it personallly interesting how this larger tragedy began with an unnecessary violation of a childs body with the excuse of "phimosis" which is something children regularly have and the fact is only in the west, especially America does such a common and largely inconsequential condition get prescribed a complete amputation of healthy bodily tissue for a condition that typically goes away on its own. Imagine if circumcision was a last resort, this would have never occured. Too bad we don't care about childrens rights. I mean, if we can't protect our own children from the medical institution cutting off their healthy body parts what hope did we have to stop them from doing trans surgeries?
As a person born with an intersex medical condition, I cannot express how much I hate Money and his horrible ideas. David deserved so much better than everything that happened to him from the circumcision, to his parents thinking a boy could be turned into a girl, to the things Money inflicted on him. Doctors really need to keep their hands off children unless medically absolutely necessary.
I can't imagine how tough your life must have been having an intersex medical condition. I learned about it through my medical education but it was never taught or brought up as the solution to pick a sex based on what you want but instead the sex organs that should have been is based on whether are not you had the Y chromosome. I hope you find peace and healing in your journey.
❤
If you ever choose to to be publicly active, your voice may help many others speak out against the ideology that feeds off of Money's ideas.
Bruce??
now imagine being born with healthy anatomy and having that healthy anatomy removed because ignorant parents sought the advise of ignorant doctors who normalized child abusive practices that stem from ignorant zealots who went around encouraging you cut healthy body parts off your boys and girls.
Thank you, for the work you do, and for being here.
This is one of my biggest concerns as a parent, to protect my children's rights in a world that wants to brainwash them into believing the status quo
I'm an identical twin this story makes me so angry. My brother was born blind and has cerebral palsy so bad he was wheelchair bound and could barely speak. So what if one of them was missing parts. This story would be like my parents breaking my legs and blinding me, because a doctor said its what they needed to do. They could have both lived there lives as brothers. Maybe a little different but still. I use past tense when I speak about my identical twin because sadly he passed away. My brother had a happy life. In spite of all the challenges life gave him. He looked forward to getting home from school so he could lose himself in the music he liked. He loved the elevator because when it moved that initial jolt made muscles move that would normally be paralyzed. Normally I don't like being so personal with internet comments, but I want anyone who is reading this to know experts are not always right. They said my brother would likely not live past 8 years old. He lived till he was 16. A lot of it has to do with the love and care my parents and grand parents gave him. Jordan if you read this please keep up your fight. It means so much.
Thank you for sharing this beautiful story about your brother.
Very moving. Thanks for sharing, and best regards to you and your family.
Respect to you and your loving family. I bet your brother was so happy to have you all in his life.
I add my own thanks. It is very important for personal experiences such as yours to be communicated.
Thank you for sharing and continuing the good fight. GOD BE WITH YOU DR. JORDAN PETERSON
As horrific as these events were and are, the real tragedy is how it is being carried on, promoted, normalized, and protected today.
Yes! It's sick and wrong☹️
Dr Money was one Sick MoFo. What’s more Baffling is that this thing happened at all & as you say “How on earth is it happening Today”. First time I’m hearing of this situation however I do live in Australia. David Reimer RIP He’s story needs to be Heard Everywhere so it can be of influence with any Family dealing with this Scurge. Absolute Tragedy Timbodemi I hear you loud & clear. CEM au.
Exactly.
AMEN!
Psychiatry is a disgusting field.
So extricating and sickening to process that this occurred. Angry is beyond an understatement.
I live in a back water country with limited outside knowledge. I heard whispers i about 2001. I finally seen what it was about. Thank you for posting this even though i am a johnny come lately on it.
What a tragically depressing story. The worst part about it is that Money lived without having been held accountable for his actions. Destroyed two lives using his own perverse ideological poison. The family should receive some sort of justice. They gave two of their young to a guy that basically exploited them as his personal guinea pigs, it's sick.
It’s criminal, not just sick.
I hope there’s a special place in hell for John Money.
@@jayjaychadoy9226 And yet feminists still venerate him like a saint, with plaques and buildings named after him.
To be fair, this entire affair ruined the lives of everyone in that family. I think only one or two of them _didn't_ commit suicide or overdose.
He ruined the lives of countless children who went through similar experiences because of his reports of success with this monstrosity of an experiment.
This is a horror story. From the medical error, to multiple child abuse instances, to the deaths. Tragic and cruel.
Listened to the first minute, decided I will not opt for circumcision if I ever have a kid and then closed then quit the internet for the night.
Hes a New Zealander. He donated his art collection to an Art Gallery in Southland, they named a wing after him and the then primeminister opened that wing.
😤
This tragedy and abomination needs to be shared widely .
Oprah Winfrey did share this story, and interviewed Mr. Reimer, and all these years later I still remember. RIP
@@caroaber And yet Oprah Winfrey praised the circumcision of boys to take their foreskin fibroblasts and turn them into facial cream. The reason that children are having gender transition surgeries performed on them is for $$$, the exact same reason as circumcision. Do you oppose the circumcision as much as you oppose gender transition?
100% It's our DUTY to share & teach people that this ENTIRE movement is based on evil & destruction. Innocent people need to be saved at all costs!
There’s a documentary right here on KZhead about their story. kzhead.info/sun/gLmNk9upiWaHZ5E/bejne.html
You can be LGBT and Christian 👨❤️👨
I am in shock. John Money is the absolute personification of evil. It makes sick to the stomach what he has done to this poor family, the twins, and our society.
Where do you think he got the funding for his “research?”
@@srimaddukuri Number 6 knows
"On the morning of 4 May 2004, Reimer drove to a grocery store's parking lot in his hometown of Winnipeg and shot himself in the head with a sawed-off shotgun" This is all I will ever need to know regarding the creditibilty of this weak human.
The evil of Dr. Josef Mengele springs to mind ...
Yes, I'm speechless
"As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised as a Girl" - I read the book in the 90's and never _ever_ forgot about David. If you're interested in David's feelings and thoughts you'd do well to read the book.
Do you have the authors name please
In the UK, cover this in A'level Psychology & Applied Psychology. My class was shocked of this and said why is it not known. I learned about it in a documentary few years previously. It opened up a whole debate. It also crossed into our Sociology class when Transgender topic arose . Only the guys who sat Psychology all spoke up about it in Sociology. Few didnt believe it, after they googled it, class was absolutely silenced. On how deep Money's rabbit hole went regards to David. Money was a true life Frankenstein.
And we have parents across the globe doing the same thing to their children, in the name of "affirming/inclusion" driven by their own narcissism, need for attention and desire to virtue signal. It's horrific.
Many parents who are desperate to help their autistic child, their mentally ill child, their possibly sexually abused child help and are being sold "transition" as a trestment. Or worse, their entirely mentally healthy child who simply doesn't conform to sexist stereotypes, is getting the idea that there is something wrong with them just as they are.
Still plenty of Munchausen's parents around for Big Pharma to harvest from.
Well said!
spot on!
Some unsuspecting parents do it because some so-called “professionals” tell them if the child is not transitioned there’s a 20-25% risk of suicide. Which is another lie first put forward by the first transgender clinic in the Netherlands. The whole ideology has been discredited on so many factual levels.
I cannot believe that everyone involved were not convicted of child abuse
Everyone involved? This was in the 60s, the parents were facing a horrible decision and without knowing better (understandably) and being desperate they put their trust in a psychopathic doctor. It’s not their fault at all in my opinion
@@captainhb I agree. Ignorance is the greatest evil. True knowledge is the only way of life.
They should be but in this Putrid and vile world. You can buy judges politicians sexes and anything you want it is a vile vile world
I can, most lawyers are as evil as Dr Money!
Every muslim or jew who believes this to be a right not to be taken away from them is a child abuser, worse than a pedophile imo. As if your spiritual beliefs could ever justify anything outside of your own delusions, unaccountable wastes of oxygen all of them.
This story hurts my souls. We need sanity in the world again.
This story is gut wrenching. Those poor boys. Both twins were abused by Money. This story is so tragic on all levels. My heart goes out to that family. The parents were misled. medical malpractice is a severe understatement
You said it.
@@georgesjeandenis yes its tragedy that nothing about gender studies or lefty wing ideology its an individual tragedy that says nothing about anything ..there are far more surgeons who do far more damage to people , because they are given protection by "hierarchy" which Jordan loves so much..Money wasn't an academic ...he was a criminal and the family that went along with this bull shit are absolute child abusers and monsters........there was no concept ...he wasn't a theorist ..to see this case as representing any thing to do with any wider issue is evil and stupid beyond belief ... it wasn't a land mark study no one it is shocking that as soon as this "study" was published wasn't immediately reported to the police....this has nothing to do with feminism ..no one with any sense feminists , conservatives ever took this seriously it never became doctrine it had no influence on any field of science ever .........."it was written into the text books of genetics" .....what utter untrue nonsense.
They actually did a SVU episode about this kind of. I’m sure the way they showed the boy finding out was different but still. An they changed the docs name of corse.
Now imagine what conversion therapy by pastors sexually abusing young confused children for years to "pray the gay away" and lying to the parents that "they aren't accepting god" and that they must stay longer. Monsters have lived in robes and crosses for decades misleading parents to feed their young to child hungry christian pastors. "People of god" Hilarious that this video ends with "join our christian app". Keep feeding the monsters. There are way more examples of christian monsters than this one doctor.
money? or is it money to the human doctor as god and lord thinking they bring salvation to the boy. Call it hospital-cult. If they didnt have the public and governments in their hand, they'd be stocking guns like cult-churches do waiting for the attack on doctors.
As a mother, how dare that evil man do that to a human being. Leaves me feeling horrified and empty at the same time. So incredibly sad.
His parents allowed it!
@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 they were totally brainwashed by that monster and the parents were too desperate, not just them many people were brainwashed by this and today also you see what's going on, people are still spewing this gender theory nonsense, it's an utter blasphemy, such disrespect to David Reimer man, but lots of people use this gender theory bullshit for their agenda to brainwash even more people
@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 Back then people looked up to doctors.
@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 Yes they did but I'm sure that it must still have been a horrifying decision to make even in a time when people had an implicit trust in the medical profession.
Doctors were viewed next to God, for Heavens sake. Give these people a brake it backfired on them horribly. They tried doing the best they could for their children, and look what a huge prestigious hospital, world renown, and a specialist Doctor can accomplish! Forever this Monster will be remembered for his vile behavior.
The depth of desperation experienced by his parents that propelled them down this twisted and horrifying path is truly beyond my imagination. Contemplating the colossal weight they were compelled to bear, every minute of their lives overshadowed by the burden of maintaining a facade of lies while raising this boy, is both heartbreaking and unimaginable. The relentless pressure they must have endured seems almost unbearable, making this one of the most horrifying and unfathomable stories I've ever encountered. The sheer emotional toll and the complexities involved in concealing the truth paint a harrowing picture of the challenges this family faced, evoking a profound sense of empathy and sorrow for these people.
You seem to be 'one of the good guys'. Thank you for your humane perspective post .
This story is disgusting. All these doctors should be put in jail.
I saw David on Oprah many years ago and I never forgot him or his story. It was gut wrenching. It’s one of the reasons why I fight this transing of children craze. It’s evil and John Money helped make it possible.
If more people listened to his horrific story, it would be impossible to argue the truth logically.
You mean Ms **”your truth my truth"** Oprah and her crowd knew about this¿? know about this¿?
It is however undeniable that some children themselves believe their inner selves to be of the opposite sex. The problem is adults being unable to know if they will maintain that position for their entire lives. Anyway it is a completely different situation to what has been described here.
Ah, or you can call it psychology. It's not that the field isn't ruined by so many of these things. I remember back inthe early 2010's they had to scrap 1/3th of all literature in the field as it was based on this ridiculous laugable study that was completely wrong with falsified data. And it's not that last century was any better. Psych. Facilities were basically nice words for experimental torture houses.
@@worrywart1311 .. I have never encountered one child that believes he/ she is opposite of their biological sex. There were girls that were “ Tom boys”, but usually grew out of it before the end of high school.A few gay kids, but none that thought they were the opposite sex…. I have always been skeptical. I believe half of what I see and none of what I hear.I would warn that there are many in the LGBTQIA++2(?) promoting, what they call “ facts “, but are not. Miriam Grossman refers to it as a “ belief system “. Much of this “ belief system” consists of theories and hypothesis promoted by Dr. John Money, who has been widely discredited and regarded by many as a monster. The beliefs in this “ system” will sound familiar. We are beaten over the head with these beliefs until we submit and succumb.Things like “ gender and sex are different “, but , for heterosexual people, it really isn’t. Or “ a man’s brain trapped in a woman’s body”. They will say” men can get pregnant “, and then argue it. They will use phrases like “ social construct”. They invent new words and phrases like “ non binary “ or “ agender” or “ cis gender”. You will hear “ a trans woman is a woman “..Not to mention the weird new pronouns. There is much more to this “ belief system “, but, ultimately, I believe it to be a form of brainwashing. Things that have been facts for my entire life of 55 years have all of a sudden become considered“ fluid”, by the trans community and medical establishment. …. As I said. Believe half of what you see and none of what you hear… especially by a medical establishment that is profiting greatly from this phenomenon and new revenue streams….follow the money. Be sure to question every “ fact” you are given. You will find they are not facts, but a part of this new and radical belief system, that attempts to separate biology, sex and gender. I have really only scratched the surface in describing this “ belief system”, but , I would urge you scour KZhead. Here are a few names. Miriam Grossman, Jennifer Bilek,Abigail Spencer and Camilla Paglia. These ladies are all liberal, feminist,journalists and professors and far more articulate than am I…. I am also a “ worrywart. I worry that there is an attempt to destroy our culture, a culture that is/ was based and centered around the love between men and women. When you say “ some children believe that their inner selves are opposite of their sex”, it may be so in rare cases. Very rare. But that very sentence sounds a lot like what you may hear from the gender cult and their belief system. I hope I have given you something to think about.✌️
I've been saying this for years. The entire ideology is based on the delusions and perversions of one disgusting man. He won an award for his "work" on the Reimer twins. It's absolutely sickening
I knew someone born male. Some complications the parents decided to do the same to their child. “She” grew up to be a “lesbian”mechanic.
Dysphoric thought has many forms and gender is one. It is delusional thinking and should be treated not acted on with surgery or hormones. You can not change gender except cosmetically and the surgery is painful non functional and the hormones can sterlize. It is creating more problems and the EU, UK and many states are stopping it for minors. But violent activists and the degenerate Biden's are still peddling this atrocity for children.
@@Yeetus223 Lake of Fire for those who did this to that boy. sigh.. spiritually grieving _[is this]_ satanism.
You are not alone in one who has been telling folks for years _[since i am an avid twenty-two plus years indagater of the machinations of the one world agenda and all that comes of it]_ that this entire 'ideology' - i would call it a most virulent form of SodomAndGomorrah utter abominable religion - is based on truly the first rebel seeking the paramount disgusting heinous horrendous grotesque mutilative perverse abominable ways to bring incomprehensible and ineffable affront to our Creator against His natural created order. I agree with you absolutely sickening... unfathomable.
How dare you use the memory of David Reimer to serve your anti-trans agenda. We all saw the Oprah interview, Google it people. THIS TRAGIC STORY HAS NOTHING TO DO TRANS AND INTERSEX INDIVIDUALS.
This revelation should also give serious pause about the medical institution in the US that was accomplice in allowing the insanity by validating it. To say, as so many will argue, that if a study has been published, therefore accepted by peers, then it is valid as medical fact is obviously not the case and the medical institution cannot be trusted.
They did a show about this on Law & Order Criminal Intent several years ago.
This John Money guy could be a Pharma executive. Almost 30 years ago I caught my own Dr. in a big lie that had negative consequences for me. Without the internet at the time I sent away for medical text books and also went the local university library to research. The resulting confrontation with the Dr. was pretty traumatic for both of us. That was a pivotal moment for me. The trust in institutions was destroyed. The whole pandemic response is no surprise to me.
Can you specify at all? Did he offer you the wrong treatment because it was lucrative for him?
Wow same similar situation w me it really opens your eyes.
@@beaver-brain It was in the earlier days of laser eye surgery when nearsighted correction was starting to become common place. Farsighted correction was in it's infancy as it's a more complicated process. I'm farsighted(+8) and only have one good eye from birth. I went in for an assessment and was declared a good candidate and that success rates were well over 90%. In fact the success rates for farsightedness dropped significantly as the numbers went from +1 up. Corrections above +6 were not being done anymore due to the abysmal results. This is all covered in the industry manual(not for the public) published by this eye institute a year later. Using the "over 90% success rates" of regular near sighted patients was completely false and known to be false at the time.
I was one of the lucky ones I suppose. I went to a well known hospital for an assessment for the then new laser eye vision correction. I am very near-sighted, and the young man who looked at my eyes said I was not a good candidate. He didn’t elaborate, and seemed brusque and dismissive. I left very disappointed. Today, I am thankful. I realize God had intervened and protected me…like He always has.
I went to a "family physician" years ago when just newly married. Told the Dr. about the then wife's issues with getting pregnant because she had too many abortions while following the feminazi mantra and whoring around in sexual "freedom" at a prestigious over-priced university. (I found out about her exploits AFTER I said I do, but then I was done.) Anyway, I lamented to this "doctor" who supposedly took a Hippocratic Oath to do no harm...or is that Hypocrite Oath?....so this dude with a license says in a very angry tone, "You are NEVER going to stop abortions! If a woman wants an abortion, I'm going to do it TO her!" So, I immediately picked up on his use of words and called him on it. "Do it TO her?! Not "for" her?" Of course, he made excuses for his Freudian slip. Then proceeded to tell me how an intern making $25,000 a year can work the weekends at an abortion clinic making hundreds if not thousands PER abortion! And it gets subsidized by the government(taxpayers) with no taxes charged to the "medical professionals" by funneling and shuffling monies around. It's a HUGE money-making scam by the so-called "medical professionals". (and watch You Tube censors remove this comment!)
There is a special place in a hell for people like John Money.
and the parents
@@martabakmanis4145 No, the parents are also the victims here. The parents were uneducated and put into an unimaginably difficult situation when their son's penis was accidentally removed. If your uneducated and you're sitting in a doctor's office you're going to assume what he or she tells you is fact. This is a tragedy all the way around.
This place is the ninth circle of hell, for those who betrayed people who trusted them
I hope so.
@@MikeTheTruthThatMatters Yes. I'm not sure why people keep blaming the parents as though they were supposed to Feel the truth. They were Uneducated and in waters that were Way outside of anything they knew. They didn't even know to get other opinions... from what is being said here. Yet, I've Yet to read any blame for the science and medical community that Knew what that monstrous fraud was doing And Did/Said Nothing. These were supposed professionals whose mandate was to Heal, Help, and Do No Harm. And there were those who Knew what Money was planning, was doing, what he did, and Did Nothing. And then there were people who read his studies and didn't even ask questions, check up on the David and his family, or even try to push back on his claims built on methods that were exceptionally anti-Scientific. One child and it's a "success"? That wasn't even peer-reviewed by a single doctor, academic, or researcher? And where were the journalists, feminists, and governmental agencies? The religious communities? No blame for these so-called educators, professionals, gatekeepers, and guardians; but it's all the parents' fault for believing the medical professionals they went to. As we Just came out of a pandemic disaster that was perpetrated on the entire Country and World led by the same kind of people who let this stuff happen to that child and his family. We. Have. Learned. Nothing. Education System failure much?
What heart breaking is that his acts continue and human beings are still living the atrocities that this man cause the Reimer family.
I have been writing to leave children alone. NO CIRCUMCISION. NO TATTOOS. NO PIERCINGS. NO MUTILATION OF ANY KIND TO PRETEND GENDER. LEAVE CHILDREN'S BODIES ALONE. Oh, I do not care about cultural religious practices. When an adult people may do as they want. But leave children alone.
Why do you believe in no circumcision? It's simply shortening a length of skin to reduce the risk of contracting certain diseases. I mostly understand piercings but most can simply be removed or have little to no negative attributes (for example earrings.)
@@That_OneGuy46 why don't you believe in the right of the individual to decide if they want a body part removed? Men have the right to decide for themselves. Others cannot be allowed to mutilate. The medical mutilation removes all the foreskin.
@@GeorgeDeCarlo It's like the safest surgery out there, it's meant to decrease the risks of getting certain cancers, and they do it when the child is young so they won't have to remember the experience when they get older. Why are you so concerned about foreskin specifically??? The parents simply want to ensure the health of their boys, would you also say that children should have the right to deny needles for things like chicken pox when their parents want to set up an appointment? Hell no!
You do not care about cultural religious practices? Why? Because it only mutilates the genitalia of little girls?
So impressed with Dr. Miriam Grossman...you can feel her pain and compassion relating this horrific and abominable episode. How people can hear of incidents like this and still promote this perverse and abusive ideology is baffling.
That's just it... They NEVER research the ending. I wish they did... Truth is everything, ESPECIALLY when it comes to something as serious as taking away the ability to create life, etc.
@@tiffanyhohmannboos7255 Why people make this about the trans thing is bewildering to me. The majority of the psychological damage was done before the transition. Would we have preferred the kid grew up without the attempt to give him some sort of normality? Cant even diagnose phimosis at that age this country is just irredeemably sick, always has been and always will be.
I too am incredibly impressed with Dr. Miriam Grossman. I would love to meet her sometime.
If you are against humans changing their natures, then how can you believe in a religion that says God became a man, a ✡?
How can people want to look like they are gods..? Actually she said this in the beginning.
What gets me is how they tried so hard to figure out how to turn him into a girl instead of trying to reverse the damage that had been done and try to give him just a normal life.
This. I was thinking why the hospital never bought up reconstruction when he was old enough. If they create one for transgender why can't they just fix the issue.
@@chainsreactingIt would have been purely cosmetic. He couldn't urinate, get hard, or feel anything. They should have just let him be a boy with a surgical injury. As a guy, I really can't imagine the hell. May he rest in peace.
This is proof of what we’ve know for millennia. Even as a gay dude, I know gender is a fact. I’m 100% man. My male body feels right, has always felt right. As an adult I fully embrace my masculinity with passion and joy. Gender identity is real, and it’s something we’re all born with. End of story.
Please just teach your little ones to love and care for their little bodies just the way they are.
I learned about this in my human sexuality class in college around 2001. In that human sexuality class , taught by a lesbian professor, we learned gender theory and also debates nature vs nurture. This professor used THIS example to reinforce to us that gender wasn’t simply nurture but something we are born with. This goes to show how far (in a bad way) we’ve come. In 22 years we have gone backwards and forgotten everything we already knew. Something so uncontroversial that my lesbian instructor, aware of gender theory, still knew our gender/sex is NATURE.
But we are making great iPhones!
@@Adennative yes exactly ...but the way Jordan and his friend are going on it was to use their words "baked into academia " can you see why this is a poisonous libelous insane lie
A lesbian is not qualified to teach normal heterosexual human sexuality. That is ludicrous. So Sorry you had to endure that experience.
@@eliara-thevoice8430 You missed the part where even a lesbian knew that John Money's study was wrong and that our gender is innate.
@@eliara-thevoice8430 As a lesbian and long term childcare director, I am offended by that comment! It is deeply lesbo/homophobic! She actually did a great service to her students, she taught reality!
I KNEW she was going to say they were sexually abused. The moment she said earlier that they would go in privately in a meeting with him... I knew it. THAT'S why we need to trust our instincts on this whole matter. We have to trust our instincts.
And NEVER let your children meet 'in private' with any adult!!
Gays and trans. All sexual abuse.
exactly! Most female animals in the animal trust in their maternal instincts women are the only ones who are just too trusting of the system we live in now.
John Money was quoted in more than one publication saying horrendous and perverted things. Like I remember one of the things he said was a kid 10-12 years old having their first sexual encounter with an older adult or family member isn’t a bad thing as long as there was a mutual attraction. He was an animal.
I am a 26yr old Indian doctor. I find few doctors supporting this gender dysphoria.Which is disgusting.I am glad now i can answer them properly with strong points.
seems like all drs support it though. from tv and online. not saying u.
@@deathgrinderb3284 perhaps they have forgotten their Hippocratic Oath.They are trying to be politically correct.I will stay true to my oath and culture and try to save people from that rabid mentality and destroying own body and soul.
Indian culture is very supportive of transgenderism
@@janusjones6519 it only supports those who are born as transgenders.Not hormone treated males with mutiliated genitals.
@@janusjones6519 Brainwashing from the west towards a generally open culture unfortunately.
What is really really unsettling about this story, is the fact that a real scientist pushed a study based more on ideology than science and no debate was allowed. That is not how science is meant to be. And for me, as a upcoming scientist its scary to think about how many studies out there, that are considered "fact" and already "proven", are nothing less than the personal opinion and world view of the author, who uses science as a media to push their message. There are strict rules to scientific work. Experiments have to be objective, reliable, valid. Other scientists have to discuss and question it. Makes you wonder how much science is basically just ideology of a guy with a Dr....
Thanks ---- for her tremendous & heartfelt, fantastic rendition .... of the tragic story
Wow! This should be required viewing in every university "gender studies" class, every teacher's college curriculum, every medical school curriculum, and every state licensure in the medical, sociological, educational fields.
The converts just wouldn't listen. it's been cleverly politicized and weaponized. how did we all not know?
…You kidding? The universities are the ones teach this trash, the belly of the beast. I was in the men’s room at a local Ivy League school ( Cornell), and there were tampons , which was surprising, since we haven’t a need . I expect this to get worse
This should be taught at high school so that nobody even signs up for a gender studies class. They should also throw in the story of Kinsey, the other half in the demonic duo, who coined a lot of the gender ideology after getting infants to simulate sex with each other. The entire core of the ideology is ROTTEN
Not allowed to have an opposing view. Thats how sick these fucks are. But it also shows how mentally weak those students are that listen to that man and think hes doing the right thing.
There are numerous cases where cycling babies with ambiguous genitalia were surgically made into girls in the days before genetic testing. The disastrous consequences were well known 20 years ago. But the fact is that not only genes and hormones determine how a child or adult feels -sexually and behaviorally- much is dependent upon the hormone receptors on the cells of various tissues -especially during development of the fetus and young child. This is critical because 1. Sometimes babies are born with genetic abnormalities for those receptors- so that the hormones don’t work on those tissues (in the brain or even in the developing genitalia) , or 2. possibly, hormone mimicking chemicals from plastics or pesticides could alter the development of those tissues. The result of all this is supported by the story of Bruce: some people feel that they are not their assigned or genetic gender. Even more importantly: we have created categories for gender behaviors: but studies of primates don’t support this theory. Not all male apes take on the same role: some attempt to dominate, while others “wowed” their partners when the dominant male wasn’t around. So there is no reason to believe that there is one way of feeling masculine and one way of feeling feminine. It makes more sense that there is a spectrum of feelings. To me, it suggests that there are likely a small percentage of people who are ambivalent about their sex, and should naturally just follow along with society’s expectations.
I remember hearing this story from our college psychology professor in the early 1980's and she claimed that Bruce was transformed into a "healthy happy girl". She couldn't have known the horrific end to this story - I have often wondered how she handled learning the truth and what she told her students in later years? You cannot change biology!!
Is she still alive?
She probably knew the truth but lied to herself, to affirm her own twisted beliefs
I wonder if they still tell about it in colleges
@@Belenus3080 They probably do and smear the the twins as liars and transphobic
@@SolarPodcast that just means they were authentically trans.
This is such a tragic and fascinating story. The fact that people blindly believe that this movement is innocent and will be saving children from suicide, is absolutely insane. People will believe anything
This is horrifying to learn this. I always thought there was some sort of a horrible issue behind it, much like Kinsey, but I didn't know the whole story until I saw this video.
The Reimer twin story has always been one of the most heartbreaking atrocities I've ever seen. Dr. Money, if you can even call him "Dr", was an absolute monster! This craziness is like a true version of "The Island of Dr. Moreau"!
There are a handful of news stories that stay with me forever. This is one of them. I learned of this many years ago and will never forget.
What about the people who knew and let Money live?
@@Nill757 Those who knew were ideologues and could care less.
I also agree, with the comparison to Dr. Mengele.
@@Nill757 People do severely misguided things all the time. Who have you killed in the name of justice? Or are you "I see no evil, I hear no evil"? You've set quite the tall keyboard order for other people. Anybody can do that all day.
Holy moly this is huge. If only they taught me that in “gender studies “ class in college in the early 2000s rather then gender is a construct!!! 😡
Gender Studies didn’t exist before this event. Gender Studies was born from this event.
Why do you think the entirety of a field of science rests on what one guy said?
@@FiggFig I also took classes in early 2000 that were a lot on gender & ethics type of stuff. It wasn’t called gender studies & I think that’s what she meant. My class was called introduction into humanities. We did go over many things like this. It was more basics. We went over psychology & gender. It wasn’t a class focused solely on gender but yes we were going over stuff like this.
@@jamessgames1156Loaded and irrelevant. John Money is credited with the creation of the term 'gender roles' and the concept that sex and gender identity are malleable and arbitrary and thus can be essentially "chosen". The entire field indeed is based on much of his work and the theories he established, though they were not formulated in any valuable scientific work and his only "proof" (the Reimer case) was an obviously catastrophic failure.
@@Wodenson5150 Well, you said it yourself. Loaded and irrelevant. Maybe one day you'll figure out that thousands of other people's work isn't invalidated because of one shitbag.
Devine prayers and condolences to the entire family where does experience. 💐💜🙏💜💐 thank you for your sacrifices, and alerting the public. RIP
I have a very close friend who is a victim of a doctor Reardon you can look him up it's a Connecticut story. It's an unbelievable story the irony of it is my father is a retired obstetrician gynecologist and he worked fairly closely with this doctor and no one at the hospital knew anything at first the original story is he took a set of twins boy and girl and had them have sex together while he took pictures his specialty was growth and development as a pediatrician. the shame is the hospital knew this guy was up to something but they let him stay on and when it got too hot for the hospital they had him resign quietly when he died and his children sold the house the new owners of the home did a demolition on the house and found over 50,000 pictures stashed in a wall of all the children he abused my friend has lived a very up and down life with relationships and he never married many lawsuits were settled this guy was a monster.
Had a professor teaching adolescent development that showed an entire documentary about this whole thing. Not much preface or explanation as to why, just ran it and let it speak for itself. Was shocked and horrified, but always been super thankful she showed it since it’s such a suppressed story.
Name of documentary?
@@cigh7445 Dr. Money And The Boy With No Penis
What’s the name of the documentary?
The name of this documentary would be wonderful
Can't be sure which one was shown to Blake but my grade 12 social studies teacher showed us one called "Dr. Money And The Boy With No Penis"
What happened to this young man was grotesque after a terrible accident that should never of happened. It sounds like the parents were awfully exploited and the child was horribly abused, not by his parents, but a supposed expert. Thank you for bringing this to light
And his parents were NOT on their job!! So, so sad. I pray for all of them and all of us! Blessings
And now that poor child is once again being horribly abused by Jordan Peterson as part of a YT Ad revenue grab for his channel to profit from hate and division. Which has always been his calling card as the well known charlatan he is. Funny, Peterson never said a peep about the trans community or anything on this topic prior to Fox News and other right wing purveyors of mass disinformation and propaganda deciding to turn this into the next "Happy Holidays" wedge issue, as yet one more way to win elections by dividing America. The irony is that the people who watch this 'snake oil' channel are always hunting and searching for 'smoking guns' in a giant pile of thoroughly debunked bogus conspiracies, yet the true manipulation is occurring to themselves. They are fed garbage lies and propaganda to shock, anger, misinform, dupe and create fear in people, and drive them to vote a particular way in upcoming elections. American democracy is being torn down, brick by brick. And it is occurring in the open, through the radicalization of many everyday Americans into rabid and fervent domestic terrorists by channels like this one. To where they end up doing heinous things like attacking and desecrating our US Capitol, idolizing a twice-impeached career criminal and con man who praises and fawns over authoritarian dictators, and encourages them to withhold vaccinations and covid medicines from themselves and children (which is a form of child negligent and abuse). THAT is the power of propaganda. And THAT is exactly what happened to the well-educated and civilized people of Germany before they were infected with the same sort of mass propaganda prior to WWII. It's time to wake up and look at what is really going on. These people always need to conjure up a fake boogie man to point to as their smoke screen, such as disparaging ethnic people, immigrants, Liberals, trans people, women's rights, etc ...all while they carefully work behind your back to disassemble our democracy, its freedoms and its protections until we no longer are living in a free society.
@@queenj.8i895 the parents were lied to. They were young. What we know now about how certain medical officials lie they didn't have. The parents were traumatized as well
@1791 maybe so, but they made all the final decisions and they were not only unwise, their multiple decisions along the way were beyond detrimental & literally evil in my view. Evil isn’t always intentional, sometimes it comes in & takes over by way of ignorance. It’s my belief that ANY parent has FAILED who thinks it’s ok to agree to ATTEMPT to change the sex of your child, mutilate - or in this case, FURTHER mutilate their body, try to lie to them their entire life & keep family secrets - ESP secrets about THEIR OWN TRUE BACKGROUND, and then these ppl left their little kids ALONE with another grown man, AND didn’t have a good enough relationship with their own children in order to know something was wrong RIGHT AWAY - UH AH!!! Just UH-AH!!!!!! Did they ever get any second, or third opinions? They just went along with what the first nut job suggested?? Did they ever think to pray about it?? Even if they were non-believers, before you go and do something major like what they did, you’d think a parent who is dying to make the right decision would at least look up one time, even out of desperation. I know for myself that being a parent is harder than we even already acknowledge that it is. I have a 15-year-old son & 12 & 11 year old girls. I’ve experienced a few surprises already, things I would never have thought would happen with us, but I have taken the #1 job of my kids safety & well-being more than seriously!! These parents allowed their children and themselves to be traumatized by ALLOWING all sorts of evil in. They didn’t guard their physical, mental, emotional, or SPIRITUAL gates. I pray ppl do learn from their mistakes and missteps. Blessings to you 🦋
a terrible "accident" oh yeah, circumcision, an elective cosmetic surgery that is forced on 99.9% of healthy children against their will, what an "accident."
And all of this is on wikipedia, that's not even "underground", can't believe some people still relay this monster's ideology
The mental toll, frustration, confusion and anger that poor kid suffered through. He must've been in pure torment.
In 1985, I took an intro to Psych class, and even though David was no longer living as a girl, they were still telling the story that "Joan" was a perfectly content girl. I didn't believe it then. I wish there were consequences for the perpetrators.
Oh, John Money is receiving the just consequences of his perversion and evil and will be for eternity....
John Money misdiagnosed Janet Frame as schizophrenic and had her committed. She narrowly missed being lobotomized, only because she won a literary prize only a short time before she was supposed to have her brain ruined. Jane Campion directed the film based on her life. It is a tear-jerker, and all of it is true.
I did not know that about Money, but most New Zealanders know a lot about Janet Frame > thanks for the knowledge
😮
Name of the movie?
@@jeffreyyoungblood7438 angel at my table (1990)
@@AugustGallmeyer1998Netflix
Such a heartbreaking story. Poor Bruce, poor David. I hope they at least sued the crap out of the doctor and hospital for destroying the life of Bruce and his brother and the parents, the entire family. Bruce didnt have a chance of being happy. Now this same evil crap is happening on a huge scale. The destruction of a generation.
I remembered getting exposed to this in a Psychology class and thinking about just how corrupt the whole operation was and how the cause and effect of it has significantly ruined everything it touches.
As a parent, I cannot imagine how much guilt these parents felt after all of this happened, even though they were victims themselves. Money was a parasite that has left a legacy that should be destroyed. He was a monster.
they were guilty of being naive and lacking in critical thinking. They didnt think for themselves, they let the self proclaimed experts do the thinking which always has dire consequences. They were also responsible for not protecting their child against dubious theories from 'the authorities' .
So what do you say to these Dr. Butchering kids now?
We have clinics in our country doing surgery and hormone therapy on children. Boston Children's Hospital being one. Evil.
@@Dippmip The Reimers were uneducated blue collar workers, just like my parents were at that time. Good hard working people but I had more education when I was in grade 8 than what either one of my parents would EVER have. They depended on the abilities and knowledge of doctors because they had no access to information like we would today. Even reading was a problem for them. Now, YOU sit in judgement of people, who lived in a time, where learning these things were near impossible unless you went into post secondary education. That's NOT guilt. That's the reality of life before the eighties for most adults. If you had asked my parents to define the term "critical thinking" back in 1965, they would have given you a blank look and shrugged their shoulders. It just wasn't something that the average person would know in those times. It would be like asking a Viking to define "airplane". It was way beyond them. That doctor took advantage of naive, uneducated and desperate parents, with little to no recourse but to go to someone that had the credentials to help them. Unfortunately, the man, who was being touted as a genius in academic circles and on TV, was no better than Dr. Mengele. The blame rests ENTIRELY on the shoulders of Dr. Money, no one else. He was an ideologue, eschewing scientific processes to find fame and glory. Someday, he will be remembered as a Mengele clone.
The worst kind of monster is one who preys on children. And we should let this be a lesson in not trusting the appeal to authority logical fallacy. The so called experts on humans as well and have their own motives usually involving money.